{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_05650_decaying_warm_majoron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1803_05650", "source_line": 3451, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 52.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier2", "rank_percentile": 100.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 4.5, "observational_leverage": 24, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier2 ranking for Decaying warm majoron dark matter: the supplied card gives a uv complete warm dark matter model with suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, high CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 52.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_05563_nonthermal_subkev_light_dark_matter_fraction_v1", "paper_id": "1912_05563", "source_line": 4079, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 52.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier2", "rank_percentile": 99.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 28, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative light_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization structure and relic reach 'no'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'decay_produced', transfer function 'mixed_cold_warm', small-scale effect 'suppression', and inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha/structure, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 52.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_15736_heavy_scalar_decay_nonthermal_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_15736", "source_line": 5651, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 50.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier2", "rank_percentile": 99.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 14, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["High-ranked because Heavy-scalar-decay non-thermal warm dark matter (warm_dark_matter) has non-CDM structure-formation behavior, nonthermal phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields. Raw score 50.0, tier2."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 50.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_04703_gauged_bl_dirac_neutrino_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_04703", "source_line": 4099, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 48.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative multi_component_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 48.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_07706_dark_fermion_relaxion_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1909_07706", "source_line": 4052, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 48.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 9, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative warm_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'smooth_cutoff', small-scale effect 'suppression', and inferred probe classes: BBN, Lyman-alpha/structure, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 48.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_09904_cosmic_ray_boosted_gidm_spin2_v1", "paper_id": "1912_09904", "source_line": 4072, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 47.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 6, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative gravitationally_interacting_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'mixed_cold_warm', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 47.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_sector_compact_object_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_13281_n_machos_v1", "paper_id": "1911_13281", "source_line": 4073, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 47, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 7, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 9, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative multi_sector_compact_object_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'not_applicable', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact objects/microlensing, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 47, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_03203_two_state_inelastic_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_03203", "source_line": 3485, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 46.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 8, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 6.5, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Two-state inelastic self-interacting dark matter: the supplied card gives a simplified model self interacting dark matter model with nonthermal phase space, medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites / halo structure; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 46.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_01112_clockwork_protected_alp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1804_01112", "source_line": 3465, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 46.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 9, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Clockwork-protected ALP dark matter: the supplied card gives a uv complete axion like dark matter model with suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, field like phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 46.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_10608_generalized_ula_cosmological_field_v1", "paper_id": "1806_10608", "source_line": 3537, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 46, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 10, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has field_like phase-space production; it gives explicit small-scale-structure leverage; it touches CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection and other probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 46, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_08484_scalar_dark_fifth_force_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_08484", "source_line": 5124, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 46, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 11, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked highest in this batch because a dark fifth force gives CMB leverage, enhanced scale-dependent growth, halo-mass effects, and partial Boltzmann-solver support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 46, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_08112_quartic_fuzzy_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1805_08112", "source_line": 3509, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 46, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 12, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has field_like phase-space production; it gives explicit small-scale-structure leverage; it touches CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection and other probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 46, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "noncanonical_scalar_unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "1803_09767_asymptotically_flat_coth_potential_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1803_09767", "source_line": 3455, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 45.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 13, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Non-canonical asymptotically-flat coth-potential unified dark sector: the supplied card gives a phenomenological parameterization noncanonical scalar unified dark sector model with suppression of small-scale power, scale dependent growth transfer behavior, field like phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, galaxy satellites / halo structure, indirect detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 45.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "noncanonical_scalar_unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "1803_09767_cascading_step_potential_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1803_09767", "source_line": 3457, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 45.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 14, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Non-canonical cascading step-potential unified dark sector: the supplied card gives a phenomenological parameterization noncanonical scalar unified dark sector model with suppression of small-scale power, scale dependent growth transfer behavior, field like phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, galaxy satellites / halo structure, indirect detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 45.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "noncanonical_scalar_unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "1803_09767_starobinsky_type_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1803_09767", "source_line": 3456, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 45.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 15, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Non-canonical Starobinsky-type unified dark sector: the supplied card gives a phenomenological parameterization noncanonical scalar unified dark sector model with suppression of small-scale power, scale dependent growth transfer behavior, field like phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, galaxy satellites / halo structure, indirect detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 45.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_03176_inelastic_dark_matter_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1911_03176", "source_line": 4075, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 45.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 16, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative inelastic_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 45.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_08579_neutrino_portal_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_08579", "source_line": 3493, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 45.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 17, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Neutrino portal freeze-in dark matter: the supplied card gives a simplified model freeze in dark matter model with suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, nonthermal phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 45.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_02530_b3_dfsz_axion_axino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_02530", "source_line": 3523, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 45, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 18, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a UV-complete model card; it has mixed_cold_warm phase-space production; it gives explicit small-scale-structure leverage; it touches BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites and other probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 45, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_12983_ultra_light_pion_baryon_wimpzilla_v1", "paper_id": "2205_12983", "source_line": 5150, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 45, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 19, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 10, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked high for this batch because it is a composite multi-component ULP/baryon WIMPzilla model with field-like suppression, multiple production mechanisms, and strong provenance."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 45, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_01249_light_radion_freeze_in_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1803_01249", "source_line": 3480, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 44.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 20, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Light radion freeze-in dark matter in an RS/SBSI model: the supplied card gives a effective field theory radion dark matter model with suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, nonthermal phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target; large penalties come from missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 44.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_09906_kev_gravitino_bino_decay_gmsb_v1", "paper_id": "2006_09906", "source_line": 4294, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 44, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 21, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 23, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative gravitino_warm_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support, production via thermal gravitino production; entropy dilution by lightest messenger decay, mixed_cold_warm phase-space treatment, small-scale-power suppression, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 44, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_04135_right_handed_neutrino_hot_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1804_04135", "source_line": 3467, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 44.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 22, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 4.5, "observational_leverage": 22, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Right-handed neutrino hot dark matter subcomponent in an SU(2)_V W-prime model: the supplied card gives a uv complete sterile neutrino dark matter model with suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, high CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target; large penalties come from missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 44.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_nugget_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_11889_neutrino_nugget_kination_ede_v1", "paper_id": "2005_11889", "source_line": 4238, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 44, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 23, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection, structure or tension connection; nonthermal phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 44, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_04901_self_interacting_neutrino_dw_sterile_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1910_04901", "source_line": 3993, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 43, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 24, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Dodelson-Widrow sterile neutrino dark matter with active-neutrino self-interactions: strong model-card science motivation, high observational leverage, high diversity value; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score 43 (tier3) uses production=nonthermal Dodelson-Widrow oscillation production; scalar-mediated active-neutrino scattering; phase=nonthermal; CMB=medium, BBN=medium; transfer=smooth_cutoff, small_scale=suppression; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 43, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_10100_inflationary_dark_photon_proca_stars_v1", "paper_id": "2203_10100", "source_line": 5107, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 43, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 25, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked high for this batch because inflation-produced vector dark matter gives rare enhanced small-scale power, Proca-star substructure, and approximate field-like phase-space information."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 43, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_13554_uv_freeze_in_baryogenesis_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_13554", "source_line": 5146, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 42, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 26, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked well for UV freeze-in baryogenesis with nonthermal phase-space, CMB/BBN relevance, and smooth-cutoff suppression."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 42, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_02052_extreme_axion_cosine_fluid_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2311_02052", "source_line": 5879, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 42, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 27, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 and the strongest scored item in this batch because the emerging extreme-axion fluid has rare enhanced small-scale-power behavior, partial Boltzmann-solver support, and CMB/LSS leverage despite missing final observables and constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 42, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_05704_type_i_non_degenerate_2hdma_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_05704", "source_line": 6002, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 42, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 28, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked within this sparse batch because it is a benchmark type-I non-degenerate 2HDM+a model with clear collider portals and a UFO implementation, while cosmological and constraint routing are still missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 42, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_cold_warm_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_1592_nrp_sterile_neutrino_mixed_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1412_1592", "source_line": 2317, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 42, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 29, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 with score 42 because the assigned model card phenomenological parameterization mixed_cold_warm_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage; uses mixed cold warm phase-space information; marks small-scale-power suppression; touches CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, galaxy satellites.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 42, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_01846_pq_dirac_neutrino_scalar_wimp_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2001_01846", "source_line": 4067, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 41.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 30, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 8, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative multi_component_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'mixed_cold_warm', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, laboratory precision/axion searches.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 41.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_03398_resonant_sterile_neutrino_nonstandard_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "1911_03398", "source_line": 3984, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 41, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 31, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 23, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Resonantly produced sterile neutrino dark matter in non-standard pre-BBN cosmology: high observational leverage, high diversity value; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score 41 (tier3) uses production=freeze-in via resonant active-sterile oscillations; Shi-Fuller mechanism in a non-standard pre-BBN expansion history; phase=resonant; CMB=medium, BBN=critical; transfer=smooth_cutoff, small_scale=suppression; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 41, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_06364_twin_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2305_06364", "source_line": 5600, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 41, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 32, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because twin sterile-neutrino dark matter has high CMB/BBN relevance, warm-structure suppression, and broad X-ray/gamma/structure complementarity, despite missing route, constraint, and code fields.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 41, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_13554_uv_freeze_in_baryogenesis_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_13554", "source_line": 5147, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 41, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 33, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked similarly to the scalar UV-freeze-in baryogenesis case, with Dirac-fermion diversity but an added BBN-decay-channel warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 41, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_02514_singlet_doublet_freeze_in_fast_expansion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_02514", "source_line": 5507, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 41, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 34, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, structure-formation leverage, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple plausible probe classes, and some code, benchmark, or analytic support.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 41, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superfluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_09474_unified_superfluid_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1810_09474", "source_line": 314, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 41, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 35, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=emerging, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is high, small-scale power effect is mixed, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth, phase-space type is field_like.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:finite_temperature_gap.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 15/17/8/0/9/8/16."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 41, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_nugget_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_11889_neutrino_nugget_simple_cdm_transition_v1", "paper_id": "2005_11889", "source_line": 4237, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 41, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 36, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection, structure or tension connection; nonthermal phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 41, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_cannibal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_08062_mixed_minimal_cannibal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1803_08062", "source_line": 3454, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40.75, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 37, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 8.75, "feasibility": 4.5, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Mixed cold plus minimal cannibal dark matter: the supplied card gives a effective field theory multi component cannibal dark matter model with suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites / halo structure; large penalties come from missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40.75, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_10029_b_l_gauged_pq_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_10029", "source_line": 3498, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 38, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for B-L gauged Peccei-Quinn axion dark matter: the supplied card gives a uv complete axion like dark matter model with field like phase space, medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites / halo structure; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_13328_nonstandard_prebbn_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1909_13328", "source_line": 4027, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40.2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 39, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.2, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior, nonthermal phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_03644_late_sommerfeld_dm_to_dark_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1803_03644", "source_line": 3486, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 40, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Late Sommerfeld-enhanced dark-matter conversion to dark radiation: the supplied card gives a simplified model self interacting dark matter model with suppression of small-scale power, scale dependent growth transfer behavior, nonthermal phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_06739_phi_freeze_in_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1609_06739", "source_line": 2894, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 41, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; mixed small-scale-power effect.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_06739_susy_equilibrium_scalar_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1609_06739", "source_line": 2895, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 42, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; mixed small-scale-power effect.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_06739_susy_phi_freeze_in_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1609_06739", "source_line": 2896, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 43, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; mixed small-scale-power effect.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_06085_numsm_fnv_leptogenesis_sterile_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_06085", "source_line": 3083, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 44, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance medium, CMB relevance medium, non-CDM structure marker suppression/smooth_cutoff, distinct phase space resonant; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, direct detection, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_15513_resonantly_produced_sterile_neutrino_n1_v1", "paper_id": "2303_15513", "source_line": 5553, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 45, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because resonant sterile-neutrino production has a supplied momentum-distribution/half-mode-mass story and X-ray/structure leverage, but the card carries strong exclusion tension and lacks populated observable and constraint entries.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_2217_dodelson_widrow_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1011_2217", "source_line": 1250, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 46, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from a canonical phenomenological_parameterization card in family sterile_neutrino_warm_dark_matter with production via Dodelson-Widrow production through active-sterile mixing in the radiation-dominated plasma.", "Observational leverage is driven by suppression of small-scale power; nonthermal phase space; medium CMB and unknown BBN relevance; probe classes: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics, galaxy satellites.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_reheating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_03440_inflaton_decay_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_03440", "source_line": 5139, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 47, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked well because inflaton-decay production has available distribution information, BBN relevance, and smooth-cutoff suppression."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_thermal_nonthermal_wimp_dark_radiation", "model_id": "1308_6630_331_wimpy_dark_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1308_6630", "source_line": 1911, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 48, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 40.0 because the model card is a speculative mixed_thermal_nonthermal_wimp_dark_radiation card with uv_complete theory support; high BBN and high CMB relevance; suppression small-scale-power behavior with unknown transfer-function information; mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior; high diversity value in the registry population and touches BBN, CMB, collider, direct detection, small-scale structure.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_mev_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_05714_flavor_blind_zprime_mev_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_05714", "source_line": 5143, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 49, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked high for this sparse batch because MeV freeze-out during neutrino decoupling directly affects CMB and BBN observables and is a rare family."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_kination_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_12336_thermal_dark_matter_kination_v1", "paper_id": "2304_12336", "source_line": 5629, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 40, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 50, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 10, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because rare kination freeze-out model with enhanced small-scale power, microhalo/substructure implications, and associated code.", "Score is still held down by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points despite limited code support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 40, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_quark_nugget_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_10249_six_flavor_quark_matter_nugget_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1804_10249", "source_line": 3458, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39.75, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 51, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 8.25, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Six-flavor quark matter nugget dark matter: the supplied card gives a uv complete macroscopic quark nugget dark matter model with nonthermal phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target; large penalties come from missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39.75, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "conformal_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_10160_conformal_freeze_in_quark_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1910_10160", "source_line": 4023, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39.7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 52, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as emerging effective_field_theory; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior, nonthermal phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_09771_2hdm_a_majorana_v1", "paper_id": "1910_09771", "source_line": 4054, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 53, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 7, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as benchmark pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_15543_minimal_decaying_dark_matter_s8_v1", "paper_id": "2403_15543", "source_line": 6000, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 54, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 22, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from decaying_dark_matter: Minimal decaying dark matter model for the S8 tension has strong observational leverage, moderate model/theory value, high diversity value through freeze-in production through the dimension-eight neutrino/Higgs operator, late decay of N2 to N1 plus neutrinos; inferred probe classes are CMB, direct_detection, indirect_detection, small_scale_structure.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_01347_axi_higgs_ultralight_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2111_01347", "source_line": 4929, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 55, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Axi-Higgs ultralight axion cosmology is speculative with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by field_like phase-space information, suppression structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: observational leverage, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_11902_ad_lball_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_11902", "source_line": 5963, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 56, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from sterile_neutrino_dark_matter: Affleck-Dine L-ball resonant sterile-neutrino dark matter scenario has strong observational leverage, high model/theory value, high diversity value through Shi-Fuller resonant active-sterile neutrino production seeded by Affleck-Dine L-ball lepton asymmetry; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, gravitational_waves, lyman_alpha, small_scale_structure.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_6061_bec_scalar_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1310_6061", "source_line": 1937, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 57, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 39.0 because the model card is a emerging fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support; high BBN and high CMB relevance; suppression small-scale-power behavior with unknown transfer-function information; field_like phase-space behavior; nonlinear halo-structure relevance; high diversity value in the registry population and touches BBN, CMB, cosmological gravity, halo dynamics, small-scale structure.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_11140_adm_cmb_birefringence_cs_current_v1", "paper_id": "2302_11140", "source_line": 5571, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 58, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because the asymmetric Chern-Simons current model is directly tied to CMB birefringence and mixed cold-warm structure, with high diversity value, but lacks explicit routes and constraints.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_06072_inelastic_freeze_in_pseudo_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2304_06072", "source_line": 5601, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 59, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because mixed cold/warm freeze-in phase space, late excited-state decays, high CMB/BBN relevance, and small-scale suppression.", "Score is still held down by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points despite limited code support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_01928_singlet_susy_singlino_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_01928", "source_line": 5131, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 60, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked well because the singlet-SUSY SIDM model touches CMB/BBN, small-scale-structure motivation, a phase transition, and partial computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_06821_neutrino_coupled_ultralight_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_06821", "source_line": 5184, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 61, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: neutrino-coupled ultralight scalar has strong CMB/BBN, field-like, smooth-cutoff, and satellite/subhalo relevance in a rare ultralight family."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_3113_neutrino_interacting_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1412_3113", "source_line": 2348, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 62, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 99.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 with score 39 because the assigned model card simplified model neutrino_portal_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage; marks small-scale-power suppression; touches BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_07528_millicharged_cointeracting_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2403_07528", "source_line": 6032, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 63, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because millicharged co-interacting dark photon dark matter is multicomponent, has mixed cold-warm phase-space content, radio-line phenomenology, and benchmark points, but constraints and routing are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_b_l_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_03695_susy_b_minus_l_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1912_03695", "source_line": 4086, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 39.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 64, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 8, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative supersymmetric_b_l_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, gravitational waves.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 39.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "charged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07926_electrically_charged_champ_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07926", "source_line": 2747, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 65, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9.8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a tier3 observational-extension candidate because it has parameter-dependent relic production, critical CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, oscillations small-scale-power behavior.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: BBN, CMB, direct detection, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_00129_lrsm_n1_triplet_scalar_diluted_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_00129", "source_line": 5940, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 66, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Minimal LRSM N1 dark matter with right-handed triplet scalar dilution has usable cosmology or structure hooks (BBN, CMB, small-scale structure) but still lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing extensions.", "Component balance: science 13, observational leverage 18, complementarity 8, feasibility 1, provenance 9, diversity 3.5, penalties 14; raw score 38.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_06777_gauged_b_l_dirac_neutrino_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_06777", "source_line": 5911, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 67, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Gauged U(1)_{B-L} light Dirac-neutrino-portal dark matter has usable cosmology or structure hooks (BBN, CMB, small-scale structure) but still lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing extensions.", "Component balance: science 12, observational leverage 18, complementarity 8, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 6.5, penalties 15; raw score 38.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_01505_gut_scale_susy_pseudo_dirac_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2001_01505", "source_line": 4080, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 68, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 7, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative higgsino_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; high-severity card warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_06876_composite_adm_dark_photon_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1805_06876", "source_line": 3491, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.25, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 69, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3.75, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Composite asymmetric dark matter with a dark photon portal: the supplied card gives a uv complete asymmetric dark matter model with high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_1774_higgs_portal_png_domain_wall_hot_cold_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_1774", "source_line": 1980, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 70, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied model-card fields: strong cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, CMB, laboratory/collider/direct, small-scale structure; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_11696_kev_miracle_higgs_decay_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1907_11696", "source_line": 3910, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 71, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 16.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB, small-scale structure.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_12348_decaying_warm_dark_matter_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2006_12348", "source_line": 4289, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 72, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative decaying_warm_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support, production via nonthermal production from dark-scalar decay; late decay of WDM into dark photon and dark radiation, decay_produced phase-space treatment, small-scale-power suppression, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_04526_rhn_oscillation_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_04526", "source_line": 3081, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 73, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability yes.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance low, CMB relevance medium, non-CDM structure marker suppression/smooth_cutoff, distinct phase space nonthermal; inferred probe classes: CMB, direct detection, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_06560_blue_axion_photon_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2301_06560", "source_line": 5511, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 74, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, structure-formation leverage, mixed_cold_warm phase-space information, multiple plausible probe classes, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_04163_late_pq_phase_transition_axion_parametric_resonance_v1", "paper_id": "1910_04163", "source_line": 3987, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 75, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Late-PQ-phase-transition axion parametric-resonance dark matter: strong model-card science motivation, high observational leverage, high diversity value; inferred probe classes are BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 38 (tier3) uses production=parametric resonance from saxion oscillations after late PQ phase transition; phase=nonthermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=medium; transfer=unknown, small_scale=suppression; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_relic_inflaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_03308_wimpflation_inflaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_03308", "source_line": 3495, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 76, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3.5, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for WIMPflation stable inflaton dark matter: the supplied card gives a phenomenological parameterization thermal relic inflaton dark matter model with high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_08795_sterile_neutrino_singlet_freeze_in_freeze_out_v1", "paper_id": "2204_08795", "source_line": 5128, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 77, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked high for this batch because sterile-neutrino dark-sector freeze-in/freeze-out has distribution information plus smooth-cutoff structure."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_11256_messenger_inflation_gravitino_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "2103_11256", "source_line": 4624, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 78, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative superwimp gravitino dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; explicit cosmological/structure leverage; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics.... The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_07838_axion_condensate_stimulated_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1911_07838", "source_line": 4068, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 79, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 8, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative axion_like_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'field_like', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: CMB, indirect detection, laboratory precision/axion searches.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_16966_u1_dark_photon_sidm_fopt_v1", "paper_id": "2306_16966", "source_line": 5671, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 80, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 14, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because U(1)' dark-photon self-interacting dark matter from a MeV first-order phase transition (self_interacting_dark_matter) has CMB/BBN relevance, vector, other portal coverage. Raw score 38.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_02906_minimal_inflaton_higgs_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2205_02906", "source_line": 5148, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 81, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked well for a UV-complete inflaton-dark-matter setup with high CMB relevance, mixed phase-space, and partial computational support, balanced by tuning/resonance warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_08409_inelastic_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2201_08409", "source_line": 5061, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 38, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 82, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 38 (tier3) as a speculative uv_complete member of inelastic_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; unusually usable computational support for this batch.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: phase transition/gw, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out; partner annihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 38, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_00820_nonthermal_wimp_baryogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1803_00820", "source_line": 3476, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 83, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Non-thermal WIMP baryogenesis model: the supplied card gives a simplified model nonthermal wimp dark matter model with nonthermal phase space, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "twin_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_03481_twin_bino_like_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_03481", "source_line": 4051, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 84, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 7, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative twin_neutralino_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_04072_mirror_star_dissipative_mirror_baryon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1909_04072", "source_line": 4025, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37.2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 85, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.8, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_11696_split_seesaw_bl_thermal_dilution_v1", "paper_id": "1907_11696", "source_line": 3911, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 86, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB, small-scale structure.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_06216_irreducible_freeze_in_axion_background_v1", "paper_id": "2209_06216", "source_line": 5286, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 87, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied fields for Irreducible freeze-in axion background: speculative status, effective-field-theory theory level, and production via freeze-in from Standard Model plasma; inverse decays, nonthermal phase space, suppression of small-scale power, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection), family/diversity context for axion_like_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2968_gravitino_lsp_right_handed_sneutrino_nlsp_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2968", "source_line": 729, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 88, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; mixed_cold_warm phase-space history; mixed_cold_warm transfer behavior with suppression small-scale-power effect; BBN critical relevance; probe coverage from BBN, gravitational/cosmology, portal/laboratory, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_13086_kinetically_coupled_axion_dilaton_fuzzy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_13086", "source_line": 5266, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 89, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied fields for Kinetically coupled axion-dilaton fuzzy dark matter model: speculative status, effective-field-theory theory level, and production via misalignment/coherent scalar-field evolution after the axion rolls down its potential; energy transfer from axion phi into dilaton chi through kinetic coupling, field-like phase space, suppression of small-scale power, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, black-hole superradiance, collider / fixed-target / beam dump), family/diversity context for fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_02804_millicharged_subcomponent_lmutau_depletion_v1", "paper_id": "1803_02804", "source_line": 3425, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 90, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status no; CMB/BBN relevance high/high; structure entry suppression/scale_dependent_growth; phase-space type thermal; portals vector.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; only partial associated-code support; warnings: subcomponent_not_all_dm, edges_motivation_context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_02847_multiple_sm_sector_dissipative_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_02847", "source_line": 3434, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 91, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance high/high; structure entry suppression/smooth_cutoff; phase-space type thermal; portals vector, gravitational.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: not_collisionless_cdm, wdm_analogy_limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_16139_late_decay_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_16139", "source_line": 4273, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 92, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via thermal freeze-out of the WIMP-like S messenger followed by late S decays into dark matter; freeze-in-like dark-sector population before S decay due to very weak couplings, decay_produced phase-space treatment, small-scale-power mixed.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; a high-severity model-card warning was retained as a penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimension_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_05318_dark_dimension_kk_graviton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_05318", "source_line": 5870, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 93, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because the dark-dimension KK graviton tower is highly distinctive, with rare tensor/multi-component content and explicit smooth-cutoff small-scale suppression, but nonlinear predictions and public computational support are not yet available."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_17238_scalar_singlet_fimp_vectorlike_parent_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "2306_17238", "source_line": 5693, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 94, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 14, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Scalar singlet FIMP dark matter with vectorlike fermion parent during reheating (freeze_in_dark_matter) has non-CDM structure-formation behavior, decay produced phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, other, higgs portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 37.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "purely_gravitational_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_07471_purely_gravitational_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_07471", "source_line": 3463, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 95, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3.5, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Purely gravitational scalar dark matter: the supplied card gives a simplified model purely gravitational dark matter model with nonthermal phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, galaxy satellites / halo structure, indirect detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_11846_thdm_sterile_neutrino_portal_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_11846", "source_line": 5180, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 96, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: Dirac-fermion neutrino-portal variant has similarly strong mixed cold/warm, CMB/BBN, and free-streaming leverage while remaining distinct from the scalar ordering."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_11846_thdm_sterile_neutrino_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_11846", "source_line": 5179, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 97, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: scalar neutrino-portal model has mixed WIMP/FIMP regimes, CMB/BBN relevance, free-streaming checks, and smooth-cutoff structure behavior."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_08881_light_thermal_pseudo_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2405_08881", "source_line": 6049, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 98, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because light pseudo-Dirac vector-portal thermal dark matter is a benchmark with strong intensity-frontier testability and NLO calculations, but explicit constraints and routing are still absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_05025_hidden_qcd_dark_meson_v1", "paper_id": "1910_05025", "source_line": 4053, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 99, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 8, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: BBN, collider/fixed-target, gravitational waves.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_00568_inverse_seesaw_b_l_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_00568", "source_line": 3475, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 100, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 5.5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Gauged B-L inverse-seesaw Dirac fermion dark matter: the supplied card gives a uv complete hidden sector dark matter model with hidden sector dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_01758_2hdm_singlet_doublet_fermion_blind_spot_v1", "paper_id": "1912_01758", "source_line": 4078, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 37.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 101, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 37.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_2613_radiative_seesaw_warm_n1_entropy_dilution_v1", "paper_id": "1208_2613", "source_line": 1660, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 102, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.8, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal production of keV N_1; entropy dilution from out-of-equilibrium N_2 decay, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 36.8 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=critical and CMB=unknown; structure fields indicate smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale power; card-implied probe classes include BBN, collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_04168_visible_sterile_neutrino_low_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "1909_04168", "source_line": 4049, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 103, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.2, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior, nonthermal phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_04168_visible_sterile_neutrino_scalar_tensor_v1", "paper_id": "1909_04168", "source_line": 4048, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 104, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.2, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior, nonthermal phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_09141_fimp_decay_entropy_v1", "paper_id": "1906_09141", "source_line": 3903, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 105, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 16.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB, small-scale structure.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_09141_fimp_decay_scattering_v1", "paper_id": "1906_09141", "source_line": 3904, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 106, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 16.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB, small-scale structure.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_4646_singlet_higgs_decay_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0711_4646", "source_line": 720, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 107, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked yes; decay_produced phase-space history; smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale-power effect; BBN medium and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, portal/laboratory, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_00129_lrsm_n1_n2_diluted_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_00129", "source_line": 5939, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 108, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Minimal LRSM N1 dark matter with N2 entropy dilution has usable cosmology or structure hooks (BBN, CMB, small-scale structure) but still lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing extensions.", "Component balance: science 13, observational leverage 18, complementarity 8, feasibility 1, provenance 9, diversity 3.5, penalties 16; raw score 36.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_07718_dilaton_resonant_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_07718", "source_line": 5503, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 109, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, structure-formation leverage, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple plausible probe classes, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutron_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_09837_majorana_neutron_decay_dm_rpv_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_09837", "source_line": 3464, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 110, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Majorana dark matter from exotic neutron decay in R-parity-violating MSSM/GUT realization: the supplied card gives a uv complete neutron decay dark matter model with decay produced phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_07921_leptophobic_axial_zprime_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_07921", "source_line": 3496, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 111, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 5.5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Anomaly-free leptophobic axial Z-prime Dirac dark matter: the supplied card gives a uv complete vector portal dark matter model with vector portal dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_11696_split_seesaw_bl_low_reheat_v1", "paper_id": "1907_11696", "source_line": 3912, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 112, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB, small-scale structure.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_00208_hidden_sector_phase_transition_axion_minicluster_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_00208", "source_line": 2880, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 113, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; enhancement small-scale-power effect.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_17238_majorana_fimp_scalar_parent_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "2306_17238", "source_line": 5692, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 114, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Majorana FIMP dark matter with charged scalar parent during reheating (freeze_in_dark_matter) has non-CDM structure-formation behavior, decay produced phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, other portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 36.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_1774_modulus_decay_axion_hot_cold_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_1774", "source_line": 1981, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 115, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied model-card fields: strong cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, CMB, laboratory/collider/direct, small-scale structure; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_06651_abelian_zprime_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1602_06651", "source_line": 2792, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 116, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in sterile_neutrino_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: non-thermal production from massive Z' decays; portals: vector, neutrino; CMB relevance is medium; BBN relevance is medium.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_thermal_history_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_4034_early_matter_domination_daughter_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1311_4034", "source_line": 1991, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 117, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied model-card fields: strong cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, indirect detection, small-scale structure; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_5466_r_invariant_gauge_mediation_gravitino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1012_5466", "source_line": 1209, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 118, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from a speculative uv_complete card in family gravitino_warm_dark_matter with production via thermal gravitino production followed by late entropy dilution; subdominant gravitinos from x_L decay.", "Observational leverage is driven by suppression of small-scale power; unknown CMB and high BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics, galaxy satellites.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_attractor_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_03295_e_model_attractor_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_03295", "source_line": 3059, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 119, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_field_attractor_dark_matter entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, non-CDM structure marker suppression/smooth_cutoff, distinct phase space field_like; inferred probe classes: CMB, gravitational waves, laboratory precision, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_attractor_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_03295_tracker_attractor_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_03295", "source_line": 3060, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 120, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_field_attractor_dark_matter entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, non-CDM structure marker suppression/smooth_cutoff, distinct phase space field_like; inferred probe classes: CMB, gravitational waves, laboratory precision, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_02401_singlet_scalar_freeze_in_dark_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "1604_02401", "source_line": 2788, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 121, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in freeze_in_self_interacting_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: Higgs-decay freeze-in; dark-sector internal thermalization; portals: higgs; CMB relevance is medium; small-scale power effect is mixed.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_02401_sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_dark_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "1604_02401", "source_line": 2789, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 122, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: Higgs-decay freeze-in to singlet scalars; scalar decay to sterile fermions; portals: higgs; CMB relevance is medium; small-scale power effect is suppression.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_02338_pseudoscalar_hidden_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_02338", "source_line": 3052, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 123, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 98.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative interacting_dark_matter entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance low, CMB relevance high, non-CDM structure marker enhancement/oscillatory; inferred probe classes: CMB, indirect detection, laboratory precision, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_13555_symmetry_restored_2hdm_7kev_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1907_13555", "source_line": 3959, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 124, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Symmetry-restored 2HDM plus 7.1 keV sterile-neutrino freeze-in dark matter: high observational leverage, high diversity value; inferred probe classes are Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score 36 (tier3) uses production=freeze-in from thermalized scalar decays S -> N1 + lepton; phase=decay_produced; CMB=unknown, BBN=low; transfer=smooth_cutoff, small_scale=suppression; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_00430_axion_clump_photon_resonance_v1", "paper_id": "1805_00430", "source_line": 3453, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 125, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 5.0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Axion dark matter clump photon-resonance model: the supplied card gives a effective field theory axion like dark matter model with field like phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_07255_scalar_dm_clumps_angular_momentum_v1", "paper_id": "1804_07255", "source_line": 3478, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 126, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 4.5, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Light scalar dark matter clumps with angular momentum: the supplied card gives a phenomenological parameterization fuzzy ultralight dark matter model with field like phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, compact objects / dynamics, galaxy satellites / halo structure; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_05621_3hdm_astrophobic_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_05621", "source_line": 6021, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 127, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because the astrophobic QCD axion model has strong CMB, mixed cold-hot phase-space, and axion-portal leverage, though thermal and charge-assignment uncertainties remain."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_evaporation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_14773_pbh_evaporated_ncdm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_14773", "source_line": 4235, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 128, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include early-universe production connection, structure or tension connection; nonthermal phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutron_dark_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_08666_neutron_dark_decay_light_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_08666", "source_line": 6016, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 129, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because the neutron dark-decay scalar model ties thermal relic dark matter to BBN, neutron-star, Higgs, and small-scale self-interaction issues, with some calculation support but missing explicit constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_04488_right_sneutrino_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1806_04488", "source_line": 3513, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 130, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it is marked benchmark; it has a simplified-model implementation; it has decay_produced phase-space production; it touches BBN, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_09794_type_iii_seesaw_freeze_in_n_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_09794", "source_line": 5140, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 131, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked well for a UV-complete Type III seesaw freeze-in candidate with CMB/BBN relevance, target abundance, and strong provenance."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "standard_model_classical_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_12405_cosmological_gauge_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2203_12405", "source_line": 5120, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 132, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for its rare classical-gauge-field framework, high CMB relevance, provenance, and associated code; low robustness and absent observable mappings prevent a higher tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "left_right_minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_01670_lrs_su2r_quintuplet_bl0_singlet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1803_01670", "source_line": 3459, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 133, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Left-right symmetric SU(2)_R quintuplet dark matter with B-L=0 and singlet scalar: the supplied card gives a uv complete left right minimal dark matter model with left right minimal dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "left_right_minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_01670_lrs_su2r_quintuplet_bl4_singlet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1803_01670", "source_line": 3461, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 134, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Left-right symmetric SU(2)_R quintuplet dark matter with B-L=4 and singlet scalar: the supplied card gives a uv complete left right minimal dark matter model with left right minimal dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_04124_fimp_dirac_singlet_2hdm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_04124", "source_line": 4752, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 135, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: freeze-in from out-of-equilibrium N1 decays; negligible inverse decay due to feeble dark coupling.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth_cutoff transfer-function shape, decay_produced phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_01082_gmsugra_dfsz_axino_lsp_bino_nlsp_v1", "paper_id": "2304_01082", "source_line": 5544, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 136, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space information, multiple plausible probe classes, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_02802_mssm_bino_slepton_coannihilation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_02802", "source_line": 3484, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 137, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 4.5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 16}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for MSSM bino-slepton coannihilation dark matter: the supplied card gives a uv complete supersymmetric neutralino dark matter model with supersymmetric neutralino dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_02802_mssm_bino_wino_coannihilation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_02802", "source_line": 3483, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 138, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 4.5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 16}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for MSSM bino-wino coannihilation dark matter: the supplied card gives a uv complete supersymmetric neutralino dark matter model with supersymmetric neutralino dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_07865_scale_invariant_inverse_seesaw_majoron_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2306_07865", "source_line": 5668, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 139, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Scale-invariant inverse-seesaw Majoron freeze-in dark matter (majoron_dark_matter) has nonthermal phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, higgs, neutrino portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields. Raw score 36.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_14091_z3_sterile_neutrino_portal_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2306_14091", "source_line": 5699, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 140, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 14, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Z3 sterile-neutrino portal scalar WIMP dark matter (sterile_neutrino_portal_dark_matter) has CMB/BBN relevance, neutrino, higgs portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields. Raw score 36.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_1071_neutrino_portal_secluded_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_1071", "source_line": 2321, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 141, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 with score 36 because the assigned model card simplified model neutrino_portal_self_interacting_dark_matter card; has explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage; marks small-scale-power suppression; touches BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_07243_z4_inert_doublet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1911_07243", "source_line": 4077, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 36.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 142, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; limited observational leverage in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 36.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1909_04053_early_matter_dominated_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1909_04053", "source_line": 4024, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35.9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 143, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35.9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_11470_massive_dark_photon_soliton_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2301_11470", "source_line": 5513, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 144, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, structure-formation leverage, field_like phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_07372_hot_big_bang_black_hole_evaporation_particle_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_07372", "source_line": 5536, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 145, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, structure-formation leverage, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple plausible probe classes, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_13754_z3_dirac_fermion_nonthermal_dm_self_interacting_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2301_13754", "source_line": 5504, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 146, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_00277_right_handed_sneutrino_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_00277", "source_line": 3477, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 147, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Right-handed sneutrino self-interacting dark matter in double focus point BLSSM: the supplied card gives a uv complete self interacting dark matter model with medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_0191_nonthermal_warm_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1210_0191", "source_line": 1671, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35.2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 148, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as late gravitino decay; subdominant thermal freezeout contribution, with decay_produced phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 35.2 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=medium and CMB=low; structure fields indicate smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale power; card-implied probe classes include BBN, collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_01136_infrared_confining_fuzzy_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1701_01136", "source_line": 2952, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 149, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and yes all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, suppression of small-scale power, smooth_cutoff transfer-function shape.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include dark_radiation_assumption."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_02804_millicharged_hidden_scalar_depletion_v1", "paper_id": "1803_02804", "source_line": 3426, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 150, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status no; CMB/BBN relevance high/critical; structure entry suppression/scale_dependent_growth; phase-space type thermal; portals vector, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; only partial associated-code support; warnings: incomplete_hidden_sector, subcomponent_not_all_dm."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_3624_gravitino_lsp_right_handed_sneutrino_nlsp_v1", "paper_id": "0710_3624", "source_line": 744, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 151, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; mixed_cold_warm phase-space history; step_like transfer behavior with suppression small-scale-power effect; BBN high and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, gravitational/cosmology, portal/laboratory, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_12258_pbh_sterile_neutrinogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_12258", "source_line": 5833, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 152, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is nonthermal Hawking emission from evaporating PBHs.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, compact objects, indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (nonthermal, suppression) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Score is limited by absent top-level observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, model-comparison fields, and sparse computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_attractor_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_03295_t_model_attractor_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_03295", "source_line": 3061, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 153, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_field_attractor_dark_matter entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, non-CDM structure marker suppression/smooth_cutoff, distinct phase space field_like; inferred probe classes: CMB, gravitational waves, laboratory precision, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_1774_qcd_axion_saxion_decay_hot_cold_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_1774", "source_line": 1978, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 154, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_10340_halo_axion_star_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_10340", "source_line": 6040, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 155, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because halo axion-star QCD axion dark matter has unusually high structure/substructure leverage and approximate phase-space content, despite being a phenomenological axion substructure variant."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_decaying_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_2406_decaying_majoron_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0705_2406", "source_line": 721, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 156, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked yes; smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale-power effect; CMB critical relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_06952_electromagnetic_alp_misalignment_targets_v1", "paper_id": "1905_06952", "source_line": 3881, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 157, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 15.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as benchmark / effective_field_theory: A benchmark family of axion-like particle dark matter models with photon coupling and relic abundance from misalignment across standard and nonstandard pre-BBN cosmologies.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN medium; CMB low; phase-space field_like; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_heavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_03252_fopt_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_03252", "source_line": 6009, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 158, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because the vector first-order phase-transition candidate adds a rarer spin assignment to the same boosted nonthermal and small-scale-power phenomenology, despite missing constraints and code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_08943_hidden_dark_matter_hidm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_08943", "source_line": 5634, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 159, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because emerging hidden-dark-matter cosmology with high CMB/BBN relevance, a half-mode scale, and suppressed substructure.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_11522_pbh_superradiance_heavy_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_11522", "source_line": 5144, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 160, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for PBH superradiance and evaporation production with high BBN relevance and partial calculation support; unresolved scalar-cloud fate reduces confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2403_07333_generalized_no_scale_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_07333", "source_line": 6004, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 161, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because the card supplies no-scale-inflation PBH benchmark points with CMB and induced-gravitational-wave relevance, offset by missing observational constraints and public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pbh_evaporation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_09194_pbh_evaporation_gravitational_dm_fopt_v1", "paper_id": "2304_09194", "source_line": 5619, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 162, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because rare FOPT-origin PBH-evaporation dark matter with decay-produced phase space and small-scale suppression.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_late_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_4391_gravitino_nlsp_to_n_superpartner_and_n_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_4391", "source_line": 2357, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 163, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_late_decay_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and late invisible decay, nonthermal production production.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; high CMB relevance; decay-produced phase space.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (3 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: late invisible decay; multi-component candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_late_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_4391_n_superpartner_nlsp_to_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_4391", "source_line": 2356, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 164, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_late_decay_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and late invisible decay, nonthermal production production.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; high CMB relevance; decay-produced phase space.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (3 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: late invisible decay; multi-component candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_late_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_4391_n_superpartner_nlsp_to_n_and_light_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_4391", "source_line": 2355, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 165, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_late_decay_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and late invisible decay, nonthermal production production.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; high CMB relevance; decay-produced phase space.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (3 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: late invisible decay; multi-component candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_09726_scotogenic_scalar_doublet_emd_v1", "paper_id": "1912_09726", "source_line": 4092, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 166, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 9, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative scotogenic_scalar_doublet_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, collider/fixed-target.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_14091_z3_sterile_neutrino_portal_fermion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2306_14091", "source_line": 5698, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 35.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 167, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Z3 sterile-neutrino portal fermion WIMP dark matter (sterile_neutrino_portal_dark_matter) has CMB/BBN relevance, neutrino, higgs portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields. Raw score 35.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 35.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_00819_b3le_scotogenic_pattern_a_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1911_00819", "source_line": 4010, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 168, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_01007_massive_dark_photon_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_01007", "source_line": 4143, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 169, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score 34.5: speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale power, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior, nonthermal phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: CMB, gravitational waves, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_06889_axion_su2_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_06889", "source_line": 5902, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 170, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Axion-SU(2) inflation vector boson dark matter has usable cosmology or structure hooks (BBN, CMB, small-scale structure) but still lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing extensions.", "Component balance: science 11, observational leverage 18, complementarity 8, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 3.5, penalties 15; raw score 34.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_13333_rolling_pq_axion_bubble_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2310_13333", "source_line": 5876, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 171, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because rolling-PQ axion bubbles combine CMB relevance, mixed small-scale effects, PBH substructure, and axion complementarity, while rare-bubble statistics and missing implementation/routing keep it below higher tiers."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_inflationary_fluctuation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_01214_scalar_field_fluctuation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_01214", "source_line": 3832, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 172, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with production listed as inflationary scalar-field fluctuations, post-inflationary scalar condensate oscillations.", "High observational leverage comes from the card's field like phase-space entry, enhancement small-scale-power entry, and high/low CMB/BBN relevance.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_10096_charge_sequestration_charged_x_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1803_10096", "source_line": 3482, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 173, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Charge-sequestration charged-X dark matter: the supplied card gives a phenomenological parameterization millicharged dark matter model with nonthermal phase space, high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_07122_light_freeze_in_two_body_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_07122", "source_line": 4755, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 174, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: freeze-in from thermal scalar two-body decay.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth_cutoff transfer-function shape.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_13754_z3_dirac_fermion_nonthermal_dm_higgs_portal_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2301_13754", "source_line": 5505, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 175, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_11344_vector_dm_magnetic_dipole_absorption_v1", "paper_id": "2303_11344", "source_line": 5526, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 176, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple plausible probe classes, and some code, benchmark, or analytic support.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_01846_pq_dirac_neutrino_fermion_wimp_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2001_01846", "source_line": 4066, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 177, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative multi_component_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'mixed_cold_warm', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, laboratory precision/axion searches.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_04430_fourth_family_dirac_neutrino_zprime_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1803_04430", "source_line": 3481, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 178, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4.5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Fourth-family Dirac-neutrino Z' WIMP: the supplied card gives a uv complete zprime wimp dark matter model with zprime wimp dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2476_ultralight_scalar_neutrino_nonselfconjugate_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2476", "source_line": 1245, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 179, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from a speculative simplified_model card in family fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter with production via scalar-field cooling, decoupling, and condensation below a critical temperature.", "Observational leverage is driven by suppression of small-scale power; field_like phase space; medium CMB and unknown BBN relevance; probe classes: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2476_ultralight_scalar_neutrino_self_conjugate_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2476", "source_line": 1246, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 180, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from a speculative simplified_model card in family fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter with production via scalar-field cooling, decoupling, and condensation below a critical temperature.", "Observational leverage is driven by suppression of small-scale power; field_like phase space; medium CMB and unknown BBN relevance; probe classes: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_07269_alp_dark_photon_magnetogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_07269", "source_line": 3367, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 181, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 18.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory support and field like phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, astrophysical fields, collider/fixed-target.", "Structure-formation field records suppression small-scale-power behavior.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_00208_pq_after_inflation_axion_minicluster_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_00208", "source_line": 2879, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 182, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium CMB relevance; enhancement small-scale-power effect; enhanced_small_scale_power transfer behavior.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_hidden_radiation", "model_id": "1602_07624_hidden_neutrino_pseudoscalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1602_07624", "source_line": 2777, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 183, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in interacting_dark_matter_hidden_radiation.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through annihilation into two mediators; late kinetic decoupling from hidden light fermions; portals: neutrino, other; CMB relevance is high; BBN relevance is medium.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_hidden_radiation", "model_id": "1602_07624_hidden_neutrino_pseudovector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1602_07624", "source_line": 2778, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 184, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 97.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in interacting_dark_matter_hidden_radiation.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through annihilation into two mediators; late kinetic decoupling from hidden light fermions; portals: neutrino, other; CMB relevance is high; BBN relevance is medium.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_hidden_radiation", "model_id": "1602_07624_hidden_neutrino_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1602_07624", "source_line": 2775, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 185, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in interacting_dark_matter_hidden_radiation.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through annihilation into two mediators; late kinetic decoupling from hidden light fermions; portals: neutrino, other; CMB relevance is high; BBN relevance is medium.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_hidden_radiation", "model_id": "1602_07624_hidden_neutrino_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1602_07624", "source_line": 2776, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 186, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in interacting_dark_matter_hidden_radiation.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through annihilation into two mediators; late kinetic decoupling from hidden light fermions; portals: neutrino, other; CMB relevance is high; BBN relevance is medium.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_08732_ultralight_scalar_neutrino_coupled_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_08732", "source_line": 4915, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 187, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Ultralight scalar dark matter coupled to Majorana neutrinos is speculative with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by field_like phase-space information, suppression structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: observational leverage, probe complementarity, provenance, diversity.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sgoldstino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_03231_cp_even_sgoldstino_wave_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_03231", "source_line": 5272, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 188, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied fields for CP-even sgoldstino wave-like dark matter: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via misalignment mechanism producing a coherently oscillating ultralight scalar field, field-like phase space, suppression of small-scale power, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection), family/diversity context for sgoldstino_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_09458_two_component_majorana_fimp_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1912_09458", "source_line": 4120, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 189, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score 34: speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, suppression small-scale power, nonthermal phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_1934_dbi_galileon_thermal_gravitino_v1", "paper_id": "1309_1934", "source_line": 1924, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 190, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 34.0 because the model card is a speculative gravitino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; medium BBN and high CMB relevance; suppression small-scale-power behavior with smooth_cutoff transfer-function information; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches BBN, CMB, collider, cosmological gravity, small-scale structure.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; high-severity card warnings limit robustness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_09154_hidden_u1d_two_component_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_09154", "source_line": 3542, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 191, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a simplified-model implementation; it has mixed_cold_warm phase-space production; it gives explicit small-scale-structure leverage; it touches CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target, direct detection and other probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_2959_mixed_axion_axino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1009_2959", "source_line": 1234, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 192, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from a speculative simplified_model card in family multi_component_dark_matter with production via axion vacuum misalignment after PQ breaking before inflation; thermal production of axinos below the axino decoupling temperature.", "Observational leverage is driven by mixed_cold_warm phase space; unknown CMB and high BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_09840_kev_sterile_neutrino_mes_a4_v1", "paper_id": "2302_09840", "source_line": 5542, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 193, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, structure-formation leverage, nonthermal phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_12322_lepton_quarticity_self_interacting_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_12322", "source_line": 5897, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 194, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because lepton quarticity ties Dirac-neutrino structure to thermal SIDM with CMB and small-scale-halo leverage, while relic/self-scattering viability still depends on mediator and portal assumptions."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0709_0297_goldilocks_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0709_0297", "source_line": 764, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 195, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 34.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance high, CMB relevance medium, small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type decay_produced; probe classes counted: ['BBN', 'CMB', 'halo/subhalo abundance', 'small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_00184_type_i_seesaw_freeze_in_s_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2304_00184", "source_line": 5529, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 196, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_01604_spectator_pq_ksvz_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1909_01604", "source_line": 3974, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 197, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for KSVZ axion dark matter with spectator PQ-field domain-wall solution: strong model-card science motivation, moderate observational leverage, high diversity value; inferred probe classes are CMB, collider / fixed-target, gravitational waves, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 34 (tier3) uses production=nonthermal coherent oscillation after the QCD scale from spectator-set axion displacement; misalignment-like axion production with domain-wall formation avoided by early spectator dynamics; phase=field_like; CMB=high, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_01144_light_dirac_neutrino_portal_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_01144", "source_line": 5173, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 198, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: decay-produced Dirac-neutrino-portal FIMP has explicit distribution/free-streaming content plus CMB, BBN, and small-scale-suppression relevance."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_thermal_nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_07078_dark_fermion_decay_injection_self_scattering_v1", "paper_id": "2204_07078", "source_line": 5119, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 199, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked well within the sparse batch because late decay injection, mixed phase-space, CMB/BBN relevance, and partial calculation support create observational leverage."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_17564_fopt_rescued_self_interacting_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_17564", "source_line": 6046, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 200, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because first-order phase-transition rescued self-interacting fermion dark matter combines BBN/CMB relevance, small-scale self-interactions, and gravitational-wave complementarity, though code and route fields are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pbh_evaporation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_09194_pbh_evaporation_gravitational_dm_curvature_v1", "paper_id": "2304_09194", "source_line": 5618, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 201, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because rare PBH-evaporation dark matter with decay-produced phase space and small-scale suppression.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_13799_cw_ultralight_scalar_higgs_portal_rhn_v1", "paper_id": "2306_13799", "source_line": 5682, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 202, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 14, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Coleman-Weinberg ultralight scalar dark matter with GeV-scale right-handed neutrinos (ultralight_scalar_dark_matter) has field like phase-space information, higgs, neutrino portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 34.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_09558_feebly_coupled_u1x_hidden_sector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_09558", "source_line": 6028, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 203, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because the feebly coupled U(1)_X hidden sector includes hidden-temperature evolution, BBN relevance, a first-order phase transition, and gravitational-wave complementarity, but no public code is supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_11314_trilinear_augmented_gaugino_mediation_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_11314", "source_line": 3474, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 204, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Trilinear-augmented gaugino mediation gravitino dark matter: the supplied card gives a phenomenological parameterization supersymmetric dark matter model with high BBN relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites / halo structure; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "left_right_minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_01670_lrs_su2r_quintuplet_bl2_singlet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1803_01670", "source_line": 3460, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 205, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Left-right symmetric SU(2)_R quintuplet dark matter with B-L=2 and singlet scalar: the supplied card gives a uv complete left right minimal dark matter model with left right minimal dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; large penalties come from missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "complex_singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_16568_cp_conserving_cxsm_domain_wall_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_16568", "source_line": 6039, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 206, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because biased domain-wall complex-singlet dark matter has BBN, gravitational-wave, Higgs-portal, and partial code support, but the viable region is narrow and routing is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_13244_sfdm_tf_v1", "paper_id": "2106_13244", "source_line": 4764, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 207, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative self_interacting_ultralight_scalar_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and production logic from: homogeneous scalar-field oscillations become nonrelativistic and matter-like after the mass term dominates; cosmological gravitational instability of the scalar-field fluid.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth_cutoff transfer-function shape, field_like phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "split_simp_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_04906_split_simp_pseudo_dirac_v1", "paper_id": "1702_04906", "source_line": 3057, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 208, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative split_simp_self_interacting_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance medium, CMB relevance medium, distinct phase space nonthermal; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "split_simp_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_04906_split_simp_real_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1702_04906", "source_line": 3058, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 209, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative split_simp_self_interacting_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance medium, CMB relevance medium, distinct phase space nonthermal; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_axion_dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_11387_dark_axion_portal_mixed_axion_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2112_11387", "source_line": 5005, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 210, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Dark Axion Portal mixed axion-dark-photon dark matter has strong supplied observational leverage; probe classes: CMB, gravitational waves, laboratory/particle, small-scale structure; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior; some implementation support from code or benchmarks, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_02077_colder_freeze_in_axino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_02077", "source_line": 3171, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 211, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 9.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 34.0: Colder freeze-in axino dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with freeze-in from thermal MSSM particles through DFSZ interactions.", "Rank-relevant positives are medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space treatment, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, CMB, collider, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_08266_singlet_doublet_dirac_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2204_08266", "source_line": 5122, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 212, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked well for a singlet-doublet Dirac seesaw model with CMB/BBN relevance and broad complementarity through vector, Higgs, neutrino, and scalar sectors."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_01383_sterile_neutrino_portal_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_01383", "source_line": 5603, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 213, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because neutrino-portal scattering, high CMB relevance, and scale-dependent small-scale suppression.", "Score is still held down by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points despite limited code support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_14242_axion_rotation_poltergeist_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2305_14242", "source_line": 5644, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 214, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because UV-complete axion-rotation dark matter with enhanced small-scale power and minihalo implications.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "heavy_quark_gluon_philic_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_11857_majorana_heavy_quark_gluon_philic_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2110_11857", "source_line": 4939, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 215, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Heavy-quark and gluon-philic Majorana dark matter EFT is benchmark with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, feasibility, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "confining_dark_sector_thermal_squeezeout", "model_id": "2203_15813_thermal_squeezeout_zprime_dark_baryons_v1", "paper_id": "2203_15813", "source_line": 5125, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 34, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 216, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a rare composite squeezeout scenario with first-order dark confinement, entropy injection, and high BBN relevance; route and constraint fields are still empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 34, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_00819_b3ltau_scotogenic_pattern_c_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1911_00819", "source_line": 4012, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 217, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_03013_scotogenic_type_ii_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_03013", "source_line": 4036, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 218, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_3278_partially_interacting_dark_atom_dao_v1", "paper_id": "1310_3278", "source_line": 1982, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 219, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied model-card fields: strong cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, dark acoustic structure, small-scale structure; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_12136_pbh_sterile_neutrinogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2312_12136", "source_line": 5903, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 220, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because PBH sterile neutrinogenesis sterile-neutrino dark matter has usable cosmology or structure hooks (BBN, CMB, compact objects, small-scale structure) but still lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing extensions.", "Component balance: science 9, observational leverage 18, complementarity 10, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 4.5, penalties 17; raw score 33.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_1352_ltr_thermal_hadronic_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0711_1352", "source_line": 725, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 221, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 because the supplied card has speculative phenomenological_parameterization model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale-power effect; BBN high and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, portal/laboratory, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_10015_blsmis_two_component_fimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_10015", "source_line": 3808, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 222, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as freeze-in S_1^1 production from Z' decay and Z'-mediated annihilation, freeze-in nu_H^1 production from Z' decay, h_2 decay, and annihilation channels.", "Moderate observational leverage comes from the card's mixed cold warm phase-space entry, cosmological relevance, or explicit non-CDM structure-formation fields.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_16242_wimp_qcd_axion_emde_multicomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2308_16242", "source_line": 5811, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 223, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is QCD axion misalignment with PQ breaking before inflation.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, axion laboratory, indirect detection, small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (unknown, enhancement) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Score is limited by absent top-level observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, model-comparison fields, and sparse computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_00010_axion_quark_nugget_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_00010", "source_line": 5522, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 224, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, structure-formation leverage, multiple plausible probe classes, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_02098_split_fermionic_wimps_v1", "paper_id": "1805_02098", "source_line": 3479, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 225, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4.5, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Split fermionic WIMPs with singlet scalar Higgs portal: the supplied card gives a simplified model wimp dark matter model with medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_11344_vector_dm_electric_dipole_absorption_v1", "paper_id": "2303_11344", "source_line": 5527, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 226, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple plausible probe classes, and some code, benchmark, or analytic support.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_04537_hidden_su_n_qcd_axion_bubbles_v1", "paper_id": "2303_04537", "source_line": 5525, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 227, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, structure-formation leverage, field_like phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_03389_heavy_dark_photon_dirac_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1911_03389", "source_line": 4081, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 228, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 9, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_03389_heavy_dark_photon_scalar_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1911_03389", "source_line": 4082, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 229, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 9, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_16122_pbh_evaporated_wimpy_baryogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_16122", "source_line": 5807, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 230, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is Hawking evaporation of pre-existing primordial black holes after WIMP freeze-out.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, compact objects, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (decay_produced, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Score is limited by absent top-level observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, model-comparison fields, and sparse computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_10360_higgs_portal_self_interacting_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_10360", "source_line": 5863, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 231, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because a rare freeze-in self-interacting Higgs-portal scalar has relic-density code support, nonthermal production, and small-scale-halo relevance, although explicit observables, constraints, and routing still need extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_wimp", "model_id": "1910_08422_singlet_triplet_scotogenic_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1910_08422", "source_line": 4046, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 232, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.7, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1907_06533_poisson_pbh_velocity_floor_v1", "paper_id": "1907_06533", "source_line": 3931, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 233, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 19, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB, compact-object/dynamics, small-scale structure.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inflationary_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_13224_inflationary_vector_dark_matter_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "2006_13224", "source_line": 4283, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 234, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative inflationary_vector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via gravitational production of the longitudinal vector mode during inflation; sub-Hubble freeze-in contribution from SM interactions when couplings are present, nonthermal phase-space treatment, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_heavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_03252_fopt_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_03252", "source_line": 6008, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 235, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because first-order phase-transition fermion production is distinctive, nonthermal, and can suppress small-scale power, but it is near-duplicate simplified content with no explicit constraints or code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_heavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_03252_fopt_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_03252", "source_line": 6007, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 236, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because first-order phase-transition scalar production is distinctive, nonthermal, and can suppress small-scale power, but the supplied row is a simplified setup with no explicit constraints or code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_04964_l2_right_sneutrino_nonthermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_04964", "source_line": 3506, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 237, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a simplified-model implementation; it has decay_produced phase-space production; it touches BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nontopological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_12290_q_ball_model_a_solitosynthesis_v1", "paper_id": "2208_12290", "source_line": 5279, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 238, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied fields for Q-ball dark matter from Model A solitosynthesis: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via solitosynthesis from free charged particles; first-order or second-order phase-transition formation from false-vacuum pockets, nonthermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, indirect detection), family/diversity context for nontopological_soliton_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nontopological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_12290_q_ball_model_b_solitosynthesis_v1", "paper_id": "2208_12290", "source_line": 5280, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 239, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied fields for Q-ball dark matter from Model B solitosynthesis: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via solitosynthesis from charged free particles; phase-transition formation from false-vacuum pockets, nonthermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, indirect detection), family/diversity context for nontopological_soliton_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2204_09628_late_forming_pbh_fermion_scalar_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "2204_09628", "source_line": 5145, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 240, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for late-forming PBH dark matter with strong CMB/BBN leverage and macroscopic diversity, but low robustness and absent structured constraints prevent a higher tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_01086_extended_lmu_ltau_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_01086", "source_line": 5101, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 241, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because it links nonthermal scalar production to leptogenesis and has warm/cold free-streaming structure; priority is capped by high stability and portal-suppression caveats plus missing structured constraints and routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_00032_inelastic_dark_photon_thermal_relic_v1", "paper_id": "2311_00032", "source_line": 5885, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 242, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because the inelastic dark-photon thermal relic has strong CMB, beam/fixed-target, collider, and late-signal complementarity with high robustness, but the model-only card omits explicit constraints and routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_06341_mirror_twin_higgs_reheaton_atomic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2311_06341", "source_line": 5880, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 243, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because the mirror-twin reheaton atomic dark matter scenario has strong BBN/CMB leverage, composite hidden-sector diversity, and broad probe complementarity, though flavor/hierarchy assumptions and absent routing constrain readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_00184_type_iii_seesaw_freeze_in_s_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2304_00184", "source_line": 5530, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 244, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_02255_high_fa_qcd_axion_pbh_ucmh_v1", "paper_id": "2205_02255", "source_line": 5183, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 245, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 96.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: high-f_a axion with PBH-seeded UCMHs has BBN/CMB relevance, enhanced small-scale power, approximate field/profile distributions, and compact-object/minihalo complementarity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_02487_minimal_atomic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_02487", "source_line": 5407, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 246, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier 3 because atomic dark matter has strong CMB/BBN relevance, mixed cold/warm phase space, oscillatory suppressed transfer behavior, nonlinear halo effects, and CLASS implementation context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_fermionic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_04590_subkev_fermionic_fermi_pressure_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_04590", "source_line": 3003, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 247, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Sub-keV fermionic dark matter with Fermi-pressure dwarf cores is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has strong cosmological or small-scale-structure leverage; uses a mixed-cold-warm phase-space history; modifies small-scale power; adds high diversity value for this batch; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "real_scalar_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_07659_decoupled_real_scalar_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_07659", "source_line": 3865, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 248, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 12.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A stable real scalar dark matter model whose relic abundance is governed by dark-sector self-coupling, relativistic freeze-out, kinetic equilibrium, and possible chemical potential while the Higgs portal is negligible.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: mixed relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN medium; CMB medium; phase-space mixed_cold_warm; transfer function mixed_cold_warm; small-scale power suppression.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: do_not_treat_as_wimp."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_02170_dissipative_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_02170", "source_line": 315, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 249, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 10, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=emerging, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is high, small-scale power effect is suppression, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth, phase-space type is field_like.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:phenomenological_gamma.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 10/12/5/3/9/4/10."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_4007_supersymmetric_two_component_radiative_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1012_4007", "source_line": 1229, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 250, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family multi_component_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out of N1 through eta_u exchange and possible N1-N2 coannihilation; thermal neutralino freeze-out as in the MSSM.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB and medium BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_bose_einstein_condensed_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_07354_asymmetric_condensed_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1502_07354", "source_line": 345, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 251, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, BBN relevance is high, small-scale power effect is suppression, transfer function shape is mixed_cold_warm.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, CMB, indirect detection, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:unspecified_portal, medium:mixed_phase_space.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/11/10/0/9/10/15."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_14446_nonminimal_gravitational_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_14446", "source_line": 5615, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 252, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because non-minimally coupled gravitational scalar production with high cosmological relevance and nonthermal suppression.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_01879_s3_inert_dark_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1804_01879", "source_line": 3466, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 253, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for S3 symmetric inert dark scalar: the supplied card gives a uv complete scalar dark matter model with scalar dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_07753_forbidden_leptophilic_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_07753", "source_line": 5679, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 254, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Forbidden leptophilic Dirac-fermion dark matter with scalar mediator (forbidden_dark_matter) has nonthermal phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, other portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields. Raw score 33.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_02352_axion_quark_nugget_frb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1806_02352", "source_line": 3547, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 255, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a UV-complete model card; it touches collider / fixed-target, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, gravitational waves / defects and other probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_07362_stochastic_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1805_07362", "source_line": 3535, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 256, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a UV-complete model card; it has field_like phase-space production; it touches CMB, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hyperlight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_10358_hyperlight_coupled_scalar_late_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_10358", "source_line": 6051, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 257, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as tier3 with raw score 33.0: speculative effective field theory model in hyperlight_scalar_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as no.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: CMB, laboratory precision, small-scale structure; phase space is field like; small-scale power effect is suppression.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is partial and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_09726_scotogenic_scalar_doublet_feu_v1", "paper_id": "1912_09726", "source_line": 4093, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 258, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 9, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative scotogenic_scalar_doublet_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, collider/fixed-target.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "heavy_quark_gluon_philic_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_11857_real_scalar_heavy_quark_gluon_philic_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2110_11857", "source_line": 4940, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 259, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Heavy-quark and gluon-philic real scalar dark matter EFT is benchmark with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, feasibility, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 1-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_09239_nontopological_soliton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2405_09239", "source_line": 6050, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 260, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because scalar nontopological soliton dark matter is a rare macroscopic composite class with nonthermal formation channels and high diversity value, despite missing code, constraints, and route maps."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_03554_two_real_singlet_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_03554", "source_line": 3524, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 33, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 261, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a simplified-model implementation; it touches BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection and other probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 33, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_monopole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_03627_hidden_monopole_axion_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1909_03627", "source_line": 4033, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 262, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_00819_b3lmu_scotogenic_pattern_b_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1911_00819", "source_line": 4011, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 263, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_1352_kination_thermal_hadronic_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0711_1352", "source_line": 726, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 264, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 because the supplied card has speculative phenomenological_parameterization model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale-power effect; BBN medium and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, portal/laboratory, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_12545_hidden_sector_kev_fermion_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_12545", "source_line": 3822, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 265, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as relativistic freeze-out through feeble portal interactions, entropy dilution from long-lived hidden scalar decay.", "High observational leverage comes from the card's thermal phase-space entry, suppression small-scale-power entry, and medium/unknown CMB/BBN relevance.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_04293_earth_shielded_plasma_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1806_04293", "source_line": 3499, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 266, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3.5, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Earth-shielded plasma dark matter: the supplied card gives a phenomenological parameterization self interacting dark matter model with nonthermal phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, compact objects / dynamics; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_relic_cosimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_00008_leptophilic_scalar_cosimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_00008", "source_line": 5510, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 267, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, multiple plausible probe classes, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_4858_supersymmetric_pq_axion_saxion_v1", "paper_id": "1207_4858", "source_line": 1653, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 268, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as axion coherent oscillation / misalignment; thermal production of axino and saxion, with field_like phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 32.5 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=high and CMB=high; card-implied probe classes include BBN, CMB, collider, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_11590_astrophysical_q_ball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_11590", "source_line": 5538, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 269, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, structure-formation leverage, field_like phase-space information, some cross-probe reach, high diversity value in the population context, and some code, benchmark, or analytic support.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_01457_planck_scale_axion_lump_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_01457", "source_line": 4751, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 270, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: nonthermal Bose-Einstein condensation; depercolation of homogeneous axion condensates into selfgravitating fuzzy lumps.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance, mixed small-scale-power effect, smooth_cutoff transfer-function shape, field_like phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_2555_minimal_pq_nmssm_singlino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1208_2555", "source_line": 1661, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 271, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out of singlino-like neutralino; Higgs or Z resonance annihilation can lower thermal abundance, with nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 32.5 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=medium and CMB=medium; card-implied probe classes include BBN, CMB, collider, direct detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_3563_nonsequestered_lvs_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1208_3563", "source_line": 1663, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 272, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as QCD axion misalignment; possible dilution from late modulus decay if it occurs after QCD phase transition, with field_like phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 32.5 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=high and CMB=medium; card-implied probe classes include BBN, CMB, indirect detection, laboratory precision; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_12342_dark_proton_pion_asymmetric_mattergenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1911_12342", "source_line": 4105, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 273, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score 32.5: speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior, phase-transition/GW-motivated phenomenology; inferred probe classes: BBN, direct detection, gravitational waves, neutrino.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2107_03580_affleck_dine_clustered_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2107_03580", "source_line": 4765, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 274, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: Affleck-Dine field quantum diffusion during inflation; baryon-rich bubble formation after inflation.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance, enhancement small-scale-power effect, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function shape, nonthermal phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_08821_hidden_sector_two_higgs_doublet_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1912_08821", "source_line": 4091, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 275, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 7, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dissipative_atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_18086_mirror_star_optically_thin_nugget_v1", "paper_id": "2311_18086", "source_line": 5924, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 276, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Optically thin mirror-star nugget emission model has usable cosmology or structure hooks (CMB, compact objects, indirect detection, small-scale structure) but still lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing extensions.", "Component balance: science 9, observational leverage 8, complementarity 10, feasibility 2, provenance 9, diversity 7.5, penalties 13; raw score 32.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_2739_extra_dimensional_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_2739", "source_line": 2215, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 277, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative sterile_neutrino_warm_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "Cosmology, phase-space, or small-scale-structure fields provide above-average observational leverage within this batch.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, neutrino/laboratory.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family, uncommon production history, or distinctive phase-space category in the provided population context.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_11696_fractional_cold_plus_warm_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1907_11696", "source_line": 3913, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 278, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 21, "penalties": 17.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB, small-scale structure.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_06220_late_universe_two_body_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_06220", "source_line": 3793, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 279, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 20, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score 32 because the card identifies production via primordial cold parent abundance fixed by recombination initial con..., late-time two-body decay into a massless daughter and a warm massiv..., mixed_cold_warm phase-space treatment, suppression small-scale-power behavior, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function shape, probe classes: CMB, decay or indirect probes, small-scale structure; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_04278_bl_dark_photon_warm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_04278", "source_line": 4276, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 280, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative warm_vector_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support, production via nonthermal decay of a coherently oscillating B-L scalar; spontaneous U(1)_B-L breaking before scalar decay, decay_produced phase-space treatment, small-scale-power suppression, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified; a high-severity model-card warning was retained as a penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_10160_vector_mediated_light_gravitino_v1", "paper_id": "1801_10160", "source_line": 3353, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 281, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 17.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative gravitino_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, compact objects/lensing.", "Structure-formation field records suppression small-scale-power behavior.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_20513_kinetic_recoupling_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2310_20513", "source_line": 5866, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 282, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because kinetic recoupling gives rare oscillatory/mixed small-scale transfer-function behavior with CMB and structure-formation leverage, even though the particle identity and UV completion are intentionally generic."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_6374_exothermic_yukawa_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1011_6374", "source_line": 1228, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 283, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from a speculative simplified_model card in family self_interacting_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out with excited states surviving from the early universe; nonthermal production of excited states from heavier state decays.", "Observational leverage is driven by mixed of small-scale power; mixed_cold_warm phase space; medium CMB and unknown BBN relevance; probe classes: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_01238_stable_scalar_mediator_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1910_01238", "source_line": 3991, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 284, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Stable scalar mediator self-interacting fermion dark matter: strong model-card science motivation, high observational leverage; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score 32 (tier3) uses production=thermal freeze-out of chi chi to S S; freeze-out/depletion of S through S S to h2 h2; phase=thermal; CMB=high, BBN=high; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_02904_lepton_portal_freeze_in_scalar_hierarchical_v1", "paper_id": "2304_02904", "source_line": 5569, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 285, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because hierarchical lepton-portal freeze-in has CMB/BBN and small-scale-suppression leverage with partial code support, but the observational-detail fields are not populated.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2403_16963_reheating_pbh_dm_broken_power_law_v1", "paper_id": "2403_16963", "source_line": 6005, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 286, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because stiff-reheating PBH production has strong CMB, BBN, PTA, and induced-gravitational-wave leverage, but the model is phenomenological and lacks public implementation or explicit routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decay_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0507300_dark_matter_from_early_decays_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0507300", "source_line": 598, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 287, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Dark matter from early decays is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card in family decay_produced_dark_matter with production described as nonthermal production from decays of a heavier parent particle.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; decay produced phase space; suppression of small-scale power; smooth cutoff transfer behavior; probe classes: BBN, CMB, halo/subhalo structure, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_12487_qg_broken_fermionic_fimp_domain_wall_v1", "paper_id": "2311_12487", "source_line": 5860, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 288, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because the QG-broken FIMP/domain-wall model has BBN, CMB, decay, and possible gravitational-wave leverage with a clear nonthermal production story, though severe symmetry-breaking assumptions and missing routing/constraints limit readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_04276_dirac_scotogenic_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2203_04276", "source_line": 5082, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 289, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 32 (tier3) as a speculative simplified_model member of freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; clear cosmological or phase-space leverage; multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, structure/dynamics, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, inflation/reheating, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in, baryogenesis/leptogenesis.", "Production summary used: freeze-in from out-of-equilibrium SM-fermion annihilations mediated by an off-shell B-L Z prime."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_3563_sequestered_lvs_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1208_3563", "source_line": 1662, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 290, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as late overall-volume-modulus decay; nonthermal LSP production, with nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 32 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=high and CMB=high; card-implied probe classes include BBN, CMB, collider, direct detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_4319_axion_axino_dark_radiation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_4319", "source_line": 1377, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 291, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as multi_component_dark_matter: production is represented by axion vacuum misalignment; phase-space is mixed_cold_warm; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation fields provide observational leverage; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_08249_inverse_seesaw_kev_neutrino_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2305_08249", "source_line": 5591, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 292, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because decay-produced keV sterile-neutrino freeze-in has warm-structure leverage and neutrino-sector motivation, despite subcomponent relic support and empty observational-detail fields.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_0536_scalar_decay_reheating_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_0536", "source_line": 1317, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 293, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance critical, small-scale power enhancement, transfer function enhanced_small_scale_power, phase-space type decay_produced.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for nonthermal_cold_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_01866_spin_2_portal_vector_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1803_01866", "source_line": 3473, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 294, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Spin-2 portal vector freeze-in dark matter: the supplied card gives a simplified model freeze in dark matter model with nonthermal phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites / halo structure; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_10139_simp_axion_portal_dark_pions_v1", "paper_id": "1806_10139", "source_line": 3544, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 295, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it gives explicit small-scale-structure leverage; it touches CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites and other probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_06039_linear_nonminimal_inflaton_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_06039", "source_line": 5817, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 296, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is nonthermal production from perturbative inflaton condensate decay.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, indirect detection, small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (decay_produced, suppression) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Score is limited by absent top-level observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, model-comparison fields, and sparse computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_06039_linear_nonminimal_inflaton_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_06039", "source_line": 5819, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 297, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is nonthermal production from perturbative inflaton condensate decay.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, indirect detection, small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (decay_produced, suppression) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Score is limited by absent top-level observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, model-comparison fields, and sparse computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_06418_dfsz_freeze_in_axino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_06418", "source_line": 3255, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 298, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, suppression small-scale power with smooth cutoff transfer behavior.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_09337_multi_scalar_field_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_09337", "source_line": 237, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 299, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative multi_component_ultralight_scalar_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=medium, transfer_function=smooth_cutoff, small_scale_power_effect=suppression, and probe classes: BBN, CMB, structure formation.", "Feasibility receives limited credit for associated_code=yes; shard-level ranks are left null for the parent aggregator."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_vacuum_bubble_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_18645_dark_matter_pearls_void_domain_walls_v1", "paper_id": "2305_18645", "source_line": 5700, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 300, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 14, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Dark matter pearls with low-tension vacuum domain walls around voids (macroscopic_vacuum_bubble_dark_matter) has non-CDM structure-formation behavior, CMB/BBN relevance, gravitational, other portal coverage, high diversity value in the population context, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support, low robustness. Raw score 32.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_02958_light_gravitino_entropy_dilution_v1", "paper_id": "2104_02958", "source_line": 4634, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 301, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative gravitino warm dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked unknown; explicit cosmological/structure leverage; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics.... The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_1253_leptophilic_nonthermal_wimp_cosmic_string_v1", "paper_id": "0905_1253", "source_line": 1011, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 302, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 32 (tier3) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from observational leverage, multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness, registry diversity value, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family nonthermal_leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and nonthermal phase-space history, suppression small-scale-power behavior, probe handles: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, galaxy satellites.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_00909_mev_singlet_scalar_simp_leptogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1908_00909", "source_line": 3978, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 303, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for MeV singlet-scalar SIMP dark matter with low-scale leptogenesis: strong model-card science motivation, moderate observational leverage; inferred probe classes are CMB, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score 32 (tier3) uses production=thermal SIMP freeze-out through 3-to-2 annihilation; coupled Boltzmann evolution including an additional 2-to-2 process with the assisting scalar; phase=thermal; CMB=medium, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dissipative_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_04575_dissipative_dark_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "2405_04575", "source_line": 6054, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 304, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as tier3 with raw score 32.0: speculative simplified model model in dissipative_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, laboratory precision, small-scale structure; phase space is nonthermal; small-scale power effect is enhancement.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_01011_sterile_neutrino_singlet_scalar_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1502_01011", "source_line": 2438, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 305, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is nonthermal; structure fields include suppression power with a smooth_cutoff transfer-function entry.", "It reaches tier3 because cosmological/structure information and computational representation partly offset the missing explicit observables and routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_higgsino_lsp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_0285_nonthermal_higgsino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1203_0285", "source_line": 1497, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 306, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 95.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card describes speculative nonthermal_higgsino_lsp_dark_matter, uv complete theory framing, low CMB and critical BBN relevance, suppression small-scale effect with smooth cutoff transfer behavior, decay produced phase-space history, with production via thermal gravitino production during reheating.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wino_lsp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_0285_nonthermal_wino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1203_0285", "source_line": 1496, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 307, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card describes speculative nonthermal_wino_lsp_dark_matter, uv complete theory framing, low CMB and critical BBN relevance, suppression small-scale effect with smooth cutoff transfer behavior, decay produced phase-space history, with production via thermal gravitino production during reheating.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2109_08701_broad_mass_pbh_lambda_universe_v1", "paper_id": "2109_08701", "source_line": 317, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 308, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is high, BBN relevance is medium, small-scale power effect is enhancement, transfer function shape is enhanced_small_scale_power.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, CMB, compact-object dynamics, small-scale structure; associated_code=partial; warnings=high:astrophysics_dependent.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/10/10/1/9/6/12."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_03681_neutrinophilic_vector_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_03681", "source_line": 4226, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 309, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include neutrino-sector connection, structure or tension connection; nonthermal phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_1035_su2x_hidden_vector_monopole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_1035", "source_line": 1950, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 310, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 32.0 because the model card is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; low BBN and high CMB relevance; nonlinear halo-structure relevance; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches CMB, collider, direct detection, halo dynamics.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_10283_kinetic_misalignment_majoron_v1", "paper_id": "2404_10283", "source_line": 6038, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 311, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because kinetic-misalignment majoron dark matter links coherent field production, leptogenesis, and neutrino/vector portals, though the extraction lacks explicit constraints and code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "long_lived_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_05056_pseudo_sakharon_v1", "paper_id": "1805_05056", "source_line": 3512, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 312, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a UV-complete model card; it touches CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_02958_decaying_gravitino_rhn_sneutrino_v1", "paper_id": "2104_02958", "source_line": 4635, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 313, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative decaying gravitino dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; explicit cosmological/structure leverage; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics.... The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "heavy_quark_gluon_philic_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_11857_real_vector_heavy_quark_gluon_philic_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2110_11857", "source_line": 4941, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 314, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Heavy-quark and gluon-philic real vector dark matter EFT is benchmark with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, feasibility, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 2-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_05096_phase_transition_hot_heavy_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_05096", "source_line": 5200, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 315, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: rare non-cold phase-transition-produced heavy scalar has nonthermal phase space, smooth-cutoff suppression, CMB relevance, and phase-transition complementarity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_01770_vector_portal_scalar_light_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_01770", "source_line": 2891, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 316, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 16}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; medium CMB relevance; 3 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by penalties from sparse observables, constraints, and routing; associated code is marked yes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_10743_inflationary_light_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2004_10743", "source_line": 4223, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 317, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include early-universe production connection, structure or tension connection; field_like phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_17037_cannibal_codecaying_forbidden_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_17037", "source_line": 5667, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 318, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 14, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Self-interacting forbidden vector dark matter with a cannibally co-decaying phase (forbidden_hidden_sector_dark_matter) has higgs portal coverage, high diversity value in the population context, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 32.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_16884_nmssm_95gev_higgs_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_16884", "source_line": 6023, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 319, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because the NMSSM 95 GeV Higgs plus neutralino scenario has benchmark points, tool support, and collider/direct-detection relevance, but it belongs to a common family and lacks encoded constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_02403_hypercharge_electroweak_alp_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_02403", "source_line": 6095, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 320, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as tier3 with raw score 32.0: speculative effective field theory model in axion_portal_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection; phase space is mixed cold warm.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is yes and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_0789_post_inflationary_axion_topological_defects_v1", "paper_id": "1412_0789", "source_line": 2343, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 32, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 321, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 18}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 with score 32 because the assigned model card uv complete axion_like_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; uses field like phase-space information; touches CMB, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 32, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_05633_velocity_dependent_sidm_millicharged_thermal_v1", "paper_id": "1910_05633", "source_line": 4028, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 322, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.7, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative simplified_model; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_04071_mirror_star_mirror_baryon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1909_04071", "source_line": 4039, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 323, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_00459_mssm_ew_axion_gravitino_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1910_00459", "source_line": 4009, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 324, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_09909_winding_string_freeze_in_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1912_09909", "source_line": 4074, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 325, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pbh_evaporation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_12282_fopt_pbh_evaporation_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_12282", "source_line": 5980, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 326, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from pbh_evaporation_dark_matter: FOPT-generated ultra-light PBH evaporation scalar dark matter has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value, high diversity value through Hawking evaporation of ultra-light PBHs formed by false-vacuum/Fermi-ball collapse in a first-order phase transition; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, compact_objects, gravitational_waves.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_03488_selective_p_wave_sommerfeld_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_03488", "source_line": 4085, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 327, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 9, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative self_interacting_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, galaxy dynamics.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_04930_2hdm_singlet_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1804_04930", "source_line": 3468, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 328, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for 2HDM portal singlet-doublet dark matter: the supplied card gives a uv complete singlet doublet dark matter model with singlet doublet dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_07008_hidden_u1_radiative_seesaw_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_07008", "source_line": 5532, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 329, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_08821_hidden_sector_b_minus_l_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1912_08821", "source_line": 4088, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 330, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 8, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_11230_z3_singlet_type_ii_seesaw_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_11230", "source_line": 5506, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 331, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, multiple plausible probe classes, and some code, benchmark, or analytic support.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_0250_multi_throat_kk_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1211_0250", "source_line": 1692, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 332, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization entry; production is summarized as population during stringy inflation/preheating/reheating; reheating-through-tunneling from an initial hidden throat, with mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 31.2 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=medium and CMB=medium; structure fields indicate mixed_cold_warm transfer behavior with mixed small-scale power; card-implied probe classes include BBN, CMB, indirect detection, small-scale structure; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "conformal_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_10160_conformal_freeze_in_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1910_10160", "source_line": 4022, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 333, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.8, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as emerging effective_field_theory; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_05790_oscillon_alp_fuzzy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_05790", "source_line": 4922, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 334, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Oscillon-forming axion-like fuzzy dark matter is speculative with phenomenological_parameterization theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by mixed_cold_warm phase-space information, suppression structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: observational leverage, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_07108_kev_sterile_neutrino_double_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_07108", "source_line": 3797, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 335, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score 31 because the card identifies production via freeze-in from in-equilibrium singlet scalar decay, subdominant active-sterile mixing production, decay_produced phase-space treatment, suppression small-scale-power behavior, smooth_cutoff transfer-function shape, probe classes: CMB, small-scale structure; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_05785_preinflationary_qcd_axion_minicluster_v1", "paper_id": "2111_05785", "source_line": 4903, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 336, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Pre-inflationary QCD axion minicluster scenario is speculative with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by field_like phase-space information, enhancement structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: observational leverage, probe complementarity, provenance, diversity.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_09658_two_cosine_emergent_dark_energy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_09658", "source_line": 3384, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 337, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 16.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory support and field like phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Structure-formation field records suppression small-scale-power behavior.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_10263_light_rh_neutrino_lepto_axiogenesis_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2402_10263", "source_line": 5971, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 338, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from axion_like_dark_matter: Light-right-handed-neutrino lepto-axiogenesis axion dark matter (freeze-in) has strong observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through kinetic misalignment production of axion dark matter, B-L/baryon asymmetry generation in the freeze-in regime; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, direct_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_0067_u1_late_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1012_0067", "source_line": 1219, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 339, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from a speculative simplified_model card in family decaying_dark_matter with production via nonthermal production required; possible out-of-equilibrium production through weak bath mixing.", "Observational leverage is driven by suppression of small-scale power; nonthermal phase space; probe classes: BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics, galaxy satellites.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_02692_reheating_produced_numsm_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_02692", "source_line": 3079, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 340, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance medium, CMB relevance medium, non-CDM structure marker suppression/unknown, distinct phase space decay_produced; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_13137_qcd_axion_bubble_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2006_13137", "source_line": 4282, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 341, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via vacuum realignment of the homogeneous QCD axion; collapse of rare dense axion bubbles into PBHs, field_like phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified; a high-severity model-card warning was retained as a penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_07359_inflaton_coupled_spectator_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_07359", "source_line": 5578, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 342, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because nonthermal spectator production has CMB and small-scale-suppression leverage plus rare-family diversity, despite empty observable, constraint, route, and code fields.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_01520_led_delayed_evaporating_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_01520", "source_line": 5685, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 343, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 14, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because LED delayed evaporating black-hole dark matter production (primordial_black_holes) has non-CDM structure-formation behavior, decay produced phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, gravitational portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 31.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_01520_led_instantly_evaporating_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_01520", "source_line": 5684, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 344, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 14, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because LED instantly evaporating black-hole dark matter production (primordial_black_holes) has non-CDM structure-formation behavior, decay produced phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, gravitational portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 31.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_12730_kinetically_misaligned_audible_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_12730", "source_line": 4920, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 345, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Kinetically misaligned audible axion dark matter is speculative with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by field_like phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: observational leverage, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_11888_no_scale_su5_gravitino_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2208_11888", "source_line": 5285, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 346, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied fields for No-scale SU(5) gravitino LSP dark matter with shifted hybrid inflation: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via thermal gravitino production during reheating, nonthermal phase space, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection, weak lensing / large-scale structure), family/diversity context for supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_2496_saxion_decay_axino_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1208_2496", "source_line": 1617, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 347, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Saxion-decay axino warm dark matter with axion dark radiation; it offers suppression in small-scale power; decay produced phase-space behavior; CMB/BBN relevance with BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, and 1 more probe hooks.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_00010_vector_portal_hidden_sector_emde_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_00010", "source_line": 3867, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 348, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 14.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A stable Dirac fermion X freezes out through hidden-sector annihilation to long-lived Z prime bosons whose late decay can create an early matter-dominated era and very dense small microhalos.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: mixed relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN critical; CMB unknown; phase-space thermal; transfer function enhanced_small_scale_power; small-scale power enhancement.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: do_not_assume_standard_wimp_history."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_14542_331r_kev_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "2104_14542", "source_line": 4684, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 349, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level uv_complete, and relic production parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; mixed_cold_warm phase space.", "Higher than most sparse cards in this batch because explicit cosmological or structure-formation fields raise observational leverage despite empty observable and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_11243_kev_hidden_photon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2006_11243", "source_line": 4281, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 350, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative hidden_photon_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via nonthermal misalignment with curvature coupling; inflationary fluctuations, field_like phase-space treatment, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_09458_two_component_scalar_fimp_charged_fermion_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1912_09458", "source_line": 4122, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 351, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score 31: speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale power, nonthermal phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_01124_neutron_dark_decay_dirac_fermion_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_01124", "source_line": 3394, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 352, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 13.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and nonthermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_01866_spin_2_portal_fermion_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1803_01866", "source_line": 3472, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 353, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Spin-2 portal fermion freeze-in dark matter: the supplied card gives a simplified model freeze in dark matter model with nonthermal phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites / halo structure; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_01866_spin_2_portal_scalar_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1803_01866", "source_line": 3471, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 354, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Spin-2 portal scalar freeze-in dark matter: the supplied card gives a simplified model freeze in dark matter model with nonthermal phase space and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites / halo structure; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_14662_scotogenic_singlet_fermion_two_step_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2207_14662", "source_line": 5300, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 355, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied fields for Scotogenic singlet fermion dark matter with two-step freeze-in phase transition: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via freeze-in from decays or scatterings of thermal bath particles modified by two-step phase transition, nonthermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, gravitational waves), family/diversity context for freeze_in_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decay_produced_neutrino_hot_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9804053_decay_produced_neutrino_chdm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9804053", "source_line": 6122, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 356, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 31 (tier3) from supplied card content: decay_produced_neutrino_hot_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and no all-DM production; decay_produced phase-space behavior; non-CDM linear structure information (suppression, smooth_cutoff); cosmological relevance: CMB high, BBN high.", "Penalties (14) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0012317_low_reheat_standard_model_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0012317", "source_line": 399, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 357, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via incomplete production during low-temperature reheating; electron-positron annihilation to neutrino pairs; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance high; linear structure effect suppression with transfer shape smooth_cutoff; nonthermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_dark_radiation", "model_id": "1304_5243_nonthermal_spin1_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_5243", "source_line": 1760, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 358, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored tier3 with raw score 31: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family nonthermal_wimp_dark_radiation, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance high; BBN relevance high; small-scale-power effect suppression; transfer function smooth_cutoff; phase-space type mixed_cold_warm; complementarity probes counted as BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 3; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_00984_inflaxion_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1907_00984", "source_line": 3979, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 359, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Inflaxion axion dark matter: moderate observational leverage; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 31 (tier3) uses production=inflationary displacement from axion-inflaton kinetic mixing; post-inflation coherent oscillations of phi_DM; phase=field_like; CMB=medium, BBN=medium; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_nonstandard_cosmology", "model_id": "2303_05813_wimp_freezeout_degb_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "2303_05813", "source_line": 5568, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 360, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because modified pre-BBN expansion gives strong cosmological leverage and rare-family diversity, though no explicit observational routes, constraints, benchmarks, or code are populated.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_0265_mlrsm_kev_rh_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_0265", "source_line": 1901, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 361, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 31.0 because the model card is a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; medium BBN and unknown CMB relevance; suppression small-scale-power behavior with smooth_cutoff transfer-function information; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches BBN, collider, neutrino, small-scale structure.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; high-severity card warnings limit robustness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_14662_scotogenic_singlet_fermion_one_step_pt_v1", "paper_id": "2207_14662", "source_line": 5299, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 362, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied fields for Scotogenic singlet fermion dark matter with one-step first-order phase transition: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via modified thermal freeze-out/freeze-in around one-step first-order phase transition, thermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, gravitational waves), family/diversity context for scotogenic_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_01336_t_channel_superwimp_bound_state_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_01336", "source_line": 5781, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 363, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because Excited-bound-state t-channel superWIMP dark matter has nontrivial cosmological or phase-space leverage, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class, partial associated-code or tool support; card-internal probe cues include axion/laboratory searches, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_03559_freeze_twin_electron_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_03559", "source_line": 3969, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 364, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Freeze-twin electron and positron dark matter: moderate observational leverage, some associated-code support; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score 31 (tier3) uses production=freeze-in through kinetic mixing after asymmetric reheating; resonant production of an on-shell twin photon followed by decay to twin electron pairs; phase=nonthermal; CMB=medium, BBN=medium; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_12199_ckm_heavy_quark_freeze_in_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_12199", "source_line": 6094, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 365, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as tier3 with raw score 31.0: speculative effective field theory model in axion_like_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as yes.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: CMB, Lyman-alpha, indirect detection, small-scale structure; phase space is nonthermal; small-scale power effect is suppression.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_12199_single_flavor_heavy_quark_freeze_in_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_12199", "source_line": 6093, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 366, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as tier3 with raw score 31.0: speculative effective field theory model in axion_like_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as yes.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: CMB, Lyman-alpha, indirect detection, small-scale structure; phase space is nonthermal; small-scale power effect is suppression.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_dirac_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_12673_pseudo_dirac_higgs_portal_excited_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_12673", "source_line": 5065, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 367, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 94.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 31 (tier3) as a speculative simplified_model member of pseudo_dirac_higgs_portal_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; clear cosmological or phase-space leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out with co-annihilation; late excited-state decay feeding stable chi_2."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_12342_dark_neutron_asymmetric_mattergenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1911_12342", "source_line": 4104, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 368, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score 31: speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior, phase-transition/GW-motivated phenomenology; inferred probe classes: BBN, direct detection, gravitational waves, neutrino.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_axion_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_0692_subdominant_axino_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_0692", "source_line": 1395, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 369, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as supersymmetric_axion_gravitino_dark_matter: production is represented by gravitino thermal production; phase-space is mixed_cold_warm; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by effective_field_theory structure and the supplied production history; cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation fields provide observational leverage; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_04773_co_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1711_04773", "source_line": 3323, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 370, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a emerging phenomenological parameterization model with parameter dependent relic-density support, high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior, enhancement in small-scale power.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_11820_broken_u1_asymmetric_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_11820", "source_line": 5565, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 371, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because asymmetric self-interacting dark matter has CMB/BBN and small-scale-halo relevance plus partial code support, although the card still lacks populated observables, constraints, and routes.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_0569_composite_sterile_dirac_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1205_0569", "source_line": 1566, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 372, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier-3 priority because the card has nonstandard sterile-neutrino production, approximate phase-space information, smooth-cutoff suppression, and CMB/BBN relevance, despite missing explicit routes and code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_07863_phi16_dark_thermal_bath_deg_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_07863", "source_line": 4243, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 373, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, early-universe production connection, larger-framework connection; decay_produced phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2403_13581_nonabelian_axion_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_13581", "source_line": 6022, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 374, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because non-Abelian axion-inflation PBH production is distinctive and complementary across CMB and induced gravitational waves, but PBH abundance is threshold-sensitive and routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_06276_dark_brane_dirac_radion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_06276", "source_line": 6027, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 375, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because radion-mediated dark-brane dark matter has BBN, CMB, PTA, and hidden-sector complementarity, while implementation and route fields are missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_03309_bl_sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_03309", "source_line": 3520, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 376, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a simplified-model implementation; it has decay_produced phase-space production; it touches BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection and other probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_07342_eev_gravitino_rpv_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1805_07342", "source_line": 3508, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 377, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a UV-complete model card; it has nonthermal phase-space production; it touches BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_00309_fermionic_scalar_portal_absorption_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_00309", "source_line": 5768, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 378, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because Fermionic scalar-portal absorption dark matter has strong theory or relic-density motivation, nontrivial cosmological or phase-space leverage, some diversity value relative to the population, partial associated-code or tool support; card-internal probe cues include BBN, CMB/cosmic-dawn, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, and additional probe classes.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1907_05608_evaporating_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1907_05608", "source_line": 3960, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 379, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Evaporating primordial black-hole dark matter as varying dark energy: moderate observational leverage, high diversity value, some associated-code support; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 31 (tier3) uses production=primordial gravitational collapse after horizon re-entry; enhanced primordial curvature fluctuations; phase=not_applicable; CMB=medium, BBN=medium; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_13445_mixed_cdm_ula_halo_model_v1", "paper_id": "2209_13445", "source_line": 5340, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 380, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as tier3 with raw score 31.0: multi_component_dark_matter with misalignment mechanism for relic ultralight axions; science=12.0, observational leverage=10.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection) and diversity=5.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_5870_kev_sterile_neutrino_warm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1009_5870", "source_line": 1193, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 381, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 31 because the supplied card has strong card-level cosmology or structure-formation leverage, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_03681_b_minus_l_vector_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_03681", "source_line": 4228, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 382, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection, structure or tension connection; nonthermal phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_08278_susy_nelson_barr_gravitino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_08278", "source_line": 5077, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 383, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 31 (tier3) as a speculative uv_complete member of gravitino_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: strong science/relic-density basis; clear cosmological or phase-space leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB, structure/dynamics, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: inflation/reheating, axion/strong-cp, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in, baryogenesis/leptogenesis.", "Production summary used: thermal gravitino production followed by dilution during reheating; production from decay and inverse decay of MSSM superparticles."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_04860_asymmetric_singlet_scalar_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_04860", "source_line": 3514, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 384, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has nonthermal phase-space production; it touches CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_06661_hidden_u1_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_06661", "source_line": 4125, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 385, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score 31.0: speculative hidden_sector_wimp_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider, direct detection, neutrino.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_history_higgsino_wimp", "model_id": "1907_09235_nonstandard_higgsino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1907_09235", "source_line": 3961, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 386, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Light higgsino dark matter in a non-standard thermal history: moderate observational leverage, high diversity value, some associated-code support; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 31 (tier3) uses production=thermal freeze-out during early matter domination; nonthermal higgsino production from scalar decay; phase=thermal; CMB=medium, BBN=critical; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_03309_invisible_qcd_axion_ars_leptogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1807_03309", "source_line": 3521, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 387, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a UV-complete model card; it has field_like phase-space production; it touches CMB, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_12485_scalar_singlet_vectorlike_quark_uv_completion_v1", "paper_id": "2403_12485", "source_line": 6026, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 388, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because the vector-like-quark UV completion links relic density to flavor-motivated invisible B decays and direct probes, but explicit observational constraints are not encoded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_00654_feeble_b_l_freeze_in_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_00654", "source_line": 6030, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 389, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because feebly gauged B-L freeze-in sterile neutrino dark matter is UV-complete and nonthermal with multiple portals, but its observational extension is limited by missing routing and code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_06642_fermionic_clockwork_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1807_06642", "source_line": 3539, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 390, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has decay_produced phase-space production; it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_pion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_03963_qcd_like_dark_pion_forbidden_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_03963", "source_line": 6018, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 391, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because the QCD-like dark-pion forbidden model is a rare composite, multicomponent, thermal construction with electroweak probes and partial computational mentions, but no explicit constraints or routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_02851_extended_double_seesaw_wimp_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2305_02851", "source_line": 5590, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 392, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because the extended double-seesaw WIMP-FIMP model has strong neutrino-sector motivation, mixed cold-warm diversity, and partial code support, but no concrete routes or constraints are populated.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_19338_nmssm_singlino_higgsino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2404_19338", "source_line": 6047, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 393, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because compressed NMSSM singlino-higgsino coannihilation has concrete thermal relic logic and scan-tool support, but it is a common neutralino family with no encoded constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_08204_scotogenic_scalar_dm_gut_baryogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1806_08204", "source_line": 3536, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 394, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a UV-complete model card; it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves / defects, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_baryon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_17488_confining_dark_baryon_inverse_seesaw_v1", "paper_id": "2403_17488", "source_line": 6017, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 395, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 9, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because the inverse-seesaw confining dark-baryon model is UV-complete, neutrino-connected, and composite, but observational leverage is limited in the supplied fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_simp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_02207_vector_simp_sux2_u1_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_02207", "source_line": 5690, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 396, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Vector SIMP dark matter in SU_X(2) x U(1)_Z' gauge model (vector_simp_dark_matter) has vector portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 31.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_08380_cp_symmetric_complex_singlet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2205_08380", "source_line": 5160, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 31, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 397, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: full thermal Higgs-portal relic tied to a strong first-order electroweak phase transition and gravitational-wave motivation, with useful benchmark/scan structure despite missing formal routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 31, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_14586_bl_pq_inflection_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1910_14586", "source_line": 4035, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 398, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, field_like phase-space information, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_2162_bino_wino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1311_2162", "source_line": 1990, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 399, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, small-scale structure; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_relic_cosimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_00008_nucleophilic_scalar_cosimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_00008", "source_line": 5509, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 400, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, some cross-probe reach, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electromagnetic_multipole_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_13643_multipole_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2303_13643", "source_line": 5533, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 401, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides CMB/BBN relevance, multiple plausible probe classes, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_5752_atomic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1209_5752", "source_line": 1628, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 402, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Atomic dark matter model; it offers suppression in small-scale power; CMB/BBN relevance with BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics, and 3 more probe hooks.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_5826_mgmsb_gravitino_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "1205_5826", "source_line": 1602, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 403, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Minimal GMSB gravitino superWIMP dark matter; it offers suppression in small-scale power; decay produced phase-space behavior; BBN relevance with BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, galaxy satellites, and 1 more probe hooks.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_1164_compressed_stau_no_scale_fsu5_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_1164", "source_line": 1951, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 404, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, indirect detection, laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_06179_light_fermionic_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1805_06179", "source_line": 3497, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 405, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Light fermionic dark sector with dark photon and dark Higgs: the supplied card gives a simplified model hidden sector dark matter model with high BBN relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_17730_axion_cogenesis_kinetic_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "2312_17730", "source_line": 5899, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 406, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because axion cogenesis via kinetic misalignment connects full dark matter production to baryogenesis and high CMB relevance, but predictions depend on inflationary/PQ assumptions and lack explicit observational routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_08821_hidden_sector_baryon_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1912_08821", "source_line": 4089, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 407, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 8, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_08821_hidden_sector_hypercharge_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1912_08821", "source_line": 4087, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 408, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 8, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_04613_t1_2a_scotogenic_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2107_04613", "source_line": 4768, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 409, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative scotogenic_wimp_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out; coannihilation among nearly degenerate Z2-odd states.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_4458_hidden_sector_thermal_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1012_4458", "source_line": 1214, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 410, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card in family hidden_sector_dark_matter with production via hidden-sector thermal freeze-out; relativistic freeze-out.", "Observational leverage is driven by suppression of small-scale power; medium CMB and high BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_06580_5d_u1_repulsive_axion_ultralight_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_06580", "source_line": 2793, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 411, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 from the supplied card: speculative effective_field_theory in axion_like_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: coherent field oscillations; possible nonstandard contributions from cosmic strings or other nonthermal cosmologies; portals: gravitational; CMB relevance is medium; small-scale power effect is suppression.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_14300_sterile_neutrino_self_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "2207_14300", "source_line": 5287, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 412, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied fields for Sterile neutrino dark matter via scalar-mediated neutrino self-interactions: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via active-sterile neutrino oscillation assisted by scalar-mediated neutrino self-interactions, nonthermal phase space, suppression of small-scale power, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, galaxy satellites), family/diversity context for sterile_neutrino_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_10263_light_rh_neutrino_lepto_axiogenesis_freeze_out_v1", "paper_id": "2402_10263", "source_line": 5970, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 413, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from axion_like_dark_matter: Light-right-handed-neutrino lepto-axiogenesis axion dark matter (freeze-out) has strong observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through kinetic misalignment production of axion dark matter, B-L/baryon asymmetry generation in the freeze-out regime; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, direct_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5456_leptophilic_sommerfeld_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5456", "source_line": 1543, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 414, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_05740_decay_induced_freeze_in_baryogenesis_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_05740", "source_line": 4936, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 415, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Decay-induced freeze-in baryogenesis scalar dark matter is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by nonthermal phase-space information, suppression structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: observational leverage, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1908_03942_curvaton_ssr_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_03942", "source_line": 3934, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 416, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB, compact-object/dynamics, small-scale structure.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mass_varying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_17947_mass_varying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2303_17947", "source_line": 5583, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 417, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because the rare mass-varying setup has smooth-cutoff small-scale structure and partial code support, but high-severity caveats and missing route/constraint fields keep it from a higher tier.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_02993_anthropic_fuzzy_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_02993", "source_line": 6011, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 418, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because fuzzy axion Brownian misalignment has strong CMB and small-scale-power leverage, but it is anthropic-assumption sensitive and lacks encoded constraints or routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_15718_ultralight_scalar_refractive_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_15718", "source_line": 5673, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 419, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because Ultralight scalar dark matter with refractive neutrino masses (fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter) has field like phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, neutrino portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support, low robustness. Raw score 30.0, tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2310_14606_inflaton_curvaton_ssr_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2310_14606", "source_line": 5878, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 420, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because sound-speed-resonance PBH production has CMB, BBN, compact-object, and gravitational-wave leverage, but abundance estimates are model-dependent and not supported by an implementation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0101524_nonresonant_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0101524", "source_line": 385, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 421, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via non-resonant scattering-induced active-to-sterile conversion; CMB relevance high and BBN relevance high; linear structure effect suppression with transfer shape smooth_cutoff; nonthermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0101524_resonant_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0101524", "source_line": 386, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 422, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via MSW-enhanced resonant active-to-sterile conversion; incoherent scattering production through active neutrinos; CMB relevance high and BBN relevance high; linear structure effect suppression with transfer shape smooth_cutoff; resonant phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1603_00464_ligo_mass_primordial_black_hole_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1603_00464", "source_line": 2765, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 423, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 from the supplied card: speculative phenomenological_parameterization in primordial_black_holes.", "Leverage comes from production: primordial black-hole formation in the early universe; abundance treated phenomenologically in this paper; portals: gravitational; CMB relevance is medium; small-scale power effect is enhancement.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_10385_stable_vector_mediator_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_10385", "source_line": 3448, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 424, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance high/high; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs, vector.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: warning_multicomponent_fraction, warning_kinetic_mixing_assumption."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_07882_super_resonant_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2208_07882", "source_line": 5296, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 425, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score from supplied fields for Super-Resonant Dark Matter: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via freeze-in through dark photon kinetic mixing, nonthermal phase space, phase-transition history, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection), family/diversity context for self_interacting_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_08305_inflaton_produced_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_08305", "source_line": 5786, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 426, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because Inflaton-produced scalar dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, nontrivial cosmological or phase-space leverage, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include CMB/cosmic-dawn, axion/laboratory searches, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_6838_u1prime_amsb_wino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1203_6838", "source_line": 1511, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 427, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and decay produced phase-space treatment.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_09458_two_component_scalar_fimp_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1912_09458", "source_line": 4121, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 428, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 93.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score 30: speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale power, nonthermal phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_sector_bound_state_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_07723_su3d_triple_higgs_bound_state_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_07723", "source_line": 3399, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 429, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 13.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative dark_sector_bound_state_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2405_15858_memory_burdened_pbh_evaporation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_15858", "source_line": 6081, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 430, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as tier3 with raw score 30.0: speculative phenomenological parameterization model in primordial_black_holes, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha, gravitational waves, small-scale structure; phase space is decay produced; small-scale power effect is suppression.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decay_produced_hot_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_6736_decay_product_hot_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1405_6736", "source_line": 2217, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 431, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative decay_produced_hot_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "Cosmology, phase-space, or small-scale-structure fields provide above-average observational leverage within this batch.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, small-scale structure.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family, uncommon production history, or distinctive phase-space category in the provided population context.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_00004_nonthermal_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_00004", "source_line": 2862, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 432, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space population.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; associated code is marked partial; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "puffy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_12668_cosmic_ray_boosted_puffy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_12668", "source_line": 5584, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 433, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because cosmic-ray-boosted puffy dark matter is rare and experimentally distinctive, but the card does not specify relic abundance and lacks explicit routes, constraints, or code.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_07048_milliev_scalar_dm_dark_photon_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1803_07048", "source_line": 3488, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 434, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 ranking for Milli-eV scalar dark matter decaying to dark photons: the supplied card gives a effective field theory axion like dark matter model with decay produced phase space, medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_09615_two_body_decaying_cdm_to_wdm_dr_v1", "paper_id": "2008_09615", "source_line": 4365, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 435, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Two-body decaying cold dark matter to warm dark matter and dark radiation: late two-body decay of cold dark matter; strong cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage, good diversity value within the population context, partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, indirect/transient, laboratory/direct and related probes.", "Tier3 because the card has unusually direct observational leverage for this shard, although explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation are still missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_2690_sterile_neutrino_pion_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_2690", "source_line": 2377, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 436, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory and freeze-in from charged pion decays after the QCD phase transition production.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance; nonthermal phase space; suppression small-scale power.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for rare production mechanism: freeze-in from charged pion decays after the QCD phase transition."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_dark_radiation", "model_id": "1304_5243_nonthermal_spin0_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_5243", "source_line": 1759, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 437, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored tier3 with raw score 30: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, family nonthermal_wimp_dark_radiation, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance high; BBN relevance high; small-scale-power effect suppression; transfer function smooth_cutoff; phase-space type mixed_cold_warm; complementarity probes counted as BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 3; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_dark_radiation", "model_id": "1304_5243_nonthermal_spin12_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_5243", "source_line": 1761, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 438, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored tier3 with raw score 30: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, family nonthermal_wimp_dark_radiation, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance high; BBN relevance high; small-scale-power effect suppression; transfer function smooth_cutoff; phase-space type mixed_cold_warm; complementarity probes counted as BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 3; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_07739_supersymmetric_flaxion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1802_07739", "source_line": 3354, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 439, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 12.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and field like phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_0236_mdm_u1x_cdm_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1404_0236", "source_line": 2108, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 440, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: CMB relevance is high; BBN relevance is medium; small-scale-power effect is suppression; transfer-function shape is smooth_cutoff; halo-mass-function effect is supplied; subhalo-mass-function effect is supplied; phase-space type is mixed_cold_warm.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2403_01416_usr_kkl_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2403_01416", "source_line": 6020, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 441, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because the USR KKL PBH scenario has CMB and gravitational-wave leverage with specified validity conditions, but no public code or constraint map is supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_17636_quadratic_scalar_uldm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2404_17636", "source_line": 6041, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 442, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because quadratically coupled scalar ultralight dark matter has strong laboratory-precision leverage and field-like phase-space content, but relic-density and route details are sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_02057_multicomponent_nonthermal_flavon_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2211_02057", "source_line": 5436, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 443, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier 3 because the multicomponent flavon portal has high CMB/BBN relevance, decay-produced phase space, smooth-cutoff suppressed small-scale power, and diversity from multicomponent nonthermal production."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_minicluster_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0607341_axion_like_scalar_miniclusters_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0607341", "source_line": 607, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 444, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 because the model card has strong card-level observational leverage from cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation fields, high diversity value within the population-count context, some computational or code support recorded in the model card, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_07863_phi16_coherent_oscillation_deg_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_07863", "source_line": 4245, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 445, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, early-universe production connection, larger-framework connection; decay_produced phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_07863_phi16_free_decay_deg_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_07863", "source_line": 4244, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 446, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, early-universe production connection, larger-framework connection; decay_produced phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_13272_spin1_relativistic_decay_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2212_13272", "source_line": 5501, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 447, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space information, multiple plausible probe classes, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_08854_lmu_ltau_complex_scalar_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_08854", "source_line": 5078, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 448, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 30 (tier3) as a speculative simplified_model member of self_interacting_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; clear cosmological or phase-space leverage; multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, structure/dynamics, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, tension/anomaly, structure/self-interaction, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through DM DM -> Z prime Z prime; asymmetric dark matter with thermal symmetric component suppressed."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_08854_lmu_ltau_dirac_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_08854", "source_line": 5079, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 449, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 30 (tier3) as a speculative simplified_model member of self_interacting_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; clear cosmological or phase-space leverage; multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, structure/dynamics, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, tension/anomaly, structure/self-interaction, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through DM DM -> Z prime Z prime; asymmetric dark matter with thermal symmetric component suppressed."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decay_produced_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_6267_long_lived_majorana_decay_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_6267", "source_line": 1771, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 450, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored tier3 with raw score 30: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family decay_produced_warm_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance medium; BBN relevance medium; small-scale-power effect suppression; transfer function smooth_cutoff; phase-space type decay_produced; complementarity probes counted as BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 2; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_03878_extended_pbh_evaporation_gravitational_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_03878", "source_line": 5424, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 451, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier 3 because extended PBH evaporation has CMB/BBN relevance, decay-produced approximate phase space, smooth-cutoff suppressed transfer behavior, and compact/cosmological complementarity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_13628_decaying_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2205_13628", "source_line": 5190, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 452, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: very rare decaying-warm model has an explicit distribution, scale-dependent growth, and small-scale suppression, but inverse-decay caveats and missing routes keep it modest."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_16532_one_to_one_mixed_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_16532", "source_line": 5713, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 453, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 12.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as tier3 from supplied model-card fields: One-to-one resonantly produced mixed sterile-neutrino dark matter is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with yes relic-abundance support and suppression of small-scale power, mixed_cold_warm phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 9.0, observational 10.0, complementarity 8.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.0, penalties 12.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_16532_three_to_one_mixed_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_16532", "source_line": 5714, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 454, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 12.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as tier3 from supplied model-card fields: Three-to-one resonantly produced mixed sterile-neutrino dark matter is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with yes relic-abundance support and suppression of small-scale power, mixed_cold_warm phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 9.0, observational 10.0, complementarity 8.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.0, penalties 12.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_03681_lmu_ltau_vector_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_03681", "source_line": 4227, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 455, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include neutrino-sector connection, structure or tension connection; nonthermal phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_tensor_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_08091_ultralight_tensor_fierz_pauli_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_08091", "source_line": 5609, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 456, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because rare ultralight tensor dark matter with field-like phase space and small-scale suppression.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_19598_scalar_decoupled_light_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "2403_19598", "source_line": 6024, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 457, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because light higgsino LSP dark matter is experimentally testable through collider and direct-detection probes, but it is a common WIMP-like case with missing routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_13959_quartic_2hdsmash_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_13959", "source_line": 5896, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 458, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3 because quartic 2HDSMASH links axion dark matter to inflation, neutrino physics, and Higgs-sector probes in a UV-complete setup, although relic-density details and observational routes are sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_09855_cmssm_stop_coannihilation_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_09855", "source_line": 3385, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 459, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Benchmark supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, galaxy/halo structure.", "Associated-code field is yes, improving implementation feasibility."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter_effective_field_theory", "model_id": "2202_06968_two_dark_vector_dsmeft_dleft_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_06968", "source_line": 5076, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 460, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 30 (tier3) as a speculative effective_field_theory member of vector_dark_matter_effective_field_theory.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: inflation/reheating, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through dark-vector annihilation and coannihilation; freeze-in from Standard Model scattering and decays through dimension-six operators."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_02997_right_handed_neutrino_forbidden_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_02997", "source_line": 5534, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 461, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, thermal phase-space information, multiple plausible probe classes, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_10606_littlest_seesaw_right_handed_neutrino_portal_fimpzilla_v1", "paper_id": "1806_10606", "source_line": 3519, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 462, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked locally because it has a simplified-model implementation; it has nonthermal phase-space production; it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_08095_scalar_driven_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_08095", "source_line": 5611, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 463, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because UV-complete scalar-driven sterile-neutrino production with nonthermal phase space and warm-like suppression.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2405_10537_bl_double_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_10537", "source_line": 6097, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 464, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as tier3 with raw score 30.0: speculative uv complete model in primordial_black_holes, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: CMB, gravitational waves, small-scale structure; small-scale power effect is enhancement.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_3902_constrained_numsm_resonant_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1204_3902", "source_line": 1589, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 465, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier-3 priority because the card has UV sterile-neutrino motivation, resonant phase-space information, smooth-cutoff suppression, BBN relevance, and full-dark-matter production, despite tuning and absent routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_number_gauge_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_17144_majorana_lepton_number_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_17144", "source_line": 6012, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 466, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because gauged lepton-number Majorana dark matter connects anomaly cancellation, neutrino physics, BBN, and laboratory probes, but the extracted card omits direct constraint and observable details."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "discrete_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_10811_a4_discrete_dark_matter_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2301_10811", "source_line": 5502, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 467, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["tier3 score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_07786_u1_t3r_subgev_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_07786", "source_line": 5123, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 468, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a UV-complete sub-GeV U(1) vector/Higgs portal with CMB and BBN relevance; formatting and branch-mixing warnings plus missing observables constrain priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_10149_resonance_enhanced_light_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_10149", "source_line": 5181, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 469, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: resonant light scalar SIDM has CMB/BBN relevance, approximate velocity treatment, and nonlinear core/cusp phenomenology, but no structured constraints or routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_10904_sidm_dark_star_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2205_10904", "source_line": 5182, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 470, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: SIDM dark-star model has CMB/BBN relevance, nonlinear halo/core behavior, and compact-object complementarity, with penalties for simplified dark-star assumptions."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_08431_sterile_neutrino_portal_ultralight_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_08431", "source_line": 5161, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 471, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: ultralight scalar coupled through sterile neutrinos has high CMB/BBN relevance and field-like phenomenology, though cosmology-friendly assumptions and missing routes suppress the score."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_interacting_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0309652_light_collisional_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0309652", "source_line": 311, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 472, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is low, BBN relevance is medium, small-scale power effect is suppression, transfer function shape is oscillatory.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, direct/lab scattering, small-scale structure; associated_code=partial; warnings=medium:wdm_proxy.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/8/8/1/9/8/11."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_2595_msugra_mixed_axion_axino_v1", "paper_id": "0906_2595", "source_line": 965, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 473, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance; mixed small-scale power effect; mixed_cold_warm transfer-function behavior; mixed_cold_warm phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, indirect detection, large-scale structure.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_00612_u1_bl_inert_doublet_two_component_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1910_00612", "source_line": 4031, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 474, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Useful observational-extension candidate within this shard, with ranks intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_04834_scotogenic_fimp_n1_v1", "paper_id": "2204_04834", "source_line": 5126, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 475, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for scotogenic freeze-in with electroweak phase-transition context and strong provenance, but no explicit gravitational-wave or constraint routing is supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_13529_so10_mixed_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_13529", "source_line": 6010, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 476, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because the SO(10) mixed singlet-inert-doublet scalar can produce the full relic density and has partial computational support, but its observational extension fields are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_13613_aks_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_13613", "source_line": 6033, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 477, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Borderline tier3 because the AKS Higgs-resonance benchmark connects scalar dark matter to radiative neutrino masses and CP violation, but observational details are not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_4821_inert_doublet_u1_string_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_4821", "source_line": 2305, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 478, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as tier3 with score 30 because the assigned model card simplified model scalar_dark_matter card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; uses mixed cold warm phase-space information; touches BBN, CMB, direct detection, gravitational waves.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_13425_cp_in_the_dark_scalar_dm_sfoewpt_v1", "paper_id": "2204_13425", "source_line": 5168, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 479, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Tier3: scalar Higgs-portal dark matter is paired with SFOEWPT and gravitational-wave motivation, with MicrOMEGAs/BSMPT-style scan evidence but incomplete structured observables."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_axion_axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_2215_pqmssm_mixed_axion_axino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1005_2215", "source_line": 1159, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 480, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 2.5, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 30 because the supplied card has some cosmology, phase-space, or structure signal, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, distinctive or underrepresented model-space coverage."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_09719_composite_neutrino_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_09719", "source_line": 5620, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 481, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 10, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth/edge-case observational-extension candidate because composite neutrino-portal dark matter with UV-complete motivation, partial code support, and nonlinear self-interaction relevance.", "Score is still held down by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points despite limited code support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_00503_higgs_portal_dark_monopole_v1", "paper_id": "2005_00503", "source_line": 4218, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 30, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 482, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "tier3", "rank_percentile": 92.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked tier3 because theory links include early-universe production connection, larger-framework connection, phase-transition or confinement connection; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: BBN, CMB, compact objects.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 30, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1910_09853_coupled_phantom_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1910_09853", "source_line": 4004, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 483, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 92.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1910_09853_coupled_quintessence_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1910_09853", "source_line": 4003, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 484, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 92.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1910_09853_coupled_vacuum_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1910_09853", "source_line": 4002, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 485, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 92.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0604132_heavy_scalar_decay_gravitino_warm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0604132", "source_line": 580, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 486, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 92.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Heavy-scalar decay gravitino warm dark matter is a speculative simplified model card in family gravitino_warm_dark_matter with production described as nonthermal production from heavy scalar X decay.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; critical BBN relevance; decay produced phase space; suppression of small-scale power; smooth cutoff transfer behavior; probe classes: BBN, CMB, halo/subhalo structure, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_09846_neutrinophilic_singlet_ds_m1_v1", "paper_id": "1710_09846", "source_line": 3294, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 487, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 92.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self interacting dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale power with smooth cutoff transfer behavior.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 29.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_09846_neutrinophilic_singlet_ds_m2_v1", "paper_id": "1710_09846", "source_line": 3295, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 488, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 92.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self interacting dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale power with smooth cutoff transfer behavior.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 29.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_5865_hidden_fermion_assisted_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1009_5865", "source_line": 1191, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 489, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 92.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 29.5 because the supplied card has strong card-level cosmology or structure-formation leverage, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, distinctive or underrepresented model-space coverage, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_05633_flavor_dependent_u1_inert_scalar_s_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1803_05633", "source_line": 3487, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after missing observational-detail and routing penalties."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 490, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer ranking for Flavor-dependent gauged U(1) inert scalar S dark matter: the supplied card gives a uv complete hidden sector dark matter model with medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_wimp", "model_id": "1804_02357_singlet_quintuplet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1804_02357", "source_line": 3489, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after missing observational-detail and routing penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 491, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer ranking for Well-tempered singlet-quintuplet fermion WIMP: the supplied card gives a effective field theory coannihilating wimp model with medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_wimp", "model_id": "1804_02357_singlet_triplet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1804_02357", "source_line": 3490, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after missing observational-detail and routing penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 492, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer ranking for Well-tempered singlet-triplet fermion WIMP: the supplied card gives a effective field theory coannihilating wimp model with medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_08268_framed_standard_model_hidden_sector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_08268", "source_line": 3492, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.25, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after missing observational-detail and routing penalties."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 493, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5.25, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer ranking for Framed Standard Model hidden-sector dark matter candidates: the supplied card gives a uv complete hidden sector dark matter model with hidden sector dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; large penalties come from missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "excited_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_0864_down_scattering_excited_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1212_0864", "source_line": 1699, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 494, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as nonthermal production of chi from late X1 decay; thermal freeze-out of X1 followed by decay, with decay_produced phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 29.2 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=high and CMB=unknown; card-implied probe classes include BBN, collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_06194_post_inflationary_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_06194", "source_line": 3799, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 495, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 29 because the card identifies production via vacuum realignment after post-inflationary PQ breaking, field_like phase-space treatment, mixed small-scale-power behavior, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function shape, probe classes: CMB, small-scale structure; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_07126_alp_catastrogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_07126", "source_line": 5255, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 496, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for ALP catastrogenesis dark matter: speculative status, phenomenological-parameterization theory level, and production via misalignment or field dynamics after U(1) breaking; string-wall network annihilation producing non-relativistic ALPs, field-like phase space, suppression of small-scale power, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics), family/diversity context for axion_like_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_13218_millicharged_excited_sfdm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_13218", "source_line": 5102, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 497, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a distinctive fuzzy/SFDM halo variant with smooth-cutoff structure, lobed excited-state phenomenology, and approximate phase-space information; missing relic-production and constraints keep it below the stronger candidates."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_05601_750gev_complex_scalar_freezein_kev_v1", "paper_id": "1603_05601", "source_line": 2738, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 498, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power behavior.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: BBN, CMB, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_0067_z4_late_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1012_0067", "source_line": 1218, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 499, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative simplified_model card in family decaying_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out in a two-phase dark-sector process.", "Observational leverage is driven by suppression of small-scale power; probe classes: BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_02640_pseudo_goldstone_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1801_02640", "source_line": 3420, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 500, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level effective_field_theory; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance medium/high; structure entry suppression/unknown; phase-space type decay_produced; portals neutrino, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: pseudo_goldstone_not_majoron_warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_06243_hidden_vector_coherent_oscillation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_06243", "source_line": 3965, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 501, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Hidden vector coherent oscillation dark matter: moderate observational leverage, high diversity value; inferred probe classes are CMB, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 29 (defer) uses production=homogeneous vector condensate generated/sustained during inflation; coherent oscillation begins when H is about m; phase=field_like; CMB=high, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_sector_bound_state_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_07723_u1d_pseudo_dirac_bound_state_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_07723", "source_line": 3398, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 502, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 13.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative dark_sector_bound_state_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, astrophysical fields, collider/fixed-target.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_5502_qcd_axion_string_radiation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1012_5502", "source_line": 1247, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 503, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative simplified_model card in family axion_like_dark_matter with production via radiation from cosmological axionic strings; string-wall decay around the QCD transition.", "Observational leverage is driven by field_like phase space; high CMB and low BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_5300_goldstini_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1012_5300", "source_line": 1225, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 504, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family supersymmetric_decaying_dark_matter with production via thermal production of goldstinos; decays of observable-sector superpartners.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase space; medium CMB and unknown BBN relevance; probe classes: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_03295_leptonic_fermion_dm_dilepton_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1805_03295", "source_line": 3442, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 505, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance high/medium; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals neutrino, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: two_stabilization_options, symbol_loss."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_03295_leptonic_scalar_dm_dilepton_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1805_03295", "source_line": 3441, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 506, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance high/medium; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals neutrino, higgs, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: symbol_loss, dirac_neutrino_required."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_01017_kahler_moduli_nonthermal_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2208_01017", "source_line": 5278, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 507, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Kahler-moduli-inflation nonthermal neutralino dark matter: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via nonthermal production from modulus/inflaton decay; post-decay neutralino annihilation, nonthermal phase space, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, direct detection), family/diversity context for supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_05298_inverse_seesaw_sterile_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_05298", "source_line": 4723, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 508, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via freeze-in decays of thermalized heavy pseudo-Dirac neutrinos to sterile dark matter plus singlet scalar or Majoron states.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN, CMB, structure formation; the raw score is 29 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phase_transition_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_02230_fermion_mediated_bubble_expansion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_02230", "source_line": 5254, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 509, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Fermion-mediated dark matter from bubble expansion: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via L to N production at bubble wall; N decay to heavy dark sector, nonthermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves, indirect detection), family/diversity context for phase_transition_produced_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_18397_defect_free_dark_photon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2310_18397", "source_line": 5862, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 510, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but close to tier3 because the defect-free dark-photon mechanism has distinctive field-like production and cosmological constraints, but tachyonic-resonance and defect-threshold uncertainties plus absent routing hold it down."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2305_12325_nonminimal_curvaton_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2305_12325", "source_line": 5599, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 511, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-ranked because non-minimal-curvaton PBH formation can account for all dark matter and has CMB/GW/PBH complementarity, but explicit constraints and computational artifacts are absent.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_12498_two_body_decaying_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2102_12498", "source_line": 4586, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 512, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative decaying_dark_matter entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=high and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_14226_conformal_scotogenic_rhn_dm_fopt_v1", "paper_id": "2207_14226", "source_line": 5262, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 513, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Conformal scotogenic right-handed-neutrino dark matter from supercooled FOPT: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out after bubble crossing; possible FIMP production from singlet-scalar decay, thermal phase space, phase-transition history, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, gravitational waves), family/diversity context for sterile_neutrino_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_14226_hybrid_scotogenic_type_i_rhn_dm_fopt_v1", "paper_id": "2207_14226", "source_line": 5263, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 514, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Hybrid scotogenic/type-I right-handed-neutrino dark matter from relativistic bubble walls: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out after FOPT; possible freeze-in from singlet scalar decay, thermal phase space, phase-transition history, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, gravitational waves), family/diversity context for sterile_neutrino_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_11014_companion_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2110_11014", "source_line": 4917, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 515, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Companion-axion dark matter model is speculative with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by field_like phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_07943_mixed_axion_adm_higgs_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2308_07943", "source_line": 5723, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 516, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Mixed axion and asymmetric dark matter from Higgs dark matter decay is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, mixed of small-scale power, mixed_cold_warm phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider/fixed-target, direct detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 11.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 6.0, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_07639_gauged_global_qcd_axion_strings_v1", "paper_id": "2311_07639", "source_line": 5856, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 517, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but near the tier3 boundary because post-inflationary axion strings/domain walls give distinctive CMB, defect, and axion-search leverage, while abundance predictions depend on uncertain network simulations and the card lacks explicit routing and constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_4094_phenomenological_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1104_4094", "source_line": 1323, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 518, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance high, BBN relevance medium, small-scale power suppression, transfer function mixed_cold_warm, phase-space type decay_produced.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "black_hole_remnant_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_07372_hot_big_bang_planckeon_remnant_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_07372", "source_line": 5537, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 519, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, some cross-probe reach, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_11122_nonstandard_singlet_scalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_11122", "source_line": 3494, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after missing observational-detail and routing penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 520, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer ranking for Singlet scalar Higgs-portal dark matter with non-standard expansion: the supplied card gives a simplified model scalar singlet higgs portal dark matter model with high BBN relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; large penalties come from missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_06526_su5_pq_axion_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_06526", "source_line": 3356, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 521, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and field like phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_7373_moduli_produced_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_7373", "source_line": 2213, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 522, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "Cosmology, phase-space, or small-scale-structure fields provide above-average observational leverage within this batch.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching BBN, CMB, collider, direct detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family, uncommon production history, or distinctive phase-space category in the provided population context.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "long_lived_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_08087_long_lived_mediator_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_08087", "source_line": 3096, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 523, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative long_lived_mediator_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance high, CMB relevance high; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection, laboratory precision.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_04665_z4_dirac_neutrino_scalar_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_04665", "source_line": 3964, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 524, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Z4 Dirac-neutrino scalar self-interacting dark matter: strong model-card science motivation, moderate observational leverage; inferred probe classes are CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score 29 (defer) uses production=annihilation of eta_1 to light scalar mediator eta_2; self-interacting dark matter through eta_2 exchange; phase=thermal; CMB=medium, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_04830_higgs_portal_scalar_hybrid_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_04830", "source_line": 3530, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 525, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a simplified-model implementation; it touches CMB, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_00730_landau_ginzburg_self_interacting_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_00730", "source_line": 347, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 526, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, BBN relevance is medium, small-scale power effect is suppression, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:initial_abundance_assumed, medium:halo_core_not_simulated.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 10/10/8/0/9/6/14."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "co_decaying_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_02018_very_supersymmetric_codecaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_02018", "source_line": 3715, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 527, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Very supersymmetric co-decaying dark sector is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, nonthermal phase-space behavior, probe relevance for BBN, CMB, small-scale structure, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_13339_pseudo_dirac_transition_dipole_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_13339", "source_line": 5085, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 528, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 29 (defer) as a speculative effective_field_theory member of freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: inflation/reheating, tension/anomaly, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: UV freeze-in from charged Standard Model fermion annihilation; freeze-in from thermal plasmon decay."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0304260_mirror_matter_lss_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0304260", "source_line": 429, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 529, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides uv complete theory support, cosmology or structure-formation leverage, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive model class; probe signal: bbn, cmb, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_2282_dfsz_axino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1108_2282", "source_line": 1390, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 530, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as axino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal production through DFSZ Yukawa/Higgs interactions and electroweak anomaly interactions; phase-space is mixed_cold_warm; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation fields provide observational leverage; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_2282_ksvz_axino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1108_2282", "source_line": 1389, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 531, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as axino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal production from QCD scatterings and decays in the hot plasma; phase-space is mixed_cold_warm; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation fields provide observational leverage; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_01729_z3_inert_multiplet_semiannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2403_01729", "source_line": 6036, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 532, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the Z3 inert multiplet semiannihilation model is rare and testable, but the card says viability needs further indirect-detection analysis and supplies no routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_04030_vector_scotogenic_hnl_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_04030", "source_line": 6029, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 533, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because vector scotogenic HNL dark matter connects neutrino mass, electroweak mediators, and coannihilation, but phase-space and observational fields are mostly unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_10857_2hdsmash_dfsz_axion_majoron_v1", "paper_id": "2309_10857", "source_line": 5795, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 534, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because 2hdSMASH DFSZ axion-majoron dark matter has strong theory or relic-density motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population, partial associated-code or tool support; card-internal probe cues include CMB/cosmic-dawn, axion/laboratory searches, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, neutrino probes.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_07540_dark_monopole_fopt_v1", "paper_id": "2204_07540", "source_line": 5092, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 535, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 29 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of topological_defect_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, compact/microlensing/dynamics, gravitational waves/inflation.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: phase transition/gw, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: first-order dark-sector phase transition; bubble-collision production of topological monopoles."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_dark_radiation", "model_id": "1706_05605_hidden_charged_dm_chiral_dark_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1706_05605", "source_line": 3170, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 536, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 29.0: Hidden-charged dark matter with chiral dark radiation is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out after early thermalization with the Standard Model.", "Rank-relevant positives are medium BBN relevance, high CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, CMB, direct detection, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_06642_scalar_clockwork_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1807_06642", "source_line": 3538, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 537, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has decay_produced phase-space production; it touches direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "t_channel_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_09326_real_scalar_t_channel_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_09326", "source_line": 6042, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 538, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because real-scalar t-channel portal dark matter has direct-detection matching and partial tool support, but it is one member of a near-duplicate quartet with empty observables and routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "clumped_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_14981_dark_cluster_microhalo_clumps_v1", "paper_id": "2306_14981", "source_line": 5708, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 539, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Dark cluster microhalo clumps is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and enhancement of small-scale power.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects/dynamics, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 7.0, observational 7.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 10, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_13613_aks_heavy_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_13613", "source_line": 6034, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 540, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the heavy AKS scalar benchmark is scientifically motivated but near-duplicate within the AKS pair and lacks explicit observational routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_03693_cdf_iihdm_low_mass_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2204_03693", "source_line": 5129, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 541, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a UV-complete inert-doublet benchmark with partial relic-density calculation support and CDF-II context, tempered by conditional/variant warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_thermal_freeze_out_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_13112_superheavy_rhn_zombie_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2107_13112", "source_line": 4766, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 29, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 542, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative superheavy_thermal_freeze_out_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out of nu_R with lighter sterile-neutrino zombie co-annihilation; exponentially enhanced annihilation from lighter co-annihilator abundance.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 29, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_02614_quartic_scalar_soliton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1909_02614", "source_line": 4001, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 543, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.4, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative effective_field_theory; rank-relevant evidence includes non-CDM structure-formation behavior, field_like phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_03414_left_right_mirror_sterile_dirac_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1910_03414", "source_line": 4050, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 544, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_06560_blue_axion_dark_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2301_06560", "source_line": 5512, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 545, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides CMB/BBN relevance, structure-formation leverage, mixed_cold_warm phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0612182_numsm_dodelson_widrow_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0612182", "source_line": 703, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 546, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal phase-space history; smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale-power effect; probe coverage from portal/laboratory, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unparticle_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_5129_thermal_unparticle_unmatter_v1", "paper_id": "0710_5129", "source_line": 711, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 547, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative effective_field_theory model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; field_like phase-space history; BBN high and CMB high relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_10043_sterile_neutrino_portal_fimp_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2212_10043", "source_line": 5514, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 548, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_08526_recycled_ultraheavy_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2310_08526", "source_line": 5861, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 549, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but close to tier3 because recycled ultraheavy dark matter touches phase transitions, PBHs, Hawking recycling, and BBN, but it remains proof-of-concept with several model-dependent assumptions and no explicit observational pipeline."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_06788_two_component_adm_bound_state_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1911_06788", "source_line": 4060, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 28.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 550, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 91.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative asymmetric_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0805_2836_low_reheat_warm_gravitino_v1", "paper_id": "0805_2836", "source_line": 798, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 551, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 28.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance medium, small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type decay_produced; probe classes counted: ['CMB', 'halo/subhalo abundance', 'small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_14103_leptophilic_zprime_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_14103", "source_line": 5898, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 552, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the leptophilic Zprime Majorana model has collider and flavor/precision leverage with partial FeynRules/CalcHEP/micrOMEGAs support, but the UV completion is anomaly-agnostic and routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_05678_messenger_qed_like_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1806_05678", "source_line": 3500, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after missing observational-detail and routing penalties."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 553, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer ranking for QED-like dark sector with heavy scalar messengers: the supplied card gives a simplified model hidden sector dark matter model with hidden sector dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_05798_real_singlet_scalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_05798", "source_line": 3462, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after missing observational-detail and routing penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 554, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer ranking for Real singlet scalar Higgs-portal dark matter with strong electroweak phase transition: the supplied card gives a simplified model higgs portal scalar dark matter model with higgs portal scalar dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; penalties mainly reflect sparse observable, constraint, and routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_13145_kreuzer_skarke_axiverse_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_13145", "source_line": 5804, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 555, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a emerging effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is vacuum realignment condensate production.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, axion laboratory, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (mixed_cold_warm, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1909_04742_spinning_pbh_matter_domination_v1", "paper_id": "1909_04742", "source_line": 4040, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 556, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_01681_stiff_scalar_field_dm_ewbg_v1", "paper_id": "1601_01681", "source_line": 2731, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.2, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 557, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has a card-local full-dark-matter production route, high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power behavior, field_like phase-space history.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: BBN, small-scale structure.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_04848_starobinsky_scalar_preheating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_04848", "source_line": 5993, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 558, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from nonthermal_scalar_dark_matter: Starobinsky-inflaton scalar dark matter from dark-sector preheating has strong observational leverage, moderate model/theory value, high diversity value through nonperturbative resonant preheating from a coherently oscillating inflaton, backreaction and inflaton-condensate fragmentation, late redshifting of a frozen comoving DM number density; inferred probe classes are CMB, small_scale_structure.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_04558_benchmark_fimp_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1907_04558", "source_line": 3930, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 559, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 18, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to small-scale structure.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_1774_thermal_qcd_axion_domain_wall_hot_cold_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_1774", "source_line": 1979, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 560, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_03793_ultralight_vector_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1611_03793", "source_line": 2963, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 561, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative ultralight_vector_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and yes all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, suppression of small-scale power, smooth_cutoff transfer-function shape.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_ultracompact_minihalo_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_1947_pbh_seeded_wimp_ucmh_boost_v1", "paper_id": "1009_1947", "source_line": 1226, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 562, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card in family wimp_ultracompact_minihalo_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out for the WIMP abundance; post-formation WIMP accretion onto PBH seeds forming UCMHs.", "Observational leverage is driven by enhancement of small-scale power; medium CMB and medium BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_3539_nonminimal_scalar_r2_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "1201_3539", "source_line": 1535, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 563, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and decay produced phase-space treatment, suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_12730_kinetically_misaligned_dark_photon_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_12730", "source_line": 4921, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 564, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Kinetically produced massive dark-photon vector dark matter is speculative with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by nonthermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: observational leverage, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_08623_light_vector_plasmon_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1902_08623", "source_line": 3789, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 565, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 28 because the card identifies production via freeze-in from plasmon decay, freeze-in from Standard Model charged-fermion annihilation, nonthermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: BBN, CMB, decay or indirect probes; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_08339_neutrino_portal_dark_force_v1", "paper_id": "2106_08339", "source_line": 4686, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 566, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; mixed_cold_warm phase space.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_antimatter_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_01200_antimatter_macros_v1", "paper_id": "2006_01200", "source_line": 4264, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 567, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative macroscopic_antimatter_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support, production via unknown macroscopic-object formation; quark-nugget-like QCD phase-transition formation cited as a related possibility, nonthermal phase-space treatment, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_10388_p_wave_breit_wigner_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2110_10388", "source_line": 4943, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 568, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: p-wave Breit-Wigner enhanced dark matter annihilation is speculative with phenomenological_parameterization theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: observational leverage, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_01341_sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_thermal_effects_v1", "paper_id": "2308_01341", "source_line": 5763, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 569, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Thermal-effects freeze-in sterile-neutrino dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, nontrivial cosmological or phase-space leverage; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, neutrino probes, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2401_09411_alp_supercooled_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2401_09411", "source_line": 5985, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 570, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from primordial_black_holes: ALP-triggered supercooled-phase-transition primordial black hole dark matter has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through supercooled first-order phase transition in an ALP sector, density fluctuations from delayed bubble nucleation, PBH collapse from large overdensities; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, compact_objects, gravitational_waves, small_scale_structure.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_01017_fibre_inflation_open_string_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2208_01017", "source_line": 5277, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 571, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Fibre-inflation open-string QCD axion dark matter: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via QCD axion misalignment after fibre-inflation reheating, field-like phase space, phase-transition history, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, indirect detection), family/diversity context for axion_like_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_0288_inert_doublet_single_higgs_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_0288", "source_line": 1510, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 572, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, effective field theory theory level, and inert doublet dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, direct detection, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_5243_bino_decay_gravitino_dark_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1304_5243", "source_line": 1762, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 573, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 28: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family gravitino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance high; BBN relevance high; small-scale-power effect suppression; transfer function smooth_cutoff; phase-space type mixed_cold_warm; complementarity probes counted as BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 77; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_6480_goldilocks_gmsb_gravitino_v1", "paper_id": "1205_6480", "source_line": 1603, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 574, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Goldilocks cosmology gravitino dark matter in minimal GMSB; it offers suppression in small-scale power; decay produced phase-space behavior; CMB/BBN relevance with BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, and 2 more probe hooks.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_00458_atomic_dark_matter_dark_magnetic_fields_v1", "paper_id": "1804_00458", "source_line": 3428, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 575, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level phenomenological_parameterization; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance high/high; structure entry unknown/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals gravitational, vector.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: not_complete_model, dark_radiation_context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_07878_dfsz_lepto_axiogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2208_07878", "source_line": 5289, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 576, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Supersymmetric DFSZ lepto-axiogenesis axion dark matter: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via kinetic misalignment from rotating Peccei-Quinn field, field-like phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves, indirect detection), family/diversity context for axion_like_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_07878_ksvz_lepto_axiogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2208_07878", "source_line": 5290, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 577, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Supersymmetric KSVZ lepto-axiogenesis axion dark matter: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via kinetic misalignment from rotating Peccei-Quinn field, field-like phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves, indirect detection), family/diversity context for axion_like_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_13492_singlet_majoron_primordial_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2310_13492", "source_line": 5869, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 578, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but close to tier3 because the singlet Majoron has strong CMB/BBN/neutrino leverage and a rare Majoron family position, but stability caveats, sparse implementation support, and missing explicit constraints reduce readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2305_04924_pbh_false_vacuum_phase_transition_v1", "paper_id": "2305_04924", "source_line": 5592, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 579, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: false-vacuum PBH formation has gravitational-wave and early-universe complementarity, but the card lacks explicit constraints, routes, benchmarks, and code.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0804_4543_numsm_resonant_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0804_4543", "source_line": 779, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 580, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 28.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance high, small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type resonant; probe classes counted: ['BBN', 'halo/subhalo abundance', 'small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_12906_pseudo_dirac_lepton_doublet_late_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_12906", "source_line": 5676, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 581, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Pseudo-Dirac SU(2)_L lepton-doublet dark matter with late scalar decay (electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter) has mixed cold warm phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, higgs, vector, other portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 28.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_01124_neutron_dark_decay_two_dark_particles_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_01124", "source_line": 3395, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 582, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and unknown phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2405_09790_modified_affleck_dine_pbh_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2405_09790", "source_line": 6074, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 583, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 28.0: speculative uv complete model in primordial_black_holes, with relic-density capability recorded as no.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure; small-scale power effect is mixed.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1911_00057_speed_breaker_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "1911_00057", "source_line": 4055, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 28.0 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 584, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative primordial_black_holes with phenomenological_parameterization structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'not_applicable', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: CMB, compact objects/microlensing.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_evaporation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_07898_pbh_evaporation_multi_species_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2204_07898", "source_line": 5114, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 585, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for PBH-evaporation multi-species production with high BBN relevance and rare diversity value; generic particle content and missing route fields impose penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_7945_symmetric_vector_kinetic_mixing_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_7945", "source_line": 1926, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 586, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 28.0 because the model card is a benchmark self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; high BBN and high CMB relevance; nonlinear halo-structure relevance and touches BBN, CMB, collider, halo dynamics.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrinophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_1936_neutrinophilic_eft_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1305_1936", "source_line": 1800, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 587, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 28: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, family neutrinophilic_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance high; BBN relevance medium; small-scale-power effect suppression; transfer function smooth_cutoff; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 5; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_like_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_10173_vector_like_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_10173", "source_line": 3517, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 588, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a simplified-model implementation; it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_relics", "model_id": "1910_05238_warm_inflation_planck_pbh_relics_v1", "paper_id": "1910_05238", "source_line": 4045, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 589, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediated_wimp", "model_id": "2110_15391_two_pseudoscalar_mediated_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_15391", "source_line": 4945, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 590, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Two-pseudoscalar-mediated simplified dark matter model is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2360_rh_sneutrino_condensate_bdm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2360", "source_line": 737, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 591, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked yes; nonthermal phase-space history; BBN medium and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_minicluster_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0607341_higgs_like_scalar_miniclusters_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0607341", "source_line": 608, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 592, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has strong card-level observational leverage from cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation fields, high diversity value within the population-count context, some computational or code support recorded in the model card, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_05703_regurgitated_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_05703", "source_line": 5797, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 593, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Regurgitated fermion dark matter has strong theory or relic-density motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, collider/fixed-target, compact objects/microlensing, direct detection, gravitational waves, and additional probe classes.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_05703_regurgitated_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_05703", "source_line": 5796, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 594, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Regurgitated scalar dark matter has strong theory or relic-density motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, collider/fixed-target, compact objects/microlensing, direct detection, gravitational waves, and additional probe classes.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_07662_variant_axion_domain_wall_safe_mev_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_07662", "source_line": 3953, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 595, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for variant axion model with domain-wall-safe PQ charges: strong model-card science motivation, moderate observational leverage; inferred probe classes are CMB, collider / fixed-target, gravitational waves, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 28 (defer) uses production=vacuum misalignment; post-inflation string-wall-system decay; phase=field_like; CMB=medium, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_07454_subhorizon_collapsed_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2306_07454", "source_line": 5652, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 596, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Sub-horizon-collapsed primordial black hole dark matter (primordial_black_holes) has gravitational portal coverage, high diversity value in the population context, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 28.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_00117_hadronic_up_scalar_fimp_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1910_00117", "source_line": 3986, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 597, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Hadronic up-type minimal scalar FIMP freeze-in model: moderate observational leverage, some associated-code support; inferred probe classes are Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score 28 (defer) uses production=freeze-in from vector-like fermion decays; phase=decay_produced; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_00117_leptonic_scalar_fimp_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1910_00117", "source_line": 3985, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 598, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Leptonic minimal scalar FIMP freeze-in model: moderate observational leverage, some associated-code support; inferred probe classes are Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score 28 (defer) uses production=freeze-in from vector-like fermion decays; phase=decay_produced; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kalb_ramond_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_02485_kalb_ramond_like_particle_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_02485", "source_line": 5836, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 599, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is freeze-in from SM fermion annihilation and Compton scattering.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, direct/collider, indirect detection, small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (mixed_cold_warm, suppression) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "so10_extra_generation_hot_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9806400_so10_extra_generation_hot_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9806400", "source_line": 6107, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 600, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 28 (defer) from supplied card content: so10_extra_generation_hot_neutrino_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and no all-DM production; non-CDM linear structure information (suppression, smooth_cutoff); cosmological relevance: CMB medium, BBN high.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dilaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_4988_light_decoupled_techni_dilaton_v1", "paper_id": "1201_4988", "source_line": 1519, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 601, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and field like phase-space treatment.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_17157_light_vector_simp_dark_pion_v1", "paper_id": "2311_17157", "source_line": 5857, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 602, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but promising for breadth because the rare composite SIMP dark-pion sector is UV-complete and multi-component with CMB and self-interaction relevance, but observational machinery and public implementation support are sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "2312_01410_yukawa_coupled_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2312_01410", "source_line": 360, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 603, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives emerging phenomenological_parameterization model; production via phenomenological cold dark matter abundance evolved with scalar-dependent mass; energy and momentum exchange between CDM and EDE scalar; CMB relevance high and BBN relevance unknown; linear structure effect suppression with transfer shape scale_dependent_growth; probe hooks: CMB, galaxy satellites/halo structure, large-scale/small-scale structure, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_freeze_in_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_00320_vector_dark_matter_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1710_00320", "source_line": 3327, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 604, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_00174_two_singlet_pq_ultralight_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_00174", "source_line": 5059, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 605, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 28 (defer) as a speculative effective_field_theory member of ultralight_axion_like_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, direct/lab, axion/laboratory.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: inflation/reheating, axion/strong-cp, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: nonthermal production from PQ symmetry breaking and kinetic Nambu-Goldstone cosmological evolution; spatially inhomogeneous mode evolution around homogeneous singlet backgrounds."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_05663_hidden_higgs_portal_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_05663", "source_line": 3550, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 606, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a simplified-model implementation; it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_2765_mu_negative_422_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_2765", "source_line": 1201, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 607, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production via thermal neutralino freeze-out; gluino coannihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_light_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1010_1789_enmssm_singlino_singlet_light_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1010_1789", "source_line": 1203, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 608, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative simplified_model card in family supersymmetric_light_neutralino_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out of light neutralinos through light Higgs exchange.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_11639_pbh_dm_from_bl_phase_transition_v1", "paper_id": "2307_11639", "source_line": 5776, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 609, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Primordial black hole dark matter from late B-L phase-transition patches has strong theory or relic-density motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include BBN, CMB/cosmic-dawn, compact objects/microlensing, gravitational waves.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_08901_inert_triplet_fermionic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_08901", "source_line": 5873, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 610, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but relatively strong within the defer band because the fermionic radiative-neutrino-mass variant has a UV-complete setup and partial micrOMEGAs support, but no explicit observables, constraints, or routes are encoded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_nmssm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_5091_nmssm_neutralino_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "1309_5091", "source_line": 1903, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 611, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 90.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 28.0 because the model card is a speculative neutralino_nmssm_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; unknown BBN and medium CMB relevance; high diversity value in the registry population and touches CMB, collider, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_02403_su2_electroweak_alp_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_02403", "source_line": 6096, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 612, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 28.0: speculative effective field theory model in axion_portal_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is yes and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_08778_cmssm_ld_vectorlike_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_08778", "source_line": 3090, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 613, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative neutralino_supersymmetric_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium; inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_08778_cmssm_que_vectorlike_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_08778", "source_line": 3091, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 614, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative neutralino_supersymmetric_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium; inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0908_0115_nonthermal_gravitino_pseudomoduli_decay_v1", "paper_id": "0908_0115", "source_line": 977, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 615, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; critical BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, CMB, indirect detection.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "spin_2_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_13381_spin2_inflationary_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2305_13381", "source_line": 5638, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 616, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because rare spin-2 inflationary dark matter with full-DM capability, field-like phase space, and strong diversity value.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "compact_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_13576_microscopic_horizonless_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_13576", "source_line": 5633, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 28, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 617, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because rare horizonless compact relic with high CMB/BBN relevance and broad compact-object complementarity.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 28, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_04002_su5_inflection_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2306_04002", "source_line": 5702, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 618, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.7, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: SU(5) inflection-point inflation primordial black-hole dark matter is a speculative uv_complete card with yes relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance, enhancement of small-scale power.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider/fixed-target, compact objects/dynamics, direct detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 12.0, observational 6.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 4.7, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_08588_fermionic_dm_two_pbh_evaporation_v1", "paper_id": "2301_08588", "source_line": 5508, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 619, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides CMB/BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space information, some cross-probe reach, and high diversity value in the population context.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_07934_dark_photon_vector_millicharged_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_07934", "source_line": 3470, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after missing observational-detail and routing penalties."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 620, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer ranking for Dark-photon portal vector millicharged dark matter: the supplied card gives a simplified model millicharged dark matter model with medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; large penalties come from missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_01352_thermal_hadronic_axion_nonstandard_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "2308_01352", "source_line": 5735, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 621, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Thermal hadronic axion in nonstandard cosmologies is a speculative effective_field_theory card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, suppression of small-scale power, mixed_cold_warm phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 7.0, observational 10.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.5, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2303_14107_string_wall_catastrogenesis_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_14107", "source_line": 5543, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 622, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_14152_dark_sink_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2312_14152", "source_line": 5919, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 623, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Dark Sink freeze-in dark matter is a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and BBN, CMB, direct detection from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 10, observational leverage 9, complementarity 8, feasibility 2, provenance 9, diversity 2.5, penalties 13; raw score 27.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_12130_vacuum_misalignment_composite_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_12130", "source_line": 4064, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 27.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 624, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative asymmetric_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, gravitational waves.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1465_rh_sneutrino_inverse_linear_seesaw_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1465", "source_line": 1690, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 625, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as thermal WIMP freeze-out through Higgs/gauge-mediated annihilation channels, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 27.5 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=unknown and CMB=medium; card-implied probe classes include CMB, collider, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_03398_dark_antineutron_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_03398", "source_line": 4777, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 626, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: asymmetry transfer through neutrino portal; dark sphaleron conversion to dark baryon asymmetry.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_03398_dark_antiproton_dark_pion_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_03398", "source_line": 4778, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 627, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: asymmetry transfer through neutrino portal; dark sphaleron conversion to dark baryon asymmetry.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_0403_gravitino_from_q_ball_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1107_0403", "source_line": 1360, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 628, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as nonthermal_gravitino_dark_matter: production is represented by nonthermal production from Affleck-Dine Q-ball decay; phase-space is nonthermal; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, cosmological phase-space, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; some cosmological or phase-space relevance is present; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_12916_littlest_seesaw_rhn_portal_fimpzilla_v1", "paper_id": "1910_12916", "source_line": 4032, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 629, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "magnetic_dipole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_05783_light_magnetic_dipole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_05783", "source_line": 2786, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 630, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative effective_field_theory in magnetic_dipole_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal chemical decoupling assumed; late kinetic decoupling studied; portals: vector; BBN relevance is medium; small-scale power effect is suppression.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_1937_rrg_warm_dark_matter_photon_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "1312_1937", "source_line": 1997, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 631, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_07660_two_component_cdm_self_heating_v1", "paper_id": "2312_07660", "source_line": 5912, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 632, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Two-component cold dark matter with self-heated light component is a speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with mixed_cold_warm phase-space information, suppression small-scale-power information, and small-scale structure from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 10, observational leverage 15, complementarity 2, feasibility 1, provenance 9, diversity 2.0, penalties 12; raw score 27.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05369_dw_modified_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05369", "source_line": 2730, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 633, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power behavior, mixed_cold_warm phase-space history.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_11218_higgs_reheating_vector_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2207_11218", "source_line": 5267, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 634, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Higgs-induced reheating vector freeze-in dark matter: speculative status, effective-field-theory theory level, and production via pure gravitational production from inflaton background; gravitational freeze-in from SM quanta, nonthermal phase space, phase-transition history, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for freeze_in_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_02668_preheating_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2209_02668", "source_line": 5265, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 635, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Preheating-produced sterile-neutrino fermionic dark matter: speculative status, effective-field-theory theory level, and production via non-perturbative gravitational production in evolving spacetime; preheating production from time-varying inflaton/Higgs-induced fermion mass, nonthermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for sterile_neutrino_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2209_05959_qcd_epoch_pbh_population_v1", "paper_id": "2209_05959", "source_line": 5273, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 636, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for QCD-epoch first-principle primordial-black-hole dark matter population: speculative status, phenomenological-parameterization theory level, and production via collapse of large-amplitude primordial curvature perturbations after inflation; critical collapse modified by QCD equation-of-state effects, nonthermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites), family/diversity context for primordial_black_holes, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phantom_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_12989_phantom_hidden_sector_sterile_neutrino_dm_creation_v1", "paper_id": "2308_12989", "source_line": 5761, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 637, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Phantom hidden-sector sterile-neutrino dark matter creation has nontrivial cosmological or phase-space leverage, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include CMB/cosmic-dawn, neutrino probes, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: ghost_eft_not_standard_dm."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1311_3090_modulated_linear_chaotic_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_3090", "source_line": 1999, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 638, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, indirect detection, small-scale structure; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_00794_inflaton_coupled_ultralight_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1606_00794", "source_line": 2855, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 639, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; suppression small-scale-power effect; field_like phase-space population; 3 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_quark_nugget_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_05090_axion_quark_nugget_survival_distribution_v1", "paper_id": "1903_05090", "source_line": 3777, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 640, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 27 because the card identifies production via collapse of axion domain-wall network during the QCD transition, matter/antimatter nugget charge separation, nonthermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: BBN, compact-object or macroscopic probes; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_1222_pure_sun_hidden_gluino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1409_1222", "source_line": 2259, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 641, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and nonthermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior, distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phase_transition_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_02230_higgs_portal_bubble_expansion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_02230", "source_line": 5252, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 642, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Higgs-portal dark matter from relativistic bubble expansion: speculative status, phenomenological-parameterization theory level, and production via production during relativistic bubble expansion; freeze-out contribution diluted by supercooling, nonthermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, gravitational waves), family/diversity context for phase_transition_produced_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phase_transition_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_02230_singlet_portal_bubble_expansion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_02230", "source_line": 5253, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 643, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Singlet-portal dark matter from bubble-wall production: speculative status, phenomenological-parameterization theory level, and production via bubble-wall production from thermal scalar s; loop-mediated s s to SM particles, nonthermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves), family/diversity context for phase_transition_produced_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2208_14978_dissipative_inflation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2208_14978", "source_line": 5297, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 644, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Dissipative-inflation primordial black hole dark matter: speculative status, phenomenological-parameterization theory level, and production via collapse of large inflationary curvature perturbations after horizon re-entry, not-applicable phase space, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, indirect detection), family/diversity context for primordial_black_holes, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_cold_warm_nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_03993_two_temperature_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2112_03993", "source_line": 5018, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 645, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 12.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Two temperature dark matter (2TDM) has strong supplied observational leverage; probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_01678_ultralight_axion_dark_su3_phase_transition_v1", "paper_id": "2109_01678", "source_line": 4872, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 646, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; suppression of small-scale power; scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior; field_like phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_0288_inert_doublet_multi_higgs_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_0288", "source_line": 1509, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 647, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, effective field theory theory level, and inert doublet dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_6382_a4_fn_seesaw_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_6382", "source_line": 1467, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 648, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card describes speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter, uv complete theory framing, medium CMB and medium BBN relevance, suppression small-scale effect with smooth cutoff transfer behavior, nonthermal phase-space history, with production via sterile-neutrino production by active-sterile oscillations used as guideline.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_6127_global_u1_pseudo_dirac_dm_dark_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1404_6127", "source_line": 2110, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 649, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: CMB relevance is high; BBN relevance is high; small-scale-power effect is suppression; transfer-function shape is oscillatory; halo-mass-function effect is supplied; subhalo-mass-function effect is supplied.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "quasi_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_00982_quasi_cold_velocity_dispersion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_00982", "source_line": 316, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 650, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, BBN relevance is low, small-scale power effect is suppression, transfer function shape is smooth_cutoff.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=partial; warnings=medium:not_wdm.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 6/11/5/1/9/6/11."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_07920_bl_2hdm_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_07920", "source_line": 4293, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 651, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support, production via thermal freeze-out through Z prime and scalar/gauge channels; possible dilution by early matter domination.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_04788_su2l_asymmetric_dark_matter_gravitational_waves_v1", "paper_id": "2209_04788", "source_line": 5298, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 652, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for SU(2)_ell asymmetric dark matter with first-order phase transition: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via asymmetric dark matter production tied to baryogenesis; annihilation of symmetric component via light CP-odd scalar, thermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves, indirect detection), family/diversity context for asymmetric_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_destructing_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_00455_dark_baryon_sddm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_00455", "source_line": 3372, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 653, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative self_destructing_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and unknown phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, astrophysical fields, collider/fixed-target.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_04906_so10_pq_model_1_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_04906", "source_line": 3361, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 654, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and field like phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, astrophysical fields, collider/fixed-target.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_0992_relativistically_decoupled_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_0992", "source_line": 1154, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 655, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 27 because the supplied card has strong card-level cosmology or structure-formation leverage, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, distinctive or underrepresented model-space coverage, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_01111_neutrinophilic_alp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1809_01111", "source_line": 3601, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 656, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative axion_like_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_7945_symmetric_vector_z_mixing_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_7945", "source_line": 1927, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 657, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 27.0 because the model card is a benchmark self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; high BBN and medium CMB relevance; nonlinear halo-structure relevance and touches BBN, CMB, collider, halo dynamics.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_08150_5d_dirac_dark_photon_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_08150", "source_line": 3531, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 658, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a simplified-model implementation; it touches CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_04074_singlet_fermion_veltman_v1", "paper_id": "1801_04074", "source_line": 3369, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 659, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Associated-code field is partial, improving implementation feasibility."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_09855_subgut_stop_coannihilation_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_09855", "source_line": 3386, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 660, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, galaxy/halo structure.", "Associated-code field is yes, improving implementation feasibility."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cannibal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_08486_cannibal_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2008_08486", "source_line": 4361, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 661, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Cannibal scalar dark matter with 3-to-2 self-interactions: unspecified early production before CMB-era evolution; strong cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage, good diversity value within the population context, partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, indirect/transient and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_1205_pseudo_familon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1201_1205", "source_line": 1508, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 662, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, effective field theory theory level, and pseudo goldstone dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_0284_singlet_doublet_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1202_0284", "source_line": 1547, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 663, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and singlet doublet dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, direct detection, indirect detection, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1907_04125_inflection_point_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1907_04125", "source_line": 356, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 664, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative effective_field_theory model; production via inflationary enhancement of curvature perturbations; horizon re-entry collapse during radiation domination; CMB relevance high and BBN relevance medium; linear structure effect enhancement with transfer shape enhanced_small_scale_power; probe hooks: BBN, CMB, compact objects/microlensing/dynamics, galaxy satellites/halo structure, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1908_01464_scalar_fragmentation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_01464", "source_line": 3955, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 665, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for primordial black holes from scalar-field fragmentation: moderate observational leverage, high diversity value; inferred probe classes are BBN, compact objects / dynamics, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score 27 (defer) uses production=scalar condensate fragmentation into solitonic lumps; rare overdense Q-ball or oscillon clusters collapsing into PBHs; phase=not_applicable; CMB=unknown, BBN=medium; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_dark_radiation", "model_id": "1507_04351_interacting_cdm_dark_radiation_drag_v1", "paper_id": "1507_04351", "source_line": 2537, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 666, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Interacting cold dark matter-dark radiation drag model: model-card structure/cosmology fields give comparatively strong observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; population counts make it a relatively distinctive registry representative; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 27.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_02657_self_interacting_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2108_02657", "source_line": 234, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 667, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a emerging self_interacting_warm_dark_matter entry with simplified_model; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=smooth_cutoff, small_scale_power_effect=suppression, and probe classes: CMB, structure formation.", "Feasibility receives limited credit for associated_code=yes; shard-level ranks are left null for the parent aggregator."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_09345_twin_simps_v1", "paper_id": "1805_09345", "source_line": 3516, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 668, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a UV-complete model card; it touches BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection and other probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_02960_u1d_vectorlike_singlet_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_02960", "source_line": 3392, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 669, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and nonthermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_4899_sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_leptogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1412_4899", "source_line": 2365, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 670, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and freeze-in from out-of-equilibrium singlet-scalar decay production.", "Observational leverage comes from decay-produced phase space; suppression small-scale power; smooth-cutoff transfer behavior.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for rare production mechanism: freeze-in from out-of-equilibrium singlet-scalar decay."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "branon_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0406076_branon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0406076", "source_line": 501, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 671, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Branon dark matter with thermal and misalignment production is a speculative effective field theory card with either relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (mixed cold warm; small-scale effect mixed); it touches cmb, galaxy satellites, indirect detection, lyman-alpha forest; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_09717_constrained_sidm_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1709_09717", "source_line": 3269, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 672, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 89.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self interacting dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale power with oscillatory transfer behavior.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 27.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_08407_time_varying_pq_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_08407", "source_line": 5339, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 673, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 27.0: axion_like_dark_matter with parametric resonance decay of the complex PQ field; science=14.0, observational leverage=8.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, direct detection) and diversity=5.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_02779_dark_matter_pearl_vacuum_bubble_v1", "paper_id": "2203_02779", "source_line": 5080, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 674, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 27 (defer) as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of macroscopic_self_interacting_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, structure/dynamics, direct/lab, compact/microlensing/dynamics, axion/laboratory.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: tension/anomaly, phase transition/gw, structure/self-interaction.", "Production summary used: formation of macroscopic new-vacuum pearls in the early Universe; phenomenological dark-to-baryonic matter ratio from ordinary matter expelled around one second after the Big Bang."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_matter_dark_energy_fifth_force", "model_id": "0906_3880_dark_matter_coupled_scalar_fifth_force_v1", "paper_id": "0906_3880", "source_line": 999, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 675, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative coupled_dark_matter_dark_energy_fifth_force entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and unknown full-density capability.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance; enhancement small-scale power effect; scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior; probe classes: CMB, fifth-force/cosmological dynamics, large-scale structure.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_11944_charged_meson_vector_portal_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_11944", "source_line": 4942, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 676, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Charged-meson vector-portal inelastic dark matter benchmark is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by unknown phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, feasibility, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_12326_qcd_axion_dark_photon_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2004_12326", "source_line": 4224, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 677, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include axion or strong-CP connection, early-universe production connection, larger-framework connection; field_like phase-space information; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_2981_no_scale_f_su5_bino_golden_strip_v1", "paper_id": "1009_2981", "source_line": 1248, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 678, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production via thermal neutralino relic abundance in the supersymmetric model.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB and unknown BBN relevance; probe classes: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "glueball_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_09510_dark_su_n_scalar_glueball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_09510", "source_line": 5687, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 679, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Dark SU(N) scalar glueball dark matter (glueball_dark_matter) has field like phase-space information, high diversity value in the population context, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 27.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_02666_nonthermal_two_component_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1501_02666", "source_line": 2376, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 680, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and nonthermal production from SM-like Higgs decays, freeze-in-like production from pair annihilation of SM particles after electroweak symmetry breaking production.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase space; mixed small-scale power; mixed-cold-warm transfer behavior.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for rare production mechanism: nonthermal production from SM-like Higgs decays, and related mechanisms; multi-component candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "colored_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_04326_t_channel_dr_colored_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2203_04326", "source_line": 5056, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 681, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 27 (defer) as a benchmark simplified_model member of colored_coannihilation_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out; colored co-annihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "colored_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_04326_t_channel_ql_colored_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2203_04326", "source_line": 5057, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 682, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 27 (defer) as a benchmark simplified_model member of colored_coannihilation_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out; colored co-annihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "colored_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_04326_t_channel_ur_colored_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2203_04326", "source_line": 5055, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 683, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 27 (defer) as a benchmark simplified_model member of colored_coannihilation_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out; colored co-annihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_15118_z8_hybrid_scotogenic_type_ii_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_15118", "source_line": 5549, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 684, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_13367_affleck_dine_forbidden_decay_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_13367", "source_line": 5626, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 685, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because Affleck-Dine asymmetric dark matter with full-DM capability, high CMB relevance, and qualitative self-interaction effects.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_08662_extended_ksvz_axion_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_08662", "source_line": 5593, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 686, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the extended KSVZ axion plus scalar model has strong theory and partial code value, but observational leverage is modest in the supplied fields.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_preheating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_08686_waterfall_scalar_preheating_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2304_08686", "source_line": 5640, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 687, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because rare waterfall-preheating scalar dark matter with nonthermal production and CMB/BBN relevance.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_10225_iss_nmssm_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_10225", "source_line": 4098, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 27.0 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 688, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 9, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; limited observational leverage in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_02217_scotozee_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_02217", "source_line": 5142, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 689, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for the companion ScotoZee Majorana fermion case with rare family diversity and partial relic-code support, while observational routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_01717_scalar_neutrino_portal_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2005_01717", "source_line": 4233, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 690, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection; nonthermal phase-space information; high or critical BBN relevance; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_thermal_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_07078_self_scattering_vector_resonance_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2204_07078", "source_line": 5117, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 691, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a benchmark self-scattering resonant freeze-out calculation with phase-space distribution information and partial code support; a high moment-equation warning caps priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_axion_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_0692_fast_decaying_axino_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_0692", "source_line": 1396, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 692, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as supersymmetric_axion_gravitino_dark_matter: production is represented by axino production followed by early decay to gravitino plus axion; phase-space is decay_produced; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, cosmological phase-space, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by effective_field_theory structure and the supplied production history; some cosmological or phase-space relevance is present; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_compact_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_13182_dark_macho_phenomenological_v1", "paper_id": "2003_13182", "source_line": 4248, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 693, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, structure or tension connection; high CMB relevance; the card says it can produce all dark matter; explicit probe classes from card fields: BBN, CMB, compact objects, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_03762_cp_even_sneutrino_nmssm_type_i_seesaw_v1", "paper_id": "1807_03762", "source_line": 3528, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 694, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a UV-complete model card; it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_04037_resonant_u1_zprime_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_04037", "source_line": 4779, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 695, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out; resonant Z prime-mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_split_supersymmetry_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_02906_so10_split_susy_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1501_02906", "source_line": 2318, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 27, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 696, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 27 because the assigned model card uv complete neutralino_split_supersymmetry_dark_matter card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; touches CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 27, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_03116_foamy_monodromy_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_03116", "source_line": 3818, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 697, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory model with production listed as misalignment with monodromy-enhanced field range, parametric growth of fluctuations from a homogeneous ALP field.", "High observational leverage comes from the card's nonthermal phase-space entry, suppression small-scale-power entry, and unknown/unknown CMB/BBN relevance.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_12442_scale_invariant_hidden_ng_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_12442", "source_line": 5966, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 698, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from hidden_sector_dark_matter: Classically scale-invariant QCD-like hidden-sector pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone dark matter has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through nonthermal production from inflaton/mediator S decay during reheating; inferred probe classes are CMB, direct_detection, indirect_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_07934_dark_photon_scalar_millicharged_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_07934", "source_line": 3469, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after missing observational-detail and routing penalties."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 699, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer ranking for Dark-photon portal scalar millicharged dark matter: the supplied card gives a simplified model millicharged dark matter model with medium CMB relevance and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection; large penalties come from missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_13407_explicit_chiral_axion_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_13407", "source_line": 5814, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 700, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is misalignment production of the axion field.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, direct/collider, gravitational waves/defects, indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (field_like, enhancement) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_13407_spontaneous_chiral_axion_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_13407", "source_line": 5815, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 701, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is misalignment production of the axion field.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, direct/collider, gravitational waves/defects, indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (field_like, enhancement) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_03624_composite_millicharged_absorption_line_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_03624", "source_line": 5515, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 702, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides CMB/BBN relevance, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_03389_electric_dipole_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1911_03389", "source_line": 4083, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 26.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 703, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_03389_magnetic_dipole_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1911_03389", "source_line": 4084, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 26.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 704, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2312_04628_supercool_phase_transition_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2312_04628", "source_line": 5888, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 705, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but useful for breadth because supercooled phase-transition PBHs connect BBN, phase-transition/GW, and compact-object probes, but the card marks PBHs as a subcomponent and lacks detailed parameter/routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_05125_ewsb_higgs_portal_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_05125", "source_line": 5867, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 706, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but useful for breadth because EWSB-triggered ALP mass evolution gives distinctive field-like nonthermal production and Higgs/axion complementarity, while observational details and code are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_06611_mev_scalar_pseudoscalar_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2310_06611", "source_line": 5822, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 707, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a benchmark simplified_model model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out during neutrino decoupling and electron-positron annihilation.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_18122_conformal_su2x_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2303_18122", "source_line": 5528, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 708, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, thermal phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_10487_lmu_ltau_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_10487", "source_line": 4056, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 26.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 709, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 10, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_09446_hidden_sector_axion_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_09446", "source_line": 4065, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 26.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 710, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: indirect detection, laboratory precision/axion searches.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "chiral_fermion_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11332_su2d_chiral_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11332", "source_line": 4108, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 711, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 26.5: speculative chiral_fermion_wimp_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, direct detection.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1465_u1r_u1bl_rh_sneutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1465", "source_line": 1691, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 712, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as thermal WIMP freeze-out with Z prime and Higgs-mediated annihilation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 26.5 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=unknown and CMB=medium; card-implied probe classes include CMB, collider, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_07992_vector_higgs_portal_uv_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1909_07992", "source_line": 4044, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 713, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative effective_field_theory; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_06320_radion_misalignment_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_06320", "source_line": 2883, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 714, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_field_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; suppression small-scale-power effect; smooth_cutoff transfer behavior; field_like phase-space population.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_13159_gravitational_hidden_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_13159", "source_line": 4295, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 715, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via inflationary gravitational production of hidden photons; longitudinal vector mode production, field_like phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1712_06574_lognormal_primordial_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_06574", "source_line": 3379, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 716, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 13.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory support and not applicable phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, compact objects/lensing.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hybrid_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5603_hybrid_axion_relic_particle_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5603", "source_line": 1546, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 717, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, and field like phase-space treatment.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (BBN, galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, direct detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_05501_friendly_axion_pair_v1", "paper_id": "2208_05501", "source_line": 5288, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 718, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Friendly coupled axion dark matter pair: speculative status, phenomenological-parameterization theory level, and production via misalignment production; autoresonant energy transfer between coupled axions, field-like phase space, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, black-hole superradiance, indirect detection), family/diversity context for axion_like_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1311_3090_modulated_quadratic_chaotic_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_3090", "source_line": 2000, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 719, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, indirect detection, small-scale structure; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fading_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_08261_fading_dark_matter_swamp_tower_v1", "paper_id": "1906_08261", "source_line": 3883, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 720, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 13.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: A late-time coupled dark-energy/dark-matter model in which a rolling scalar motivated by swampland conjectures makes dark matter masses decrease in the recent universe.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: phenomenological relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN low; CMB medium; phase-space unknown; transfer function scale_dependent_growth; small-scale power suppression.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: phenomenological_not_particle_complete."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_6669_scalar_field_udm_fast_transition_v1", "paper_id": "1011_6669", "source_line": 1213, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 721, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card in family unified_dark_matter with production via phenomenological unified dark fluid initial condition; late-time fast transition in scalar-field equation of state.", "Observational leverage is driven by field_like phase space; high CMB and unknown BBN relevance; probe classes: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics, galaxy satellites.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2207_10056_reverse_engineered_usr_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10056", "source_line": 5259, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 722, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Reverse-engineered ultra-slow-roll primordial black hole dark matter: speculative status, phenomenological-parameterization theory level, and production via inflationary curvature perturbation enhancement; gravitational collapse after horizon re-entry, not-applicable phase space, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites), family/diversity context for primordial_black_holes, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_08107_nonminimal_scalarized_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_08107", "source_line": 5271, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 723, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Nonminimally coupled scalarized cold-dark-matter field: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via field displacement during inflation followed by tachyonic growth and coherent oscillations about the potential minimum, field-like phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches), family/diversity context for scalar_field_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_04618_triple_unification_ultralight_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2012_04618", "source_line": 5, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 724, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, medium CMB relevance and high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space description, some computational or code support; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_cosmology_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_00620_bimetric_freeze_in_freeze_out_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_00620", "source_line": 5541, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 725, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides CMB/BBN relevance, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_0683_two_body_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_0683", "source_line": 2261, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 726, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative decaying_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and decay_produced phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior, distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_05064_koto_scalar_p_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2006_05064", "source_line": 4299, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 727, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative light_scalar_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via UV freeze-in after low-temperature reheating; thermal freeze-out through an added neutrino effective interaction.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1907_06353_cosmological_wetting_transition_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_06353", "source_line": 3977, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 728, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for cosmological wetting transition scalar dark matter: moderate observational leverage; inferred probe classes are CMB, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves.", "Score 26 (defer) uses production=coherent scalar oscillations of phi around a temporary local minimum; late environment-dependent conversion of the cosmological bulk phi component into dark energy; phase=field_like; CMB=medium, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_06931_su_n_glueball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1610_06931", "source_line": 2876, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 729, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; suppression small-scale-power effect; field_like phase-space population; 2 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "baryon_lepton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_00009_nucleon_decay_bminusl_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_00009", "source_line": 3389, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 730, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative baryon_lepton_portal_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory support and unknown phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9702236_interacting_hot_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9702236", "source_line": 24, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 731, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, high CMB relevance and high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, some computational or code support, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_14052_scalar_mediator_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_14052", "source_line": 5589, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 732, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the electron-philic scalar-mediator benchmark is near-term testable in principle, but this card supplies little observational-detail machinery.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0009003_nonthermal_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0009003", "source_line": 375, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 733, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 88.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via non-thermal production from topological-defect or cosmic-string decay; decay of unstable heavy particles; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance unknown; linear structure effect suppression with transfer shape smooth_cutoff; nonthermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_09041_hidden_sector_cannibal_ecde_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_09041", "source_line": 4698, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 734, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; critical BBN relevance; mixed of small-scale power.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_4890_light_hidden_fermion_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1004_4890", "source_line": 1091, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 735, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model hidden_sector_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium, BBN critical); structure signal (suppression, mixed_cold_warm); mixed_cold_warm phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_06816_ohelium_composite_dark_atom_v1", "paper_id": "1808_06816", "source_line": 3575, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 736, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative composite_dark_matter entry with phenomenological-parameterization theory support; it can supply all dark matter according to the production block, has mixed-cold-warm phase-space behavior, has suppression in small-scale power.", "The main positive leverage comes from explicit cosmological or small-scale-structure fields rather than from a populated observable-routing block.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_11885_nonzero_velocity_axion_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "1911_11885", "source_line": 4096, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 26.0 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 737, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative axion_like_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'field_like', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: laboratory precision/axion searches.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2311_15065_mst_eft_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2311_15065", "source_line": 5852, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 738, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the MST-EFT PBH scenario has PTA/SIGW, PBH, CMB, and BBN relevance, but nonlinear/PBH-abundance uncertainties and absent observable routing, constraints, and code keep follow-up value modest."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_09515_sterile_neutrino_dark_sector_freeze_out_v1", "paper_id": "2302_09515", "source_line": 5524, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 739, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, thermal phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "elko_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_05180_elko_electromagnetic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1712_05180", "source_line": 3378, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 740, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative elko_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, astrophysical fields, collider/fixed-target.", "Associated-code field is partial, improving implementation feasibility."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_condensate_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_03191_gravitational_neutrino_condensate_cold_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1602_03191", "source_line": 2760, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 741, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative phenomenological_parameterization in neutrino_condensate_cold_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: late phase transition converting relic neutrinos from hot to cold component; formation of bound neutrino states or neutrino superfluid; portals: neutrino, gravitational, other; CMB relevance is high; phase-space type is field_like.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_07992_massive_spin2_portal_uv_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1909_07992", "source_line": 4042, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 742, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.6, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative simplified_model; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_01604_spectator_pq_ultralight_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1909_01604", "source_line": 3975, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 743, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Spectator PQ-field ultralight scalar dark matter: moderate observational leverage; inferred probe classes are gravitational waves, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 26 (defer) uses production=nonthermal coherent oscillation of S after H drops below m_S; dynamically set initial amplitude from spectator scaling solution; phase=field_like; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_03670_dark_photon_freeze_in_emd_v1", "paper_id": "2204_03670", "source_line": 5133, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 744, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for early-matter-dominated dark-photon freeze-in with high BBN relevance and a target abundance, but two high validity warnings impose a large penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_03756_nonperiodic_alp_fragmentation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_03756", "source_line": 5608, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 745, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because ALP fragmentation with enhanced small-scale power and dense-minihalo phenomenology.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_atom_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_09973_fourth_generation_dark_atoms_v1", "paper_id": "2110_09973", "source_line": 4938, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 746, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Fourth-generation U-antiquark dark atoms is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by unknown phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, Lyman-alpha forest.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance, diversity.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_17834_subsolar_pbh_curvature_perturbations_v1", "paper_id": "2306_17834", "source_line": 5663, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 747, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Subsolar-mass primordial black holes from monochromatic curvature perturbations (primordial_black_holes) has CMB/BBN relevance, gravitational portal coverage, high diversity value in the population context, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support, low robustness. Raw score 26.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_7945_asymmetric_vector_kinetic_mixing_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_7945", "source_line": 1928, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 748, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 26.0 because the model card is a benchmark asymmetric_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; high BBN and not_applicable CMB relevance; nonlinear halo-structure relevance and touches BBN, collider, halo dynamics.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_08150_5d_majorana_dark_photon_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_08150", "source_line": 3532, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 749, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a simplified-model implementation; it touches CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_07987_higgs_portal_dark_qed_v1", "paper_id": "1909_07987", "source_line": 3989, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 750, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Higgs portal to dark QED: moderate observational leverage; inferred probe classes are BBN, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 26 (defer) uses production=asymmetric dark matter abundance; annihilation of the symmetric component into dark photons; phase=nonthermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=medium; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_14264_gravitational_portal_rhn_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_14264", "source_line": 5787, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 751, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Gravitational-portal right-handed-neutrino dark matter during reheating has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, CMB/cosmic-dawn, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: stability_is_assumed."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07712_bosonic_seesaw_axion_like_s_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07712", "source_line": 2790, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 752, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in axion_like_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: nonthermal coherent oscillation / misalignment; thermal production shown insufficient; portals: axion, higgs, other; CMB relevance is medium; phase-space type is field_like.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_04906_so10_pq_model_21_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_04906", "source_line": 3362, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 753, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and field like phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, astrophysical fields, collider/fixed-target.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_04906_so10_pq_model_22_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_04906", "source_line": 3363, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 754, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and field like phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, astrophysical fields, collider/fixed-target.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_04906_so10_pq_model_31_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_04906", "source_line": 3364, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 755, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and field like phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, astrophysical fields, collider/fixed-target.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_04906_so10_pq_model_32_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_04906", "source_line": 3365, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 756, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and field like phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, astrophysical fields, collider/fixed-target.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_05561_comprehensive_asymmetric_mirror_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1801_05561", "source_line": 3407, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 757, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance medium/high; structure entry unknown/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs, other, gravitational.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: composition_regime_dependence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_02458_chilly_asymmetric_reheating_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1604_02458", "source_line": 2766, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 758, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: asymmetric reheating populates the hidden sector at lower temperature; dark matter relic abundance subsequently set by interactions internal to the thermalized hidden sector; portals: other; CMB relevance is high; BBN relevance is high.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_03456_ultralight_axion_soliton_nfw_halo_v1", "paper_id": "1502_03456", "source_line": 2412, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 759, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter entry (phenomenological_parameterization); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is field_like; structure fields include suppression power with a smooth_cutoff transfer-function entry.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_13950_triplet_fermion_dm_fast_expansion_v1", "paper_id": "2303_13950", "source_line": 5580, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 760, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the electroweak triplet in a fast-expanding pre-BBN cosmology has useful complementarity, but a high-severity caveat and empty observational-detail fields reduce priority.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "e6_inspired_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_5967_e6_custodial_susy_two_candidate_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1205_5967", "source_line": 1561, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 761, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth candidate because the card describes a rare E6-inspired multi-component setup with mixed cold-warm phase-space behavior and small-scale-power effects, although the stable candidate and relic fraction are spectrum dependent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_05511_hybrid_mediation_mixed_axion_wino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_05511", "source_line": 3074, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 762, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with theory level unknown and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from distinct phase space mixed_cold_warm; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_moduli_cosmology", "model_id": "2308_15380_dirac_wimp_from_modulus_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2308_15380", "source_line": 5778, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 763, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Dirac fermion WIMP from modulus-dominated nonstandard cosmology has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include BBN, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_04582_melting_domain_wall_ultralight_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_04582", "source_line": 5757, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 764, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Melting-domain-wall ultralight scalar dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include BBN, axion/laboratory searches, black-hole superradiance, gravitational waves.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: exponent_signs_need_review."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_11115_a4_dirac_neutrino_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1805_11115", "source_line": 3505, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 765, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has decay_produced phase-space production; it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1807_00463_affleck_dine_hbb_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "1807_00463", "source_line": 3504, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 766, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a UV-complete model card; it touches compact objects / dynamics, gravitational waves / defects, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_05199_higgs_portal_gravitational_production_v1", "paper_id": "2403_05199", "source_line": 6025, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 767, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because gravitational reheating production adds distinctive nonthermal freeze-in physics, but the score is limited by missing code, constraints, and sensitivity to reheating assumptions."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "co_simp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_04955_z3_leptophilic_co_simp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_04955", "source_line": 5751, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 768, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Z3 leptophilic Co-SIMP dark matter for global 21-cm cosmology has some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class, partial associated-code or tool support; card-internal probe cues include CMB/cosmic-dawn, axion/laboratory searches, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_09203_bl_fimp_fermion_scalar_nlop_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_09203", "source_line": 5052, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 769, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 26 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-in from bath-particle _D processes; nonthermal/super-WIMP contribution from out-of-equilibrium _D decay."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_04677_qcd_axion_strings_post_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "1806_04677", "source_line": 3503, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 770, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it is marked canonical; it has a UV-complete model card; it has nonthermal phase-space production; it touches gravitational waves / defects, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_11176_dark_qcd_pi_axiverse_v1", "paper_id": "2304_11176", "source_line": 5595, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 771, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the dark-QCD pi-axiverse is a distinctive composite multi-species axion-like model, but the observational-detail fields are largely empty.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_3297_amsb_heavy_axino_decay_axion_wino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1004_3297", "source_line": 1124, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 772, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in multi_component_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium BBN relevance, mixed-cold-warm phase space, mixed small-scale-power effect, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_4770_no_scale_neutralino_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1310_4770", "source_line": 1925, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 773, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 26.0 because the model card is a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support; medium BBN and low CMB relevance and touches BBN, collider, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "familon_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_0880_familon_like_wispy_pseudogoldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_0880", "source_line": 1949, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 774, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 26.0 because the model card is a speculative familon_like_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support; low BBN and medium CMB relevance; field_like phase-space behavior; high diversity value in the registry population and touches CMB, collider, laboratory precision.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_04308_bl_type_iii_two_component_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_04308", "source_line": 3962, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 775, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Type-III-seesaw U(1) B-L model with two-component Dirac dark matter: strong model-card science motivation, some associated-code support; inferred probe classes are CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 26 (defer) uses production=thermal WIMP freeze-out of two coupled Dirac fermion components; pair annihilation to visible-sector states; phase=thermal; CMB=low, BBN=low; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_07601_dilaton_pngb_forbidden_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_07601", "source_line": 6019, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 776, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because dilaton forbidden dark matter is a rare composite EFT with BBN and self-interaction relevance, but the SM portal is generic and routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlino_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5244_cnmssm_singlino_stau_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5244", "source_line": 1524, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 777, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: benchmark status, benchmark mapping theory level, and singlino neutralino dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_03996_finite_modular_majoron_v1", "paper_id": "2405_03996", "source_line": 6065, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 778, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 26.0: speculative uv complete model in majoron_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB, indirect detection; phase space is field like.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_02681_dynamical_scotogenic_fermionic_majoron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_02681", "source_line": 5575, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 779, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the dynamical scotogenic majoron model has neutrino/majoron complementarity and full-DM relic support, but concrete observational and computational fields are absent.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_sector_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_00702_mirror_electron_sequential_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2311_00702", "source_line": 5854, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 780, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable because it is a rare mirror-sector sequential freeze-in construction that can produce all dark matter, with good provenance and nonthermal phase-space information, but explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_forbidden_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_05459_fopt_forbidden_decay_scotogenic_rhn_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_05459", "source_line": 5656, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 781, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because FOPT-enabled forbidden-decay scotogenic right-handed-neutrino dark matter (scotogenic_forbidden_decay_dark_matter) has higgs, neutrino portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 26.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "t_channel_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_09326_complex_scalar_t_channel_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_09326", "source_line": 6043, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 782, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because complex-scalar t-channel portal dark matter is testable and partly tool-supported, but it is near-duplicate content with no supplied observables, constraints, or route map."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "t_channel_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_09326_dirac_fermion_t_channel_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_09326", "source_line": 6044, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 783, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Dirac-fermion t-channel portal dark matter is testable and partly tool-supported, but it is near-duplicate content with no supplied observables, constraints, or route map."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "t_channel_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_09326_majorana_fermion_t_channel_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_09326", "source_line": 6045, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 784, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Majorana-fermion t-channel portal dark matter is testable and partly tool-supported, but it is near-duplicate content with no supplied observables, constraints, or route map."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_03721_dirac_scotogenic_singlet_doublet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_03721", "source_line": 5810, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 785, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, direct/collider, indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_02207_simplified_spin1_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_02207", "source_line": 5689, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 786, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Simplified spin-1 dark matter with dark photon mediator (vector_dark_matter) has CMB/BBN relevance, vector portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 26.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_09277_inelastic_lmu_ltau_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_09277", "source_line": 3972, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 787, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Inelastic U(1) L_mu-L_tau charged scalar dark matter: strong model-card science motivation; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 26 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out with S-P coannihilation through the extra U(1) gauge interaction; phase=thermal; CMB=medium, BBN=medium; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_06216_no_scale_bl_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_06216", "source_line": 5081, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 788, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 26 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of gravitino_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: strong science/relic-density basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, gravitational waves/inflation.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, inflation/reheating, phase transition/gw, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in, baryogenesis/leptogenesis.", "Production summary used: thermal gravitino production during reheating after hybrid inflation; vacuum energy transferred to coherent oscillations of the inflaton S and waterfall scalar, whose decays reheat the universe."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cosmic_string_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_06178_abelian_higgs_string_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_06178", "source_line": 5353, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 789, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Abelian-Higgs string-decay dark matter scenario has some cosmology or phase-space leverage, probe classes: BBN, CMB, gravitational waves, phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "miracle_less_wimp", "model_id": "2307_00537_bl_miracle_less_wimp_entropy_dilution_v1", "paper_id": "2307_00537", "source_line": 5704, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 790, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Gauged U(1)_B-L Miracle-less WIMP with late entropy dilution is a speculative simplified_model card with yes relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance, critical BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 12.0, observational 5.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.0, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "accident_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_10092_su2_fiveplet_accident_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2307_10092", "source_line": 5774, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 791, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because SU(2) x U(1) five-plet accident dark matter has strong theory or relic-density motivation, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include BBN, CMB/cosmic-dawn, axion/laboratory searches, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, and additional probe classes.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_11551_leptophilic_u1_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_11551", "source_line": 5164, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 792, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-to-mid observational value: UV-complete leptophilic SIDM has halo-structure leverage and multi-probe potential, but the card says detailed phenomenology remains future work and lacks routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_02217_scotozee_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_02217", "source_line": 5141, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 793, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a ScotoZee scalar inert thermal relic connecting dark matter to radiative neutrino mass with partial relic-code support, but CDM-like structure lowers priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_01717_pseudoscalar_neutrino_portal_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2005_01717", "source_line": 4234, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 794, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 87.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection; nonthermal phase-space information; high or critical BBN relevance; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_or_subthreshold_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_07078_self_scattering_subthreshold_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_07078", "source_line": 5118, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 795, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for sub-threshold scalar freeze-out with self-scattering and available distribution information, but high sensitivity to momentum tails limits follow-up value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_12278_dark_charge_z6_two_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_12278", "source_line": 4797, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 796, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out through F5 to F6 conversion; F6 annihilation through Z prime.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, mixed_cold_warm phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "long_range_interacting_heavy_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0504621_y_interacting_heavy_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0504621", "source_line": 331, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 797, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=no; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, BBN relevance is low, phase-space type is thermal, nonlinear halo or subhalo effect is stated.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, direct/lab scattering, indirect detection, small-scale structure; associated_code=partial; warnings=medium:subcomponent_only.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/4/10/1/9/7/12."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_4765_nonthermal_wino_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0906_4765", "source_line": 1000, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 798, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative nonthermal_wino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, CMB, indirect detection.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_03025_flipped_su5_light_neutralino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2107_03025", "source_line": 4767, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 799, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out; right-handed slepton coannihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_09679_su2r_axiogenesis_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_09679", "source_line": 4762, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 26, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 800, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: kinetic misalignment from axion/PQ-field rotation; parametric production of axion fluctuations.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 26, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_00036_subkev_decaying_fermion_u1x_v1", "paper_id": "2002_00036", "source_line": 4185, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 801, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of hidden_sector_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space information.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity credit reflects a comparatively distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or dominant probe class in the population context.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0509275_cmssm_gravitino_tp_ntp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509275", "source_line": 561, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 802, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["CMSSM gravitino dark matter with thermal and NLSP-decay production is a speculative uv complete card in family gravitino_dark_matter with production described as thermal production through scattering and decay processes of ordinary particles and superparticles during thermal expansion.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; mixed cold warm phase space; suppression of small-scale power; mixed cold warm transfer behavior; probe classes: BBN, CMB, halo/subhalo structure, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_13821_alp_gravitational_reheating_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "2312_13821", "source_line": 5890, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 803, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the ALP reheating branch is flexible and complementary across CMB/BBN/axion probes, but the broad ALP parameter freedom and missing routing/constraints keep follow-up value modest."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_13821_qcd_axion_gravitational_reheating_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "2312_13821", "source_line": 5889, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 804, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the QCD axion reheating branch has BBN/CMB and axion-search relevance, but viability depends on nonstandard reheating assumptions and the supplied card lacks explicit constraints and computation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "filtered_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_02830_filtered_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_02830", "source_line": 4124, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 805, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 25.5: speculative filtered_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: nonthermal phase-space behavior, phase-transition/GW-motivated phenomenology; inferred probe classes: direct detection, gravitational waves.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_15920_long_lived_axion_domain_wall_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_15920", "source_line": 5839, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 77, "global_rank": 806, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a emerging effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is nonthermal axion production from collapse and decay of long-lived domain walls.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, axion laboratory, gravitational waves/defects, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (decay_produced, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2304_01249_hybrid_inflation_waterfall_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_01249", "source_line": 5545, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 807, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_10486_qcd_axion_parametric_resonance_v1", "paper_id": "1711_10486", "source_line": 3291, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 808, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative qcd axion dark matter candidate with phenomenological parameterization theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale power with smooth cutoff transfer behavior, nonthermal phase-space structure.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching CMB, galaxy satellites.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 25.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_4376_density_dependent_interactions_v1", "paper_id": "1208_4376", "source_line": 1664, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 809, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out with phi-dependent annihilation cross section; post-freeze-out evolution of chameleon field changes late-time interaction strength, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 25.5 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=medium and CMB=medium; card-implied probe classes include BBN, CMB, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2309_14993_stiff_reheating_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_14993", "source_line": 5827, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 810, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is gravitational collapse of large density perturbations after horizon re-entry during stiff reheating.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, compact objects, small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (not_applicable, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2303_02168_multifield_inflation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2303_02168", "source_line": 5535, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 811, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, CMB/BBN relevance, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_12634_z3_pseudo_goldstone_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_12634", "source_line": 4116, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 812, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 25.5: speculative pseudo_goldstone_higgs_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, phase-transition/GW-motivated phenomenology; inferred probe classes: CMB, direct detection, gravitational waves.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_01739_qcd_axion_domain_wall_pbh_mixed_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_01739", "source_line": 5801, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 813, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative uv_complete model; the main production handle is PQ symmetry breaks during inflation.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, axion laboratory, compact objects, gravitational waves/defects, with phase-space/structure entries (nonthermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_5669_pbh_reheated_scalar_unification_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_5669", "source_line": 1361, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 814, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as scalar_field_unified_dark_matter: production is represented by field survival after inflation with PBH reheating; phase-space is field_like; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, compact objects / dynamics, cosmological phase-space, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by phenomenological_parameterization structure and the supplied production history; some cosmological or phase-space relevance is present; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_14317_type_i_nmssm_sneutrino_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1910_14317", "source_line": 4016, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 815, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.1, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptonic_color_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_01379_alternative_su3_4_leptonic_color_v1", "paper_id": "1801_01379", "source_line": 3340, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 816, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with yes relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, 4 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_07992_high_scale_susy_gravitino_uv_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1909_07992", "source_line": 4041, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 817, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.4, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative effective_field_theory; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_02033_z4_loop_suppression_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1911_02033", "source_line": 4013, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 818, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.3, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_10859_nonadiabatic_gravitational_uldm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_10859", "source_line": 4127, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 819, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 25: speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale power, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior, nonthermal phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_01246_vector_mediator_reannihilating_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_01246", "source_line": 3409, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 820, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 15, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance high/low; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals none.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: closed_sector_assumption, vector_scalar_difference."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1906_06348_charged_planck_scale_relics_v1", "paper_id": "1906_06348", "source_line": 3902, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 821, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamics.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_02273_affleck_dine_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1907_02273", "source_line": 3927, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 822, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative q_ball_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamics.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_15672_scalar_freeze_in_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_15672", "source_line": 4291, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 823, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via freeze-in from Standard Model plasma; e+e- annihilation through off-shell dark photon, nonthermal phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_15672_spinor_freeze_in_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_15672", "source_line": 4292, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 824, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via freeze-in from Standard Model plasma; e+e- annihilation through off-shell dark photon, nonthermal phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_02294_s3_z2_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_02294", "source_line": 4119, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 825, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 25: speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: suppression small-scale power, nonthermal phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: collider, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_11935_vector_wave_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2203_11935", "source_line": 5116, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 826, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a rare vector-wave dark-matter simulation entry with suppression/core structure; no relic prediction or constraint routing keeps the score low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0411283_decaying_dm_to_lorentz_violating_fermions_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0411283", "source_line": 541, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 827, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Decaying dark matter to Lorentz-violating fermions is a speculative effective field theory card with either relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (decay produced; small-scale effect suppression); it touches cmb, galaxy satellites, indirect detection, lyman-alpha forest; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2011_10606_higgs_noncanonical_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2011_10606", "source_line": 244, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 828, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=medium, transfer_function=enhanced_small_scale_power, small_scale_power_effect=enhancement, and probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamical.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2011_10606_tmodel_noncanonical_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2011_10606", "source_line": 245, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 829, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=medium, transfer_function=enhanced_small_scale_power, small_scale_power_effect=enhancement, and probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamical.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_08863_fermionic_inelastic_crdm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_08863", "source_line": 4912, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 830, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Fermionic inelastic cosmic-ray-accelerated dark matter is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by nonthermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: observational leverage, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1802_06785_pbh_running_indices_md_asteroid_full_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_06785", "source_line": 3405, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 831, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level phenomenological_parameterization; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance medium/medium; structure entry unknown/cdm_like; phase-space type not_applicable; portals gravitational.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: mass_notation_caution."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_14052_spin2_mediator_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_14052", "source_line": 5587, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 832, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: this benchmark light-DM spin-2 mediator has near-term accelerator/electron-probe relevance, but high-severity caveats and missing routes/constraints/code keep the score low.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_14052_spin2_mediator_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_14052", "source_line": 5588, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 833, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the scalar-DM spin-2 benchmark is experimentally oriented, yet the card lacks populated observational routes, constraints, benchmarks, and code.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_06739_equilibrium_scalar_freeze_in_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1609_06739", "source_line": 2893, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 834, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space population.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_11264_two_component_bdm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_11264", "source_line": 4285, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 835, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative multi_component_boosted_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via annihilation of the heavier dominant component chi_A into boosted chi_B pairs; Galactic Center or halo annihilation flux, nonthermal phase-space treatment, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_15016_lepton_number_scalar_capture_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_15016", "source_line": 5929, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 836, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Lepton-number-two ultralight scalar dark matter for neutrinoless double beta capture is a speculative ultralight_scalar_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space information, suppression small-scale-power information, and CMB, small-scale structure from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 11, observational leverage 12, complementarity 5, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 5.0, penalties 17; raw score 25.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_09907_scalar_secret_neutrino_sterile_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_09907", "source_line": 4886, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 837, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior; nonthermal phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_ultralight_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_00999_multi_ultralight_axion_mixed_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_00999", "source_line": 238, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 838, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative multi_component_ultralight_axion_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=smooth_cutoff, small_scale_power_effect=suppression, and probe classes: CMB, structure formation.", "Feasibility receives limited credit for associated_code=partial; shard-level ranks are left null for the parent aggregator."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0502222_bstv_scalar_oscillation_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0502222", "source_line": 335, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 839, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is high, BBN relevance is low, small-scale power effect is suppression, transfer function shape is smooth_cutoff.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:do_not_map_to_standard_fuzzy_dm, medium:parameters_are_examples.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 9/11/5/0/9/5/14."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_05487_rpv_axiogenesis_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_05487", "source_line": 4935, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 78, "global_rank": 840, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: RPV axiogenesis axion dark matter is speculative with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by field_like phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter_nonstandard_thermal_history", "model_id": "1909_01457_pre_emd_freeze_in_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1909_01457", "source_line": 3915, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 841, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter_nonstandard_thermal_history entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to BBN, CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_03652_z_portal_rhn_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_03652", "source_line": 3355, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 842, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_04512_asymmetric_dark_matter_nuggets_v1", "paper_id": "1805_04512", "source_line": 3540, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 843, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has nonthermal phase-space production; it touches collider / fixed-target, compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_03061_dark_matter_vortices_v1", "paper_id": "2111_03061", "source_line": 4911, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 844, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Dark matter vortex filament model is speculative with phenomenological_parameterization theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by field_like phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_09640_clockwork_scalar_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2310_09640", "source_line": 5881, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 845, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the clockwork scalar occupies distinctive subcomponent small-scale-suppression space, but it explicitly cannot be all dark matter and lacks observable routes and code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_6679_gravitino_dm_from_bl_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "1202_6679", "source_line": 1501, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 846, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and gravitino dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_06382_string_axiverse_misalignment_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_06382", "source_line": 3626, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 79, "global_rank": 847, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as emerging axion_like_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_3470_chilled_sterile_neutrino_out_of_equilibrium_decay_v1", "paper_id": "0801_3470", "source_line": 775, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 848, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability yes, raw score 25.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance low, small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type decay_produced; probe classes counted: ['halo/subhalo abundance', 'small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_02049_coherent_incoherent_bosonic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_02049", "source_line": 350, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 849, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=emerging, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=unknown; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, small-scale power effect is mixed, transfer function shape is mixed_cold_warm, phase-space type is mixed_cold_warm.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=no; warnings=medium:framework_not_relic_model, medium:phase_dependent_predictions.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/10/5/0/9/8/14."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_07313_su2x_supercooled_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_07313", "source_line": 4275, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 850, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative hidden_sector_vector_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support, production via thermal inflation and supercooling; first-order phase-transition sudden freeze-out, mixed_cold_warm phase-space treatment, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_7945_symmetric_scalar_higgs_portal_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_7945", "source_line": 1929, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 851, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 25.0 because the model card is a benchmark self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; high BBN and not_applicable CMB relevance; nonlinear halo-structure relevance and touches BBN, direct detection, halo dynamics.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_04902_majoron_misalignment_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_04902", "source_line": 3073, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 852, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative majoron_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, distinct phase space field_like; inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_08464_asymmetric_dm_sterile_neutrino_dark_msw_v1", "paper_id": "1702_08464", "source_line": 3018, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 853, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Asymmetric dark matter with sterile-neutrino Dark MSW interactions is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has strong cosmological or small-scale-structure leverage; modifies small-scale power; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_01675_present_decaying_lepton_q_ball_v1", "paper_id": "2403_01675", "source_line": 6003, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 854, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 9, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because late-decaying lepton Q-balls are distinctive macroscopic subcomponent dark matter with gamma-ray and BBN relevance, but the card says they are not all of dark matter and lacks reusable routing or code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "quark_philic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_1312_vib_bottom_philic_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1203_1312", "source_line": 1550, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 855, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 86.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and quark philic dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_05619_synchronous_mirror_atomic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2403_05619", "source_line": 362, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 856, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives emerging phenomenological_parameterization model; production via mirror-sector population linked to visible-sector criteria; dark plasma recombination into dark atoms; CMB relevance high and BBN relevance medium; linear structure effect suppression with transfer shape scale_dependent_growth; thermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2402_13924_r_symmetric_gut_higgs_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_13924", "source_line": 5954, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 857, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from primordial_black_holes: R-symmetric GUT Higgs inflation PBH dark matter has moderate observational leverage, high model/theory value through ultra-slow-roll enhancement of the primordial scalar curvature power spectrum, radiation-era gravitational collapse of enhanced perturbations into primordial black holes; inferred probe classes are CMB, compact_objects, gravitational_waves.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_00669_nonrelativistic_axion_eft_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1604_00669", "source_line": 2783, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 80, "global_rank": 858, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: canonical effective_field_theory in axion_like_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: vacuum misalignment mechanism; cosmic string decay mechanism; portals: axion; CMB relevance is medium; phase-space type is field_like.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5851_post_inflation_string_wall_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5851", "source_line": 1505, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 81, "global_rank": 859, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: canonical status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, and field like phase-space treatment.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_13269_scale_invariant_vector_fimp_prebbn_v1", "paper_id": "2203_13269", "source_line": 5108, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 860, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for its fast pre-BBN freeze-in cosmology and high BBN relevance; the lack of structure predictions and a high nonstandard-history warning suppress the score."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_scalar_coannihilation", "model_id": "2111_01164_pure_scalar_inelastic_coannihilation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_01164", "source_line": 4946, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 861, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Pure-scalar inelastic coannihilation dark matter model is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance, diversity.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_07462_hidden_axion_saxion_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2304_07462", "source_line": 5635, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 82, "global_rank": 862, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because hidden axion production from saxion decay with decay-produced phase space and small-scale suppression.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_00730_cosine_self_interacting_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_00730", "source_line": 348, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 863, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, small-scale power effect is suppression, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth, phase-space type is field_like.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:variant_not_generic_quartic, medium:initial_abundance_assumed.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 10/9/5/0/9/6/14."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_07726_higgs_parity_mirror_electron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_07726", "source_line": 3770, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 864, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 25 because the card identifies production via non-thermal production from inflaton or other energy-dominating par..., thermal freeze-out considered but rejected for the viable abundance, nonthermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: direct detection, small-scale structure; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2404_06506_false_vacuum_island_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2404_06506", "source_line": 6037, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 865, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because false-vacuum-island PBHs are distinctive and gravitational-wave relevant, but the card is deliberately model-independent with little implementation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_moduli_cosmology", "model_id": "2308_15380_complex_scalar_wimp_from_modulus_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2308_15380", "source_line": 5779, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 866, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Complex scalar WIMP from modulus-dominated nonstandard cosmology has some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include BBN, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "branon_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0411076_low_tension_branon_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0411076", "source_line": 503, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 867, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Low-tension brane-world branon WIMP dark matter is a speculative effective field theory card with either relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (mixed cold warm; small-scale effect mixed); it touches cmb, galaxy satellites, indirect detection, lyman-alpha forest; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_15380_bino_neutralino_modulus_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_15380", "source_line": 5780, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 868, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Bino-like neutralino dark matter from modulus decay in the MSSM has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: severe_branching_requirement."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_00016_fermionic_invisible_zprime_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1806_00016", "source_line": 3525, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 869, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has nonthermal phase-space production; it touches collider / fixed-target, gravitational waves / defects, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1805_03639_sound_speed_resonance_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "1805_03639", "source_line": 3501, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 870, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it touches compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0509257_intermediate_pgb_partial_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509257", "source_line": 545, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "The card frames the candidate as a subcomponent or not able to produce all dark matter."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 871, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 13.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Intermediate-mass pseudo-Goldstone boson partial dark matter is a speculative effective field theory card with subcomponent relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (field like; small-scale effect suppression); it touches cmb, galaxy satellites, lyman-alpha forest; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_6256_goldstone_remnant_z2_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_6256", "source_line": 1948, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 872, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 25.0 because the model card is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; medium BBN and high CMB relevance and touches BBN, CMB, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2405_06882_bounce_generated_primordial_black_holes_v1", "paper_id": "2405_06882", "source_line": 6048, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 873, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because bounce-generated PBHs provide a distinctive EFT cosmology with PBH and CMB/GW relevance, but observational windows and public implementation are not encoded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9908515_extra_dimensional_axion_kk_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9908515", "source_line": 6133, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 83, "global_rank": 874, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 25 (defer) from supplied card content: axion_like_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; decay_produced phase-space behavior; cosmological relevance: CMB high, BBN high.", "Penalties (17) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_01962_dark_z_fermionic_dm_extra_higgs_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "2311_01962", "source_line": 5886, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 875, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the UV-complete dark-Z fermion model is viable and complementary across vector/Higgs portals, but it is CDM-like and lacks encoded constraints, routes, or public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_04304_u1_emu_dirac_leptophilic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_04304", "source_line": 4261, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 876, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative leptophilic_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support, production via thermal freeze-out through Zprime-mediated annihilation; Breit-Wigner enhanced annihilation near the Zprime pole.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlino_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5244_snmssm_singlino_lsp_benchmark_lines_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5244", "source_line": 1523, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 877, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: benchmark status, benchmark mapping theory level, and singlino neutralino dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_11072_conformal_bl_pseudo_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_11072", "source_line": 5564, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 878, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the conformal B-L pseudo-Goldstone model is a rare UV-motivated full-DM scenario, but observational extension is held back by missing observable, constraint, and computation fields.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_01772_adjoint_su5_ksvz_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1908_01772", "source_line": 3966, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 84, "global_rank": 879, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Adjoint SU(5) KSVZ QCD axion: strong model-card science motivation; inferred probe classes are CMB, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 25 (defer) uses production=pre-inflationary PQ breaking; axion field misalignment saturating the dark matter relic abundance; phase=field_like; CMB=medium, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_02337_susy_422_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_02337", "source_line": 6035, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 880, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the SUSY 4-2-2 neutralino scenario connects relic density to LFV, muon g-2, and collider spectra, but it is a common neutralino family with sparse implementation detail."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1102_0492_supersymmetric_leptophilic_higgs_singlino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1102_0492", "source_line": 1212, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 881, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family supersymmetric_leptophilic_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out via s-channel light pseudoscalar exchange.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_5908_u1h_superheavy_wimpzilla_dark_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1410_5908", "source_line": 2282, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 882, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative superheavy_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and nonthermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_00490_z4_singlet_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_00490", "source_line": 3549, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 883, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_00417_u1x_remnant_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_00417", "source_line": 5539, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 884, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2212_00775_spinning_pbh_evaporation_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_00775", "source_line": 5406, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Follow-up is plausible, but absent observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes keep it below tier 3."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 885, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful but still limited: spinning PBH evaporation gives BBN, CMB, nonthermal phase-space, and compact-object probe hooks, with FRISBHEE/BlackHawk code context, but no explicit constraints or routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11332_su2d_two_component_chiral_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11332", "source_line": 4109, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 886, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 25.0: speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, direct detection.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dynamical_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_11021_ddm_mathusla_toy_ensemble_v1", "paper_id": "1809_11021", "source_line": 3623, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 887, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as benchmark dynamical_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, high CMB relevance, mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_17212_anomaly_free_axion_3hdm_bl_v1", "paper_id": "2203_17212", "source_line": 5132, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 85, "global_rank": 888, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a UV-complete anomaly-free axion/3HDM/B-L model with strong explanatory motivation, but CDM-like structure and missing observable routing make follow-up value moderate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_02921_cgut_inert_dark_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2004_02921", "source_line": 4221, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 889, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include early-universe production connection, larger-framework connection; nonthermal phase-space information; high or critical BBN relevance; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_1306_preheating_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1002_1306", "source_line": 1103, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 890, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in decaying_scalar_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, field-like phase space, suppression small-scale-power effect, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_05684_millicharged_subcomponent_massless_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2305_05684", "source_line": 5625, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 891, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because millicharged subcomponent with high CMB/BBN relevance and strong probe complementarity despite not supplying all DM.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "accident_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_10092_su3_tenplet_accident_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2307_10092", "source_line": 5775, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 892, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because SU(3) x U(1) ten-plet accident dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include BBN, CMB/cosmic-dawn, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_02740_extended_ma_inert_scalar_preheating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_02740", "source_line": 3094, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 893, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative scotogenic_inert_scalar_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium; inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_12353_gauged_b_l_decaying_majoron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_12353", "source_line": 5157, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 894, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-to-mid observational value: decaying Majoron subcomponent has high CMB relevance and dark-radiation/decay complementarity, but notation and routing gaps keep it below tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_axion_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_00443_landscape_susy_axion_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1905_00443", "source_line": 3851, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 895, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A gravity-safe SUSY DFSZ axion construction in which axions and a higgsino-like neutralino jointly make the dark matter abundance, with the Peccei-Quinn scale scanned in a string-landscape setting.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: mixed relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN medium; CMB medium; phase-space unknown; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_00866_as_sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2204_00866", "source_line": 5103, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 896, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 10, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a UV-complete asymptotic-safety freeze-in sterile-neutrino setup with target relic abundance and strong provenance; observable routing is sparse, so follow-up value is moderate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mimetic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_12161_miteves_noether_current_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_12161", "source_line": 4786, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 897, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative mimetic_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: Noether-current cosmological integration constant; background scalar-vector dynamics.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, not_applicable phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_12278_dark_charge_z4_two_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_12278", "source_line": 4796, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 898, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: thermal annihilation through the Z prime portal; dark-sector self-annihilation and conversion between the two components.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, mixed_cold_warm phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_3540_higgs_philic_u1_sneutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0906_3540", "source_line": 970, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 899, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, CMB, direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_06893_super_natural_mssm_nonthermal_axino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1502_06893", "source_line": 2410, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 900, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a supersymmetric_axino_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is decay_produced; cosmological relevance is CMB=unknown, BBN=critical.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_03762_cp_odd_sneutrino_nmssm_type_i_seesaw_v1", "paper_id": "1807_03762", "source_line": 3529, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 901, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 7, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a UV-complete model card; it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_1731_luminogenesis_inflationary_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1411_1731", "source_line": 2308, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 902, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 25 because the assigned model card uv complete hidden_sector_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; touches BBN, CMB, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_6632_self_interacting_boosted_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_6632", "source_line": 2329, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 903, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 25 because the assigned model card simplified model multi_component_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; uses mixed cold warm phase-space information; touches direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection, laboratory precision / fifth-force searches.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_2219_reannihilating_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1104_2219", "source_line": 1400, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 904, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal production of heavy DFSZ axinos; phase-space is nonthermal; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, cosmological phase-space, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_13337_large_extra_dimension_kk_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_13337", "source_line": 4794, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 86, "global_rank": 905, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 9, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and production logic from: solar Primakoff production; photon coalescence in the solar plasma.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space distribution.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "left_right_symmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_02343_dlrm_right_fermion_quintuplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_02343", "source_line": 4250, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 906, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection, structure or tension connection; high CMB relevance; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: BBN, CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2108_01340_gauss_bonnet_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2108_01340", "source_line": 4763, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 907, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: inflationary enhancement of curvature perturbations; horizon reentry and gravitational collapse.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance, not_applicable phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_wimp_inflation", "model_id": "1007_1672_wimp_dark_matter_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "1007_1672", "source_line": 1180, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 908, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 25 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, distinctive or underrepresented model-space coverage, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_0898_a4_majoron_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1007_0898", "source_line": 1172, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 909, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 25 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, high scientific motivation from its theory setting and relic mechanism, distinctive or underrepresented model-space coverage, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2305_14399_dark_fopt_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_14399", "source_line": 5605, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 910, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because dark first-order-transition PBH formation with CMB/BBN and gravitational-wave-style complementarity, but little detailed routing.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_massive_particle", "model_id": "1501_01973_u1dm_z3_scalar_simp_v1", "paper_id": "1501_01973", "source_line": 2326, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 911, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 25 because the assigned model card simplified model strongly_interacting_massive_particle card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; touches CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_04196_qyu_422_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1503_04196", "source_line": 2424, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 912, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked yes; cosmological relevance is CMB=medium, BBN=unknown; feasibility support scores 1 from code or analytic representation fields.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonabelian_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_11863_su2x_nonabelian_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_11863", "source_line": 4785, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 913, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative nonabelian_vector_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: standard thermal freeze-out; co-annihilation with dark-charge fermions.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_01687_dark_linear_seesaw_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_01687", "source_line": 5623, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 25, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 914, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 10, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because UV-complete dark linear-seesaw scalar dark matter with rich theory motivation and partial code support.", "Score is still held down by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points despite limited code support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 25, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_05678_cool_atomic_dark_matter_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2311_05678", "source_line": 5850, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card.", "Relic-density follow-up value is reduced because the card does not support a full-DM regime or leaves it unknown."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 915, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is dark recombination of dark protons and dark electrons into neutral dark atoms.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, direct/collider, small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, suppression) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0004332_cosh_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0004332", "source_line": 52, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 916, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 85.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this ultralight_scalar_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, suppression in small-scale power, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2402_14069_memory_burden_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_14069", "source_line": 5982, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 917, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from primordial_black_holes: Memory-burden primordial black hole dark matter has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through primordial black hole formation from primordial fluctuations with survival enabled by memory-burden-suppressed evaporation; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, compact_objects.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_11862_fermion_moduli_portal_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1911_11862", "source_line": 4062, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 24.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 918, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: gravitational waves.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_16087_ksvz_axion_dgt5_q_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2310_16087", "source_line": 5847, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 87, "global_rank": 919, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is axion misalignment after post-inflationary PQ breaking.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, axion laboratory, gravitational waves/defects, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (field_like, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_11844_heavy_zprime_freeze_in_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "1911_11844", "source_line": 4070, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 24.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 920, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_3996_frozen_in_scalar_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1306_3996", "source_line": 1840, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 921, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a emerging sterile_neutrino_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is decay_produced; small-scale power effect is suppression; transfer function is smooth_cutoff; BBN relevance is medium.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on BBN, small-scale structure and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_08821_hidden_sector_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1912_08821", "source_line": 4090, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 24.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 922, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 10, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_00305_plateau_string_axion_ula_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_00305", "source_line": 3333, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 923, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory model with parameter dependent relic-density support, field like phase-space behavior, mixed in small-scale power, 2 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "parallel_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_2543_parallel_universe_dark_atoms_v1", "paper_id": "1311_2543", "source_line": 1987, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 924, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, laboratory/collider/direct; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_06473_brickred_axion_neutrino_mediators_v1", "paper_id": "2309_06473", "source_line": 5825, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 88, "global_rank": 925, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative uv_complete model; the main production handle is nonthermal axion misalignment mechanism.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, axion laboratory, gravitational waves/defects, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (field_like, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electromagnetic_form_factor_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_0503_anapole_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1211_0503", "source_line": 1698, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 926, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out through p-wave annihilation to Standard Model fermions, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 24.5 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=low and CMB=medium; card-implied probe classes include CMB, direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_08272_scalar_condensate_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2310_08272", "source_line": 5875, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 927, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the condensate-plus-freeze-in scalar has a useful mixed cold-warm phase-space handle, but it is a toy/simplified construction without explicit observational constraints or routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_08425_axiverse_early_collapse_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_08425", "source_line": 5895, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 89, "global_rank": 928, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the axiverse early-collapse loophole is UV-motivated and diverse, but string-network collapse dynamics are analytic/uncalibrated and no explicit observables or routes are encoded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_17710_pq_inflation_axion_kinetic_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "2310_17710", "source_line": 5849, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 90, "global_rank": 929, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is nonthermal axion kinetic misalignment from initial PQ charge.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, axion laboratory, direct/collider, gravitational waves/defects, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (field_like, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter_with_entropy_production", "model_id": "1008_1740_saxion_diluted_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1740", "source_line": 1162, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 930, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 24.5 because the supplied card has some cosmology, phase-space, or structure signal, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, distinctive or underrepresented model-space coverage, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_07642_chiral_composite_adm_nf2_v1", "paper_id": "2105_07642", "source_line": 4757, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 931, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: asymmetric dark matter; dark baryon-antibaryon annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_07642_chiral_composite_adm_nf3_bl_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2105_07642", "source_line": 4758, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 932, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: asymmetric dark matter through B-L portal transfer; dark baryon annihilation of symmetric component.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dirac_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_13397_local_b_l_dirac_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2103_13397", "source_line": 4626, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 933, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative asymmetric dirac dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_15565_scalar_self_interacting_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_15565", "source_line": 5746, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 934, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Scalar-mediated self-interacting sterile neutrino dark matter is a speculative simplified_model card with yes relic-abundance support and suppression of small-scale power, nonthermal phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 10.0, observational 8.0, complementarity 8.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 3.2, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_10563_conformal_freeze_in_composite_dark_pion_v1", "paper_id": "2209_10563", "source_line": 5374, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 935, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Conformal freeze-in composite dark-pion dark matter has notable cosmology, phase-space, or small-scale-structure leverage, probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_07951_kinetic_mixing_cosmic_millicharged_background_v1", "paper_id": "2308_07951", "source_line": 5740, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 936, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Kinetic-mixing cosmic millicharged-particle background with dark photon is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 9.0, observational 6.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.2, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_1109_dodelson_widrow_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_1109", "source_line": 1953, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 937, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: small-scale structure; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_1109_msm_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_1109", "source_line": 1955, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 938, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: small-scale structure; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_1109_shi_fuller_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_1109", "source_line": 1954, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 939, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: small-scale structure; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2402_04158_slow_fopt_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2402_04158", "source_line": 5989, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 940, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from primordial_black_holes: Primordial black hole dark matter from slow supercooled first-order phase transitions has moderate observational leverage through large inhomogeneities from slow supercooled first-order phase transitions, collapse of overdense patches at horizon re-entry, critical collapse scaling for PBH masses; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, compact_objects, gravitational_waves, indirect_detection, small_scale_structure.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11708_model_a_prime_vector_mediator_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11708", "source_line": 4135, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 941, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 24: speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonlinear structure-formation effect; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11708_model_a_scalar_mediator_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11708", "source_line": 4136, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 942, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 24: speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonlinear structure-formation effect; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11708_model_b_prime_vector_mediator_extra_scalar_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11708", "source_line": 4137, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 943, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 24: speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonlinear structure-formation effect; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11708_model_b_scalar_mediator_extra_scalar_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11708", "source_line": 4138, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 944, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 24: speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonlinear structure-formation effect; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11708_model_c_pwave_scalar_mediator_decay_chain_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11708", "source_line": 4139, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 945, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 24: speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonlinear structure-formation effect; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11708_model_d_stable_vector_mediator_scalar_annihilation_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11708", "source_line": 4140, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 946, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 24: speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonlinear structure-formation effect; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_10148_decaying_superheavy_dm_icecube_baryogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1911_10148", "source_line": 4069, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 24.0 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 947, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative decaying_superheavy_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization structure and relic reach 'unknown'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_08820_emergent_strong_cp_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_08820", "source_line": 3866, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 948, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 13.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / effective_field_theory: Light massive vector dark matter whose net spin density couples to the QCD G G tilde operator, making strong-CP cancellation an environmental effect of the dark-matter background.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, unknown, production reach unknown; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space field_like; transfer function smooth_cutoff; small-scale power suppression.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: do_not_treat_as_qcd_axion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_00017_nucleon_coupled_boson_star_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_00017", "source_line": 5269, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 949, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Nucleon-coupled boson star dark matter: speculative status, phenomenological-parameterization theory level, and production via formation of compact boson-star structures from light bosonic dark matter during structure formation, field-like phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, direct detection), family/diversity context for hidden_sector_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_08863_scalar_inelastic_crdm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_08863", "source_line": 4913, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 950, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Scalar inelastic cosmic-ray-accelerated dark matter is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by nonthermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: observational leverage, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 1-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0607012_warm_neutralino_low_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0607012", "source_line": 622, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 951, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has strong card-level observational leverage from cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation fields, high diversity value within the population-count context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1912_01653_pbh_stiff_kination_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "1912_01653", "source_line": 4126, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 952, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 24: speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: critical BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior, compact-object/PBH phenomenology; inferred probe classes: BBN, compact objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_00670_spontaneous_baryogenesis_scalar_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_00670", "source_line": 2859, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 953, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_field_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; high CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; field_like phase-space population.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_16078_scalar_boosted_dark_matter_semiannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2006_16078", "source_line": 4267, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 954, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative multi_component_boosted_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via thermal freeze-out through semi-annihilation of the dominant component; boosted subdominant component from local semi-annihilation, mixed_cold_warm phase-space treatment, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_05008_qcd_axion_dark_photon_depletion_v1", "paper_id": "1708_05008", "source_line": 3233, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 91, "global_rank": 955, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: QCD axion dark-photon depletion model is a speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, enhanced_small_scale_power transfer behavior with enhancement small-scale effect, CMB/BBN relevance high/high, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_07001_dirac_neutrino_portal_thermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_07001", "source_line": 3214, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 956, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Thermal dark matter through the Dirac neutrino portal is a speculative neutrino_portal_thermal_dark_matter card with smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale effect, CMB/BBN relevance high/high, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1903_09598_thermal_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_09598", "source_line": 3796, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 957, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 24 because the card identifies production via collapse of enhanced curvature perturbations generated at the end o..., critical collapse at horizon re-entry, not_applicable phase-space treatment, probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact-object or macroscopic probes, direct detection; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_cosmology_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_01056_kination_nonequilibrium_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_01056", "source_line": 3087, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 958, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative nonstandard_cosmology_dark_matter entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance critical, CMB relevance medium, distinct phase space nonthermal; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, indirect detection, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0412304_low_reheating_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0412304", "source_line": 504, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization.", "The card frames the candidate as a subcomponent or not able to produce all dark matter."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 959, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Low-reheating visible sterile-neutrino hot dark matter subcomponent is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card with subcomponent relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (nonthermal; small-scale effect suppression); it touches bbn, cmb, direct detection, galaxy satellites; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_03932_alp_mediated_fermion_freeze_in_dfo_v1", "paper_id": "2209_03932", "source_line": 5274, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 960, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for ALP-mediated fermion dark matter with freeze-in and decoupled freeze-out: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via direct freeze-in from Standard Model fermion scattering through an off-shell ALP; freeze-in from ALP scattering, nonthermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, indirect detection, weak lensing / large-scale structure), family/diversity context for freeze_in_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_6382_effective_a4_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_6382", "source_line": 1468, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 961, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card describes speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter, effective field theory theory framing, medium CMB and medium BBN relevance, suppression small-scale effect with smooth cutoff transfer behavior, nonthermal phase-space history, with production via sterile-neutrino production by active-sterile oscillations used as guideline.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0204307_scalar_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0204307", "source_line": 19, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 962, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, medium CMB relevance and medium BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space description, some computational or code support; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_11822_alp_photon_dark_photon_depletion_v1", "paper_id": "2401_11822", "source_line": 5986, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 92, "global_rank": 963, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from axion_like_dark_matter: ALP dark matter with photon-dark-photon gauge-field depletion has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through misalignment production, post-inflationary inhomogeneous axion field from strings and domain walls, resonant transfer of ALP energy to photon and dark-photon fields; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, gravitational_waves.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1906_04858_primordial_extremal_black_hole_dark_electromagnetism_v1", "paper_id": "1906_04858", "source_line": 3899, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 964, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: A model in which primordial near-extremal Reissner-Nordstrom black holes charged under a dark U(1) survive as dark matter because Hawking evaporation and Schwinger discharge are suppressed.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, either, production reach yes; BBN high; CMB medium; phase-space not_applicable; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: formation_uncertainty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_10135_colored_mediator_freezein_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "1809_10135", "source_line": 3609, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 965, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, decay_produced phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_02116_ultralight_axion_instanton_fuzzy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_02116", "source_line": 3031, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 966, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ultralight axion fuzzy dark matter with instanton potential and temperature-dependent mass is ranked because it can produce the full dark-matter abundance in the card; has strong cosmological or small-scale-structure leverage; uses a field-like phase-space history; modifies small-scale power; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_03404_mirrored_gut_composite_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_03404", "source_line": 3944, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 967, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to BBN, CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_11222_post_recombination_superheavy_scalar_graviton_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2304_11222", "source_line": 5596, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 968, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: post-recombination decay to gravitons is rare and observationally distinctive, but the parent production is assumed and high-severity decay-channel caveats reduce priority.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_01418_self_interacting_bosonic_dm_core_v1", "paper_id": "1804_01418", "source_line": 3452, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after missing observational-detail and routing penalties."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 969, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.5, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer ranking for Self-interacting bosonic dark matter core in neutron stars: the supplied card gives a phenomenological parameterization self interacting dark matter model with self interacting dark matter phenomenology and probe relevance through BBN, CMB, compact objects / dynamics, galaxy satellites / halo structure; large penalties come from missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_08750_submev_scalar_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_08750", "source_line": 3075, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 970, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance high, CMB relevance high; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_4030_two_component_conversion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1112_4030", "source_line": 1542, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 971, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and multi component dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_03909_decaying_alp_dm_direct_collapse_v1", "paper_id": "2404_03909", "source_line": 6013, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 972, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 9, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because decaying ALP dark matter has distinctive high-redshift photon-injection leverage, but the row is phenomenological and lacks code, constraints, and routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boson_star_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_04690_string_moduli_star_compact_object_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_04690", "source_line": 3515, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 973, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has field_like phase-space production; it touches compact objects / dynamics, gravitational waves / defects, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_5431_kev_sterile_neutrino_warm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_5431", "source_line": 762, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 974, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 24.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance medium, small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type nonthermal; probe classes counted: ['CMB', 'halo/subhalo abundance', 'small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_01327_axionlike_dark_matter_electroweak_cogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2111_01327", "source_line": 4910, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 93, "global_rank": 975, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Axionlike dark matter electroweak cogenesis model is speculative with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by field_like phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_09106_massless_dark_photon_composite_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_09106", "source_line": 3605, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 976, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, high CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_04809_alp_cogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2006_04809", "source_line": 4265, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 94, "global_rank": 977, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 84.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via kinetic misalignment of a rotating ALP condensate; weak-scale ALP baryogenesis through electroweak anomaly, field_like phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_04453_hidden_sector_dark_fermion_hubble_tension_v1", "paper_id": "2202_04453", "source_line": 5054, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 978, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 24 (defer) as a speculative simplified_model member of hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; clear cosmological or phase-space leverage; multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, direct/lab.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: tension/anomaly, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: freeze-in-like population of a colder hidden sector through feeble kinetic mixing; dark-sector freeze-out of D after hidden-sector reactions become inefficient."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_05443_x_portal_vector_mev_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1608_05443", "source_line": 2871, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 979, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; 3 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_1883_r_invariant_new_inflation_gmsb_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_1883", "source_line": 719, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 980, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal phase-space history; BBN high and CMB high relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, gravitational/cosmology.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_08399_extra_modulus_diluted_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_08399", "source_line": 2779, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 981, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in supersymmetric_nonthermal_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: nonthermal LSP production from gravitino decay; entropy dilution by late extra-modulus decay; portals: gravitational, other; BBN relevance is critical; phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_05680_axion_pbh_dressed_minihalos_v1", "paper_id": "2102_05680", "source_line": 4584, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 982, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=medium and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03329_nonthermal_sterile_hot_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03329", "source_line": 4677, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 983, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and relic production no; high CMB relevance; decay_produced phase space; suppression of small-scale power.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_3470_chilled_sterile_neutrino_equilibrium_decay_v1", "paper_id": "0801_3470", "source_line": 774, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 984, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability yes, raw score 24.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance low, small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type decay_produced; probe classes counted: ['halo/subhalo abundance', 'small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_pbh_evaporation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_1909_pbh_evaporation_hidden_sector_dm_cogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1401_1909", "source_line": 2038, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 985, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=nonthermal, and structure effect=suppression/smooth_cutoff.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, structure formation, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_07779_lvs_string_ultralight_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1703_07779", "source_line": 3043, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 986, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Large Volume Scenario string ultralight axion is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has strong cosmological or small-scale-structure leverage; uses a field-like phase-space history; modifies small-scale power; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_00644_alp_mediated_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_00644", "source_line": 5523, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 987, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides CMB/BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_13061_low_reheating_higgs_portal_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2306_13061", "source_line": 5670, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 988, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Low-reheating Higgs-portal freeze-in dark matter at stronger coupling (freeze_in_dark_matter) has nonthermal phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, higgs portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 24.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_2699_asymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1201_2699", "source_line": 1545, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 989, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and asymmetric dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, direct detection, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2203_15605_multifield_sharp_turn_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_15605", "source_line": 5136, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 990, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for inflationary PBH production and induced-gravitational-wave complementarity, but abundance sensitivity, low robustness, and missing constraints lower the score."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_1312_vib_muon_philic_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1203_1312", "source_line": 1548, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 991, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and leptophilic dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_1312_vib_tau_philic_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1203_1312", "source_line": 1549, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 992, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and leptophilic dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_06039_linear_nonminimal_inflaton_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_06039", "source_line": 5818, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 993, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is nonthermal production from perturbative inflaton condensate decay.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (decay_produced, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_05619_asynchronous_mirror_atomic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2403_05619", "source_line": 363, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 994, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives emerging phenomenological_parameterization model; production via mirror-sector population linked to visible-sector criteria; asynchronous dark recombination into dark atoms; CMB relevance high and BBN relevance medium; linear structure effect suppression with transfer shape scale_dependent_growth; thermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_08815_interacting_scalar_field_dm_ede_v1", "paper_id": "2402_08815", "source_line": 213, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 995, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a emerging fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=smooth_cutoff, small_scale_power_effect=mixed, and probe classes: CMB, structure formation.", "Feasibility receives limited credit for associated_code=yes; shard-level ranks are left null for the parent aggregator."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_07602_two_component_ultralight_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_07602", "source_line": 44, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 996, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a emerging phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, mixed small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space description, some computational or code support; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_scalar_coannihilation", "model_id": "2111_01164_scalar_vector_inelastic_coannihilation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_01164", "source_line": 4947, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 997, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Scalar-vector inelastic coannihilation dark matter model is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance, diversity.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 1-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_07906_tiny_split_mirror_baryon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_07906", "source_line": 3507, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 998, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_00372_dark_u1d_breit_wigner_leptophilic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_00372", "source_line": 3400, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 999, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative leptophilic_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Associated-code field is partial, improving implementation feasibility."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_0553_decaying_scalar_cdm_dark_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1205_0553", "source_line": 1611, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 1000, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization card for Decaying scalar CDM to dark radiation; it offers field like phase-space behavior; CMB/BBN relevance with BBN, CMB, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_11556_dark_loops_model_3_scalar_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_11556", "source_line": 5260, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1001, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Dark Loops Model 3 scalar-doublet dark matter: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out with annihilation and coannihilation, thermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for scalar_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_11556_dark_loops_model_5_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_11556", "source_line": 5261, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1002, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Dark Loops Model 5 scalar-singlet dark matter: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out with annihilation and coannihilation, thermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for scalar_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_03863_nmssm_singlino_dm_benchmarks_v1", "paper_id": "2209_03863", "source_line": 5283, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1003, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for NMSSM singlino dark matter benchmark regions: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via thermal neutralino relic abundance; resonant annihilation through Z or Higgs bosons, thermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for supersymmetric_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2205_06065_axion_monodromy_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2205_06065", "source_line": 218, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 1004, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with uv_complete; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=medium, transfer_function=enhanced_small_scale_power, small_scale_power_effect=enhancement, and probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamical.", "Feasibility receives limited credit for associated_code=partial; shard-level ranks are left null for the parent aggregator.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: illustrative_not_viable."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_2839_anomalous_u1_supersymmetric_radiative_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1011_2839", "source_line": 1207, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 1005, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family multi_component_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out of neutralino component; thermal freeze-out of N_1 with N_2 coannihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1685_zee_babu_u1bl_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1685", "source_line": 1684, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 1006, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out with annihilation to Goldstone bosons and charged-scalar channels; resonant gamma-gamma annihilation through the dark scalar H2, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 24 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=medium and CMB=medium; card-implied probe classes include BBN, CMB, collider, direct detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_10311_anomaly_free_alp_inflaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_10311", "source_line": 4398, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 95, "global_rank": 1007, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Anomaly-free ALP inflaton dark matter for the XENON1T excess: coherent ALP inflaton oscillations after inflation; strong cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage, good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, laboratory/direct and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_06242_planck_suppressed_higgs_oscillating_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1603_06242", "source_line": 2781, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1008, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative effective_field_theory in scalar_field_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: inflationary displacement from quasi-de Sitter fluctuations; coherent post-electroweak scalar oscillations; portals: higgs, gravitational; CMB relevance is high; phase-space type is field_like.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_06242_rs_bulk_scalar_higgs_oscillating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_06242", "source_line": 2782, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1009, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in scalar_field_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: inflationary displacement of the zero-mode; post-electroweak coherent scalar oscillations; portals: higgs; CMB relevance is high; phase-space type is field_like.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_wimp_depopulation", "model_id": "1712_05170_phase_transition_depopulated_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_05170", "source_line": 3373, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1010, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative thermal_wimp_depopulation card with simplified model theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, galaxy/halo structure.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_05290_su5_u1x_zprime_portal_rhn_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_05290", "source_line": 3396, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1011, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_04729_hidden_u1h_bosonic_h2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_04729", "source_line": 3377, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1012, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0512172_negative_m0_gravitino_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0512172", "source_line": 636, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1013, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has strong card-level observational leverage from cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation fields, high diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_14922_z5_two_component_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_14922", "source_line": 4290, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 1014, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via thermal freeze-out; annihilation.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05349_ethos_4_benchmark_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05349", "source_line": 301, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 1015, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=benchmark_mapping, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, small-scale power effect is suppression, transfer function shape is oscillatory, nonlinear halo or subhalo effect is stated.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=partial; warnings=medium:benchmark_mapping_only.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 10/8/5/1/9/2/11."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_07841_z2_fermion_dm_majorana_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1609_07841", "source_line": 2897, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1016, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative secluded_wimp_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium BBN relevance; 2 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by penalties from sparse observables, constraints, and routing; associated code is marked partial."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_07841_z2_fermion_dm_pseudo_dirac_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1609_07841", "source_line": 2898, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1017, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative secluded_wimp_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium BBN relevance; 2 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by penalties from sparse observables, constraints, and routing; associated code is marked partial."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_07462_q_ball_decay_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_07462", "source_line": 5636, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 1018, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because Q-ball decay scalar dark matter with multi-component decay-produced phase space and small-scale suppression.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_05771_warm_inflation_pq_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_05771", "source_line": 4720, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 96, "global_rank": 1019, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via misalignment after the QCD phase transition; PQ phase transition during warm inflation sets small-scale axion fluctuations.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB, structure formation; the raw score is 24 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_baryon_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_12712_dark_baryon_scalar_mediator_m1_v1", "paper_id": "2111_12712", "source_line": 4932, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1020, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Dark baryon model with right-handed scalar mediator Model 1 is speculative with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by unknown phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, galaxy satellites.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance, diversity.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_10524_interacting_scalar_field_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_10524", "source_line": 6053, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1021, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 24.0: speculative effective field theory model in interacting_scalar_field_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as unknown.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: small-scale structure; phase space is field like; small-scale power effect is suppression.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is partial and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_07324_multi_waterfall_hybrid_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_07324", "source_line": 5672, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 1022, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Multi-waterfall hybrid-inflation primordial black-hole dark matter (primordial_black_holes) has CMB/BBN relevance, gravitational portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 24.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2307_03078_curvaton_asteroid_mass_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_03078", "source_line": 5683, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 1023, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Asteroid-mass primordial black-hole dark matter from a quadratic curvaton with vanishing mean (primordial_black_holes) has CMB/BBN relevance, gravitational portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 24.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_08508_alternative_u1x_dirac_rh_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_08508", "source_line": 5070, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1024, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 24 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through X-mediated annihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_01804_low_reheat_hidden_glueball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1704_01804", "source_line": 3012, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 1025, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Hidden-sector glueball dark matter in a late-modulus low-reheat cosmology is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has some cosmological, phase-space, or halo-structure leverage; uses a nonthermal phase-space history; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_02347_cosmic_selection_rule_glueball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1704_02347", "source_line": 3013, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 1026, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Cosmic-selection-rule SU(N)d glueball dark matter is ranked because it can produce the full dark-matter abundance in the card; has some cosmological, phase-space, or halo-structure leverage; uses a nonthermal phase-space history; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9804291_hadronic_axion_hot_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9804291", "source_line": 6100, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 97, "global_rank": 1027, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 24.0: speculative uv complete model in axion_like_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as no.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, indirect detection, small-scale structure; phase space is thermal; small-scale power effect is suppression.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_inflaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "0708_3983_bl_rh_sneutrino_inflaton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0708_3983", "source_line": 718, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1028, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked yes; BBN medium and CMB high relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "z3_scalar_3to2_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_05412_heavy_majoron_3to2_z3_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_05412", "source_line": 5051, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1029, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 24 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of z3_scalar_3to2_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, structure/dynamics, direct/lab.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, structure/self-interaction.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through three-to-two dark matter annihilations in the heavy-Majoron regime."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "continuum_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_13009_near_continuum_z_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2306_13009", "source_line": 5669, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1030, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Near-continuum Z-portal dark matter (continuum_dark_matter) has vector, gravitational portal coverage, high diversity value in the population context, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields. Raw score 24.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_3297_amsb_axino_lsp_axion_axino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1004_3297", "source_line": 1125, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 1031, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in multi_component_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by mixed-cold-warm phase space, mixed small-scale-power effect, mixed-cold-warm transfer-function shape, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_5105_secluded_u1_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1012_5105", "source_line": 1230, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 1032, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production via thermal neutralino freeze-out computed with micrOMEGAs for benchmark spectra.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_0835_fsu5_nonuniversal_higgs_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1101_0835", "source_line": 1211, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 1033, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out; coannihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_0835_fsu5_uh_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1101_0835", "source_line": 1210, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 1034, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out; coannihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "stable_higgs_dark_matter", "model_id": "1010_6135_h_parity_stable_higgs_gauge_higgs_unification_v1", "paper_id": "1010_6135", "source_line": 1205, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1035, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family stable_higgs_dark_matter with production via thermal cold relic abundance of stable H-parity-odd Higgs bosons.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "split_supersymmetry_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_0555_mini_split_neutralino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_0555", "source_line": 1657, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1036, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out of a wino or higgsino-like neutralino LSP; possible mixed dark matter with an axion component for lighter wino spectra, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 24 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=medium and CMB=unknown; card-implied probe classes include BBN, collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_04311_z2_fermion_dark_u1_bound_states_v1", "paper_id": "1910_04311", "source_line": 3992, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 1037, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Z2 fermion dark matter from broken local U(1) with bound states: strong model-card science motivation; inferred probe classes are BBN, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 24 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out; co-annihilation chi1 chi2 to A prime R; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=medium; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_09610_dfsz_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2302_09610", "source_line": 5582, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1038, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 83.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the DFSZ axion has strong theory motivation and broad axion complementarity, but the supplied card is CDM-like and lacks populated constraints, routes, and code.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_01091_model_i_final_bound_state_real_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_01091", "source_line": 5137, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1039, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for final-state bound-state thermal freeze-out in a real-scalar model; phase-space approximations help, while missing constraints/routing limit priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_01091_model_ii_final_bound_state_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_01091", "source_line": 5138, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1040, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked similarly to the real-scalar bound-state model, with complex-scalar p-wave dynamics but no structured observational or computational payload."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_03309_singlet_majoron_dm_extension_v1", "paper_id": "1807_03309", "source_line": 3522, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1041, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a simplified-model implementation; it touches CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_2253_pure_gravity_mediation_wino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1202_2253", "source_line": 1486, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1042, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out with neutral/charged wino coannihilation.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2304_10084_dark_fopt_fermi_ball_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_10084", "source_line": 5610, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 1043, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because FOPT Fermi-ball PBH formation with nonthermal phase-space content and broad probe complementarity.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_05214_kev_sterile_neutrino_secret_scalar_qi_v1", "paper_id": "2210_05214", "source_line": 5341, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 1044, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 24.0: sterile_neutrino_dark_matter with Dodelson-Widrow active-sterile oscillation in the presence of a new light scalar; science=15.0, observational leverage=5.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_10514_z2_z2_two_inert_doublet_3hdm_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_10514", "source_line": 5071, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 1045, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 24 (defer) as a speculative simplified_model member of multi_component_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: axion/strong-cp, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out with two-component annihilation, coannihilation, and conversion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_07345_fermion_uv_freeze_in_baryogenesis_emd_v1", "paper_id": "2304_07345", "source_line": 5617, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 1046, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because fermionic UV freeze-in linked to baryogenesis and early matter domination.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_07345_scalar_uv_freeze_in_baryogenesis_emd_v1", "paper_id": "2304_07345", "source_line": 5616, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 1047, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because scalar UV freeze-in linked to baryogenesis and early matter domination.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_6229_unbroken_u1x_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1310_6229", "source_line": 1905, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 1048, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 24.0 because the model card is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; nonlinear halo-structure relevance; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider, direct detection, halo dynamics, neutrino.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_5488_ezssm_bino_inelastic_upscattering_v1", "paper_id": "1201_5488", "source_line": 1481, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 1049, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out of a mostly bino LSP.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_06506_fermionic_dm_scalar_mediator_ewbg_v1", "paper_id": "1703_06506", "source_line": 3078, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1050, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance low; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_5243_gmsb_nmssm_light_heavy_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1008_5243", "source_line": 1178, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 1051, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 24 because the supplied card has some cosmology, phase-space, or structure signal, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_2399_hylogenesis_antibaryonic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1008_2399", "source_line": 1173, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 1052, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 24 because the supplied card has some cosmology, phase-space, or structure signal, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_06793_neutrino_portal_fimp_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_06793", "source_line": 5315, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 1053, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 24.0: freeze_in_dark_matter with freeze-in through feeble neutrino-portal scattering and decays; science=15.0, observational leverage=4.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics) and diversity=5.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_4601_majoronic_dark_radiation_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_4601", "source_line": 2221, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 1054, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete hidden_sector_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching CMB, collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_dirac_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_01960_resonant_pseudo_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_01960", "source_line": 5744, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1055, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Resonant pseudo-Dirac dark matter is a emerging simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 10.0, observational 4.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.0, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_axion_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_0692_cosmologically_stable_axino_codm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_0692", "source_line": 1394, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1056, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as supersymmetric_axion_gravitino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal scattering; phase-space is nonthermal; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, cosmological phase-space, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by effective_field_theory structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermion_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_06392_so10_fermion_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_06392", "source_line": 5112, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1057, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a UV-complete SO(10) electroweak-triplet relic candidate with partial calculation support; coannihilation sensitivity and absent observables/routing reduce extension priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2106_05637_phase_transition_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2106_05637", "source_line": 4754, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 1058, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated emerging primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: collapse of overdense Hubble volumes from delayed false-vacuum decay during first-order phase transitions.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, not_applicable phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_generated_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_04965_pbh_evaporation_gravitational_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_04965", "source_line": 5310, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1059, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 24.0: primordial_black_hole_generated_dark_matter with Hawking evaporation of primordial black holes; science=14.0, observational leverage=2.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves) and diversity=9.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_13401_scoto_seesaw_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2104_13401", "source_line": 4623, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1060, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a emerging scotogenic scalar dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; strong card-local scientific motivation; probe classes inferred from card fields include CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_02803_gauged_inverse_seesaw_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_02803", "source_line": 4798, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 24, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1061, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative scalar_singlet_wimp_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: thermal WIMP freeze-out from the Standard Model bath; 2-to-2 annihilation and coannihilation involving Higgs, scalar, gauge, and neutrino final states.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 24, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_06928_right_handed_neutrino_coupled_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2108_06928", "source_line": 4835, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.8, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1062, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, non-CDM structure information, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bound_state_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_11288_vector_mediated_bound_state_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1910_11288", "source_line": 4047, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1063, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative simplified_model; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_04322_nonminimal_ultralight_axion_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_04322", "source_line": 87, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 1064, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, mixed in small-scale power, scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_15533_sterile_neutrino_strong_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2403_15533", "source_line": 5998, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 1065, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from sterile_neutrino_dark_matter: Sterile neutrino freeze-in at stronger coupling has moderate observational leverage, high model/theory value through Boltzmann-suppressed freeze-in from the Standard Model thermal bath, scalar annihilation through singlet/Higgs portal; inferred probe classes are collider, direct_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "astro-ph0509141_clustered_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0509141", "source_line": 597, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 1066, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Clustered primordial black hole dark matter from radiation-era collapse is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card in family primordial_black_holes with production described as direct gravitational collapse of order-unity radiation-density perturbations at horizon entry during radiation domination.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space; enhancement of small-scale power; enhanced small scale power transfer behavior; probe classes: BBN, CMB, halo/subhalo structure, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2402_05179_supercooled_fopt_pbh_dm_magnetogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2402_05179", "source_line": 5981, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 1067, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from primordial_black_holes: Supercooled FOPT primordial black hole dark matter with magnetogenesis has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through collapse of late-nucleating overdense Hubble patches during a strongly supercooled first-order phase transition; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, compact_objects, gravitational_waves.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0411283_late_decoupling_lorentz_violating_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0411283", "source_line": 540, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization.", "The card frames the candidate as a subcomponent or not able to produce all dark matter."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1068, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Late-decoupling Lorentz-violating fermion dark-sector component is a speculative effective field theory card with subcomponent relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (thermal; small-scale effect suppression); it touches bbn, cmb, galaxy satellites, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_0551_kevin_gevin_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1205_0551", "source_line": 1615, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 1069, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for keVin-GeVin warm dark matter; it offers suppression in small-scale power; BBN relevance with BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_12192_mirror_baryon_dirac_leptogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_12192", "source_line": 3826, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 1070, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as asymmetric production through Dirac leptogenesis, mirror sphaleron conversion of mirror lepton asymmetry to mirror baryon asymmetry.", "Moderate observational leverage comes from the card's unknown phase-space entry, cosmological relevance, or explicit non-CDM structure-formation fields.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "k_essence_unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "0809_0375_power_law_tachyon_quartessence_v1", "paper_id": "0809_0375", "source_line": 97, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1071, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this k_essence_unified_dark_matter_dark_energy card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression in small-scale power, scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2302_05655_eft_sharp_transition_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2302_05655", "source_line": 5531, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 1072, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides CMB/BBN relevance, and multiple plausible probe classes.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_06893_dark_inflaxion_v1", "paper_id": "2310_06893", "source_line": 5846, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 98, "global_rank": 1073, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is misalignment production of the lighter ALP mode after inflation.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, axion laboratory, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (field_like, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_05096_light_vector_neutrino_scattering_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_05096", "source_line": 3825, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1074, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory model with production listed as inflationary misalignment of a light vector condensate.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_15967_electroweak_axion_fuzzy_mixed_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_15967", "source_line": 5394, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 1075, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Electroweak axion mixed fuzzy and cold dark matter has notable cosmology, phase-space, or small-scale-structure leverage, probe classes: CMB, small-scale structure, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "compact_object_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_06716_dark_sector_vacuum_scalarization_solitos_v1", "paper_id": "2401_06716", "source_line": 5984, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1076, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from compact_object_dark_matter: Dark-sector vacuum-scalarized non-topological soliton stars has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value, high diversity value through solitosynthesis, solitogenesis through first- or second-order cosmological phase transitions, Yukawa-driven dark-fermion clustering in radiation domination; inferred probe classes are compact_objects, small_scale_structure.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_10743_neutrino_portal_multicomponent_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_10743", "source_line": 5884, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 1077, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the multicomponent neutrino-portal SIDM setup connects relic asymmetries to halo self-interactions, but stabilization and observable mapping are not explicit enough for high-priority extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_12286_dark_neutron_wimp_baryogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2401_12286", "source_line": 5976, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 1078, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from asymmetric_dark_matter: Mirror-sector dark neutron WIMP-baryogenesis model has moderate observational leverage, high model/theory value through asymmetric dark matter from parallel WIMP baryogenesis, thermal freezeout of baryon-parent WIMPs followed by CP-violating decays, asymmetric reheating by a long-lived reheaton; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, gravitational_waves.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_higgs_portal_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_5615_baby_zilla_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1211_5615", "source_line": 1695, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1079, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as nonthermal production in bubble collisions at a strongly first-order electroweak phase transition, with nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 23.5 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, gravitational waves; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 2 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_4524_type_iii_gmsb_gravitino_wdm_2x24_v1", "paper_id": "0807_4524", "source_line": 800, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 1080, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 23.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance medium, small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type mixed_cold_warm; probe classes counted: ['BBN', 'small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_13758_symmetric_atomic_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2312_13758", "source_line": 5921, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1081, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Symmetric ultraheavy atomic dark matter freeze-out through rearrangement is a emerging atomic_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and BBN, CMB from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 13, observational leverage 8, complementarity 5, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 5.5, penalties 17; raw score 23.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "moduli_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_6403_light_moduli_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1209_6403", "source_line": 1634, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1082, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory card for Light moduli dark matter with anthropically selected abundance; it offers field like phase-space behavior; CMB/BBN relevance with BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_02243_pngb_linear_breaking_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_02243", "source_line": 5900, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 1083, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the linear-breaking pNGB singlet has a concrete Higgs-portal thermal relic setup and partial FeynRules/micrOMEGAs support, but it is CDM-like and lacks encoded constraints/routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_triplet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_08901_inert_triplet_bosonic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_08901", "source_line": 5874, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1084, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the rare bosonic inert-triplet variant has partial relic-code support and good audit fields, but scanned relic viability is sparse and observational routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_11248_superweak_sterile_neutrino_freezein_v1", "paper_id": "2104_11248", "source_line": 4630, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 1085, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative sterile neutrino dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; some cosmological or phase-space leverage; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.... The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_01486_type_ib_rhn_portal_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_01486", "source_line": 4791, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 1086, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: freeze-in via right-handed-neutrino portal couplings.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space distribution.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_02040_gravity_mediated_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_02040", "source_line": 2416, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1087, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is mixed_cold_warm; cosmological relevance is CMB=medium, BBN=high.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_matter_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_0677_exact_parity_mirror_baryon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0809_0677", "source_line": 877, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1088, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, direct detection and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "chiral_nonabelian_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_02722_smallest_non_abelian_chiral_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1706_02722", "source_line": 3165, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1089, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 23.5: Smallest non-Abelian chiral dark-sector dark-proton dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with symmetric thermal freeze-out of dark baryons.", "Rank-relevant positives are high BBN relevance, high CMB relevance, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, CMB, collider, direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_1997_high_scale_messenger_darkogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1997", "source_line": 1168, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 1090, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 23.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, high scientific motivation from its theory setting and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "invisible_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_6218_three_higgs_flavored_pq_invisible_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1410_6218", "source_line": 2248, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1091, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete invisible_axion_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching CMB, axion searches.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family, uncommon production history, or distinctive phase-space category in the provided population context.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_07216_gauged_bl_dirac_scotogenic_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_07216", "source_line": 4605, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1092, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative scotogenic dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_13475_alp_extended_su2d_vector_dm_catalyzed_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2107_13475", "source_line": 4781, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1093, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative vector_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and production logic from: catalyzed freeze-out; X X -> Z prime Z prime depletion.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_13857_singlet_doublet_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_13857", "source_line": 4761, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1094, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out; co-annihilation with heavier vector-like fermion states.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_4929_pseudoscalar_yukawa_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_4929", "source_line": 2250, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1095, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching CMB, collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_00859_fermi_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2107_00859", "source_line": 4787, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1096, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative macroscopic_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: dark first-order phase transition; false-vacuum trapping.", "Observational leverage is driven by not_applicable phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "discrete_flavor_higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_1145_q4_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1212_1145", "source_line": 1697, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.3, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1097, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.8, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal annihilation into Standard Model particles; coannihilation and dark conversion among nearly degenerate hidden scalars when relevant, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 23.3 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_07951_pure_cosmic_millicharged_background_v1", "paper_id": "2308_07951", "source_line": 5739, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1098, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Pure fermionic cosmic millicharged-particle background is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 6.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.2, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_1999_no_scale_flipped_su5_neutralino_flippon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1208_1999", "source_line": 1654, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 1099, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 82.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.2, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out with stau-neutralino coannihilation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 23.2 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=unknown and CMB=medium; card-implied probe classes include CMB, collider, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_06681_agnostic_vector_portal_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_06681", "source_line": 4107, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 1100, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 23: speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked unknown.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonlinear structure-formation effect; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, direct detection, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_05376_fuzzy_dark_fluid_unified_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2007_05376", "source_line": 95, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 1101, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, suppression in small-scale power, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_14089_inelastic_dark_photon_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_14089", "source_line": 4297, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1102, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative inelastic_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via thermal freeze-out; secluded annihilation to dark photons.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_16078_fermion_boosted_dark_matter_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2006_16078", "source_line": 4268, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1103, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative multi_component_boosted_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation of the dominant fermion component; boosted subdominant component from local annihilation, mixed_cold_warm phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_16078_scalar_boosted_dark_matter_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2006_16078", "source_line": 4266, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1104, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative multi_component_boosted_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation of the dominant component; boosted subdominant component from local annihilation, mixed_cold_warm phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_08796_neutrino_interacting_mev_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_08796", "source_line": 2702, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 1105, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has parameter-dependent relic production, suppression small-scale-power behavior, high diversity value in the population context.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: small-scale structure.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_09010_noncanonical_scalar_unified_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_09010", "source_line": 2605, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 1106, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Non-canonical scalar unified dark matter-dark energy model is marked speculative with phenomenological parameterization theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage, some computational representation or tool support, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare production wording in population counts, field_like phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'field like' and small-scale-power effect 'suppression'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_01631_axi_higgs_ultralight_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_01631", "source_line": 4697, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 99, "global_rank": 1107, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production no; high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; field_like phase space.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_03928_primordial_magnetic_field_alp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1702_03928", "source_line": 3011, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 100, "global_rank": 1108, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Axionlike-particle dark matter produced by primordial magnetic fields is ranked because it can produce the full dark-matter abundance in the card; has strong cosmological or small-scale-structure leverage; uses a nonthermal phase-space history; modifies small-scale power; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_06071_qcd_axion_hilltop_phase_shift_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_06071", "source_line": 3918, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1109, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative qcd_axion_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to BBN, CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_6374_yukawa_potential_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1011_6374", "source_line": 1227, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 1110, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative simplified_model card in family self_interacting_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out is examined as one possible abundance mechanism; asymmetric dark matter is noted as an alternative.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_08750_nonabelian_goldstone_absorption_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_08750", "source_line": 3076, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 101, "global_rank": 1111, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory and production ability unknown.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance medium, CMB relevance medium, distinct phase space nonthermal; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, indirect detection, laboratory precision, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_destructing_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_00455_angular_momentum_sddm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_00455", "source_line": 3370, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1112, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative self_destructing_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and nonthermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_08453_bouncing_three_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_08453", "source_line": 5282, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 1113, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Bouncing three-scalar dark matter: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freezeout modified by a bounce; chemical-potential-driven conversion among dark-sector species, thermal phase space, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for hidden_sector_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0204293_qcd_transition_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0204293", "source_line": 430, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 1114, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, cosmology or structure-formation leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: bbn, cmb, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_07102_bosonic_forbidden_mesonic_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_07102", "source_line": 4255, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1115, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative forbidden_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via thermal freeze-out; forbidden annihilation to slightly heavier unstable mediator.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_07102_fermionic_secluded_mesonic_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_07102", "source_line": 4254, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1116, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative light_thermal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via thermal freeze-out; secluded p-wave annihilation to unstable mediators.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_05443_x_portal_scalar_mev_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1608_05443", "source_line": 2870, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 77, "global_rank": 1117, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; 3 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_3167_degenerate_free_fermion_inflaton_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_3167", "source_line": 2252, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1118, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative fermionic_warm_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and decay_produced phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by non-CDM structure-formation behavior, distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_05427_composite_accidental_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1602_05427", "source_line": 2753, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 102, "global_rank": 1119, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in axion_like_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: nonthermal initial-displacement production of the axion field; portals: axion; CMB relevance is high; phase-space type is field_like.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_scalar_clump_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_04638_axion_monodromy_scalar_clump_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_04638", "source_line": 4278, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1120, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative axion_like_scalar_clump_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via coherent axion-like scalar oscillations; delayed parametric resonance of density perturbations, field_like phase-space treatment, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_clump_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_04638_polynomial_scalar_clump_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_04638", "source_line": 4277, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1121, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative scalar_clump_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via coherent scalar-field oscillations; tachyonic instability when scalar-fluid sound speed squared becomes negative, field_like phase-space treatment, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2201_11761_large_extra_dimension_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2201_11761", "source_line": 5048, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 1122, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Large-extra-dimension primordial black hole dark matter has strong supplied observational leverage; probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact objects, small-scale structure; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "top_philic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_00814_top_philic_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_00814", "source_line": 3366, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1123, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative top_philic_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_00037_electron_flavored_dirac_dm_model_i_v1", "paper_id": "1712_00037", "source_line": 3382, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1124, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative lepton_flavored_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1701_05774_affleck_dine_high_bubble_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1701_05774", "source_line": 230, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 1125, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with uv_complete; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=medium, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=mixed, and probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamical.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophobic_u1_b_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_5934_leptophobic_u1b_fermion_x_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_5934", "source_line": 1515, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1126, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and leptophobic u1 b dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, direct detection, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophobic_u1_b_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_5934_leptophobic_u1b_scalar_x_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_5934", "source_line": 1514, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1127, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and leptophobic u1 b dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, direct detection, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_11007_post_inflationary_ultralight_axion_string_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_11007", "source_line": 4560, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 103, "global_rank": 1128, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=high and BBN=medium.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0708_2786_thermally_produced_gravitino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "0708_2786", "source_line": 732, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 1129, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal phase-space history; BBN medium and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, gravitational/cosmology.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_1939_composite_asymmetric_technibaryon_v1", "paper_id": "1112_1939", "source_line": 1506, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 1130, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and nonthermal phase-space treatment.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_03829_dissipative_dark_electromagnetism_v1", "paper_id": "1707_03829", "source_line": 3193, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 78, "global_rank": 1131, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 23.0: Dissipative dark electromagnetism model is a speculative simplified model entry with asymmetric dark matter abundance.", "Rank-relevant positives are high CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, oscillatory transfer behavior, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: CMB, direct detection, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "massive_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0005123_low_reheat_massive_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0005123", "source_line": 401, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1132, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, cosmology or structure-formation leverage, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive model class; probe signal: bbn, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_10577_lrsm_rh_neutrino_warm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_10577", "source_line": 3581, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 1133, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has nonthermal phase-space behavior, has suppression in small-scale power.", "The main positive leverage comes from explicit cosmological or small-scale-structure fields rather than from a populated observable-routing block.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_09730_natural_amsb_higgsino_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1801_09730", "source_line": 3421, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 1134, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance unknown/medium; structure entry unknown/cdm_like; phase-space type mixed_cold_warm; portals higgs, axion, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: higgsino_not_full_dm_warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_09406_general_interacting_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1708_09406", "source_line": 3247, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1135, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: General interacting dark sector with dark matter and dark radiation is a emerging interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter card with smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale effect, CMB/BBN relevance high/medium, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_02713_baryon_violating_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1712_02713", "source_line": 3351, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 1136, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and nonthermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is low/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_4679_susy_u1b_u1l_multicomponent_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1012_4679", "source_line": 1215, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 1137, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family multi_component_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out of cold components; s-channel Z_B-resonant annihilation for the light leptophobic component.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection, laboratory precision / neutrino.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_07542_flipped_su5_inflaton_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_07542", "source_line": 3054, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1138, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability yes.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance high; inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_0906_degenerate_leptophilic_radiative_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_0906", "source_line": 1502, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1139, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and radiative neutrino mass dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, direct detection, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_00016_abelian_vector_invisible_zprime_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1806_00016", "source_line": 3526, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 1140, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has nonthermal phase-space production; it touches collider / fixed-target, gravitational waves / defects, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_00016_nonabelian_vector_invisible_zprime_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1806_00016", "source_line": 3527, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 1141, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has nonthermal phase-space production; it touches collider / fixed-target, gravitational waves / defects, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_11918_su2_center_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_11918", "source_line": 5518, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 79, "global_rank": 1142, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_11918_su3_center_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_11918", "source_line": 5519, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 80, "global_rank": 1143, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_02835_forbidden_fermion_mediator_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_02835", "source_line": 5521, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 77, "global_rank": 1144, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, nonthermal phase-space information, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_09747_modular_a4_muon_specific_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_09747", "source_line": 5548, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1145, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5717_type_i_seesaw_minimal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5717", "source_line": 1527, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1146, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and minimal dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5717_type_iii_seesaw_minimal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5717", "source_line": 1528, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1147, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and minimal dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_03167_fimp_dark_matter_from_flavon_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2305_03167", "source_line": 5627, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 78, "global_rank": 1148, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because flavon-portal FIMP production with decay-produced phase space and possible free-streaming suppression.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_04463_self_interacting_scalar_field_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_04463", "source_line": 5631, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1149, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because rare self-interacting ultralight scalar-field soliton model with field-like suppression.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ghost_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1001_4634_ghost_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1001_4634", "source_line": 1099, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1150, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative effective_field_theory ghost_condensate_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium); structure signal (suppression, scale_dependent_growth); field_like phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_baryon_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_12712_dark_baryon_scalar_mediator_m2_v1", "paper_id": "2111_12712", "source_line": 4933, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1151, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Dark baryon model with scalar mediator Model 2 is speculative with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by unknown phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, galaxy satellites.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance, diversity.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 1-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_00323_dirac_vector_mediator_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2309_00323", "source_line": 5792, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 81, "global_rank": 1152, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Dirac dark matter with a vector mediator and modified freeze-out has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, axion/laboratory searches, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_02149_cp_violating_spin0_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_02149", "source_line": 3044, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 1153, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["CP-violating spin-0 mediator self-interacting fermion dark matter is ranked because it can produce the full dark-matter abundance in the card; has some cosmological, phase-space, or halo-structure leverage; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_08828_superweak_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_08828", "source_line": 5887, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 1154, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the superweak sterile-neutrino candidate has strong theoretical motivation and multiple portals, but proceedings-style extraction, sparse relic details, and missing observable routing reduce immediate value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_03518_corrected_alp_pq_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_03518", "source_line": 5439, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Promising axion and structure hooks remain below tier 3 because observables, constraints, routing, and code are missing."], "family_rank": 104, "global_rank": 1155, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Strong within the deferred group: corrected ALP/PQ field dark matter has mixed phase space, approximate distribution support, CMB relevance, and suppressed small-scale power, but no explicit route or code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_06159_mev_z3_scalar_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2302_06159", "source_line": 5559, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1156, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the rare semi-annihilating MeV scalar family and partial code support help, but the supplied card has no populated observational routes, constraints, or benchmarks.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_2384_b_l_right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1104_2384", "source_line": 1342, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 1157, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level BBN relevance high, small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_07236_su2n_multipartite_fimp_vector_boson_v1", "paper_id": "1905_07236", "source_line": 3891, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 79, "global_rank": 1158, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A non-abelian SU(2)_N Standard Model extension where mass-degenerate neutral vector bosons X and anti-X are FIMP dark matter, with additional long-lived neutral scalar triplet components.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN high; CMB medium; phase-space nonthermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_12154_qcd_axion_hybrid_inflation_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_12154", "source_line": 5752, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1159, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because QCD axion hybrid-inflation dark matter has strong theory or relic-density motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include CMB/cosmic-dawn, axion/laboratory searches.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_09785_nonminimal_scalar_inflationary_fluctuation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_09785", "source_line": 3627, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1160, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 81.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative gravitationally_produced_scalar_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, enhancement small-scale-power effect, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_11896_higgsed_dark_photon_gravitational_production_v1", "paper_id": "2204_11896", "source_line": 5149, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 82, "global_rank": 1161, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for Higgsed dark-photon gravitational production with available distribution information and strong provenance, but limited cosmological/structure leverage."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multipartite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_00991_gauge_b_l_multipartite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_00991", "source_line": 2811, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1162, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from structure formation relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_5615_nonthermal_ewpt_vector_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1211_5615", "source_line": 1694, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1163, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as nonthermal production from first-order electroweak bubble collisions; partial post-transition annihilation wash-out, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 23 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_15906_gravitationally_produced_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_15906", "source_line": 5844, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 1164, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is gravitational particle production during inflation.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, with phase-space/structure entries (nonthermal, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_06741_gravity_portal_stable_rhn_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_06741", "source_line": 6078, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 80, "global_rank": 1165, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 23.0: speculative simplified model model in freeze_in_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB, gravitational waves; phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_5013_u1h_wimpzilla_dark_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1305_5013", "source_line": 1820, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1166, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative superheavy_hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is nonthermal; CMB relevance is high; BBN relevance is high.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on BBN, CMB, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_14801_type_iii_inert_doublet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_14801", "source_line": 5688, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1167, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Type-III radiative inert-doublet scalar dark matter (inert_doublet_dark_matter) has higgs, vector, other portal coverage, but is held back by limited computational support. Raw score 23.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_05382_n2hdm_full_dark_phase_v1", "paper_id": "2004_05382", "source_line": 4258, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 1168, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support, production via multi-component thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal and electroweak interactions.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_13238_multicomponent_asymmetric_cogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_13238", "source_line": 5563, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 1169, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: cogenesis and multi-component relic production give strong scientific motivation, but observational leverage is weak in the supplied card because routes and constraints are empty.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_07232_susy_dfsz_late_decaying_gravitino_axino_v1", "paper_id": "2105_07232", "source_line": 4748, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1170, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative superwimp_axion_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via thermal gravitino/axino production before saxion domination; entropy dilution from saxion decay.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN, CMB; the raw score is 23 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Diversity credit is elevated because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive family or production regime in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_preheating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_15808_gravitational_preheating_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_15808", "source_line": 5111, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1171, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for rare gravitational preheating production and partial relic-density calculation support; missing routing and high nonthermal-production warnings keep it modest."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wino_lsp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_2395_spread_susy_wino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_2395", "source_line": 1639, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1172, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory card for Spread Supersymmetry with wino LSP dark matter; it offers nonthermal phase-space behavior; CMB/BBN relevance with BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, and 1 more probe hooks.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrinophilic_scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_15760_z3_scotogenic_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_15760", "source_line": 5758, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1173, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Z3 scotogenic neutrinophilic Dirac-fermion dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, CMB/cosmic-dawn, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, and additional probe classes.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrinophilic_scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_15760_z3_scotogenic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_15760", "source_line": 5759, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1174, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Z3 scotogenic neutrinophilic scalar dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, CMB/cosmic-dawn, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, and additional probe classes.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_02255_s3_majorana_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_02255", "source_line": 4000, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 1175, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for S3 Majorana right-handed-neutrino dark matter: strong model-card science motivation; inferred probe classes are CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 23 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out; phase=thermal; CMB=low, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_baryon_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0509242_mirror_baryon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509242", "source_line": 529, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1176, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Broken-Z2 mirror baryon dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches bbn, cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_00505_se6ssm_gravitino_neutral_exotic_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_00505", "source_line": 5321, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 1177, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 23.0: multi_component_dark_matter with thermal production of gravitinos from scattering in the thermal bath; science=13.0, observational leverage=5.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) and diversity=5.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_05716_gravitational_rhn_fimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_05716", "source_line": 5344, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 81, "global_rank": 1178, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 23.0: freeze_in_dark_matter with graviton-mediated inflaton-condensate scattering to N1 pairs; science=15.0, observational leverage=5.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, gravitational waves, indirect detection) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_05716_majoron_scalar_two_step_gravitational_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_05716", "source_line": 5345, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 82, "global_rank": 1179, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 23.0: freeze_in_dark_matter with gravitational production of scalar S from the inflaton condensate; science=15.0, observational leverage=5.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_06082_small_lambda_kappa_nmssm_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_06082", "source_line": 5110, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 1180, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a UV-complete NMSSM neutralino relic-density benchmark with partial computational support; observational fields are sparse and structure is CDM-like."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_05579_2hdm_portal_forbidden_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_05579", "source_line": 5135, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1181, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as the companion forbidden fermion thermal relic; useful as breadth for the 2HDM portal family but observational-extension payload is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_05579_2hdm_portal_forbidden_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_05579", "source_line": 5134, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1182, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a UV-complete forbidden scalar thermal relic with medium CMB relevance; the card lacks routes, constraints, code, and distinctive structure."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_11775_so10_pseudo_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_11775", "source_line": 5594, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1183, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the SO(10) pseudo-Goldstone model is rare and UV-motivated, but the current card has sparse observational and computational support.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_02698_scalar_singlet_two_step_ewpt_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_02698", "source_line": 3056, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1184, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection, laboratory precision.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_14764_sesm_inelastic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_14764", "source_line": 5540, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1185, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_08686_singlet_scalar_waterfall_decay_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2304_08686", "source_line": 5641, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1186, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because singlet-scalar waterfall decay dark matter with nonthermal production and moderate cosmological relevance.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_17851_su2d_neutron_decay_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_17851", "source_line": 6109, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 83, "global_rank": 1187, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 23 (defer) from supplied card content: freeze_in_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior; cosmological relevance: CMB medium, BBN medium.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_08406_2hda_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_08406", "source_line": 5113, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1188, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a 2HD+a singlet-fermion WIMP benchmark with collider/direct-detection complementarity implied by the portals, but sparse constraints and no code keep it mid-tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_3523_supersymmetric_atomic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1009_3523", "source_line": 1179, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1189, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 23 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_axial_vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_01366_s_channel_axial_vector_simplified_dirac_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1603_01366", "source_line": 2768, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1190, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: benchmark simplified_model in simplified_axial_vector_mediator_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through dark matter self-annihilation; portals: vector.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_08888_high_scale_fopt_scotogenic_fimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_08888", "source_line": 5630, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 84, "global_rank": 1191, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because high-scale FOPT scotogenic FIMP production with neutrino-sector motivation and BBN relevance.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_02233_thermal_mass_lmu_ltau_freeze_in_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_02233", "source_line": 5185, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 85, "global_rank": 1192, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: thermal-mass Lmu-Ltau freeze-in is UV-complete and has a distinctive production threshold, but no distribution function or formal probe routing is supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_misalignment_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_04476_thermal_misalignment_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_04476", "source_line": 4852, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1193, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is emerging and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; field_like phase-space production; rare family in population context (count 2).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_03429_vll_decay_freezein_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2107_03429", "source_line": 4784, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 86, "global_rank": 1194, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: freeze-in from vector-like lepton decay; out-of-equilibrium production from the thermal bath.", "Observational leverage is driven by decay_produced phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fraternal_twin_higgs_wimp", "model_id": "2106_12578_z2_fraternal_twin_tau_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2106_12578", "source_line": 4782, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1195, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative fraternal_twin_higgs_wimp card with effective_field_theory theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out; hidden-sector annihilation through twin photon and twin weak mediators.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_02803_gauged_inverse_seesaw_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_02803", "source_line": 4799, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 23, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1196, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative sterile_neutrino_wimp_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: thermal WIMP freeze-out; Z prime mediated annihilation to Standard Model fermions and sterile neutrinos.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 23, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_07176_nonuniversal_u1prime_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1909_07176", "source_line": 4020, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 1197, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.4, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes limited explicit observational handles in the supplied card.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_05249_z4_fermion_fimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_05249", "source_line": 5720, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 87, "global_rank": 1198, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 1.7, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Z4 fermion FIMP dark matter with singlet scalar mediator is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance, nonthermal phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 4.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 1.7, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_higgs_doublet_z_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_09234_z_portal_cpviolating_3hdm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1909_09234", "source_line": 4021, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1199, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.3, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_18557_mediator_decay_freeze_in_emd_v1", "paper_id": "2402_18557", "source_line": 5952, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 88, "global_rank": 1200, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from freeze_in_dark_matter: Mediator-decay freeze-in dark matter during early matter domination has moderate observational leverage through freeze-in from on-shell mediator decay, inverse annihilation subchannel, early matter domination dilution; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, collider.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_13878_dark_population_transfer_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_13878", "source_line": 5972, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 1201, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from sterile_neutrino_dark_matter: Dark population transfer sterile neutrino dark matter has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value, high diversity value through active-neutrino scattering-induced decoherence produces heavy sterile N1, dark-sector internal thermalization through scalar-mediated sterile self-interactions, population transfer from N1 to N2 through 2-to-2 scatterings and 1-to-3 decays; inferred probe classes are indirect_detection, small_scale_structure.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_12423_quintessential_inflation_rh_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_12423", "source_line": 3845, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 1202, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as gravitational particle production during kination.", "Moderate observational leverage comes from the card's nonthermal phase-space entry, cosmological relevance, or explicit non-CDM structure-formation fields.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_0079_heavy_moduli_nonthermal_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "0705_0079", "source_line": 745, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1203, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative phenomenological_parameterization model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal phase-space history; BBN critical and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, gravitational/cosmology.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_11045_axion_assisted_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_11045", "source_line": 5356, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 77, "global_rank": 1204, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Axion-assisted resonance sterile-neutrino dark matter has notable cosmology, phase-space, or small-scale-structure leverage, probe classes: BBN, small-scale structure, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_11862_scalar_moduli_portal_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1911_11862", "source_line": 4061, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 22.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 89, "global_rank": 1205, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: gravitational waves.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_10112_gauged_charged_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_10112", "source_line": 5958, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 83, "global_rank": 1206, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from hidden_sector_dark_matter: Gauged charged complex scalar dark matter with dark Higgs and dark photon has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through thermal freeze-out of symmetric X/Xbar dark matter through dark-sector annihilation channels; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB, collider, direct_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_17099_type_ii_2hdm_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2312_17099", "source_line": 5922, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1207, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Type-II extended 2HDM QCD axion dark matter is a speculative qcd_axion_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space information, none small-scale-power information, and CMB from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 13, observational leverage 8, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 5.5, penalties 15; raw score 22.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_03826_freeze_in_lepton_flavored_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_03826", "source_line": 5942, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 90, "global_rank": 1208, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Freeze-in lepton-flavored dark matter with right-handed lepton mediator is a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and collider, small-scale structure from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 10, observational leverage 7, complementarity 5, feasibility 2, provenance 9, diversity 2.5, penalties 13; raw score 22.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_05579_cxsm_z2_breaking_pseudo_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_05579", "source_line": 4101, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1209, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 22.5: speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: phase-transition/GW-motivated phenomenology; inferred probe classes: collider, direct detection, gravitational waves.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_11386_mirror_atomic_dark_matter_hubble_tension_v1", "paper_id": "2108_11386", "source_line": 4816, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1210, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, non-CDM structure information, some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_13378_dark_quark_nugget_dark_binary_v1", "paper_id": "2312_13378", "source_line": 5927, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1211, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Dark-quark-nugget dark binaries with a long-range dark force is a speculative macroscopic_dark_matter card with not_applicable phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and CMB, compact objects, gravitational waves from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 10, observational leverage 5, complementarity 8, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 6.5, penalties 16; raw score 22.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_00306_supersymmetric_stronger_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1505_00306", "source_line": 2450, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 105, "global_rank": 1212, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a axion_like_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked yes; phase-space type is field_like; cosmological relevance is CMB=high, BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_1997_low_scale_darkogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1997", "source_line": 1167, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 1213, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 22.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, high scientific motivation from its theory setting and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_13475_su2d_vector_dm_catalyzed_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2107_13475", "source_line": 4780, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1214, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative vector_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and production logic from: catalyzed freeze-out; X X -> Z prime Z prime depletion.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_00890_radiative_seesaw_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2104_00890", "source_line": 4627, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1215, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative radiative seesaw scalar dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_07992_moduli_portal_uv_freeze_in_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1909_07992", "source_line": 4043, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 91, "global_rank": 1216, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.8, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative effective_field_theory; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_like_lepton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_4235_vector_like_lepton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1207_4235", "source_line": 1659, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1217, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out; co-annihilation with E_1, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 22.2 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2307_08046_modified_higgs_inflation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2307_08046", "source_line": 5732, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 1218, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Modified Higgs-inflation primordial black-hole dark matter is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, compact objects/dynamics, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 2.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 3.2, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_08296_self_interacting_sterile_neutrino_heavy_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1903_08296", "source_line": 3800, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 78, "global_rank": 1219, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 17, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 22 because the card identifies production via active-to-sterile conversion modified by sterile self-interactions, nonthermal phase-space treatment, suppression small-scale-power behavior, smooth_cutoff transfer-function shape, probe classes: small-scale structure; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1910_10602_attractor_inflation_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "1910_10602", "source_line": 241, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 1220, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=medium, transfer_function=enhanced_small_scale_power, small_scale_power_effect=enhancement, and probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamical.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: fine_tuned_usr."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_07973_fermionic_uv_ir_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1907_07973", "source_line": 3945, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 92, "global_rank": 1221, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 80.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to BBN, CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_01246_scalar_mediator_closed_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_01246", "source_line": 3410, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 1222, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance medium/low; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals none.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: closed_sector_assumption, vector_scalar_difference."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_07086_clockwork_axion_defect_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "1803_07086", "source_line": 3439, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 106, "global_rank": 1223, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance high/low; phase-space type field_like; portals axion, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: clockwork_not_standard_axion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ballistic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_00028_ballistic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1811_00028", "source_line": 3697, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1224, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 12.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative ballistic_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes; high CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior; oscillations small-scale-power effect.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_00436_asymmetric_bose_gas_light_bec_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1709_00436", "source_line": 3222, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 1225, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Light asymmetric Bose gas dark matter with present-day condensate is a speculative scalar_field_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale effect, CMB/BBN relevance medium/high, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_09409_generalized_hilltop_reheating_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_09409", "source_line": 5696, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 93, "global_rank": 1226, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Non-thermal vector-like fermion dark matter from generalized Hilltop reheating (freeze_in_dark_matter) has nonthermal phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, other, gravitational, higgs portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support, low robustness. Raw score 22.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_09409_nonminimal_coleman_weinberg_reheating_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_09409", "source_line": 5697, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 94, "global_rank": 1227, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Non-thermal vector-like fermion dark matter from non-minimal Coleman-Weinberg reheating (freeze_in_dark_matter) has nonthermal phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, other, gravitational, higgs portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support, low robustness. Raw score 22.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_02698_portalino_neutrino_portal_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_02698", "source_line": 5295, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1228, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Portalino-inspired neutrino-portal Dirac fermion dark matter: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out through hidden-sector annihilation channels, thermal phase space, phase-transition history, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for neutrino_portal_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_10963_leptophilic_light_flavon_hot_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1812_10963", "source_line": 3748, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 95, "global_rank": 1229, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Leptophilic light flavon hot-relic model is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card treats it as non-full or subdominant dark matter, mixed cold warm phase-space behavior, probe relevance for BBN, CMB, small-scale structure, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_01007_alp_dark_photon_audible_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1912_01007", "source_line": 4142, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 107, "global_rank": 1230, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 22: speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, phase-transition/GW-motivated phenomenology; inferred probe classes: CMB, gravitational waves.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_0954_resonant_7kev_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1403_0954", "source_line": 2085, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 79, "global_rank": 1231, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of sterile_neutrino_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; non-CDM small-scale structure information; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_11295_wimpy_leptogenesis_emd_v1", "paper_id": "2208_11295", "source_line": 5292, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1232, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for WIMPy leptogenesis inert-doublet dark matter with early matter domination: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via WIMP freeze-out; lepton-number-violating dark matter annihilation, thermal phase space, phase-transition history, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for cold_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_11295_wimpy_leptogenesis_feu_v1", "paper_id": "2208_11295", "source_line": 5291, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1233, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for WIMPy leptogenesis inert-doublet dark matter with fast expanding universe: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via WIMP freeze-out; lepton-number-violating dark matter annihilation, thermal phase space, phase-transition history, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for cold_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_11295_wimpy_leptogenesis_stg_v1", "paper_id": "2208_11295", "source_line": 5293, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1234, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for WIMPy leptogenesis inert-doublet dark matter with scalar-tensor gravity: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via WIMP freeze-out; lepton-number-violating dark matter annihilation, thermal phase space, phase-transition history, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for cold_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_09422_gluophilic_zprime_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2208_09422", "source_line": 5268, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 96, "global_rank": 1235, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Gluophilic Z-prime portal FIMP dark matter: speculative status, effective-field-theory theory level, and production via freeze-in from gluon annihilation through off-shell Z-prime, nonthermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for freeze_in_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2310_16877_qcd_colored_primordial_black_hole_v1", "paper_id": "2310_16877", "source_line": 5882, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 1236, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because colored PBHs are a rare compact-object variant with BBN/QCD-era leverage, but survival and mass-function assumptions are uncertain and no observational pipeline is supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1902_04082_co_decaying_dm_primordial_black_holes_v1", "paper_id": "1902_04082", "source_line": 3712, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 1237, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Primordial black holes from co-decaying dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, probe relevance for BBN, CMB, small-scale structure, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_cold_hot_bosonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph9702125_three_level_neutrino_laser_majoron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9702125", "source_line": 6123, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1238, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 22 (defer) from supplied card content: mixed_cold_hot_bosonic_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and no all-DM production; mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior; non-CDM linear structure information (suppression, mixed_cold_warm); cosmological relevance: BBN high.", "Penalties (18) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1010_3431_scalar_graviton_soft_core_halo_v1", "paper_id": "1010_3431", "source_line": 1249, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1239, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family modified_gravity_scalar_field_dark_matter with production via coherent scalar-graviton field configured as a static galactic halo.", "Observational leverage is driven by field_like phase space; probe classes: Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / dynamics, galaxy satellites.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "subcomponent_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_13043_jovian_captured_gev_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_13043", "source_line": 5955, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1240, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from subcomponent_asymmetric_dark_matter: Jovian captured GeV dark matter toy model has moderate observational leverage, high diversity value through subcomponent relic assumed, Jupiter capture, annihilation of accumulated DM inside Jupiter; inferred probe classes are direct_detection, indirect_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_07779_higgs_singlet_operator_ultralight_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1703_07779", "source_line": 3042, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 1241, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Higgs-singlet higher-dimensional-operator ultralight axion is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has strong cosmological or small-scale-structure leverage; uses a field-like phase-space history; modifies small-scale power; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_07779_susy_instanton_ultralight_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1703_07779", "source_line": 3041, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 1242, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Supersymmetric instanton-generated ultralight axion is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has strong cosmological or small-scale-structure leverage; uses a field-like phase-space history; modifies small-scale power; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_04287_vector_coherent_oscillation_curvaton_v1", "paper_id": "2303_04287", "source_line": 5560, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1243, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: coherent vector production tied to curvaton perturbations gives CMB-scale leverage and diversity, but a high-severity warning plus empty observational-detail fields keep priority low.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_04087_sterile_neutrino_scalar_nsi_v1", "paper_id": "2111_04087", "source_line": 4893, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 80, "global_rank": 1244, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high BBN relevance; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior; nonthermal phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_05821_majorana_scalar_qcd_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1801_05821", "source_line": 3397, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1245, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative coannihilating_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_01520_led_planckeon_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_01520", "source_line": 5686, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 1246, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because LED Planckeon black-hole remnant dark matter (primordial_black_holes) has nonthermal phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, gravitational portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 22.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0503057_axion_trapping_cosmic_string_wakes_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0503057", "source_line": 531, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 108, "global_rank": 1247, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Axion trapping by cosmic string wakes is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card with unknown relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (nonthermal; small-scale effect enhancement); it touches black-hole superradiance, cmb, galaxy satellites, lyman-alpha forest; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_4858_millicharged_atomic_dm_elastic_v1", "paper_id": "1201_4858", "source_line": 1503, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 84, "global_rank": 1248, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and hidden sector dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (CMB, BBN, galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_4858_millicharged_atomic_dm_hyperfine_v1", "paper_id": "1201_4858", "source_line": 1504, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 85, "global_rank": 1249, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and hidden sector dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, direct detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_06441_qcd_axion_curvature_pq_breaking_v1", "paper_id": "2404_06441", "source_line": 6006, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 109, "global_rank": 1250, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 9, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because curvature-induced PQ breaking gives a motivated axion-isocurvature target, but the card has a severe axion-quality warning and lacks code, constraints, and observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_02615_metastable_conformal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2103_02615", "source_line": 4561, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 97, "global_rank": 1251, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=medium and BBN=low.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_13101_z6_singlet_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2401_13101", "source_line": 5987, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1252, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from singlet_fermion_dark_matter: Z6 singlet Dirac dark matter has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value, high diversity value through thermal freeze-out through scalar-mediated annihilation, resonant annihilation near h and S poles, dominant chi chi -> S S annihilation for high masses; inferred probe classes are direct_detection, small_scale_structure.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_06752_resonant_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_06752", "source_line": 2501, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 81, "global_rank": 1253, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Resonantly produced 7.1 keV sterile neutrino warm dark matter: model-card structure/cosmology fields give comparatively strong observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 22.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_05257_gravity_mediated_susy_gut_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "2208_05257", "source_line": 5284, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 1254, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Gravity-mediated supersymmetric GUT neutralino LSP dark matter: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out; coannihilation regions, thermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_10928_adagio_dark_photon_thermal_relic_v1", "paper_id": "2308_10928", "source_line": 5764, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1255, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Adagio dark-photon thermal relic dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, CMB/cosmic-dawn, axion/laboratory searches, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, and additional probe classes.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: standard_cosmology_misuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_04678_heavy_qcd_axion_level_crossing_v1", "paper_id": "2306_04678", "source_line": 5694, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 110, "global_rank": 1256, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Heavy QCD axion dark matter from sterile-axion avoided level crossing (axion_like_dark_matter) has field like phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, axion portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 22.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0803_3725_axionic_mirage_axino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0803_3725", "source_line": 797, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1257, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 22.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance medium, small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type decay_produced; probe classes counted: ['BBN', 'small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "curvature_coupled_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_09836_curvature_coupled_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_09836", "source_line": 3877, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1258, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / effective_field_theory: A massive vector dark matter field whose homogeneous, transverse, and longitudinal modes evolve under a non-minimal Ricci-scalar coupling during inflation.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN unknown; CMB high; phase-space field_like; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: vector_longitudinal_caveat."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_baryon_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_12712_dark_baryon_vector_mediator_m3_v1", "paper_id": "2111_12712", "source_line": 4934, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1259, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Dark baryon model with vector mediator Model 3 is speculative with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by unknown phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, galaxy satellites.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance, diversity.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 2-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_06011_dark_glueball_ultralight_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1805_06011", "source_line": 3502, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 1260, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a UV-complete model card; it has mixed_cold_warm phase-space production; it touches indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_07114_multifield_ultralight_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2301_07114", "source_line": 36, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 1261, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a emerging simplified_model model, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space description, some computational or code support, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_quark_nugget_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_01509_axion_quark_nugget_solar_flare_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_01509", "source_line": 3401, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1262, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status yes; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type nonthermal; portals axion, other; underrepresented family count 3.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: application_vs_core_model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_02947_dark_u1x_vector_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_02947", "source_line": 3403, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1263, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; only partial associated-code support; warnings: model_a_vs_model_b."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "1301_0354_phase_transition_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1301_0354", "source_line": 1681, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1264, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as asymmetric production of X-particles and baryons from decays of unspecified prehistoric particles; strongly first-order phase transition from phi=0 to phi nonzero, with nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 22 reflects card-implied probe classes include compact objects, gravitational waves, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_hawking_radiation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_01301_superheavy_hawking_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_01301", "source_line": 3852, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1265, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: A nonthermal superheavy stable particle population produced by Hawking evaporation during an early primordial-black-hole dominated era.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN high; CMB medium; phase-space nonthermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: pbh_history_required."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "condensate_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "astro-ph0211303_cdm_condensate_transition_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0211303", "source_line": 418, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1266, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive model class, partial computational support from associated code or calculations; probe signal: cmb, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, a high-severity card warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_higgs_portal_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_10739_electroweak_symmetric_dark_matter_ball_v1", "paper_id": "1906_10739", "source_line": 3949, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1267, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative macroscopic_higgs_portal_soliton_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to compact-object/dynamics.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_vector_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_0022_u1x_isospin_violating_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_0022", "source_line": 1916, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1268, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 22.0 because the model card is a speculative asymmetric_vector_higgs_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; unknown BBN and medium CMB relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior; high diversity value in the registry population and touches CMB, collider, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_05029_effective_right_handed_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_05029", "source_line": 4364, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 82, "global_rank": 1269, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Effective right-handed sterile-neutrino dark matter with SM gauge interactions: early-universe thermal decoupling through suppressed weak interactions; some cosmological or phase-space leverage, good diversity value within the population context, partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, indirect/transient, laboratory/direct and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_00323_dirac_scalar_mediator_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2309_00323", "source_line": 5793, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 86, "global_rank": 1270, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Dirac dark matter with a scalar mediator and modified freeze-out has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, axion/laboratory searches, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_01899_gamma_ray_triangle_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_01899", "source_line": 2796, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 1271, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in asymmetric_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: asymmetric dark matter abundance with unspecified asymmetry generation; present-day self-annihilation of the dominant particle component to N_D pairs; portals: higgs, neutrino, other; phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_03120_sequestered_lvs_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_03120", "source_line": 2799, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 1272, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out of a Higgsino-like neutralino after modulus reheating; mixed axion-Higgsino dark matter if the Higgsino is thermally underproduced; portals: vector, higgs, gravitational; CMB relevance is medium; BBN relevance is medium.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_2164_oscillating_asymmetric_dark_matter_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1109_2164", "source_line": 1393, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 1273, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as asymmetric_dark_matter: production is represented by asymmetry generation related to baryogenesis-like dynamics; phase-space is nonthermal; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, cosmological phase-space, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by phenomenological_parameterization structure and the supplied production history; some cosmological or phase-space relevance is present; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_01522_chiral_b_l_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_01522", "source_line": 5520, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 87, "global_rank": 1274, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides strong model-building or relic-density motivation, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_01217_singlet_doublet_fermion_dm_scalar_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1902_01217", "source_line": 3769, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1275, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 22 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out, co-annihilation with charged and heavier neutral vector-like fermions, thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: BBN, collider, direct detection; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_06741_gravity_reheating_qcd_axion_relic_v1", "paper_id": "2405_06741", "source_line": 6079, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 111, "global_rank": 1276, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 22.0: speculative phenomenological parameterization model in axion_like_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB, gravitational waves; phase space is field like.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_04721_two_component_wimp_solar_conversion_v1", "paper_id": "2304_04721", "source_line": 5585, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 1277, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the two-component WIMP conversion model has useful solar/direct-detection complementarity, but observational and computational fields are empty in the supplied card.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2202_02401_two_form_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_02401", "source_line": 5060, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 1278, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 22 (defer) as a speculative effective_field_theory member of primordial_black_holes.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB, compact/microlensing/dynamics, gravitational waves/inflation.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: inflation/reheating, phase transition/gw, structure/self-interaction, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: gravitational collapse of enhanced primordial curvature perturbations sourced by amplified two-form fields during inflation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "compact_object_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_12181_cgf_dark_matter_stars_v1", "paper_id": "2203_12181", "source_line": 5088, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1279, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 22 (defer) as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of compact_object_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: structure/dynamics, compact/microlensing/dynamics.", "Production summary used: CGF semi-classical initial state from the electroweak transition onward; gravitational collapse of initial CGF fluctuations into self-gravitating dark matter stars."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_06270_z3_nmssm_light_singlino_funnel_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_06270", "source_line": 3973, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 1280, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Z3-symmetric NMSSM light singlino funnel dark matter: some associated-code support; inferred probe classes are CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 22 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out through Z, SM-like Higgs, and singlet-like Higgs funnels; coannihilation with higgsino-like electroweakinos in compressed parts of the parameter space; phase=thermal; CMB=medium, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_04818_gauged_lepton_dark_sector_cp_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_04818", "source_line": 3982, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 88, "global_rank": 1281, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Gauged lepton-number dark-sector CP-violating fermion dark matter: strong model-card science motivation; inferred probe classes are BBN, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 22 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out of Z2-stabilized chi; annihilation through Z prime and dark scalar channels; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=medium; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0810_4421_scale_invariant_vector_field_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "0810_4421", "source_line": 869, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1282, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 79.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, field like phase-space behavior. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_01670_reheaton_decay_kination_emd_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_01670", "source_line": 5301, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1283, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 22.0: nonthermal_dark_matter with nonthermal decay production from long-lived reheaton; science=13.0, observational leverage=5.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, direct detection, galaxy satellites) and diversity=5.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dipolar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0804_3518_dipolar_dark_matter_gravitational_polarization_v1", "paper_id": "0804_3518", "source_line": 310, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1284, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is high, phase-space type is field_like, nonlinear halo or subhalo effect is stated.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, compact-object dynamics, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:effective_validity.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/5/8/0/9/6/14."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "accidental_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_07759_scalar_extended_accidental_composite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_07759", "source_line": 6001, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1285, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card describes a rare UV-complete composite accidental-symmetry family, but it has no explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, code, or structure-formation handle."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_like_lepton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_11646_s3_2hdm_vll_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_11646", "source_line": 5058, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1286, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 22 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of vector_like_lepton_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through VLL annihilation/coannihilation channels."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_03390_conformal_u1x_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_03390", "source_line": 3875, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1287, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A classically scale-invariant Higgs-portal model with a complex singlet scalar mediator, a dark U(1)_X gauge boson, and two degenerate Dirac singlet fermions as dark matter.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN unknown; CMB high; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1262_susy_axion_hybrid_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1262", "source_line": 1333, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1288, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance high, phase-space type field_like.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for supersymmetric_axion_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_00529_freeze_in_hidden_sector_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_00529", "source_line": 4359, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1289, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Freeze-in hidden-sector self-interacting dark fermion model with a light dark photon: freeze-in from the visible sector; some cosmological or phase-space leverage, good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, indirect/transient and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_00849_stfm_singlet_fimp_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2208_00849", "source_line": 5308, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 98, "global_rank": 1290, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 22.0: freeze_in_dark_matter with thermal freeze-in; science=14.0, observational leverage=4.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_00849_stfm_triplet_wimp_nonthermal_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2208_00849", "source_line": 5307, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 99, "global_rank": 1291, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 22.0: freeze_in_dark_matter with freeze-out; science=14.0, observational leverage=4.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sub_gev_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_08430_complex_scalar_dark_higgs_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_08430", "source_line": 3267, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1292, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sub gev vector portal dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 22.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sub_gev_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_08430_pseudo_dirac_dark_higgs_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_08430", "source_line": 3266, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1293, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sub gev vector portal dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 22.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2106_00111_fermi_ball_collapse_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_00111", "source_line": 4734, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 1294, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with simplified_model theory support and production via first-order phase transition trapping; Fermi-ball formation from false-vacuum remnants.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN, CMB, compact objects/dynamics; the raw score is 22 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_baryonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_0660_many_copy_standard_model_baryon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0903_0660", "source_line": 958, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1295, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_baryonic_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, CMB, indirect detection.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0908_3399_gravitino_dm_general_neutralino_nlsp_v1", "paper_id": "0908_3399", "source_line": 972, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1296, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from critical BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, indirect detection.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_13126_two_component_wimp_fimp_scalar_u1_lmu_ltau_v1", "paper_id": "2202_13126", "source_line": 5074, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 1297, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 22 (defer) as a speculative simplified_model member of multi_component_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: strong science/relic-density basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, gravitational waves/inflation.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, tension/anomaly, phase transition/gw, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out of phi_1; freeze-in production of phi_2."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superfluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_08117_quartic_superfluid_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_08117", "source_line": 4612, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1298, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative superfluid dark matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_6646_secluded_dm_hidden_cft_v1", "paper_id": "1203_6646", "source_line": 1498, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1299, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable secluded_hidden_sector_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out into hidden-sector states.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_04776_flavor_symmetric_vectorlike_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_04776", "source_line": 2751, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1300, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative effective_field_theory in higgs_portal_fermion_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through annihilation; coannihilation with nearby odd fermions; portals: higgs, neutrino, vector.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_11408_hidden_self_interacting_dirac_dm_fopt_v1", "paper_id": "2209_11408", "source_line": 5367, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 1301, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Hidden self-interacting Dirac dark matter with scalar-mediated first-order phase transition has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: BBN, CMB, direct detection, gravitational waves, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2209_15343_nonminimal_supergravity_pbh_dm_cubic_v1", "paper_id": "2209_15343", "source_line": 5326, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 1302, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 22.0: primordial_black_holes with enhanced curvature perturbations during two-field nonminimally coupled supergravity inflation; science=15.0, observational leverage=3.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, gravitational waves) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2209_15343_nonminimal_supergravity_pbh_dm_sextic_v1", "paper_id": "2209_15343", "source_line": 5327, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 77, "global_rank": 1303, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 22.0: primordial_black_holes with enhanced curvature perturbations during two-field nonminimally coupled supergravity inflation; science=15.0, observational leverage=3.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, gravitational waves) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_13233_type_ii_seesaw_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_13233", "source_line": 5346, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 112, "global_rank": 1304, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 22.0: axion_like_dark_matter with misalignment after electroweak-scale ALP mass generation; science=15.0, observational leverage=3.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, gravitational waves) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_09249_dark_dimension_dark_graviton_v1", "paper_id": "2209_09249", "source_line": 5335, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 89, "global_rank": 1305, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 22.0: hidden_sector_dark_matter with gravitational production from Standard Model brane into bulk KK gravitons; science=14.0, observational leverage=3.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection) and diversity=6.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_08125_left_right_triplet_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_08125", "source_line": 3055, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 1306, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability yes.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance low, CMB relevance low; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_1525_u1r_sterile_neutrino_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1411_1525", "source_line": 2346, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 83, "global_rank": 1307, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 22 because the assigned model card uv complete sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; marks small-scale-power suppression; touches Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_01366_s_channel_vector_simplified_dirac_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1603_01366", "source_line": 2767, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1308, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: benchmark simplified_model in simplified_vector_mediator_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through dark matter self-annihilation; portals: vector.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2405_04397_su5_u1_hybrid_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_04397", "source_line": 6068, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 78, "global_rank": 1309, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 22.0: speculative uv complete model in primordial_black_holes, with relic-density capability recorded as yes.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB, gravitational waves.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_axion_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_5413_pqmssm_mixed_axion_neutralino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1103_5413", "source_line": 1326, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1310, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance high.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for multi_component_axion_neutralino_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2305_09630_double_well_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_09630", "source_line": 5614, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 79, "global_rank": 1311, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because PBH dark matter from double-well inflation with full-DM capability and broad PBH probe complementarity.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_13722_inverse_phase_transition_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_13722", "source_line": 4631, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1312, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative scalar portal dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, gravitational waves. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_baryon_number_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_03749_local_baryon_number_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_03749", "source_line": 6083, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1313, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 22.0: speculative uv complete model in gauged_baryon_number_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as yes.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_3823_higgs_portal_vector_dark_matter_u1_v1", "paper_id": "1412_3823", "source_line": 2332, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 22, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1314, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 22 because the assigned model card uv complete higgs_portal_dark_matter card; touches direct detection, gravitational waves, laboratory precision / fifth-force searches.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 22, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_3891_linear_seesaw_mixed_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_3891", "source_line": 1651, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1315, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.8, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out of a sneutrino LSP; coannihilation or s-channel resonance in parts of parameter space, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 21.8 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_13460_scale_invariant_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1910_13460", "source_line": 4006, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1316, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.3, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative simplified_model; rank-relevant evidence includes multiple probe-relevant card fields.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1505_00034_logotropic_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1505_00034", "source_line": 77, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1317, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this unified_dark_matter_dark_energy card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression in small-scale power, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2402_06613_radiative_hybrid_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_06613", "source_line": 5957, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 80, "global_rank": 1318, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from primordial_black_holes: Radiative hybrid inflation primordial black hole dark matter has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through PBH formation from enhanced curvature perturbations during waterfall transition; inferred probe classes are CMB, compact_objects, gravitational_waves.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2311_17829_dressed_pbh_particle_dm_coexistence_v1", "paper_id": "2311_17829", "source_line": 5893, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 81, "global_rank": 1319, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because dressed PBH-particle coexistence has compact-object and halo-profile leverage, but it is primarily phenomenological and depends on unspecified particle-DM microphysics."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_14345_nonthermal_decay_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2211_14345", "source_line": 5385, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1320, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Nonthermal decay-produced dark matter for the Hubble tension has notable cosmology, phase-space, or small-scale-structure leverage, probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space, large penalties for missing observables, constraints, and follow-up machinery."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_singlino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0405109_approximate_pq_singlino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0405109", "source_line": 554, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1321, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Approximate-PQ electroweak supersymmetry with singlino LSP dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family supersymmetric_singlino_dark_matter with production described as thermal production followed by pre-BBN entropy dilution.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; suppression of small-scale power; smooth cutoff transfer behavior; probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_0470_mixed_collisionless_free_streaming_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0711_0470", "source_line": 753, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 1322, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 21.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance medium, small-scale power suppression, transfer function mixed_cold_warm, phase-space type mixed_cold_warm; probe classes counted: ['CMB', 'small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_06487_vector_dm_magnetic_dipole_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2210_06487", "source_line": 5358, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 100, "global_rank": 1323, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Vector dark matter freeze-in through magnetic dipole interactions has notable cosmology, phase-space, or small-scale-structure leverage, probe classes: CMB, small-scale structure, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0604270_susy_so10_mixed_lsp_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0604270", "source_line": 570, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 1324, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Supersymmetric SO(10) mixed LSP-neutrino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family multi_component_dark_matter with production described as stable LSP cold component from unbroken matter parity.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; mixed cold warm phase space; mixed of small-scale power; mixed cold warm transfer behavior; probe classes: CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_0646_scalar_decay_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "0807_0646", "source_line": 882, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 84, "global_rank": 1325, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, decay produced phase-space behavior. Score is limited by little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_10356_spin_zero_no_freeze_in_no_freeze_out_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_10356", "source_line": 5716, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 1326, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Spin-zero no-freeze-in/no-freeze-out warm dark matter is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with yes relic-abundance support and suppression of small-scale power.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across Lyman-alpha forest, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 7.0, observational 7.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 3.5, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_10750_dark_u1_vector_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2001_10750", "source_line": 4150, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1327, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 21.5: speculative vector_higgs_portal_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: nonlinear structure-formation effect; inferred probe classes: direct detection, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_2164_oscillating_asymmetric_dark_matter_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1109_2164", "source_line": 1392, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 1328, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as asymmetric_dark_matter: production is represented by asymmetry generation related to baryogenesis-like dynamics; phase-space is nonthermal; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, cosmological phase-space, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by phenomenological_parameterization structure and the supplied production history; some cosmological or phase-space relevance is present; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_01368_bouncing_multicomponent_fermion_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_01368", "source_line": 5891, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 1329, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the bouncing two-component pNGB/fermion yield mechanism is distinctive and has partial micrOMEGAs support, but observables, constraints, and robust scan coverage are missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_1231_nnmsm_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1309_1231", "source_line": 1960, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1330, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_08231_qcd_axion_stochastic_window_v1", "paper_id": "2312_08231", "source_line": 5925, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 1331, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because QCD axion dark matter with quasi-flat stochastic inflationary misalignment is a emerging qcd_axion_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space information, none small-scale-power information, and CMB from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 14, observational leverage 6, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 5.5, penalties 15; raw score 21.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2106_04303_multi_bumpy_inflation_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2106_04303", "source_line": 4760, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 82, "global_rank": 1332, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: multi-peak inflationary enhancement of curvature perturbations; radiation-era PBH collapse in several mass ranges.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, mixed small-scale-power effect, not_applicable phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2106_04303_solo_bumpy_inflation_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2106_04303", "source_line": 4759, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 83, "global_rank": 1333, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: inflationary enhancement of curvature perturbations; radiation-era gravitational collapse.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, mixed small-scale-power effect, not_applicable phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0509121_lcsugra_bino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509121", "source_line": 535, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 1334, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because LCSUGRA Bino-like neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches bbn, cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_out_coscattering_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_08450_hidden_sector_coscattering_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1705_08450", "source_line": 3185, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1335, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 21.5: Hidden-sector coscattering dark matter is a emerging simplified model entry with thermal coscattering freeze-out.", "Rank-relevant positives are medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space treatment, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, CMB, collider.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_0221_model_independent_string_qcd_axion_domain_wall_one_v1", "paper_id": "1405_0221", "source_line": 2216, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 113, "global_rank": 1336, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete axion_like_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching CMB, axion searches.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_07625_alp_string_wall_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2103_07625", "source_line": 4620, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 114, "global_rank": 1337, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative axion like dark matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; some cosmological or phase-space leverage; probe classes inferred from card fields include CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, gravitational waves, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_11248_superweak_sterile_neutrino_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2104_11248", "source_line": 4629, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 85, "global_rank": 1338, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative sterile neutrino dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; some cosmological or phase-space leverage; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.... The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_14317_iss_nmssm_sneutrino_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1910_14317", "source_line": 4017, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 1339, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.1, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes limited explicit observational handles in the supplied card.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_03956_non_susy_so10_triplet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_03956", "source_line": 2877, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1340, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative electroweak_triplet_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; 2 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_07832_superheavy_vectorlike_doublet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2103_07832", "source_line": 4621, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1341, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative superheavy wimp dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1711_06129_double_inflation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1711_06129", "source_line": 3297, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 84, "global_rank": 1342, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial black holes candidate with phenomenological parameterization theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites, and additional probe classes.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 21.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_15541_affleck_dine_qball_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_15541", "source_line": 5748, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1343, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 78.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Affleck-Dine Q-ball gravitino dark matter in gauge-mediated MSSM is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, CMB, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 10.0, observational 3.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 4.5, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_03680_vector_portal_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_03680", "source_line": 5719, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1344, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: TeV-scale Majorana fermion dark matter with a massive vector portal is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 2.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 2.5, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_03680_vector_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_03680", "source_line": 5718, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1345, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: TeV-scale scalar dark matter with a massive vector portal is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 2.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 2.5, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_0941_so10_su5_nugm_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_0941", "source_line": 1376, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 1346, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out of the neutralino LSP; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_09494_hidden_u1_scalar_h2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_09494", "source_line": 4641, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1347, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative hidden sector scalar dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_6358_charged_excitation_case_b_scalar_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1209_6358", "source_line": 1670, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1348, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as co-annihilation with charged scalar excitation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 21.2 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=medium and CMB=unknown; card-implied probe classes include BBN, collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_01050_qcd_confinement_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_01050", "source_line": 4018, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 1349, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.8, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative effective_field_theory; rank-relevant evidence includes field_like phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_15555_bubbletron_heavy_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_15555", "source_line": 5710, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1350, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Bubbletron-produced heavy fermion dark matter is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and nonthermal phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 9.0, observational 2.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.2, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_1176_high_scale_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1408_1176", "source_line": 2249, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1351, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete q_ball_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamics.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family, uncommon production history, or distinctive phase-space category in the provided population context.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_04146_chameleon_scalaron_f_r_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_04146", "source_line": 3956, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1352, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 14, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for chameleon scalaron dark matter in F(R) gravity with R^2 correction: moderate observational leverage; inferred probe classes are BBN, galaxy satellites, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 21 (defer) uses production=coherent scalaron oscillations around the chameleon effective-potential minimum in the early universe; modified-gravity scalar degree of freedom from F(R)+R^2 dynamics; phase=field_like; CMB=unknown, BBN=high; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2004_06106_rapid_turn_multifield_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_06106", "source_line": 4259, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 85, "global_rank": 1353, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative primordial_black_holes card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via inflationary enhancement of curvature perturbations; post-inflation collapse of overdense regions into PBHs, small-scale-power enhancement.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_02793_nonthermal_fermionic_b_l_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1612_02793", "source_line": 2982, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 101, "global_rank": 1354, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include thermal-wimp-confusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_08064_self_interacting_higgs_portal_scalar_early_md_v1", "paper_id": "1803_08064", "source_line": 3433, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 1355, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance unknown/high; portals higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: combined_histories, nonstandard_cosmology."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_06161_fimpzilla_conformal_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2306_06161", "source_line": 5695, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 102, "global_rank": 1356, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because FIMPzilla scalar dark matter from a conformal sector (freeze_in_dark_matter) has nonthermal phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, other portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 21.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0511630_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0511630", "source_line": 626, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 86, "global_rank": 1357, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has strong card-level observational leverage from cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation fields, moderate diversity value within the population-count context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_11938_inelastic_scalar_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2006_11938", "source_line": 4286, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1358, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative inelastic_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via thermal freeze-out through p-wave annihilation into SM fermions via s-channel A'; late phi1-phi2 conversion freeze-out.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_07176_qcd_axion_early_matter_domination_v1", "paper_id": "1807_07176", "source_line": 3552, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 115, "global_rank": 1359, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with phenomenological-parameterization theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has field-like phase-space behavior, has enhancement in small-scale power.", "The main positive leverage comes from explicit cosmological or small-scale-structure fields rather than from a populated observable-routing block.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_09462_kerr_pbh_evaporated_non_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2207_09462", "source_line": 5238, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1360, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; suppression of small-scale power, yes associated-code support, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "string_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_07865_string_axion_pbh_coexistence_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_07865", "source_line": 3215, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1361, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: String axion dark matter coexisting with O(10) solar-mass primordial black holes is a speculative string_axion_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, enhanced_small_scale_power transfer behavior with enhancement small-scale effect, CMB/BBN relevance high/medium, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "atomic_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_2075_dark_atom_sidm_dao_benchmark_v1", "paper_id": "1405_2075", "source_line": 2198, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1362, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines benchmark status, simplified_model theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space entry, approximate distribution-function support, and mixed small-scale-power effect.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_5120_quantum_environment_dark_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1304_5120", "source_line": 1782, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 1363, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 21: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, family multi_component_dark_matter, and relic-production flag no.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance medium; BBN relevance high; small-scale-power effect suppression; transfer function mixed_cold_warm; phase-space type mixed_cold_warm; complementarity probes counted as BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 220; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1010_5417_majoron_axion_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1010_5417", "source_line": 1204, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 116, "global_rank": 1364, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family axion_like_dark_matter with production via cold axion dark matter scenario assessed through axion mass compatibility; production mechanism not specified in detail.", "Observational leverage is driven by field_like phase space; probe classes: Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, galaxy satellites.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2111_15280_quantum_well_stochastic_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_15280", "source_line": 4916, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 86, "global_rank": 1365, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Quantum-well stochastic-inflation primordial black hole dark matter is speculative with phenomenological_parameterization theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by not_applicable phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0504096_bulk_shortcut_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0504096", "source_line": 600, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 87, "global_rank": 1366, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Bulk-shortcut sterile-neutrino warm dark matter is a speculative simplified model card in family sterile_neutrino_dark_matter with production described as resonant active-to-sterile conversion when the early-Universe temperature drops below the brane-bulk resonance energy.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space; suppression of small-scale power; smooth cutoff transfer behavior; probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_04426_condensed_axion_cooling_v1", "paper_id": "1805_04426", "source_line": 3511, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 117, "global_rank": 1367, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has field_like phase-space production; it touches CMB, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_13298_e6_two_component_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1911_13298", "source_line": 4076, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 21 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 1368, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative multi_component_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'unknown', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: BBN, collider/fixed-target.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0104173_bino_neutralino_cdm_damping_cutoff_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0104173", "source_line": 403, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 1369, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, cosmology or structure-formation leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: cmb, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_03216_su2d_vector_multipole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_03216", "source_line": 4296, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1370, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative vector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via thermal freeze-out of W_D^+/- vectors.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0303564_baryonic_chaplygin_quartessence_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0303564", "source_line": 420, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1371, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, cosmology or structure-formation leverage, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive model class; probe signal: cmb, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_4138_pq_leptoquark_diquark_mixed_axion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1308_4138", "source_line": 1977, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 1372, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_4138_pq_scotogenic_mixed_axion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1308_4138", "source_line": 1976, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 1373, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_04087_sterile_neutrino_bminusl_vector_nsi_v1", "paper_id": "2111_04087", "source_line": 4895, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 88, "global_rank": 1374, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high BBN relevance; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior; nonthermal phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_04087_sterile_neutrino_neutrinophilic_vector_nsi_v1", "paper_id": "2111_04087", "source_line": 4894, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 89, "global_rank": 1375, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high BBN relevance; suppression of small-scale power; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior; nonthermal phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_6586_cold_wavelike_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1406_6586", "source_line": 169, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 1376, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 21.0 for fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter: positive factors include emerging status, carded ability to supply all dark matter, field_like phase-space behavior, smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior, suppression in small-scale power, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; current-data compatibility is unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_13376_qcd_domain_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_13376", "source_line": 5805, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 90, "global_rank": 1377, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is resonant active-neutrino to sterile-neutrino conversion in matter-antimatter domains.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, gravitational waves/defects, indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, with phase-space/structure entries (resonant, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_00037_electron_flavored_dirac_dm_model_ii_v1", "paper_id": "1712_00037", "source_line": 3383, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1378, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative lepton_flavored_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_3116_next_minimal_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1203_3116", "source_line": 1512, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1379, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and higgs portal dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, direct detection, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "baryon_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_01316_density_dependent_baryon_dm_cooling_v1", "paper_id": "1712_01316", "source_line": 3368, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1380, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative baryon_interacting_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_0683_many_body_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_0683", "source_line": 2262, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 1381, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative decaying_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and not_applicable phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, non-CDM structure-formation behavior, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_statistics_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_07289_parafermionic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1807_07289", "source_line": 3548, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1382, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it touches collider / fixed-target, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_03631_type_i_seesaw_majoron_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1903_03631", "source_line": 3773, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1383, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 21 because the card identifies production via not specified in detail in the assigned text; treated as a viable w..., suppression small-scale-power behavior, probe classes: CMB, small-scale structure; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_1782_rpv_axino_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1403_1782", "source_line": 2061, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1384, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of axino_warm_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; non-CDM small-scale structure information; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_02122_kalb_ramond_gravitational_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_02122", "source_line": 5681, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 118, "global_rank": 1385, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Kalb-Ramond gravitational axion dark matter from heavy sterile fermions (axion_like_dark_matter) has field like phase-space information, axion, neutrino, gravitational, other portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 21.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hot_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9910349_two_neutrino_hot_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9910349", "source_line": 6103, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1386, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 21 (defer) from supplied card content: hot_neutrino_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and no all-DM production; non-CDM linear structure information (suppression, smooth_cutoff); cosmological relevance: CMB medium, BBN medium.", "Penalties (17) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_05859_superheavy_asymmetric_thermal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1701_05859", "source_line": 3100, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 1387, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance high, CMB relevance low; inferred probe classes: BBN, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_absorption_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_12635_fermionic_absorption_charged_current_v1", "paper_id": "1905_12635", "source_line": 3831, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1388, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory model with production listed as thermal production, relativistic decoupling.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_04769_long_lived_stau_coannihilation_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_04769", "source_line": 2752, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 1389, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal coannihilation; late stau decay into neutralino LSP during BBN-era cosmology; portals: vector, other; BBN relevance is critical; phase-space type is decay_produced.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_12624_z3_complex_scalar_inflaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_12624", "source_line": 5251, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1390, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Z3 complex scalar inflaton-dark-matter model: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out with Z3 semi-annihilation; scalar-portal interactions, thermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for scalar_portal_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_05487_minimal_light_lepton_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_05487", "source_line": 5275, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1391, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Minimal light lepton portal dark matter: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out; annihilation into active neutrinos in the light lepton-portal setup, thermal phase space, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection), family/diversity context for lepton_portal_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_05487_singlet_extended_light_lepton_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_05487", "source_line": 5276, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1392, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Singlet-extended light lepton portal dark matter: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out; annihilation into active neutrinos mediated by the singlet-like scalar s, thermal phase space, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection), family/diversity context for lepton_portal_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "astro_ph0302035_massive_primordial_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0302035", "source_line": 432, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 87, "global_rank": 1393, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, cosmology or structure-formation leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: cmb, compact objects, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_2478_inert_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0912_2478", "source_line": 1030, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 91, "global_rank": 1394, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 21 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from observational leverage, multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness, registry diversity value, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family sterile_neutrino_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and mixed_cold_warm phase-space history, suppression small-scale-power behavior, probe handles: Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2303_16035_transient_constant_roll_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2303_16035", "source_line": 5562, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 88, "global_rank": 1395, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the PBH mechanism has multi-probe potential through compact-object and early-universe signatures, but this card gives sparse observational and computational support.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_gauge_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_05632_gauged_two_higgs_doublet_scalar_d_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_05632", "source_line": 3510, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1396, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a UV-complete model card; it touches collider / fixed-target, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2203_12332_regular_black_hole_remnant_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_12332", "source_line": 5109, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 89, "global_rank": 1397, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a macroscopic PBH-remnant scenario with high BBN relevance, but follow-up value is limited by phenomenological production assumptions and missing observable/constraint content."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_decay_product_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_02225_decay_product_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_02225", "source_line": 4270, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1398, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative superheavy_decay_product_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via nonthermal production from decays of gravitationally produced superheavy chi particles, decay_produced phase-space treatment, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_11645_susy_dfsz_extended_e_i_mixed_axion_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2303_11645", "source_line": 5557, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 1399, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the extended DFSZ mixed-component model is somewhat less duplicative than the base variants, but still lacks concrete observable, constraint, route, benchmark, or code support.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0003046_self_interacting_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0003046", "source_line": 408, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1400, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, cosmology or structure-formation leverage, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive model class, partial computational support from associated code or calculations; probe signal: small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_14660_gravitational_genesis_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_14660", "source_line": 4900, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 1401, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from effective_field_theory theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; suppression of small-scale power; mixed_cold_warm transfer-function behavior; mixed_cold_warm phase-space production; distinct production or phase-space niche in the population context.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05349_ethos_1_benchmark_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05349", "source_line": 298, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 1402, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as ETHOS-1 interacting dark-matter dark-radiation benchmark, a speculative self interacting dark matter entry with benchmark mapping theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, oscillatory transfer behavior, nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: benchmark_mapping_only."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2420_ussm_a_neutralino_gauged_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2420", "source_line": 1220, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 1403, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative simplified_model card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production via thermal neutralino decoupling; co-annihilation can reduce neutralino relic density when available.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB and unknown BBN relevance; probe classes: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_5114_e6ssm_inert_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1012_5114", "source_line": 1221, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 1404, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 77.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out with Z-resonance annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB and unknown BBN relevance; probe classes: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0709_4593_rpv_gravitino_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0709_4593", "source_line": 708, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 1405, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; BBN high and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, gravitational/cosmology, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_00711_hidden_sector_nucleon_compact_star_v1", "paper_id": "1908_00711", "source_line": 3954, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1406, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for interacting hidden-sector nucleon compact-star dark matter: high diversity value; inferred probe classes are compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, galaxy satellites, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 21 (defer) uses production=hidden-sector baryogenesis/asymmetric dark matter assumed; gravitational collapse into compact stars from degenerate hidden nucleons; phase=unknown; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_2962_z4_two_sector_scalar_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1202_2962", "source_line": 1521, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 1407, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and multi component dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_00513_leptoquark_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_00513", "source_line": 2456, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 92, "global_rank": 1408, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=sterile_neutrino_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from phase_space=nonthermal; small_scale_power_effect=suppression; transfer_function_shape=smooth_cutoff.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=170, diversity_value=6.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_15322_qcd_axion_reheating_misalignment_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_15322", "source_line": 5783, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1409, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because QCD axion dark matter from misalignment during inflationary reheating has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include BBN, axion/laboratory searches, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: requires_reheating_era_oscillation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_4866_secluded_wimp_rh_neutrino_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "0711_4866", "source_line": 750, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1410, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; BBN critical and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_4866_secluded_wimp_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "0711_4866", "source_line": 749, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1411, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; BBN critical and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_4866_secluded_wimp_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "0711_4866", "source_line": 748, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1412, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; BBN critical and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_01823_two_scalar_z2_higgs_portal_no_cross_couplings_v1", "paper_id": "1906_01823", "source_line": 3868, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1413, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A Standard Model extension with two real singlet scalars s and s prime, where a Z2 symmetry stabilizes the lighter scalar s as thermal Higgs-portal dark matter; The variant sets the singlet-only cross-couplings lambda...", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB high; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_01823_two_scalar_z2_higgs_portal_with_cross_couplings_v1", "paper_id": "1906_01823", "source_line": 3869, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1414, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A Standard Model extension with two real singlet scalars s and s prime, where a Z2 symmetry stabilizes the lighter scalar s as thermal Higgs-portal dark matter; The variant includes dimensionless singlet-only s-s' cro...", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB high; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "curvature_coupled_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_09836_curvature_coupled_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_09836", "source_line": 3876, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1415, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / effective_field_theory: A light scalar or pseudoscalar dark matter field whose cosmological evolution is modified by a non-minimal coupling to the Ricci scalar during inflation.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN unknown; CMB high; phase-space field_like; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superfluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_10286_two_body_superfluid_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2302_10286", "source_line": 5551, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1416, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the card gives a rare superfluid black-hole-density-profile variant with validity and robustness notes, but no observable list, constraints, routing, or code support.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_13063_higgs_r2_singlet_scalar_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2202_13063", "source_line": 5066, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 103, "global_rank": 1417, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 21 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: strong science/relic-density basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB, direct/lab.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: inflation/reheating, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: freeze-in from thermal SM/Higgs scattering after reheating; freeze-in from thermal scattering during reheating."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_03145_qcd_axion_mediated_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_03145", "source_line": 5675, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 90, "global_rank": 1418, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 14, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because QCD axion-mediated Dirac fermion dark matter (hidden_sector_dark_matter) has CMB/BBN relevance, axion portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 21.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_00585_z2_scalar_neutrino_mass_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1801_00585", "source_line": 3380, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1419, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_05676_lsidm_vectorlike_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2310_05676", "source_line": 5821, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 1420, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative uv_complete model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out in a fast-expanding non-standard cosmology.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_14594_scalar_mediated_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_14594", "source_line": 5772, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 91, "global_rank": 1421, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Scalar-mediated Dirac fermion dark matter with Higgs portal has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include CMB/cosmic-dawn, axion/laboratory searches, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_04371_dark_pair_plasma_vectorlike_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_04371", "source_line": 2426, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 1422, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a self_interacting_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); structure fields include suppression power with a unknown transfer-function entry; cosmological relevance is CMB=medium, BBN=unknown; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, compact objects / dynamics, galaxy satellites, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_09018_majorana_dm_quark_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1605_09018", "source_line": 2866, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1423, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; medium CMB relevance; 4 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_energy_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0407196_interacting_quintessence_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0407196", "source_line": 248, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1424, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative interacting_dark_energy_cold_dark_matter entry with simplified_model; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=medium, transfer_function=scale_dependent_growth, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: BBN, CMB, precision/fifth-force.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_03126_thermalized_boosted_millicharged_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_03126", "source_line": 5342, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 1425, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 21.0: multi_component_dark_matter with asymmetric dark-sector abundance; heavy and light MCPs later thermalize in the galactic halo; science=9.0, observational leverage=6.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) and diversity=6.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_08121_high_scale_susy_wino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1712_08121", "source_line": 3352, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1426, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is low/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_09566_mirror_baryon_pbh_evaporation_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_09566", "source_line": 5303, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 1427, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 21.0: multi_component_dark_matter with Hawking radiation from evaporating light PBHs; science=11.0, observational leverage=6.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics) and diversity=5.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_05967_dark_u1x_majorana_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1806_05967", "source_line": 3541, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 92, "global_rank": 1428, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a simplified-model implementation; it touches collider / fixed-target, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_07204_su6_so6_composite_pngb_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_07204", "source_line": 5546, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1429, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_04372_gravitational_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2105_04372", "source_line": 4735, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1430, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravitational_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production via Hawking evaporation of primordial black holes; graviton-mediated standard model particle scatterings.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN, CMB, compact objects/dynamics; the raw score is 21 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Diversity credit is elevated because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive family or production regime in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_06494_hidden_dirac_fermion_dark_photon_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_06494", "source_line": 4717, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 1431, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via freeze-in production of D and anti-D through feeble visible-hidden couplings; multi-temperature hidden-sector evolution.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN, CMB, structure formation; the raw score is 21 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9903542_superheavy_inflation_relic_x_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9903542", "source_line": 6115, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1432, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 21 (defer) from supplied card content: superheavy_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior; non-CDM linear structure information (unknown, scale_dependent_growth); cosmological relevance: CMB medium.", "Penalties (17) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_06469_majorana_majoron_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_06469", "source_line": 5859, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 119, "global_rank": 1433, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because it connects Majoron dark matter to neutrino mass and baryogenesis with field-like production, while direct observables, constraints, routing, and code are not supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_3636_nonthermal_split_susy_wimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1312_3636", "source_line": 2007, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1434, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=decay_produced, and structure effect=unknown/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0412200_nonthermal_wino_anomaly_mediated_nmssm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0412200", "source_line": 542, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1435, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Nonthermal wino dark matter in UV-insensitive anomaly-mediated NMSSM extension is a speculative simplified model card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (decay produced; small-scale effect none); it touches bbn, cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_02117_phase_transition_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_02117", "source_line": 3040, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 1436, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Generative-sector first-order phase-transition asymmetric dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has some cosmological, phase-space, or halo-structure leverage; uses a nonthermal phase-space history; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0618_symmetric_light_mediator_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0618", "source_line": 1899, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 1437, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a benchmark simplified-model model with self-interacting production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonlinear structure-formation effects.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching BBN, CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites / small-scale structure, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9809547_bosonic_superheavy_x_vacuum_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9809547", "source_line": 6143, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1438, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 21 (defer) from supplied card content: superheavy_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior; non-CDM linear structure information (unknown, scale_dependent_growth); cosmological relevance: CMB medium.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_5647_axion_mediated_dirac_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1212_5647", "source_line": 1700, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1439, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out through axion-mediated annihilation; resonantly enhanced present-day annihilation to gamma gamma, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 21 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, indirect detection, laboratory precision; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_07022_lepton_portal_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2204_07022", "source_line": 5121, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1440, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a lepton-portal thermal relic with explicit coannihilation validity and high provenance; no structured observables, constraints, routing, or code lowers priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_06869_so10_u1_higgs_portal_singlet_doublet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_06869", "source_line": 3900, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1441, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A non-supersymmetric SO(10) U(1) GUT where an unbroken Z2 leaves the lightest neutral linear combination of new 10-plet doublet and singlet fermions stable as Higgs-portal dark matter.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN low; CMB low; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_2326_pq_mssm_axino_thermal_inflation_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1004_2326", "source_line": 1098, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1442, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete axino_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium, BBN high); nonthermal phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_06987_complex_singlet_cp_z2_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_06987", "source_line": 3546, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 1443, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it touches collider / fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves / defects, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_03166_annihilation_product_direct_detection_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1501_03166", "source_line": 2311, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 93, "global_rank": 1444, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 21 because the assigned model card phenomenological parameterization hidden_sector_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; uses nonthermal phase-space information; touches BBN, CMB, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "u1x_scalar_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_03333_u1x_dark_sector_scalar_phi0_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_03333", "source_line": 2762, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1445, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in u1x_scalar_dark_sector_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal annihilation dominated by t-channel vector-like lepton exchange; nonthermal production required if phi0 is to be all dark matter in the diphoton-compatible parameter region; portals: vector, higgs, other; CMB relevance is medium.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_08375_quintet_minimal_dark_matter_higgs_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "2307_08375", "source_line": 5773, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1446, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because SU(2)_L quintet fermion minimal dark matter with Higgs inflation has strong theory or relic-density motivation; card-internal probe cues include CMB/cosmic-dawn, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_b_minus_l_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_14053_b3_l2_dirac_rh_neutrino_thermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_14053", "source_line": 5777, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1447, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because B_3-L_2 Dirac right-handed-neutrino thermal dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_4313_late_scalar_decay_wino_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "0807_4313", "source_line": 853, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1448, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_02718_gauge_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_02718", "source_line": 3951, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1449, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Gauge-singlet Z2-odd scalar dark matter in a lepton-specific U(1)_X two-Higgs-doublet model: strong model-card science motivation, some associated-code support; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 21 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out; scalar portal annihilation; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_00007_fermionic_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_00007", "source_line": 3411, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1450, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals neutrino, higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; only partial associated-code support; warnings: candidate_branching, constraints_omitted."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_00007_scalar_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_00007", "source_line": 3412, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1451, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals neutrino, higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; only partial associated-code support; warnings: candidate_branching, constraints_omitted."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_08615_neutrinophilic_thdm_z3_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_08615", "source_line": 3424, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1452, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance low/unknown; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs, neutrino, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; only partial associated-code support; warnings: symmetry_label_ambiguity, scenario_not_separate_model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_02977_vector_dm_top_partner_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1703_02977", "source_line": 3072, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1453, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative coannihilating_vector_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, indirect detection, laboratory precision.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_08470_scale_invariant_su2x_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_08470", "source_line": 2787, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1454, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in hidden_vector_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal WIMP freeze-out; annihilation and semiannihilation; portals: higgs, vector.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "u1_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_08067_u1_ay_bq_dark_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2204_08067", "source_line": 5127, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1455, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a rare U(1) vector-portal thermal relic with resonance-sensitive freeze-out; absent observables/routing and moderate warnings keep it in tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_01214_scotogenic_inert_scalar_top_fcnc_v1", "paper_id": "2204_01214", "source_line": 5130, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1456, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a UV-complete scotogenic inert-scalar model tied to top FCNC phenomenology, but relic and observational mappings are not implemented in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_3578_short_lived_pgb_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1312_3578", "source_line": 2035, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1457, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=partial and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_06471_neutrino_philic_twin_2hdm_cogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2005_06471", "source_line": 4204, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 1458, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection; high CMB relevance; high or critical BBN relevance; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inflaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_5021_chaotic_braneworld_inflaton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0906_5021", "source_line": 962, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1459, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative inflaton_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance; field_like phase-space history; probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_04227_asymptotically_safe_quintuplet_minimal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_04227", "source_line": 3895, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1460, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: N_F copies of hypercharge-zero SU(2)_L fermion quintuplets developed as the n=5 asymptotically safe minimal-dark-matter variant.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN low; CMB low; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_04227_asymptotically_safe_triplet_minimal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_04227", "source_line": 3894, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1461, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: N_F copies of hypercharge-zero SU(2)_L fermion triplets whose neutral components are thermally produced WIMP dark matter.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN low; CMB low; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_00705_dark_sector_seeded_nelson_barr_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2303_00705", "source_line": 5567, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1462, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the Nelson-Barr scalar WIMP has strong theory motivation and rare-family value, but the supplied card is observationally sparse and has no route, constraint, or code support.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_03866_y0_inert_triplet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2111_03866", "source_line": 4931, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1463, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Z2-odd Y=0 inert SU(2) triplet scalar dark matter is benchmark with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: gravitational waves.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_10415_bl_origin_qcd_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2005_10415", "source_line": 4210, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 1464, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, axion or strong-CP connection, early-universe production connection; field_like phase-space information; high CMB relevance; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_6189_split_neutrino_sneutrino_inflaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_6189", "source_line": 1482, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1465, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 76.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable sneutrino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out of the lightest right-handed sneutrino after reheating.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0509128_deflected_amsb_bino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509128", "source_line": 508, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1466, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Deflected anomaly-mediated bino neutralino dark matter is a speculative simplified model card with either relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_02669_boosted_two_component_pseudoscalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1503_02669", "source_line": 2433, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1467, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a boosted_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is mixed_cold_warm; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0407646_scalar_tensor_dm_baryon_relaxation_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0407646", "source_line": 514, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1468, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Scalar-tensor dynamical relaxation of the dark-matter-to-baryon ratio is a speculative effective field theory card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches bbn, cmb, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2207_11502_alpha_attractor_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2207_11502", "source_line": 5304, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 90, "global_rank": 1469, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 21.0: primordial_black_holes with inflationary ultra-slow-roll enhancement of scalar perturbations; science=14.0, observational leverage=3.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2207_11502_canonical_kahler_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2207_11502", "source_line": 5305, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 91, "global_rank": 1470, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 21.0: primordial_black_holes with inflationary ultra-slow-roll enhancement of scalar perturbations; science=14.0, observational leverage=3.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_06506_fermionic_dm_pseudoscalar_mediator_ewbg_v1", "paper_id": "1703_06506", "source_line": 3077, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 1471, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance low; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_4749_s3_inert_doublet_split_h2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_4749", "source_line": 2223, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1472, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete inert_doublet_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_05583_so10_scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1602_05583", "source_line": 2791, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 1473, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in higgs_portal_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: standard thermal freeze-out through the Higgs portal; portals: higgs.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_2964_nmssm_pamela_neutralino_resonance_v1", "paper_id": "0905_2964", "source_line": 993, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1474, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_5738_higgs_portal_singlet_scalar_rh_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1405_5738", "source_line": 2219, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 1475, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete higgs_portal_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching CMB, collider, direct detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_scalar_cogenesis_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_0287_susy_scalar_n1_cogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1305_0287", "source_line": 1819, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1476, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative nonthermal_scalar_cogenesis_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is nonthermal; BBN relevance is medium.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on BBN, direct detection, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "charged_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_13677_nonlinear_charged_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2004_13677", "source_line": 4215, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1477, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, early-universe production connection, structure or tension connection; high CMB relevance; explicit probe classes from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_05431_hidden_supersymmetric_n1_sym_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2304_05431", "source_line": 5639, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 94, "global_rank": 1478, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because hidden supersymmetric Yang-Mills dark sector with UV-complete composite motivation and qualitative self-interactions.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "so10_netdm", "model_id": "1502_06929_so10_netdm_model_i_dirac_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1502_06929", "source_line": 2431, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1479, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a so10_netdm entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is nonthermal; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "so10_netdm", "model_id": "1502_06929_so10_netdm_model_ii_weyl_adjoint_v1", "paper_id": "1502_06929", "source_line": 2432, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1480, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a so10_netdm entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is nonthermal; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_07943_kk_gauge_boson_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_07943", "source_line": 5391, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1481, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Kaluza-Klein gauge boson dark matter from brane-world quantum gravity has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: CMB, phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_12606_sterile_neutrino_higgs_portal_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2003_12606", "source_line": 4229, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1482, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include early-universe production connection, neutrino-sector connection, phase-transition or confinement connection; nonthermal phase-space information; the card says it can produce all dark matter; explicit probe classes from card fields: CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_0770_next_to_minimal_supergravity_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0808_0770", "source_line": 863, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 1483, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_10898_type_ii_scalar_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_10898", "source_line": 5717, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 1484, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Type-II radiative scalar triplet dark matter with vector-like lepton doublets is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 9.0, observational 2.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 1.0, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_14882_light_2hdm_scalar_forbidden_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_14882", "source_line": 5328, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1485, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 21.0: forbidden_dark_matter with thermal freeze-out; science=13.0, observational leverage=2.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection) and diversity=6.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_05377_melting_cosmic_string_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_05377", "source_line": 4793, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 1486, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative scalar_field_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: inverse phase transition production of coherent scalar oscillations.", "Observational leverage is driven by field_like phase-space distribution.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_vector_wimp", "model_id": "2308_16390_minimal_dark_u1_vector_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2308_16390", "source_line": 5824, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1487, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative uv_complete model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out of vector dark matter through A' A' -> phi phi in the dark sector.", "Follow-up value comes from direct/collider, gravitational waves/defects, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_00715_gauge_mediated_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1502_00715", "source_line": 2429, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1488, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a q_ball_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is nonthermal; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_lsp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_13963_lsp_hilltop_supernatural_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "2003_13963", "source_line": 4212, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1489, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, early-universe production connection, larger-framework connection; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: BBN, CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_03507_hidden_sector_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1501_03507", "source_line": 2379, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 1490, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal freeze-out through annihilation to light vector mediators production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection, small-scale structure.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_fermion_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_05375_triplet_fermion_dm_type_iii_seesaw_higgs_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "1501_05375", "source_line": 2319, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1491, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 21 because the assigned model card simplified model minimal_fermion_multiplet_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; touches CMB, direct detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_wimp", "model_id": "2210_05380_lowest_energy_higgson_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2210_05380", "source_line": 5324, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1492, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 21.0: electroweak_wimp with thermal freezeout relic-density matching; science=10.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection, stellar streams) and diversity=7.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "accidental_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_00508_accidental_real_singlet_z2_v1", "paper_id": "1502_00508", "source_line": 2414, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1493, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a accidental_scalar_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_3967_asymmetric_inelastic_scalar_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1108_3967", "source_line": 1371, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1494, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as asymmetric_inert_doublet_dark_matter: production is represented by asymmetric dark matter from out-of-equilibrium scalar-triplet decays; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection, neutrino/cosmology.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "littlest_higgs_t_parity_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_06195_simplified_nlht_heavy_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_06195", "source_line": 5311, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1495, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 21.0: littlest_higgs_t_parity_dark_matter with thermal freeze-out with co-annihilation; science=14.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection, stellar streams) and diversity=7.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_03429_heavy_dark_photon_vll_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2107_03429", "source_line": 4783, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1496, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated benchmark vector_dark_photon_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out; co-annihilation with vector-like leptons in the compressed regime.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_06783_gev_mixed_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1503_06783", "source_line": 2408, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 21.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1497, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a sneutrino_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; feasibility support scores 1 from code or analytic representation fields; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 21.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_10805_ulap_oscillon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1909_10805", "source_line": 4005, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 1498, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.4, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes non-CDM structure-formation behavior, field_like phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_3891_u1r_u1bl_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_3891", "source_line": 1652, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1499, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.8, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out of a sneutrino LSP; coannihilation or s-channel resonance in parts of parameter space, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 20.8 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_12762_type_ii_seesaw_asymmetric_dirac_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1910_12762", "source_line": 4015, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 1500, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative effective_field_theory; rank-relevant evidence includes limited explicit observational handles in the supplied card.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_02981_hidden_gauged_su3_multispecies_v1", "paper_id": "1911_02981", "source_line": 4030, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 1501, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.6, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes limited explicit observational handles in the supplied card.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_1109_thermal_fermion_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_1109", "source_line": 1952, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 1502, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 16, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: small-scale structure; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_6291_dw_sterile_neutrino_wdm_halo_model_v1", "paper_id": "1109_6291", "source_line": 1434, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 1503, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 20.5 because the card describes warm dark matter at phenomenological parameterization level, with Dodelson-Widrow thermally-produced sterile-neutrino warm dark matter as adopted by the paper and medium CMB relevance, suppression in small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer-function shape with partial associated-code support.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_04625_fermion_millicharged_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2002_04625", "source_line": 4194, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 1504, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of millicharged_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space information.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity credit reflects a comparatively distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or dominant probe class in the population context.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2403_04054_extremal_kerr_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_04054", "source_line": 60, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 92, "global_rank": 1505, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this primordial_black_holes card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_scalar_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1012_1175_bolon_coupled_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1012_1175", "source_line": 81, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1506, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this coupled_scalar_dark_matter_dark_energy card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, suppression in small-scale power, field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0502211_neutralino_from_heavy_gravitino_decay_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0502211", "source_line": 530, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1507, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Neutralino dark matter from heavy gravitino decay is a speculative simplified model card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (decay produced; small-scale effect none); it touches bbn, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_scalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03238_flavor_specific_scalar_secluded_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03238", "source_line": 4642, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1508, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative secluded scalar mediator dark matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and relic support marked yes; some cosmological or phase-space leverage; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_4749_s3_two_inert_doublet_degenerate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_4749", "source_line": 2222, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 1509, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete multi_component_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_06089_cp_pq_scotogenic_inert_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_06089", "source_line": 4753, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 1510, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out/coannihilation of inert scalar; axion misalignment/string contribution as a possible subcomponent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_3945_composite_inelastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0903_3945", "source_line": 892, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1511, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_03631_fnpq_dfsz_type_i_flavored_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2102_03631", "source_line": 4603, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 120, "global_rank": 1512, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative axion like dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_03631_fnpq_dfsz_type_ii_flavored_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2102_03631", "source_line": 4604, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 121, "global_rank": 1513, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative axion like dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_3692_hypercharge_impure_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_3692", "source_line": 2218, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1514, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative higgsino_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_02953_dfsz_axion_higgs_model_v1", "paper_id": "1503_02953", "source_line": 2406, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 122, "global_rank": 1515, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 17}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a axion_like_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is field_like; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sexaquark_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_03123_deeply_bound_sexaquark_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2306_03123", "source_line": 5701, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1516, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Deeply bound uuddss sexaquark dark matter is a speculative uv_complete card with yes relic-abundance support and medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 11.0, observational 1.0, complementarity 8.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.5, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_12663_fermionic_u1x_higgs_charge_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_12663", "source_line": 5747, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1517, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Fermionic U(1)_X dark matter with Higgs charge and kinetic mixing is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 9.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 2.5, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_abelian_vector_boson_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_2631_neutral_su2n_vector_boson_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1007_2631", "source_line": 1186, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1518, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 20.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, distinctive or underrepresented model-space coverage, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_09494_hidden_u1_fermionic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_09494", "source_line": 4640, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1519, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative hidden sector fermion dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_07263_planet_9_axion_star_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_07263", "source_line": 5733, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 123, "global_rank": 1520, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Planet 9 axion-star dark matter subcomponent is a speculative effective_field_theory card with no relic-abundance support and field_like phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across compact objects/dynamics, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves, indirect detection, laboratory precision; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 7.0, observational 3.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.2, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_02080_axiogenesis_rotating_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1910_02080", "source_line": 4014, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 124, "global_rank": 1521, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.1, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative effective_field_theory; rank-relevant evidence includes field_like phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fifth_force_clumped_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_05300_primordial_fifth_force_dm_halos_v1", "paper_id": "1906_05300", "source_line": 129, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1522, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative fifth_force_clumped_dark_matter card with simplified model theory-level support and high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, enhancement small-scale-power effect, enhanced small scale power transfer behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2401_09408_qcd_pbh_aborted_baryogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2401_09408", "source_line": 246, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 93, "global_rank": 1523, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=medium, transfer_function=enhanced_small_scale_power, small_scale_power_effect=enhancement, and probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamical.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: baryogenesis_dm_link_model_dependent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_12264_cointeracting_conformal_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_12264", "source_line": 5010, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 1524, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Co-interacting conformal two-component dark matter has strong supplied observational leverage; probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_05437_faser_fermionic_dark_sector_cascade_v1", "paper_id": "2006_05437", "source_line": 4279, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 95, "global_rank": 1525, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via thermal freeze-out through Y anti-Y annihilation to neutral intermediates.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_05437_faser_scalar_dark_sector_cascade_v1", "paper_id": "2006_05437", "source_line": 4280, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 96, "global_rank": 1526, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 75.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via thermal freeze-out through scalar Y Y annihilation to neutral intermediates.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_matter_dark_radiation_conversion", "model_id": "2011_04606_late_time_dmdr_conversion_v1", "paper_id": "2011_04606", "source_line": 4474, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1527, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Higher local observational leverage from cosmological or structure-formation fields in the supplied card for dark_matter_dark_radiation_conversion.", "Diversity credit comes from decay_produced phase-space history, suppression small-scale-power effect, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is helped by yes associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 20.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter_chaplygin_gas", "model_id": "astro-ph0310181_inhomogeneous_chaplygin_condensate_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0310181", "source_line": 461, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1528, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; suppression small-scale-power effect; oscillatory transfer behavior; field_like phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0609081_higgs_singlet_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0609081", "source_line": 642, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 93, "global_rank": 1529, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has strong card-level observational leverage from cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation fields, moderate diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hybrid_chaplygin_gas", "model_id": "astro-ph0503428_hybrid_chaplygin_gas_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0503428", "source_line": 8, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1530, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_axion_like_oscillon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_13504_ulap_oscillon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2010_13504", "source_line": 4456, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1531, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Higher local observational leverage from cosmological or structure-formation fields in the supplied card for ultralight_axion_like_oscillon_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from field_like phase-space history, mixed small-scale-power effect, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 20.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dissipative_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_09359_mirror_dark_plasma_steady_state_halo_v1", "paper_id": "1801_09359", "source_line": 3381, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1532, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative dissipative_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_0506_spin_3_2_effective_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1201_0506", "source_line": 1544, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1533, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, effective field theory theory level, and effective field theory dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, direct detection, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_13358_starobinsky_hidden_scalar_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2105_13358", "source_line": 4744, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 97, "global_rank": 1534, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via nonthermal pair production from scalaron decay.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB, structure formation; the raw score is 20 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1912_13326_pbh_eeftoi_dispersion_v1", "paper_id": "1912_13326", "source_line": 4123, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 94, "global_rank": 1535, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 20: speculative primordial_black_holes card with effective_field_theory theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: nonlinear structure-formation effect, compact-object/PBH phenomenology; inferred probe classes: compact objects, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_05868_neutrino_self_interaction_sterile_freezein_v1", "paper_id": "2111_05868", "source_line": 4906, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 94, "global_rank": 1536, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Neutrino self-interaction assisted sterile-neutrino freeze-in dark matter is benchmark with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by nonthermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: indirect detection.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_18524_pq_inflation_axion_dm_higher_dimensional_v1", "paper_id": "2305_18524", "source_line": 5678, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 125, "global_rank": 1537, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because PQ inflation axion dark matter with higher-dimensional operators (axion_like_dark_matter) has field like phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, axion, gravitational portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 20.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_1232_s3_schizophrenic_neutrino_rh_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1232", "source_line": 1202, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1538, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative simplified_model card in family sneutrino_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out for the lightest right-handed sneutrino when B-L is broken around the TeV scale.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB and medium BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "baryonic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_09913_scalar_hexaquark_s_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_09913", "source_line": 3820, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1539, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with production listed as thermal production before primordial nucleosynthesis, freeze-out of a compact baryonic composite.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_absorption_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_12635_fermionic_absorption_neutral_current_v1", "paper_id": "1905_12635", "source_line": 3830, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1540, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory model with production listed as thermal production, relativistic decoupling.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_12430_su2d_gauge_boson_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2208_12430", "source_line": 5264, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 98, "global_rank": 1541, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for SU(2)_D isospin-charged gauge-boson dark matter: speculative status, uv-complete theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out through forbidden dark-gauge-boson annihilation, thermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for hidden_sector_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2009_04731_clustered_primordial_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_04731", "source_line": 4384, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 95, "global_rank": 1542, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Clustered primordial black-hole dark matter: formation by collapse of large overdensities at horizon re-entry after inflation; strong cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage, good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, compact-object/dynamics, structure formation.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "u1_prime_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_5934_u1_prime_extra_doublet_fermion_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_5934", "source_line": 1513, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1543, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and u1 prime cold dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5717_type_iii_seesaw_darkon_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5717", "source_line": 1526, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1544, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and higgs portal scalar dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_moduli_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_03025_multi_moduli_prompt_annihilation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_03025", "source_line": 3864, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1545, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: A nonthermal hidden-sector dark matter scenario in which multiple moduli decay to dark matter and dark radiation, with prompt dark matter annihilation to dark radiation reducing overproduction.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN critical; CMB medium; phase-space decay_produced; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: generic_dm_microphysics, nonstandard_history_required."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_03313_superheavy_lepton_virtual_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_03313", "source_line": 5598, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1546, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the superheavy lepton variant is more developed and can make full dark matter, but virtual-black-hole assumptions and missing routes/constraints keep priority low.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_08205_three_scalar_inelastic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_08205", "source_line": 4304, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1547, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 3, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Three-scalar inelastic scalar dark matter model for muon g-2 and XENON1T as a speculative inelastic_scalar_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via thermal freeze-out of the nearly degenerate scalar dark matter components.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=medium; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_09992_thermal_wino_smallest_halos_v1", "paper_id": "1901_09992", "source_line": 3718, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1548, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Thermal wino dark matter with inelastic kinetic decoupling is a benchmark simplified model candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, probe relevance for small-scale structure; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_gravitational_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_3539_superheavy_scalar_r2_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "1201_3539", "source_line": 1536, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1549, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and nonthermal phase-space treatment.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05349_ethos_2_benchmark_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05349", "source_line": 299, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 1550, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as ETHOS-2 interacting dark-matter dark-radiation benchmark, a speculative self interacting dark matter entry with benchmark mapping theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, oscillatory transfer behavior, nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: benchmark_mapping_only."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05349_ethos_3_benchmark_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05349", "source_line": 300, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 1551, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as ETHOS-3 interacting dark-matter dark-radiation benchmark, a speculative self interacting dark matter entry with benchmark mapping theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, oscillatory transfer behavior, nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: benchmark_mapping_only."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_1411_inert_doublet_new_viable_region_v1", "paper_id": "1011_1411", "source_line": 1216, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1552, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative simplified_model card in family scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to electroweak gauge bosons.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB and unknown BBN relevance; probe classes: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_03542_nonabelian_wimp_dark_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1505_03542", "source_line": 2478, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 99, "global_rank": 1553, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=high; small_scale_power_effect=suppression; transfer_function_shape=scale_dependent_growth.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=506, diversity_value=4.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2207_13689_spiked_extended_pbh_mass_function_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_13689", "source_line": 373, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 96, "global_rank": 1554, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via collapse of radiation-era density perturbations into PBHs; Press-Schechter mass-function construction from broken-power-law plus log-normal-spike primordial spectrum; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance unknown; linear structure effect enhancement with transfer shape enhanced_small_scale_power; probe hooks: CMB, compact objects/microlensing/dynamics, galaxy satellites/halo structure, large-scale/small-scale structure, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_0364_u1x_three_higgs_neutral_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_0364", "source_line": 1529, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1555, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and vector portal fermion dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, direct detection, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_09582_secluded_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1905_09582", "source_line": 3857, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 100, "global_rank": 1556, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A hidden U_X(1) vector dark matter model in which the vector X annihilates mainly to hidden scalar mediators S that decay to Standard Model particles through Higgs mixing; the paper develops conventional and nonconven...", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: mixed relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN high; CMB medium; phase-space thermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_04197_misaligned_axion_chern_simons_condensate_v1", "paper_id": "2303_04197", "source_line": 5558, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 126, "global_rank": 1557, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the axion Chern-Simons condensate is a distinctive nonthermal field-like setup, but follow-up value is limited by missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational support.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_12388_partially_composite_susy_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_12388", "source_line": 3643, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 1558, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative gravitino_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mass_dimension_one_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_16848_mass_dimension_one_fermion_em_coupled_v1", "paper_id": "2305_16848", "source_line": 5691, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1559, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 13, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Mass-dimension-one fermion non-minimally coupled to electromagnetism (mass_dimension_one_fermion_dark_matter) has vector, other portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support, low robustness. Raw score 20.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_01270_low_mass_cpviolating_effective_idm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_01270", "source_line": 5657, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1560, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Low-mass CP-violating effective inert-doublet dark matter (inert_doublet_effective_field_theory_dark_matter) has higgs, vector portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 20.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_08679_two_component_baryon_scattering_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_08679", "source_line": 5705, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 1561, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Two-component baryon-scattering dark matter for cool-core cluster heating is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with unknown relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects/dynamics, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 6.0, observational 6.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 4.0, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_0103_scale_invariant_hidden_pion_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1012_0103", "source_line": 1206, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 101, "global_rank": 1562, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family hidden_sector_dark_matter with production via annihilation of hidden pion pairs into SM particles through singlet messenger and Higgs-sector mixing.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_07204_su6_sp6_composite_pngb_complex_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_07204", "source_line": 5547, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1563, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_10513_leptophilic_scalar_u1_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2110_10513", "source_line": 4944, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1564, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Leptophilic scalar dark matter in a gauged U(1)_ model is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: Lyman-alpha forest, direct detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_3739_big_bang_dark_nucleosynthesis_nuclear_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_3739", "source_line": 2350, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1565, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 20 because the assigned model card phenomenological parameterization asymmetric_composite_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; uses nonthermal phase-space information; touches BBN, CMB.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_08883_inert_doublet_triplet_vll_assisted_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_08883", "source_line": 5865, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1566, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because it is a viable inert-doublet/VLL-assisted relic scenario with clear model structure, but the assigned card is mostly CDM-like and has no explicit observational constraints, routes, or implementation files."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_11541_scale_invariant_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1711_11541", "source_line": 3408, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1567, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status yes; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; only partial associated-code support; warnings: constraints_omitted."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "discrete_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_2962_z3_scalar_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1202_2962", "source_line": 1520, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1568, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and discrete scalar dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_13653_hybrid_two_scalar_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2211_13653", "source_line": 5430, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Promising cosmological hooks remain under-specified because observables, constraints, and routing are absent."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1569, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but relatively high: the hybrid two-scalar dark sector has high CMB relevance, field-like behavior, scale-dependent growth, rare family coverage, and partial code context, but no explicit routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superfluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_08874_right_handed_neutrino_condensate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_08874", "source_line": 6070, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1570, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 20.0: speculative effective field theory model in superfluid_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB; phase space is field like.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superfluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_08874_vector_like_quark_condensate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_08874", "source_line": 6071, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1571, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 20.0: speculative effective field theory model in superfluid_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB; phase space is field like.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_14996_late_decay_millicharged_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_14996", "source_line": 4888, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 1572, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_00227_visible_heavy_qcd_axion_darkly_charged_mirror_relics_v1", "paper_id": "1702_00227", "source_line": 3008, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 1573, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Darkly charged mirror-sector relics in a visible heavy QCD axion model is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has some cosmological, phase-space, or halo-structure leverage; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_02699_u1_vectorlike_quark_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_02699", "source_line": 3092, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1574, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative leptophilic_scalar_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium; inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dissipative_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_08557_atomic_dark_matter_dark_star_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2208_08557", "source_line": 5313, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1575, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 20.0: dissipative_dark_matter with not specified in detail; assumes a primordial atomic dark matter subcomponent; science=8.0, observational leverage=5.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics) and diversity=8.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_10504_dark_confining_axiverse_heavy_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_10504", "source_line": 5314, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 127, "global_rank": 1576, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 20.0: axion_like_dark_matter with misalignment production diluted by early matter domination from dark glueballs; science=12.0, observational leverage=5.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, direct detection) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_15653_hadrophilic_uv_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_15653", "source_line": 5347, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 104, "global_rank": 1577, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 20.0: freeze_in_dark_matter with UV freeze-in from SM annihilations after low-temperature reheating; science=12.0, observational leverage=5.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_01591_singlet_scalar_dimension_six_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2403_01591", "source_line": 6031, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1578, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the dimension-six Higgs-portal singlet has electroweak-phase-transition motivation but sparse relic, observable, and constraint detail in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_05723_kinetically_mixed_lmutau_dirac_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1803_05723", "source_line": 3427, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 102, "global_rank": 1579, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance medium/low; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals vector.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; only partial associated-code support; warnings: kinetic_mixing_matters, standard_cosmology_assumption."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "brane_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0709_4023_brane_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0709_4023", "source_line": 723, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1580, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative effective_field_theory model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, gravitational/cosmology, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_4321_pmssm_gravitino_lsp_model_set_v1", "paper_id": "1206_4321", "source_line": 1581, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 1581, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Useful breadth candidate because the card has benchmark-set status, BBN-sensitive late NLSP decays, decay-produced phase space, and gravitino cosmology, but route and implementation fields remain empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_06226_low_reheating_dark_photon_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_06226", "source_line": 6058, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 105, "global_rank": 1582, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 20.0: speculative simplified model model in freeze_in_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, direct detection; phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is partial and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_radion_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0408448_long_lived_radion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0408448", "source_line": 519, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1583, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Long-lived radion dark matter in Randall-Sundrum cosmology is a speculative effective field theory card with either relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (field like; small-scale effect unknown); it touches bbn, cmb; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "muon_g2_majorana_wimp", "model_id": "2204_02413_muon_g2_higgs_coupled_majorana_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2204_02413", "source_line": 5098, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1584, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 20 (defer) as a speculative simplified_model member of muon_g2_majorana_wimp.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: tension/anomaly, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out; possible nonthermal completion if thermal abundance is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "muon_g2_majorana_wimp", "model_id": "2204_02413_muon_g2_leptophilic_majorana_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2204_02413", "source_line": 5099, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1585, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 20 (defer) as a speculative simplified_model member of muon_g2_majorana_wimp.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: tension/anomaly, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out; possible nonthermal completion if thermal abundance is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_16480_minimal_susy_u1x_gaugino_singlet_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_16480", "source_line": 5760, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 1586, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because R-parity-conserving minimal SUSY U(1)_X gaugino-singlet neutralino dark matter has strong theory or relic-density motivation; card-internal probe cues include BBN, axion/laboratory searches, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_05799_so10_split_susy_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_05799", "source_line": 5782, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 1587, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 74.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because R-parity neutralino dark matter in a split-SUSY SO(10) GUT has strong theory or relic-density motivation, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: composition_unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_1904_susylr_unstable_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0808_1904", "source_line": 871, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 1588, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_pico_charged_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_14421_pico_charged_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_14421", "source_line": 4377, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1589, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Pico-charged particles from dark matter decay: SLIM-like thermal freeze-out of X through annihilation to neutrinos and a right-handed Majorana fermion; some cosmological or phase-space leverage, good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, indirect/transient and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_01107_axion_dm_dark_higgs_ede_trapping_v1", "paper_id": "2209_01107", "source_line": 5322, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 128, "global_rank": 1590, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 20.0: axion_like_dark_matter with axion misalignment from coherent oscillations; science=12.0, observational leverage=4.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_05680_scalar_condensate_ew_snr_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_05680", "source_line": 5343, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1591, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 20.0: scalar_dark_matter with thermalized scalar condensate from global charge asymmetry; science=11.0, observational leverage=4.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, direct detection, indirect detection, stellar streams) and diversity=5.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_10159_conformal_o_n_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_10159", "source_line": 5067, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1592, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 20 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through scalar annihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_04035_complex_singlet_pseudoscalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_04035", "source_line": 5068, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1593, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 20 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: multiple inferred probe classes.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB, direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through scalar annihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_00553_lmu_ltau_scotogenic_freeze_in_two_component_v1", "paper_id": "1711_00553", "source_line": 3302, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 106, "global_rank": 1594, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with yes relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0103340_phion_self_interacting_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0103340", "source_line": 378, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1595, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative simplified_model model; production via thermal production and freeze-out through Higgs-mediated annihilation; relativistic or nonrelativistic decoupling depending on Higgs coupling; CMB relevance low and BBN relevance unknown; linear structure effect suppression with transfer shape unknown; thermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauge_portal_electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_0491_electroweak_multiplet_gauge_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_0491", "source_line": 1656, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1596, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal gauge-portal annihilation/freeze-out inferred from electroweak annihilation and relic-abundance mass choice, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 20 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_09277_inelastic_bl_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_09277", "source_line": 3970, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1597, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Inelastic U(1) B-L charged scalar dark matter: strong model-card science motivation; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 20 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out with S-P coannihilation through the extra U(1) gauge interaction; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_10759_stueckelberg_u1x_scotogenic_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_10759", "source_line": 5062, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1598, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 20 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of scotogenic_fermion_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through gauge-mediated annihilation; thermal freeze-out through Yukawa-mediated annihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_02568_higgs_preheating_gravitational_freeze_in_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_02568", "source_line": 5613, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 107, "global_rank": 1599, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because gravitational freeze-in during Higgs preheating with nonthermal phase space.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_03776_ultralight_pngb_strong_gravity_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2305_03776", "source_line": 5643, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 129, "global_rank": 1600, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because ultralight pNGB dark matter for strong-gravity scenarios with field-like behavior.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_5108_gravitino_gmsb_scalar_decay_low_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "0909_5108", "source_line": 981, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 1601, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravitino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "z_prime_portal_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_10185_u1x_majorana_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1906_10185", "source_line": 3886, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1602, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A residual-Z2-stabilized Majorana fermion chi_1, mostly from S_1R and S_2R, in an anomaly-cancelled extra U(1)_X gauge model. Its thermal relic abundance is controlled by X-mediated annihilation and chi_2 co-annihilat...", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB medium; phase-space thermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "feebly_interacting_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_02338_scalar_dm_preheating_v1", "paper_id": "1809_02338", "source_line": 3586, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1603, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative feebly_interacting_scalar_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "It receives diversity credit for occupying a relatively sparse or phenomenologically distinctive region of the model-card population.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_11622_late_decay_self_interacting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2110_11622", "source_line": 4879, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 1604, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high CMB relevance; decay_produced phase-space production; distinct production or phase-space niche in the population context.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_3297_amsb_gravitino_decay_wino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1004_3297", "source_line": 1123, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1605, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in nonthermal_wino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase space, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_3297_amsb_moduli_nonthermal_wino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1004_3297", "source_line": 1122, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1606, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in nonthermal_wino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase space, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_2371_so10_nonuniversal_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0809_2371", "source_line": 868, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 1607, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_3730_higgs_portal_self_interacting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1411_3730", "source_line": 2353, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 1608, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal freeze-out production.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, collider, direct detection, neutrino/indirect, ....", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_10650_331_svs_invisible_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_10650", "source_line": 4371, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 130, "global_rank": 1609, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Minimal SVS 3-3-1 invisible axion dark matter: vacuum misalignment/coherent oscillations of the axion field; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, gravitational waves, indirect/transient and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_06203_on_axion_like_angular_dm_production_v1", "paper_id": "2108_06203", "source_line": 4795, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 131, "global_rank": 1610, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: post-inflationary spontaneous symmetry breaking; topological defect evolution.", "Observational leverage is driven by field_like phase-space distribution.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "spin1_simplified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_01267_unitary_spin1_schannel_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_01267", "source_line": 2761, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1611, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: benchmark simplified_model in spin1_simplified_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: collider production through quark-antiquark annihilation into W plus invisibly decaying Z-prime; mono-jet production with QCD and electroweak radiation; portals: vector.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_01903_vector_like_sneutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1604_01903", "source_line": 2771, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 1612, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out; coannihilation with vector-like sleptons; portals: higgs, vector, other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_13607_z2_complex_scalar_scattering_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_13607", "source_line": 5650, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 1613, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because asymmetric Z2 scalar scattering production with coupled Boltzmann treatment and moderate cosmological relevance.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_13607_z3_complex_scalar_semi_annihilation_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_13607", "source_line": 5649, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 1614, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because asymmetric Z3 scalar semi-annihilation with coupled Boltzmann treatment and moderate cosmological relevance.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_1077_scalar_singlet_triplet_z2_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1311_1077", "source_line": 1933, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 1615, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 20.0 because the model card is a speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and touches collider, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_3304_supersymmetric_u1_hylogenesis_antibaryon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1206_3304", "source_line": 1591, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 1616, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but distinctive because the card links asymmetric multi-component dark matter to nonthermal hylogenesis and BBN-relevant low-temperature reheating, with missing routing and model-building caveats."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "b_minus_l_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_11325_b_minus_l_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_11325", "source_line": 3940, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1617, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative b_minus_l_vector_portal_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to BBN, CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_11450_low_scale_trinification_majoron_v1", "paper_id": "2004_11450", "source_line": 4241, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1618, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection; decay_produced phase-space information; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_14354_complex_vector_condensate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_14354", "source_line": 4207, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1619, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, early-universe production connection, structure or tension connection; field_like phase-space information; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_lsp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_01347_u1r_superheavy_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_01347", "source_line": 4866, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1620, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from uv_complete theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; nonthermal phase-space production; rare family in population context (count 1).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_misalignment_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_04476_muon_coupled_thermal_misalignment_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_04476", "source_line": 4853, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1621, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is emerging and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from effective_field_theory theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; field_like phase-space production; rare family in population context (count 2).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_3459_long_lived_scalar_a_neutrino_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1412_3459", "source_line": 2364, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 1622, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative decaying_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and nonthermal superheavy dark matter production, long-lived decaying dark matter production.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase space; probe classes: collider, direct detection, indirect/cosmology, neutrino/indirect, ....", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for rare production mechanism: nonthermal superheavy dark matter production, and related mechanisms."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_03750_post_recombination_decaying_cdm_photon_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "2304_03750", "source_line": 5628, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 1623, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because post-recombination decaying-CDM photon reheating with partial code support but subcomponent-only relic role.", "Score is still held down by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points despite limited code support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_13787_asymmetric_atomic_dm_bound_state_v1", "paper_id": "2007_13787", "source_line": 4358, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1624, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Asymmetric atomic dark matter with massive dark photon bound-state formation: asymmetric relic abundance; good diversity value within the population context, partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, indirect/transient.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_3829_a4_split_seesaw_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1107_3829", "source_line": 1386, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 95, "global_rank": 1625, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as sterile_neutrino_dark_matter: production is represented by split-seesaw generation of a keV sterile neutrino; phase-space is nonthermal; inferred probe coverage includes cosmological phase-space, indirect detection, neutrino/cosmology.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_06834_scale_invariant_su2_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_06834", "source_line": 2831, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 103, "global_rank": 1626, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from BBN, CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_17390_cosmic_string_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_17390", "source_line": 5647, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 104, "global_rank": 1627, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because UV-complete dark-photon dark matter from cosmic-string loop decay with rare vector dark-matter content.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_messenger_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0412048_gmsb_messenger_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0412048", "source_line": 546, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1628, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because GMSB messenger-sector scalar dark matter is a speculative simplified model card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches bbn, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "conversion_driven_freeze_out_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_16086_conversion_driven_t_channel_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2404_16086", "source_line": 6082, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1629, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 20.0: speculative simplified model model in conversion_driven_freeze_out_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as yes.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_fermion_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_05375_fiveplet_fermion_dm_type_i_seesaw_higgs_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "1501_05375", "source_line": 2320, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1630, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 20 because the assigned model card simplified model minimal_fermion_multiplet_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; touches CMB, direct detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_02560_su5_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1711_02560", "source_line": 3296, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1631, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark cold dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching CMB, direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 20.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_07970_susy_su2h_confinement_z2_r_parity_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_07970", "source_line": 2447, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 1632, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a multi_component_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_03610_two_portal_fermionic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1504_03610", "source_line": 2418, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1633, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a wimp_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked yes; feasibility support scores 1 from code or analytic representation fields; implicit probe coverage includes direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_0969_rnumdm_majorana_quintuplet_v1", "paper_id": "1108_0969", "source_line": 1359, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1634, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as radiative_seesaw_minimal_dark_matter: production is represented by standard thermal freeze-out; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection, neutrino/cosmology.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_majorana_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_4858_degenerate_majorana_internal_bremsstrahlung_v1", "paper_id": "1411_4858", "source_line": 2313, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1635, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 20 because the assigned model card simplified model coannihilating_majorana_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "left_right_symmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_06193_dark_left_right_scotino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1501_06193", "source_line": 2340, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1636, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 20 because the assigned model card uv complete left_right_symmetric_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlino_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_5432_scale_free_ewbg_singlino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1410_5432", "source_line": 2316, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1637, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 20 because the assigned model card uv complete singlino_higgs_portal_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavor_specific_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_13361_muon_specific_scalar_dm_modular_a4_u1h_v1", "paper_id": "2304_13361", "source_line": 5607, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 20, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1638, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because a rare muon-specific modular-flavor scalar model with UV-complete motivation but no explicit follow-up probes in the supplied card.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 20, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_09245_qcd_axion_alp_pq_breaking_mixing_v1", "paper_id": "2307_09245", "source_line": 5734, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 132, "global_rank": 1639, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.7, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: QCD axion-ALP mass mixing with explicit PQ symmetry breaking is a speculative effective_field_theory card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and medium CMB relevance, field_like phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves, indirect detection, laboratory precision; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 9.0, observational 3.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 2.7, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_06586_so_2n_baryonic_glueball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_06586", "source_line": 5721, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 105, "global_rank": 1640, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.7, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: SO(2N) baryonic glueball dark matter is a speculative uv_complete card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and nonthermal phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across galaxy satellites, gravitational waves, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 11.0, observational 2.0, complementarity 8.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 3.7, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hypercharged_minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_7495_nonthermal_hypercharged_multiplet_v1", "paper_id": "1310_7495", "source_line": 1969, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1641, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_07069_kinetically_coupled_ede_sfdm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_07069", "source_line": 161, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 1642, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 19.5 for scalar_field_dark_matter: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior, suppression in small-scale power, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; current-data compatibility is unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_11254_tsallis_wimp_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "1911_11254", "source_line": 4095, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 19.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1643, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative thermal_wimp_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_6228_gmsb_gravitino_thermal_leptogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1311_6228", "source_line": 1996, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 1644, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_04936_dark_photon_dirac_hot_relic_v1", "paper_id": "2003_04936", "source_line": 4162, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 106, "global_rank": 1645, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of hidden_sector_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, small-scale-power suppression.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_02906_leptophilic_scalar_mediator_thermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_02906", "source_line": 5991, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1646, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from leptophilic_thermal_dark_matter: Thermal leptophilic Majorana dark matter with CP-even scalar mediator has moderate observational leverage, high model/theory value, high diversity value through thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model charged leptons; inferred probe classes are collider.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_06476_2hdm_fermionic_singlet_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_06476", "source_line": 5517, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 1647, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides moderate scientific motivation, thermal phase-space information, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_10015_blsmis_kev_s1_fimp_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_10015", "source_line": 3807, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 108, "global_rank": 1648, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 73.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as freeze-in from nonthermal Z' decay Z' -> S_1^1 S_1^1, freeze-in from SM-fermion annihilation f fbar -> S_1^1 S_1^1 mediated by Z'.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_04492_dark_atoms_millicharged_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2001_04492", "source_line": 4145, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1649, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 19.5: speculative atomic_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance; inferred probe classes: CMB, direct detection.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_09349_two_component_boosted_light_dm_nu2hdm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_09349", "source_line": 5843, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 77, "global_rank": 1650, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out of both components.", "Follow-up value comes from direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (mixed_cold_warm, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_axion_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_4108_flaxino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0801_4108", "source_line": 813, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1651, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is medium/high, phase space is nonthermal. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_15284_resonance_scanning_higgs_portal_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2012_15284", "source_line": 4608, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 1652, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative higgs portal dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked yes; some cosmological or phase-space leverage; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_11019_asymmetrically_reheated_twin_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_11019", "source_line": 4602, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 1653, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative higgs portal dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; some cosmological or phase-space leverage; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_03724_qg_broken_z2_scalar_dm_domain_wall_v1", "paper_id": "2308_03724", "source_line": 5736, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1654, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Quantum-gravity-broken Z2 singlet scalar dark matter with domain walls is a speculative simplified_model card with unknown relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 7.0, observational 4.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 4.5, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0412058_split_susy_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0412058", "source_line": 534, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1655, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Split-Supersymmetry neutralino dark matter is a speculative simplified model card with either relic-density treatment; it touches bbn, cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fourth_generation_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_2749_fourth_generation_majorana_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_2749", "source_line": 1686, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1656, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out of fourth-generation Majorana neutrino annihilation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 19.5 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_04627_z3_inert_doublet_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_04627", "source_line": 5937, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1657, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Z3 inert doublet-singlet scalar dark matter is a speculative scalar_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, none small-scale-power information, and gravitational waves from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 10, observational leverage 4, complementarity 2, feasibility 1, provenance 9, diversity 5.5, penalties 12; raw score 19.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2210_16462_late_forming_pbh_thermal_fermi_balls_v1", "paper_id": "2210_16462", "source_line": 5372, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 97, "global_rank": 1658, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Late-forming PBH from thermal balls and Fermi balls has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact objects, gravitational waves, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_05684_z3_scalar_semiproduction_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_05684", "source_line": 4637, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 109, "global_rank": 1659, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, gravitational waves. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_5709_neutrinophilic_u1_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_5709", "source_line": 1682, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 107, "global_rank": 1660, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory entry; production is summarized as thermal WIMP production through vector and Higgs portal annihilation channels, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 19.5 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_03765_model_b_dark_radiation_inert_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1711_03765", "source_line": 3284, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1661, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative seesaw dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB, direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 19.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_17523_light_smuon_gutc_nmssm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2312_17523", "source_line": 5926, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 1662, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Light-smuon GUTc-NMSSM neutralino dark matter is a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, none small-scale-power information, and collider, direct detection from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 12, observational leverage 3, complementarity 5, feasibility 1, provenance 9, diversity 1.5, penalties 12; raw score 19.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_04375_reshuffled_simp_model_a_v1", "paper_id": "2107_04375", "source_line": 4769, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 1663, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and production logic from: thermal SIMP 3-to-2 freeze-out; post-freeze-out loop-induced 2-to-2 reshuffling of component densities.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_04375_reshuffled_simp_model_b_v1", "paper_id": "2107_04375", "source_line": 4770, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 1664, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and production logic from: thermal SIMP 3-to-2 freeze-out; post-freeze-out loop-induced 2-to-2 reshuffling of component densities.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_0270_xogenesis_l_violating_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1009_0270", "source_line": 1185, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 1665, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 19.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_01072_supercooled_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_01072", "source_line": 5711, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 1666, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Extremely supercooled singlet scalar dark matter is a speculative uv_complete card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 10.0, observational 1.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.5, provenance 9.0, diversity 3.0, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp", "model_id": "1711_11376_leptophilic_fermion_dm_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1711_11376", "source_line": 3344, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1667, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with yes relic-density support, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp", "model_id": "1711_11376_leptophilic_fermion_dm_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1711_11376", "source_line": 3346, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1668, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with yes relic-density support, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp", "model_id": "1711_11376_leptophilic_scalar_dm_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1711_11376", "source_line": 3343, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1669, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with yes relic-density support, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp", "model_id": "1711_11376_leptophilic_scalar_dm_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1711_11376", "source_line": 3345, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1670, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with yes relic-density support, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "isospin_violating_inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_1391_inelastic_vector_isospin_violating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1108_1391", "source_line": 1362, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1671, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as isospin_violating_inelastic_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out through hidden-sector vector annihilation and coannihilation; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_05653_type_ii_2hdms_pseudoscalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_05653", "source_line": 5738, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1672, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Type-II 2HDMS with pseudoscalar singlet dark matter is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 2.5, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_12473_type_ii_2hdm_real_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_12473", "source_line": 5741, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1673, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Type-II 2HDM with real singlet scalar dark matter is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 2.5, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_12473_type_x_2hdm_real_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_12473", "source_line": 5742, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1674, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Type-X 2HDM with real singlet scalar dark matter is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 2.5, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_bino_slepton_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03290_bino_smuon_selectron_coannihilation_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03290", "source_line": 4616, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1675, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative neutralino bino slepton coannihilation dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_bino_slepton_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03290_bino_stau_coannihilation_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03290", "source_line": 4615, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1676, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative neutralino bino slepton coannihilation dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_bino_wino_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03290_bino_wino_coannihilation_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03290", "source_line": 4617, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1677, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative neutralino bino wino coannihilation dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_04312_qcd_axion_pbh_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "2110_04312", "source_line": 4842, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.2, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 133, "global_rank": 1678, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, field like phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_10359_heavy_dark_baryon_hidden_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_10359", "source_line": 5392, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 1679, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Heavy dark baryons in a hidden MSSM-like sector has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: CMB, phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_0228_asymmetric_right_handed_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_0228", "source_line": 2202, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 1680, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete asymmetric_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection, neutrino/laboratory.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_10094_minicharged_subcomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_10094", "source_line": 3437, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 1681, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level phenomenological_parameterization; relic status no; CMB/BBN relevance high/unknown; portals vector.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: do_not_promote_to_full_dm, uv_completion_missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_04824_geometric_baryogenesis_ultralight_alp_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_04824", "source_line": 2981, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 1682, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_10148_lmu_ltau_ultralight_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2311_10148", "source_line": 5851, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 1683, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card has a distinctive ultralight L_mu-L_tau pulsar-timing signature and an approximate field-like phase-space model, while cosmological production, observables, constraints, routing, and public implementation support are missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decay_produced_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_10315_decaying_wimp_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_10315", "source_line": 27, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1684, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, high CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, decay_produced phase-space description, some computational or code support; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_06294_hadrophilic_sequential_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2005_06294", "source_line": 4253, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 110, "global_rank": 1685, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via sequential freeze-in; non-thermal mediator production followed by mediator annihilation to DM, nonthermal phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_03128_light_exothermic_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_03128", "source_line": 5996, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1686, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from inelastic_dark_matter: Light exothermic inelastic dark matter with vector mediator has moderate observational leverage through thermal freeze-out of nearly degenerate inelastic components, annihilation to dark photons when kinematically open; inferred probe classes are CMB, direct_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1804_08639_slow_reheating_primordial_black_holes_v1", "paper_id": "1804_08639", "source_line": 3447, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 98, "global_rank": 1687, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level phenomenological_parameterization; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance unknown/medium; phase-space type not_applicable; portals gravitational.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: warning_pbh_fraction_parameter_dependent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_02389_hidden_pq_higgs_axion_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "1606_02389", "source_line": 2856, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 134, "global_rank": 1688, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; high CMB relevance; field_like phase-space population; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_00415_iss23_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_00415", "source_line": 3226, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 96, "global_rank": 1689, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: ISS(2,3) sterile-neutrino dark matter from small lepton-number violation is a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale effect, CMB/BBN relevance medium/high, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_05482_xc_charged_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1702_05482", "source_line": 3106, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 1690, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of self_interacting_dark_matter with raw score 19.0.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 166.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "charged_leptophilic_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_02182_charged_leptophilic_dark_electron_v1", "paper_id": "1812_02182", "source_line": 3689, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1691, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative charged_leptophilic_self_interacting_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; suppression small-scale-power effect; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_3753_nonminimally_coupled_bec_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1310_3753", "source_line": 228, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1692, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=scale_dependent_growth, small_scale_power_effect=mixed, and probe classes: CMB, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_05279_double_inflation_parametric_resonance_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_05279", "source_line": 2987, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1693, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_hole_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on high CMB relevance.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_05279_axion_curvaton_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_05279", "source_line": 2990, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1694, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_hole_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on high CMB relevance.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_11837_palatini_higgs_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_11837", "source_line": 3947, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 135, "global_rank": 1695, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_05492_flaxion_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_05492", "source_line": 2971, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 136, "global_rank": 1696, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and yes all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include flaxion_not_generic_axion, flaxion_domain_wall_sensitive."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_07228_coupled_sfdm_ede_v1", "paper_id": "2307_07228", "source_line": 182, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 1697, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 19.0 for fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior, suppression in small-scale power, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; current-data compatibility is unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_2727_light_vector_decay_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1403_2727", "source_line": 2075, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 97, "global_rank": 1698, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of sterile_neutrino_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; non-CDM small-scale structure information; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_fuzzy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_14288_two_component_wave_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_14288", "source_line": 108, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1699, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated emerging multi_component_fuzzy_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2401_10925_galileon_usr_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2401_10925", "source_line": 5959, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 99, "global_rank": 1700, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from primordial_black_holes: Galileon ultra-slow-roll primordial black-hole dark matter has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through collapse of enhanced primordial density perturbations generated by a Galileon ultra-slow-roll phase, w-dependent Press-Schechter threshold statistics; inferred probe classes are BBN, compact_objects, gravitational_waves.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_conversion_driven_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_07513_leptophilic_feeble_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_07513", "source_line": 3824, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1701, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as conversion-driven freeze-out, freeze-in.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensate_scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "0805_3827_bec_scalar_field_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0805_3827", "source_line": 777, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1702, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, relic viability unknown, raw score 19.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type field_like; probe classes counted: ['halo/subhalo abundance', 'small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_12342_ultralight_axion_bec_v1", "paper_id": "2103_12342", "source_line": 4672, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 1703, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; field_like phase space; suppression of small-scale power.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_09389_reheating_induced_inflaxion_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_09389", "source_line": 4300, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 137, "global_rank": 1704, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via reheating-induced misalignment; axion displacement by axion-inflaton kinetic mixing, field_like phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_13358_starobinsky_scalar_coherent_oscillation_v1", "paper_id": "2105_13358", "source_line": 4747, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 1705, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production via coherent oscillation from non-minimal curvature coupling; misalignment from soft Z2 breaking.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB, structure formation; the raw score is 19 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_03426_axion_domain_wall_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2402_03426", "source_line": 5973, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 78, "global_rank": 1706, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from multi_component_dark_matter: QCD axion domain-wall primordial-black-hole subcomponent model has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through axion misalignment, axion string and defect radiation, collapse of self-enclosed axion domain walls into PBHs; inferred probe classes are BBN, compact_objects.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_04745_secretly_asymmetric_fdm_zprime_v1", "paper_id": "1608_04745", "source_line": 2874, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 1707, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; 2 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_13358_starobinsky_hidden_vector_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2105_13358", "source_line": 4746, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 108, "global_rank": 1708, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via nonthermal pair production from scalaron decay.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB, structure formation; the raw score is 19 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensate_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_3091_relativistic_bec_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0705_3091", "source_line": 714, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1709, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 72.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative phenomenological_parameterization model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; field_like phase-space history; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, gravitational/cosmology.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation. Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive model class in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_05492_trapped_axion_dark_photon_production_v1", "paper_id": "2303_05492", "source_line": 5561, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1710, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: trapped-axion dark-photon production is rare and distinctive, but the relic abundance is unknown, robustness is low, and no observable routing or code is supplied.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1006_4008_resonant_msm_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1006_4008", "source_line": 1140, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 98, "global_rank": 1711, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory entry in sterile_neutrino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, resonant phase space, suppression small-scale-power effect, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_10107_neutron_dark_decay_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_10107", "source_line": 3533, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 109, "global_rank": 1712, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a UV-complete model card; it touches BBN, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection, laboratory precision probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_12118_adr_sterile_neutrino_axion_like_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_12118", "source_line": 5767, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 138, "global_rank": 1713, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Axion-like dark matter coupled to ADR sterile neutrinos has some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, CMB/cosmic-dawn, axion/laboratory searches, neutrino probes.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_03089_su2_hidden_vector_dark_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "1801_03089", "source_line": 3375, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 111, "global_rank": 1714, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and nonthermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_03089_u1_hidden_vector_dark_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "1801_03089", "source_line": 3376, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 112, "global_rank": 1715, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and nonthermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_14688_reproductive_freeze_in_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_14688", "source_line": 4382, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 113, "global_rank": 1716, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Reproductive freeze-in self-interacting dark matter: reproductive freeze-in from an ultra-relativistic underoccupied dark sector; strong cosmology, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage, good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, structure formation.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_2064_indirect_fermionic_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1203_2064", "source_line": 1518, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1717, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and fermionic higgs portal dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_2064_resonant_fermionic_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1203_2064", "source_line": 1517, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1718, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and fermionic higgs portal dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dissipative_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_05209_atomic_dissipative_dark_matter_dbh_v1", "paper_id": "2009_05209", "source_line": 243, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1719, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative dissipative_dark_matter entry with simplified_model; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=scale_dependent_growth, small_scale_power_effect=suppression, and probe classes: CMB, gravitational waves, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: event_interpretation_dependent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_13716_dark_su3_glueball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_13716", "source_line": 5281, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 110, "global_rank": 1720, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Dark SU(3) scalar glueball dark matter: speculative status, effective-field-theory theory level, and production via thermal production in a decoupled confining dark sector; glueball number-changing self-interactions around confinement, thermal phase space, phase-transition history.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, indirect detection), family/diversity context for hidden_sector_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_00609_resonant_self_interacting_bound_state_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_00609", "source_line": 3518, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 1721, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it touches direct detection, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector_scalar_field", "model_id": "0706_3667_affine_quintessence_unified_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "0706_3667", "source_line": 307, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1722, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, small-scale power effect is suppression, transfer function shape is smooth_cutoff, phase-space type is field_like.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:canonical_sound_speed.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/8/5/0/9/6/16."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0709_3918_nonthermal_neutralino_mirage_mediation_v1", "paper_id": "0709_3918", "source_line": 722, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1723, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked yes; nonthermal phase-space history; BBN high relevance; probe coverage from BBN.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_5136_fn_kev_sterile_neutrino_scenario_a_v1", "paper_id": "1105_5136", "source_line": 1330, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 99, "global_rank": 1724, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type nonthermal.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_4213_light_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1004_4213", "source_line": 1110, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 1725, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in gravitino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by mixed-cold-warm phase space, suppression small-scale-power effect, mixed-cold-warm transfer-function shape, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superfluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_07371_two_state_superfluid_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1911_07371", "source_line": 270, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1726, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Two-state unified superfluid dark sector, a speculative superfluid dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, scale dependent growth transfer behavior, field like phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: effective_model, late_time_growth."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1905_01741_pbh_remnant_kination_quintessence_v1", "paper_id": "1905_01741", "source_line": 3889, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 100, "global_rank": 1727, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: Mini primordial black holes from an attractor-inflation curvature spike evaporate into stable remnants that can constitute cold dark matter.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN high; CMB medium; phase-space not_applicable; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: remnant_physics_unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1905_01741_pbh_remnant_matter_domination_v1", "paper_id": "1905_01741", "source_line": 3888, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 101, "global_rank": 1728, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: Mini primordial black holes from an attractor-inflation curvature spike evaporate into stable remnants that can constitute cold dark matter.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN high; CMB medium; phase-space not_applicable; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: remnant_physics_unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1905_01741_pbh_remnant_radiation_domination_v1", "paper_id": "1905_01741", "source_line": 3887, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 102, "global_rank": 1729, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: Mini primordial black holes from an attractor-inflation curvature spike evaporate into stable remnants that can constitute cold dark matter.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN high; CMB medium; phase-space not_applicable; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: remnant_physics_unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavour_vacuum_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_3461_flavour_vacuum_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1112_3461", "source_line": 1541, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1730, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, and flavour vacuum dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_4614_two_singlet_light_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_4614", "source_line": 1531, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1731, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and scalar singlet higgs portal dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, direct detection, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "astro-ph0308183_inhomogeneous_dilaton_oscillatons_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0308183", "source_line": 235, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1732, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative scalar_field_unified_dark_matter_dark_energy entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=suppression, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: phenomenological_domain_dynamics."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_02399_majoron_inverse_seesaw_dim6_v1", "paper_id": "2304_02399", "source_line": 5581, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1733, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the inverse-seesaw Majoron setup has rare-family value and partial code support, but the relic status is uncertain and high-severity warnings limit follow-up priority.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_02225_superheavy_gravitational_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_02225", "source_line": 4269, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1734, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative gravitationally_produced_superheavy_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via nonthermal gravitational production from post-inflationary Hubble-rate spikes, nonthermal phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superfluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_10286_three_body_superfluid_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2302_10286", "source_line": 5552, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1735, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the three-body superfluid equation of state is distinctive, yet the card flags the Hamiltonian as illustrative and lacks observational routes, constraints, benchmarks, and code.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_01469_bl_freeze_in_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_01469", "source_line": 2867, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 100, "global_rank": 1736, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium CMB relevance; nonthermal phase-space population; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scale_invariant_wimpzilla_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05890_scale_invariant_pseudoscalar_wimpzilla_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05890", "source_line": 2721, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1737, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has parameter-dependent relic production, high CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space history, high diversity value in the population context.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_1613_mixed_bino_higgsino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1012_1613", "source_line": 1208, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1738, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card in family neutralino_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out; neutralino/chargino coannihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_0365_two_singlet_light_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1101_0365", "source_line": 1232, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1739, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative simplified_model card in family scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out WIMP annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_0285_z2_singlet_scalar_s_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1012_0285", "source_line": 1223, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 1740, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family higgs_portal_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out of S through Higgs-portal annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection, laboratory precision / neutrino.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_06324_flavor_broken_scalegenesis_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_06324", "source_line": 3374, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 111, "global_rank": 1741, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_11930_secluded_u1_singlino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_11930", "source_line": 4919, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1742, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Secluded U(1)' singlino-like neutralino dark matter is speculative with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_2704_affleck_dine_radiative_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1101_2704", "source_line": 1233, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 79, "global_rank": 1743, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family multi_component_dark_matter with production via R-parity neutralino dark matter production in supersymmetric cosmology; Z_2-odd neutral-field dark matter abundance in a radiative neutrino mass model.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, laboratory precision / neutrino.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2106_02467_step_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_02467", "source_line": 4722, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 103, "global_rank": 1744, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production via collapse of enhanced primordial density perturbations after horizon reentry; radiation-dominated PBH formation.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB, compact objects/dynamics, structure formation; the raw score is 19 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Diversity credit is elevated because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive family or production regime in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0412586_long_range_scalar_dm_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0412586", "source_line": 364, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 1745, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative simplified_model model; production via possible thermal production or freeze-out for massive species; initial relativistic screening population; CMB relevance low and BBN relevance unknown; linear structure effect enhancement with transfer shape scale_dependent_growth; probe hooks: galaxy dynamics/self-interaction, galaxy satellites/halo structure, large-scale/small-scale structure, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_07940_leptophobic_zp_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_07940", "source_line": 2863, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1746, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_vector_mediator_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; medium CMB relevance; 3 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_09018_scalar_dm_gluon_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1605_09018", "source_line": 2864, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1747, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; medium CMB relevance; 3 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_09018_scalar_dm_quark_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1605_09018", "source_line": 2865, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1748, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; medium CMB relevance; 3 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_16781_anapole_idm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_16781", "source_line": 5661, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 1749, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Anapole photon-coupled inelastic dark matter (inelastic_dark_matter) has vector portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields. Raw score 19.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_16781_charge_radius_idm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_16781", "source_line": 5662, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 1750, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Charge-radius photon-coupled inelastic dark matter (inelastic_dark_matter) has vector portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields. Raw score 19.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_16781_electric_dipole_idm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_16781", "source_line": 5659, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 1751, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Electric-dipole photon-coupled inelastic dark matter (inelastic_dark_matter) has vector portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields. Raw score 19.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_16781_magnetic_dipole_idm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_16781", "source_line": 5660, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 1752, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Magnetic-dipole photon-coupled inelastic dark matter (inelastic_dark_matter) has vector portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields. Raw score 19.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_08917_bino_higgsino_tempered_singlino_nmssm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_08917", "source_line": 5978, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1753, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supersymmetric_dark_matter: Bino-higgsino-tempered singlino NMSSM dark matter has moderate model/theory value through thermal freeze-out of a singlino-dominated neutralino, resonant annihilation through Z or singlet-like Higgs funnels, co-annihilation with nearby bino-like neutralino; inferred probe classes are collider, direct_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_strange_quark_matter_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_12094_strangelet_macro_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2404_12094", "source_line": 6092, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1754, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 19.0: speculative phenomenological parameterization model in macroscopic_strange_quark_matter_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, compact objects/dynamics; phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0212275_dark_group_warm_dark_baryons_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0212275", "source_line": 341, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 112, "global_rank": 1755, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, small-scale power effect is suppression, transfer function shape is smooth_cutoff, phase-space type is thermal.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:warm_dark_matter_mapping.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 11/6/5/0/9/3/15."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrinophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_01259_neutrinophilic_model_ii_scalar_z3_v1", "paper_id": "1901_01259", "source_line": 3757, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1756, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 19 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out through S-wave semi-annihilation mediated by the..., thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: BBN, CMB; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrinophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_01259_neutrinophilic_model_iii_coannihilating_dirac_u1_v1", "paper_id": "1901_01259", "source_line": 3758, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1757, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 19 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out through P-wave coannihilation of chi_1 and chi_2..., thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: BBN, CMB; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_08236_despicable_dark_relic_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1808_08236", "source_line": 3616, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1758, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative gravitationally_produced_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from suppression small-scale-power effect, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9807374_n1_axion_wall_decay_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9807374", "source_line": 6141, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 1759, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 19 (defer) from supplied card content: qcd_axion_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior; non-CDM linear structure information (suppression, unknown).", "Penalties (18) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_02025_charged_scalar_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2211_02025", "source_line": 5438, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Small-scale leverage is present, but observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are absent."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 1760, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but notable: charged scalar fuzzy/ultralight dark matter can make all dark matter and has CMB plus small-scale suppression hooks, but no route or code support is supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_misalignment_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_14469_invisible_dilaton_misalignment_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_14469", "source_line": 5566, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1761, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the scalar-field misalignment family is rare and scientifically interesting, but the card has high-severity caveats and little observational or computational detail.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_08341_minimal_so10_bino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_08341", "source_line": 2970, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1762, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and yes all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include so10_not_generic_neutralino."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_09299_axion_kination_kinetic_misalignment_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2108_09299", "source_line": 4875, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 139, "global_rank": 1763, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is emerging and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from effective_field_theory theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; field_like phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_2313_sub_ev_scalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1003_2313", "source_line": 1119, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 1764, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in ultralight_scalar_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, field-like phase space, suppression small-scale-power effect, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_07028_majorana_singlet_neutrino_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1706_07028", "source_line": 3166, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1765, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 19.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 19.0: Majorana singlet neutrino-portal dark matter is a speculative effective field theory entry with thermal freeze-out.", "Rank-relevant positives are high BBN relevance, high CMB relevance, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, CMB, collider, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_07028_real_scalar_singlet_neutrino_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1706_07028", "source_line": 3167, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1766, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 19.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 19.0: Real scalar singlet neutrino-portal dark matter is a speculative effective field theory entry with thermal freeze-out.", "Rank-relevant positives are high BBN relevance, high CMB relevance, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, CMB, collider, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_10894_generalized_deflected_amsb_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_10894", "source_line": 3085, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 1767, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance low, CMB relevance medium; inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_05584_pdgssm_multicomponent_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_05584", "source_line": 3088, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 1768, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance low, CMB relevance medium; inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_14307_qcd_axion_pbh_early_matter_domination_v1", "paper_id": "2209_14307", "source_line": 5337, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 140, "global_rank": 1769, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 19.0: axion_like_dark_matter with misalignment production modified by PBH early matter domination; science=10.0, observational leverage=5.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_4677_kinetic_mixing_zprime_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1306_4677", "source_line": 1892, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 114, "global_rank": 1770, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 71.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with decay, freeze-in production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9809547_fermionic_superheavy_x_vacuum_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9809547", "source_line": 6144, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1771, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 19 (defer) from supplied card content: superheavy_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior; non-CDM linear structure information (unknown, scale_dependent_growth); cosmological relevance: CMB medium.", "Penalties (17) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "quark_matter_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph9802236_primordial_quark_object_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9802236", "source_line": 6129, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1772, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 19 (defer) from supplied card content: quark_matter_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and yes all-DM production; cosmological relevance: CMB high, BBN high.", "Penalties (18) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "complex_scalar_dark_fluid", "model_id": "astro-ph0509592_complex_scalar_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0509592", "source_line": 9, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1773, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, medium CMB relevance and medium BBN relevance, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_gravitational_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_5931_gravitationally_produced_x_boson_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_5931", "source_line": 1477, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1774, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable nonthermal_gravitational_dark_matter variant and records gravitational particle production during the non-adiabatic transition from quasi-de Sitter inflation to the post-inflationary phase.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_like_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_05068_top_philic_vectorlike_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_05068", "source_line": 3440, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1775, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance medium/none; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; only partial associated-code support; warnings: do_not_add_higgs_portal, small_yukawa_regime."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_13116_low_scale_hypercolor_axion_domain_wall_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_13116", "source_line": 3882, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 80, "global_rank": 1776, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A post-inflationary PQ axion model where a low-scale hypercolor interaction solves the domain-wall problem and yields axion plus hypercolor bound-state dark matter candidates.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: mixed relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN medium; CMB low; phase-space unknown; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "moduli_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_3460_large_volume_light_modulus_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0705_3460", "source_line": 759, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1777, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 19.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance high, CMB relevance medium, phase-space type field_like; probe classes counted: ['BBN', 'CMB'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "z2_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_4394_z2_symmetric_real_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1308_4394", "source_line": 1923, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1778, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 19.0 because the model card is a speculative z2_scalar_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; medium BBN and unknown CMB relevance; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches BBN, collider, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_1222_hidden_u1x_asymmetric_y_v1", "paper_id": "1409_1222", "source_line": 2258, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 1779, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and nonthermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_06124_z2_scalar_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1702_06124", "source_line": 3051, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1780, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_singlet_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph9806480_chiral_vorton_superconducting_string_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9806480", "source_line": 6125, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1781, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 19 (defer) from supplied card content: topological_defect_relic_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior; cosmological relevance: CMB medium, BBN medium.", "Penalties (19) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptoquark_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_06768_leptoquark_portal_singlet_vectorlike_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_06768", "source_line": 5256, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1782, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Leptoquark-portal SU(2)L-singlet vector-like fermion dark matter: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out; coannihilation with colored vector-like partner, thermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection), family/diversity context for leptoquark_portal_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_out_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_14972_fn_rhn_flavon_freeze_out_v1", "paper_id": "2307_14972", "source_line": 5754, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1783, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Froggatt-Nielsen flavon-portal right-handed-neutrino freeze-out dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, some diversity value relative to the population, partial associated-code or tool support; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlino_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_00343_pq_singlino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_00343", "source_line": 3065, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1784, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative singlino_neutralino_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability yes.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_02977_bino_sbottom_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1703_02977", "source_line": 3071, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1785, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_coannihilation_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, indirect detection, laboratory precision.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_02977_bino_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1703_02977", "source_line": 3070, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1786, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_coannihilation_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, indirect detection, laboratory precision.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauge_higgs_unification_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_04621_ghu_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_04621", "source_line": 3068, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1787, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative gauge_higgs_unification_fermion_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory and production ability yes.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_3660_yukawa_coupled_quintessence_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_3660", "source_line": 2349, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1788, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 19 because the assigned model card phenomenological parameterization interacting_dark_energy_dark_matter card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; touches CMB, laboratory precision / fifth-force searches.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_05382_n2hdm_dark_singlet_phase_v1", "paper_id": "2004_05382", "source_line": 4257, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1789, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support, production via thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal scalar interactions.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_09282_z3_leptophilic_complex_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2203_09282", "source_line": 5089, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1790, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 19 (defer) as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_scalar_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out; annihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_3657_multicomponent_ohe_uu_dark_atoms_v1", "paper_id": "1411_3657", "source_line": 2366, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 81, "global_rank": 1791, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and charge-asymmetric excess tied to baryon asymmetry, OHe formation after primordial helium synthesis, and related mechanisms production.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space; probe classes: BBN, small-scale structure.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for rare production mechanism: charge-asymmetric excess tied to baryon asymmetry, and related mechanisms; composite candidate; multi-component candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_2510_cmssm_rhn_gravitino_sneutrino_nlsp_v1", "paper_id": "0902_2510", "source_line": 975, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 1792, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravitino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_1182_gauge_mediated_r_ball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_1182", "source_line": 1335, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1793, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level BBN relevance high, phase-space type nonthermal.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for non_topological_soliton_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_04655_dirac_scotogenic_inert_doublet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_04655", "source_line": 5577, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1794, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the inert-doublet scalar variant remains viable and rare enough for diversity, but it is CDM-like in the supplied fields and lacks populated observational-detail support.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_06947_light_higgsino_nonthermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_06947", "source_line": 3036, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1795, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["High-scale SUSY light neutral higgsino dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has some cosmological, phase-space, or halo-structure leverage; uses a nonthermal phase-space history; adds high diversity value for this batch; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_04061_curvature_induced_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_04061", "source_line": 4219, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1796, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include early-universe production connection; field_like phase-space information; high CMB relevance; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "charged_q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_04352_charged_q_ball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_04352", "source_line": 2802, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1797, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from BBN relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_2419_pmssm_374345_gravitino_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "1305_2419", "source_line": 1747, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1798, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 3.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to neutrino, supersymmetric framework, phase-transition/nonstandard history.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 1 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0509039_moduli_anomaly_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509039", "source_line": 516, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1799, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Mixed moduli-anomaly mediated MSSM with nonthermal neutral-Higgsino dark matter is a speculative effective field theory card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (decay produced; small-scale effect unknown); it touches bbn, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0810_3625_so10_axion_gut_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "0810_3625", "source_line": 894, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 141, "global_rank": 1800, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, full dark-matter abundance capability, field like phase-space behavior. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_02230_singlet_majorana_wimp_eft_simplified_v1", "paper_id": "1604_02230", "source_line": 2798, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1801, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: benchmark effective_field_theory in effective_wimp_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out of the WIMP through EFT interactions; possible additional nonthermal contribution if thermal abundance is below the observed value; portals: higgs, vector, other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_inflaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_5284_ekpyrotic_reheating_inflaton_remnant_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1203_5284", "source_line": 1488, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1802, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable scalar_inflaton_dark_matter variant and records surviving inflaton remnant after ekpyrotic reheating.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_06430_qyu_umssm_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_06430", "source_line": 2758, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 1803, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal neutralino freeze-out; chargino-neutralino coannihilation; portals: higgs, vector.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_01853_minimal_vector_fermion_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_01853", "source_line": 3281, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 82, "global_rank": 1804, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi component dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 19.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_3578_long_lived_pgb_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1312_3578", "source_line": 2034, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1805, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=partial and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_06471_fraternal_twin_higgs_cogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2005_06471", "source_line": 4205, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 1806, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection; high CMB relevance; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: BBN, CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9709492_supersymmetric_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9709492", "source_line": 6140, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1807, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 19 (defer) from supplied card content: q_ball_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior; cosmological relevance: BBN medium.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_5488_e6ssm_inert_neutralino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_5488", "source_line": 1480, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 1808, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out of an inert-neutralino LSP.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_1485_light_dark_photon_force_v1", "paper_id": "1412_1485", "source_line": 2344, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 113, "global_rank": 1809, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 19 because the assigned model card simplified model hidden_sector_dark_matter card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; touches BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_1485_light_dark_scalar_force_v1", "paper_id": "1412_1485", "source_line": 2345, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 114, "global_rank": 1810, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 19 because the assigned model card simplified model hidden_sector_dark_matter card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; touches BBN, CMB, indirect detection, laboratory precision / fifth-force searches.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_11646_fourth_generation_dark_atom_v1", "paper_id": "2106_11646", "source_line": 4776, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1811, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative composite_dark_matter card with unknown theory support and production logic from: electroweak sphaleron transfer of asymmetry; formation of helium-bound dark atoms after primordial helium production.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance.", "Diversity value is elevated by underrepresented family, production, phase-space, or structure-formation categories in the supplied population counts.", "Despite the distinctive category coverage, missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and routing keep the card in the defer tier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3094_su5_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3094", "source_line": 864, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 1812, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0503052_su5_goldstino_bino_wino_split_susy_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0503052", "source_line": 547, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1813, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because SU(5) Goldstino split-SUSY Bino-Wino neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches bbn, cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_4320_hylogenesis_antibaryonic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_4320", "source_line": 1398, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 1814, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as asymmetric_dark_matter: production is represented by nonthermal CP-violating X1 decays during reheating; phase-space is nonthermal; inferred probe coverage includes cosmological phase-space, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_2560_higgsino_sneutrino_late_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1409_2560", "source_line": 2254, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1815, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative nonthermal_higgsino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and nonthermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, registry-diversity value; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_02266_e7_nls_focus_point_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_02266", "source_line": 2392, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1816, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and nonthermal Higgsino production production.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase space; probe classes: collider, direct detection, small-scale structure.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (19 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: nonthermal Higgsino production."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_18740_hidden_u1x_dirac_fermion_dark_z_v1", "paper_id": "2305_18740", "source_line": 5648, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 115, "global_rank": 1817, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because hidden U(1)_X dark-Z thermal freeze-out model with partial relic-density code support.", "Score is still held down by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points despite limited code support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_07406_minimal_pq_axion_texture_zero_v1", "paper_id": "2304_07406", "source_line": 5624, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 1818, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because QCD axion model tied to fermion texture structure and field-like dark matter behavior.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_12302_techni_pati_salam_composite_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2005_12302", "source_line": 4211, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1819, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection; nonthermal phase-space information; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_07472_wimpflation_stable_inflaton_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2107_07472", "source_line": 4788, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 1820, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and production logic from: reheating by inflaton-Higgs scattering; thermalization with the Standard Model bath.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0509118_kk_photon_coannihilation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509118", "source_line": 525, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1821, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Kaluza-Klein photon dark matter with level-one coannihilation is a benchmark effective field theory card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_16090_superweak_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_16090", "source_line": 5325, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 101, "global_rank": 1822, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 19.0: sterile_neutrino_dark_matter with resonant thermal freezeout via Z' exchange; science=15.0, observational leverage=1.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection) and diversity=3.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_04680_anomalous_u1_le_lmu_ltau_axi_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_04680", "source_line": 6073, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 116, "global_rank": 1823, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 19.0: speculative effective field theory model in hidden_sector_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory flavor; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is partial and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_04680_anomalous_u1_lmu_ltau_axi_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_04680", "source_line": 6072, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 117, "global_rank": 1824, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 19.0: speculative effective field theory model in hidden_sector_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory flavor; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is partial and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_0617_two_component_singlet_scalar_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_0617", "source_line": 2208, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 83, "global_rank": 1825, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete multi_component_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_mixed_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_5539_natural_susy_higgsino_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1203_5539", "source_line": 1614, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1826, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Natural SUSY higgsino-axion dark matter; it offers BBN relevance with BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_fermion_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_3227_vector_fermion_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1409_3227", "source_line": 2243, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1827, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative vector_fermion_portal_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family, uncommon production history, or distinctive phase-space category in the provided population context.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_06680_elder_self_interacting_21cm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_06680", "source_line": 5622, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 1828, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because ELDER self-interacting dark matter with 21-cm motivation but mostly missing cosmological routing detail.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_majorana_wimp", "model_id": "1710_00691_u1d_dark_sector_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_00691", "source_line": 3274, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1829, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden sector majorana wimp candidate with uv complete theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 19.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_01973_u1dm_z3_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1501_01973", "source_line": 2325, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1830, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 19 because the assigned model card simplified model scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; touches CMB.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_4785_scotogenic_inverse_seesaw_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_4785", "source_line": 2242, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1831, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 70.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_7312_u1_prime_rh_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_7312", "source_line": 2361, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1832, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative right_handed_sneutrino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out of a stable right-handed sneutrino LSP in the U(1)' supersymmetric seesaw setup production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection, neutrino/indirect.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (4 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: thermal freeze-out of a stable right-handed sneutrino LSP in the U(1)' supersymmetric seesaw setup."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "z3_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_00508_accidental_complex_scalar_z3_v1", "paper_id": "1502_00508", "source_line": 2415, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1833, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a z3_scalar_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inflaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_05539_inflaton_incomplete_decay_wimplaton_v1", "paper_id": "1501_05539", "source_line": 2420, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1834, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a inflaton_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gut_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_1894_so10_scalar_16_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0907_1894", "source_line": 985, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 19, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1835, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gut_scalar_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 19, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_1128_axionic_see_saw_v1", "paper_id": "1207_1128", "source_line": 1665, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 142, "global_rank": 1836, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.8, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory entry; production is summarized as nonthermal primordial production of cold axions; cold Bose-Einstein condensate of primordial axions, with field_like phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 18.8 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=unknown and CMB=medium; card-implied probe classes include CMB, laboratory precision; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_09801_z3_scalar_exponential_growth_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_09801", "source_line": 5749, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1837, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.7, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Z3 scalar dark matter with exponential-growth production is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and nonthermal phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 3.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 4.7, penalties 16.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1301_1864_quantum_fermionic_wdm_thomas_fermi_v1", "paper_id": "1301_1864", "source_line": 1693, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 1838, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization entry; production is summarized as not derived in this paper; phase-space distribution is inherited from evolution since decoupling, with mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 18.5 reflects structure fields indicate smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale power; card-implied probe classes include small-scale structure; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_04936_heavy_mediator_dirac_hot_relic_v1", "paper_id": "2003_04936", "source_line": 4161, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 118, "global_rank": 1839, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of hidden_sector_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, small-scale-power suppression.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_11993_heavy_adm_higgs_portal_wd_ignition_v1", "paper_id": "1904_11993", "source_line": 3828, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 1840, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as asymmetric dark matter abundance, late-decaying fields may deplete late-time relic particle abundances in super-heavy ADM cosmologies.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_11993_heavy_adm_vector_portal_wd_ignition_v1", "paper_id": "1904_11993", "source_line": 3827, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 1841, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as asymmetric dark matter abundance, late-decaying fields may deplete late-time relic particle abundances in super-heavy ADM cosmologies.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_04648_cold_natural_hidden_sector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_04648", "source_line": 4128, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 119, "global_rank": 1842, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 18.5: speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unparticle_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_1506_z2_unparticle_higgs_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0711_1506", "source_line": 739, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1843, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative effective_field_theory model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1706_03746_pbh_dm_inflaton_running_emd_v1", "paper_id": "1706_03746", "source_line": 3175, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 104, "global_rank": 1844, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 18.5: PBH dark matter from running-inflaton perturbations in an early matter-dominated era is a speculative phenomenological parameterization entry with collapse of enhanced inflaton-sourced density perturbations during an early matter-dominated era.", "Rank-relevant positives are high BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space treatment, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, CMB, compact objects, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1706_03746_pbh_dm_spectator_blue_spectrum_emd_v1", "paper_id": "1706_03746", "source_line": 3176, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 105, "global_rank": 1845, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 18.5: PBH dark matter from blue spectator-field perturbations in an early matter-dominated era is a speculative phenomenological parameterization entry with collapse of spectator-field-sourced density perturbations during an early matter-dominated era.", "Rank-relevant positives are high BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space treatment, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, CMB, compact objects, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0709_1218_hidden_sector_pion_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "0709_1218", "source_line": 746, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 120, "global_rank": 1846, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_hidden_sector_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_03837_u1x_millicharged_dark_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2312_03837", "source_line": 5906, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1847, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because U(1)_X millicharged dark fermion freeze-in model is a speculative millicharged_hidden_sector_freeze_in_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and BBN from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 10, observational leverage 7, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 6.5, penalties 16; raw score 18.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_05420_feeton_b_minus_l_threshold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2310_05420", "source_line": 5802, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 121, "global_rank": 1848, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is inflationary production of light gauge bosons independent of gauge coupling.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (nonthermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_17246_vectorlike_portal_scalar_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2312_17246", "source_line": 5892, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 115, "global_rank": 1849, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the vectorlike-portal scalar FIMP has a clear finite-temperature freeze-in setup, but no explicit observables, constraints, or public implementation are supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_03232_z8_z22_flavonic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2404_03232", "source_line": 5992, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1850, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from flavonic_dark_matter: Z8 x Z22 flavonic dark matter has moderate model/theory value, high diversity value through initial misalignment of the axial flavon field during inflation; inferred probe classes are indirect_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2301_12750_vas_supergravity_a4_asteroid_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_12750", "source_line": 65, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 106, "global_rank": 1851, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this primordial_black_holes card is viable enough to score, with uv_complete theory support and high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2301_12750_vas_supergravity_b3_asteroid_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_12750", "source_line": 66, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 107, "global_rank": 1852, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this primordial_black_holes card is viable enough to score, with uv_complete theory support and high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "e6_inspired_susy_hot_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_11533_e6_exotic_hot_dark_matter_asymmetry_v1", "paper_id": "1710_11533", "source_line": 3328, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1853, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 9.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with no relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, decay produced phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_09126_fermionic_higgs_portal_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_09126", "source_line": 2725, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1854, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has a card-local full-dark-matter production route, medium CMB relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB, collider, direct detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2311_17760_smooth_crossover_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2311_17760", "source_line": 5931, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 108, "global_rank": 1855, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Smooth-crossover primordial black-hole dark matter is a speculative primordial_black_holes card with not_applicable phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and compact objects, gravitational waves from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 9, observational leverage 4, complementarity 5, feasibility 1, provenance 9, diversity 3.5, penalties 13; raw score 18.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_01263_type_iii_gmsb_lhu_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_01263", "source_line": 4803, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 1856, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_6523_susy_pq_dirac_neutrino_axion_axino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1402_6523", "source_line": 2046, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 84, "global_rank": 1857, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=mixed_cold_warm, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "miracle_less_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_10474_miracle_less_wimp_bl_entropy_dilution_v1", "paper_id": "2202_10474", "source_line": 5029, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1858, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Miracle-less WIMP with gauged B-L entropy dilution has probe classes: BBN, gravitational waves, laboratory/particle; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_13407_tdsidm_smbh_seed_v1", "paper_id": "2103_13407", "source_line": 4643, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 1859, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative self interacting dark matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and relic support marked yes; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_5865_hidden_condensate_matter_parity_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1009_5865", "source_line": 1192, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 1860, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_3932_thermal_right_handed_sneutrino_v1", "paper_id": "0809_3932", "source_line": 885, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1861, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, full dark-matter abundance capability, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_fermionic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_06141_higgs_portal_fermion_dm_neutron_star_v1", "paper_id": "2104_06141", "source_line": 4622, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1862, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative higgs portal fermionic dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked unknown; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_5100_no_scale_fsu5_golden_point_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1007_5100", "source_line": 1190, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 1863, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, high scientific motivation from its theory setting and relic mechanism."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_04955_z3_semi_annihilating_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_04955", "source_line": 5750, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1864, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Z3 semi-annihilating dark matter for global 21-cm cosmology is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 7.0, observational 1.0, complementarity 8.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 3.5, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "isospin_violating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_1391_elastic_scalar_vector_isospin_violating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1108_1391", "source_line": 1363, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1865, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as isospin_violating_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out through Z-prime and scalar mediator channels; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_0580_three_degenerate_mixed_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_0580", "source_line": 1176, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 1866, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_04783_spontaneous_cp_scotogenic_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_04783", "source_line": 5808, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1867, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative uv_complete model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out of the inert-doublet neutral component.", "Follow-up value comes from direct/collider, gravitational waves/defects, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "left_right_scotino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1006_3804_dark_left_right_scotino_v1", "paper_id": "1006_3804", "source_line": 1153, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1868, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, distinctive or underrepresented model-space coverage, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_fermion_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_3967_asymmetric_inelastic_fermion_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1108_3967", "source_line": 1372, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1869, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as asymmetric_fermion_doublet_dark_matter: production is represented by asymmetric dark matter from out-of-equilibrium scalar-triplet decays; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_11779_u1x_pq_dfsz_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1909_11779", "source_line": 4026, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 143, "global_rank": 1870, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.9, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes field_like phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_04312_alp_pbh_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "2110_04312", "source_line": 4841, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.2, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 144, "global_rank": 1871, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, field like phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_6358_charged_excitation_case_a_majorana_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1209_6358", "source_line": 1669, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1872, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as co-annihilation with charged excitation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 18.2 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=medium and CMB=unknown; card-implied probe classes include BBN, collider, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_6577_cmssm_q_ball_bino_cogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1405_6577", "source_line": 2207, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1873, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete supersymmetric_asymmetric_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "No distinct probe classes were explicit enough to score complementarity.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family, uncommon production history, or distinctive phase-space category in the provided population context.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_09990_trapped_vacuum_bubble_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_09990", "source_line": 5707, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 109, "global_rank": 1874, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Trapped-vacuum-bubble primordial black hole dark matter is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, compact objects/dynamics, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 1.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 4.2, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_04694_rsb_phase_transition_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2307_04694", "source_line": 5743, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1875, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 7.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Primordial black holes from radiative-symmetry-breaking first-order phase transitions is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across compact objects/dynamics, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 8.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 7.2, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0701011_axino_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0701011", "source_line": 653, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1876, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: strong cosmology/structure leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0701011_gravitino_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0701011", "source_line": 652, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1877, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: strong cosmology/structure leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0701007_right_handed_sneutrino_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0701007", "source_line": 693, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1878, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: strong cosmology/structure leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boson_star_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_02094_liouville_boson_star_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1906_02094", "source_line": 3892, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support.", "The supplied card indicates a subcomponent/no-full-abundance dark matter role."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1879, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: A light singlet scalar boson-star dark-matter subcomponent benchmark with a nontrivial self-interaction potential.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: phenomenological relic treatment, subcomponent, production reach no; BBN unknown; CMB high; phase-space field_like; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boson_star_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_02094_logarithmic_boson_star_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1906_02094", "source_line": 3893, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support.", "The supplied card indicates a subcomponent/no-full-abundance dark matter role."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1880, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: A light singlet scalar boson-star dark-matter subcomponent benchmark with a nontrivial self-interaction potential.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: phenomenological relic treatment, subcomponent, production reach no; BBN unknown; CMB high; phase-space field_like; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_5902_hidden_photon_misalignment_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_5902", "source_line": 1538, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 122, "global_rank": 1881, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, and field like phase-space treatment.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_00948_solar_neutrino_boosted_bound_state_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2001_00948", "source_line": 4102, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 123, "global_rank": 1882, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 18: speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: direct detection, neutrino.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_assisted_wimp", "model_id": "1311_1637_cusp_emission_p_wave_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1311_1637", "source_line": 1986, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1883, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_assisted_wimp", "model_id": "1311_1637_cusp_emission_s_wave_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1311_1637", "source_line": 1985, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1884, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_assisted_wimp", "model_id": "1311_1637_field_theory_string_p_wave_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1311_1637", "source_line": 1984, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1885, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_assisted_wimp", "model_id": "1311_1637_field_theory_string_s_wave_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1311_1637", "source_line": 1983, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1886, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_04294_dynamical_decay_constant_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_04294", "source_line": 2851, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 145, "global_rank": 1887, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; high CMB relevance; field_like phase-space population; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_04394_surface_type_dbi_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2307_04394", "source_line": 212, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 1888, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative scalar_field_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=scale_dependent_growth, small_scale_power_effect=suppression, and probe classes: CMB, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_1256_rotating_bec_cdm_vortices_v1", "paper_id": "1106_1256", "source_line": 1281, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1889, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 18 for Rotating Bose-Einstein-condensate cold dark matter with possible vortices: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from phase space is field_like; distribution function availability is approximate; small-scale power shows suppression; transfer shape is smooth_cutoff.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_11264_semi_annihilation_bdm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_11264", "source_line": 4284, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1890, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative boosted_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via semi-annihilation produces a boosted final-state dark matter particle; annihilations in the Galactic Center or halo can provide the BDM flux, nonthermal phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified; a high-severity model-card warning was retained as a penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_08188_one_hz_alp_two_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1912_08188", "source_line": 4106, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 146, "global_rank": 1891, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 18: speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and relic-density support marked yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: high BBN relevance, field_like phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: BBN.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_11862_vector_moduli_portal_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1911_11862", "source_line": 4063, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 18.0 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 116, "global_rank": 1892, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 69.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: none explicit in the card.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_04963_scalar_contact_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_04963", "source_line": 4287, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 1893, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative inelastic_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via thermal freeze-out of XX', XX, and X'X' annihilation into lepton pairs; late conversion scattering e X' -> e X maintains equal component densities until about MeV temperatures.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_2217_boson_decay_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1011_2217", "source_line": 1251, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1894, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 18 for Boson-decay sterile-neutrino warm dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is medium; phase space is decay_produced; distribution function availability is yes; small-scale power shows suppression.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_11038_light_scalar_mediator_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1711_11038", "source_line": 3416, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 117, "global_rank": 1895, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance unknown/medium; phase-space type nonthermal; portals higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: scalar_freeze_in_subcomponent_warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_17171_type_x_2hdm_secluded_dirac_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2312_17171", "source_line": 5908, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1896, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Type-X 2HDM secluded Dirac-fermion dark sector is a speculative secluded_dark_sector_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and BBN from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 8, observational leverage 9, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 6.0, penalties 16; raw score 18.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phase_transition_sudden_freeze_out_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_07313_scalar_quartic_bubble_filtered_sudden_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2006_07313", "source_line": 4274, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1897, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative phase_transition_sudden_freeze_out_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support, production via first-order phase-transition sudden freeze-out; bubble filtering of a thermal DM flux at expanding walls, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_inflaton_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_17262_nonthermal_inflaton_decay_fermion_dm_metric_v1", "paper_id": "2401_17262", "source_line": 5947, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1898, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Nonthermal inflaton-decay fermion dark matter (metric formalism) is a speculative nonthermal_inflaton_decay_dark_matter card with decay_produced phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and CMB from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 12, observational leverage 9, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 6.0, penalties 20; raw score 18.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_inflaton_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_17262_nonthermal_inflaton_decay_fermion_dm_palatini_v1", "paper_id": "2401_17262", "source_line": 5948, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1899, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Nonthermal inflaton-decay fermion dark matter (Palatini formalism) is a speculative nonthermal_inflaton_decay_dark_matter card with decay_produced phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and CMB from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 12, observational leverage 9, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 6.0, penalties 20; raw score 18.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_07626_extended_dm_eft_fermion_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1712_07626", "source_line": 3359, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1900, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative effective_field_theory_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_destructing_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_00455_tunneling_sddm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_00455", "source_line": 3371, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1901, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative self_destructing_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and unknown phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_07720_confined_colored_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_07720", "source_line": 3390, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 124, "global_rank": 1902, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified model theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is high/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, astrophysical fields, collider/fixed-target.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_4491_assisted_freeze_out_multicomponent_v1", "paper_id": "1112_4491", "source_line": 1533, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 85, "global_rank": 1903, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and multi component dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, direct detection, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_2064_pseudoscalar_fermionic_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1203_2064", "source_line": 1516, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1904, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, effective field theory theory level, and fermionic higgs portal dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "puffy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_13243_finite_size_puffy_dm_electron_recoil_v1", "paper_id": "2304_13243", "source_line": 5586, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1905, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: finite-size puffy dark matter is rare and electron-recoil motivated, but relic production is unspecified and follow-up routing is absent.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_00716_anomalous_u1_string_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_00716", "source_line": 2757, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 147, "global_rank": 1906, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in axion_like_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: bosonic coherent motion / axion misalignment-like production; portals: axion; phase-space type is field_like.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_11554_cpt_symmetric_rhn_dark_matter_anita_v1", "paper_id": "1803_11554", "source_line": 3429, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1907, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level phenomenological_parameterization; relic status yes; phase-space type nonthermal; portals higgs, gravitational.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: w1, w2."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_01770_baryonic_vector_scalar_light_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_01770", "source_line": 2892, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 125, "global_rank": 1908, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; associated code is marked yes; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_5136_fn_kev_sterile_neutrino_scenario_b_v1", "paper_id": "1105_5136", "source_line": 1331, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 102, "global_rank": 1909, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type nonthermal.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "baryomorphosis_scalar_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_3124_baryomorphosis_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1201_3124", "source_line": 1534, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1910, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and mixed cold warm phase-space treatment.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_1536_7kev_rpv_axino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1403_1536", "source_line": 2087, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 1911, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of warm_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; non-CDM small-scale structure information; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_06611_millicharged_dirac_neutrino_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2310_06611", "source_line": 5823, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card.", "Relic-density follow-up value is reduced because the card does not support a full-DM regime or leaves it unknown."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 1912, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out supplemented by annihilation into neutrinos.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, direct/collider, indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2308_14688_planet_mass_pbh_higgs_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "2308_14688", "source_line": 214, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 110, "global_rank": 1913, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=enhanced_small_scale_power, small_scale_power_effect=enhancement, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical, gravitational waves.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: abundance_sensitivity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_06382_three_body_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1608_06382", "source_line": 2872, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 1914, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative decaying_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing medium CMB relevance; 3 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; associated code is marked partial; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0608147_low_energy_seesaw_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0608147", "source_line": 634, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 103, "global_rank": 1915, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, moderate diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_03871_wimp_isocurvature_early_matter_domination_v1", "paper_id": "1507_03871", "source_line": 2535, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1916, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for WIMP isocurvature with early matter domination: model-card phase-space, cosmology, or structure fields provide some observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 18.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_15322_alp_reheating_misalignment_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_15322", "source_line": 5784, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 148, "global_rank": 1917, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Axion-like particle dark matter from misalignment during inflationary reheating has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include BBN, axion/laboratory searches.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_03079_bigravity_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2310_03079", "source_line": 5790, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 126, "global_rank": 1918, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Bi-gravity portal dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include axion/laboratory searches, laboratory precision.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_01785_rotating_pq_axion_kinetic_misalignment_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_01785", "source_line": 5084, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 149, "global_rank": 1919, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18 (defer) as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of axion_like_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB, axion/laboratory.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: phase transition/gw, axion/strong-cp, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in, baryogenesis/leptogenesis.", "Production summary used: kinetic misalignment from axion rotation; possible misalignment axion production."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_1328_gut_focused_higgsino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1402_1328", "source_line": 1989, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1920, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_05802_u1d_majorana_eta2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_05802", "source_line": 3358, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1921, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative vector_portal_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_01270_high_mass_effective_idm_derivative_variant_v1", "paper_id": "2307_01270", "source_line": 5658, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1922, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because High-mass effective inert-doublet derivative-operator dark matter variant (inert_doublet_effective_field_theory_dark_matter) has higgs, vector portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support, low robustness. Raw score 18.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_06736_hidden_u1h_zprime_wimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_06736", "source_line": 3393, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 127, "global_rank": 1923, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_07462_b_l_seesaw_vectorlike_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1803_07462", "source_line": 3432, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1924, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance medium/unknown; phase-space type thermal; portals vector.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: charge_choice_matters, constraints_not_extracted."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_12591_type_ii_seesaw_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_12591", "source_line": 5872, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1925, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the UV-complete type-II-seesaw/inert-doublet construction is scientifically motivated, but relic-density details and observational machinery are sparse in the supplied fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_02756_planck_suppressed_superwimp_case_i_visible_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1906_02756", "source_line": 3896, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1926, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / effective_field_theory: The inert scalar doublet mother decays through Planck-suppressed operators into SM leptons as well as the singlet fermion dark matter; the singlet is long-lived but not perfectly stable.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN medium; CMB medium; phase-space decay_produced; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_02756_planck_suppressed_superwimp_case_ii_neutrino_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1906_02756", "source_line": 3897, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1927, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / effective_field_theory: A gauged-uplift variant where the scalar mother decays to the singlet fermion dark matter plus a SM neutrino, with the dark matter treated as perfectly stable.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN medium; CMB medium; phase-space decay_produced; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_02756_planck_suppressed_superwimp_case_iii_pair_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1906_02756", "source_line": 3898, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 1928, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / effective_field_theory: A gauged-uplift variant where the scalar mother decays into a pair of singlet fermion dark matter particles through a naturally tiny electroweak-over-Planck effective coupling.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN medium; CMB medium; phase-space decay_produced; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_10125_flavonic_goldstone_misalignment_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_10125", "source_line": 5573, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 150, "global_rank": 1929, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: flavonic Goldstone misalignment is a coherent full-DM scenario, but the card is CDM-like and observational-detail support is sparse.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_02126_z_n_axion_alp_double_level_crossing_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_02126", "source_line": 5800, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 151, "global_rank": 1930, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Z_N axion dark matter with ALP double level crossings has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include axion/laboratory searches, gravitational waves.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_16376_u2_12_doublet_anomaly_free_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_16376", "source_line": 5096, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 152, "global_rank": 1931, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18 (defer) as a speculative effective_field_theory member of axion_like_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: collider/accelerator, axion/laboratory.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, tension/anomaly, axion/strong-cp.", "Production summary used: not specified; abundance fraction imposed phenomenologically for Xenon1T interpretation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "massive_graviton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_06704_bimetric_massive_graviton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1604_06704", "source_line": 371, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1932, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative uv_complete model; production via nonthermal generation from inhomogeneous sources during preheating after inflation; linear structure effect suppression with transfer shape unknown; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: large-scale/small-scale structure, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cosmological_gauge_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_12052_cgf_cosmology_su2_weak_gauge_field_v1", "paper_id": "2203_12052", "source_line": 5094, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1933, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of cosmological_gauge_field_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: semiclassical cosmological initial condition; classical Yang-Mills field evolution from the electroweak transition onward."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_6338_classically_scale_invariant_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_6338", "source_line": 1907, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 1934, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18.0 because the model card is a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; unknown BBN and high CMB relevance and touches CMB, cosmological gravity, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_08780_secluded_dark_higgs_strahlung_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_08780", "source_line": 3080, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 128, "global_rank": 1935, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability yes.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance medium, CMB relevance low; inferred probe classes: BBN, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_02699_spin_flipped_vectorlike_scalar_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_02699", "source_line": 3093, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1936, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative fermionic_leptophilic_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium; inferred probe classes: CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_higgs_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_6208_so7_g2_composite_higgs_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_6208", "source_line": 1658, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1937, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory entry; production is summarized as relic abundance from derivative interactions fixed by the SO(7)/G2 coset for sufficiently heavy singlet scalar dark matter, with unknown phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 18 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_06988_leptophilic_composite_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_06988", "source_line": 4659, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1938, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level uv_complete, and relic production yes; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_lsp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0211147_mssm_flat_direction_lsp_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0211147", "source_line": 427, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1939, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides simplified model theory support, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: bbn, cmb.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_07784_dark_sector_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_07784", "source_line": 5064, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1940, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of radiative_neutrino_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through t-channel dark-scalar exchange; possible resonant annihilation through additional complex scalar singlets."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2308_14908_r_symmetric_su5_inflation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_14908", "source_line": 5762, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 111, "global_rank": 1941, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Primordial-black-hole dark matter from R-symmetric SU(5) multifield inflation has strong theory or relic-density motivation, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include CMB/cosmic-dawn, compact objects/microlensing.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: pbh_abundance_sensitive."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_10448_lmu_ltau_scalar_dm_zprime_v1", "paper_id": "1801_10448", "source_line": 3402, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1942, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status yes; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals vector; underrepresented family count 1.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: stability_unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_3591_g2_mssm_nonthermal_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1104_3591", "source_line": 1315, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 1943, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level BBN relevance critical, phase-space type decay_produced.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_2858_gravitino_stau_nlsp_dark_component_v1", "paper_id": "1008_2858", "source_line": 1149, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 1944, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization entry in gravitino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, critical BBN relevance, nonthermal phase space, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_8152_inert_scalar_quartet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_8152", "source_line": 1915, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1945, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 11, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18.0 because the model card is a speculative inert_electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; unknown BBN and medium CMB relevance; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches CMB, collider, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2309_14929_charged_primordial_black_hole_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_14929", "source_line": 5791, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 112, "global_rank": 1946, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Charged spinning primordial black hole dark matter has some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include axion/laboratory searches, collider/fixed-target, compact objects/microlensing, direct detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_0285_z2_singlet_fermion_n_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1012_0285", "source_line": 1224, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1947, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family singlet_fermion_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out of N; loop-suppressed annihilation through S and N_i.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection, laboratory precision / neutrino.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_1222_minimal_hidden_u1x_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1409_1222", "source_line": 2257, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 129, "global_rank": 1948, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and nonthermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_01726_2hdm_scalar_singlet_doubly_blind_spot_v1", "paper_id": "1907_01726", "source_line": 3980, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 1949, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for 2HDM plus scalar singlet doubly blind-spot dark matter: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 18 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out from equilibrium with the Standard Model; phase=thermal; CMB=low, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_2011_qcd_hidden_axion_resonant_conversion_v1", "paper_id": "1411_2011", "source_line": 2253, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 153, "global_rank": 1950, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and field_like phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_02327_complex_singlet_dark_phase_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_02327", "source_line": 3099, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1951, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_05569_scale_invariant_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_05569", "source_line": 2780, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 1952, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in scotogenic_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out of singlet fermion dark matter; annihilation through inert scalar and Higgs/dilaton mediated channels; portals: higgs, neutrino, other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_09566_mirror_baryon_heavy_pbh_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_09566", "source_line": 5302, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 86, "global_rank": 1953, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 68.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 18.0: multi_component_dark_matter with mirror baryon relic component; science=11.0, observational leverage=4.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, indirect detection) and diversity=3.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "0904_2789_susy_gut_decaying_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0904_2789", "source_line": 893, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 1954, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_12755_singlet_triplet_scotogenic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_12755", "source_line": 5799, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 1955, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Singlet-triplet scotogenic scalar dark matter model has moderate scientific motivation, partial associated-code or tool support; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_07621_gev_u1x_dirac_fermion_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1907_07621", "source_line": 3981, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 130, "global_rank": 1956, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for GeV-scale U(1)_X Dirac fermion dark sector: strong model-card science motivation; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 18 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out through A prime mediated annihilation; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_massive_particle", "model_id": "1702_07860_dark_meson_simp_v1", "paper_id": "1702_07860", "source_line": 3064, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1957, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a benchmark strongly_interacting_massive_particle entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_massive_particle", "model_id": "1702_07860_discrete_gauge_simp_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1702_07860", "source_line": 3063, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1958, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a benchmark strongly_interacting_massive_particle entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_09277_inelastic_flavored_bl3_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_09277", "source_line": 3971, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1959, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Inelastic third-generation B-L charged scalar dark matter: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 18 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out with S-P coannihilation through the extra U(1) gauge interaction; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "u1_extended_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_03275_umssm_kinetic_mixing_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_03275", "source_line": 3066, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1960, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative u1_extended_supersymmetric_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_b-l_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_01769_bl_gaugino_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_01769", "source_line": 2754, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1961, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in supersymmetric_b-l_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through resonant s-channel Z prime annihilation; portals: vector.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_3041_inflaton_decay_nonthermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_3041", "source_line": 2330, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1962, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 18 because the assigned model card phenomenological parameterization nonthermal_dark_matter card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; uses decay produced phase-space information; touches BBN, CMB.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_05382_n2hdm_dark_doublet_phase_v1", "paper_id": "2004_05382", "source_line": 4256, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 1963, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support, production via thermal freeze-out through scalar and electroweak interactions.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_02828_dark_cp_2hdm_complex_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_02828", "source_line": 5855, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 1964, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the thermal Higgs-portal scalar model is well defined and auditably extracted, but its current card has standard CDM-like behavior and no explicit observational constraints, observables, or routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_3545_u1r_gravitino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "0901_3545", "source_line": 964, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 1965, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravitino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_4412_su5_btau_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1201_4412", "source_line": 1522, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 1966, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and supersymmetric neutralino dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets partial associated-code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_4657_domino_flavor_axion_axino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0906_4657", "source_line": 990, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 87, "global_rank": 1967, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_11149_scotogenic_hybrid_texture_n1_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_11149", "source_line": 5574, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 131, "global_rank": 1968, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the scotogenic hybrid-texture model has good UV motivation, but current observational follow-up value is low because the supplied card has no populated observable or route fields.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0408336_intermediate_scale_pq_axion_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0408336", "source_line": 527, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 154, "global_rank": 1969, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Intermediate-scale Peccei-Quinn axion dark matter is a speculative uv complete card with either relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (field like; small-scale effect unknown); it touches bbn, cmb; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0407245_scalar_field_mini_machos_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0407245", "source_line": 550, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1970, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Scalar-field mini-MACHO dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (nonthermal; small-scale effect none); it touches cmb, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "oscillating_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_14013_pregeometry_oscillating_gauge_field_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_14013", "source_line": 29, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1971, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative uv_complete model, medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_04672_majoraxion_case_a_v1", "paper_id": "2204_04672", "source_line": 5104, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 155, "global_rank": 1972, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a motivated Majoraxion/PQ-flavour case with field-like nonthermal production, but CDM-like structure and absent observable routing keep it low tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_11150_dark_magnetic_dipole_vector_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2106_11150", "source_line": 4790, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 132, "global_rank": 1973, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out through dark photon mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "split_supersymmetry_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0405159_split_susy_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0405159", "source_line": 526, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1974, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Split-supersymmetry neutralino dark matter is a speculative effective field theory card with either relic-density treatment; it touches bbn, cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_3030_fermion_lepton_flavored_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_3030", "source_line": 2264, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 1975, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and nonthermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_3030_scalar_lepton_flavored_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_3030", "source_line": 2263, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 1976, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and nonthermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1709_05565_log_corrected_single_field_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_05565", "source_line": 3263, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 113, "global_rank": 1977, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial black holes candidate with effective field theory theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 18.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1709_05565_polynomial_single_field_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_05565", "source_line": 3264, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 114, "global_rank": 1978, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial black holes candidate with effective field theory theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 18.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2008_10476_supergravity_pbh_double_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "2008_10476", "source_line": 4366, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 115, "global_rank": 1979, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Modified-supergravity double-inflation PBH dark matter: PBH formation from enhanced primordial curvature perturbations after double inflation; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamics and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1301_1773_singlet_fermion_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1301_1773", "source_line": 1678, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 1980, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out through Higgs/singlet-scalar portal annihilation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 18 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_04840_gauged_b_l_scotoseesaw_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_04840", "source_line": 5766, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1981, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Gauged B-L scoto-seesaw Majorana fermion dark matter has strong theory or relic-density motivation; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_06903_fcd_odd_pngb_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_06903", "source_line": 3053, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1982, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative composite_scalar_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance low, CMB relevance low; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_00009_alp_mediated_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_00009", "source_line": 3253, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1983, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion like mediated dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 18.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_05412_majoron_semiannihilating_z3_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_05412", "source_line": 5050, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1984, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Majoron-assisted semi-annihilating Z3 scalar dark matter has probe classes: BBN, laboratory/particle, small-scale structure; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10499_neutron_coannihilating_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10499", "source_line": 5195, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1985, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: rare neutron-coannihilating EFT has critical BBN sensitivity and distinctive mass window, but UV completion and thermal-history warnings keep priority low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_18226_u1_self_interacting_dark_matter_dark_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "2405_18226", "source_line": 6126, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 1986, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18 (defer) from supplied card content: self_interacting_dark_matter with simplified_model theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; cosmological relevance: BBN medium.", "Penalties (14) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_13966_simp_dark_pion_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2004_13966", "source_line": 4214, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 1987, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include phase-transition or confinement connection, structure or tension connection; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: BBN, CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_00525_superweak_sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2112_00525", "source_line": 5003, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1988, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Super-weak U(1)_z sterile-neutrino freeze-in dark matter has probe classes: BBN, laboratory/particle; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_12517_axiogenesis_magnetic_helicity_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_12517", "source_line": 5433, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Scientific motivation is high, but missing observables, constraints, routing, and code keep it below tier 3."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 1989, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["One of the stronger deferred cards: UV-complete axiogenesis links axion dark matter to baryogenesis/magnetic helicity and has nonthermal CMB relevance, but route and constraint fields are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_type_ii_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_10516_scotogenic_type_ii_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_10516", "source_line": 3859, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1990, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A type-II seesaw extension with a Higgs triplet, Z2-odd vector-like lepton doublet, and Z2-odd singlet Majorana lepton, where the viable dark matter candidate is the mostly singlet Majorana state.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space thermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_11558_dark_su2d_vector_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2109_11558", "source_line": 4858, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 1991, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; nonthermal phase-space production; rare family in population context (count 6).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_09586_dark_u1d_breit_wigner_v1", "paper_id": "1712_09586", "source_line": 3339, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1992, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with high CMB relevance, 4 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_04325_axion_quark_nugget_thunderstorm_bursts_v1", "paper_id": "2008_04325", "source_line": 4386, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 1993, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Axion quark nugget dark matter with thunderstorm burst interpretation: formation of quark and antiquark nuggets during the QCD transition; good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamics and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonabelian_exciting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_0233_nonabelian_doublet_collisional_xdm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_0233", "source_line": 2271, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1994, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative nonabelian_exciting_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and nonthermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, registry-diversity value; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_14882_light_2hdm_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_14882", "source_line": 5329, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 1995, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 18.0: higgs_portal_dark_matter with thermal freeze-out through s-channel light-scalar exchange; science=13.0, observational leverage=2.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection) and diversity=3.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1006_0133_numsm_sterile_neutrino_baryogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1006_0133", "source_line": 1194, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 104, "global_rank": 1996, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, high scientific motivation from its theory setting and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1006_4007_numsm_loop_corrected_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1006_4007", "source_line": 1195, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 105, "global_rank": 1997, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, high scientific motivation from its theory setting and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_2468_singlet_scalar_s_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_2468", "source_line": 1354, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 1998, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter: production is represented by post-inflation reheating by stochastic resonance through the Higgs portal; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by effective_field_theory structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_compact_object_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_07728_light_primordial_exotic_compact_object_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_07728", "source_line": 3338, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 1999, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with yes relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_fermion_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_06602_triplet_knt_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_06602", "source_line": 4391, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2000, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Triplet generalized KNT fermion dark matter: standard thermal freeze-out dominated by electroweak gauge annihilation; good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, indirect/transient, laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_2246_two_component_boosted_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_2246", "source_line": 2301, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 88, "global_rank": 2001, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 18 because the assigned model card simplified model multi_component_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; uses mixed cold warm phase-space information; touches direct detection, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_4014_composite_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1411_4014", "source_line": 2347, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 2002, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 18 because the assigned model card simplified model asymmetric_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; touches BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_13174_anomalous_u1_moduli_portal_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2204_13174", "source_line": 5176, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 118, "global_rank": 2003, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: UV-complete heavy moduli-portal FIMP has analytic reheating production and full-DM relic logic, but observable mappings are mostly absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_13174_non_anomalous_moduli_portal_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2204_13174", "source_line": 5177, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 119, "global_rank": 2004, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: non-anomalous moduli-portal FIMP is a substantive variant with analytic production, but it remains observationally under-routed and close to the anomalous variant."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "early_matter_domination_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_13136_visible_sector_emd_thermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_13136", "source_line": 4878, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2005, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: critical BBN relevance; rare family in population context (count 2).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phase_transition_diluted_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_1317_phase_transition_diluted_neutralino_relic_v1", "paper_id": "0909_1317", "source_line": 1002, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2006, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 18 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness, registry diversity value.", "Card-local details considered: identity family phase_transition_diluted_neutralino_dark_matter, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and probe handles: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_1573_general_nmssm_singlino_cp_odd_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1409_1573", "source_line": 2251, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 2007, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0503052_pati_salam_wino_split_susy_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0503052", "source_line": 548, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2008, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Pati-Salam Goldstino split-SUSY Wino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_3155_z2_odd_singlet_scalar_higgs_sector_v1", "paper_id": "0902_3155", "source_line": 900, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2009, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, full dark-matter abundance capability, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_07540_randall_sundrum_gravity_mediated_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1706_07540", "source_line": 3178, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2010, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 18.0: Randall-Sundrum gravity-mediated spin-1 dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with thermal freeze-out via s-channel KK graviton exchange.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_3859_nuhm_relic_density_benchmark_mapping_v1", "paper_id": "1109_3859", "source_line": 1470, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 2011, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter variant and records LSP relic abundance adjusted through NUHM Higgs-sector parameters.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_3516_lepton_flavored_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1109_3516", "source_line": 1367, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2012, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as flavored_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_10617_right_sneutrino_lsp_compressed_higgsino_v1", "paper_id": "1710_10617", "source_line": 3287, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2013, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sneutrino dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 18.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_8120_complex_vector_effective_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1307_8120", "source_line": 1849, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2014, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 67.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative effective_wimp_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on collider, direct detection, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_8120_real_vector_effective_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1307_8120", "source_line": 1848, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2015, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative effective_wimp_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on collider, direct detection, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_06931_higgs_inflation_scalar_dm_rh_neutrinos_v1", "paper_id": "1504_06931", "source_line": 2381, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2016, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal Higgs-portal scalar dark matter production inferred from the Higgs-portal setup production.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_02904_lr_su2r_quintuplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_02904", "source_line": 3625, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2017, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative minimal_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_14309_z3_dark_matter_companion_v1", "paper_id": "2405_14309", "source_line": 6077, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2018, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 18.0: speculative simplified model model in semi_annihilating_scalar_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: direct detection, indirect detection; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is partial and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_06750_leptophilic_scalar_stodolsky_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_06750", "source_line": 5606, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2019, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because a rare leptophilic scalar/Stodolsky-effect target with diversity value but weak cosmological and routing support.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_mass_singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_05417_sequential_u1x_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_05417", "source_line": 4868, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2020, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from uv_complete theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; rare family in population context (count 1).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_09605_complex_singlet_pseudo_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_09605", "source_line": 4353, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2021, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as General complex-singlet pseudo-Goldstone dark matter: thermal relic abundance through annihilation channels mediated by h1 and h2; partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes collider/fixed-target, gravitational waves, indirect/transient and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_2407_tev_three_loop_radiative_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_2407", "source_line": 1157, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2022, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_coupled_dark_sector", "model_id": "2211_00025_annihilating_strongly_coupled_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2211_00025", "source_line": 5333, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2023, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 18.0: strongly_coupled_dark_sector with thermal freeze-out with velocity-enhanced present-day annihilation; science=9.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection, stellar streams) and diversity=7.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_14519_nmssm_neutralino_fopt_dilution_v1", "paper_id": "2207_14519", "source_line": 5318, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2024, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 18.0: supersymmetric_dark_matter with thermal neutralino freeze-out; science=14.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_2763_electroweak_triplet_unification_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1008_2763", "source_line": 1155, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 18, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2025, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 18 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 18, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_16207_parity_right_handed_neutrino_warm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_16207", "source_line": 5362, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 106, "global_rank": 2026, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Parity-model right-handed neutrino warm dark matter has some cosmology or phase-space leverage, probe classes: small-scale structure, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_irruptive_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_1584_kinetic_irrupton_superheavy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_1584", "source_line": 2236, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2027, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative superheavy_irruptive_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching CMB, cosmological production.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family, uncommon production history, or distinctive phase-space category in the provided population context.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_irruptive_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_1584_potential_irrupton_superheavy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_1584", "source_line": 2235, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2028, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative superheavy_irruptive_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching CMB, cosmological production.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family, uncommon production history, or distinctive phase-space category in the provided population context.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_15495_imperfect_axion_sm_linear_pq_breaking_v1", "paper_id": "2305_15495", "source_line": 5712, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 156, "global_rank": 2029, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 1.7, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Imperfect QCD axion with SM-linear Peccei-Quinn breaking is a speculative effective_field_theory card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and field_like phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 9.0, observational 2.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 1.7, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_05425_axion_magnetogenesis_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2307_05425", "source_line": 5731, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 157, "global_rank": 2030, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 2.7, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Axion dark matter magnetogenesis variant is a speculative effective_field_theory card with yes relic-abundance support and field_like phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across galaxy satellites, indirect detection, laboratory precision; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 10.0, observational 2.0, complementarity 8.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 2.7, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_16958_bare_mass_inflaton_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_16958", "source_line": 5977, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2031, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from cold_dark_matter: Bare-mass inflaton cold dark matter from scalar-scattering reheating has moderate observational leverage through residual inflaton condensate after scalar-scattering reheating, annihilation freezeout of inflatons, transition from quartic-like to quadratic matter-like redshifting; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "annihilating_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_09235_leptophilic_annihilating_decaying_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_09235", "source_line": 3814, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2032, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory model with production listed as nonthermal freeze-in after low reheating, present-day annihilation and late decay are part of the phenomenological setup.", "Moderate observational leverage comes from the card's nonthermal phase-space entry, cosmological relevance, or explicit non-CDM structure-formation fields.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_09867_warm_dm_schwarzschild_pbh_evaporation_v1", "paper_id": "2012_09867", "source_line": 4525, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 2033, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from suppression of small-scale power, decay_produced phase space.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_19762_two_field_wave_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2310_19762", "source_line": 5845, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 89, "global_rank": 2034, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is not specified in the paper; halo-scale nonrelativistic field configuration is assumed.", "Follow-up value comes from small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (field_like, suppression) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_11584_audible_axion_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_11584", "source_line": 4537, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 158, "global_rank": 2035, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, field_like phase space.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2310_11034_galileon_negative_ng_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_11034", "source_line": 5871, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 116, "global_rank": 2036, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because it has PBH/SIGW observational motivation and useful non-Gaussian production structure, but the card is phenomenological, PBH-abundance sensitive, and lacks explicit constraints, routing, or code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_02149_black_hole_axion_star_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_02149", "source_line": 5877, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 159, "global_rank": 2037, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because black-hole-assisted axion-star condensation is distinctive for compact-object environments, but the cosmological relic calculation is assumed rather than supplied and observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3340_radiative_seesaw_n1_warm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3340", "source_line": 876, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 107, "global_rank": 2038, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, suppression in small-scale power, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_11514_self_destructing_atomic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2001_11514", "source_line": 4178, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2039, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of self_interacting_atomic_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space information.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity credit reflects a comparatively distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or dominant probe class in the population context.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_reheating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_02348_gravitational_reheating_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_02348", "source_line": 5019, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2040, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Gravitational reheating fermion dark matter has some cosmological or structure-formation leverage; probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_reheating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_02348_gravitational_reheating_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_02348", "source_line": 5020, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2041, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Gravitational reheating scalar dark matter has some cosmological or structure-formation leverage; probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_reheating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_02348_gravitational_reheating_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_02348", "source_line": 5021, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2042, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Gravitational reheating vector dark matter has some cosmological or structure-formation leverage; probe classes: BBN, CMB, small-scale structure; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_14794_gravitational_vector_reheating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_14794", "source_line": 5883, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2043, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because gravitational vector reheating has a clear analytic production story and rare gravitational-freeze-in family value, but observable complementarity is narrow and stability/completion assumptions remain open."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_08626_cpt_symmetric_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2103_08626", "source_line": 4639, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 108, "global_rank": 2044, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative sterile neutrino dark matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; some cosmological or phase-space leverage; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, indirect detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_03063_bare_chi_dark_higgs_zprime_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1610_03063", "source_line": 2887, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2045, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production.", "Score limited by penalties from sparse observables, constraints, and routing; associated code is marked partial."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_06172_light_scalar_mediated_sidm_grb_v1", "paper_id": "2308_06172", "source_line": 5722, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 2046, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Light-scalar-mediated self-interacting dark matter for GRB221009A is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 9.0, observational 4.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 0.5, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "0804_3470_chaotic_new_inflation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0804_3470", "source_line": 867, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 117, "global_rank": 2047, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_03083_z6r_pure_gravity_wino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_03083", "source_line": 5012, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2048, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Z6R pure-gravity-mediation wino dark matter model has some cosmological or structure-formation leverage; probe classes: BBN, CMB, gravitational waves, laboratory/particle, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_13717_superheavy_susy_kind_r2_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2401_13717", "source_line": 5946, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2049, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Superheavy SUSY-kind dark matter in R^2 cosmology is a speculative superheavy_dark_matter card with unknown phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and CMB, compact objects, indirect detection from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 9, observational leverage 4, complementarity 8, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 5.5, penalties 18; raw score 17.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_07515_extended_ma_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2001_07515", "source_line": 4148, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2050, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 17.5: speculative scotogenic_fermion_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_02424_gut_inspired_zprime_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1609_02424", "source_line": 2873, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2051, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative zprime_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; medium CMB relevance; 2 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_majorana_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_06815_idm_majorana_neutrino_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "1706_06815", "source_line": 3157, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2052, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 17.5: Inert-doublet right-handed Majorana-neutrino SuperWIMP dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with freeze-in production from charged-scalar decays while the NLOP is thermal.", "Rank-relevant positives are high BBN relevance, decay produced phase-space treatment, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, collider.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0618_asymmetric_light_mediator_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0618", "source_line": 1900, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 2053, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a benchmark simplified-model model with asymmetric/baryogenesis, self-interacting production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, nonlinear structure-formation effects.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching BBN, direct detection, galaxy satellites / small-scale structure, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_09842_z3_scalar_singlet_inflation_pseudoscalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_09842", "source_line": 5838, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2054, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is freeze-in from inflaton decay hprime -> A A.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (unknown, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_1866_positive_deflected_amsb_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_1866", "source_line": 1696, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 2055, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out of the lightest neutralino; Higgsino-like annihilation to W bosons, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 17.5 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; associated code support is marked partial; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_04276_scotogenic_majorana_fermion_spontaneous_lepton_number_v1", "paper_id": "1908_04276", "source_line": 3914, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2056, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_fermion_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0412264_mssm_ewbg_neutralino_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0412264", "source_line": 515, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 2057, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because MSSM electroweak-baryogenesis neutralino dark matter with light-stop coannihilation is a speculative uv complete card with either relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_3279_kev_vector_u1_bosonic_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "0807_3279", "source_line": 879, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 133, "global_rank": 2058, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_2644_axionic_mirage_mediation_axino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0809_2644", "source_line": 880, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2059, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, decay produced phase-space behavior. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_b_l_dark_matter", "model_id": "0812_2196_supersymmetric_b_l_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0812_2196", "source_line": 898, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2060, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, full dark-matter abundance capability, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_03878_scalar_pseudoscalar_mixed_qq_aa_v1", "paper_id": "1711_03878", "source_line": 3313, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2061, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_03878_scalar_pseudoscalar_on_shell_aa_v1", "paper_id": "1711_03878", "source_line": 3314, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2062, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_03878_scalar_pseudoscalar_qq_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1711_03878", "source_line": 3312, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2063, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_boson_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_10647_light_mediator_pngb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2108_10647", "source_line": 4837, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2064, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2309_16246_affleck_dine_lognormal_pbh_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2309_16246", "source_line": 5809, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 118, "global_rank": 2065, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is collapse of high-baryon-density isocurvature domains during the QCD phase transition.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, compact objects, gravitational waves/defects, with phase-space/structure entries (not_applicable, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2310_06901_baby_pbh_from_catalyzed_phase_transition_v1", "paper_id": "2310_06901", "source_line": 5842, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 119, "global_rank": 2066, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is PBH-catalyzed vacuum nucleation creates true-vacuum bubbles only around parent PBHs.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, compact objects, gravitational waves/defects, with phase-space/structure entries (not_applicable, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_0009_scalar_triplet_asymmetric_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1206_0009", "source_line": 1608, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 2067, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete card for Scalar triplet darko-lepto-genesis with inert fermion doublet dark matter; it offers decay produced phase-space behavior with Lyman-alpha forest, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_11889_z4_two_component_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_11889", "source_line": 4772, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 90, "global_rank": 2068, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out with coupled Boltzmann equations; semi-annihilation.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_11889_z6_23_unconditional_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_11889", "source_line": 4774, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 91, "global_rank": 2069, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out with coupled Boltzmann equations; semi-annihilation.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_baryon_lepton_majorana_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_13397_local_b_l_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2103_13397", "source_line": 4625, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2070, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative gauged baryon lepton majorana dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked unknown; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dipole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_1988_luminous_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1988", "source_line": 1196, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2071, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 17.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, distinctive or underrepresented model-space coverage, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_mixed_wino_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03223_wino_higgsino_sugra_partial_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03223", "source_line": 4614, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2072, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative neutralino mixed wino higgsino dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked no; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_lepton_number_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_10324_u1l_z3d_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_10324", "source_line": 4618, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2073, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative gauged lepton number scalar dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "b_minus_l_majorana_wimp", "model_id": "1710_05775_bl_majorana_dual_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_05775", "source_line": 3275, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2074, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative b minus l majorana wimp candidate with uv complete theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 17.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_03266_minimal_gauge_mediation_gravitino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_03266", "source_line": 4543, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2075, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 66.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 8.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from high BBN relevance, suppression of small-scale power.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_13134_metric_affine_gravity_fermion_dm_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2306_13134", "source_line": 5703, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2076, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 12.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Metric-affine gravitational portal to singlet-fermion dark matter is a speculative effective_field_theory card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and nonthermal phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 7.0, observational 3.0, complementarity 5.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 4.2, penalties 12.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_07961_bec_scalar_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1611_07961", "source_line": 2947, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 2077, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it can supply the full dark-matter abundance in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance high, BBN relevance high, phase-space type field_like, and structure fields with small-scale effect suppression and transfer shape smooth_cutoff.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_04203_light_zprime_ultralight_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_04203", "source_line": 3699, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 2078, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 12.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes; high CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; field_like phase-space behavior; suppression small-scale-power effect.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_neutrino_superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0701007_right_handed_kk_neutrino_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0701007", "source_line": 694, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2079, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: strong cosmology/structure leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_4039_self_interacting_scalar_field_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1101_4039", "source_line": 39, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 2080, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space description, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1802_06785_pbh_running_indices_rd_ligo_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "1802_06785", "source_line": 3404, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 120, "global_rank": 2081, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level phenomenological_parameterization; relic status no; CMB/BBN relevance medium/low; structure entry unknown/cdm_like; phase-space type not_applicable; portals gravitational.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: subcomponent_only."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_03284_alp_miracle_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1702_03284", "source_line": 3101, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 160, "global_rank": 2082, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of axion_like_dark_matter with raw score 17.0.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation fields, distinct phase-space production.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0102419_scalar_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0102419", "source_line": 30, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 2083, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space description, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_luminous_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_12461_luminous_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_12461", "source_line": 4272, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2084, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative inelastic_luminous_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via cosmological cold dark matter population assumed; detector signal arises from inelastic upscattering followed by excited-state decay, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_04824_geometric_baryogenesis_qcd_axion_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_04824", "source_line": 2980, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 161, "global_rank": 2085, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_8191_scalar_graviton_systolon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1401_8191", "source_line": 1988, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2086, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_5902_alp_misalignment_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_5902", "source_line": 1537, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 162, "global_rank": 2087, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, and field like phase-space treatment.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_12306_pbh_assisted_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_12306", "source_line": 4535, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 2088, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, suppression of small-scale power, mixed_cold_warm phase space.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2110_14379_evaporating_pbh_cosmological_spacetime_v1", "paper_id": "2110_14379", "source_line": 4914, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 121, "global_rank": 2089, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Evaporating primordial black holes in cosmological space-time is speculative with phenomenological_parameterization theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by not_applicable phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_06655_resonantly_produced_7kev_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1507_06655", "source_line": 2558, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 109, "global_rank": 2090, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory level; score-relevant card features include resonant phase space, suppression small-scale power.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dissipative_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_02422_dissipative_dark_matter_halo_v1", "paper_id": "1611_02422", "source_line": 2994, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2091, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative dissipative_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_07946_self_interacting_ultralight_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1709_07946", "source_line": 3223, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 2092, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Self-interacting ultra-light axion dark matter is a speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior with suppression small-scale effect, CMB/BBN relevance medium/unknown, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1906_08217_thermal_history_multimodal_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_08217", "source_line": 3849, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 122, "global_rank": 2093, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with production listed as primordial black hole formation enhanced by equation-of-state drops during thermal history.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_01977_diluted_equilibrium_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_01977", "source_line": 2580, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 110, "global_rank": 2094, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory level; score-relevant card features include nonthermal phase space, suppression small-scale power, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hot_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0507544_thermal_fermionic_hot_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0507544", "source_line": 588, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2095, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Thermally produced fermionic hot dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card in family hot_dark_matter with production described as relativistic thermal decoupling.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; suppression of small-scale power; smooth cutoff transfer behavior; probe classes: CMB, halo/subhalo structure, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "collider_simplified_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_13578_mono_wprime_dark_higgs_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_13578", "source_line": 5864, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2096, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the collider mono-Wprime/dark-Higgs setup has near-term collider feasibility, but the dark matter identity and relic-density model are largely unspecified and the card lacks cosmological observables or constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_4676_single_operator_wimp_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1305_4676", "source_line": 1856, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2097, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a benchmark effective-field-theory model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from suppression in small-scale power, nonlinear structure-formation effects.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching galaxy satellites / small-scale structure, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_13492_leptophilic_scalar_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2111_13492", "source_line": 4949, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2098, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Leptophilic scalar dark matter effective field theory is speculative with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1908_10930_scalar_fragmentation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10930", "source_line": 3968, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 123, "global_rank": 2099, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Primordial black holes from scalar-field fragmentation: moderate observational leverage, high diversity value; inferred probe classes are compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Score 17 (defer) uses production=inflationary scalar displacement; fragmentation into unstable Q-balls or oscillons; phase=nonthermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_08456_warped_dark_dimension_kk_graviton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_08456", "source_line": 5915, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2100, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Warped Dark Dimension Kaluza-Klein dark-graviton dark matter is a speculative extra_dimensional_dark_matter card with decay_produced phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and CMB from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 10, observational leverage 8, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 4.0, penalties 16; raw score 17.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_09138_zn_axion_alp_double_level_crossing_v1", "paper_id": "2401_09138", "source_line": 5962, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 163, "global_rank": 2101, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from axion_like_dark_matter: Z_N axion and ALP double-level-crossing domain-wall model has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through nonthermal axion misalignment, trapped+kinetic misalignment for the Z_N axion, double level crossing with domain-wall formation; inferred probe classes are gravitational_waves.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_00319_asymptotically_safe_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_00319", "source_line": 3422, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2102, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; phase-space type field_like; portals higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: toy_model_scope, nonthermal_abundance_uncertain."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "solitonic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10930_swgc_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10930", "source_line": 3967, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2103, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Scalar weak-gravity Q-ball dark matter: moderate observational leverage, high diversity value; inferred probe classes are compact objects / dynamics.", "Score 17 (defer) uses production=inflationary displacement of a spectator scalar; post-inflation relaxation; phase=nonthermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_07030_viscous_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1708_07030", "source_line": 3234, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2104, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Viscous cold dark matter model is a speculative cold_dark_matter card with scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior with suppression small-scale effect, CMB/BBN relevance high/unknown, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2007_09957_higgs_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_09957", "source_line": 291, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 124, "global_rank": 2105, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Higgs-inflation primordial black-hole dark matter, a speculative primordial black holes entry with effective field theory theory support and high CMB relevance, enhancement of small-scale power, enhanced small scale power transfer behavior, nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: benchmark_dependence, pbh_constraints_not_encoded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_1077_asymmetric_atomic_dark_matter_massive_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1403_1077", "source_line": 2071, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 2106, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of asymmetric_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; non-CDM small-scale structure information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_00009_higgs_portal_bminusl_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_00009", "source_line": 3388, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 2107, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_12869_two_real_singlet_scalar_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2207_12869", "source_line": 5294, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2108, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Two real singlet scalar Higgs-portal dark matter model: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out through scalar portal annihilation, thermal phase space, phase-transition history, CMB/BBN relevance.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_04827_strongly_interacting_dm_lmbh_v1", "paper_id": "2404_04827", "source_line": 6015, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2109, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because strongly interacting dark matter induced low-mass-gap black holes are observationally distinctive, but the card leaves the particle identity and cosmological production largely unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_05515_dark_qcd_flavored_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_05515", "source_line": 4901, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 2110, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Flavored dark-QCD asymmetric dark matter is speculative with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_10343_anomaly_free_hadrophilic_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_10343", "source_line": 4927, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 134, "global_rank": 2111, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: anomaly-free hadrophilic U(1) vector complex-scalar dark matter is benchmark with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_00323_majorana_tchannel_freezein_v1", "paper_id": "2309_00323", "source_line": 5794, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 120, "global_rank": 2112, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Majorana t-channel mediator freeze-in dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, some observationally distinctive cosmology or portal structure; card-internal probe cues include BBN, gravitational waves.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_03621_sqcd_inflation_pngb_multi_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_03621", "source_line": 3445, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 92, "global_rank": 2113, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance low/unknown; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: variant_dependence, direct_detection_not_encoded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_11645_susy_dfsz_base_b_i_mixed_axion_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2303_11645", "source_line": 5554, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 93, "global_rank": 2114, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the mixed axion/Higgsino DFSZ model can make full dark matter and has useful validity notes, but this base-model card is near-duplicate, domain-wall-history dependent, and missing observational-detail fields.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_11645_susy_dfsz_base_b_ii_mixed_axion_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2303_11645", "source_line": 5555, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 94, "global_rank": 2115, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the mixed axion/Higgsino DFSZ model can make full dark matter, but this base-model variant is near-duplicate and its observational extension is limited by empty observables, constraints, routes, and code fields.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_11645_susy_dfsz_base_b_iii_mixed_axion_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2303_11645", "source_line": 5556, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 95, "global_rank": 2116, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the card preserves a viable mixed axion/neutralino setup, yet the base-model duplication and domain-wall-history caveat dominate the sparse observational-detail support.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_03862_nonminimal_longitudinal_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_03862", "source_line": 5829, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2117, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is nonthermal inflationary gravitational production of longitudinal vector quantum fluctuations.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, with phase-space/structure entries (nonthermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_2823_singlet_scalar_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0711_2823", "source_line": 778, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 111, "global_rank": 2118, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 17.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance low, small-scale power suppression, transfer function smooth_cutoff, phase-space type decay_produced; probe classes counted: ['small-scale structure'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_5053_sterile_neutrino_dm_leptogenesis_dilution_v1", "paper_id": "1403_5053", "source_line": 2119, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 112, "global_rank": 2119, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: small-scale-power effect is suppression; transfer-function shape is smooth_cutoff; phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_09317_u1_bminusl_extended_numsm_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1606_09317", "source_line": 2854, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 113, "global_rank": 2120, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space population; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mass_varying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_07884_mass_varying_scalar_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_07884", "source_line": 5403, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Interesting small-scale behavior is present, but the card does not provide observable routing or likelihood support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2121, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked above many model-only cards because the mass-varying scalar-fermion scenario has mixed cold/warm phase space and suppressed scale-dependent growth, but it lacks routes, constraints, observables, and code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "2211_07139_noncanonical_domain_wall_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2211_07139", "source_line": 284, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2122, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Noncanonical domain-wall unified dark matter-dark energy model, a speculative topological defect unified dark sector entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, scale dependent growth transfer behavior.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: not_particle_dm, nonclustering_matter."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_08702_chameleonic_scalaron_fr_gravity_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_08702", "source_line": 3213, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2123, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Chameleonic scalaron dark matter in F(R) gravity is a speculative modified_gravity_scalar_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior with unknown small-scale effect, CMB/BBN relevance unknown/medium, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "evanescent_dark_sector_matter", "model_id": "1204_0485_evanescent_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1204_0485", "source_line": 256, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2124, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Evanescent matter, a speculative evanescent dark sector matter entry with simplified model theory support and medium CMB relevance, enhancement of small-scale power, enhanced small scale power transfer behavior, nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: evanescent_not_all_dm."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kinetic_mixing_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_09814_nonabelian_kinetic_mixing_dark_photon_portal_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2206_09814", "source_line": 5258, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2125, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Non-abelian kinetic-mixing dark-photon portal matter model: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out through dark-photon kinetic mixing, thermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for kinetic_mixing_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_03397_lmu_ltau_dirac_dm_kinetic_mixing_v1", "paper_id": "2209_03397", "source_line": 5270, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 135, "global_rank": 2126, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for L_mu - L_tau Dirac dark matter with general kinetic mixing: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out, thermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection), family/diversity context for hidden_sector_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "black_hole_remnant_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_01301_planck_remnant_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_01301", "source_line": 3853, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2127, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: A variant in which each evaporating primordial black hole leaves a stable Planck-mass remnant whose abundance can be the dark matter.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN high; CMB low; phase-space nonthermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: remnant_existence_assumed."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_03271_xsm_fermionic_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_03271", "source_line": 3858, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2128, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A singlet-scalar extension of the Standard Model in which a fermionic dark matter particle couples through the new scalar, giving Higgs-portal invisible Higgs and di-Higgs signatures.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: mixed relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space unknown; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_00027_uv_freeze_in_time_dependent_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "2305_00027", "source_line": 5612, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 121, "global_rank": 2129, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because UV freeze-in during reheating with high CMB/BBN relevance but unknown particle content and sparse implementation detail.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrinophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_01259_neutrinophilic_model_ia_scalar_z2_v1", "paper_id": "1901_01259", "source_line": 3755, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2130, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 17 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out through S-wave annihilation to SM neutrinos via ..., thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: BBN, CMB; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrinophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_01259_neutrinophilic_model_ib_dirac_z2_v1", "paper_id": "1901_01259", "source_line": 3756, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2131, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 17 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out through P-wave annihilation to SM neutrinos via ..., thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: BBN, CMB; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_11407_radiative_kinetic_mixing_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1905_11407", "source_line": 3871, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 122, "global_rank": 2132, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A fermionic dark matter model where a massive dark U(1) vector communicates with hypercharge through loop-generated, momentum- and temperature-dependent kinetic mixing from heavy vector-like hybrid fermions.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space nonthermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: tree_contact_mixing_changes_model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2005_hidden_stueckelberg_millicharged_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2005", "source_line": 736, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2133, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_1366_supersymmetric_minimal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1203_1366", "source_line": 1507, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2134, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and minimal dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_16376_u2_23_doublet_anomaly_free_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_16376", "source_line": 5097, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 164, "global_rank": 2135, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 17 (defer) as a speculative effective_field_theory member of axion_like_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: collider/accelerator, axion/laboratory.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, tension/anomaly, axion/strong-cp.", "Production summary used: not specified; abundance fraction imposed phenomenologically for Xenon1T interpretation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1912_01061_non_attractor_inflation_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "1912_01061", "source_line": 4097, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 17.0 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 125, "global_rank": 2136, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 65.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative primordial_black_holes with phenomenological_parameterization structure and relic reach 'unknown'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'not_applicable', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: compact objects/microlensing.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_01776_dark_photon_bound_state_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_01776", "source_line": 2795, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 136, "global_rank": 2137, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out; annihilation to dark photons; portals: vector; CMB relevance is medium.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1911_04520_density_power_dm_de_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "1911_04520", "source_line": 220, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2138, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative interacting_dark_matter_dark_energy entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=scale_dependent_growth, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB, indirect detection, structure formation.", "Feasibility receives limited credit for associated_code=partial; shard-level ranks are left null for the parent aggregator."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_09683_modified_press_schechter_extended_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_09683", "source_line": 211, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2139, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_hole_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=enhancement, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_13358_starobinsky_dark_glueball_v1", "paper_id": "2105_13358", "source_line": 4743, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 77, "global_rank": 2140, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via scalaron decay to dark gluons; dark confinement.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN, CMB, structure formation; the raw score is 17 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_12608_melting_domain_wall_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_12608", "source_line": 5011, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 2141, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Melting dark domain-wall scalar dark matter has some cosmological or structure-formation leverage; probe classes: BBN, CMB, gravitational waves; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_16570_axion_witten_schwinger_dissipation_v1", "paper_id": "2309_16570", "source_line": 5798, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 165, "global_rank": 2142, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Axion-like dark matter with Schwinger-Witten monopole dissipation has moderate scientific motivation, some diversity value relative to the population; card-internal probe cues include axion/laboratory searches, gravitational waves.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2589_modified_exponent_two_scalar_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2589", "source_line": 1557, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2143, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-low priority because it keeps the distinctive two-scalar dark-sector cosmology and field-like phase space, with somewhat less severe warnings than the late-oscillation branch, but still lacks explicit observational routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavoured_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_09274_flavoured_majorana_dmfv_conversion_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2312_09274", "source_line": 5916, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2144, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Flavoured Majorana dark matter in Dark Minimal Flavour Violation with conversion-driven freeze-out is a speculative flavoured_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and CMB, collider from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 9, observational leverage 5, complementarity 5, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 5.0, penalties 16; raw score 17.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_3166_biased_domain_wall_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1207_3166", "source_line": 1593, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 166, "global_rank": 2145, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but useful for diversity because the card has nonthermal biased-domain-wall axion production, approximate spectrum information, and CMB/BBN relevance, limited by simulation-scaling warnings and missing routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pbh_evaporation_nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_10511_pbh_evaporation_nonthermal_wimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1711_10511", "source_line": 3276, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2146, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative pbh evaporation nonthermal dark matter candidate with phenomenological parameterization theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, critical BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space structure.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 17.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "chaplygin_gas_quartessence", "model_id": "astro-ph0207423_chaplygin_gas_quartessence_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0207423", "source_line": 7, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2147, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_00052_pbh_evaporation_superheavy_gravitational_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_00052", "source_line": 5416, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Useful cosmological hooks are present, but missing constraints, observables, and routing keep follow-up below tier 3."], "family_rank": 137, "global_rank": 2148, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Moderate within the deferred group: PBH evaporation of superheavy gravitational dark matter has BBN and nonthermal phase-space hooks, but no code or explicit observable routing is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_5338_linde_axion_large_pq_field_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1305_5338", "source_line": 1838, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 2149, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative qcd_axion_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is field_like; CMB relevance is high.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on CMB and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_1104_nmfv_gmsb_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0808_1104", "source_line": 887, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 2150, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, mixed cold warm phase-space behavior. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptoquark_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_06768_leptoquark_portal_triplet_vectorlike_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_06768", "source_line": 5257, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because supplied model-only fields give low current observational-extension readiness."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2151, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied fields for Leptoquark-portal SU(2)L-triplet vector-like fermion dark matter: speculative status, simplified-model theory level, and production via thermal freeze-out; electroweak annihilation, thermal phase space.", "Observational value comes from inferred probe classes (BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection), family/diversity context for leptoquark_portal_dark_matter, and auditable provenance/validity fields.", "Penalized because this assigned card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation; no strict global elimination statement was present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1102_2340_running_mass_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1102_2340", "source_line": 1306, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 126, "global_rank": 2152, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance high, BBN relevance high.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_00941_radiative_seesaw_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_00941", "source_line": 3414, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2153, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; phase-space type thermal; portals vector, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: garbled_gauge_label, dampe_specific."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_09957_gauged_b_minus_2l_radiative_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_09957", "source_line": 3543, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2154, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a simplified-model implementation; it touches collider / fixed-target, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_4667_decaying_gravitino_leptogenesis_rpv_v1", "paper_id": "0809_4667", "source_line": 831, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 2155, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is high/high. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_4197_gauge_mediated_affleck_dine_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0907_4197", "source_line": 1001, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2156, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 17 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, registry diversity value, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family q_ball_dark_matter, theory level uv_complete, and nonthermal phase-space history, probe handles: BBN, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wino_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9906527_nonthermal_wino_cdm_amsb_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9906527", "source_line": 6108, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2157, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 17 (defer) from supplied card content: nonthermal_wino_cold_dark_matter with simplified_model theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior; cosmological relevance: BBN critical.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_03076_ma_xion_radiative_seesaw_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_03076", "source_line": 3258, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 167, "global_rank": 2158, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion like dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from high CMB relevance, field like phase-space structure.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 17.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_10766_coinciding_resonance_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_10766", "source_line": 4202, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 114, "global_rank": 2159, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, neutrino-sector connection; resonant phase-space information; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: BBN.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_03866_inert_complex_singlet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2111_03866", "source_line": 4930, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2160, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Z2-odd inert complex singlet scalar dark matter is benchmark with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: gravitational waves.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_00391_gravitational_fermionic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_00391", "source_line": 4225, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2161, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include early-universe production connection; nonthermal phase-space information; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_00090_two_axion_level_crossing_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_00090", "source_line": 6067, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 168, "global_rank": 2162, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 17.0: speculative uv complete model in axion_like_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as yes.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: CMB; phase space is field like.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_2835_warped_throat_curvaton_hidden_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0905_2835", "source_line": 969, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 138, "global_rank": 2163, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance; field_like phase-space history; probe classes: CMB.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_10548_minimal_so10_pq_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_10548", "source_line": 3729, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 2164, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Minimal non-supersymmetric SO(10) U(1)_PQ axion dark matter is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, field like phase-space behavior, probe relevance for CMB, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_13280_preheating_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_13280", "source_line": 4865, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 123, "global_rank": 2165, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from phenomenological_parameterization theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; nonthermal phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_moduli_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_05971_anthropic_modulus_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_05971", "source_line": 4885, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2166, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from phenomenological_parameterization theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space production; rare family in population context (count 1).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_05769_milli_magnetic_monopole_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2105_05769", "source_line": 4756, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 139, "global_rank": 2167, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: model-dependent early-universe dark monopole production; survival as local dark matter fraction.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space distribution.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2007_13776_uv_protected_natural_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_13776", "source_line": 4370, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 127, "global_rank": 2168, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as UV-protected Natural Inflation primordial black hole dark matter: inflationary enhancement of small-scale scalar perturbations; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamics and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_5878_fermionic_adm_light_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1306_5878", "source_line": 1881, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 2169, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 17.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with asymmetric/baryogenesis production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching BBN, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3.5 while penalties total 17.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_04840_gauged_b_l_scotoseesaw_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_04840", "source_line": 5765, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2170, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Gauged B-L scoto-seesaw scalar dark matter has moderate scientific motivation; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0509221_natural_mssm_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509221", "source_line": 543, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2171, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Light neutral Higgsino dark matter in natural MSSM is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (decay produced; small-scale effect none); it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_08608_heavy_light_asymmetric_dark_meson_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_08608", "source_line": 4357, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 2172, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Heavy-light dark meson asymmetric resonant self-interacting dark matter: asymmetric production of heavy dark quarks, with the final dark matter abundance set by n_c and n_b asymmetries; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, indirect/transient, laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_02078_radiative_linear_seesaw_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_02078", "source_line": 3098, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2173, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_inert_scalar_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_6582_u1prime_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_6582", "source_line": 1906, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2174, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 17.0 because the model card is a speculative right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_00990_affleck_dine_q_ball_pbh_cogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1711_00990", "source_line": 3289, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2175, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative q ball dark matter candidate with phenomenological parameterization theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space structure.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, gravitational waves.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 17.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_07822_ksvz_dfsz_early_strong_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_07822", "source_line": 5434, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables, constraints, routes, or code are present in the card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2176, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["One of the stronger deferred cards: UV-complete early-strong-QCD axion dark matter has strong-CP motivation and nonthermal CMB relevance, but lacks supplied observational routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_t_channel_scalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_01366_t_channel_scalar_mediator_dirac_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1603_01366", "source_line": 2769, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2177, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: benchmark simplified_model in simplified_t_channel_scalar_mediator_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through dark matter self-annihilation; portals: other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_axion_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_03713_z24r_gspq_dfsz_axion_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_03713", "source_line": 3590, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2178, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_axion_higgsino_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it can supply all dark matter according to the production block, has field-like phase-space behavior.", "It receives diversity credit for occupying a relatively sparse or phenomenologically distinctive region of the model-card population.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_axion_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_03713_z24r_hybrid_spm_dfsz_axion_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_03713", "source_line": 3591, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2179, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_axion_higgsino_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it can supply all dark matter according to the production block, has field-like phase-space behavior.", "It receives diversity credit for occupying a relatively sparse or phenomenologically distinctive region of the model-card population.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_06108_singlet_doublet_triplet_radiative_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_06108", "source_line": 3844, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2180, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as thermal freeze-out.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_2246_z3_semi_annihilating_boosted_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_2246", "source_line": 2300, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 78, "global_rank": 2181, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and mixed_cold_warm phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, registry-diversity value; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_3930_ewsusy_gmsugra_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_3930", "source_line": 2237, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 2182, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_5441_gauged_axi_higgs_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1005_5441", "source_line": 1171, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 169, "global_rank": 2183, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 17 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_16219_forbidden_conformal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_16219", "source_line": 5835, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2184, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is thermal forbidden freeze-out through DM DM -> dilaton dilaton.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, gravitational waves/defects, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2005_02895_two_field_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_02895", "source_line": 365, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 128, "global_rank": 2185, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via gravitational collapse of large overdensities from a two-field inflation power-spectrum peak; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance medium; probe hooks: BBN, CMB, compact objects/microlensing/dynamics, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2205_13540_single_field_two_parabola_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_13540", "source_line": 5163, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 129, "global_rank": 2186, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: simplified PBH inflation model has CMB/PBH complementarity and analytic control, but abundance sensitivity and missing structured observables are large penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2205_08906_hierarchical_pbh_dwarf_galaxy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_08906", "source_line": 5175, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 130, "global_rank": 2187, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: PBH dwarf-core merger hierarchy is distinctive and tied to compact-object/dynamical probes, but dense-core assumptions and missing constraint/routing fields limit priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_5353_singlet_scalar_dm_higgs_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "0909_5353", "source_line": 978, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2188, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_singlet_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_06619_majoron_portal_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_06619", "source_line": 3648, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 79, "global_rank": 2189, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative self_interacting_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance.", "The card has an audit trail and assumptions, but still lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_08597_symmetric_scalar_acdm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_08597", "source_line": 5188, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2190, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: rare asymmetric composite dark-baryon scenario has full-DM asymmetry logic, but no structured phase-space, observables, or constraints are supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9909509_affleck_dine_qball_bball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9909509", "source_line": 6111, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2191, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 17 (defer) from supplied card content: macroscopic_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9808276_superball_baryonic_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9808276", "source_line": 6127, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2192, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 17 (defer) from supplied card content: macroscopic_composite_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and yes all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_11398_right_handed_neutrino_b_l_2hdm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_11398", "source_line": 4870, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2193, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from uv_complete theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium BBN relevance.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_misalignment_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_03410_gravitational_misalignment_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2004_03410", "source_line": 4230, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2194, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include early-universe production connection, structure or tension connection; field_like phase-space information; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_baryonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_04240_neutron_mixing_baryonic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2005_04240", "source_line": 4209, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2195, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, larger-framework connection; nonthermal phase-space information; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5902_vector_wimp_miracle_nonlinear_sigma_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5902", "source_line": 1492, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2196, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable vector_wimp_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out of vector WIMP annihilating mainly to W and Z boson pairs.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_08508_quartification_kinetic_mixing_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_08508", "source_line": 5745, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 140, "global_rank": 2197, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 64.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Quartification kinetic-mixing portal dark matter is a speculative uv_complete card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 10.0, observational 1.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 1.0, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_19962_type_ii_2hdms_pseudoscalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_19962", "source_line": 5848, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2198, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is annihilation-controlled relic abundance through scalar-mediated channels.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (unknown, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_06802_nmssmr_right_handed_sneutrino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "2109_06802", "source_line": 4830, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 2199, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_8120_complex_scalar_effective_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1307_8120", "source_line": 1845, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2200, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative effective_wimp_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on collider, direct detection, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_8120_dirac_fermion_effective_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1307_8120", "source_line": 1847, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2201, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative effective_wimp_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on collider, direct detection, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_8120_majorana_fermion_effective_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1307_8120", "source_line": 1846, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2202, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative effective_wimp_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on collider, direct detection, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_8120_real_scalar_effective_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1307_8120", "source_line": 1844, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2203, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative effective_wimp_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on collider, direct detection, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_4479_lr_cp_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1008_4479", "source_line": 1174, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2204, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 17 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_06000_pseudoscalar_portal_2hdm_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1502_06000", "source_line": 2389, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2205, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal freeze-out through pseudoscalar-mediated annihilation, resonant annihilation near pseudoscalar pole production.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (11 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: resonant annihilation near pseudoscalar pole."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0407239_generalized_chaplygin_gas_decomposition_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0407239", "source_line": 544, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2206, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Interacting generalized Chaplygin gas dark matter decomposition is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches, weak lensing / large-scale structure; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0908_0915_intersecting_d6_brane_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0908_0915", "source_line": 988, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 2207, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_3318_z2_z2prime_three_component_radiative_seesaw_v1", "paper_id": "1207_3318", "source_line": 1584, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 96, "global_rank": 2208, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but useful for diversity because the card gives a UV three-component radiative-seesaw model with coupled conversion and semi-annihilation, offset by symbol-loss and missing routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_z3_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_11823_gauged_z3_scalar_dm_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "2003_11823", "source_line": 4246, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2209, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include early-universe production connection, structure or tension connection; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "conversion_driven_freeze_out_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_12428_leptophilic_conversion_driven_leptogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2404_12428", "source_line": 6075, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2210, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 17.0: speculative simplified model model in conversion_driven_freeze_out_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as yes.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: collider/fixed-target; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is partial and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_09740_secluded_supersymmetric_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2106_09740", "source_line": 4714, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2211, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative secluded_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via thermal freeze-out within the secluded sector; s-wave annihilation into lighter secluded-sector particles.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN; the raw score is 17 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card.", "Diversity credit is elevated because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive family or production regime in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "b_l_complex_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_06566_complex_scalar_b_l_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_06566", "source_line": 2803, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2212, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked yes.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavoured_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_10357_flavoured_majorana_dmfv_v1", "paper_id": "2109_10357", "source_line": 4862, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2213, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; rare family in population context (count 5).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_coupled_dark_sector", "model_id": "2211_00025_decaying_strongly_coupled_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2211_00025", "source_line": 5334, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2214, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 17.0: strongly_coupled_dark_sector with nonthermal production during reheating, gravitational production, or first-order phase transition; science=10.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection) and diversity=7.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_00332_gauged_baryon_lepton_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_00332", "source_line": 5706, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 141, "global_rank": 2215, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Gauged baryon and lepton number Majorana dark matter is a speculative uv_complete card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, gravitational waves, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 11.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 1.0, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_01773_multistep_scalar_cascade_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1503_01773", "source_line": 2427, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 142, "global_rank": 2216, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a hidden_sector_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_2999_three_loop_rh_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_2999", "source_line": 2255, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2217, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_triplet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_6394_radiative_seesaw_triplet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_6394", "source_line": 1487, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2218, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable radiative_seesaw_triplet_fermion_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_00038_umssm_heavy_rh_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1711_00038", "source_line": 3334, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 2219, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_00566_scale_invariant_hidden_qcd_pion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_00566", "source_line": 2448, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 143, "global_rank": 2220, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a hidden_sector_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_03285_minimal_sun_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1506_03285", "source_line": 2449, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 144, "global_rank": 2221, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a hidden_sector_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_5643_bl_sneutrino_sommerfeld_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0909_5643", "source_line": 960, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2222, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sneutrino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_03905_lepton_flavor_u1x_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_03905", "source_line": 5621, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2223, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because UV-complete scotogenic/flavor model with neutrino-mass motivation but little supplied observable leverage.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_14189_u1d_scotogenic_inert_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "2004_14189", "source_line": 4242, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 17, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2224, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, neutrino-sector connection, structure or tension connection; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 17, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_09755_resonant_axiverse_pair_v1", "paper_id": "2109_09755", "source_line": 4818, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.8, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 170, "global_rank": 2225, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by non-CDM structure information, field like phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1212_6770_cmb_equilibrated_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1212_6770", "source_line": 1680, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 131, "global_rank": 2226, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.8, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization entry; production is summarized as primordial black-hole population assumed; PBH number conservation n proportional to a^-3, with not_applicable phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 16.8 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=unknown and CMB=high; card-implied probe classes include CMB, compact objects, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_0235_dark_visible_parallel_universe_mulato_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_0235", "source_line": 1655, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 145, "global_rank": 2227, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.8, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as asymmetric reheating with colder dark sectors; mirror-baryon abundance set by dark-sector baryon asymmetry and sector multiplicity, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 16.8 reflects cosmological relevance is BBN=high and CMB=medium; card-implied probe classes include BBN, CMB; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_5065_inert_singlet_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_5065", "source_line": 1687, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2228, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.8, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal annihilation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 16.8 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1288_triplet_seesaw_asymmetric_fermion_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1288", "source_line": 1672, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 2229, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.8, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as asymmetric production from out-of-equilibrium scalar-triplet decays linked to leptogenesis, with unknown phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 16.8 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_2097_mpp_scalar_singlet_rh_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_2097", "source_line": 2234, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2230, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete scalar_singlet_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, neutrino/laboratory.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_bino_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_14438_high_scale_mssm_bino_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2308_14438", "source_line": 5730, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2231, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.7, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: High-scale MSSM bino dark matter from UV freeze-in is a speculative effective_field_theory card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and nonthermal phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 6.0, observational 2.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 4.7, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_14981_long_range_dark_nuggets_v1", "paper_id": "2306_14981", "source_line": 5709, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2232, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 5.7, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Long-range dark nuggets is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across compact objects/dynamics, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 8.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.7, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_hot_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_05987_nonthermal_sterile_hot_dm_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2009_05987", "source_line": 4415, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2233, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes nonthermal two-body decay of an early matter-dominating inflaton/modulus, matter-to-radiation transition with free-streaming sterile decay products.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, high CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space structure, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_02487_self_interacting_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_02487", "source_line": 4470, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 115, "global_rank": 2234, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Higher local observational leverage from cosmological or structure-formation fields in the supplied card for sterile_neutrino_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from nonthermal phase-space history, suppression small-scale-power effect, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 16.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hot_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0507544_thermal_bosonic_hot_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0507544", "source_line": 589, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2235, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Thermally produced bosonic hot dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card in family hot_dark_matter with production described as relativistic thermal decoupling.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; suppression of small-scale power; smooth cutoff transfer behavior; probe classes: CMB, halo/subhalo structure, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "generalized_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_13617_negative_eos_generalized_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_13617", "source_line": 58, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2236, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this generalized_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, suppression in small-scale power, scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_03049_high_scale_axion_explicit_pq_breaking_v1", "paper_id": "1601_03049", "source_line": 2733, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 171, "global_rank": 2237, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has parameter-dependent relic production, high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space history.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_13001_evaporating_pbh_boosted_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_13001", "source_line": 4792, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2238, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative boosted_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: present-day Hawking emission from evaporating primordial black holes.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space distribution.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1311_3090_modulated_hilltop_p4_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_3090", "source_line": 2001, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 132, "global_rank": 2239, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=not_applicable, and structure effect=enhancement/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, structure formation, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_0490_fd_term_right_handed_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0808_0490", "source_line": 821, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2240, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is high/high. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_4677_heavy_zprime_effective_complex_scalar_netdm_v1", "paper_id": "1306_4677", "source_line": 1891, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 124, "global_rank": 2241, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative effective-field-theory model with freeze-in production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_4677_heavy_zprime_effective_dirac_netdm_v1", "paper_id": "1306_4677", "source_line": 1890, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 125, "global_rank": 2242, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative effective-field-theory model with freeze-in production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_01946_sterile_neutrino_portal_majorana_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2203_01946", "source_line": 5045, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2243, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Sterile-neutrino-portal Majorana dark matter EFT has some cosmological or structure-formation leverage; probe classes: BBN, CMB, laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_06815_type_iii_seesaw_sterile_neutrino_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "1706_06815", "source_line": 3156, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2244, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 16.5: Type III seesaw sterile-neutrino SuperWIMP dark matter is a speculative effective field theory entry with freeze-in from thermal NLOP decays.", "Rank-relevant positives are high BBN relevance, decay produced phase-space treatment, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, collider.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0805_1133_rpv_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0805_1133", "source_line": 816, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2245, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked yes, CMB/BBN relevance is medium/high. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_11019_twin_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_11019", "source_line": 4601, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 2246, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative higgs portal dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_09164_portalino_neutrino_philic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_09164", "source_line": 3310, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2247, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, 4 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_02030_type_i_seesaw_fimp_rhn_v1", "paper_id": "2104_02030", "source_line": 4633, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2248, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative freeze in sterile neutrino dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include indirect detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimensions_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_7050_stable_vacuum_mued_lkp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1401_7050", "source_line": 2036, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2249, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as benchmark with theory_level=effective_field_theory, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=partial and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_03622_generalized_no_scale_fsu5_bino_bulk_v1", "paper_id": "2310_03622", "source_line": 5828, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 2250, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative uv_complete model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out through Bino annihilation in the right-handed slepton bulk region.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_0232_no_scale_supergut_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1009_0232", "source_line": 1170, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 2251, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0405097_nmsm_scalar_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0405097", "source_line": 549, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2252, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because New Minimal Standard Model scalar-singlet dark matter is a speculative uv complete card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_10764_two_higgs_doublet_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_10764", "source_line": 3311, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 2253, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 2 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_0580_light_mixed_sneutrino_thermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_0580", "source_line": 1175, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 2254, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_08945_two_singlet_scalar_vll_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_08945", "source_line": 4800, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 97, "global_rank": 2255, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out; assisted freeze-out through S1 S1 to S2 S2 dark matter conversions.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_11889_nonminimal_z6_13_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_11889", "source_line": 4775, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 98, "global_rank": 2256, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out with coupled Boltzmann equations; dark matter conversion.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_11889_z6_13_two_component_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_11889", "source_line": 4773, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 99, "global_rank": 2257, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and production logic from: thermal freeze-out with coupled Boltzmann equations; dark matter conversion.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_2024_minimal_gaugomaly_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_2024", "source_line": 1197, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 2258, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 63.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0502247_dirac_rh_neutrino_lzp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0502247", "source_line": 528, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2259, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Dirac right-handed-neutrino LZP dark matter is a speculative simplified model card with either relic-density treatment; it touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_effective_field_theory", "model_id": "1008_1783_complex_scalar_wimp_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1783", "source_line": 1165, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2260, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, high scientific motivation from its theory setting and relic mechanism."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1001_0051_lukewarm_ultralight_scalar_bec_v1", "paper_id": "1001_0051", "source_line": 183, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 2261, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 12.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 16.0 for fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter: positive factors include effective_field_theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic-density viability, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_4278_electroweak_sterile_neutrino_production_v1", "paper_id": "0902_4278", "source_line": 943, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 116, "global_rank": 2262, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, non-CDM linear-structure information, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_2751_cosmic_bose_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1110_2751", "source_line": 198, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2263, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 16.0 for bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter: positive factors include parameter-dependent relic-density viability, high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior, mixed_cold_warm transfer-function behavior, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_05707_axion_nonstandard_pre_bbn_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "1904_05707", "source_line": 3784, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 172, "global_rank": 2264, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 16 because the card identifies production via vacuum_realignment, axionic_string_decay, field_like phase-space treatment, probe classes: BBN; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_15488_bosonic_infrared_dressing_ultralight_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2110_15488", "source_line": 4908, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2265, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Bosonic infrared-dressing ultralight scalar dark matter is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by nonthermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_09042_xhe_ohe_composite_dark_atom_v1", "paper_id": "2111_09042", "source_line": 4907, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2266, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: XHe/OHe composite dark atom dark matter is speculative with phenomenological_parameterization theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by unknown phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_4720_string_axiverse_ultralight_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0905_4720", "source_line": 925, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 173, "global_rank": 2267, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has effective-theory structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, high cosmological relevance, non-CDM linear-structure information, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_04963_vector_contact_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_04963", "source_line": 4288, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 2268, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative inelastic_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via thermal freeze-out of XX' annihilation into lepton pairs in the EFT; late conversion scattering e X' -> e X maintains equal components until about MeV temperatures.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified; a high-severity model-card warning was retained as a penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_03310_axion_minicluster_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1707_03310", "source_line": 3218, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 174, "global_rank": 2269, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Axion minicluster dark matter is a speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior with enhancement small-scale effect, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_07415_wormhole_axion_ultralight_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1706_07415", "source_line": 3117, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 2270, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter with raw score 16.0.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from non-CDM structure-formation fields, distinct phase-space production.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 68.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_atom_dark_matter", "model_id": "0806_1067_ano_helium_fourth_generation_dark_atom_v1", "paper_id": "0806_1067", "source_line": 118, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2271, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative composite_dark_atom_dark_matter card with uv complete theory-level support and high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, mixed cold warm phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_cosmology_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_01056_kination_freeout_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_01056", "source_line": 3086, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2272, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative nonstandard_cosmology_dark_matter entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance critical, CMB relevance medium; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_14857_indy_inverse_decay_freezeout_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_14857", "source_line": 4902, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 126, "global_rank": 2273, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: INDY inverse-decay freezeout dark matter is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: BBN, indirect detection.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phenomenological_mps_bump_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_05070_power_law_mps_bump_microhalos_v1", "paper_id": "2102_05070", "source_line": 4583, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2274, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_mps_bump_dark_matter entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=low and BBN=medium.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_7348_freeze_in_through_portals_v1", "paper_id": "1309_7348", "source_line": 1994, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 127, "global_rank": 2275, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_01766_gravitational_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2005_01766", "source_line": 4252, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2276, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative vector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via gravitational production from quantum fluctuations; tachyonic enhancement of longitudinal modes, nonthermal phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_02124_adjoint_messenger_gmsb_gravitino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1609_02124", "source_line": 2902, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2277, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type mixed_cold_warm, and structure fields with small-scale effect suppression and transfer shape smooth_cutoff.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_06597_starobinsky_abs_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_06597", "source_line": 259, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 133, "global_rank": 2278, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Starobinsky-ABS F(R) primordial black hole dark matter, a speculative primordial black holes entry with effective field theory theory support and high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, enhancement of small-scale power, enhanced small scale power transfer behavior.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: abundance_is_highly_tuned, not_particle_dm."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_00759_su3prime_gauged_pq_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1803_00759", "source_line": 3444, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 175, "global_rank": 2279, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type field_like; portals axion, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: domain_wall_context, wino_overclosure_side_issue."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_10103_dm_induced_affleck_dine_baryogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1703_10103", "source_line": 3084, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 146, "global_rank": 2280, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory and production ability unknown.", "Observational leverage comes from BBN relevance medium, CMB relevance medium; inferred probe classes: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection, laboratory precision, small-scale structure.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2102_02461_hybrid_inflation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2102_02461", "source_line": 226, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 134, "global_rank": 2281, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=enhanced_small_scale_power, small_scale_power_effect=enhancement, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_3394_curvaton_relativistic_dark_matter_decay_v1", "paper_id": "0912_3394", "source_line": 1028, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2282, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 16 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from observational leverage, auditable provenance and robustness, registry diversity value.", "Card-local details considered: identity family nonthermal_dark_matter, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and decay_produced phase-space history, probe handles: BBN, CMB.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_10343_anomaly_free_hadrophilic_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_10343", "source_line": 4928, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 147, "global_rank": 2283, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: anomaly-free hadrophilic U(1) vector Majorana-fermion dark matter is benchmark with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 1-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "soft_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_08646_soft_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2105_08646", "source_line": 344, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2284, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=unknown; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, small-scale power effect is mixed, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth, nonlinear halo or subhalo effect is stated.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:not_particle_microphysics, medium:perturbation_only.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 6/7/5/0/9/7/18."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0509532_biscalar_mond_scalar_oscillation_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0509532", "source_line": 229, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2285, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative scalar_field_cold_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=suppression, and probe classes: CMB, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_hot_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_0459_1p5ev_neutrino_hot_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1003_0459", "source_line": 2, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2286, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, suppression small-scale-power effect, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_leptonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11950_softly_broken_u1l_majorana_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11950", "source_line": 4057, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 16 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2287, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative scotogenic_leptonic_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'unknown'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'unknown', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_07142_resonant_wino_zreft_v1", "paper_id": "1712_07142", "source_line": 3391, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2288, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative wimp_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is low/high; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_07626_extended_dm_eft_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_07626", "source_line": 3360, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2289, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative effective_field_theory_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is medium/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_03974_higgs_portal_scalar_hidden_sector_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "1712_03974", "source_line": 3418, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 148, "global_rank": 2290, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance medium/medium; structure entry unknown/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_03974_vector_portal_hidden_sector_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "1712_03974", "source_line": 3417, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 149, "global_rank": 2291, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance medium/medium; structure entry unknown/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals vector.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_2698_self_interacting_bec_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1103_2698", "source_line": 351, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2292, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via cosmological condensate formation; halo formation through Jeans instability; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance unknown; linear structure effect mixed with transfer shape unknown; field_like phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_08814_sterile_neutrino_gev_leptogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1905_08814", "source_line": 3870, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support.", "The supplied card indicates a subcomponent/no-full-abundance dark matter role."], "family_rank": 117, "global_rank": 2293, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A Standard Model extension with one keV right-handed neutrino as dark matter and two nearly degenerate GeV right-handed neutrinos that generate lepton asymmetries affecting resonant production.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, subcomponent, production reach no; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space resonant; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: do_not_mark_full_abundance."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_01879_axion_minicluster_modified_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "1808_01879", "source_line": 3595, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 176, "global_rank": 2294, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with effective-field-theory theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has field-like phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_07987_asymmetric_inelastic_dark_qed_v1", "paper_id": "1909_07987", "source_line": 3990, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 150, "global_rank": 2295, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Asymmetric inelastic dark QED with dark muonium: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score 16 (defer) uses production=asymmetric dark matter abundance; inelastic dark-sector scattering suppresses direct detection; phase=nonthermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_06494_two_hidden_sector_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_06494", "source_line": 4718, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2296, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative dark_photon_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via production through two-hidden-sector kinetic and mass mixing in a multi-temperature cosmology; possible gravitational production for suitable reheating temperature.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN, CMB; the raw score is 16 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fourth_generation_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_3021_fourth_majorana_neutrino_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "1308_3021", "source_line": 1965, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2297, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_07288_nonminimal_spectator_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_07288", "source_line": 2723, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2298, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space history, high diversity value in the population context.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_05393_super_heavy_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1708_05393", "source_line": 3219, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2299, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Super-Heavy Gravitino Dark Matter in Starobinsky-Polonyi supergravity is a speculative superheavy_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, CMB/BBN relevance high/high, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_00009_neutrinophilic_bminusl_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_00009", "source_line": 3387, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2300, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative neutrino_portal_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is low/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "conversion_driven_freeze_out", "model_id": "1904_00238_conversion_driven_t_channel_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_00238", "source_line": 3823, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2301, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as conversion-driven freeze-out, co-annihilation through scalar-partner annihilations.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_05441_higgsploding_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1803_05441", "source_line": 3438, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 2302, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status yes; CMB/BBN relevance medium/none; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: higgsplosion_assumption."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_14972_fn_rhn_flavon_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2307_14972", "source_line": 5755, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 128, "global_rank": 2303, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Froggatt-Nielsen flavon-portal right-handed-neutrino freeze-in dark matter has moderate scientific motivation, partial associated-code or tool support; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_0804_mixed_axion_axino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0910_0804", "source_line": 1024, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 100, "global_rank": 2304, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 16 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family multi_component_dark_matter, theory level uv_complete, and mixed_cold_warm phase-space history, probe handles: BBN, CMB.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_04136_alp_derivative_condensate_production_v1", "paper_id": "1508_04136", "source_line": 2547, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 177, "global_rank": 2305, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Axion-like particle dark matter from derivative coupling to a scalar condensate: model-card phase-space, cosmology, or structure fields provide some observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 16.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_pion_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_10724_dark_pion_multiplet_category_i_v1", "paper_id": "1910_10724", "source_line": 3994, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2306, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Dark pion multiplet dark matter, category I unforbidden: high diversity value; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score 16 (defer) uses production=thermal dark-sector evolution with WZW 3-to-2 processes; 2-to-2 conversion of stable pions into unstable pions; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_pion_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_10724_dark_pion_multiplet_category_ii_v1", "paper_id": "1910_10724", "source_line": 3995, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2307, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Dark pion multiplet dark matter, category II partially forbidden: high diversity value; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score 16 (defer) uses production=thermal dark-sector evolution with WZW 3-to-2 processes; 2-to-2 conversion of stable pions into unstable pions; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_pion_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_10724_dark_pion_multiplet_category_iii_v1", "paper_id": "1910_10724", "source_line": 3996, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2308, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Dark pion multiplet dark matter, category III forbidden: high diversity value; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score 16 (defer) uses production=thermal dark-sector evolution with WZW 3-to-2 processes; 2-to-2 conversion of stable pions into unstable pions; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "catalyzed_annihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_02447_catalyzed_annihilation_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_02447", "source_line": 4597, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2309, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative catalyzed_annihilation_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=high and BBN=high.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07828_xy_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07828", "source_line": 2744, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2310, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has parameter-dependent relic production, nonthermal phase-space history, partial collider_simulation support.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: collider.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1905_12182_closed_axion_domain_wall_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_12182", "source_line": 3908, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 135, "global_rank": 2311, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to compact-object/dynamics.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "relaxion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_08633_all_in_one_relaxion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1902_08633", "source_line": 3781, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2312, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 16 because the card identifies production via post_reheating_field_misalignment, coherent_relaxion_oscillations, field_like phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_05802_u1d_dirac_eta2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_05802", "source_line": 3357, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority because explicit observables, constraints, routing, or public implementation support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2313, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Speculative vector_portal_dark_matter card with uv complete theory support and thermal phase-space information.", "Observational leverage is low/medium; inferred probe coverage: BBN, CMB, collider/fixed-target, galaxy/halo structure.", "Sparse explicit observables, constraints, routing, and public-code fields limit extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1093_pseudo_dirac_midm_rayleigh_uv_completion_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1093", "source_line": 1666, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 151, "global_rank": 2314, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freezeout through dipole-mediated annihilation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 16 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1301_3668_two_component_scalar_dm_130gev_line_v1", "paper_id": "1301_3668", "source_line": 1689, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 101, "global_rank": 2315, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as coupled thermal freeze-out of two scalar components; dark-sector conversion S S to eta0 eta0, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 16 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_00227_visible_heavy_qcd_axion_mirrored_dirac_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1702_00227", "source_line": 3010, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 152, "global_rank": 2316, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mirrored Dirac neutrino dark matter with B-prime-minus-L-prime annihilation is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has some cosmological, phase-space, or halo-structure leverage; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_06388_nonlinear_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_06388", "source_line": 2868, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2317, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; 3 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_03275_umssm_kinetic_mixing_rh_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_03275", "source_line": 3067, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2318, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative sneutrino_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_02659_stringy_rvm_kr_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2105_02659", "source_line": 4702, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 178, "global_rank": 2319, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 62.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via nonthermal axion background from stringy RVM inflation; late non-perturbative axion mass generation.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN, CMB, gravitational waves; the raw score is 16 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_02601_sugra_pbh_gravitino_composite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_02601", "source_line": 249, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2320, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_hole_composite_dark_matter entry with uv_complete; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: power_peak_tuning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "2102_04232_ide1_log_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2102_04232", "source_line": 312, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2321, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is high, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=partial; warnings=medium:fluid_not_particle.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/4/5/1/9/3/13."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "2102_04232_ide2_sine_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2102_04232", "source_line": 313, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2322, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is high, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=partial; warnings=medium:fluid_not_particle.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/4/5/1/9/3/13."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimensions", "model_id": "1805_01642_quasi_universal_6d_ued_b01_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_01642", "source_line": 3431, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2323, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level effective_field_theory; relic status parameter_dependent; phase-space type thermal; portals vector, higgs; underrepresented family count 1.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; only partial associated-code support; warnings: do_not_promote_constraints, higgs_localization_variant."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_10792_hot_hidden_sector_dark_qed_v1", "paper_id": "2405_10792", "source_line": 6066, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 153, "global_rank": 2324, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 16.0: speculative simplified model model in hidden_sector_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, laboratory precision; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_07269_susy_axion_domain_wall_safe_v1", "paper_id": "1710_07269", "source_line": 3301, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 179, "global_rank": 2325, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support, high CMB relevance, field like phase-space behavior, 2 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_b_minus_l_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_06344_canonical_b_l_seesaw_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_06344", "source_line": 3879, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2326, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A spontaneously broken U(1)_{B-L} model with type-I seesaw neutrino masses and a vector-like Dirac fermion dark matter candidate charged under B-L.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN low; CMB medium; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_b_minus_l_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_06344_stueckelberg_b_l_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_06344", "source_line": 3878, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2327, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A U(1)_{B-L} gauge model where B-L is unbroken, neutrinos are Dirac, the gauge boson mass is generated by the Stueckelberg mechanism, and a vector-like Dirac fermion is the thermal dark matter candidate.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN low; CMB medium; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "purely_gravitational_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_10032_gravitationally_produced_pgdm_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "1812_10032", "source_line": 3713, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2328, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Gravitationally produced PGDM with scalar reheating is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, nonthermal phase-space behavior, probe relevance for BBN, CMB, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_01803_su5_singlet_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1804_01803", "source_line": 3446, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2329, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs; underrepresented family count 3.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: warning_no_full_relic_solver."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_04672_majoraxion_case_b_v1", "paper_id": "2204_04672", "source_line": 5105, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 180, "global_rank": 2330, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a second Majoraxion benchmark case; useful for family coverage but penalized as a near-duplicate with the same missing observational-extension payload."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_04672_majoraxion_case_c_v1", "paper_id": "2204_04672", "source_line": 5106, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 181, "global_rank": 2331, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a third Majoraxion benchmark case; explanatory motivation is strong, while duplicate status and absent constraints/routing suppress priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_14549_hidden_photon_dm_from_hidden_symmetry_breaking_v1", "paper_id": "2105_14549", "source_line": 4750, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2332, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_photon_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via longitudinal hidden photon production by parametric resonance at hidden U(1) breaking; possible cosmic-string loop emission of longitudinal vectors.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB; the raw score is 16 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Diversity credit is elevated because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive family or production regime in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_12034_u1d_dirac_fermion_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2203_12034", "source_line": 5087, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 129, "global_rank": 2333, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: strong science/relic-density basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: freeze-in from rare Standard Model Higgs decays h -> N N."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimpless_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_4479_amsb_wimpless_hidden_electron_v1", "paper_id": "1111_4479", "source_line": 1446, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2334, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 16.0 because the card describes wimpless hidden sector dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal freeze-out in a hidden sector; annihilation to massless hidden photons and medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimpless_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_4479_amsb_wimpless_selectron_v1", "paper_id": "1111_4479", "source_line": 1445, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2335, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 16.0 because the card describes wimpless hidden sector dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal freeze-out in a hidden sector; annihilation to massless hidden photons and medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_04274_pq_mirror_world_mirror_electron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_04274", "source_line": 5466, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2336, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: PQ mirror world with mirror electron dark matter has solid theory/motivation content, high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2307_08552_high_sound_speed_pbh_counterpart_v1", "paper_id": "2307_08552", "source_line": 206, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 136, "global_rank": 2337, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a emerging primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=high, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact-object/dynamical.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_07716_not_forbidden_vector_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1702_07716", "source_line": 3047, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 154, "global_rank": 2338, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Not-Forbidden vector-portal dark matter is ranked because it can produce the full dark-matter abundance in the card; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_05601_750gev_complex_scalar_majorana_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1603_05601", "source_line": 2737, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2339, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has a card-local full-dark-matter production route, medium CMB relevance, partial code support.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB, collider, indirect detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0408120_u1_prime_s_model_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0408120", "source_line": 507, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2340, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Supersymmetric U(1)' S-model neutralino dark matter is a speculative simplified model card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_5065_inert_singlet_vectorlike_unification_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_5065", "source_line": 1688, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 2341, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal annihilation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 16 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "well_tempered_wimp", "model_id": "1603_07387_singlet_doublets_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1603_07387", "source_line": 2794, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2342, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in well_tempered_wimp.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out; coannihilation among mixed singlet-doublet states; portals: higgs, vector.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_quark_nugget_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph9810335_relic_qgp_quark_nugget_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9810335", "source_line": 6138, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2343, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16 (defer) from supplied card content: macroscopic_quark_nugget_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; cosmological relevance: CMB medium, BBN high.", "Penalties (18) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "discrete_symmetry_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_02190_seesaw_a4_ddm_model_a_v1", "paper_id": "1603_02190", "source_line": 2772, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2344, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in discrete_symmetry_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out in an inert-Higgs-doublet-like Z2-odd sector; portals: higgs, other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "discrete_symmetry_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_02190_seesaw_a4_ddm_model_b_v1", "paper_id": "1603_02190", "source_line": 2773, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2345, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in discrete_symmetry_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out in an inert-Higgs-doublet-like Z2-odd sector; portals: higgs, other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_04778_utilitarian_u1x_pseudodirac_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_04778", "source_line": 2797, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2346, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in supersymmetric_singlet_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through S S annihilation in the singlet sector; portals: vector, higgs, other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_1665_nmssm_light_higgsino_singlino_v1", "paper_id": "1309_1665", "source_line": 1902, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2347, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16.0 because the model card is a speculative neutralino_supersymmetric_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_2916_hidden_mirror_matter_bbn_v1", "paper_id": "1401_2916", "source_line": 2019, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 155, "global_rank": 2348, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=unknown, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=unknown, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=partial and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_10449_nmssm_singlino_scalar_mediator_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_10449", "source_line": 4654, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 80, "global_rank": 2349, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level uv_complete, and relic production yes; high BBN relevance; probe relevance for BBN, small-scale structure.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dirac_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_09201_scotogenic_dirac_leptoquark_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2204_09201", "source_line": 5115, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks enough structured observables, constraints, routing, or computational artifacts to justify near-term extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2350, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked but low because the scotogenic/leptoquark construction is theoretically motivated while the dark-matter candidate and relic-density implementation are underspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_5013_displaced_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "0906_5013", "source_line": 983, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2351, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative superwimp_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space history; probe classes: BBN, indirect detection.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "matter_dominated_freezeout_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_03758_matter_dominated_freezeout_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_03758", "source_line": 3322, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2352, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with yes relic-density support, high BBN relevance, 2 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_08048_nonabelian_dark_glueball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_08048", "source_line": 2839, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 156, "global_rank": 2353, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from BBN, CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_04610_gravitino_lsp_hybrid_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_04610", "source_line": 3262, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 2354, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravitino dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 16.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_20478_two_axion_level_crossing_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "2405_20478", "source_line": 6130, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 182, "global_rank": 2355, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16 (defer) from supplied card content: axion_like_dark_matter with simplified_model theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; field_like phase-space behavior; cosmological relevance: CMB medium.", "Penalties (17) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_plasma", "model_id": "1603_07324_two_component_dark_plasma_v1", "paper_id": "1603_07324", "source_line": 2770, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2356, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative phenomenological_parameterization in self_interacting_dark_plasma.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out of dark fermions to dark photons; dark freeze-out alternative; portals: none.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare family or distinctive production, phase-space, or structure-formation behavior in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2109_14838_hybrid_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_14838", "source_line": 4869, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 137, "global_rank": 2357, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from phenomenological_parameterization theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_14637_string_axiverse_alp_strings_v1", "paper_id": "2109_14637", "source_line": 4873, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 183, "global_rank": 2358, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is emerging and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from uv_complete theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; field_like phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_07107_forbidden_dark_matter_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1505_07107", "source_line": 2475, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2359, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=forbidden_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=medium; BBN relevance=medium.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=9, diversity_value=4.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0607437_light_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0607437", "source_line": 323, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2360, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, BBN relevance is medium, phase-space type is thermal.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, CMB, direct/lab scattering, indirect detection; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:borderline_existing_ldm.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/2/10/0/9/4/17."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_1601_hidden_gauge_gmsb_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_1601", "source_line": 1453, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 2361, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable gravitino_dark_matter variant and records thermal production of light gravitinos.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_01830_group_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_01830", "source_line": 5646, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 81, "global_rank": 2362, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because group-scale velocity-dependent SIDM simulation model with partial code support but unknown production and phase space.", "Score is still held down by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points despite limited code support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_08281_resonant_real_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1503_08281", "source_line": 2425, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 2363, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a higgs_portal_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; cosmological relevance is CMB=medium, BBN=unknown; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0405476_singlet_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0405476", "source_line": 513, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 118, "global_rank": 2364, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Singlet sterile-neutrino dark matter with pulsar-kick mixing is a speculative simplified model card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (nonthermal; small-scale effect unknown); it touches direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_02594_charged_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1505_02594", "source_line": 2490, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2365, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=q_ball_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from phase_space=nonthermal.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=19, diversity_value=6.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_4842_dark_technicolor_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1410_4842", "source_line": 2266, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 157, "global_rank": 2366, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and nonthermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_01023_secluded_scalar_leptophilic_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2310_01023", "source_line": 5831, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2367, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out through secluded annihilation into singlet scalar mediators.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_01129_two_gauge_frictional_misalignment_alp_v1", "paper_id": "2206_01129", "source_line": 5192, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 184, "global_rank": 2368, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: two-gauge ALP friction variant gains diversity over the minimal case, but still lacks routes, constraints, and robust hidden-sector observational mappings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_0668_so10_210_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0901_0668", "source_line": 956, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 2369, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_0668_so10_54_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0901_0668", "source_line": 955, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 2370, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_06419_lr_broken_4_2_2_bino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2202_06419", "source_line": 5072, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 2371, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: tension/anomaly.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out; stau-neutralino coannihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_18677_qcd_axion_mixed_axiverse_v1", "paper_id": "2305_18677", "source_line": 5645, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 185, "global_rank": 2372, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because multi-component QCD-axion/axiverse model with field-like behavior but sparse observational detail.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_apparent_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_11492_yukawa_apparent_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2304_11492", "source_line": 5642, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2373, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because rare modified-gravity apparent dark matter with galactic-dynamics motivation but low robustness as a BSM DM card.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_03036_su2d_u1d_asymmetric_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_03036", "source_line": 3551, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 2374, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it can supply all dark matter according to the production block.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_13205_su2d_scotogenic_freezein_v1", "paper_id": "2204_13205", "source_line": 5171, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 130, "global_rank": 2375, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: full-DM SU(2)D FIMP benchmark has decay-produced nonthermal production, but no phase-space distribution, constraints, or observable routes are supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_05694_z3_dm_companion_leptonic_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2405_05694", "source_line": 6069, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2376, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 16.0: speculative simplified model model in wimp_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as yes.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: direct detection; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is partial and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_15167_pq_singlet_fermion_axion_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_15167", "source_line": 4881, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 102, "global_rank": 2377, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: mixed_cold_warm phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_1354_susy_type_i_seesaw_neutralino_threshold_v1", "paper_id": "1005_1354", "source_line": 1113, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 2378, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_1566_gev_leptophobic_zprime_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_1566", "source_line": 2296, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 158, "global_rank": 2379, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_5581_higgsino_world_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_5581", "source_line": 1358, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 2380, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 61.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out with efficient electroweak annihilation; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by phenomenological_parameterization structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0412001_ued_kaluza_klein_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0412001", "source_line": 518, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2381, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Universal extra dimensions Kaluza-Klein dark matter is a speculative effective field theory card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_6889_modified_radiative_seesaw_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_6889", "source_line": 2281, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2382, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2302_06886_antisymmetric_usr_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_06886", "source_line": 224, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 138, "global_rank": 2383, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with uv_complete; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical, gravitational waves.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0408213_light_dark_matter_u_f_mediators_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0408213", "source_line": 517, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2384, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Light dark matter with light gauge boson and heavy F mediator is a speculative simplified model card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches bbn, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_04964_environment_dependent_dark_photon_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2208_04964", "source_line": 5312, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 159, "global_rank": 2385, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 16.0: hidden_sector_dark_matter with thermal freeze-out through annihilation into dark photons; science=13.0, observational leverage=1.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection) and diversity=3.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "0908_4317_split_ued_kaluza_klein_photon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0908_4317", "source_line": 1015, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2386, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 16 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family kaluza_klein_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_3013_spherical_extra_dimensions_multistate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1005_3013", "source_line": 1188, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 103, "global_rank": 2387, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_3750_susy_su5_type_i_iii_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1007_3750", "source_line": 1189, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 2388, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1006_2518_real_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1006_2518", "source_line": 1152, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 2389, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_0283_broken_nonabelian_dark_sector_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0901_0283", "source_line": 952, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 160, "global_rank": 2390, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0411254_warped_lzp_right_handed_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0411254", "source_line": 505, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2391, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Warped GUT lightest Z_3 charged particle dark matter is a speculative effective field theory card with either relic-density treatment; it touches bbn, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cosmic_string_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_3695_type_iib_kinky_cycloop_relics_v1", "paper_id": "0906_3695", "source_line": 994, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2392, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative cosmic_string_relic_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and unknown full-density capability.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical probes, indirect detection.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_1131_naturally_split_mssm_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_1131", "source_line": 1489, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2393, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out of a Higgsino-dominated LSP.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "tau_portal_complex_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_3347_complex_scalar_tau_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_3347", "source_line": 2246, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2394, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative tau_portal_complex_scalar_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "tau_portal_dirac_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_3347_dirac_fermion_tau_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_3347", "source_line": 2244, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2395, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative tau_portal_dirac_fermion_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "tau_portal_majorana_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_3347_majorana_fermion_tau_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_3347", "source_line": 2245, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2396, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative tau_portal_majorana_fermion_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "tau_portal_real_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_3347_real_scalar_tau_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_3347", "source_line": 2247, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2397, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative tau_portal_real_scalar_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_specific_higgs_portal_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_09145_neutrino_specific_2hdm_z2_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_09145", "source_line": 3004, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2398, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Neutrino-specific two-Higgs-doublet model with Z2-odd Majorana fermion dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_14610_quark_philic_flavored_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2405_14610", "source_line": 6099, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2399, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 16.0: emerging simplified model model in flavored_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: collider/fixed-target, laboratory flavor; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9804237_susy_q_ball_baryonic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9804237", "source_line": 6119, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2400, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 16 (defer) from supplied card content: non_topological_soliton_dark_matter with simplified_model theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; cosmological relevance: BBN medium.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_03299_sp_scalar_gauge_dark_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "2004_03299", "source_line": 4222, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 161, "global_rank": 2401, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include asymmetry or baryon/lepton connection, larger-framework connection, phase-transition or confinement connection; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: BBN.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_13605_scoto_type_ii_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_13605", "source_line": 5159, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2402, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: fermion scotogenic coannihilation case is well identified, but coannihilation dependence and absent structured observables limit extension priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_13605_scoto_type_ii_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_13605", "source_line": 5158, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2403, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: scalar scotogenic thermal relic has narrow relic windows and good provenance, but the assigned card omits the direct-detection/collider constraints as structured fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_08081_not_so_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_08081", "source_line": 6055, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 2404, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 16.0: speculative uv complete model in inelastic_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: laboratory precision; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is partial and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_3566_ycmssm_bino_neutralino_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1104_3566", "source_line": 1328, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2405, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for supersymmetric_neutralino_coannihilation_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_09319_techni_composite_higgs_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_09319", "source_line": 4887, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2406, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from uv_complete theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: rare family in population context (count 8).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_dark_matter", "model_id": "0810_5344_wimp_annihilation_to_light_boson_v1", "paper_id": "0810_5344", "source_line": 870, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2407, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_subgev_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_01347_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_01347", "source_line": 5728, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2408, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Majorana dark matter with a kinetically mixed dark photon is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 3.0, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_subgev_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_01347_scalar_elastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_01347", "source_line": 5725, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2409, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Scalar elastic dark matter with a kinetically mixed dark photon is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 3.0, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_subgev_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_01347_scalar_inelastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_01347", "source_line": 5726, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2410, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Scalar inelastic dark matter with a kinetically mixed dark photon is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 8.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 3.0, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "continuum_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_16326_fermion_z_portal_continuum_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_16326", "source_line": 5331, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2411, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 16.0: continuum_dark_matter with thermal freeze-out through Z-mediated annihilation; science=9.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection, stellar streams) and diversity=7.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_left_right_symmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1001_0307_left_right_singlet_scalar_triplet_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1001_0307", "source_line": 1050, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2412, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 16 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness, registry diversity value, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family decaying_left_right_symmetric_dark_matter, theory level uv_complete, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_6078_flavor_symmetry_smssm_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_6078", "source_line": 2214, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 2413, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_5776_scale_invariant_u1x_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_5776", "source_line": 2231, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 162, "global_rank": 2414, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete hidden_sector_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warped_extra_dimension_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_03706_ir_uv_ir_warped_dark_higgs_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1504_03706", "source_line": 2440, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2415, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a warped_extra_dimension_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); implicit probe coverage includes CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_03710_so10_pq_axion_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_03710", "source_line": 5349, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 104, "global_rank": 2416, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 16.0: multi_component_dark_matter with axion misalignment and axionic-string decay; science=14.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=8.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches, stellar streams) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_flavoured_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_10700_higgs_portal_lepton_flavoured_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_10700", "source_line": 5832, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2417, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out.", "Follow-up value comes from direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_4253_dipolar_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_4253", "source_line": 2304, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2418, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 16 because the assigned model card effective field theory multi_component_fermion_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_portal_leptino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_3250_zprime_inverse_seesaw_leptino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1207_3250", "source_line": 1588, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2419, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 10, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but comparatively strong among sparse WIMP cards because the assigned card gives a UV inverse-seesaw leptino construction, high robustness, and multiple portal handles, though resonance tuning and missing routes remain limiting."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_05949_inert_doublet_ewpt_lop_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_05949", "source_line": 2393, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2420, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark inert_doublet_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal freeze-out through Higgs funnel, gauge channels, and scalar interactions, nonthermal production or dilution for under/over-abundant benchmark regimes production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pnGB_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_00332_composite_dark_sector_real_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1504_00332", "source_line": 2394, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2421, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative composite_pnGB_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out through electroweak gauge interactions production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (3 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: thermal freeze-out through electroweak gauge interactions; composite candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_triplet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_13325_real_singlet_inert_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_13325", "source_line": 5602, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2422, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because rare inert-triplet scalar family and electroweak phase-transition motivation, but little supplied observational routing.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_04681_u1x_u1n_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_04681", "source_line": 5604, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2423, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because a motivated family-dependent right-handed-neutrino construction, but the supplied card is CDM-like and observationally sparse.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_00745_simp_dark_meson_zprime_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1504_00745", "source_line": 2428, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 82, "global_rank": 2424, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a self_interacting_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked yes; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_09572_susy_u1x_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_09572", "source_line": 5162, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2425, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: UV-complete right-handed-neutrino Z-prime resonance relic with a rare family label, but supplied observational content is mostly collider/relic context rather than structured follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_higgs_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_08663_so7_so6_composite_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1605_08663", "source_line": 2822, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 16, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2426, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked yes.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 16, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_1892_single_rh_neutrino_nmssm_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_1892", "source_line": 2228, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 2427, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection, neutrino/laboratory.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_01050_hidden_su_n_confinement_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_01050", "source_line": 4019, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 163, "global_rank": 2428, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.3, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative effective_field_theory; rank-relevant evidence includes field_like phase-space information.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_04497_so10_pq_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_04497", "source_line": 5729, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 186, "global_rank": 2429, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 1.7, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: SO(10) U(1)_PQ axion dark matter with 10_F and 16_H extension is a speculative uv_complete card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and field_like phase space.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across galaxy satellites, indirect detection, laboratory precision; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 10.0, observational 2.0, complementarity 8.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 1.7, penalties 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_11844_spin2_portal_freeze_in_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "1911_11844", "source_line": 4071, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 15.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 131, "global_rank": 2430, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'yes'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'nonthermal', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: none explicit in the card.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_04936_heavy_thermal_hot_relic_v1", "paper_id": "2003_04936", "source_line": 4160, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 164, "global_rank": 2431, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of hidden_sector_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, small-scale-power suppression.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_12637_msm_freeze_in_lta_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_12637", "source_line": 4498, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 119, "global_rank": 2432, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Higher local observational leverage from cosmological or structure-formation fields in the supplied card for sterile_neutrino_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from resonant phase-space history, suppression small-scale-power effect, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 15.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1531_gauge_mediated_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1531", "source_line": 1722, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 2433, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as observationally relevant through medium BBN relevance, low CMB relevance, and phase/structure fields where present.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to baryogenesis/cogenesis, supersymmetric framework, phase-transition/nonstandard history.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_08988_thermalized_fimp_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2005_08988", "source_line": 4200, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 132, "global_rank": 2434, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of freeze_in_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space information.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "astro-ph0604013_step_like_quartessence_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0604013", "source_line": 76, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2435, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this unified_dark_matter_dark_energy card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, suppression in small-scale power, scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_03049_high_scale_axion_large_fi_v1", "paper_id": "1601_03049", "source_line": 2732, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 187, "global_rank": 2436, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has parameter-dependent relic production, high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space history.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "2310_09798_momentum_coupled_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2310_09798", "source_line": 194, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2437, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15.5 for interacting_dark_sector: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, high CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, suppression in small-scale power, some associated computational support, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; current-data compatibility is unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_16732_kaniadakis_pev_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_16732", "source_line": 5820, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 2438, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is freeze-in from inverse decays and Yukawa production processes.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, CMB, direct/collider, indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, with phase-space/structure entries (nonthermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_6640_hidden_w_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1309_6640", "source_line": 1962, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2439, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: indirect detection, laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "t_channel_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0592_dirac_fermion_t_channel_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0592", "source_line": 1971, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2440, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "t_channel_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0592_majorana_fermion_t_channel_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0592", "source_line": 1972, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2441, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 60.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_06476_minimal_fermionic_singlet_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_06476", "source_line": 5516, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 2442, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides thermal phase-space information, and some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_12940_supersymmetric_flavoured_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_12940", "source_line": 3805, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2443, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out through leptophilic annihilation.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_13588_axion_dm_nonstandard_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "2107_13588", "source_line": 4811, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 188, "global_rank": 2444, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, field like phase-space history, explicit benchmark points, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2578_cpv_mssm_light_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2578", "source_line": 734, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 2445, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_03063_single_dark_higgs_axial_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1610_03063", "source_line": 2885, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2446, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; associated code is marked partial; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_05910_pseudo_goldstone_bl_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2001_05910", "source_line": 4146, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2447, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15.5: speculative pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: collider, direct detection, neutrino.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_lmu_ltau_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_14528_mev_lmu_ltau_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2107_14528", "source_line": 4812, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2448, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_08947_neutral_naturalness_pngb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2003_08947", "source_line": 4149, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2449, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15.5: speculative pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: direct detection.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "weakly_interacting_massive_particle", "model_id": "1610_07617_electroweak_wimponium_wino_v1", "paper_id": "1610_07617", "source_line": 2869, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2450, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative weakly_interacting_massive_particle entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_4163_singlet_dirac_fermion_scalar_messenger_v1", "paper_id": "1209_4163", "source_line": 1668, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 2451, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freezeout through scalar-mediated annihilation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 15.5 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0810_5126_dark_electromagnetism_v1", "paper_id": "0810_5126", "source_line": 850, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 165, "global_rank": 2452, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked yes, CMB/BBN relevance is medium/medium. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_subcomponent_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_4095_exothermic_double_disk_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1307_4095", "source_line": 1878, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2453, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with asymmetric/baryogenesis, dissipative disk production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection, phase-space / transfer-function probes.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 7.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0503248_thermal_higgsino_pev_split_susy_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0503248", "source_line": 533, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2454, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Thermal Higgsino LSP in PeV-scale split supersymmetry is a speculative simplified model card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0503248_thermal_wino_pev_split_susy_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0503248", "source_line": 532, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2455, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Thermal Wino LSP in PeV-scale split supersymmetry is a speculative simplified model card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "resonant_annihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_6027_breit_wigner_kinetic_decoupling_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_6027", "source_line": 1370, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2456, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as resonant_annihilation_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_07168_e7_bino_wino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1907_07168", "source_line": 3942, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2457, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative neutralino_coannihilation_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to BBN.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07828_xyb_light_b_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07828", "source_line": 2745, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2458, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because it has a card-local full-dark-matter production route, partial collider_simulation support.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: collider.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_3124_techni_o_helium_v1", "paper_id": "0807_3124", "source_line": 838, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2459, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/medium, phase space is nonthermal. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3384_fermionic_wimp_axial_vector_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3384", "source_line": 857, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2460, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives benchmark status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3384_fermionic_wimp_pseudoscalar_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3384", "source_line": 855, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2461, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives benchmark status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3384_fermionic_wimp_scalar_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3384", "source_line": 854, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2462, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives benchmark status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3384_fermionic_wimp_tensor_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3384", "source_line": 858, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2463, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives benchmark status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3384_fermionic_wimp_vector_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3384", "source_line": 856, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 2464, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives benchmark status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3384_scalar_wimp_scalar_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3384", "source_line": 859, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 2465, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives benchmark status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3384_scalar_wimp_scalar_pseudoscalar_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3384", "source_line": 861, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 2466, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives benchmark status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3384_scalar_wimp_vector_axial_vector_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3384", "source_line": 862, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 2467, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives benchmark status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3384_scalar_wimp_vector_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3384", "source_line": 860, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 2468, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives benchmark status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_0176_rpv_leptonically_decaying_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0811_0176", "source_line": 891, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2469, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, full dark-matter abundance capability, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_baryonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_08951_stable_sexaquark_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1708_08951", "source_line": 3198, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2470, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 15.5: Stable sexaquark dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization entry with formation in the quark-gluon plasma described by a Boltzmann equation.", "Rank-relevant positives are medium BBN relevance, nonlinear structure information, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: BBN, direct detection, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_00042_seesaw_neutrino_portal_hidden_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2104_00042", "source_line": 4645, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 133, "global_rank": 2471, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked yes; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, indirect detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_3656_extended_linear_seesaw_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1409_3656", "source_line": 2238, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 120, "global_rank": 2472, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching Lyman-alpha forest, neutrino/laboratory.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_1708_pqsugra_pq3_axino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1212_1708", "source_line": 1728, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2473, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to strong-CP/PQ/axion, supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_1708_pqsugra_pq3prime_axino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1212_1708", "source_line": 1729, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2474, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to strong-CP/PQ/axion, supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0509112_n_mssm_light_singlino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509112", "source_line": 522, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 2475, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Nearly minimal nMSSM light singlino neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card with either relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0509112_nmssm_singlino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509112", "source_line": 521, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 2476, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because NMSSM singlino-admixed lightest neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card with either relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0509112_umssm_zprime_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509112", "source_line": 523, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 2477, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because U(1)' extended MSSM neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card with either relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_07839_dark_u1d_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_07839", "source_line": 5803, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 105, "global_rank": 2478, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out of the vector and fermion components using coupled Boltzmann yields.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_2215_sugra19_neutralino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1005_2215", "source_line": 1158, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 2479, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 2.5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 15.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "top_philic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_0618_top_window_effective_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1009_0618", "source_line": 1187, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2480, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 15.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_3463_radiative_seesaw_fermionic_n_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_3463", "source_line": 1808, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2481, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal; CMB relevance is medium.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on CMB, collider, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_3463_radiative_seesaw_inert_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_3463", "source_line": 1810, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2482, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative inert_triplet_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal; CMB relevance is medium.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on CMB, collider and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_06759_knt_light_rh_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1504_06759", "source_line": 2434, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2483, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_06759_quintuplet_three_loop_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1504_06759", "source_line": 2436, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2484, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_06759_septuplet_three_loop_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1504_06759", "source_line": 2437, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2485, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_06759_triplet_three_loop_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1504_06759", "source_line": 2435, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 2486, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "technicolor_dark_matter", "model_id": "0812_3406_timp_technicolor_v1", "paper_id": "0812_3406", "source_line": 852, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2487, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_0233_right_handed_majorana_neutrino_gut_v1", "paper_id": "0901_0233", "source_line": 896, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2488, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, full dark-matter abundance capability, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_higgs_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_0796_inert_2_plus_1_higgs_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1408_0796", "source_line": 2229, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2489, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative inert_higgs_doublet_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_higgs_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_0796_inert_4_plus_2_higgs_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1408_0796", "source_line": 2230, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2490, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative inert_higgs_doublet_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_5239_flavored_dm_right_handed_su2f_v1", "paper_id": "1104_5239", "source_line": 1352, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2491, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as flavored_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal annihilation of f anti-f to Standard Model quarks through flavor interactions; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_5239_flavored_dm_vector_su2f_v1", "paper_id": "1104_5239", "source_line": 1353, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2492, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as flavored_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal annihilation of f anti-f to Standard Model quarks through flavor interactions; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_01871_su2h_scalar_doublet_kinetic_mixing_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_01871", "source_line": 4619, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 166, "global_rank": 2493, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_effective_field_theory", "model_id": "1008_1783_dirac_fermion_wimp_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1783", "source_line": 1163, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2494, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 15.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, high scientific motivation from its theory setting and relic mechanism, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majorana_effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_10097_minimal_majorana_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1711_10097", "source_line": 3332, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2495, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 2 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_fermionic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_0367_d6_fermionic_singlet_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_0367", "source_line": 1351, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2496, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as leptophilic_fermionic_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out through n_S annihilation; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_09908_heavy_lifted_postinflationary_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2209_09908", "source_line": 5377, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 189, "global_rank": 2497, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Inflationary heavy-lifted post-inflationary QCD axion dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: CMB, phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_07420_nonthermal_decay_dark_matter_phantom_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "2311_07420", "source_line": 141, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2498, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative nonthermal_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth cutoff transfer behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0611111_gravitino_gauge_mediation_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0611111", "source_line": 659, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 2499, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: strong cosmology/structure leverage; rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0008451_massive_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0008451", "source_line": 114, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 2500, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 12, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative warm_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and high BBN relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, decay produced phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_08186_freeze_in_light_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2011_08186", "source_line": 4501, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 134, "global_rank": 2501, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 12.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from high CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, nonthermal phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_00056_low_scale_inflation_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_00056", "source_line": 5653, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 190, "global_rank": 2502, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 59.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Low-scale-inflation axion dark matter isocurvature model (axion_like_dark_matter) has field like phase-space information, CMB/BBN relevance, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 15.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_dust_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_2051_modified_dust_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1412_2051", "source_line": 106, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2503, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative modified_dust_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, mixed small-scale-power effect, smooth cutoff transfer behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_04821_late_decaying_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_04821", "source_line": 2937, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 106, "global_rank": 2504, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 11, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it can supply the full dark-matter abundance in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance high, BBN relevance low, phase-space type decay_produced, and structure fields with small-scale effect suppression and transfer shape scale_dependent_growth.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2006_16249_cosmic_string_cusp_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_16249", "source_line": 4298, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 139, "global_rank": 2505, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support, production via cosmic-string cusp collapse; nonthermal gravitational collapse, nonthermal phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified; a high-severity model-card warning was retained as a penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_15488_fermionic_infrared_dressing_ultralight_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2110_15488", "source_line": 4909, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2506, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Fermionic infrared-dressing ultralight scalar dark matter is speculative with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by nonthermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 1-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_10036_vector_coherent_oscillation_kinetic_function_v1", "paper_id": "2004_10036", "source_line": 4260, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2507, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative ultralight_vector_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via inflationary production of homogeneous vector condensate; coherent oscillation after H approximately m_A, field_like phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified; a high-severity model-card warning was retained as a penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_07202_freeze_in_fermion_singlet_nsc_v1", "paper_id": "2012_07202", "source_line": 4550, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 135, "global_rank": 2508, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from high BBN relevance, suppression of small-scale power, nonthermal phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0006024_scalar_field_cosh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0006024", "source_line": 170, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 2509, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15.0 for fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter: positive factors include effective_field_theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic-density viability, medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_14192_suppressed_production_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_14192", "source_line": 5484, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 121, "global_rank": 2510, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 10.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Suppressed-production sterile neutrino dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase space, suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth_cutoff transfer shape, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_12168_gravitational_atom_pidm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_12168", "source_line": 3819, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 167, "global_rank": 2511, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as gravitational freeze-in from the Standard Model thermal plasma, primordial two-particle gravitational bound-state formation.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_03931_axion_bec_cooling_alp_v1", "paper_id": "1812_03931", "source_line": 3766, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 191, "global_rank": 2512, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15 because the card identifies production via thermal axion production, misalignment production, field_like phase-space treatment, probe classes: CMB; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_07265_fuzzy_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2101_07265", "source_line": 4572, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 2513, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from phase-space type is field_like.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_08963_new_wimp_post_reheating_production_v1", "paper_id": "1902_08963", "source_line": 281, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2514, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as New WIMP paradigm with post-reheating dark matter production, a speculative wimp dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and high CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, thermal phase-space treatment, nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: generic_wimp_particle_content, reheating_degeneracy."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_01701_two_axion_ula_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_01701", "source_line": 2653, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 192, "global_rank": 2515, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability yes, and family count 338. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space behavior.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2108_04408_supergravity_double_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_04408", "source_line": 126, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 140, "global_rank": 2516, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with uv complete theory-level support and high CMB relevance, enhancement small-scale-power effect, enhanced small scale power transfer behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "off_shell_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_02448_off_shell_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1604_02448", "source_line": 153, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2517, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15.0 for off_shell_dark_matter: positive factors include effective_field_theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic-density viability, nonthermal phase-space behavior, smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior, suppression in small-scale power, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_03909_subdominant_particle_x_direct_collapse_v1", "paper_id": "2404_03909", "source_line": 6014, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, and current follow-up value is low relative to stronger batch entries."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 2518, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the decaying particle X row is a generic subcomponent parameterization with high-redshift photon-injection relevance but little microphysical specification or implementation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_08753_geometric_torsion_scalar_field_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_08753", "source_line": 98, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 2519, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this scalar_field_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression in small-scale power, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior, field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2111_13099_ewpt_pbh_dim6_dim8_higgs_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2111_13099", "source_line": 4937, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 141, "global_rank": 2520, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Electroweak phase-transition primordial black hole model in dimension-6/8 Higgs EFT is speculative with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by not_applicable phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, gravitational waves.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2403_13484_stochastic_eft_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2403_13484", "source_line": 5994, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 142, "global_rank": 2521, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from primordial_black_holes: Stochastic-EFT single-field inflation primordial black hole dark matter has moderate observational leverage, moderate model/theory value through collapse of enhanced small-scale curvature perturbations after horizon re-entry, ultra-slow-roll phase with quantum-diffusion dominated stochastic dynamics, non-Gaussian tail of the curvature-perturbation probability distribution; inferred probe classes are CMB, compact_objects.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_04077_mixed_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_04077", "source_line": 2542, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 122, "global_rank": 2522, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Mixed dark matter from sterile neutrinos: model-card structure/cosmology fields give comparatively strong observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_04745_secretly_asymmetric_fdm_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1608_04745", "source_line": 2875, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 2523, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; high BBN relevance; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superfluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_04083_classicalizing_superfluid_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1801_04083", "source_line": 3406, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2524, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level effective_field_theory; relic status parameter_dependent; phase-space type mixed_cold_warm; portals other; underrepresented family count 9.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: prior_model_developed_elsewhere."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_2989_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_2989", "source_line": 1530, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 2525, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, and supersymmetric neutralino dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection, collider / fixed-target / beam dump) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_14467_modular_flavored_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_14467", "source_line": 5680, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 193, "global_rank": 2526, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Modular flavored-QCD axion dark matter model with sterile neutrinos (axion_like_dark_matter) has field like phase-space information, axion portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 15.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_4507_axion_bec_photon_cooling_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_4507", "source_line": 1297, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 194, "global_rank": 2527, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 15 for Axion Bose-Einstein-condensate photon-cooling dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is critical; BBN relevance is critical; phase space is field_like; probe hints: BBN, CMB.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0306493_generalized_chaplygin_udm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0306493", "source_line": 439, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2528, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive model class; probe signal: cmb, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_dark_qcd_dark_baryon", "model_id": "2011_06589_stump_ultralight_dark_qcd_v1", "paper_id": "2011_06589", "source_line": 4475, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2529, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for ultralight_dark_qcd_dark_baryon.", "Diversity credit comes from nonthermal phase-space history, mixed small-scale-power effect, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_5753_t13_fermionic_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1011_5753", "source_line": 1217, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 2530, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family decaying_dark_matter with production via phenomenological decaying dark matter abundance assumed.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: BBN, compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection, laboratory precision / neutrino.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_3076_cold_positron_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1206_3076", "source_line": 1604, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 2531, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization card for Two-component decaying dark matter with cold positrons; it offers decay produced phase-space behavior; CMB/BBN relevance with BBN, CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, and 1 more probe hooks.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_12483_higgs_portal_wimp_admixed_neutron_star_v1", "paper_id": "1905_12483", "source_line": 3850, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2532, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out in the early Universe, gravitational capture or admixture in neutron stars.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_out_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_04056_defrosting_blast_freezing_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2306_04056", "source_line": 5674, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2533, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Defrosting and blast-freezing WIMP dark matter (freeze_out_dark_matter) has other portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 15.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_singlet_wimp", "model_id": "2111_07091_u1prime_singlet_fermion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2111_07091", "source_line": 4948, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2534, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: U(1)' SUSY singlet fermion WIMP dark matter is speculative with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, none structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_11686_einstein_cartan_singlet_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2008_11686", "source_line": 4375, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2535, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Einstein-Cartan portal singlet-fermion dark matter: freeze-in-like production from thermal Standard Model fermion annihilation via Einstein-Cartan four-fermion interactions; some cosmological or phase-space leverage, good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes structure formation.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_02004_nonminimal_gravitational_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_02004", "source_line": 5069, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2536, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 15 (defer) as a speculative effective_field_theory member of gravitationally_produced_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: CMB.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: inflation/reheating, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: gravitational freeze-in from thermal Higgs scattering; inflaton-condensate scattering/excitation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "technicolor_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0611341_su4_partially_gauged_technibaryon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0611341", "source_line": 701, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2537, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_1157_axion_bose_einstein_condensate_v1", "paper_id": "1111_1157", "source_line": 1438, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 195, "global_rank": 2538, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 15.0 because the card describes axion like dark matter at uv complete level, with vacuum realignment; string decay when PQ breaking is after inflation and medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space behavior.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "purely_gravitational_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_10973_pure_gravitational_hidden_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_10973", "source_line": 3779, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2539, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15 because the card identifies production via gravitational production of longitudinal vector modes during/after ..., subdominant transverse-mode production near the end of inflation an..., nonthermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0904_3800_blue_isocurvature_susy_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0904_3800", "source_line": 903, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 196, "global_rank": 2540, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, high cosmological relevance, non-CDM linear-structure information, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_origin_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_04693_so10_singlet_doublet_majorana_cogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1611_04693", "source_line": 2965, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2541, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_origin_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_origin_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_04693_so10_stop_like_transfer_majorana_v1", "paper_id": "1611_04693", "source_line": 2966, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2542, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_origin_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_07714_scalar_coupled_variable_mass_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_07714", "source_line": 40, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2543, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, high CMB relevance and medium BBN relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_remnant_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0104160_planck_black_hole_remnant_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0104160", "source_line": 389, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2544, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via Primordial black-hole formation from sharply peaked density fluctuations; Early black-hole-dominated epoch; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance high; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: BBN, CMB, compact objects/microlensing/dynamics, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_02692_u1_t3r_electron_subgev_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_02692", "source_line": 3855, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 168, "global_rank": 2545, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A sub-GeV dark matter model in which U(1)_T3R is broken to a stabilizing Z2 and the charged light-flavor sector includes the right-handed electron.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN medium; CMB medium; phase-space thermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_02692_u1_t3r_muon_subgev_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_02692", "source_line": 3854, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 169, "global_rank": 2546, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A sub-GeV dark matter model in which U(1)_T3R is broken to a stabilizing Z2 and the charged light-flavor sector includes the right-handed muon.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach yes; BBN medium; CMB medium; phase-space thermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_02032_complex_scalar_self_interacting_warm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_02032", "source_line": 2460, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2547, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=self_interacting_warm_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from phase_space=nonthermal; small_scale_power_effect=suppression.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: Lyman-alpha forest, galaxy satellites.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=3, diversity_value=6.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2589_two_scalar_interacting_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2589", "source_line": 1556, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2548, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mid-low priority because the card has distinctive interacting dark-matter/dark-energy background dynamics, field-like phase space, and CMB/BBN relevance, but no perturbation routing, constraints, observables, or code are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "quark_nugget_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0211559_quark_nugget_macho_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0211559", "source_line": 426, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2549, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive model class; probe signal: bbn, compact objects.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5717_type_i_seesaw_darkon_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5717", "source_line": 1525, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 2550, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, uv complete theory level, and higgs portal scalar dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, weak lensing / large-scale structure) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_08934_sterile_neutrino_portal_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1803_08934", "source_line": 3435, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2551, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance medium/unknown; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals neutrino, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: warn_not_original_model_claim, warn_no_constraints_in_model_card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_03560_5d_kinetic_mixing_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_03560", "source_line": 3436, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2552, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance medium/unknown; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals vector.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: warn_effective_5d_model, warn_no_constraints_in_model_card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0606296_right_handed_sneutrino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0606296", "source_line": 614, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2553, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, some computational or code support recorded in the model card, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_07573_asymmetric_dark_matter_nuggets_v1", "paper_id": "1812_07573", "source_line": 3753, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2554, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15 because the card identifies production via asymmetric dark matter abundance, symmetric component freeze-out, nonthermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: compact-object or macroscopic probes; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_10071_b3l_tau_singlet_doublet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_10071", "source_line": 3946, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2555, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "resonant_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2371_p_wave_complex_scalar_resonant_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2371", "source_line": 1613, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2556, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for p-wave complex-scalar resonant WIMP model; it offers CMB/BBN relevance with BBN, CMB, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_04195_hierarchical_inert_doublet_model_v1", "paper_id": "1905_04195", "source_line": 3842, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2557, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, Higgs-resonance annihilation for light dark matter.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_baryon_number_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_01017_anomaly_free_baryon_number_model_i_majorana_v1", "paper_id": "1904_01017", "source_line": 3803, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2558, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as thermal freeze-out.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_baryon_number_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_01017_anomaly_free_baryon_number_model_ii_majorana_v1", "paper_id": "1904_01017", "source_line": 3804, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2559, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as thermal freeze-out.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_04048_z2_scalar_singlet_condensate_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1506_04048", "source_line": 2488, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 136, "global_rank": 2560, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=medium; phase_space=nonthermal; distribution_function_available=approximate.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=249, diversity_value=4.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_04170_pn_gb_derivative_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1910_04170", "source_line": 3999, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 2561, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for pNGB scalar dark matter with derivative Higgs portal: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 15 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavor_symmetry_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_1371_a4_stable_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1011_1371", "source_line": 1231, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2562, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative simplified_model card in family flavor_symmetry_scalar_dark_matter with production via unknown.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection, laboratory precision / neutrino.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_10146_triplet_majorana_leptoquark_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_10146", "source_line": 3545, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 2563, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 58.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a simplified-model implementation; it touches collider / fixed-target, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_00192_hidden_sector_fermion_higgs_portal_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "1606_00192", "source_line": 2829, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 170, "global_rank": 2564, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from BBN, CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_08871_dirty_dark_matter_pearls_v1", "paper_id": "2205_08871", "source_line": 5169, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2565, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: very rare macroscopic composite/SIDM-like model with BBN and halo-dynamics hooks, but severe speculative-vacuum warnings and low robustness dominate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_0781_right_handed_sneutrino_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0912_0781", "source_line": 1043, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2566, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 15 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family sneutrino_dark_matter, theory level uv_complete, and decay_produced phase-space history, probe handles: BBN, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_06344_gauged_lepton_majorana_leptophilic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_06344", "source_line": 3880, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2567, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A local U(1)_L model in which anomaly cancellation predicts a Majorana dark matter candidate whose mass is generated when lepton number is spontaneously broken.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN low; CMB medium; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_1880_fast_transition_unified_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1210_1880", "source_line": 326, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2568, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is high, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:fluid_not_particle.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/4/5/0/9/5/16."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_15637_thermal_relic_rhn_bminusl_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_15637", "source_line": 5917, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 123, "global_rank": 2569, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Thermal relic right-handed neutrino dark matter in low-scale U(1)_{B-L} is a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and CMB, direct detection from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 13, observational leverage 4, complementarity 5, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 0.0, penalties 16; raw score 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1801_00686_fermionic_minimal_dark_matter_5d_gauge_higgs_unification_v1", "paper_id": "1801_00686", "source_line": 3419, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2570, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status yes; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs, vector.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: ghu_singlet_focus_warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1804_09660_three_rhn_low_scale_scotogenic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1804_09660", "source_line": 3430, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2571, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; CMB/BBN relevance low/low; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs, neutrino, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: w1, w2."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_10699_gravitational_self_interacting_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_10699", "source_line": 4655, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 137, "global_rank": 2572, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production yes; medium CMB relevance; nonthermal phase space; probe relevance for CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_13933_feeble_neutrino_portal_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_13933", "source_line": 4206, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 138, "global_rank": 2573, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include neutrino-sector connection; nonthermal phase-space information; high CMB relevance; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_03760_majorana_cp_violating_higgs_portal_strong_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2405_03760", "source_line": 6087, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2574, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 15.0: speculative effective field theory model in higgs_portal_freeze_in_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: indirect detection; phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_4791_gauged_r_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1002_4791", "source_line": 1095, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2575, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (BBN high); nonthermal phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_03312_nearglobal_abelian_higgs_dark_photon_string_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_03312", "source_line": 3733, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2576, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Near-global Abelian-Higgs cosmic-string dark photon dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, nonthermal phase-space behavior, probe relevance for CMB, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_5097_gauge_mediated_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1103_5097", "source_line": 1296, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 2577, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 15 for Gauge-mediated inflation model with gravitino dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from BBN relevance is critical; phase space is decay_produced; probe hints: BBN.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_1813_rpv_right_handed_neutrino_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0903_1813", "source_line": 942, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2578, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, high cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space character, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_solitonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0106008_q_ball_self_interacting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0106008", "source_line": 254, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2579, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Q-ball self-interacting dark matter, a speculative self interacting solitonic dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and nonthermal phase-space treatment, nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: variant_mixing, collision_outcome."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_07546_wimp_freezeout_during_monomial_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "2209_07546", "source_line": 5320, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2580, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 15.0: wimp_dark_matter with chemical equilibrium with SM bath followed by freeze-out during reheating; science=7.0, observational leverage=3.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (BBN, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection) and diversity=5.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_08711_pseudoscalar_portal_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_08711", "source_line": 3069, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2581, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_03607_modified_inert_doublet_z2_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1602_03607", "source_line": 2764, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2582, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative effective_field_theory in radiative_seesaw_inert_doublet_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out of the stable lightest Z2-odd inert scalar; portals: higgs, vector.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_07173_conformal_i_nonminimally_coupled_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_07173", "source_line": 327, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2583, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=partial; warnings=medium:fluid_coupled_dm.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/3/5/1/9/4/14."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_07173_conformal_ii_nonminimally_coupled_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_07173", "source_line": 328, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2584, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=partial; warnings=medium:fluid_coupled_dm.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/3/5/1/9/4/14."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_07173_disformal_iii_nonminimally_coupled_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_07173", "source_line": 329, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2585, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=partial; warnings=medium:fluid_coupled_dm.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/3/5/1/9/4/14."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dilaton_diluted_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1102_4277_dilaton_diluted_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1102_4277", "source_line": 1325, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2586, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance critical.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for dilaton_diluted_neutralino_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_09674_spontaneously_broken_higgs_portal_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1709_09674", "source_line": 3282, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 2587, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar field dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space structure.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching CMB, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 15.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_01263_thermal_hidden_sector_scalar_contact_v1", "paper_id": "2105_01263", "source_line": 4701, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2588, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_thermal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via hidden-sector thermal freeze-out; scalar contact annihilation.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN, CMB; the raw score is 15 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_07411_inert_doublet_scalar_dm_cdfii_muon_g2_v1", "paper_id": "2204_07411", "source_line": 5100, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 2589, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 15 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of inert_doublet_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, tension/anomaly.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out through electroweak gauge annihilation; subdominant p-wave Yukawa annihilation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0201185_gauge_mediated_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0201185", "source_line": 446, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2590, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides uv complete theory support, moderate diversity value; probe signal: bbn, compact objects.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "astro_ph0208032_dilatonic_cdm_interactions_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0208032", "source_line": 423, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2591, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive model class; probe signal: cmb, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0106119_gauge_mediated_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0106119", "source_line": 392, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2592, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative simplified_model model; production via Affleck-Dine field rotation and fragmentation; spatial instabilities grow into Q-balls; CMB relevance unknown and BBN relevance medium; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: BBN, compact objects/dynamics, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_heavy_baryon_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_0196_stable_fifth_family_baryon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0907_0196", "source_line": 236, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2593, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative composite_heavy_baryon_dark_matter entry with uv_complete; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=low, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=none, and probe classes: indirect detection, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_3304_higgs_portal_supersymmetric_hylogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1206_3304", "source_line": 1592, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 2594, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card supplies an asymmetric Higgs-portal hylogenesis variant with nonthermal production, but it is less developed and lacks explicit observational routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_05476_2hdm_bl_vector_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_05476", "source_line": 3761, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2595, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out, late-time entropy dilution after freeze-out, thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: collider; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_04712_5d_sugra_wino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1505_04712", "source_line": 2519, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2596, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for 5D SUGRA wino dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 15.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "massive_graviton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_01969_chameleon_bigravity_massive_graviton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_01969", "source_line": 330, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2597, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, phase-space type is field_like.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:modified_gravity_mapping.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 10/3/2/0/9/5/14."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_vector_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_2812_stueckelberg_vector_condensate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1105_2812", "source_line": 1304, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2598, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium, phase-space type field_like.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for hidden_vector_condensate_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_08910_qcd_axion_star_branches_v1", "paper_id": "1710_08910", "source_line": 3293, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 197, "global_rank": 2599, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a emerging axion like dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from field like phase-space structure.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching galaxy satellites.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 15.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_11133_t13b_singlet_doublet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_11133", "source_line": 3763, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2600, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out, coannihilation with nearby Z2-odd fermion or scalar states, thermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_triplet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_11133_t13b_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_11133", "source_line": 3764, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2601, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 15 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out, coannihilation with charged scalar triplet components, thermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_11642_field_theory_axiverse_v1", "paper_id": "2404_11642", "source_line": 6091, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2602, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 15.0: speculative uv complete model in multi_component_axion_like_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is field like.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_1566_gev_leptophobic_zprime_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_1566", "source_line": 2295, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 171, "global_rank": 2603, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_3279_kev_pseudoscalar_bosonic_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "0807_3279", "source_line": 878, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 198, "global_rank": 2604, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, effective field theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_1961_g2_mssm_hidden_sector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_1961", "source_line": 2268, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 172, "global_rank": 2605, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and nonthermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by distinctive phase-space history, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1905_13202_false_vacuum_bubble_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_13202", "source_line": 337, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 143, "global_rank": 2606, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, nonlinear halo or subhalo effect is stated.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, compact-object dynamics, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:mass-spectrum-missing.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 9/2/8/0/9/3/16."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_dark_matter", "model_id": "0908_3892_hidden_mev_fermion_ovr_v1", "paper_id": "0908_3892", "source_line": 986, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2607, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_operator_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_00227_visible_heavy_qcd_axion_mirrored_neutron_v1", "paper_id": "1702_00227", "source_line": 3009, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 173, "global_rank": 2608, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Mirrored neutron dark matter in a visible heavy QCD axion model is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_5781_q_ball_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1209_5781", "source_line": 1646, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 2609, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Q-ball decay gravitino dark matter in gauge-mediated supersymmetry; it offers decay produced phase-space behavior with Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_01129_minimal_frictional_misalignment_alp_v1", "paper_id": "2206_01129", "source_line": 5191, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 199, "global_rank": 2610, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: frictional-misalignment ALP is distinctive and tied to hidden-radiation cosmology, but the supplied card lacks concrete observables and has sphaleron-rate uncertainties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bremsstrahlung_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_01454_scalar_singlet_neutrino_bremsstrahlung_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_01454", "source_line": 3747, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2611, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Scalar singlet neutrino-bremsstrahlung dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, probe relevance for BBN, CMB, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_12034_u1d_dirac_fermion_freeze_out_v1", "paper_id": "2203_12034", "source_line": 5086, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 174, "global_rank": 2612, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 15 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: strong science/relic-density basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out via N Nbar -> Z_D Z_D."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_18332_gm_s_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_18332", "source_line": 6136, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2613, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 15 (defer) from supplied card content: scalar_singlet_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; cosmological relevance: CMB medium.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9605325_wilsonian_singlet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9605325", "source_line": 6117, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 175, "global_rank": 2614, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 15 (defer) from supplied card content: hidden_sector_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warped_extra_dimension_gravitational_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_04340_warped_extra_dimension_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_04340", "source_line": 3952, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2615, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Scalar dark matter with enhanced gravitational interactions in warped extra dimensions: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score 15 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out; annihilation into on-shell KK gravitons; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_multi_higgs_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_12522_two_inert_doublet_3hdm_h1_v1", "paper_id": "1907_12522", "source_line": 3958, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2616, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Two-inert-doublet 3HDM with stable H1 dark matter: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score 15 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out of H1 with annihilation and coannihilation among inert scalars; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_08597_sm_fermion_scalar_acdm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_08597", "source_line": 5189, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2617, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: rare asymmetric composite variant, penalized for model-dependent dark-baryon lifetime and sparse observational content."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_08483_lambda6_flipped_su5_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_08483", "source_line": 3856, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2618, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A flipped SU(5) U(1) GUT cosmology in which the lambda_6 coupling links reheating, gravitino production, nonthermal LSP dark matter, neutrino masses, and baryogenesis.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: mixed relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space unknown; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: unspecified_lsp_identity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_string_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_4905_intersecting_d6_neutralino_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0903_4905", "source_line": 929, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2619, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, high cosmological relevance, partial code or computational support, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Penalties mainly reflect missing observable mapping, constraints, and routing rather than global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_00365_minimal_b_l_freeze_in_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_00365", "source_line": 4249, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 139, "global_rank": 2620, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include early-universe production connection, larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection; nonthermal phase-space information; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_1262_supersoft_singlet_sommerfeld_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0910_1262", "source_line": 1046, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 176, "global_rank": 2621, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 15 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family hidden_sector_dark_matter, theory level effective_field_theory, and probe handles: BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_0011_nmssm_singlino_soft_lepton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0811_0011", "source_line": 890, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2622, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, full dark-matter abundance capability, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_1131_brane_world_nmssm_singlino_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_1131", "source_line": 1490, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 2623, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out of mixed singlino-Higgsino neutralino dark matter.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_2206_so10_neutralino_stau_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1112_2206", "source_line": 1479, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 2624, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 57.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out with neutralino-stau coannihilation.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_3859_cmssm_lsp_benchmark_mapping_v1", "paper_id": "1109_3859", "source_line": 1469, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 2625, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter variant and records supersymmetric relic abundance in standard Big-Bang cosmology.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_1148_gluino_nlsp_neutralino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "0905_1148", "source_line": 971, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 2626, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2305_03491_usr_primordial_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_03491", "source_line": 5637, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 144, "global_rank": 2627, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because USR primordial-black-hole dark matter with full-DM capability but little supplied observational detail.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_2594_inert_doublet_radiative_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1207_2594", "source_line": 1598, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 2628, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card ties inert-doublet scalar dark matter to radiative neutrino physics and full thermal abundance, but the observational-extension and code fields are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_03419_so10_pseudo_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_03419", "source_line": 4741, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2629, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via thermal freeze-out through scalar-portal annihilation.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB; the raw score is 15 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_massive_particle_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_10691_stable_dark_pion_simp_v1", "paper_id": "2110_10691", "source_line": 4892, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2630, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from uv_complete theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium BBN relevance; rare family in population context (count 4).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_09948_flipped_su5_a4_neutralino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_09948", "source_line": 5715, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 2631, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 12.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Neutralino cold dark matter in a flipped SU(5) U(1)_ F-theory A4 model is a speculative uv_complete card with unknown relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 7.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 0.0, penalties 12.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_6288_e6_u1n_higgsino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_6288", "source_line": 2269, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 2632, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_subgev_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_01347_pseudo_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_01347", "source_line": 5727, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2633, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Pseudo-Dirac dark matter with a kinetically mixed dark photon is a speculative simplified_model card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across collider/fixed-target, direct detection, galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 7.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 10.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 3.0, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_3533_classically_scale_invariant_pseudoscalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_3533", "source_line": 2294, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 177, "global_rank": 2634, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonabelian_exciting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_0233_nonabelian_doublet_decaying_xdm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_0233", "source_line": 2270, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2635, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative nonabelian_exciting_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and unknown phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, registry-diversity value, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_12505_dark_photon_sommerfeld_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2210_12505", "source_line": 5350, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 140, "global_rank": 2636, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 15.0: freeze_in_dark_matter with IR freeze-in; science=11.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches, stellar streams) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "continuum_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_16326_vector_z_portal_continuum_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_16326", "source_line": 5332, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2637, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 15.0: continuum_dark_matter with thermal freeze-out through generalized Chern-Simons Z portal; science=9.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection, laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches, stellar streams) and diversity=7.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_14390_higgson_wimp_second_order_gauge_couplings_v1", "paper_id": "2107_14390", "source_line": 4789, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2638, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated speculative electroweak_wimp_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: thermal production; standard freeze-out through electroweak annihilation.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_2722_d6_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1109_2722", "source_line": 1475, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2639, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable singlet_scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out through annihilation of two inert scalars into fermion pairs via neutral-Higgs exchange.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_3891_inverse_seesaw_mixed_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_3891", "source_line": 1650, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2640, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Inverse-seesaw mixed sneutrino dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_6302_scpv_nmssm_rh_sneutrino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1209_6302", "source_line": 1626, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 2641, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Spontaneously CP-violating NMSSM right-handed sneutrino LSP dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_5651_vector_higgs_portal_singlet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1005_5651", "source_line": 1200, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 2642, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 15 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_0642_dark_instanton_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_0642", "source_line": 1181, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 2643, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 15 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_7329_modified_split_susy_intermediate_higgs_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_7329", "source_line": 2359, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 2644, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out, neutralino-chargino coannihilation, and related mechanisms production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection, indirect/cosmology.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_07848_su2x_z3_higgs_triplet_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_07848", "source_line": 2446, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 178, "global_rank": 2645, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a hidden_sector_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_07971_sterile_neutrino_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2209_07971", "source_line": 5348, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 141, "global_rank": 2646, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 15.0: freeze_in_dark_matter with freeze-in from decays of thermal S1; science=14.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=8.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection, stellar streams) and diversity=3.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_01096_two_scalar_mediator_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_01096", "source_line": 4646, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2647, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative scalar higgs portal dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_5443_su2d_vector_scalar_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_5443", "source_line": 2314, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 107, "global_rank": 2648, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 15 because the assigned model card uv complete multi_component_dark_matter card; touches direct detection, laboratory precision / fifth-force searches.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_triplet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_2916_adjoint_su2_majorana_wino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1111_2916", "source_line": 1476, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2649, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable electroweak_triplet_fermion_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out through electroweak annihilation of the neutral Majorana state and coannihilating charged states.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2205_04471_multifield_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_04471", "source_line": 5153, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 145, "global_rank": 2650, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: multifield-inflation PBH production is distinctive and connected to compact-object probes, but the card lacks transfer functions, constraints, routes, and robust observable mappings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_03799_singlet_fermion_scalar_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1501_03799", "source_line": 2369, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 2651, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal WIMP freeze-out through scalar portal annihilation production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_11058_lepton_portal_hidden_valley_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1711_11058", "source_line": 3326, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2652, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 2 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_04824_so10_axion_fermion_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_04824", "source_line": 5165, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 108, "global_rank": 2653, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: SO(10) axion plus fermion multicomponent scenario is scientifically motivated, but the fermion production mechanism and observable mapping are unresolved in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0904_2201_type_ii_seesaw_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0904_2201", "source_line": 953, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2654, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative singlet_scalar_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_06003_scotogenic_singlet_doublet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_06003", "source_line": 5174, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2655, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: rare scotogenic scalar singlet-doublet relic with scan windows, but observational leverage is CDM-like and no constraints or routing are extracted."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_wimp", "model_id": "1711_02110_pseudoscalar_mediator_simplified_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1711_02110", "source_line": 3330, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2656, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2108_08416_susy_qball_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2108_08416", "source_line": 4861, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 146, "global_rank": 2657, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from uv_complete theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_1708_pqsugra_pq2_axino_neutralino_colsp_v1", "paper_id": "1212_1708", "source_line": 1727, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 15, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2658, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to strong-CP/PQ/axion, supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 15, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_03259_scale_invariant_vector_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2109_03259", "source_line": 4839, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.8, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 142, "global_rank": 2659, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by nonthermal phase-space history, some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_02605_abelian_scalar_bsf_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1911_02605", "source_line": 4029, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 179, "global_rank": 2660, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 6, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative simplified_model; rank-relevant evidence includes limited explicit observational handles in the supplied card.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_05669_yukawa_deflected_amsb_axino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_05669", "source_line": 3806, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2661, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as nonthermal production from frozen-out LOSP decays to axino.", "Moderate observational leverage comes from the card's nonthermal phase-space entry, cosmological relevance, or explicit non-CDM structure-formation fields.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_07875_scdew_strongly_coupled_de_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1503_07875", "source_line": 92, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2662, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this mixed_warm_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, suppression in small-scale power, mixed_cold_warm transfer behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_0542_ksvz_axion_kaplan_manohar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0705_0542", "source_line": 738, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 200, "global_rank": 2663, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; field_like phase-space history; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_thomas_fermi_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_04212_thomas_fermi_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_04212", "source_line": 3841, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2664, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with production listed as not in thermal equilibrium with the Standard Model, primordial abundance from unspecified early-universe mechanism.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_2176_braneworld_gravitational_production_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0705_2176", "source_line": 706, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2665, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative phenomenological_parameterization model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal phase-space history; BBN medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, gravitational/cosmology.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_03837_u1x_dark_photon_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2312_03837", "source_line": 5907, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2666, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because keV U(1)_X dark photon dark matter subcomponent is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_photon_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and BBN from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 8, observational leverage 7, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 6.5, penalties 18; raw score 14.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_04085_extended_2hdm_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2001_04085", "source_line": 4192, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 143, "global_rank": 2667, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of freeze_in_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include decay_produced phase-space information, small-scale-power suppression, 2 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_4493_low_mass_singlet_doublet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0705_4493", "source_line": 735, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2668, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_08235_lr_pq_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_08235", "source_line": 3811, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 201, "global_rank": 2669, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as PQ symmetry breaking produces a cold axion dark matter candidate, misalignment-like axion cold dark matter logic is invoked by mass/decay-constant range.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_colored_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_2679_dirac_fermion_colored_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1308_2679", "source_line": 1963, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2670, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_colored_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_2679_majorana_fermion_colored_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1308_2679", "source_line": 1964, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2671, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_technibaryon_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_6625_vectorlike_technineutron_su2v_v1", "paper_id": "1308_6625", "source_line": 1966, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2672, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; high diversity credit from a rare family, unusual production channel, or non-CDM behavior; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_06958_dirac_neutrino_cluster_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1510_06958", "source_line": 61, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2673, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this neutrino_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_00792_su5_scalar_multiplet_ultralight_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_00792", "source_line": 5905, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 2674, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Grand-unified scalar multiplet ultralight dark matter is a speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and laboratory precision from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 10, observational leverage 5, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 4.5, penalties 16; raw score 14.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "negative_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_07962_negative_mass_creation_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1712_07962", "source_line": 179, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2675, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 14.5 for negative_mass_dark_matter: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, high CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, some associated computational support, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; current-data compatibility is unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1685_zee_babu_z2_real_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1685", "source_line": 1683, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 2676, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out through Higgs portal and charged-scalar annihilation channels, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 14.5 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_00579_qcd_axion_domain_wall_matter_domination_v1", "paper_id": "1802_00579", "source_line": 3342, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 202, "global_rank": 2677, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with yes relic-density support, high BBN relevance, decay produced phase-space behavior, 2 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_07110_smart_u1x_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2002_07110", "source_line": 4176, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 2678, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of qcd_axion_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space information, 2 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity credit reflects a comparatively distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or dominant probe class in the population context.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "s_channel_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07975_fermiophobic_scalar_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07975", "source_line": 2748, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2679, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves partial collider_simulation support.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2211_11387_two_field_gaussian_bump_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_11387", "source_line": 75, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 147, "global_rank": 2680, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this primordial_black_holes card is viable enough to score, with uv_complete theory support and high CMB relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_0270_xogenesis_b_violating_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1009_0270", "source_line": 1184, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 2681, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 14.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_00042_seesaw_neutrino_portal_freeze_in_line_v1", "paper_id": "2104_00042", "source_line": 4644, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 144, "global_rank": 2682, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked yes; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, indirect detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0410007_cp_phased_msugra_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0410007", "source_line": 502, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 2683, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because CP-phased mSUGRA neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_09129_bl_bino_like_coannihilation_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_09129", "source_line": 2712, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2684, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium BBN relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: BBN, collider.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_inverse_seesaw_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_04336_radiative_inverse_seesaw_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_04336", "source_line": 2722, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2685, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 56.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance, partial relic_density_calculation support.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_12920_companion_axion_model_v1", "paper_id": "2109_12920", "source_line": 4844, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2686, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by field like phase-space history, some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "u1x_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_02718_u1x_charged_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_02718", "source_line": 3950, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2687, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative u1x_scalar_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0806_3225_inverse_seesaw_sneutrino_v1", "paper_id": "0806_3225", "source_line": 881, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 2688, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimension_kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_4507_nmued_b1_lkp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1305_4507", "source_line": 1851, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2689, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with coannihilation production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, collider / fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_3463_radiative_seesaw_inert_doublet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_3463", "source_line": 1809, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2690, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative inert_scalar_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal; CMB relevance is medium.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on CMB, collider and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_02905_conformal_dark_pion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_02905", "source_line": 3256, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 83, "global_rank": 2691, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self interacting dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 14.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauge_higgs_unification_dark_matter", "model_id": "0908_0212_h_parity_stable_higgs_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0908_0212", "source_line": 1009, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2692, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 14.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family gauge_higgs_unification_dark_matter, theory level uv_complete, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_6302_scpv_nmssm_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1209_6302", "source_line": 1625, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2693, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Spontaneously CP-violating NMSSM neutralino LSP dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_09414_cp_even_inert_scalar_r1_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1705_09414", "source_line": 3151, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2694, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 14.5: CP-even inert-scalar R1 scotogenic dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out of the inert scalar R1.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_09414_cp_odd_inert_scalar_i1_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1705_09414", "source_line": 3152, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2695, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 14.5: CP-odd inert-scalar I1 scotogenic dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out of the inert scalar I1.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "isospin_violating_inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_3943_inelastic_isospin_violating_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1108_3943", "source_line": 1364, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2696, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as isospin_violating_inelastic_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal WIMP production (generic motivation only); phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_effective_field_theory", "model_id": "1008_1783_majorana_fermion_wimp_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1783", "source_line": 1164, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2697, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 14.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, high scientific motivation from its theory setting and relic mechanism, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_7331_parallel_universe_dark_baryons_v1", "paper_id": "1410_7331", "source_line": 2227, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 180, "global_rank": 2698, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete hidden_sector_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_3513_su2_technicolor_goldstone_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1109_3513", "source_line": 1356, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2699, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as composite_asymmetric_dark_matter: production is represented by asymmetric dark matter with antiparticle annihilated away; phase-space is unknown; inferred probe coverage includes gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_lepton_number_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_01321_z2_odd_exotic_neutral_fermion_x_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1706_01321", "source_line": 3153, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2700, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 14.5: Z2-odd exotic neutral fermion X in a gauged lepton-number model is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out through Z'-mediated annihilation to leptons.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_11723_light_u1x_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2209_11723", "source_line": 5378, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 181, "global_rank": 2701, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Light U(1)_X vector dark matter with scalar-Higgs portal has some cosmology or phase-space leverage, probe classes: BBN, CMB, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1910_10575_dressed_primordial_black_hole_minihalos_v1", "paper_id": "1910_10575", "source_line": 4038, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 148, "global_rank": 2702, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.8, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes limited explicit observational handles in the supplied card.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_12711_lr_higgs_parity_n1_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2007_12711", "source_line": 4401, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 124, "global_rank": 2703, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes freeze-out through SU(2)_R x U(1)_{B-L} gauge interactions, entropy dilution from N2 decay.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance, mixed cold warm phase-space structure, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0611552_degenerate_sterile_neutrino_ball_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0611552", "source_line": 663, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 125, "global_rank": 2704, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 13, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: strong cosmology/structure leverage; rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_08975_curvaton_axion_dm_secondary_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "1611_08975", "source_line": 3000, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 203, "global_rank": 2705, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and yes all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include secondary_inflation_required."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_6556_23_inverse_seesaw_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_6556", "source_line": 2167, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 126, "global_rank": 2706, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with medium BBN relevance, mixed_cold_warm phase-space entry, approximate distribution-function support, and suppression small-scale-power effect.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_6556_scalar_singlet_extended_23_iss_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_6556", "source_line": 2168, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 127, "global_rank": 2707, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with medium BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space entry, approximate distribution-function support, and suppression small-scale-power effect.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_08372_type_ii_small_complex_structure_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_08372", "source_line": 2878, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 204, "global_rank": 2708, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; medium CMB relevance; field_like phase-space population; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_08940_scalar_inflaton_preheating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_08940", "source_line": 5204, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 145, "global_rank": 2709, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, medium CMB relevance; suppression of small-scale power; nonthermal phase-space behavior, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2008_12202_punctuated_inflation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2008_12202", "source_line": 232, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 149, "global_rank": 2710, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=mixed, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: manual_inflation_end."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2008_12202_ultra_slow_roll_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2008_12202", "source_line": 231, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 150, "global_rank": 2711, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=mixed, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: threshold_sensitivity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_coupled_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_00012_galactic_dm_neutrino_mass_scalar_force_v1", "paper_id": "1803_00012", "source_line": 3443, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2712, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level phenomenological_parameterization; relic status unknown; CMB/BBN relevance low/low; portals neutrino, other; underrepresented family count 1.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: missing_relic_origin, environment_dependent_neutrino_mass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_08459_exceptional_braneworld_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_08459", "source_line": 5032, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 2713, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Exceptional-periodicity braneworld spinor warm dark matter has strong supplied observational leverage; probe classes: small-scale structure; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hadrophilic_light_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_12630_hadrophilic_atmospheric_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_12630", "source_line": 5095, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2714, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 14 (defer) as a speculative simplified_model member of hadrophilic_light_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: atmospheric meson decays in cosmic-ray air showers; prompt scalar mediator decay S -> chi chi."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_2196_fractionally_coupled_cdm_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1304_2196", "source_line": 174, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2715, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 14.0 for coupled_dark_matter: positive factors include uv_complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-density viability, high CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, enhancement in small-scale power, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_12408_dark_second_force_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_12408", "source_line": 165, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2716, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 14.0 for interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter: positive factors include emerging status, effective_field_theory theory level, carded ability to supply all dark matter, high CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_10343_u1b_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_10343", "source_line": 4925, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 182, "global_rank": 2717, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: gauged U(1)_B baryon-number complex-scalar dark matter is benchmark with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 2-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_0283_fermionic_oscillating_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_0283", "source_line": 1539, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 2718, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, effective field theory theory level, and asymmetric dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_0283_scalar_oscillating_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_0283", "source_line": 1540, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 2719, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, effective field theory theory level, and asymmetric dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites, indirect detection) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "spin_3_2_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_15146_gravitationally_produced_raritron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_15146", "source_line": 5834, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2720, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is nonthermal gravitational production from the inflaton condensate.", "Follow-up value comes from BBN, with phase-space/structure entries (nonthermal, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter_misalignment", "model_id": "2306_01291_mass_varying_vector_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "2306_01291", "source_line": 5664, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2721, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Mass-varying vector boson from gauged quintessence misalignment (vector_dark_matter_misalignment) has field like phase-space information, gravitational, other portal coverage, high diversity value in the population context, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 14.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_2304_warm_self_interacting_dm_energy_density_v1", "paper_id": "1003_2304", "source_line": 1128, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 84, "global_rank": 2722, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization entry in self_interacting_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance, mixed small-scale-power effect, scale-dependent-growth transfer-function shape, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_07542_dark_axion_portal_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_07542", "source_line": 3113, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 183, "global_rank": 2723, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of hidden_sector_dark_matter with raw score 14.0.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from non-CDM structure-formation fields, distinct phase-space production.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 506.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_05672_rhn_decay_stable_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2301_05672", "source_line": 5494, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 146, "global_rank": 2724, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Stable singlet fermion dark matter from right-handed neutrino decay has solid theory/motivation content, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, decay_produced phase space, suppression small-scale-power effect, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_02592_baryon_number_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2307_02592", "source_line": 5677, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 2725, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Baryon-number-conserving complex scalar dark matter with neutron portal (asymmetric_dark_matter) has higgs, other portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 14.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_01007_dark_u1d_fimp_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2105_01007", "source_line": 4688, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 147, "global_rank": 2726, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_00725_fermionic_singlet_gravity_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1611_00725", "source_line": 2962, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2727, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravity_portal_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_dipole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_04540_q_deformed_dipole_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1803_04540", "source_line": 3450, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2728, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level effective_field_theory; relic status no; CMB/BBN relevance medium/unknown; phase-space type thermal; portals vector; underrepresented family count 1.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: warning_1803_04540_1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimpy_baryogenesis_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_1145_wimpy_leptogenesis_absorptive_fsi_v1", "paper_id": "1309_1145", "source_line": 1959, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2729, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: indirect detection; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_12117_holographic_qcd_composite_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1906_12117", "source_line": 3963, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 205, "global_rank": 2730, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Holographic composite QCD axion: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 14 (defer) uses production=QCD axion cosmological relic from the axion field; temperature-dependent axion mass affects the relic abundance; phase=field_like; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_13541_four_higgs_pq_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_13541", "source_line": 4262, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 206, "global_rank": 2731, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support, production via vacuum misalignment production; topological-defect production depending on PQ-breaking history, field_like phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_14152_axion_kinetic_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "1910_14152", "source_line": 3988, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 207, "global_rank": 2732, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Axion kinetic misalignment dark matter: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force.", "Score 14 (defer) uses production=kinetic misalignment from nonzero initial axion velocity; rotation of the PQ field generated by early higher-dimensional explicit breaking; phase=field_like; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_07138_rpv_type_iii_seesaw_gravitino_v1", "paper_id": "2204_07138", "source_line": 5091, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 2733, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 14 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of gravitino_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; some cosmological or phenomenological leverage; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, inflation/reheating, tension/anomaly, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: nonthermal gravitino dark matter in gauge-mediated SUSY-breaking context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_11153_strangeon_nugget_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1904_11153", "source_line": 85, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2734, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this macroscopic_composite_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and high BBN relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0709_3952_gravitino_dm_stop_nlsp_v1", "paper_id": "0709_3952", "source_line": 707, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 2735, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked unknown; BBN high and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB, gravitational/cosmology.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_11621_attractor_inflation_scalar_spectator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_11621", "source_line": 4611, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2736, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative gravitational production dark matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; some cosmological or phase-space leverage; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_02199_warped_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1906_02199", "source_line": 3885, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 184, "global_rank": 2737, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A truncated AdS5 braneworld dark sector with SM fields on the UV brane, dark particles such as DM on the IR brane, and a 5d bulk scalar mediator whose high-momentum opacity changes dark-matter complementarity.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: mixed relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN medium; CMB unknown; phase-space unknown; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: generic_dm_identity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_10392_two_flavour_t_channel_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_10392", "source_line": 4660, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 109, "global_rank": 2738, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; mixed_cold_warm phase space.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_4149_qcd_phase_transition_domain_wall_remnants_v1", "paper_id": "0705_4149", "source_line": 727, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2739, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative phenomenological_parameterization model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, compact/topological.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_supersymmetry", "model_id": "0710_1843_gut_less_susy_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0710_1843", "source_line": 713, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2740, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative phenomenological_parameterization model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gaugino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_09084_minimal_su5_supergut_pgm_gaugino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1902_09084", "source_line": 3812, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2741, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, wino annihilation.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dirac_neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_05648_dirac_neutrino_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_05648", "source_line": 4595, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2742, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative dirac_neutrino_portal_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=high and BBN=high.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_baryonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0002381_primordial_fog_particle_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0002381", "source_line": 6, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2743, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, enhancement small-scale-power effect, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9505069_induced_gravity_higgs_oscillation_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9505069", "source_line": 37, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 2744, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative uv_complete model, medium CMB relevance and high BBN relevance, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_10491_ultralight_proca_vector_fuzzy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_10491", "source_line": 3633, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 2745, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "braneworld_pseudoscalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0411262_branon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0411262", "source_line": 1, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2746, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 55.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, mixed small-scale-power effect, mixed_cold_warm phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_05966_ce6ssm_mixed_bino_inert_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_05966", "source_line": 2995, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 2747, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and yes all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_06047_string_axion_witten_effect_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_06047", "source_line": 3212, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 208, "global_rank": 2748, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: String axion dark matter with disappearing hidden monopoles is a speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, CMB/BBN relevance medium/high, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "purely_gravitational_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_10973_pure_gravitational_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_10973", "source_line": 3778, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2749, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 14 because the card identifies production via gravitational particle production in expanding FRW background, production during inflaton coherent oscillations in reheating, nonthermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coherent_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_06323_standard_model_cgf_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2204_06323", "source_line": 5090, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2750, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 14 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of coherent_field_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis; high diversity value in the population context.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Production summary used: semiclassical initial coherent state; classical SU(2)-Higgs cosmological gauge-field evolution."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_03248_dark_photon_fopt_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_03248", "source_line": 3095, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2751, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative dark_photon_portal_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory and production ability unknown.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2004_08111_pre_big_bang_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_08111", "source_line": 343, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 151, "global_rank": 2752, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is high, BBN relevance is high.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, CMB, compact-object dynamics; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:fine_tuned_sound_speed, high:qualitative_mass_function.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/4/8/0/9/3/18."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0603187_ac_composite_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0603187", "source_line": 599, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2753, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["AC composite dark matter with invisible light is a speculative uv complete card in family composite_dark_matter with production described as primordial AC-lepton asymmetry.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, CMB, halo/subhalo structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_03128_axion_gluon_portal_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_03128", "source_line": 5654, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 185, "global_rank": 2754, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Axion-gluon portal Dirac fermion dark matter (hidden_sector_dark_matter) has axion portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 14.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_3041_inflaton_mediated_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_3041", "source_line": 2331, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 148, "global_rank": 2755, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 14 because the assigned model card effective field theory freeze_in_dark_matter card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; uses nonthermal phase-space information; touches BBN, CMB.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0511789_ac_atom_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0511789", "source_line": 621, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2756, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, high diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_03416_secluded_relic_dark_photon_dmc_v1", "paper_id": "2303_03416", "source_line": 5572, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 186, "global_rank": 2757, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the secluded dark-photon component has some probe complementarity, but it is only a subcomponent and the card lacks concrete observables, routes, constraints, and code.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_2014_salam_sezgin_scalar_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "0903_2014", "source_line": 346, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 2758, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=no; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, BBN relevance is medium, phase-space type is field_like.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, CMB; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:subcomponent_not_full_dm, medium:transition_tuned.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 9/4/5/0/9/5/18."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_13292_two_scalar_singlet_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1909_13292", "source_line": 3997, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 110, "global_rank": 2759, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Two-component scalar singlet dark matter with long-lived decay: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score 14 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out; thermal freeze-in; phase=unknown; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "2111_00029_nonminimally_coupled_scalar_unified_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_00029", "source_line": 357, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2760, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative effective_field_theory model; production via nonminimal gravitational amplification of baryonic density; incomplete scalar-field decay after inflation; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance medium; field_like phase-space treatment; probe hooks: BBN, CMB, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_tensor_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_02835_bifurcated_scalar_tensor_mev_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_02835", "source_line": 5004, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2761, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Bifurcated scalar-tensor meV scalar dark matter has some cosmological or structure-formation leverage; probe classes: CMB, gravitational waves; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_4394_gravitino_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1103_4394", "source_line": 1299, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 149, "global_rank": 2762, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 14 for Gravitino freeze-in dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from BBN relevance is high; phase space is decay_produced; probe hints: BBN, collider.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_00869_type_ii_seesaw_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_00869", "source_line": 3413, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2763, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: dampe_specific, constraints_omitted_by_run."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_multihiggs_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_09598_i2plus1_3hdm_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_09598", "source_line": 3423, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2764, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level simplified_model; relic status parameter_dependent; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs, vector; underrepresented family count 1.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: subcomponent_benchmarks, collider_signal_focus."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_05722_lepton_quarticity_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1802_05722", "source_line": 3449, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 187, "global_rank": 2765, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; structure entry none/cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; portals higgs.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: warning_1802_05722_1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0612275_inert_doublet_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0612275", "source_line": 704, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2766, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_09143_sugra_singlet_fermion_gravitational_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_09143", "source_line": 3874, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2767, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A fermionic partner of a Z2-stabilized gauge-singlet chiral superfield whose nonthermal abundance is generated by gravitational production in supergravity.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space nonthermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_4791_gauged_r_right_handed_sneutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1002_4791", "source_line": 1096, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 2768, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (BBN high); nonthermal phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_8131_high_scale_qcd_axion_isocurvature_suppression_v1", "paper_id": "1304_8131", "source_line": 1799, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2769, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 14: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family axion_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance high; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type field_like; complementarity probes counted as CMB.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 6; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_07584_archimedean_lever_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_07584", "source_line": 5093, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 111, "global_rank": 2770, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 14 (defer) as a speculative effective_field_theory member of multi_component_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in, baryogenesis/leptogenesis.", "Production summary used: thermal relic freeze-out of X; scalar misalignment."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0804_0863_g2_mssm_nonthermal_wino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0804_0863", "source_line": 787, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2771, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 14.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance high, phase-space type nonthermal; probe classes counted: ['BBN'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "0911_4463_mirror_asymmetric_dark_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "0911_4463", "source_line": 1066, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 2772, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete asymmetric_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (BBN high); nonthermal phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_04065_trace_coupled_light_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_04065", "source_line": 3725, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2773, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Trace-coupled light scalar dark matter is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, field like phase-space behavior, probe relevance for BBN, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_10949_dark_z_fermionic_ldm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_10949", "source_line": 4890, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 188, "global_rank": 2774, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_13157_resonantly_excited_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_13157", "source_line": 4880, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 209, "global_rank": 2775, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from effective_field_theory theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; field_like phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_axion_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_4807_gut_scale_pqmssm_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1104_4807", "source_line": 1402, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2776, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 14.0 because the card describes mixed axion neutralino dark matter at phenomenological parameterization level, with axion coherent misalignment; neutralino thermal freeze-out modified by saxion-dominated expansion and critical BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_hidden_monopole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_06047_hidden_monopole_witten_effect_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_06047", "source_line": 3211, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2777, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Hidden monopole dark matter with Witten-effect axion dynamics is a speculative self_interacting_hidden_monopole_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, CMB/BBN relevance medium/unknown, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2010_03976_planet_mass_pbh_dust_stage_v1", "paper_id": "2010_03976", "source_line": 332, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 152, "global_rank": 2778, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=no; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, BBN relevance is critical.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: BBN, CMB, compact-object dynamics, gravitational waves; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:rough_abundance.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 5/3/10/0/9/4/17."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unparticle_dark_component", "model_id": "0812_4489_interacting_ucdm_unparticle_dark_component_v1", "paper_id": "0812_4489", "source_line": 865, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2779, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, direct detection and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unparticle_dark_component", "model_id": "0812_4489_interacting_xucdm_unparticle_dark_component_v1", "paper_id": "0812_4489", "source_line": 866, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2780, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, direct detection and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_05723_ew_mssm_stau_l_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2308_05723", "source_line": 5769, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 2781, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because EW MSSM bino dark matter with SU(2) doublet stau coannihilation has partial associated-code or tool support; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1203_4663_running_mass_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1203_4663", "source_line": 1493, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 153, "global_rank": 2782, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable primordial_black_holes variant and records collapse of enhanced primordial scalar perturbations generated near the end of running-mass inflation.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_5160_susy_hidden_dirac_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1211_5160", "source_line": 1676, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 189, "global_rank": 2783, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as thermal annihilation in the hidden sector, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 14 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_5160_susy_hidden_majorana_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1211_5160", "source_line": 1677, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 190, "global_rank": 2784, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as thermal annihilation in the hidden sector, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 14 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_00478_asymmetric_dm_light_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1703_00478", "source_line": 3028, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 2785, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Asymmetric Dirac dark matter with a light scalar mediator is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_00478_asymmetric_dm_light_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1703_00478", "source_line": 3027, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 2786, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Asymmetric Dirac dark matter with a light vector mediator is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2205_10148_ad_lball_pbh_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2205_10148", "source_line": 5178, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 154, "global_rank": 2787, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: L-ball PBH subcomponent has BBN and compact-object relevance, but the card explicitly warns against treating it as full PBH dark matter."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "branon_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_08354_massive_branon_cold_dm_flexible_brane_v1", "paper_id": "1904_08354", "source_line": 3780, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2788, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 14 because the card identifies production via branon annihilation cross-section chosen to reproduce observed cold..., thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: collider, compact-object or macroscopic probes; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_0520_complex_singlet_scalar_inflaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0909_0520", "source_line": 967, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 2789, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_0520_real_singlet_scalar_inflaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0909_0520", "source_line": 966, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 2790, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_6270_light_bino_neutralino_sneutrino_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1303_6270", "source_line": 1752, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2791, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 14: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family supersymmetric_thermal_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance critical; BBN relevance medium; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as BBN, CMB.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 1; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "regenerated_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_3727_regenerated_neutralino_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1204_3727", "source_line": 1570, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2792, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but distinctive because the card has nonthermal regenerated neutralino production and late-decay cosmology, offset by an unspecified FIMP parent and absent observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "discrete_flavor_inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_6890_sigma54_discrete_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1210_6890", "source_line": 1679, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2793, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete entry; production is summarized as WIMP-like thermal production through electroweak and Higgs-sector interactions is suggested by the paper's comparison to generic WIMP dark matter, with unknown phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 14 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0610277_wino_lsp_no_singlet_anomaly_mediation_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0610277", "source_line": 630, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2794, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some computational or code support recorded in the model card, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_11773_nonminimal_gravity_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_11773", "source_line": 5387, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2795, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Postinflationary scalar dark matter from non-minimal gravity coupling has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: phase-space observables, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space, large penalties for missing observables, constraints, and follow-up machinery."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_17203_su2d_chiral_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_17203", "source_line": 5918, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 191, "global_rank": 2796, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because SU(2)_D chiral fermion dark matter with dark isospin-3/2 fermion is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and gravitational waves from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 11, observational leverage 3, complementarity 2, feasibility 1, provenance 9, diversity 1.0, penalties 13; raw score 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_05952_pseudo_goldstone_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1812_05952", "source_line": 3762, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2797, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 14 because the card identifies production via thermal WIMP-like annihilation through Higgs-like scalars, nonthermal production allowed by the paper, probe classes: collider; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_04373_scenario_i_d5_mass_fimp_rhn_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_04373", "source_line": 4669, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2798, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space; probe relevance for BBN.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_04373_scenario_ii_two_d5_operators_fimp_rhn_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_04373", "source_line": 4670, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2799, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space; probe relevance for BBN.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_04373_scenario_iii_bare_mass_fimp_rhn_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_04373", "source_line": 4671, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2800, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space; probe relevance for BBN.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_12560_scalaron_decay_heavy_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_12560", "source_line": 6080, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2801, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 14.0: speculative simplified model model in superheavy_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as yes.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: indirect detection; phase space is decay produced.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dirac_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_01535_delta27_u1_scotogenic_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_01535", "source_line": 3861, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2802, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A U(1)-extended Delta(27) scotogenic Dirac-neutrino model in which the lightest dark Dirac fermion N is stabilized by a residual dark symmetry and can be a thermal dark matter candidate.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space thermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_equilibrium_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1302_4438_non_equilibrium_thermal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1302_4438", "source_line": 1789, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2803, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 14: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family non_equilibrium_thermal_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance medium; phase-space type nonthermal; complementarity probes counted as CMB.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 1; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_12008_hybrid_scotogenic_type_i_iii_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_12008", "source_line": 3937, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2804, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inflationary_complex_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_05904_inflationary_complex_scalar_charge_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_05904", "source_line": 3561, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2805, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative inflationary_complex_scalar_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has field-like phase-space behavior.", "It receives diversity credit for occupying a relatively sparse or phenomenologically distinctive region of the model-card population.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_11186_dynamical_axion_misalignment_damp0_v1", "paper_id": "1812_11186", "source_line": 3714, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 2806, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Dynamical Axion Misalignment Production near the bottom is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, field like phase-space behavior, probe relevance for CMB, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_12185_electroweak_skyrmion_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_12185", "source_line": 4863, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 2807, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 54.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from effective_field_theory theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; nonthermal phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "massive_spin_2_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_05128_trimetric_spin2_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1709_05128", "source_line": 3240, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2808, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Maximally symmetric trimetric spin-2 dark matter is a speculative massive_spin_2_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, CMB/BBN relevance medium/unknown, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_10561_extended_scotogenic_cp_n1_mother_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_10561", "source_line": 5975, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2809, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter: Extended scotogenic CP model with N1-sourced inert-doublet dark matter has high model/theory value, high diversity value through S-mediated scatterings populate N_1 in thermal equilibrium, thermal freeze-out of eta_R^0, late N_1 decay supplies eta_R^0 and lepton asymmetry; inferred probe classes are no explicit probe classes.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_5595_higgs_inflaton_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0906_5595", "source_line": 1022, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 2810, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 14 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family scalar_singlet_dark_matter, theory level effective_field_theory, and probe handles: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0410114_asymmetric_mixed_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0410114", "source_line": 539, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization."], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 2811, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Asymmetric mixed sneutrino dark matter is a speculative effective field theory card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches bbn, cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2201_07243_foewpt_fermi_ball_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_07243", "source_line": 5034, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 155, "global_rank": 2812, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: FOEWPT Fermi-ball primordial black hole dark matter has probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact objects, gravitational waves, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "750gev_resonance_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_04913_750gev_scalar_mediator_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_04913", "source_line": 2719, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2813, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance, partial relic_density_calculation support.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB, collider, indirect detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_05971_bilinear_scalar_condensate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_05971", "source_line": 2453, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 192, "global_rank": 2814, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=medium; distribution_function_available=approximate.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=506, diversity_value=4.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_04096_vectorlike_neutrino_globule_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1506_04096", "source_line": 2483, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2815, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=macroscopic_composite_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from phase_space=nonthermal.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=12, diversity_value=6.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_higgs_portal_wimp", "model_id": "1305_4625_weinberg_hidden_sector_w_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1305_4625", "source_line": 1868, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2816, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching BBN, CMB, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_4404_sterile_state_dipole_rayleigh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_4404", "source_line": 1791, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 112, "global_rank": 2817, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 14: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family multi_component_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance medium; BBN relevance medium; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as BBN, CMB.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 220; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_1187_decaying_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0906_1187", "source_line": 961, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 2818, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravitino_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_00942_charge_transfer_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_00942", "source_line": 5151, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 210, "global_rank": 2819, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: a distinct charge-transfer/kinetic-misalignment axion scenario with good provenance, but no explicit observable, constraint, routing, code, or small-scale-structure content is supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inverse_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_07728_scotogenic_inverse_seesaw_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1907_07728", "source_line": 3957, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2820, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Scotogenic inverse-seesaw scalar WIMP: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are collider / fixed-target.", "Score 14 (defer) uses production=thermal WIMP production analogous to the minimal scotogenic scalar scenario; phase=thermal; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2655_f_theory_qcd_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2655", "source_line": 1568, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 211, "global_rank": 2821, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but scientifically motivated because the card connects a UV F-theory setting to a QCD axion candidate with field-like phase space, while relic density and moduli-stabilization details are not worked through."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_07569_sterile_neutrino_dipole_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2108_07569", "source_line": 4874, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 128, "global_rank": 2822, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from effective_field_theory theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: nonthermal phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2109_00118_usr_pbh_affleck_dine_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_00118", "source_line": 4851, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 156, "global_rank": 2823, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from phenomenological_parameterization theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: high CMB relevance; distinct production or phase-space niche in the population context.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_16509_gauged_q_ball_fopt_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2404_16509", "source_line": 6076, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2824, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 14.0: speculative uv complete model in soliton_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as yes.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_08236_kklt_gev_axino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2105_08236", "source_line": 4713, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2825, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_axino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via nonthermal axino production from heavy gravitino decays after moduli decay; freeze-in through the Higgs/higgsino sector suppressed by moduli domination and entropy dilution.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 14 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Diversity credit is elevated because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive family or production regime in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2209_01552_fopt_fermi_ball_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2209_01552", "source_line": 5309, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 157, "global_rank": 2826, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 14.0: primordial_black_holes with dark-sector first-order phase transition; science=8.0, observational leverage=1.0, complementarity=10.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, galaxy satellites) and diversity=5.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0904_1933_higgs_coupled_quintessence_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0904_1933", "source_line": 897, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 2827, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, phenomenological parameterization theory level, full dark-matter abundance capability, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0810_1875_so10_two_step_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0810_1875", "source_line": 888, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2828, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_08654_d2380_hexaquark_bec_v1", "paper_id": "2001_08654", "source_line": 322, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 2829, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, direct/lab scattering, indirect detection; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:2001_08654_warning_not_bsm, medium:2001_08654_warning_no_transfer.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/1/8/0/9/4/15."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "A 7-10 GeV Dirac fermion dark matter scenario interacting with quarks and leptons through a weakly coupled light vector boson, thermally producing the measured dark matter abundance.", "model_id": "1011_1499_light_vector_mediator_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1011_1499", "source_line": 1255, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2830, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 14 for Light Dirac dark matter with weak vector mediator: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is medium; probe hints: CMB, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_5462_dark_two_higgs_doublet_singlet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1410_5462", "source_line": 2362, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 193, "global_rank": 2831, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_1641_u1_complex_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1411_1641", "source_line": 2363, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 194, "global_rank": 2832, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0006128_gravity_mediation_type_stable_q_ball_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0006128", "source_line": 377, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2833, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative simplified_model model; production via Affleck-Dine condensate instability and fragmentation into Q-balls; nonthermal soliton formation after inflation; CMB relevance unknown and BBN relevance medium; probe hooks: BBN, compact objects/dynamics, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_03589_mdddu_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2005_03589", "source_line": 4208, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2834, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include larger-framework connection; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_08215_sesm_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2205_08215", "source_line": 5187, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2835, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: scalar WIMP with coannihilation regimes and a sparse family label, but the extracted model-only card lacks the direct-detection/flavor constraints as objects."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_13205_su2d_scotogenic_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2204_13205", "source_line": 5170, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 113, "global_rank": 2836, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: UV-complete multi-component freeze-out variant has clear relic logic, but little extracted observational leverage and no routing or constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03217_bino_neutralino_slepton_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03217", "source_line": 4658, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 2837, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status benchmark, theory level simplified_model, and relic production yes; medium CMB relevance; probe relevance for CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "top_portal_radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_2606_top_portal_majorana_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1307_2606", "source_line": 1843, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2838, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative top_portal_radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on collider and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter_simplified_mssm", "model_id": "1506_02148_degenerate_squark_bino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1506_02148", "source_line": 2524, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2839, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Degenerate squark plus bino neutralino simplified MSSM dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter_simplified_mssm", "model_id": "1506_02148_light_gluino_bino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1506_02148", "source_line": 2523, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2840, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Light gluino plus bino neutralino simplified MSSM dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter_simplified_mssm", "model_id": "1506_02148_light_neutralino_chargino_bino_wino_v1", "paper_id": "1506_02148", "source_line": 2527, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2841, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Light neutralino-chargino bino-wino simplified MSSM dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter_simplified_mssm", "model_id": "1506_02148_light_sbottom_bino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1506_02148", "source_line": 2525, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2842, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Light sbottom plus bino neutralino simplified MSSM dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter_simplified_mssm", "model_id": "1506_02148_light_stop_bino_wino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1506_02148", "source_line": 2526, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2843, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Light stop plus bino-wino neutralino simplified MSSM dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_wimpless_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_0099_invisible_photino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1011_0099", "source_line": 1258, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2844, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 14 for Invisible photino dark matter from hierarchically split gauge mediation: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from BBN relevance is medium; probe hints: BBN.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mass_dimension_one_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_03881_elko_neutrino_interaction_v1", "paper_id": "2109_03881", "source_line": 4867, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2845, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from effective_field_theory theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; rare family in population context (count 2).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_dark_matter", "model_id": "0810_1502_secluded_wimp_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "0810_1502", "source_line": 883, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2846, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonabelian_exciting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_0233_nonabelian_triplet_decaying_xdm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_0233", "source_line": 2272, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2847, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative nonabelian_exciting_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and unknown phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, registry-diversity value, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "private_higgs_dark_matter", "model_id": "0804_3792_private_higgs_singlet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "0804_3792", "source_line": 875, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2848, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_1772_yukawa_fermion_dark_nuggets_v1", "paper_id": "1411_1772", "source_line": 2287, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2849, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative composite_self_interacting_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and not_applicable phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, registry-diversity value, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_4872_secluded_higgs_portal_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1109_4872", "source_line": 1457, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2850, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable secluded_dark_matter variant and records thermal secluded annihilation N N -> S S.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "heavy_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_2930_fourth_generation_majorana_neutrino_u1f_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_2930", "source_line": 1460, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2851, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable heavy_neutrino_dark_matter variant and records thermal annihilation of heavy Majorana neutrinos to Standard Model final states.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dilaton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_2225_fermionic_higgs_dilaton_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_2225", "source_line": 2256, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2852, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative dilaton_portal_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediated_fermionic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_02327_pseudoscalar_mediated_fermionic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1705_02327", "source_line": 3164, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2853, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 14.0: Simplified pseudoscalar-mediated fermionic dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with standard thermal freeze-out through pseudoscalar-mediated annihilation.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_03057_lepton_flavored_dm_couplet_v1", "paper_id": "1503_03057", "source_line": 2411, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2854, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a flavored_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_4580_mev_vector_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_4580", "source_line": 1388, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 195, "global_rank": 2855, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as hidden_sector_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out through p-wave annihilation; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_12552_bino_slepton_muon_g2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_12552", "source_line": 5336, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2856, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 14.0: supersymmetric_dark_matter with thermal freeze-out; science=12.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=8.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_1663_u1x_two_component_scalar_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_1663", "source_line": 2327, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 114, "global_rank": 2857, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 14 because the assigned model card uv complete multi_component_dark_matter card; touches indirect detection, laboratory precision / fifth-force searches.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_3506_focus_point_rh_neutrino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_3506", "source_line": 1473, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 77, "global_rank": 2858, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out of the lightest neutralino.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_12476_z3_nmssm_neutralino_sfoewpt_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_12476", "source_line": 5039, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 78, "global_rank": 2859, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 3.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Z3 NMSSM neutralino dark matter with strong first-order electroweak phase transition benchmarks has probe classes: gravitational waves, laboratory/particle; some implementation support from code or benchmarks, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_1789_susy_bl_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_1789", "source_line": 1462, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2860, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out with resonantly enhanced Zprime-mediated annihilation.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_2902_flavor_symmetry_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_2902", "source_line": 2233, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2861, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative flavored_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Associated code or implementation notes give limited feasibility support, while explicit routes remain missing.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_u1x_right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_13778_leptophilic_u1x_toy_model_ii_n2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_13778", "source_line": 4363, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2862, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Leptophilic U(1)_X Toy Model II N2 dark matter: thermal freeze-out; partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes collider/fixed-target, laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vectorlike_lepton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_02680_higgs_triplet_vectorlike_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1502_02680", "source_line": 2430, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2863, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a vectorlike_lepton_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; feasibility support scores 1 from code or analytic representation fields; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_5660_generic_u1d_gauge_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_5660", "source_line": 2367, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 196, "global_rank": 2864, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal freeze-out through gauge portal annihilation, s-channel Z' annihilation, and related mechanisms production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_00028_fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1503_00028", "source_line": 2383, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 2865, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal annihilation through scalar/pseudoscalar Higgs-portal interactions production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_02086_a4_scotogenic_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_02086", "source_line": 2391, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2866, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scotogenic_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out through scalar interactions, possible coannihilation or additional s interactions in the dark sector production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_03955_a4_z2_multicomponent_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_03955", "source_line": 2387, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 115, "global_rank": 2867, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out, co-annihilation among Z2-odd scalar states production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_scalar_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_06432_two_active_one_inert_3hdm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_06432", "source_line": 2396, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2868, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 53.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative inert_scalar_doublet_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal freeze-out via resonant annihilation through active A/H scalars production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (1 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: thermal freeze-out via resonant annihilation through active A/H scalars."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pnGB_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_00332_composite_dark_sector_complex_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1504_00332", "source_line": 2395, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2869, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative composite_pnGB_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out through electroweak gauge interactions production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (3 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: thermal freeze-out through electroweak gauge interactions; composite candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_09691_fopt_qball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1709_09691", "source_line": 3268, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2870, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative q ball dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 14.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0904_2201_type_ii_seesaw_breit_wigner_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0904_2201", "source_line": 954, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2871, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative singlet_scalar_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_2219_dfsz_axino_kim_nilles_v1", "paper_id": "1104_2219", "source_line": 1399, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2872, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as axino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal regeneration from Higgs/Higgsino decays; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_inverse_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_2529_u1d_radiative_inverse_seesaw_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1204_2529", "source_line": 1600, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2873, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but diverse because the card gives a UV radiative inverse-seesaw WIMP family with vector, Higgs, and exotic-lepton handles, but the lightest odd state and charged-relic condition are unresolved."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_11586_multicomponent_scalar_dark_photon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2109_11586", "source_line": 4876, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 116, "global_rank": 2874, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_2419_pmssm_1046838_pure_higgsino_v1", "paper_id": "1305_2419", "source_line": 1743, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2875, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 3.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 1 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "co_scattering_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_03708_compressed_coscattering_fermion_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2007_03708", "source_line": 4327, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2876, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Compressed co-scattering fermion dark sector benchmark as a benchmark co_scattering_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via thermal freeze-out through co-scattering.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_4624_minimal_universal_extra_dimensions_lkp_v1", "paper_id": "1002_4624", "source_line": 1092, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2877, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: benchmark uv_complete kaluza_klein_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "z_prime_mediated_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_04573_u1_lmu_ltau_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_04573", "source_line": 3245, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 14, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2878, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Local U(1)_{L_mu-L_tau} Majorana fermion dark matter model is a speculative z_prime_mediated_wimp_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 14, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_03279_twin_higgs_majorana_mirror_baryon_abundance_v1", "paper_id": "2109_03279", "source_line": 4822, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.8, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 2879, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_10313_nonperiodic_alp_pminus_half_v1", "paper_id": "2402_10313", "source_line": 5944, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 212, "global_rank": 2880, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Non-periodic ALP dark matter with p = -1/2 potential is a speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space information, mixed small-scale-power information, and small-scale structure from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 8, observational leverage 10, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 3.5, penalties 19; raw score 13.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_10313_nonperiodic_alp_pplus_half_v1", "paper_id": "2402_10313", "source_line": 5945, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 213, "global_rank": 2881, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Non-periodic ALP dark matter with p = 1/2 potential is a speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space information, mixed small-scale-power information, and small-scale structure from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 8, observational leverage 10, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 3.5, penalties 19; raw score 13.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_evaporation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_09725_pbh_evaporated_self_thermalizing_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2010_09725", "source_line": 4481, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2882, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Higher local observational leverage from cosmological or structure-formation fields in the supplied card for primordial_black_hole_evaporation_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from decay_produced phase-space history, suppression small-scale-power effect, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 13.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_14419_fermionic_dm_dark_mediator_dmans_v1", "paper_id": "2401_14419", "source_line": 5953, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 85, "global_rank": 2883, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from self_interacting_dark_matter: Fermionic dark matter with scalar and vector dark mediators in dark-matter-admixed neutron stars has moderate observational leverage through neutron-star dark matter may arise from accretion, inheritance from progenitor environments, or neutron decay in the core, cosmological production mechanism is not specified; relic abundance is used to fix mediator couplings; inferred probe classes are compact_objects, direct_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_06948_correlated_qcd_axion_bose_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1904_06948", "source_line": 3809, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 2884, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a emerging phenomenological parameterization model with production listed as relic QCD axion population assumed after the radiation-dominated era; microscopic production is not developed in this paper.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_13345_dark_meissner_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2312_13345", "source_line": 5920, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2885, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Dark Meissner light scalar dark matter is a speculative light_scalar_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and BBN from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 6, observational leverage 8, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 5.5, penalties 17; raw score 13.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_12204_velocity_dependent_interacting_cdm_de_v1", "paper_id": "2012_12204", "source_line": 186, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2886, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 13.5 for interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter: positive factors include effective_field_theory theory level, carded ability to supply all dark matter, high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_08130_decaying_coannihilator_sommerfeld_v1", "paper_id": "2401_08130", "source_line": 5961, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2887, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from coannihilation_dark_matter: Decaying-coannihilator finite-range Sommerfeld coannihilation scenario has moderate model/theory value, high diversity value through thermal freeze-out, coannihilation, Sommerfeld-modified coannihilator annihilation; inferred probe classes are CMB.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2012_07883_quantum_fisher_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2012_07883", "source_line": 96, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 158, "global_rank": 2888, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this primordial_black_holes card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, enhancement in small-scale power.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_2924_stueckelberg_millicharged_hidden_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "0705_2924", "source_line": 731, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 197, "global_rank": 2889, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_2924_stueckelberg_xwimp_milliweak_v1", "paper_id": "0705_2924", "source_line": 730, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 198, "global_rank": 2890, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0709_1862_ussm_singlino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0709_1862", "source_line": 733, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 79, "global_rank": 2891, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2550_mnssm_lightest_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2550", "source_line": 747, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 80, "global_rank": 2892, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB, portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_03063_higgs_chi_stueckelberg_zprime_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1610_03063", "source_line": 2886, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2893, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; associated code is marked partial; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "resonant_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2371_s_wave_split_scalar_resonant_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2371", "source_line": 1612, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2894, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for s-wave split-scalar resonant WIMP model; it offers CMB/BBN relevance with BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, and 1 more probe hooks.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_13389_fundamental_vector_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2401_13389", "source_line": 5988, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2895, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from vector_dark_matter: Fundamental SU(2)L vector-doublet dark matter with Sommerfeld enhancement has limited but scoreable model-card content through thermal WIMP freeze-out in the electroweak vector multiplet framework, annihilation through electroweak and Higgs channels; inferred probe classes are direct_detection, gravitational_waves, indirect_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11875_mssm30_neutralino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11875", "source_line": 4111, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 81, "global_rank": 2896, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 13.5: speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_2258_gmes_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0705_2258", "source_line": 740, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 82, "global_rank": 2897, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; BBN medium and CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from BBN, CMB.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_02152_string_torsion_kr_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_02152", "source_line": 4806, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 214, "global_rank": 2898, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by field like phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_05819_stueckelberg_millicharged_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_05819", "source_line": 4850, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2899, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_decay_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_1425_exodus_hidden_sector_decay_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1212_1425", "source_line": 1737, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2900, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to baryogenesis/cogenesis, hidden-sector structure, supersymmetric framework, phase-transition/nonstandard history.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=no, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_07489_asymmetric_self_interacting_dark_qed_v1", "paper_id": "1712_07489", "source_line": 3349, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 2901, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative unknown model with parameter dependent relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, 4 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_08257_asymmetric_mediator_scotogenic_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_08257", "source_line": 5373, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 2902, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Asymmetric-mediator scotogenic singlet-scalar dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: CMB, phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_03738_z2_two_singlet_scalar_s1_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_03738", "source_line": 2750, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2903, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves a card-local full-dark-matter production route, partial collider_simulation support.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: collider.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_1119_gravitino_stop_nlsp_lithium_v1", "paper_id": "0811_1119", "source_line": 895, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 2904, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, uv complete theory level, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_0270_xogenesis_su2l_sphaleron_v1", "paper_id": "1009_0270", "source_line": 1182, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 2905, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bound_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_2166_bound_dark_matter_phase_transition_v1", "paper_id": "1107_2166", "source_line": 1357, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2906, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as bound_dark_matter: production is represented by nonperturbative dark-gauge condensation/phase transition from a relativistic hot phase to cold bound states; phase-space is mixed_cold_warm; inferred probe coverage includes cosmological phase-space, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_5548_thermal_asymmetric_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1104_5548", "source_line": 1397, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 2907, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as asymmetric_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out with conserved particle-antiparticle asymmetry; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by phenomenological_parameterization structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_0802_gravitino_dm_light_higgsino_hybrid_mediation_v1", "paper_id": "1105_0802", "source_line": 1378, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 2908, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal gravitino production after reheating; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_baryon_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_6893_spontaneously_broken_mirror_baryon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_6893", "source_line": 1423, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2909, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 13.5 because the card describes mirror baryon asymmetric dark matter at uv complete level, with mirror leptogenesis; asymmetric mirror baryon production from heavy mirror Majorana neutrino decays and high BBN relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_4930_scalar_phantom_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1207_4930", "source_line": 1636, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 2910, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Simplest scalar phantom dark matter model; it offers CMB relevance with CMB, Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics, and 2 more probe hooks.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0509112_secluded_umssm_smodel_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509112", "source_line": 524, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization."], "family_rank": 83, "global_rank": 2911, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Secluded U(1)' S-model neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card with either relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_2305_b_l_radiative_inverse_seesaw_eta_r_v1", "paper_id": "1210_2305", "source_line": 1635, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 2912, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete card for Radiative inverse-seesaw B-L model with eta_R scalar dark matter; it offers CMB relevance with CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_07388_so7_g2_composite_singlet_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_07388", "source_line": 3173, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2913, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 13.5: SO(7)/G_2 composite singlet pNGB dark matter is a speculative effective field theory entry with thermal freeze-out of the neutral singlet pNGB.", "Rank-relevant positives are medium CMB relevance, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: CMB, collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_01239_leptophilic_two_portal_dirac_dm_model_a_v1", "paper_id": "1712_01239", "source_line": 3347, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 199, "global_rank": 2914, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative unknown model with yes relic-density support, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_01239_leptophilic_two_portal_dirac_dm_model_b_v1", "paper_id": "1712_01239", "source_line": 3348, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 200, "global_rank": 2915, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative unknown model with yes relic-density support, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_09756_atomki_secluded_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_09756", "source_line": 3200, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2916, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 13.5: Atomki-motivated secluded Majorana fermion dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with thermal freeze-out with p-wave annihilation in the secluded sector.", "Rank-relevant positives are nonlinear structure information, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: direct detection, laboratory precision, small-scale structure.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2210_14094_gluodynamics_phase_transition_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2210_14094", "source_line": 5371, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 159, "global_rank": 2917, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Gluodynamics first-order phase-transition PBH production has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: BBN, compact objects, gravitational waves, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_00525_superweak_sterile_neutrino_freeze_out_v1", "paper_id": "2112_00525", "source_line": 5002, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2918, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Super-weak U(1)_z sterile-neutrino freeze-out dark matter has probe classes: BBN, laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_triplet_fermionic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_08888_singlet_triplet_fermionic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1711_08888", "source_line": 3308, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2919, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with yes relic-density support, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1006_1357_semielastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1006_1357", "source_line": 1151, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 201, "global_rank": 2920, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_07115_low_mass_nonabelian_vector_g2hdm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_07115", "source_line": 4610, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 202, "global_rank": 2921, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_07859_top_fcnc_majorana_scalar_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_07859", "source_line": 4648, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2922, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative simplified fermion dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_2118_light_dark_zprime_isospin_violating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_2118", "source_line": 1365, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 203, "global_rank": 2923, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as hidden_sector_dark_matter: production is represented by asymmetric dark matter origin; phase-space is unknown; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_effective_field_theory", "model_id": "1008_1783_real_scalar_wimp_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1783", "source_line": 1166, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2924, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, high scientific motivation from its theory setting and relic mechanism, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_02170_self_interacting_puffy_dm_sommerfeld_v1", "paper_id": "2308_02170", "source_line": 5737, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 86, "global_rank": 2925, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 11.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Self-interacting puffy dark matter with Sommerfeld enhancement is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with parameter_dependent relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 7.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 5.0, feasibility 1.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 2.5, penalties 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_5542_pseudoscalar_dirac_dm_flavor_universal_v1", "paper_id": "1406_5542", "source_line": 2205, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2926, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_5542_pseudoscalar_dirac_dm_higgs_like_v1", "paper_id": "1406_5542", "source_line": 2206, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2927, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_03279_twin_higgs_vector_quark_mirror_neutron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_03279", "source_line": 4823, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.2, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 2928, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by nonthermal phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_00685_recurrent_axinova_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_00685", "source_line": 5480, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 215, "global_rank": 2929, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 52.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 11.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Recurrent axinova axion-like dark matter has limited supplied theoretical scoring fields, high CMB relevance, field_like phase space, enhancement small-scale-power effect, enhanced_small_scale_power transfer shape, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_0607_sterile_neutrino_kination_pre_bbn_v1", "paper_id": "1402_0607", "source_line": 2054, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 129, "global_rank": 2930, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of sterile_neutrino_dark_matter; abundance capability marked no; non-CDM small-scale structure information; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support; large sparsity penalties from missing observational-extension fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_0607_sterile_neutrino_scalar_tensor_pre_bbn_v1", "paper_id": "1402_0607", "source_line": 2055, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 130, "global_rank": 2931, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of sterile_neutrino_dark_matter; abundance capability marked no; non-CDM small-scale structure information; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support; large sparsity penalties from missing observational-extension fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_04123_u1x_dirac_cold_hidden_thermal_relic_v1", "paper_id": "2402_04123", "source_line": 5969, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 204, "global_rank": 2932, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from hidden_sector_dark_matter: Cold U(1)_X hidden-sector Dirac thermal relic has moderate observational leverage through thermal relic from coupled visible-hidden Boltzmann evolution, dark-sector annihilation and conversion involving D and dark photons; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_04123_u1x_dirac_hot_hidden_thermal_relic_v1", "paper_id": "2402_04123", "source_line": 5968, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 205, "global_rank": 2933, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from hidden_sector_dark_matter: Hot U(1)_X hidden-sector Dirac thermal relic has moderate observational leverage through thermal relic from coupled visible-hidden Boltzmann evolution, dark-sector annihilation and conversion involving D and dark photons; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_10343_u1b_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_10343", "source_line": 4926, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 206, "global_rank": 2934, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: gauged U(1)_B baryon-number Majorana-fermion dark matter is benchmark with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, probe complementarity, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 3-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_05737_dynamical_qcd_axion_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "1911_05737", "source_line": 4131, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 216, "global_rank": 2935, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 13: speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_14668_gravitational_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_14668", "source_line": 5016, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2936, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Gravitationally produced fermion dark matter from inflaton reheating has some cosmological or structure-formation leverage; probe classes: small-scale structure; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_14668_gravitational_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_14668", "source_line": 5015, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2937, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Gravitationally produced scalar dark matter from inflaton reheating has some cosmological or structure-formation leverage; probe classes: small-scale structure; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_14668_gravitational_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_14668", "source_line": 5017, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2938, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Gravitationally produced vector dark matter from inflaton reheating has some cosmological or structure-formation leverage; probe classes: small-scale structure; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_05738_non_equilibrium_thermal_freeze_in_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_05738", "source_line": 285, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 150, "global_rank": 2939, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Non-equilibrium thermal scalar freeze-in dark matter with perturbative resonance, a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and high CMB relevance, scale dependent growth transfer behavior, nonthermal phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: benchmark_not_uv_complete, not_all_freeze_in."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_11982_inflationary_bubble_smpbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_11982", "source_line": 159, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 2940, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 13.0 for primordial_black_hole_dark_matter: positive factors include emerging status, high CMB relevance, enhancement in small-scale power, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "1310_5335_interacting_dark_matter_vve_v1", "paper_id": "1310_5335", "source_line": 1934, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2941, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13.0 because the model card is a speculative interacting_dark_sector card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support; high BBN and high CMB relevance; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches BBN, CMB.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_02167_zprime_dark_fermion_candidate_v1", "paper_id": "1807_02167", "source_line": 3534, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because model-card-local observables, constraints, routing, or code support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 207, "global_rank": 2942, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked locally but not rejected because it has a UV-complete model card; it touches collider / fixed-target, indirect detection probes.", "Penalized because observables are not explicitly populated, theory-to-observable routes are absent, no usable associated code is provided, warnings or missing relic details make the extension riskier."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_06859_doubly_charged_two_positron_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_06859", "source_line": 5853, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 2943, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the two-positron decay idea is observationally distinctive for cosmic-ray and gamma-ray phenomenology, but the card is phenomenological, subcomponent-oriented, and lacks a full relic model, constraints, routing, and usable model code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_04818_multi_epoch_decaying_cdm_ensemble_v1", "paper_id": "2203_04818", "source_line": 5083, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 117, "global_rank": 2944, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13 (defer) as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of multi_component_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: some cosmological or phenomenological leverage.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: BBN, CMB.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: unspecified early-universe production setting the initial chi_n abundances before last scattering."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_00725_inert_doublet_gravity_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1611_00725", "source_line": 2961, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2945, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravity_portal_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_08409_electromagnetic_dark_radiation_from_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_08409", "source_line": 4580, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 2946, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative decaying_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=high and BBN=medium.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_5580_hidden_photino_rpv_freeze_in_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1403_5580", "source_line": 2044, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 208, "global_rank": 2947, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=nonthermal, and structure effect=suppression/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, structure formation, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_14273_minimal_preheating_gravitational_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_14273", "source_line": 5868, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2948, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the gravitational preheating abundance mechanism can produce all dark matter, but the microscopic candidate and observable channels are sparse and feasibility is low without public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_04046_gauged_lmu_ltau_vectorlike_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_04046", "source_line": 2858, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 209, "global_rank": 2949, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_04940_long_lived_inert_scalar_freeze_in_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_04940", "source_line": 5237, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 151, "global_rank": 2950, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; decay produced phase-space behavior, partial associated-code support. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_07137_bosonic_seesaw_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1610_07137", "source_line": 2890, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 152, "global_rank": 2951, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; nonthermal phase-space population.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_07777_scalar_relaxation_dm_baryon_coincidence_v1", "paper_id": "2310_07777", "source_line": 5858, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routing are missing or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 210, "global_rank": 2952, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the scalar relaxation mechanism is conceptually distinctive for the baryon-to-dark-matter coincidence, but the microscopic dark matter identity and observable mapping are deliberately generic and under-specified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_08339_thick_brane_bulk_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_08339", "source_line": 3795, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 211, "global_rank": 2953, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 13 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out through p-wave annihilation via the dark-photon ..., thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: BBN, CMB; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_11154_decaying_majoron_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_11154", "source_line": 3767, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2954, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 13 because the card identifies production via thermal relic Majorons, nonthermal misalignment production, probe classes: CMB, decay or indirect probes; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_03401_neutron_dark_decay_model_ii_v1", "paper_id": "1905_03401", "source_line": 3890, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 212, "global_rank": 2955, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / effective_field_theory: A neutron dark-decay hidden-sector model in which a dark fermion near the neutron mass can be dark matter and obtains the correct relic density through t-channel annihilation via a dark scalar.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: neutron_star_issue."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "technicolor_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11682_holographic_technicolor_timp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11682", "source_line": 4110, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2956, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 13: speculative technicolor_composite_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: medium CMB relevance; inferred probe classes: CMB, direct detection.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_cosmology_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_10746_decaying_particle_era_relic_density_v1", "paper_id": "1902_10746", "source_line": 3771, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2957, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 13 because the card identifies production via freeze-in thermal production without chemical equilibrium, freeze-out during reheating, probe classes: BBN, decay or indirect probes; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_02057_one_component_nonthermal_flavon_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2211_02057", "source_line": 5435, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Cosmological hooks are present, but observational-extension machinery is missing."], "family_rank": 153, "global_rank": 2958, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but useful: the one-component flavon portal has nonthermal production plus CMB/BBN relevance, but no supplied constraints, observables, routes, or code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_nonstandard_cosmology", "model_id": "1906_04183_wimp_nonstandard_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "1906_04183", "source_line": 3862, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2959, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: A phenomenological WIMP dark matter model where a generic WIMP freezes out during an early epoch dominated by a decaying component with equation of state w, altering the relic abundance through modified expansion and ...", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: mixed relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN critical; CMB unknown; phase-space thermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: pre_bbn_requirement."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_05923_u1x_pq_invisible_axion_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_05923", "source_line": 4103, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 217, "global_rank": 2960, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 13: speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: field_like phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: no explicit probe routing objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_3138_gauge_mediation_gravitino_no_qball_v1", "paper_id": "1404_3138", "source_line": 2080, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 2961, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of gravitino_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_3138_gauge_mediation_gravitino_qball_v1", "paper_id": "1404_3138", "source_line": 2081, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 2962, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of gravitino_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimensions_dark_matter", "model_id": "0708_0239_minimal_ued_g1_lkp_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "0708_0239", "source_line": 671, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2963, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: some cosmology or phase-space leverage; rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "b_minus_l_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_02661_b_minus_l_z2_n1_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1612_02661", "source_line": 2979, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2964, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative b_minus_l_wimp_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and yes all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include warn_1612_02661_hierarchy."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1093_pure_majorana_rayleigh_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1093", "source_line": 1667, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 213, "global_rank": 2965, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal freezeout through Rayleigh-operator annihilation, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 13 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_4685_vector_boson_130gev_line_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1211_4685", "source_line": 1685, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 2966, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory entry; production is summarized as thermal freeze-out with total V V annihilation cross section near 1 pb; Higgs-pair annihilation through lambda_1 or lambda_3, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 13 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied, 1 high-severity card warning(s) limit reuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_baryon_number_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_3970_baryonic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1309_3970", "source_line": 1912, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2967, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13.0 because the model card is a speculative gauged_baryon_number_fermion_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; unknown BBN and medium CMB relevance; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches CMB, collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "u1_vector_portal_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_6029_u1p_darkon_v1", "paper_id": "1309_6029", "source_line": 1913, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2968, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13.0 because the model card is a speculative u1_vector_portal_singlet_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; unknown BBN and medium CMB relevance; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches CMB, collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2405_13117_memory_burden_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2405_13117", "source_line": 6064, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 160, "global_rank": 2969, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 13.0: speculative phenomenological parameterization model in primordial_black_holes, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN, CMB.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_5297_inflaton_decay_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1311_5297", "source_line": 2033, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 2970, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=mixed_cold_warm, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_2430_light_gluino_wino_lsp_nonthermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1002_2430", "source_line": 1088, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 84, "global_rank": 2971, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium, BBN medium); decay_produced phase-space/production behavior.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_04755_anomaly_free_u1_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_04755", "source_line": 2888, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 214, "global_rank": 2972, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; 2 card-implied probe classes.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_00941_radiative_seesaw_inert_singlet_boson_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_00941", "source_line": 3415, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because model-card observational details, constraints, routing, or computational support are incomplete."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 2973, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative and theory level uv_complete; relic status parameter_dependent; phase-space type thermal; portals vector, other.", "Score is limited by no observables list; no applicable constraints list; no theory-to-observable routes; no computational-representation block; associated code unknown; warnings: garbled_gauge_label, dampe_specific."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_05721_bubble_expansion_scalar_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_05721", "source_line": 4559, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 215, "global_rank": 2974, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=unknown and BBN=medium.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2212_03403_dinkic_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_03403", "source_line": 5413, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["The card gives phenomenological hooks but not enough implementation or observational detail for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 161, "global_rank": 2975, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked PBH entry: it has compact-object and CMB relevance plus enhanced small-scale power, but lacks explicit constraints, routes, code, and benchmarks in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0605016_late_scalar_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0605016", "source_line": 647, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 85, "global_rank": 2976, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, moderate diversity value within the population-count context, some computational or code support recorded in the model card, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_6799_axial_vector_mediator_simplified_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_6799", "source_line": 1908, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 2977, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13.0 because the model card is a benchmark simplified_vector_mediator_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; high-severity card warnings limit robustness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_feebly_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0512118_right_handed_sneutrino_lsp_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0512118", "source_line": 643, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2978, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, high diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_16090_resonant_reheating_scalar_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2404_16090", "source_line": 6059, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 154, "global_rank": 2979, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 13.0: speculative simplified model model in freeze_in_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: BBN; phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_14549_axion_dm_from_hidden_symmetry_breaking_v1", "paper_id": "2105_14549", "source_line": 4749, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 218, "global_rank": 2980, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via nonthermal parametric resonance at hidden symmetry breaking; energy transfer from cold dark-Higgs condensate to NG bosons.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB; the raw score is 13 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_2835_gmsb_gravitino_scalar_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1002_2835", "source_line": 1080, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 2981, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete gravitino_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (BBN high); decay_produced phase-space/production behavior.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_4635_split_ued_right_handed_kk_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1004_4635", "source_line": 1073, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2982, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model kaluza_klein_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (BBN high); decay_produced phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_0468_higher_dimension_xdm_baryogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1304_0468", "source_line": 1787, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 2983, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 13: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, family singlet_fermion_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: BBN relevance high; phase-space type decay_produced; complementarity probes counted as BBN.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 6; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_4186_inflation_enhanced_pq_breaking_axion_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_4186", "source_line": 2107, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 219, "global_rank": 2984, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: CMB relevance is high; phase-space type is field_like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_09143_sugra_singlet_scalar_gravitational_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_09143", "source_line": 3873, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 2985, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A Z2-stabilized scalar component of a gauge-singlet chiral superfield whose abundance is generated by gravitational production in supergravity after inflation.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: nonthermal relic treatment, either, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space nonthermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: sugra_scalar_kahler_dependence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_01443_generic_u1x_two_component_scalar_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_01443", "source_line": 5053, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 118, "global_rank": 2986, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13 (defer) as a speculative uv_complete member of multi_component_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: moderate science basis.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: neutrino, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: thermal freeze-out of two coupled dark matter components; annihilation and coannihilation through Higgs and Z-prime portals."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_0948_nonthermal_wino_from_llp_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1303_0948", "source_line": 1811, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 2987, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is decay_produced; BBN relevance is high.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on BBN and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_axion_axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_4807_gut_scale_pqmssm_axino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1104_4807", "source_line": 1401, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2988, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 13.0 because the card describes mixed axion axino dark matter at phenomenological parameterization level, with axion coherent misalignment; out-of-equilibrium thermal axino production and critical BBN relevance, mixed cold warm phase-space behavior.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cosmological_gravitational_particle_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_17611_spin0_cgpp_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2405_17611", "source_line": 6089, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2989, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 13.0: speculative simplified model model in cosmological_gravitational_particle_production_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cosmological_gravitational_particle_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_17611_spin1_cgpp_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2405_17611", "source_line": 6090, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 2990, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 51.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 13.0: speculative simplified model model in cosmological_gravitational_particle_production_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_05723_ew_mssm_stau_r_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2308_05723", "source_line": 5770, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 86, "global_rank": 2991, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because EW MSSM bino dark matter with SU(2) singlet stau coannihilation has partial associated-code or tool support; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_12862_nonholomorphic_nuhm2_yukawa_unified_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_12862", "source_line": 5771, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 87, "global_rank": 2992, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Non-holomorphic NUHM2 Yukawa-unified SUSY GUT neutralino dark matter has partial associated-code or tool support; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_07214_fermionic_u1x_radiative_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1602_07214", "source_line": 2755, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 216, "global_rank": 2993, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through annihilation into pairs of dark gauge bosons; portals: vector, higgs.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_07214_scalar_u1x_radiative_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1602_07214", "source_line": 2756, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 217, "global_rank": 2994, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative uv_complete in hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through scalar annihilation into dark gauge boson pairs; portals: vector, higgs.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "2405_05798_page_like_unified_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "2405_05798", "source_line": 355, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2995, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via phenomenological continuity-equation evolution of a unified dark fluid; CMB relevance high and BBN relevance medium; probe hooks: BBN, CMB, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0803_0140_noncritical_string_neutralino_relic_v1", "paper_id": "0803_0140", "source_line": 812, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 88, "global_rank": 2996, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is medium/high. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0302080_varying_mass_bino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0302080", "source_line": 434, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 89, "global_rank": 2997, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value; probe signal: cmb, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bosonic_compact_object_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_05395_proca_star_vector_condensate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_05395", "source_line": 222, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 2998, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative bosonic_compact_object_dark_matter entry with uv_complete; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: compact-object/dynamical, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0610110_cpv_mssm_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0610110", "source_line": 615, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 2999, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some computational or code support recorded in the model card, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_3254_nnmsm_type_ii_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1309_3254", "source_line": 1935, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 3000, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13.0 because the model card is a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and touches direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_3254_nnmsm_type_iii_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1309_3254", "source_line": 1936, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 3001, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13.0 because the model card is a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and touches direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_00496_heavy_quark_spin1_mediator_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_00496", "source_line": 3776, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3002, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 13 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation mediated by R, thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: collider; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dirac_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_01535_delta27_u1_scotogenic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_01535", "source_line": 3860, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3003, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / uv_complete: A U(1)-extended Standard Model with Delta(27) family symmetry where Dirac-neutrino masses arise from a dark-sector loop; in the scalar hierarchy, the lighter eta scalar eigenstate is the stabilized dark matter candidate.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, unknown, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB unknown; phase-space thermal; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_03497_bimetric_massive_spin2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_03497", "source_line": 2833, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3004, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "galileon_unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1704_08640_shift_symmetric_galileon_unified_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1704_08640", "source_line": 303, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3005, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, phase-space type is field_like.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:not_particle_relic.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 10/3/2/0/9/6/17."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_1400_kev_freeze_in_majoron_triplet_higgs_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_1400", "source_line": 2050, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3006, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=nonthermal, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_13709_glaciation_dark_photon_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2111_13709", "source_line": 4891, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 155, "global_rank": 3007, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavor_symmetric_singlet_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_07419_a4_u1_singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1611_07419", "source_line": 2992, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3008, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative flavor_symmetric_singlet_doublet_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "1301_7536_rpv_axino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1301_7536", "source_line": 1738, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3009, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to neutrino, strong-CP/PQ/axion, inflation/curvaton, supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=no, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_10561_scotogenic_n1_mother_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_10561", "source_line": 5974, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3010, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter: Scotogenic inert-doublet dark matter with a right-handed-neutrino mother has high model/theory value, high diversity value through thermal freeze-out of eta_R^0, late N_1 decay into inert scalars that cascade to eta_R^0, low-scale leptogenesis from out-of-equilibrium N_1 decay; inferred probe classes are no explicit probe classes.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "0911_2310_interacting_dark_matter_negative_pressure_v1", "paper_id": "0911_2310", "source_line": 1026, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 87, "global_rank": 3011, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 13 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family self_interacting_dark_matter, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and probe handles: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2008_01457_no_scale_sugra_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_01457", "source_line": 4378, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 162, "global_rank": 3012, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Primordial black holes from modified no-scale supergravity: inflationary amplification of curvature perturbations near an inflection point; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, compact-object/dynamics, indirect/transient and related probes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_0674_deflected_mirage_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0905_0674", "source_line": 1010, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 90, "global_rank": 3013, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 13 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and probe handles: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "750gev_resonance_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_04913_750gev_pseudoscalar_mediator_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_04913", "source_line": 2720, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3014, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance, partial relic_density_calculation support.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB, collider, indirect detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_3477_z2_inert_doublet_vectorlike_lepton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0905_3477", "source_line": 1007, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3015, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 13 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family inert_doublet_dark_matter, theory level uv_complete, and probe handles: BBN, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_4374_dual_component_thermal_wimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0907_4374", "source_line": 992, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 119, "global_rank": 3016, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_12954_precision_unified_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_12954", "source_line": 5788, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 91, "global_rank": 3017, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Precision-unified Higgsino neutralino dark matter has moderate scientific motivation; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_12954_precision_unified_wino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_12954", "source_line": 5789, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 92, "global_rank": 3018, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Precision-unified wino neutralino dark matter has moderate scientific motivation; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_07453_conformal_inverse_seesaw_kev_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_07453", "source_line": 2476, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 131, "global_rank": 3019, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=sterile_neutrino_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from phase_space=nonthermal.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=170, diversity_value=3.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_02293_feebly_interacting_stable_scalar_relic_v1", "paper_id": "2210_02293", "source_line": 5330, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3020, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 13.0: nonthermal_dark_matter with inflationary gravitational production; science=9.0, observational leverage=2.0, complementarity=8.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (gravitational waves, indirect detection, stellar streams) and diversity=5.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0509024_light_bino_nmssm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509024", "source_line": 511, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 93, "global_rank": 3021, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Light bino-like neutralino dark matter in the NMSSM is a speculative uv complete card with either relic-density treatment; it touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_3761_global_b_l_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1312_3761", "source_line": 2030, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 120, "global_rank": 3022, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_05672_nonthermal_cmssm_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1502_05672", "source_line": 2444, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 94, "global_rank": 3023, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is nonthermal; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_09129_bl_wino_like_triplet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_09129", "source_line": 2711, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3024, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium BBN relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: BBN, collider.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07894_gauged_two_loop_z3_model_i_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07894", "source_line": 2741, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3025, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB, direct detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_3727_o_gauge_simp_pion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_3727", "source_line": 2374, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 88, "global_rank": 3026, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal SIMP 3-to-2 freeze-out within the hidden sector production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: small-scale structure.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for rare production mechanism: thermal SIMP 3-to-2 freeze-out within the hidden sector; composite candidate; multi-component candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_3727_sp_gauge_simp_pion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_3727", "source_line": 2372, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 89, "global_rank": 3027, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal SIMP 3-to-2 freeze-out within the hidden sector production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: small-scale structure.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for rare production mechanism: thermal SIMP 3-to-2 freeze-out within the hidden sector; composite candidate; multi-component candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_3727_su_gauge_simp_pion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_3727", "source_line": 2373, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 90, "global_rank": 3028, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal SIMP 3-to-2 freeze-out within the hidden sector production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: small-scale structure.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for rare production mechanism: thermal SIMP 3-to-2 freeze-out within the hidden sector; composite candidate; multi-component candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_13224_inverse_seesaw_scalar_higgs_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_13224", "source_line": 3863, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3029, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A scalar-Higgs portal dark-matter model linking a fermionic dark sector to an inverse-seesaw neutrino sector through an electroweak singlet scalar.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: thermal relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN unknown; CMB low; phase-space thermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_03645_scotogenic_inert_doublet_inflaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_03645", "source_line": 3638, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3030, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative scalar_wimp_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0009089_baryonic_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0009089", "source_line": 384, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 3031, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative uv_complete model; production via Affleck-Dine baryogenesis condensate fragmentation; first-order phase transition or charge accretion possible; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: compact objects/dynamics, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_absorption_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10861_neutral_current_fermionic_absorption_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10861", "source_line": 3938, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3032, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative fermionic_absorption_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_5431_interfering_composite_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1105_5431", "source_line": 1276, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3033, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 13 for Interfering composite asymmetric dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal; probe hints: direct detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wrapped_brane_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_2495_wrapped_brane_gas_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0907_2495", "source_line": 980, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3034, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative wrapped_brane_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and unknown full-density capability.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase-space history; probe classes: compact-object/dynamical probes.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_13520_resonant_dark_photon_heating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_13520", "source_line": 5219, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3035, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 3.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include simplified model construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, field like phase-space behavior, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_06217_dark_photon_nuclear_bound_state_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_06217", "source_line": 4898, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 218, "global_rank": 3036, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: nonthermal phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0512303_flipped_su5_crypton_decay_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0512303", "source_line": 628, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3037, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has high diversity value within the population-count context, some computational or code support recorded in the model card, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_05776_cxsm_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_05776", "source_line": 5932, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 121, "global_rank": 3038, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Complex singlet scalar model with singlet fermion dark matter is a speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, none small-scale-power information, and no explicit routed probe class from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 13, observational leverage 2, complementarity 0, feasibility 1, provenance 9, diversity 0.0, penalties 12; raw score 13.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_5257_higgs_portal_singlet_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_5257", "source_line": 2057, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3039, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of singlet_vector_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; partial associated computational tool support; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "stable_higgs_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_3129_gauge_higgs_unification_stable_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "1003_3129", "source_line": 1106, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3040, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in stable_higgs_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_topological_defect_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_0099_invisible_monopole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1011_0099", "source_line": 1259, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3041, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 13 for Invisible monopole dark matter from hidden SU(2) breaking: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_2869_supersymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_force_v1", "paper_id": "1109_2869", "source_line": 1465, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 219, "global_rank": 3042, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable hidden_sector_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out/annihilation computed numerically.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_1262_inverse_seesaw_singlet_sneutrino_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0907_1262", "source_line": 1013, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 3043, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 13 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_04019_asymmetric_fermion_higgs_portal_pulsar_collapse_v1", "paper_id": "1504_04019", "source_line": 2423, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 3044, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a asymmetric_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, compact objects / dynamics, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_wimp", "model_id": "2309_00374_fermion_singlet_higgs_portal_heavy_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "2309_00374", "source_line": 5830, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3045, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out of the WIMP through Higgs-portal and heavy-neutrino annihilation channels.", "Follow-up value comes from direct/collider, indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_electroweak_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_07197_singlet_doublet_triplet_majorana_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1504_07197", "source_line": 2482, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3046, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=mixed_electroweak_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=medium.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=1, diversity_value=4.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "A light fermion dark matter scenario coupled to a singlet scalar that mixes with Higgs bosons; scalar exchange accounts for elastic scattering and can yield the desired thermal abundance, while gamma rays require an additional annihilation channel.", "model_id": "1011_1499_higgs_mixed_scalar_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1011_1499", "source_line": 1256, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3047, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 13 for Fermion dark matter with Higgs-mixed singlet scalar mediator: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is medium; probe hints: CMB, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_5058_sommerfeld_resonant_heavy_wino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1009_5058", "source_line": 1260, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3048, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 13 for Sommerfeld-resonant heavy wino LSP dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from distribution function availability is approximate; probe hints: direct detection, indirect detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_multicomponent_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_6568_vectorlike_fermion_n_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1307_6568", "source_line": 1816, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3049, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative decaying_multicomponent_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal; CMB relevance is medium.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on CMB, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_multicomponent_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_6568_vectorlike_scalar_n_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1307_6568", "source_line": 1817, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3050, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative decaying_multicomponent_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal; CMB relevance is medium.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on CMB, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_2075_z2_odd_radiative_neutrino_mass_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1105_2075", "source_line": 1270, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3051, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 50.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 13 for Model II radiative neutrino mass model with Z2-odd inert scalar dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is medium; probe hints: CMB, collider.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0610077_heavy_wino_lsp_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0610077", "source_line": 645, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3052, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some computational or code support recorded in the model card, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "2003_13146_darkon_noether_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "2003_13146", "source_line": 4247, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3053, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include larger-framework connection; the card says it can produce all dark matter; explicit probe classes from card fields: CMB.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_07316_hidden_sector_tower_scalar_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2205_07316", "source_line": 5172, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 220, "global_rank": 3054, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: multi-component hidden-sector tower has Boltzmann-temperature evolution, but stability, UV completion, and observational routing remain too incomplete for high priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0803_0253_constrained_nmssm_singlino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0803_0253", "source_line": 776, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes"], "family_rank": 95, "global_rank": 3055, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 13.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance medium; probe classes counted: ['CMB'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_5122_qyu_neutralino_dm_case_i_v1", "paper_id": "1105_5122", "source_line": 1310, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 96, "global_rank": 3056, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vectorlike_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_07263_vectorlike_neutrino_pseudoscalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1603_07263", "source_line": 2801, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3057, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked yes.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_11919_soft_su2_pseudo_ng_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_11919", "source_line": 5155, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 221, "global_rank": 3058, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: complete hidden-sector pNG thermal relic with clear assumptions, yet it is observationally CDM-like in the supplied fields and has no extracted probe routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_13013_conversion_driven_fermionic_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_13013", "source_line": 5443, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Partial MadDM/micrOMEGAs/SARAH context helps, but missing observables, constraints, and routing keep priority low."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 3059, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but feasible: conversion-driven scotogenic dark matter is UV-complete and neutrino-motivated with partial computational support, but supplied observable routing is absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_12242_inverse_seesaw_3loop_z4_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_12242", "source_line": 6063, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 3060, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 13.0: speculative uv complete model in scotogenic_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: laboratory flavor; phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_02891_triplet_fermion_singlet_scalar_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_02891", "source_line": 2546, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3061, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Electroweak triplet fermion dark matter with singlet scalar portal: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; population counts make it a relatively distinctive registry representative; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 13.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_7708_supersymmetric_partially_interacting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1405_7708", "source_line": 2201, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 122, "global_rank": 3062, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete multi_component_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching BBN.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9605325_uniton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9605325", "source_line": 6116, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3063, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13 (defer) from supplied card content: strongly_interacting_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_4186_f_su5_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1003_4186", "source_line": 1130, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 97, "global_rank": 3064, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_3963_dark_light_higgs_singlino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1009_3963", "source_line": 1150, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3065, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in supersymmetric_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_06475_light_scalar_dm_intermediate_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1503_06475", "source_line": 2407, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3066, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a light_scalar_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_2729_soft_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0912_2729", "source_line": 1032, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 3067, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 13 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter, theory level uv_complete, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vectorized_lepton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_08896_vectorized_lepton_portal_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1705_08896", "source_line": 3169, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3068, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 13.0: Vectorized lepton portal fermion dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with standard thermal freeze-out of chi_1.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0911_2939_e6_secluded_u1_neutralino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "0911_2939", "source_line": 1035, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 98, "global_rank": 3069, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 13 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, theory level uv_complete, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_leptophilic_or_quarkphilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_03382_dirac_dark_matter_charged_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1503_03382", "source_line": 2445, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3070, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a simplified_leptophilic_or_quarkphilic_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, direct detection, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_3569_ewimp_doublet_yneg_half_higgs_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1410_3569", "source_line": 2241, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3071, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative electroweak_interacting_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_3569_ewimp_triplet_y0_higgs_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1410_3569", "source_line": 2239, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3072, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative electroweak_interacting_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_3569_ewimp_triplet_yneg1_higgs_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1410_3569", "source_line": 2240, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3073, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative electroweak_interacting_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_00009_semi_visible_hidden_valley_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1503_00009", "source_line": 2413, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 222, "global_rank": 3074, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a hidden_sector_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_1162_su2n_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1409_1162", "source_line": 2292, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 223, "global_rank": 3075, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_7606_cocktail_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1410_7606", "source_line": 2267, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 3076, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_14519_type_ii_2hdm_s_singlet_scalar_fopt_dilution_v1", "paper_id": "2207_14519", "source_line": 5317, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3077, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 13.0: singlet_scalar_dark_matter with thermal freeze-out before or during electroweak FOPT; science=11.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=8.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_14519_xsm_singlet_scalar_fopt_dilution_v1", "paper_id": "2207_14519", "source_line": 5316, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3078, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 13.0: singlet_scalar_dark_matter with thermal freeze-out followed by possible entropy dilution from electroweak first-order phase transition; science=11.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=8.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection) and diversity=4.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_b_minus_l_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_08606_dynamical_inverse_seesaw_dirac_dark_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1707_08606", "source_line": 3196, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3079, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 13.0: Dynamical inverse-seesaw Dirac dark fermion with elusive Z' is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out through Z'-mediated annihilation to Standard Model fermions.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_2582_on_scalar_singlet_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_2582", "source_line": 1463, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 3080, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable scalar_singlet_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal annihilation into SM particles.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "running_coupling_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_8034_asymptotically_safe_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1412_8034", "source_line": 2315, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3081, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 13 because the assigned model card simplified model running_coupling_thermal_dark_matter card; touches direct detection, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_6679_syndetic_z2_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1411_6679", "source_line": 2303, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3082, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 13 because the assigned model card uv complete scotogenic_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, gravitational waves.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_05479_supersymmetric_higgs_portal_dirac_singlino_v1", "paper_id": "1501_05479", "source_line": 2384, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 3083, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out, co-annihilation with Higgsinos production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_06421_complex_singlet_dark_phase_v1", "paper_id": "1504_06421", "source_line": 2380, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 3084, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal Higgs-portal production inferred from use of relic-density computation with micrOMEGAS production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_annihilation_spectral_feature_model", "model_id": "1405_6921_majorana_charged_gauge_boson_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1405_6921", "source_line": 2211, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3085, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative wimp_annihilation_spectral_feature_model card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_annihilation_spectral_feature_model", "model_id": "1405_6921_majorana_charged_scalar_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1405_6921", "source_line": 2210, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3086, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative wimp_annihilation_spectral_feature_model card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_annihilation_spectral_feature_model", "model_id": "1405_6921_real_scalar_vector_like_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1405_6921", "source_line": 2212, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3087, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative wimp_annihilation_spectral_feature_model card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_8664_three_loop_global_u1_bosonic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_8664", "source_line": 2368, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 3088, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and stable scalar relic abundance through the model's scalar interactions production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_3276_dirac_right_handed_sneutrino_neutrinophilic_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "1205_3276", "source_line": 1582, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3089, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card connects a UV sneutrino candidate to neutrinophilic Higgs physics and thermal freeze-out, but the observational-extension fields are otherwise sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_6416_discrete_gauge_darkon_b_l_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1205_6416", "source_line": 1590, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 224, "global_rank": 3090, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card provides a UV discrete-gauge B-L scalar WIMP with explicit freeze-out/coannihilation logic, but no observational routes, constraints, or code are included."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9804378_superconducting_string_vorton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9804378", "source_line": 6142, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3091, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 13 (defer) from supplied card content: topological_relic_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavor_violating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_0623_flavor_violating_colored_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_0623", "source_line": 1384, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3092, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as flavor_violating_dark_matter: production is represented by collider production through flavor-violating colored mediator exchange; phase-space is unknown; inferred probe coverage includes collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_2666_gauged_baryon_number_vector_model_i_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_2666", "source_line": 1379, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 3093, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as asymmetric_dark_matter: production is represented by asymmetric production through Affleck-Dine dynamics; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_2666_gauged_baryon_number_vector_model_ii_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_2666", "source_line": 1380, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 77, "global_rank": 3094, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as asymmetric_dark_matter: production is represented by asymmetric production through Affleck-Dine dynamics; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "z_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_2985_generalized_z_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1411_2985", "source_line": 2309, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3095, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 13 because the assigned model card effective field theory z_portal_dark_matter card; touches indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_03700_radiative_inert_doublet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1501_03700", "source_line": 2312, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 3096, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 13 because the assigned model card uv complete inert_doublet_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_04784_scale_invariant_u1_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_04784", "source_line": 5388, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 225, "global_rank": 3097, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Classically scale-invariant U(1) dark-sector fermion dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: collider."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_wimp", "model_id": "1711_02110_2hdm_pseudoscalar_mediator_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1711_02110", "source_line": 3331, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3098, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_5499_strongly_interacting_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0909_5499", "source_line": 982, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 78, "global_rank": 3099, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modular_flavor_majorana_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_05674_modular_a4_tau_omega_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_05674", "source_line": 4883, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3100, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: rare family in population context (count 2).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_00588_fourth_family_fermiophobic_u1_dark_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2110_00588", "source_line": 4860, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3101, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: rare family in population context (count 4).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_13219_modular_a4_dirac_radiative_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2003_13219", "source_line": 4201, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3102, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_00884_spin1_triplet_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_00884", "source_line": 4220, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 3103, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include structure or tension connection; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_11434_d4_scotogenic_majorana_n3_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2003_11434", "source_line": 4216, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 13, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3104, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 13, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "elastically_decoupling_thermal_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_04545_elastically_decoupling_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1512_04545", "source_line": 2726, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3105, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: BBN, CMB.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_00341_fat_brane_scalar_dm_bl_vector_v1", "paper_id": "1911_00341", "source_line": 4008, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 226, "global_rank": 3106, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.3, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative simplified_model; rank-relevant evidence includes limited explicit observational handles in the supplied card.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_02279_large_charge_ksvz_ultralight_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_02279", "source_line": 4407, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 3107, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes axion field misalignment or other axion population mechanism consistent with CDM-like redshifting.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space structure, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_0527_late_decaying_dark_matter_recoil_v1", "paper_id": "1406_0527", "source_line": 2192, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 3108, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, phenomenological_parameterization theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with decay_produced phase-space entry, approximate distribution-function support, suppression small-scale-power effect, and step_like transfer-function shape.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sexaquark_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_03972_sexaquark_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2403_03972", "source_line": 5997, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3109, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from sexaquark_dark_matter: Sexaquark dark matter has high diversity value through QCD-era thermal equilibrium and freeze-out, possible asymmetric baryon-number storage in sexaquarks, survival or annihilation of antisexaquark relics; inferred probe classes are BBN, CMB.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_08426_wgc_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_08426", "source_line": 3815, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 156, "global_rank": 3110, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as Higgs-portal freeze-in, Higgs decays h -> phi phi* for m_phi < m_h/2.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_coupled_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_03692_complex_scalar_neutrino_dm_dirac_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1705_03692", "source_line": 3111, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3111, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of neutrino_coupled_scalar_dark_matter with raw score 12.5.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 2.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_coupled_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_03692_real_scalar_neutrino_dm_dirac_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1705_03692", "source_line": 3112, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3112, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 49.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of neutrino_coupled_scalar_dark_matter with raw score 12.5.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance, non-CDM structure-formation fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 2.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1810_12608_critical_higgs_inflation_planck_relic_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_12608", "source_line": 64, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 163, "global_rank": 3113, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this primordial_black_holes card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "1406_7297_binned_interacting_vacuum_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_7297", "source_line": 55, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3114, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this interacting_dark_sector card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "1406_7297_q34_late_time_interacting_vacuum_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_7297", "source_line": 56, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3115, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this interacting_dark_sector card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_07948_classic_window_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2107_07948", "source_line": 4809, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 220, "global_rank": 3116, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, field like phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_3183_scotogenic_scalar_triplet_u1d_v1", "paper_id": "1310_3183", "source_line": 1968, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3117, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_3183_scotogenic_scalar_triplet_z2_v1", "paper_id": "1310_3183", "source_line": 1967, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3118, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_1668_pseudo_dirac_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_1668", "source_line": 742, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3119, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked yes; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_1668_real_non_chiral_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_1668", "source_line": 741, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3120, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked yes; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_baryon_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_3725_mirror_baryon_asymmetric_dm_nn_oscillation_v1", "paper_id": "1109_3725", "source_line": 1405, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3121, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 12.5 because the card describes mirror baryon asymmetric dark matter at effective field theory level, with asymmetric dark matter genesis from B-L and CP violating ordinary-mirror interactions; primordial baryogenesis in both ordinary and mirror sectors and high BBN relevance, high CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_4276_warm_inflation_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1208_4276", "source_line": 1632, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 3122, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization card for Thermally produced gravitino dark matter in supersymmetric warm inflation; it offers CMB/BBN relevance with BBN, CMB, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2006_16641_modified_supergravity_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_16641", "source_line": 99, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 164, "global_rank": 3123, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this primordial_black_holes card is viable enough to score, with uv_complete theory support and high CMB relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_4866_secluded_composite_hidden_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "0711_4866", "source_line": 751, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 227, "global_rank": 3124, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 12.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance high, CMB relevance medium; probe classes counted: ['BBN', 'CMB'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_03430_light_chiral_dark_pion_v1", "paper_id": "1603_03430", "source_line": 2736, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 228, "global_rank": 3125, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves a card-local full-dark-matter production route, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: BBN, CMB.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07828_xyb_heavy_b_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07828", "source_line": 2746, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3126, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves a card-local full-dark-matter production route, partial collider_simulation support.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: collider.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_4524_type_iii_gmsb_gravitino_cdm_3x24_v1", "paper_id": "0807_4524", "source_line": 799, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 3127, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 12.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance medium, phase-space type nonthermal; probe classes counted: ['BBN'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_09350_critical_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_09350", "source_line": 3273, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 3128, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs portal scalar dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from high CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching CMB, direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 12.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_05115_alternative_b_l_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1711_05115", "source_line": 3285, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3129, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative seesaw dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, CMB.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 12.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_0084_decaying_wino_lle_pgm_v1", "paper_id": "1305_0084", "source_line": 1818, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3130, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative decaying_wino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is mixed_cold_warm.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on no explicit probe class in observables, constraints, or routing fields and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_1334_susy_u1x_cogenesis_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1312_1334", "source_line": 2017, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 79, "global_rank": 3131, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=nonthermal, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_magnetic_inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_4200_dark_magnetic_inelastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1007_4200", "source_line": 1161, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3132, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 12.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, distinctive or underrepresented model-space coverage, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_04201_inert_doublet_blind_spot_fopt_v1", "paper_id": "1704_04201", "source_line": 3179, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3133, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 12.5: Inert doublet blind-spot scalar dark matter with first-order phase transition is a speculative simplified model entry with thermal freeze-out of the inert scalar through electroweak and Higgs-mediated channels.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: direct detection, gravitational waves, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_04201_mixed_singlet_triplet_blind_spot_v1", "paper_id": "1704_04201", "source_line": 3181, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3134, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 12.5: Mixed singlet-triplet blind-spot scalar dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with thermal freeze-out of a mixed singlet-triplet scalar through electroweak annihilation.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection, gravitational waves.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_00395_semi_annihilating_boosted_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2309_00395", "source_line": 5837, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3135, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; the main production handle is thermal relic abundance set by semi-annihilation.", "Follow-up value comes from indirect detection, neutrino/indirect, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_07980_neutrinophilic_u1x_singlet_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_07980", "source_line": 4831, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 229, "global_rank": 3136, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_06151_ad_leptogenesis_wimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_06151", "source_line": 5033, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3137, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Affleck-Dine leptogenesis WIMP dark matter model has probe classes: CMB, laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_01911_mssm_bino_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1706_01911", "source_line": 3186, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3138, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 15.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 12.5: MSSM bino-stop co-annihilation scenario is a benchmark uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out with stop co-annihilation.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_b_l_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00874_b_l_scalar_dm_rh_neutrino_inverse_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00874", "source_line": 3189, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3139, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 12.5: U(1) B-L scalar dark matter with right-handed-neutrino inverse-decay effects is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out with annihilation to right-handed neutrinos.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_2527_nmssm_right_sneutrino_resonant_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1401_2527", "source_line": 2022, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3140, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=yes and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "excited_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_4327_su2_excited_dark_matter_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "0901_4327", "source_line": 899, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3141, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_5153_singlet_portal_hidden_sector_h_prime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_5153", "source_line": 1169, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 230, "global_rank": 3142, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 12.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_08873_majorana_lrsm_x_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_08873", "source_line": 4636, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 231, "global_rank": 3143, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_12122_yukawa_unified_nhssm_bino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2101_12122", "source_line": 4613, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 99, "global_rank": 3144, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative supersymmetric neutralino dark matter entry with uv_complete theory level and relic support marked yes; strong card-local scientific motivation; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_3274_light_chargino_neutralino_mssm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1305_3274", "source_line": 1837, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 100, "global_rank": 3145, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a benchmark supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter model with benchmark_mapping theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on direct detection, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_05755_accidental_z2_septuplet_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_05755", "source_line": 2419, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 3146, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked yes; implicit probe coverage includes galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2205_00603_starobinsky_fr_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_00603", "source_line": 110, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 165, "global_rank": 3147, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and high CMB relevance, enhancement small-scale-power effect, enhanced small scale power transfer behavior, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_02276_post_inflation_axion_minihalo_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_02276", "source_line": 4334, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 221, "global_rank": 3148, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Post-inflationary axion dark matter with minihalo isocurvature fluctuations as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via post-inflationary PQ symmetry breaking.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=unknown; phase-space type field_like; structure-formation entries transfer=enhanced_small_scale_power and small-scale effect=enhancement.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0703624_scalar_phase_transition_white_noise_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0703624", "source_line": 669, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 3149, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: some cosmology or phase-space leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_05280_hybrid_condensate_particle_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_05280", "source_line": 177, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 3150, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 12.0 for scalar_field_dark_matter: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, field_like phase-space behavior, oscillatory transfer-function behavior, mixed in small-scale power, diversity credit from distinctive card fields, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_07792_scalar_field_wave_excited_halo_v1", "paper_id": "2004_07792", "source_line": 90, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 3151, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and suppression in small-scale power, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior, field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_08168_two_component_decaying_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1602_08168", "source_line": 225, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 132, "global_rank": 3152, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=low, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=smooth_cutoff, small_scale_power_effect=suppression, and probe classes: indirect detection, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: line_origin."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_10464_ulap_oscillon_component_v1", "paper_id": "2112_10464", "source_line": 4952, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 222, "global_rank": 3153, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion like dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and early-universe ULAP field oscillation.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by field like phase space, mixed small-scale power, enhanced small scale power transfer-function shape; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by partial associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_2705_unsterile_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1004_2705", "source_line": 1077, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 133, "global_rank": 3154, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative effective_field_theory sterile_neutrino_dark_matter; structure signal (suppression, smooth_cutoff); nonthermal phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0006074_kinetic_equilibrium_phase_space_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0006074", "source_line": 412, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 3155, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_06067_effective_range_self_interacting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_06067", "source_line": 3976, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 91, "global_rank": 3156, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Effective-range self-interacting dark matter parametrization: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are galaxy satellites.", "Score 12 (defer) uses production=generic SIDM production is not fixed by the effective-range parametrization; SIMP thermal freeze-out through 3 to 2 transitions is discussed as one strongly coupled realization; phase=unknown; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=cdm_like, small_scale=none; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_4500_decay_regenerated_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1402_4500", "source_line": 2084, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 80, "global_rank": 3157, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of asymmetric_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; some structure-formation leverage; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support; large sparsity penalties from missing observational-extension fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_07209_u1_3_4_vectorlike_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "2303_07209", "source_line": 5550, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation.", "The card is still scorable and not globally eliminated, but current follow-up value is low from supplied fields."], "family_rank": 101, "global_rank": 3158, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score because the card provides some cross-probe reach.", "Main limitations are missing explicit observables, constraint payloads, observable-routing entries, and computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0306020_decaying_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0306020", "source_line": 440, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 3159, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: cmb, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_13212_degenerate_mirror_asymmetric_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "2211_13212", "source_line": 5408, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Incomplete relic model status plus missing observables, constraints, routing, and code reduce current extension value."], "family_rank": 232, "global_rank": 3160, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: mirror asymmetric reheating is distinctive and touches CMB/BBN through nonthermal thermal-history effects, but the card says it is not a complete single-candidate relic model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2305_03313_superheavy_proton_like_virtual_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_03313", "source_line": 5597, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3161, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the superheavy proton-like virtual-black-hole model is rare, but it is theoretically fragile, not the preferred variant in the card, and lacks observational-detail support.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_4462_top_flavored_sfdm_v1", "paper_id": "1309_4462", "source_line": 1961, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3162, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1906_09930_planck_relic_trans_planckian_scattering_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_09930", "source_line": 3884, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support."], "family_rank": 166, "global_rank": 3163, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / phenomenological_parameterization: A dark matter scenario where trans-Planckian particle collisions after high-scale reheating produce microscopic black holes that evaporate to stable Planck-mass relics.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: phenomenological relic treatment, full_dark_matter, production reach parameter_dependent; BBN low; CMB low; phase-space nonthermal; transfer function cdm_like; small-scale power none.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: stable_relic_assumption_critical."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_04743_higgs_portal_stronger_coupling_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2402_04743", "source_line": 5983, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 157, "global_rank": 3164, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from freeze_in_dark_matter: Higgs-portal scalar freeze-in at stronger coupling has moderate model/theory value through Boltzmann-suppressed freeze-in from SM thermal bath, Higgs and vector boson pair annihilation h_i h_i -> s s, nonstandard reheating through inflaton decay to right-handed neutrinos followed by N_R decay to SM states; inferred probe classes are indirect_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phenomenological_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_08102_evolving_dark_matter_late_time_eos_v1", "paper_id": "2209_08102", "source_line": 261, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3165, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Evolving dark matter with late-time negative equation of state, a speculative phenomenological dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, scale dependent growth transfer behavior.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: 2209_effective_not_microphysical."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_07209_two_scalar_boosted_mev_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2012_07209", "source_line": 4496, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3166, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for boosted_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from mixed_cold_warm phase-space history, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 12.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_04693_so10_scalar_singlet_asymmetric_cogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1611_04693", "source_line": 2964, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 81, "global_rank": 3167, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inflaton_dark_matter_unification", "model_id": "1811_05493_warm_little_inflaton_cold_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_05493", "source_line": 3672, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3168, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative inflaton_dark_matter_unification with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes; high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; field_like phase-space behavior; high model-card diversity value from population-count rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_07037_plateau_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1807_07037", "source_line": 3560, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 223, "global_rank": 3169, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with phenomenological-parameterization theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has field-like phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_00036_z2_scotogenic_proton_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_00036", "source_line": 3813, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 3170, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, pair annihilation to leptons.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_00027_dsnb_boosted_leptophilic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_00027", "source_line": 4653, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3171, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and relic production unknown; medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_0015_axion_cdm_kination_v1", "paper_id": "0912_0015", "source_line": 1065, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 224, "global_rank": 3172, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative phenomenological_parameterization axion_like_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (BBN high); field_like phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_0015_axion_cdm_low_temperature_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "0912_0015", "source_line": 1064, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 225, "global_rank": 3173, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 48.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative phenomenological_parameterization axion_like_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (BBN high); field_like phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_07035_weakly_interacting_continuum_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_07035", "source_line": 4732, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 233, "global_rank": 3174, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and production via thermal freeze-out through continuum annihilation to Standard Model states; generalized Boltzmann evolution over continuum masses.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB; the raw score is 12 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_00210_light_scalar_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_00210", "source_line": 4587, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 123, "global_rank": 3175, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from phase-space type is mixed_cold_warm.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_00791_one_loop_scalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_00791", "source_line": 2881, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 3176, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production.", "Score limited by penalties from sparse observables, constraints, and routing; associated code is marked partial."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_06218_chiral_u1x_fermion_n_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_06218", "source_line": 2900, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 234, "global_rank": 3177, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production.", "Score limited by penalties from sparse observables, constraints, and routing; associated code is marked partial."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_06218_chiral_u1x_scalar_x_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_06218", "source_line": 2899, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 235, "global_rank": 3178, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production.", "Score limited by penalties from sparse observables, constraints, and routing; associated code is marked partial."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_09385_holographic_composite_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1911_09385", "source_line": 4141, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 226, "global_rank": 3179, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 12: speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: field_like phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: no explicit probe routing objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_3138_gravity_mediation_lsp_qball_v1", "paper_id": "1404_3138", "source_line": 2079, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 3180, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of supersymmetric_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_3138_gravity_mediation_nonthermal_lsp_no_qball_v1", "paper_id": "1404_3138", "source_line": 2078, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 3181, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of supersymmetric_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_02949_electroweak_kk_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1702_02949", "source_line": 3062, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3182, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative kaluza_klein_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1806_05390_quasi_inflection_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1806_05390", "source_line": 3559, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 167, "global_rank": 3183, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological-parameterization theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_05774_singlet_scalar_neutral_vlf_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_05774", "source_line": 2774, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 236, "global_rank": 3184, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through scalar-mediated self-annihilation into Standard Model final states; portals: higgs, other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0301237_oscillating_bd_radion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0301237", "source_line": 428, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 3185, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: bbn, cmb.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_09106_massive_dark_photon_two_component_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_09106", "source_line": 3606, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 124, "global_rank": 3186, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative multi_component_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_0691_gev_matter_dark_higgsino_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "1004_0691", "source_line": 1090, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 125, "global_rank": 3187, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model multi_component_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium, BBN medium); mixed_cold_warm phase-space/production behavior.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_00725_scalar_singlet_gravity_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1611_00725", "source_line": 2960, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3188, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravity_portal_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_remnant_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0112107_pbh_planck_remnant_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0112107", "source_line": 425, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3189, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: bbn, compact objects.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1710_02865_vacuum_bubble_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "1710_02865", "source_line": 43, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 168, "global_rank": 3190, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, nonthermal phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_01847_littlest_seesaw_neutrino_gravity_portal_fimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_01847", "source_line": 4372, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 158, "global_rank": 3191, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Littlest Seesaw neutrino-gravity portal FIMP dark matter: freeze-in via right-handed-neutrino portal; some cosmological or phase-space leverage; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "active_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_00716_sm_lgt_active_neutrino_bcs_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_00716", "source_line": 47, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3192, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative uv_complete model, medium CMB relevance, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dirac_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11950_dirac_z3_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11950", "source_line": 4059, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 12 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3193, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative scotogenic_dirac_neutrino_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'unknown'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'unknown', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_00804_mixed_wino_higgsino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_00804", "source_line": 2984, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 102, "global_rank": 3194, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_2368_gravitino_split_susy_brpv_v1", "paper_id": "1406_2368", "source_line": 2220, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 3195, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative gravitino_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching BBN.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_00119_sterile_neutrino_smeft_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2405_00119", "source_line": 6060, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 134, "global_rank": 3196, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 12.0: speculative effective field theory model in sterile_neutrino_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: indirect detection; phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_3693_zprime_mediated_wino_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0801_3693", "source_line": 790, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3197, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 12.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance high, phase-space type mixed_cold_warm; probe classes counted: ['BBN'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_08227_gravitino_gaugino_mediation_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_08227", "source_line": 2835, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 3198, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from BBN relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_06830_axion_fr_gravity_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2001_06830", "source_line": 324, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 227, "global_rank": 3199, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, phase-space type is field_like.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:modified_gravity_context.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 10/4/2/0/9/2/15."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_12585_hidden_photon_alp_messenger_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_12585", "source_line": 4379, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3200, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Z2-stabilized hidden photon dark matter with an ALP messenger: misalignment; some cosmological or phase-space leverage, good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes CMB.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_pseudo_dirac_bino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0708_3970_pseudo_dirac_bino_v1", "paper_id": "0708_3970", "source_line": 710, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3201, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_03415_gravitational_scalar_singlet_reheating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_03415", "source_line": 3224, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 237, "global_rank": 3202, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Gravitationally produced non-minimally coupled scalar singlet dark matter is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, CMB/BBN relevance high/unknown, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_07153_dbrane_disformal_thermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_07153", "source_line": 3235, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 238, "global_rank": 3203, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: D-brane disformal thermal dark matter model is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with CMB/BBN relevance medium/critical, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_05788_flavor_u1_radiative_seesaw_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_05788", "source_line": 3089, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3204, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative_seesaw_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phenomenological_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_08330_soft_dark_energy_and_dark_matter_lcdm_extension_v1", "paper_id": "2112_08330", "source_line": 34, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3205, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, some computational or code support, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phenomenological_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_08330_soft_dark_matter_lcdm_extension_v1", "paper_id": "2112_08330", "source_line": 35, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3206, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, some computational or code support, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_05956_three_component_simp_z2_z3_v1", "paper_id": "2103_05956", "source_line": 4563, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 126, "global_rank": 3207, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=medium and BBN=medium.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_05956_two_component_simp_z2_z3_v1", "paper_id": "2103_05956", "source_line": 4562, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 127, "global_rank": 3208, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=medium and BBN=medium.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0302080_varying_mass_cold_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0302080", "source_line": 433, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3209, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value; probe signal: cmb, small-scale structure.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_2411_black_hole_universe_dark_matter_lattice_v1", "paper_id": "1204_2411", "source_line": 28, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3210, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 10, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, nonthermal phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_1001_so10_pq_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1305_1001", "source_line": 1876, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 228, "global_rank": 3211, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with asymmetric/baryogenesis, axion/field production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, field-like phase-space behavior.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_kinetic_mixing_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_4447_rg_focused_u1x_resonant_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1309_4447", "source_line": 1910, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3212, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 12.0 because the model card is a speculative hidden_sector_kinetic_mixing_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_kinetic_mixing_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_4447_rg_focused_u1x_threshold_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1309_4447", "source_line": 1909, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3213, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 12.0 because the model card is a speculative hidden_sector_kinetic_mixing_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector_scalar_field", "model_id": "0706_3667_affine_k_essence_unified_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "0706_3667", "source_line": 308, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3214, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, phase-space type is field_like.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:phenomenological_density_only, medium:sound_speed_tuning.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/3/2/0/9/5/14."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_07518_gauged_2hdm_dfsz_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2106_07518", "source_line": 4709, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 229, "global_rank": 3215, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via vacuum realignment mechanism.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB; the raw score is 12 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_00207_dark_so10_composite_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_00207", "source_line": 3933, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 239, "global_rank": 3216, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_04892_polarized_higher_spin_wave_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_04892", "source_line": 4855, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 3217, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from effective_field_theory theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: field_like phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_05048_singlet_doublet_z_mediated_thermal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1611_05048", "source_line": 2991, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3218, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative singlet_doublet_wimp_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_07844_monodromy_alp_fragmentation_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2004_07844", "source_line": 4231, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 230, "global_rank": 3219, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include axion or strong-CP connection, early-universe production connection; field_like phase-space information; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_2524_gravitational_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1109_2524", "source_line": 1350, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3220, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level phase-space type nonthermal.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for gravitational_production_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_1784_decaying_metastable_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1784", "source_line": 1148, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 240, "global_rank": 3221, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in hidden_sector_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_1784_endothermic_metastable_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1784", "source_line": 1147, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 241, "global_rank": 3222, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in hidden_sector_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_1784_exothermic_metastable_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_1784", "source_line": 1146, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 242, "global_rank": 3223, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in hidden_sector_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_07670_massive_singlet_majoron_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1709_07670", "source_line": 3201, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3224, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Massive singlet majoron dark matter is a speculative majoron_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, CMB/BBN relevance medium/low, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2112_00762_hybrid_preheating_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2112_00762", "source_line": 5022, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 169, "global_rank": 3225, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Primordial black holes from axion-coupled hybrid-inflation preheating has probe classes: BBN, CMB, compact objects, gravitational waves, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_13148_inelastic_dissipative_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2309_13148", "source_line": 5826, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card.", "Relic-density follow-up value is reduced because the card does not support a full-DM regime or leaves it unknown."], "family_rank": 92, "global_rank": 3226, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is asymmetric dark-sector relic assumed as a subdominant component.", "Follow-up value comes from compact objects, indirect detection, small-scale structure, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_00670_pbh_cosmic_string_network_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_00670", "source_line": 210, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3227, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_hole_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2401_07523_periodic_derivative_coupling_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_07523", "source_line": 216, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 170, "global_rank": 3228, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical, gravitational waves.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_2582_on_scalar_singlet_fidm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_2582", "source_line": 1464, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3229, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable scalar_singlet_dark_matter variant and records non-equilibrium freeze-in-like production through feeble Higgs-portal processes.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_10314_forbidden_dark_photon_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1807_10314", "source_line": 3613, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 243, "global_rank": 3230, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_10314_inelastic_light_fermion_dark_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "1807_10314", "source_line": 3610, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 244, "global_rank": 3231, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_4696_bmssm_neutralino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0906_4696", "source_line": 991, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 103, "global_rank": 3232, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_05417_baryon_lepton_duplicity_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_05417", "source_line": 3631, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 245, "global_rank": 3233, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_coupled_light_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_6079_mev_scalar_3p1p1_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1306_6079", "source_line": 1842, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3234, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 47.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative sterile_neutrino_coupled_light_scalar_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=unknown, and BBN relevance is high.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on BBN, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_07410_fraternal_twin_baryon_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_07410", "source_line": 2486, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 82, "global_rank": 3235, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=asymmetric_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from phase_space=nonthermal.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=182, diversity_value=4.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_04517_pev_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1606_04517", "source_line": 2815, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 135, "global_rank": 3236, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked yes.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from BBN, CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_mediator_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_04456_lmu_ltau_2hdm_vectorlike_light_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_04456", "source_line": 4683, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3237, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; probe relevance for BBN, CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2104_08654_no_scale_kahler_kinetic_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_08654", "source_line": 4663, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 171, "global_rank": 3238, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; probe relevance for CMB, compact objects.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_quark_matter_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0001284_relic_quark_gluon_plasma_objects_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0001284", "source_line": 404, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3239, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value; probe signal: bbn, compact objects.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_4322_light_dirac_rh_sneutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1305_4322", "source_line": 1815, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 3240, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on direct detection, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "so10_gut_multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_05601_so10_model_iii_triplet_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_05601", "source_line": 3848, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3241, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as thermal WIMP freeze-out, multi-component thermal abundance.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_04137_radiatively_driven_natural_susy_axion_higgsino_v1", "paper_id": "1503_04137", "source_line": 2421, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 128, "global_rank": 3242, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 6, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a multi_component_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; phase-space type is mixed_cold_warm; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sommerfeld_enhanced_wimp", "model_id": "2104_14881_pwave_sommerfeld_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2104_14881", "source_line": 4687, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3243, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and relic production parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; probe relevance for CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_07942_nested_radiative_scotogenic_freezein_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_07942", "source_line": 5154, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 159, "global_rank": 3244, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: UV-complete scotogenic freeze-in model with neutrino/Higgs portals and nonthermal production, but missing routing, constraints, code, and phase-space details limit follow-up value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_07661_extended_so_n_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_07661", "source_line": 5396, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 231, "global_rank": 3245, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Extended SO(N) dynamical-PQ QCD axion dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_goldstino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_1967_uneaten_goldstino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1002_1967", "source_line": 1082, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3246, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative effective_field_theory supersymmetric_goldstino_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (BBN high); above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "compact_ultradense_object_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_4572_bsm_compact_ultradense_object_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_4572", "source_line": 1334, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3247, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level phase-space type nonthermal.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for compact_ultradense_object_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1302_0012_baryogenesis_from_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1302_0012", "source_line": 1807, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 83, "global_rank": 3248, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_06280_neutrino_condensation_sterile_scalar_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_06280", "source_line": 3775, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3249, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 12 because the card identifies production via decaying warm dark matter abundance treated phenomenologically thro..., probe classes: decay or indirect probes; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_08137_s3_two_inert_doublet_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1511_08137", "source_line": 2716, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3250, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves a card-local full-dark-matter production route, high diversity value in the population context.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: direct detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "standard_model_gauge_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_02881_cgf_dark_matter_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "2211_02881", "source_line": 5428, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["No supplied observables, constraints, routes, or code for observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3251, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but distinctive: the standard-model gauge-field dark matter fluid is rare and can produce all dark matter, but supplied observational leverage is limited to field-like behavior."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_04722_minimal_seesaw_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2211_04722", "source_line": 5404, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["The card intentionally omits constraints, observables, and routing, so follow-up value is currently low."], "family_rank": 84, "global_rank": 3252, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scientifically valuable as a UV-complete asymmetric right-handed-neutrino dark matter cogenesis model, but observational leverage is limited to nonthermal production in the supplied fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_06065_vector_dm_time_dependent_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "2111_06065", "source_line": 4889, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 160, "global_rank": 3253, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from effective_field_theory theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: nonthermal phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_10944_alternative_u1_b_l_radiative_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_10944", "source_line": 4577, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3254, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative_freeze_in_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from phase-space type is decay_produced.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_08263_a4_z4_one_zero_scotogenic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_08263", "source_line": 4918, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 3255, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: A4 x Z4 one-zero-texture scotogenic scalar dark matter is speculative with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: no explicit probe class in the model card.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0308118_ad_qball_nonthermal_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0308118", "source_line": 480, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3256, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by decay_produced phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0308118_ad_qball_nonthermal_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0308118", "source_line": 481, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3257, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by decay_produced phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_07735_scotogenic_inverse_seesaw_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_07735", "source_line": 3244, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 136, "global_rank": 3258, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Scotogenic inverse-seesaw sterile-neutrino dark matter is a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_06712_minimal_so10_dfsz_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_06712", "source_line": 2550, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 232, "global_rank": 3259, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Minimal non-supersymmetric SO(10) DFSZ axion dark matter model: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 12.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_02316_asymmetric_dark_matter_nuggets_v1", "paper_id": "1707_02316", "source_line": 3203, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 85, "global_rank": 3260, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Asymmetric dark matter nuggets from darkleosynthesis is a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_04261_supersymmetric_composite_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_04261", "source_line": 3225, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 233, "global_rank": 3261, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Supersymmetric product-group composite QCD axion dark matter is a speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "massive_gravity_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_05003_massive_graviton_condensate_v1", "paper_id": "1707_05003", "source_line": 3237, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3262, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Massive graviton condensate dark matter is a speculative massive_gravity_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_07521_post_inflation_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_07521", "source_line": 3227, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 234, "global_rank": 3263, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Post-inflationary QCD axion dark matter scenario is a canonical axion_like_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "technicolor_techni_dilaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_5326_light_decoupled_techni_dilaton_v1", "paper_id": "1101_5326", "source_line": 1257, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3264, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 12 for Light decoupled techni-dilaton dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from phase space is field_like.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_6364_thdm_d_isospin_violating_darkon_v1", "paper_id": "1112_6364", "source_line": 1471, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 3265, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter variant and records thermal WIMP annihilation through H-mediated diagrams.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_7000_light_bino_higgsino_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_7000", "source_line": 2260, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 104, "global_rank": 3266, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "magnetic_inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_4200_magnetic_inelastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1007_4200", "source_line": 1160, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3267, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 12 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_3075_type_i_seesaw_cmssm_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0909_3075", "source_line": 1045, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 105, "global_rank": 3268, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 12 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, theory level uv_complete, and probe handles: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2112_14588_fermi_ball_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2112_14588", "source_line": 5014, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 172, "global_rank": 3269, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Fermi-ball collapse primordial black hole dark matter has probe classes: BBN, compact objects, gravitational waves, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_3499_scalar_vector_portal_subgev_thermal_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1205_3499", "source_line": 1583, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3270, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card gives a sub-GeV vector-portal thermal relic with CMB relevance and fixed-target-like portal handles, but no explicit routes, constraints, or public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_03884_so10_scalar_quintet_mdm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_03884", "source_line": 4813, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3271, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_6082_yukawa_unified_422_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1203_6082", "source_line": 1569, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 106, "global_rank": 3272, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card records an explicit UV 4-2-2 neutralino scan with relic-compatible mechanisms and CMB relevance, but no observational routing, constraints, or public implementation are supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2008_12456_scalar_force_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2008_12456", "source_line": 4376, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 173, "global_rank": 3273, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Primordial black hole dark matter from scalar-force radiative cooling: thermal heavy-particle abundance followed by freeze-out/asymmetric relic; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes compact-object/dynamics, structure formation.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_5529_inert_doublet_thermal_history_v1", "paper_id": "1105_5529", "source_line": 1271, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 3274, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 12 for Inert Doublet Model thermal history toward the inert phase: status=benchmark, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is medium; probe hints: CMB, laboratory precision.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_15703_light_thermal_sidm_singlet_fermion_assisted_v1", "paper_id": "2211_15703", "source_line": 5420, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Self-interaction interest is not backed by supplied observables, constraints, routing, or code."], "family_rank": 93, "global_rank": 3275, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: light thermal self-interacting dark matter is scientifically useful and can produce all dark matter, but the supplied structure fields are CDM-like and routes are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_mirage_mediation_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0610361_mirage_mediation_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0610361", "source_line": 620, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3276, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has high diversity value within the population-count context, some computational or code support recorded in the model card, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_1165_no_scale_fsu5_bino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_1165", "source_line": 1305, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 107, "global_rank": 3277, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_5122_qyu_neutralino_dm_case_ii_v1", "paper_id": "1105_5122", "source_line": 1311, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 108, "global_rank": 3278, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_triplet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1102_4906_y2_inert_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1102_4906", "source_line": 1303, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3279, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for inert_triplet_scalar_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_02278_cp_violating_singlet_doublet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_02278", "source_line": 3709, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3280, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because CP-violating singlet-doublet fermion dark matter is a emerging simplified model candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, probe relevance for CMB; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimension_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_04985_nested_warped_ued_b1_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1703_04985", "source_line": 3007, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3281, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Nested warped UED B1 dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_triplet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1102_4906_y0_inert_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1102_4906", "source_line": 1302, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3282, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for inert_triplet_scalar_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_04286_alrm_degenerate_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2211_04286", "source_line": 5410, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["No supplied observables, constraints, or routing; only partial computational support is available."], "family_rank": 129, "global_rank": 3283, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: the UV-complete ALRM degenerate scalar candidate has partial code context and CMB relevance, but thermal CDM-like behavior and missing routes limit leverage."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_6921_radiative_lepton_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1401_6921", "source_line": 2024, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3284, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_00599_blssmis_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2207_00599", "source_line": 5212, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 3285, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 7.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, some analytic or public-code feasibility support. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_03185_su2h_u1x_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_03185", "source_line": 4854, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 246, "global_rank": 3286, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_10041_fermionic_higgs_portal_kinetic_decoupling_v1", "paper_id": "2004_10041", "source_line": 4213, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3287, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include phase-transition or confinement connection; the card says it can produce all dark matter.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "little_higgs_t_parity_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_4739_slht_heavy_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0903_4739", "source_line": 935, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3288, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has effective-theory structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, partial code or computational support, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Penalties mainly reflect missing observable mapping, constraints, and routing rather than global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_2204_ussm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0811_2204", "source_line": 851, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3289, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "brane_world_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0806_1516_brane_gravivector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0806_1516", "source_line": 886, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3290, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, effective field theory theory level, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_5651_fermion_higgs_portal_singlet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1005_5651", "source_line": 1199, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 3291, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 12 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_2831_non_abelian_su2d_two_component_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0910_2831", "source_line": 1042, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 130, "global_rank": 3292, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 12 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family multi_component_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_01143_kk_graviton_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_01143", "source_line": 3336, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3293, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_7061_radiative_type_i_seesaw_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1207_7061", "source_line": 1637, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3294, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete card for Radiative type-I seesaw U(1) B-L Dirac dark matter model; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_13373_asymmetric_simp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2207_13373", "source_line": 5306, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 86, "global_rank": 3295, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 46.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 12.0: asymmetric_dark_matter with asymmetric SIMP freeze-out; science=11.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=8.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection, stellar streams) and diversity=3.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_00504_bino_gluino_coannihilation_high_scale_susy_v1", "paper_id": "1504_00504", "source_line": 2422, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3296, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a supersymmetric_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_1452_light_higgsino_dbrane_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_1452", "source_line": 2334, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3297, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 12 because the assigned model card uv complete supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_1482_economical_331_h10_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_1482", "source_line": 1472, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 94, "global_rank": 3298, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable self_interacting_dark_matter variant and records thermal annihilation of H_1^0 through scalar, gauge, and exotic-quark mediated channels.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_8651_gfv_su5_bino_sneutrino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1412_8651", "source_line": 2339, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 109, "global_rank": 3299, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 12 because the assigned model card uv complete supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_1316_complex_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_1316", "source_line": 1494, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3300, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable higgs_portal_scalar_singlet_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out through scalar annihilation.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_5462_exotic_fermion_fiveplet_n10_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_5462", "source_line": 1474, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3301, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter variant and records standard thermal freeze-out of N_1 with electroweak coannihilations.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "quarkophilic_wimp_simplified_model", "model_id": "0907_4511_quarkophilic_majorana_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0907_4511", "source_line": 1023, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3302, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 12 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family quarkophilic_wimp_simplified_model, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_6132_elementary_pgb_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_6132", "source_line": 2375, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 3303, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out through scalar-mediated annihilation production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_07447_gaugino_mediation_neutralino_stau_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1501_07447", "source_line": 2439, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 110, "global_rank": 3304, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_01755_atomic_dark_matter_massive_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1502_01755", "source_line": 2397, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 87, "global_rank": 3305, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and dark particle-antiparticle asymmetry, symmetric component annihilation, and related mechanisms production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for rare production mechanism: dark atom formation in the early universe and halos; composite candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_10096_degenerate_png_complex_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_10096", "source_line": 5632, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the rule.", "The supplied card does not provide enough explicit observable, constraint, routing, or benchmark content for higher-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3306, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension value because rare pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone complex-singlet model, but relic and observable detail are thin.", "Score is held down because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, computational-representation blocks, and benchmark points."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph9909546_lepton_number_violating_sneutrino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9909546", "source_line": 6145, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 3307, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 12 (defer) from supplied card content: supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_2666_gauged_baryon_number_axial_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_2666", "source_line": 1381, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 88, "global_rank": 3308, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as asymmetric_dark_matter: production is represented by asymmetric production through Affleck-Dine dynamics; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_1277_sm3_darkon_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1109_1277", "source_line": 1374, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 3309, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal WIMP freeze-out; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_1277_sm4_darkon_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1109_1277", "source_line": 1375, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 3310, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal WIMP freeze-out; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_twin_baryon_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_03520_minimal_twin_baryon_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_03520", "source_line": 2461, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3311, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=asymmetric_twin_baryon_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=2, diversity_value=6.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_04430_fermi_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2008_04430", "source_line": 4373, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3312, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Fermi-ball dark matter from a first-order phase transition: dark fermion trapping in false-vacuum remnants during a first-order phase transition; good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes compact-object/dynamics, gravitational waves.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "excited_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_1965_abelian_excited_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1204_1965", "source_line": 1599, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3313, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but diverse because the card describes a multi-state Abelian excited-dark-matter construction, while mass splittings, lifetimes, and missing routing add substantial uncertainty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavor_symmetry_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_2874_a4_flavor_z2_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1101_2874", "source_line": 1267, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3314, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 12 for A4 flavor-symmetry scalar dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from probe hints: collider, laboratory precision.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_01215_bouncing_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2210_01215", "source_line": 5323, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3315, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 12.0: thermal_dark_matter with thermal freezeout with bouncing equilibrium abundance; science=10.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=5.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (indirect detection, stellar streams) and diversity=7.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_u1x_right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_13778_leptophilic_u1x_toy_model_i_n2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_13778", "source_line": 4362, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3316, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Leptophilic U(1)_X Toy Model I right-handed-neutrino dark matter: thermal freeze-out; partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_09753_vdm1n_vector_doublet_hnl_v1", "paper_id": "2211_09753", "source_line": 5389, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 3317, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because VDM1N massive vector doublet with one left-handed heavy neutral lepton has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: collider, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_16559_on_degenerate_scalar_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_16559", "source_line": 5427, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Code context helps, but absent observables, constraints, and routing keep extension value low."], "family_rank": 131, "global_rank": 3318, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but feasible: the degenerate scalar triplet has electroweak-WIMP style relevance and associated code context, but the supplied card is CDM-like with no concrete routes or constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_08998_z4_scalar_dm_flavored_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2205_08998", "source_line": 5156, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 3319, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: rare scalar-singlet flavored-mediator construction, but the card has degraded notation, unknown structure behavior, and no observable or constraint objects."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_02846_vector_like_lepton_singlet_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2106_02846", "source_line": 4736, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3320, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative electroweak_fermion_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; co-annihilation with the charged vector-like lepton.", "Card-local leverage comes from collider/fixed-target; the raw score is 12 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_2419_pmssm_2342344_bino_squark_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1305_2419", "source_line": 1744, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 111, "global_rank": 3321, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 3.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 1 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_2419_pmssm_2387564_bino_a_funnel_v1", "paper_id": "1305_2419", "source_line": 1745, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 112, "global_rank": 3322, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 3.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 1 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_2419_pmssm_2750334_well_tempered_bino_higgsino_v1", "paper_id": "1305_2419", "source_line": 1746, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 113, "global_rank": 3323, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 3.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 1 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_2419_pmssm_401479_bino_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1305_2419", "source_line": 1742, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 114, "global_rank": 3324, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 3.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 1 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_00867_natural_susy_so10_neutralino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2005_00867", "source_line": 4232, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 115, "global_rank": 3325, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include larger-framework connection; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_00588_fermiophobic_u1_type_ib_dark_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2110_00588", "source_line": 4859, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3326, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from effective_field_theory theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: rare family in population context (count 4).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2005_03600_scotogenic_3311_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2005_03600", "source_line": 4236, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 3327, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include axion or strong-CP connection, larger-framework connection, neutrino-sector connection; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_2753_y0_inert_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1108_2753", "source_line": 1339, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3328, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for inert_scalar_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_technicolor_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_4839_ew_charged_pngb_timp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1007_4839", "source_line": 1144, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3329, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory entry in composite_technicolor_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_technicolor_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_4839_sm_singlet_pngb_timp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1007_4839", "source_line": 1143, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3330, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory entry in composite_technicolor_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_wimp", "model_id": "1606_01853_right_handed_sneutrino_s331rh_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1606_01853", "source_line": 2843, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3331, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_02969_ads_qcd_hidden_pion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1606_02969", "source_line": 2836, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 247, "global_rank": 3332, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimpless_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_4573_fermion_wimpless_majorana_v1", "paper_id": "1004_4573", "source_line": 1115, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3333, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in wimpless_hidden_sector_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_03224_majorana_charged_mediator_simplified_model_v1", "paper_id": "1605_03224", "source_line": 2820, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 12, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3334, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as benchmark with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 12, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector_phenomenology", "model_id": "1910_05185_dissipative_quintessential_dm_production_v1", "paper_id": "1910_05185", "source_line": 4034, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3335, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.8, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes cosmological relevance.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_11308_higgs_sourced_scalar_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2009_11308", "source_line": 4446, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 161, "global_rank": 3336, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes freeze-in from out-of-equilibrium Higgs decays h -> X X after electroweak symmetry breaking.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase-space structure, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_02279_clockwork_ultralight_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_02279", "source_line": 4411, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 3337, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes axion field misalignment or other axion population mechanism consistent with CDM-like redshifting.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space structure, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_02279_dark_photon_kinetic_mixing_ultralight_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_02279", "source_line": 4409, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 3338, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes axion field misalignment or other axion population mechanism consistent with CDM-like redshifting.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space structure, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_07914_dark_charged_neutron_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1902_07914", "source_line": 3817, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 248, "global_rank": 3339, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as invisible neutron decay inside neutron stars, dark charge separation in degenerate stellar matter.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_07097_higher_derivative_dark_matter_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1512_07097", "source_line": 83, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3340, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this effective_fluid_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression in small-scale power, smooth_cutoff transfer behavior, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_0126_singlet_fermion_two_higgs_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1311_0126", "source_line": 1970, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3341, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: indirect detection, laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_1982_stable_axino_qks_ewimp_v1", "paper_id": "0809_1982", "source_line": 846, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3342, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is medium/high, phase space is nonthermal. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_04558_resonant_sidm_dark_deuteron_v1", "paper_id": "1905_04558", "source_line": 3829, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 95, "global_rank": 3343, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with production listed as thermal decoupling of dark matter followed by dark-deuteron production through three-body recombination.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_09127_low_scale_flavon_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1911_09127", "source_line": 4094, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 11.5 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 116, "global_rank": 3344, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with effective_field_theory structure and relic reach 'parameter_dependent'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'thermal', transfer function 'cdm_like', small-scale effect 'none', and inferred probe classes: none explicit in the card.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_5604_2hdm_portal_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1212_5604", "source_line": 1673, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 3345, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as not specified as a cosmological production mechanism; paper assumes S dark matter for an annihilation-line fit, with unknown phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 11.5 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0802_3377_lepton_number_driven_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0802_3377", "source_line": 771, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 137, "global_rank": 3346, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 11.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance medium, phase-space type resonant; probe classes counted: ['BBN'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_1020_scalar_field_unified_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0807_1020", "source_line": 834, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3347, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked yes, CMB/BBN relevance is high/unknown, phase space is field_like. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector_scalar", "model_id": "2311_16836_unified_tdiff_scalar_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2311_16836", "source_line": 175, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3348, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 11.5 for unified_dark_sector_scalar: positive factors include emerging status, uv_complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-density viability, high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_6813_qball_wino_cogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1211_6813", "source_line": 1708, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3349, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to baryogenesis/cogenesis, supersymmetric framework, phase-transition/nonstandard history.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2101_02156_complex_scalar_reheating_planck_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_02156", "source_line": 4609, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 174, "global_rank": 3350, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial black holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include BBN, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0504246_ir_brane_composite_dsb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0504246", "source_line": 576, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 249, "global_rank": 3351, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["IR-brane composite DSB dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family hidden_sector_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_11269_one_loop_high_mass_idm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_11269", "source_line": 3941, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 3352, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_01497_radiative_light_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1704_01497", "source_line": 3110, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 162, "global_rank": 3353, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of freeze_in_dark_matter with raw score 11.5.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance, distinct phase-space production.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_07562_z3_scalar_simp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1904_07562", "source_line": 3810, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 96, "global_rank": 3354, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal SIMP freeze-out through 3_DM -> 2_DM number-changing processes in the dark sector, WIMP-like 2_DM -> 2_SM freeze-out is possible in the same Lagrangian when portal couplings are larger.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2303_06616_jet_emitting_pbh_radio_background_v1", "paper_id": "2303_06616", "source_line": 79, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 175, "global_rank": 3355, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this primordial_black_holes card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_11485_two_component_dark_u1_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_11485", "source_line": 5035, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 132, "global_rank": 3356, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 45.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Two-component dark U(1)_X fermion-vector dark matter has probe classes: BBN, CMB, laboratory/particle, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_0270_xogenesis_new_gauge_sphaleron_v1", "paper_id": "1009_0270", "source_line": 1183, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 89, "global_rank": 3357, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 11.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_10957_extended_scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1711_10957", "source_line": 3304, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 250, "global_rank": 3358, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with yes relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, 2 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_03398_ultra_light_scalar_bec_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1502_03398", "source_line": 2417, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 3359, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter entry (effective_field_theory); phase-space type is field_like; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2653_umssm_u_parity_multiple_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2653", "source_line": 752, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3360, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 11.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance medium; probe classes counted: ['CMB'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_qcd_dark_baryon", "model_id": "1306_4676_dark_qcd_ir_fixed_point_dark_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "1306_4676", "source_line": 1872, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3361, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with asymmetric/baryogenesis, decay production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 7.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07894_gauged_three_loop_z4_knt_like_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07894", "source_line": 2743, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 3362, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_1334_u1x_cogenesis_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1312_1334", "source_line": 2016, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 90, "global_rank": 3363, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=nonthermal, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_0682_minimal_trilinear_rpv_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0907_0682", "source_line": 1016, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3364, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 11.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family decaying_neutralino_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_01244_scalar_u1_le_lmu_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1712_01244", "source_line": 3350, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 251, "global_rank": 3365, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 3 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimension_kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_4507_nmued_w3_lkp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1305_4507", "source_line": 1852, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3366, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_03650_z2_asymmetric_dm_from_scattering_v1", "paper_id": "2103_03650", "source_line": 4606, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 91, "global_rank": 3367, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative asymmetric dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_03650_z3_asymmetric_dm_from_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2103_03650", "source_line": 4607, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 92, "global_rank": 3368, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative asymmetric dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_03914_scalar_triplet_flavor_leptogenesis_ihd_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_03914", "source_line": 4814, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 3369, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_14682_supersymmetric_4_2_2_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2308_14682", "source_line": 5806, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 117, "global_rank": 3370, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative uv_complete model; the main production handle is thermal freeze-out with neutralino coannihilation.", "Follow-up value comes from indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_8251_nuhm2_iss_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1401_8251", "source_line": 2026, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 118, "global_rank": 3371, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=partial and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_1953_mev_millicharged_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0809_1953", "source_line": 872, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 3372, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_04550_scale_invariant_u1x_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_04550", "source_line": 4647, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 252, "global_rank": 3373, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter entry with unknown theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_13000_mirror_world_atomic_dark_matter_scaling_v1", "paper_id": "2107_13000", "source_line": 4771, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score falls below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "The card has low local observational leverage from mostly unknown, thermal, CDM-like, or not-applicable structure and phase-space fields."], "family_rank": 133, "global_rank": 3374, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a non-eliminated emerging multi_component_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production logic from: phenomenological mirror-sector abundance assignment; atomic dark matter subcomponent with lower dark temperature.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has mostly CDM-like or unknown structure and phase-space entries.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable-constraint lists, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dilaton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_1319_dilaton_assisted_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0909_1319", "source_line": 1020, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3375, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 11.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family dilaton_mediated_dark_matter, theory level effective_field_theory, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_08277_inert_doublet_two_triplet_leptogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_08277", "source_line": 5813, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 3376, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative uv_complete model; the main production handle is thermal inert-doublet dark-matter freeze-out.", "Follow-up value comes from direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (thermal, none) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_04931_extended_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1706_04931", "source_line": 3192, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 3377, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 11.5: Extended Higgs-portal scalar dark matter with right-handed neutrinos is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal annihilation.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_2118_baryonic_zprime_isospin_violating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_2118", "source_line": 1366, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 253, "global_rank": 3378, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as hidden_sector_dark_matter: production is represented by asymmetric dark matter origin; phase-space is unknown; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_massive_particle_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_00592_radiative_simp_scotogenic_v1", "paper_id": "1705_00592", "source_line": 3190, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3379, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 11.5: Radiative SIMP scotogenic dark matter model is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal SIMP production through 3-to-2 self-annihilation.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_7202_inverse_seesaw_complex_scalar_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_7202", "source_line": 1702, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3380, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to neutrino, baryogenesis/cogenesis.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "confined_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_1413_confined_cold_dark_matter_cosmic_web_v1", "paper_id": "0809_1413", "source_line": 835, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3381, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 9.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_04814_hidden_pion_chiral_scale_invariant_v1", "paper_id": "2109_04814", "source_line": 4840, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.2, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 254, "global_rank": 3382, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, decay produced phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_12389_composite_pngb_dm_top_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2107_12389", "source_line": 4810, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.2, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3383, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by explicit benchmark points, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_baryon_number_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_14268_asymptotically_safe_gauged_baryon_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_14268", "source_line": 5364, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3384, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Asymptotically safe gauged-baryon-number fermion dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_06867_inelastic_boosted_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1612_06867", "source_line": 2954, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3385, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative boosted_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and unknown all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include detection_strategy_not_complete_model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1811_06532_multimodal_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1811_06532", "source_line": 135, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 176, "global_rank": 3386, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, enhancement small-scale-power effect, oscillatory transfer behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_11971_nonminimal_wave_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2106_11971", "source_line": 251, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 3387, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Non-minimally coupled wave dark matter, a speculative fuzzy ultralight dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, field like phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: no_relic_mechanism."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_03771_multiple_ultralight_axionic_wave_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_03771", "source_line": 3667, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 3388, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes; medium CMB relevance; field_like phase-space behavior; suppression small-scale-power effect; scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0703590_neutrino_cluster_mond_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0703590", "source_line": 154, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3389, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 11.0 for neutrino_dark_matter: positive factors include medium CMB relevance, smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior, suppression in small-scale power, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_tensor_modified_expansion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_05553_scalar_tensor_modified_expansion_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1612_05553", "source_line": 2983, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3390, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_tensor_modified_expansion_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on high BBN relevance.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include generic-particle-content."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "branon_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0405165_branon_dark_geometry_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0405165", "source_line": 500, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3391, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; mixed small-scale-power effect; mixed_cold_warm transfer behavior; mixed_cold_warm phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_00014_dark_monopole_ab_dipole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_00014", "source_line": 3872, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 after model-card-local penalties for sparse observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and/or computational support.", "The supplied card indicates a subcomponent/no-full-abundance dark matter role."], "family_rank": 255, "global_rank": 3392, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative / simplified_model: A dark U(1)_D scenario in which confined dark monopole-antimonopole bound states form magnetic dipoles that couple weakly to the visible photon through kinetic mixing below the dark-photon mass.", "Relic and observational hooks in the card: phenomenological relic treatment, subcomponent, production reach no; BBN low; CMB low; phase-space unknown; transfer function unknown; small-scale power unknown.", "Penalty reflects empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, computational representation in the supplied model card.", "High-severity card warning(s) included in penalties: subcomponent_not_full_dm."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_radiation", "model_id": "2104_05352_transient_dm_radiation_thermalization_v1", "paper_id": "2104_05352", "source_line": 268, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3393, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Transient dark matter-radiation thermalization model, a speculative interacting dark matter radiation entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, scale dependent growth transfer behavior, thermal phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: not_wimp_applicable."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10689_munu_ssm_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10689", "source_line": 5224, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 138, "global_rank": 3394, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, suppression of small-scale power; nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0805_4014_mond_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "0805_4014", "source_line": 289, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 139, "global_rank": 3395, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Single sterile-neutrino MOND dark matter model, a speculative sterile neutrino dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer behavior, thermal phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: modified_gravity_mapping."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_01755_number_theory_dark_matter_model_a_v1", "paper_id": "1811_01755", "source_line": 3679, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 140, "global_rank": 3396, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal phase-space behavior; suppression small-scale-power effect; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_01755_number_theory_dark_matter_model_b_v1", "paper_id": "1811_01755", "source_line": 3680, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 141, "global_rank": 3397, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal phase-space behavior; suppression small-scale-power effect; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "2109_03536_interacting_two_scalar_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2109_03536", "source_line": 325, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3398, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=unknown; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth, phase-space type is field_like.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:not_particle_relic_model.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 5/6/5/0/9/4/18."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_11273_decaying_dm_millicharged_intermediates_v1", "paper_id": "1901_11273", "source_line": 3738, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 3399, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Decaying scalar dark matter with millicharged intermediates is a speculative simplified model candidate with decay produced phase-space behavior, probe relevance for BBN, CMB; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_5615_two_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1309_5615", "source_line": 1974, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3400, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_10025_complex_axion_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2004_10025", "source_line": 4263, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 235, "global_rank": 3401, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via coherent oscillations of the angular axion component after its effective potential is generated; potential generation after a phase transition and integration out of massive gauge degrees of freedom, field_like phase-space treatment.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_10934_dark_glueball_d8_gauge_portal_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1901_10934", "source_line": 3751, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 256, "global_rank": 3402, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 11 because the card identifies production via prethermal UV freeze-in of dark gluons, UV freeze-in during reheating, nonthermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_0514_multiple_cdm_opposite_de_couplings_v1", "paper_id": "1204_0514", "source_line": 297, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 134, "global_rank": 3403, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Multiple cold dark matter with opposite dark-energy couplings, a speculative multi component dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, scale dependent growth transfer behavior, nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: w1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "string_defect_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_1726_d_particle_foam_defect_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1211_1726", "source_line": 171, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3404, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 9.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 11.0 for string_defect_dark_matter: positive factors include simplified_model theory level, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, enhancement in small-scale power, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_01466_dark_ksvz_dark_photon_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1611_01466", "source_line": 2978, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3405, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_photon_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include warn_1611_01466_stability."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_03067_u1_lmu_ltau_scalar_fimp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1612_03067", "source_line": 2993, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 163, "global_rank": 3406, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and yes all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include do_not_treat_as_wimp."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_1982_stable_gravitino_qks_ewimp_v1", "paper_id": "0809_1982", "source_line": 845, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 3407, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is medium/high, phase space is nonthermal. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_06663_quintessence_kinetic_mixing_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1907_06663", "source_line": 3932, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 164, "global_rank": 3408, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_12546_single_modulus_pqmssm_mixed_axion_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_12546", "source_line": 5463, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 135, "global_rank": 3409, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Single-modulus PQMSSM mixed axion and higgsino dark matter has solid theory/motivation content, medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, mixed_cold_warm phase space, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_3462_moving_brane_disformal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1312_3462", "source_line": 16, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 257, "global_rank": 3410, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative uv_complete model, medium CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_3834_fast_transition_affine_udm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_3834", "source_line": 3, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3411, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, high CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0507120_ghost_condensate_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0507120", "source_line": 593, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3412, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ghost-condensate dark matter is a speculative effective field theory card in family modified_gravity_scalar_dark_matter with production described as coherent nonzero ghost charge density redshifting as matter.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; field like phase space; probe classes: CMB, halo/subhalo structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_06912_qcd_axion_radial_mode_dipole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_06912", "source_line": 5415, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Unknown relic viability and absent observables, constraints, routing, and code make extension low priority."], "family_rank": 236, "global_rank": 3413, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the QCD-axion radial-mode/dipole scenario has field-like behavior and critical CMB relevance, but relic production is unknown and routes are missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter_with_axion_like_particle", "model_id": "2212_04647_scalar_dark_matter_to_axions_v1", "paper_id": "2212_04647", "source_line": 5437, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Unknown relic viability and missing observables, constraints, routing, and code limit current value."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3414, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but distinctive: scalar dark matter decaying to axions is a rare family with CMB and decay-produced phase-space hooks, but relic viability is unknown and implementation details are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_08750_alp_domain_wall_anthropic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_08750", "source_line": 4678, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 237, "global_rank": 3415, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production yes; high CMB relevance; field_like phase space; probe relevance for CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_10073_su5_u1x_ksvz_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2106_10073", "source_line": 4690, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 238, "global_rank": 3416, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level uv_complete, and relic production parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; field_like phase space; probe relevance for CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_06947_gravitino_thermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_06947", "source_line": 3037, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3417, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 44.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["High-scale SUSY gravitino dark matter with light higgsino NLSP is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has some cosmological, phase-space, or halo-structure leverage; uses a nonthermal phase-space history; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_00586_axion_fr_gravity_v1", "paper_id": "2012_00586", "source_line": 269, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 239, "global_rank": 3418, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Axion F(R) gravity dark matter and dark energy model, a speculative axion like dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and high CMB relevance, field like phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_09471_mixed_wimp_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1810_09471", "source_line": 3666, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 136, "global_rank": 3419, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative multi_component_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes; medium CMB relevance; field_like phase-space behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2108_12475_primordial_black_hole_perturbation_v1", "paper_id": "2108_12475", "source_line": 4871, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 177, "global_rank": 3420, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is benchmark and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from phenomenological_parameterization theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_06587_nonminimal_inert_doublet_inflaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_06587", "source_line": 3241, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 3421, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Non-minimally coupled inert doublet inflaton dark matter is a speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter card with CMB/BBN relevance high/unknown, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vacuum_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_5946_vacuum_energy_dark_matter_massive_fields_v1", "paper_id": "1404_5946", "source_line": 2073, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3422, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative effective_field_theory member of vacuum_energy_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support; large sparsity penalties from missing observational-extension fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_13272_spin0_relativistic_decay_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2212_13272", "source_line": 5499, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3423, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Spin-0 relativistic-decay dark matter EFT has some theory and relic-density motivation, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, decay_produced phase space, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_higgs_flavon_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_04822_higgs_flavon_inert_doublet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_04822", "source_line": 2763, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3424, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative effective_field_theory in inert_doublet_higgs_flavon_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: not calculated; candidate is inherited from the inert doublet model; expected thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal and electroweak interactions if treated like standard inert-doublet dark matter; portals: higgs, other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_fermion_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_10916_fermion_doublet_d5_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1703_10916", "source_line": 3097, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3425, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative electroweak_fermion_doublet_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory and production ability parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0608265_cmssm_neutralino_slinky_benchmark_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0608265", "source_line": 640, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 119, "global_rank": 3426, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has limited positive support beyond basic model identity, provenance, and relic-density context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_3679_nonstandard_cosmology_asymmetric_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1304_3679", "source_line": 1780, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 93, "global_rank": 3427, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 11: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, family asymmetric_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance medium; BBN relevance critical; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as BBN, CMB.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 182; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_06107_dst_unified_dark_matter_dark_energy_v1", "paper_id": "2104_06107", "source_line": 53, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3428, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this unified_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_01263_thermal_hidden_sector_s_channel_dirac_v1", "paper_id": "2105_01263", "source_line": 4700, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3429, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; probe relevance for BBN, CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_01263_thermal_hidden_sector_t_channel_dirac_v1", "paper_id": "2105_01263", "source_line": 4699, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3430, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; probe relevance for BBN, CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modulated_freeze_out_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0502113_modulated_freezeout_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0502113", "source_line": 520, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3431, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Stable heavy particle dark matter with fluctuating annihilation cross section is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card with either relic-density treatment; it touches cmb, indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_06727_early_qcd_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2004_06727", "source_line": 4239, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 3432, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include phase-transition or confinement connection; high or critical BBN relevance; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: BBN.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07941_vlq_singlet_scalar_dm_model3_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07941", "source_line": 2759, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3433, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in singlet_scalar_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out through annihilation into top-quark pairs; portals: other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_14403_rs_scalar_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_14403", "source_line": 4203, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 165, "global_rank": 3434, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low-current-priority because theory links include early-universe production connection; nonthermal phase-space information; the card marks all-dark-matter production as parameter dependent; explicit probe classes from card fields: BBN.", "Score is limited by absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison compatibility, and computational-representation blocks in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_0011_induced_nucleon_decay_adm_doublet_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1312_0011", "source_line": 2029, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 94, "global_rank": 3435, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=effective_field_theory, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=nonthermal, and structure effect=unknown/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_0011_induced_nucleon_decay_adm_singlet_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1312_0011", "source_line": 2028, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 95, "global_rank": 3436, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=effective_field_theory, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=nonthermal, and structure effect=unknown/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0712_3300_sweet_spot_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0712_3300", "source_line": 766, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 3437, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 11.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance medium, phase-space type decay_produced; probe classes counted: ['BBN'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_01379_fimplaton_freeze_in_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1607_01379", "source_line": 2844, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 166, "global_rank": 3438, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic production marked yes.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_09950_axion_monopole_hidden_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2105_09950", "source_line": 4704, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 137, "global_rank": 3439, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and production via Kibble-Zurek monopole production; axion abundance set by monopole-loop-induced potential.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB; the raw score is 11 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9802238_gravitational_superheavy_x_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9802238", "source_line": 6118, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3440, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 11 (defer) from supplied card content: superheavy_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and yes all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "continuum_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_14023_z_portal_continuum_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_14023", "source_line": 4728, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3441, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative continuum_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and production via thermal freeze-out of continuum states.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB; the raw score is 11 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Diversity credit is elevated because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive family or production regime in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_00401_unified_qcd_axion_susy_breaking_v1", "paper_id": "1702_00401", "source_line": 3039, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 3442, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Unified QCD axion and gauge-mediated SUSY-breaking model is ranked because it uses a field-like phase-space history; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_00829_extended_inert_doublet_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_00829", "source_line": 3948, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 3443, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_6299_su5_neutralino_sbottom_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1111_6299", "source_line": 1439, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 120, "global_rank": 3444, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 11.0 because the card describes supersymmetric neutralino dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal freeze-out with neutralino-sbottom coannihilation and medium CMB relevance with partial associated-code support.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_03760_scalar_higgs_portal_strong_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2405_03760", "source_line": 6085, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3445, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 11.0: speculative simplified model model in higgs_portal_freeze_in_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_like_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_10475_axino_like_alpino_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1902_10475", "source_line": 3772, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3446, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 11 because the card identifies production via low-reheating freeze-in from thermal-plasma scattering followed by ..., nonthermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_10998_heavy_composite_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2012_10998", "source_line": 4483, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3447, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for composite_asymmetric_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from nonthermal phase-space history, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_04445_lrsm_pev_n1_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1606_04445", "source_line": 2812, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 3448, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked yes.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_10757_hadrophobic_electrophobic_alp_inflaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_10757", "source_line": 5452, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 240, "global_rank": 3449, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Hadrophobic and electrophobic GUT ALP inflaton dark matter has solid theory/motivation content, medium CMB relevance, field_like phase space, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_5440_string_photino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0909_5440", "source_line": 1005, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 258, "global_rank": 3450, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 11 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family hidden_sector_dark_matter, theory level effective_field_theory, and probe handles: BBN, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_4872_dark_sector_decay_super_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1109_4872", "source_line": 1458, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3451, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable superwimp_dark_matter variant and records nonthermal production from late S -> 2 N decays after S freeze-out.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0509024_light_singlino_nmssm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0509024", "source_line": 512, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization."], "family_rank": 121, "global_rank": 3452, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Light singlino-like neutralino dark matter in the NMSSM is a speculative uv complete card with either relic-density treatment; it touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2310_04174_stochastic_spectator_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2310_04174", "source_line": 302, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 178, "global_rank": 3453, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is high, BBN relevance is low.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, compact-object dynamics; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:spectator_not_particle_dm, medium:anthropic_abundance.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/2/5/0/9/2/15."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_07655_u1_t3r_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2105_07655", "source_line": 4703, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 259, "global_rank": 3454, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; dark-Higgs resonant annihilation.", "Card-local leverage comes from BBN, CMB; the raw score is 11 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_08121_nonabelian_hidden_gauge_hadronic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_08121", "source_line": 2452, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 260, "global_rank": 3455, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=medium; BBN relevance=medium.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: BBN, CMB.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=506, diversity_value=4.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_07410_fraternal_twin_atom_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_07410", "source_line": 2487, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 96, "global_rank": 3456, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=asymmetric_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from phase_space=nonthermal.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=182, diversity_value=4.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_04946_secluded_vector_higgs_portal_cascade_v1", "paper_id": "2001_04946", "source_line": 4171, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3457, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of secluded_vector_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, 2 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity credit reflects a comparatively distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or dominant probe class in the population context.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_08066_stable_gauged_vorton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2112_08066", "source_line": 5024, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3458, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Stable gauged vorton dark matter from bosonic superconducting strings has probe classes: BBN, gravitational waves; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_6046_b_l_mssm_right_handed_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1101_6046", "source_line": 1252, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 3459, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 11 for B-L MSSM right-handed sneutrino thermal dark matter in inflection-point inflation: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is high; probe hints: CMB, collider.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_3082_split_vector_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1011_3082", "source_line": 1329, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 261, "global_rank": 3460, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance high.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_1097_sequestered_gauge_mediation_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0808_1097", "source_line": 822, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 122, "global_rank": 3461, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is high/unknown. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_3848_nmsugra_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0809_3848", "source_line": 824, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 123, "global_rank": 3462, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is high/unknown. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_11830_complex_singlet_degenerate_pseudoscalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_11830", "source_line": 4693, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 3463, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level uv_complete, and relic production parameter_dependent; probe relevance for small-scale structure.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_08828_two_component_scalar_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2003_08828", "source_line": 4195, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 138, "global_rank": 3464, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of multi_component_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include nonthermal phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity credit reflects a comparatively distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or dominant probe class in the population context.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "clockwork_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_14071_clockwork_axion_first_order_pq_v1", "paper_id": "2012_14071", "source_line": 4551, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3465, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative clockwork_axion_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from phase-space type is field_like.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_16802_forbidden_decay_scattering_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_16802", "source_line": 5395, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 167, "global_rank": 3466, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Freeze-in heavy fermion dark matter from plasma-induced forbidden decay and activated scattering has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph9810361_wimpzilla_nonthermal_superheavy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9810361", "source_line": 6105, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3467, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 11 (defer) from supplied card content: superheavy_nonthermal_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_1483_gauge_mediated_decaying_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_1483", "source_line": 1757, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3468, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 11: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family decaying_gravitino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: BBN relevance high; transfer function cdm_like; complementarity probes counted as BBN.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 4; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_01410_f_term_hybrid_inflation_split_susy_wino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_01410", "source_line": 2515, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3469, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for F-term hybrid inflation split-SUSY wino dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_08153_hidden_monopole_alp_witten_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_08153", "source_line": 4666, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 262, "global_rank": 3470, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; probe relevance for CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0001173_susy_baryonic_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0001173", "source_line": 411, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3471, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides simplified model theory support, moderate diversity value; probe signal: compact objects.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_08254_ksvz_axino_neutralino_nlsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_08254", "source_line": 2458, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 241, "global_rank": 3472, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=axion_like_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from phase_space=mixed_cold_warm.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=338, diversity_value=7.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_00819_b_minus_l_scalar_fimp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1704_00819", "source_line": 3025, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 168, "global_rank": 3473, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scalar FIMP dark matter in a U(1) B-L model is ranked because it can produce the full dark-matter abundance in the card; uses a nonthermal phase-space history; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "doublet_triplet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_04990_doublet_triplet_fermion_nonstandard_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "1809_04990", "source_line": 3583, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3474, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative doublet_triplet_fermion_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it can supply all dark matter according to the production block.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_06409_dark_monopole_su_n_gut_v1", "paper_id": "1809_06409", "source_line": 3637, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3475, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative topological_defect_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and unknown abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_axion_axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_3769_pqmssm_mixed_axion_axino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1012_3769", "source_line": 1266, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3476, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 11 for PQMSSM mixed axion/axino dark matter with saxion dilution: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from BBN relevance is high; probe hints: BBN.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_5679_sneutrino_inflation_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1101_5679", "source_line": 1268, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 97, "global_rank": 3477, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 11 for Sneutrino-inflation asymmetric dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is high; probe hints: CMB.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1102_3455_asymmetric_minimal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1102_3455", "source_line": 1291, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 98, "global_rank": 3478, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 43.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 11 for Asymmetric minimal dark matter from leptogenesis: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal; probe hints: collider.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1102_0556_g2_m_theory_mixed_wino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1102_0556", "source_line": 1263, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 3479, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 11 for G2-M theory mostly wino LSP dark matter with Higgsino admixture: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal; probe hints: indirect detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_spin2_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_15873_spin2_bigravity_anisotropic_production_v1", "paper_id": "2211_15873", "source_line": 5412, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Rare theory content is not enough to offset missing observables, constraints, routing, code, and high-severity caveats."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3480, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Distinctive but deferred: ultralight spin-2 bigravity dark matter is an extremely rare field-like class, but severe extraction warnings and absent observational routing dominate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_0481_mssm_neutralino_susy_qcd_v1", "paper_id": "0901_0481", "source_line": 928, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3481, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, high cosmological relevance, partial code or computational support, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Penalties mainly reflect missing observable mapping, constraints, and routing rather than global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_09187_u1_bl_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_09187", "source_line": 3929, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 3482, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative scalar_singlet_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_6478_left_right_susy_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1109_6478", "source_line": 1442, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 124, "global_rank": 3483, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 11.0 because the card describes supersymmetric neutralino dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal freeze-out; co-annihilation and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage with partial associated-code support.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "0911_1570_itimp_weak_isotriplet_technicolor_v1", "paper_id": "0911_1570", "source_line": 1059, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3484, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete asymmetric_composite_dark_matter; nonthermal phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_scalar_graviton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_1437_unimodular_bimode_scalar_graviton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_1437", "source_line": 1448, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3485, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 11.0 because the card describes modified gravity scalar graviton dark matter at effective field theory level, with coherent_scalar_graviton_static_halo_solution; dark_lacuna_gravitational_structure and field like phase-space behavior.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_thermal_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_10030_higgs_mediated_colored_coannihilation_bsf_v1", "paper_id": "1901_10030", "source_line": 3754, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3486, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 11 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out, colored coannihilation, thermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_14105_three_loop_inverse_scotogenic_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_14105", "source_line": 5910, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3487, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Three-loop inverse scotogenic seesaw fermion dark matter is a speculative scotogenic_fermion_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and no explicit routed probe class from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 13, observational leverage 2, complementarity 0, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 3.0, penalties 16; raw score 11.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "antibaryonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_5914_antibaryonic_fourth_generation_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1303_5914", "source_line": 1806, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3488, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative antibaryonic_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on no explicit probe class in observables, constraints, or routing fields and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_03549_qcd_neutrino_condensate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_03549", "source_line": 4696, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3489, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production yes; field_like phase space.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_09756_atomki_secluded_real_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_09756", "source_line": 3199, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3490, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 11.0: Atomki-motivated secluded real scalar dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with thermal freeze-out by secluded annihilation to X X and s s.", "Rank-relevant positives are medium CMB relevance, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: CMB, direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0810_5762_stueckelberg_hidden_dirac_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0810_5762", "source_line": 889, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 263, "global_rank": 3491, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, full dark-matter abundance capability, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_07222_singlet_majorana_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1504_07222", "source_line": 2489, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 3492, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=higgs_portal_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=yes.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=90, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1307_5119_inflection_point_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1307_5119", "source_line": 1826, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 179, "global_rank": 3493, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative primordial_black_holes model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=no, and phase-space type is not_applicable; CMB relevance is medium.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on CMB, compact-object dynamics, gravitational waves and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_06553_mpp_real_triplet_scalar_minimal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_06553", "source_line": 2455, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3494, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=minimal_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=medium.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=23, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_06553_mpp_triplet_majorana_minimal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_06553", "source_line": 2454, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3495, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=minimal_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=medium.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=23, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_06658_a4_to_z3_self_interacting_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_06658", "source_line": 2492, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 97, "global_rank": 3496, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=self_interacting_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=yes.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=166, diversity_value=2.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimpy_baryogenesis_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_0094_quark_wimpy_baryogenesis_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1210_0094", "source_line": 1621, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3497, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory card for Quark WIMPy baryogenesis effective-field-theory dark matter; it offers BBN relevance with BBN, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_7008_dirac_weak_isospin_multiplet_v1", "paper_id": "1305_7008", "source_line": 1853, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3498, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_4882_so10_neutralino_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1307_4882", "source_line": 1855, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 125, "global_rank": 3499, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with coannihilation production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 1 while penalties total 17."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_5013_displaced_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0906_5013", "source_line": 984, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 99, "global_rank": 3500, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1801_06138_qcd_eos_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1801_06138", "source_line": 3341, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 180, "global_rank": 3501, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 2 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_06388_visible_dark_photon_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_06388", "source_line": 3602, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 264, "global_rank": 3502, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as benchmark hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_05023_conformal_u1x_zprime_rhn_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1704_05023", "source_line": 3049, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 3503, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Classically conformal U(1)X Z-prime portal right-handed-neutrino dark matter is ranked because it can produce the full dark-matter abundance in the card; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_08251_generative_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1711_08251", "source_line": 3290, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 100, "global_rank": 3504, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching CMB, gravitational waves.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 11.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_4321_pmssm_neutralino_lsp_model_set_v1", "paper_id": "1206_4321", "source_line": 1580, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 126, "global_rank": 3505, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked benchmark-set candidate because the card has a broad pMSSM neutralino model set and CMB relevance, but no individual observational routes, constraints, benchmarks, or code are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0609257_light_nmssm_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0609257", "source_line": 629, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 127, "global_rank": 3506, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some computational or code support recorded in the model card, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_01635_inverse_decay_chain_thermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_01635", "source_line": 5199, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3507, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: inverse-decay chain variant is rare and distinctive, but metastability caveats and missing observational detail keep it deferred."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_01635_zombie_chain_thermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_01635", "source_line": 5198, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3508, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: very rare zombie-chain thermal relic has distinctive production diversity, but particle properties and observational mappings are mostly unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_6575_bgw_mirage_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1303_6575", "source_line": 1792, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 128, "global_rank": 3509, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 11: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance medium; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as CMB.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 309; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_3797_so10_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0912_3797", "source_line": 1069, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3510, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete scalar_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium).", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_04286_alrm_scotino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2211_04286", "source_line": 5411, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Follow-up is held back by absent observables, constraints, and routing despite partial model-code context."], "family_rank": 265, "global_rank": 3511, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: the ALRM scotino candidate is UV-complete with partial code context, but the supplied fields give only weak CMB relevance and no concrete observable route."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_04016_su2d_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_04016", "source_line": 5152, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 266, "global_rank": 3512, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: UV-complete vector hidden-sector thermal relic with rare vector statistics, but observational handles are mostly absent and the mass-ordering warning is important."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_10802_no_scale_sugra_neutralino_dm_small_a0_v1", "paper_id": "2109_10802", "source_line": 4857, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 129, "global_rank": 3513, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from uv_complete theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_10802_no_scale_sugra_neutralino_dm_zero_a0_v1", "paper_id": "2109_10802", "source_line": 4856, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 130, "global_rank": 3514, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from uv_complete theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_09559_hybrid_triplet_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_09559", "source_line": 4882, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 267, "global_rank": 3515, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "string_motivated_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0610129_large_volume_iib_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0610129", "source_line": 675, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3516, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; limited computational support; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_singlet_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_00227_thermal_singlino_higgsino_blind_spot_v1", "paper_id": "1705_00227", "source_line": 3128, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3517, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of supersymmetric_singlet_doublet_dark_matter with raw score 11.0.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 1.", "Feasibility receives limited support from partial associated-code information, but explicit routes and benchmarks are absent.", "Penalties are moderate for missing observable/routing fields but partly offset by provenance, validity-domain, and robustness entries."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_0617_gauged_bl_singlet_scalar_x_v1", "paper_id": "1005_0617", "source_line": 1139, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3518, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in scalar_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_3429_scale_invariant_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1408_3429", "source_line": 2278, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 268, "global_rank": 3519, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimensions_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_1598_nonminimal_ued_w3_lkp_v1", "paper_id": "0811_1598", "source_line": 874, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3520, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, effective field theory theory level, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_4872_split_scalar_higgs_portal_wimps_v1", "paper_id": "1109_4872", "source_line": 1456, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 3521, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable higgs_portal_dark_matter variant and records thermal coannihilation between S1 and S2.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_3861_supersymmetric_four_higgs_light_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1110_3861", "source_line": 1466, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 131, "global_rank": 3522, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out via neutralino annihilation to quarks through extra Higgs exchange.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_3905_bmssm_neutralino_correlated_sfermions_v1", "paper_id": "0912_3905", "source_line": 1048, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 132, "global_rank": 3523, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 11 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, theory level effective_field_theory, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_3905_bmssm_neutralino_light_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "0912_3905", "source_line": 1049, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 133, "global_rank": 3524, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 11 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, theory level effective_field_theory, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_5651_scalar_higgs_portal_singlet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1005_5651", "source_line": 1198, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 3525, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 11 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, moderate scientific value from its stated theory and relic mechanism, little implementation or routing support, a small near-duplicate penalty within this assigned batch."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_2872_weak_scale_xray_line_pseudo_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_2872", "source_line": 2297, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 269, "global_rank": 3526, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_6542_susy_inverse_seesaw_sneutrino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1207_6542", "source_line": 1622, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 3527, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for SUSY inverse-seesaw light sneutrino LSP dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_5153_u1prime_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1408_5153", "source_line": 2280, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 3528, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative scalar_singlet_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_5730_light_neutralino_no_light_sfermions_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_5730", "source_line": 2290, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 134, "global_rank": 3529, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a benchmark supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_05503_one_higgs_scotogenic_flavored_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_05503", "source_line": 2459, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3530, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=scotogenic_flavored_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=1, diversity_value=5.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_1992_gauged_b_l_zee_babu_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1410_1992", "source_line": 2293, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 139, "global_rank": 3531, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_4998_mssm_sbottom_offshell_z_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1410_4998", "source_line": 2342, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 135, "global_rank": 3532, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 11 because the assigned model card uv complete supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_4998_mssm_sbottom_slepton_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1410_4998", "source_line": 2341, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 136, "global_rank": 3533, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 11 because the assigned model card uv complete supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_0752_electroweak_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_0752", "source_line": 2333, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3534, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 11 because the assigned model card effective field theory electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_4378_near_pq_nmssm_singlino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1110_4378", "source_line": 1454, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 3535, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable neutralino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out with close-to-resonance annihilation via the light CP-odd Higgs a_1.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_0656_inflation_extended_radiative_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_0656", "source_line": 1500, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 3536, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out of stable N_R1.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_4872_nmssm_type_susy_higgs_portal_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1109_4872", "source_line": 1459, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 3537, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable supersymmetric_dark_matter variant and records parameter-dependent Higgs-portal freeze-out or nonthermal production depending on the singlet-sector regime.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_1405_z2_right_handed_neutrino_bl_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_1405", "source_line": 1495, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3538, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out through resonant annihilation.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_4048_complex_singlet_scalar_dm_high_scale_v1", "paper_id": "1411_4048", "source_line": 2351, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 3539, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 42.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal annihilation production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_04221_cp_1234_two_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_04221", "source_line": 5027, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3540, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: CP-1234 two-singlet scalar dark matter has probe classes: gravitational waves, laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_1407_lepton_flavored_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1411_1407", "source_line": 2352, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3541, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative lepton_flavored_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory and thermal freeze-out production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_03614_pseudo_dirac_gluino_neutralino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1502_03614", "source_line": 2388, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 137, "global_rank": 3542, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out with neutralino-stau coannihilation production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_00505_generalized_gravity_mediation_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_00505", "source_line": 2390, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 138, "global_rank": 3543, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal neutralino freeze-out production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_4373_hidden_sector_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0907_4373", "source_line": 987, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 270, "global_rank": 3544, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_composite_wimp", "model_id": "0906_0577_vectorlike_confinement_hyperpion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0906_0577", "source_line": 1021, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3545, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 11 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family hidden_sector_composite_wimp, theory level uv_complete, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_02544_resonant_wino_zreft_v1", "paper_id": "1710_02544", "source_line": 3288, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3546, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative wino dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching direct detection, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 11.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sommerfeld_enhanced_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_0235_pseudo_goldstone_sommerfeld_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0907_0235", "source_line": 997, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3547, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sommerfeld_enhanced_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: direct/inelastic detection, indirect detection.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_3390_split_susy_higgs_resonance_bino_v1", "paper_id": "1108_3390", "source_line": 1391, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 3548, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as neutralino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out with resonant s-channel Higgs annihilation; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by effective_field_theory structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_05957_composite_doublet_pngb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1501_05957", "source_line": 2442, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3549, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter entry (effective_field_theory); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_05957_composite_singlet_pngb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1501_05957", "source_line": 2441, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3550, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter entry (effective_field_theory); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_05957_composite_triplet_pngb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1501_05957", "source_line": 2443, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3551, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter entry (effective_field_theory); relic production is marked parameter_dependent; implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_07972_baryonic_zprime_darkonium_v1", "paper_id": "1807_07972", "source_line": 3585, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3552, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_6283_snail_diagram_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_6283", "source_line": 2328, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 3553, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 11 because the assigned model card uv complete radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_10627_two_component_scalar_singlet_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_10627", "source_line": 4381, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3554, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Two-component scalar singlet-doublet dark matter from three-body-decay leptogenesis: thermal freeze-out; partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_09941_realistic_simplified_higgsino_mssm_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_09941", "source_line": 3329, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 139, "global_rank": 3555, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from the associated-code field, but no public computational representation is recorded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_5090_msugra_type_ii_seesaw_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0907_5090", "source_line": 998, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 140, "global_rank": 3556, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_3646_nmssm_130gev_bino_internal_bremsstrahlung_v1", "paper_id": "1306_3646", "source_line": 1834, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3557, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_03417_singlet_doublet_triplet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_03417", "source_line": 3035, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3558, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Singlet-doublet fermionic dark matter with a type-II seesaw scalar triplet is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_02377_singlet_doublet_scalar_dm_model_i_v1", "paper_id": "2008_02377", "source_line": 4380, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3559, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Model-I singlet-doublet scalar dark matter for lepton AMMs and neutrino mass: thermal freeze-out; good diversity value within the population context, partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_2084_charge_asymmetric_three_body_lfv_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1108_2084", "source_line": 1373, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3560, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as decaying_asymmetric_dark_matter: production is represented by charge-asymmetric dark matter abundance; phase-space is unknown; inferred probe coverage includes indirect detection.", "Score drivers: provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated; diversity value is high from rare family or uncommon phase-space/production features.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_08531_type1_type2_seesaw_dirac_fermion_wimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_08531", "source_line": 5166, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 271, "global_rank": 3561, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: hidden Dirac WIMP connects to seesaw model-building, but observational leverage, code, routes, and detailed relic scans are absent or degraded."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_04557_two_loop_radiative_seesaw_global_u1_kev_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1503_04557", "source_line": 2386, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 142, "global_rank": 3562, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal production through annihilation to Goldstone bosons production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: neutrino/indirect.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_01628_nonabelian_singlet_higgs_portal_simp_v1", "paper_id": "1606_01628", "source_line": 2848, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 98, "global_rank": 3563, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from structure formation relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extended_gauge_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_5779_331lhn_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1206_5779", "source_line": 1586, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3564, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but diverse because the card describes a rare 331LHN scalar WIMP family with explicit relic logic, while observable and routing fields are absent in this model-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_5313_u1d_scotogenic_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_5313", "source_line": 1829, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3565, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative scotogenic_hidden_sector_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_baryon_lepton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_05111_gauged_baryon_lepton_leptobaryon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_05111", "source_line": 4390, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3566, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Gauged baryon and lepton number leptobaryon dark matter: thermal annihilation through s-channel Z_B into quark pairs; good diversity value within the population context; inferred probe coverage includes gravitational waves.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "resonant_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_06036_u1_lmutau_zprime_resonance_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_06036", "source_line": 3571, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3567, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative resonant_hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_6260_axion_like_domain_wall_network_v1", "paper_id": "1205_6260", "source_line": 1578, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3568, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but diverse because the card treats a macroscopic domain-wall-network candidate with rare topological-defect phenomenology, while observational routing and network-density validation are missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_7835_next_to_littlest_higgs_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_7835", "source_line": 1777, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 3569, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 11: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family inert_doublet_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: BBN relevance low; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 54; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modular_flavor_majorana_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_05674_modular_a4_tau_i_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2111_05674", "source_line": 4884, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3570, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from simplified_model theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: rare family in population context (count 2).", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_02166_low_mass_inert_doublet_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2101_02166", "source_line": 4585, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3571, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_doublet_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_13011_hypercolor_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2110_13011", "source_line": 4899, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 140, "global_rank": 3572, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from uv_complete theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_with_colored_mediators", "model_id": "2012_09022_scalar_singlet_colourful_mediators_v1", "paper_id": "2012_09022", "source_line": 4536, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3573, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dipole_rayleigh_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_4404_stable_electroweak_messenger_dipole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_4404", "source_line": 1790, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3574, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 11: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family dipole_rayleigh_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 1; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_gauge_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_03735_lmu_ltau_light_fermion_leptoquark_v1", "paper_id": "2106_03735", "source_line": 4689, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3575, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_14443_electroweak_multiplet_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2104_14443", "source_line": 4740, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3576, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a emerging effective_field_theory_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and production via thermal freeze-out through EFT annihilation operators; co-annihilation for electroweak multiplets.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 11 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_higgs_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_02366_six_higgs_doublet_lah_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1709_02366", "source_line": 3249, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3577, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Six Higgs doublet lightest additional Higgs dark matter is a speculative inert_higgs_doublet_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_axion_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_7852_rns_axion_higgsino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_7852", "source_line": 1725, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 11, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3578, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to strong-CP/PQ/axion, supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 11, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0510628_dark_sector_interaction_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0510628", "source_line": 562, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3579, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scalar-dependent-mass interacting dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card in family interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter with production described as late-time relic-density evolution from conserved dark matter number density and scalar-dependent particle mass.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; enhancement of small-scale power; enhanced small scale power transfer behavior; probe classes: CMB, small-scale structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_6632_complex_singlet_cp_odd_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1309_6632", "source_line": 1975, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 3580, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_1910_unified_dark_fluid_dm_dr_v1", "paper_id": "1306_1910", "source_line": 1877, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3581, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative phenomenological-parameterization model with dark-fluid/radiation production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching BBN, CMB.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 6.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_mev_p_wave_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_1689_mev_anapole_dark_matter_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1212_1689", "source_line": 1734, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3582, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to neutrino, phase-transition/nonstandard history.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_mev_p_wave_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_1689_mev_edm_dark_matter_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1212_1689", "source_line": 1733, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3583, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to neutrino, phase-transition/nonstandard history.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_06882_qcd_axion_nonstandard_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "2012_06882", "source_line": 4509, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 242, "global_rank": 3584, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from critical BBN relevance, field_like phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_05841_radiative_seesaw_inert_doublet_dm_singlet_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "1509_05841", "source_line": 2567, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 3585, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_04213_product_gauge_heavy_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_04213", "source_line": 3305, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 243, "global_rank": 3586, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space behavior, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_6264_pq_dirac_neutrino_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_6264", "source_line": 1616, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 244, "global_rank": 3587, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Peccei-Quinn Dirac-neutrino axion dark matter model; it offers field like phase-space behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_15697_electron_specific_scalar_mediator_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_15697", "source_line": 5934, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3588, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Dirac fermion DM with an electron-specific spin-0 mediator is a benchmark light_thermal_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and collider from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 11, observational leverage 3, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 3.5, penalties 18; raw score 10.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_thermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_15697_electron_specific_scalar_mediator_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_15697", "source_line": 5935, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3589, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Majorana fermion DM with an electron-specific spin-0 mediator is a benchmark light_thermal_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and collider from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 11, observational leverage 3, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 3.5, penalties 18; raw score 10.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_4219_su5_1_200_neutralino_bulk_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0705_4219", "source_line": 717, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3590, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_4219_su5_1_24_neutralino_bulk_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0705_4219", "source_line": 715, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3591, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_4219_su5_1_75_neutralino_bulk_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0705_4219", "source_line": 716, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3592, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; CMB medium relevance; probe coverage from CMB.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_05656_classically_conformal_two_scalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_05656", "source_line": 3843, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3593, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as thermal Higgs-portal production, freeze-out inferred from thermal abundance discussion.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "so10_gut_scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_05601_so10_model_i_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_05601", "source_line": 3846, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3594, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as thermal WIMP freeze-out.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "so10_gut_scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_05601_so10_model_ii_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_05601", "source_line": 3847, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3595, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete model with production listed as thermal WIMP freeze-out.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0503117_superwimp_parameterization_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0503117", "source_line": 538, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 3596, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Model-independent superWIMP collider-production parameterization is a benchmark phenomenological parameterization card with either relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (decay produced; small-scale effect unknown); it touches indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_07206_type_i_nmssm_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_07206", "source_line": 3943, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 3597, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative sneutrino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_04198_vector_dm_cs_kinetic_mixing_v1", "paper_id": "1706_04198", "source_line": 3187, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3598, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 10.5: Vector dark matter with Chern-Simons coupling and kinetic-mixing Z prime portal is a speculative effective field theory entry with thermal WIMP freeze-out through vector-mediated annihilation.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection, indirect detection, laboratory precision.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_07388_so7_g2_composite_triplet_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_07388", "source_line": 3172, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3599, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 10.5: SO(7)/G_2 composite inert-triplet pNGB dark matter is a speculative effective field theory entry with thermal WIMP freeze-out of the neutral triplet pNGB.", "Rank-relevant positives are medium CMB relevance, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: CMB, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauge_higgs_unification_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_3741_gauge_higgs_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0910_3741", "source_line": 1034, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3600, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 41.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 10.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family gauge_higgs_unification_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2210_14171_pbh_clusteringenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2210_14171", "source_line": 5354, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 181, "global_rank": 3601, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Primordial black hole clusteringenesis scenario has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: CMB, compact objects, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_04128_nonuniversal_u1x_scalar_singlet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1512_04128", "source_line": 2710, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3602, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: collider, direct detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_0582_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1312_0582", "source_line": 2002, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 141, "global_rank": 3603, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=partial and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_8251_cmssm_iss_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1401_8251", "source_line": 2025, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 142, "global_rank": 3604, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=partial and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_1431_mass_degenerate_majorana_scalar_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1207_1431", "source_line": 1647, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 3605, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Mass-degenerate Majorana fermion scalar-mediator dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_0864_radiative_inverse_seesaw_fermionic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1207_0864", "source_line": 1631, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 3606, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Radiative inverse seesaw fermionic Higgs-portal dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_07592_flux_mediated_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2103_07592", "source_line": 4638, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 272, "global_rank": 3607, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dilaton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_1319_dilaton_assisted_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0909_1319", "source_line": 1018, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3608, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 10.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family dilaton_mediated_dark_matter, theory level effective_field_theory, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dilaton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_1319_dilaton_assisted_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0909_1319", "source_line": 1019, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3609, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 10.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family dilaton_mediated_dark_matter, theory level effective_field_theory, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_4667_pq_wino_like_adjoint_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0906_4667", "source_line": 1008, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3610, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 10.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family electroweak_triplet_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_4496_hidden_vector_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0912_4496", "source_line": 1036, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3611, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 10.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family hidden_vector_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_07297_su2_lepton_partner_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1705_07297", "source_line": 3174, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 101, "global_rank": 3612, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 10.5: SU(2)_ell partner-of-right-handed-neutrino asymmetric dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with asymmetric dark matter number generated with lepton asymmetry by SU(2)_ell instantons during a first-order phase transition.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, gravitational waves.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_b_minus_l_majorana_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_08737_alternative_bl_neutrinophilic_2hdm_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_08737", "source_line": 3197, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3613, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 10.5: Alternative U(1)_B-L neutrinophilic 2HDM Majorana dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out through s-channel Z' exchange to fermion pairs.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "confining_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_09827_thermal_squeezeout_dark_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "2103_09827", "source_line": 4632, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3614, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative confining hidden sector dark matter entry with simplified_model theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; useful diversity value; probe classes inferred from card fields include gravitational waves. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07894_gauged_one_loop_z2_radiative_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07894", "source_line": 2740, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.2, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 3615, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_00759_hot_nede_dark_electroweak_planckian_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_00759", "source_line": 4986, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 273, "global_rank": 3616, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and gravitational freeze-in at high energies close to the Planck scale.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space, suppression small-scale power, scale dependent growth transfer-function shape; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_12377_leptophilic_majorana_conversion_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2212_12377", "source_line": 5468, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 169, "global_rank": 3617, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 9.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Leptophilic Majorana t-channel portal dark matter with conversion and freeze-in regimes has limited supplied theoretical scoring fields, high BBN relevance, mixed_cold_warm phase space, suppression small-scale-power effect, smooth_cutoff transfer shape, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_2346_hidden_hot_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0912_2346", "source_line": 1052, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 274, "global_rank": 3618, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative phenomenological_parameterization hidden_sector_dark_matter; structure signal (suppression, smooth_cutoff).", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_06320_stable_light_fermion_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_06320", "source_line": 2884, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 275, "global_rank": 3619, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space population; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_10229_decaying_dm_photon_coupling_v1", "paper_id": "1803_10229", "source_line": 121, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 3620, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative decaying_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and high CMB relevance, suppression small-scale-power effect, scale dependent growth transfer behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_08675_nonminimal_natural_inflation_fermion_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2306_08675", "source_line": 5665, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 170, "global_rank": 3621, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Fermionic FIMP dark matter from non-minimal natural inflation (freeze_in_dark_matter) has nonthermal phase-space information, gravitational, other portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 10.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_08675_periodic_nonminimal_natural_inflation_fermion_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2306_08675", "source_line": 5666, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 171, "global_rank": 3622, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Fermionic FIMP dark matter from periodic non-minimal natural inflation (freeze_in_dark_matter) has nonthermal phase-space information, gravitational, other portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support. Raw score 10.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_11293_diluted_thermal_relic_with_dilutor_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2206_11293", "source_line": 5215, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 3623, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, suppression of small-scale power; mixed cold warm phase-space behavior, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2403_15979_lorentz_bump_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_15979", "source_line": 142, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 182, "global_rank": 3624, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and high CMB relevance, enhancement small-scale-power effect, enhanced small scale power transfer behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_5243_milli_interacting_dark_atoms_v1", "paper_id": "1401_5243", "source_line": 1995, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 276, "global_rank": 3625, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct, small-scale structure; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_7862_warped_accidental_heavy_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1310_7862", "source_line": 1958, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3626, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bound_graviton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_02534_graviball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_02534", "source_line": 4271, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3627, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative bound_graviton_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support, production via formation in high-energy graviton-graviton or multi-graviton gravitational scattering; black-hole/geon-like gravitational collapse of energetic gravitons, rare or sparse-family diversity value in the supplied population counts.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified; a high-severity model-card warning was retained as a penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_07261_self_interacting_scalar_soliton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_07261", "source_line": 3785, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 99, "global_rank": 3628, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 10 because the card identifies production via field fragmentation from attractive self-interaction instability, soliton formation from cosmological initial conditions, field_like phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0609731_relic_neutrino_cdm_mixture_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0609731", "source_line": 151, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 141, "global_rank": 3629, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 10.0 for multi_component_dark_matter: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior, mixed in small-scale power, diversity credit from distinctive card fields, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_14629_dimension8_higgs_portal_freeze_in_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_14629", "source_line": 5753, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 172, "global_rank": 3630, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Dimension-8 Higgs-portal freeze-in scalar dark matter has limited but scoreable model-card content; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: eft_validity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_05716_condensed_neutrino_object_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_05716", "source_line": 215, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3631, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative neutrino_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: ordinary_neutrino_borderline."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0511774_preinflationary_axion_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0511774", "source_line": 627, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 245, "global_rank": 3632, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, moderate diversity value within the population-count context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bosonic_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9902272_quantum_dew_bose_condensate_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9902272", "source_line": 6120, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3633, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 10 (defer) from supplied card content: bosonic_condensate_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and unknown all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Penalties (18) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "spectator_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_02586_spectator_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1811_02586", "source_line": 3660, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3634, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative spectator_scalar_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes; high CMB relevance; field_like phase-space behavior; high model-card diversity value from population-count rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2404_02295_no_scale_spectator_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2404_02295", "source_line": 136, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 183, "global_rank": 3635, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with uv complete theory-level support and high CMB relevance, enhancement small-scale-power effect.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dynamic_vacuum_dark_matter", "model_id": "0806_2805_dynamic_vacuum_variable_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "0806_2805", "source_line": 295, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3636, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Dynamic vacuum-variable oscillating cold dark matter, a speculative dynamic vacuum dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and medium CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, field like phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: not-particle-dm, clustering-unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_13263_post_inflationary_alp_z_n_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_13263", "source_line": 5483, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 246, "global_rank": 3637, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Post-inflationary N>1 ALP dark matter with softly broken residual Z_N has solid theory/motivation content, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase space, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0210052_disappearing_brane_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0210052", "source_line": 201, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 3638, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative decaying_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=medium, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: BBN, CMB, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2109_05571_cep_holographic_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2109_05571", "source_line": 4817, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 184, "global_rank": 3639, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_6738_10_gev_neutralino_light_stau_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_6738", "source_line": 1940, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 143, "global_rank": 3640, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 10.0 because the model card is a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; medium BBN and unknown CMB relevance and touches BBN, collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2003_02778_accreting_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2003_02778", "source_line": 4187, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 185, "global_rank": 3641, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of primordial_black_holes; rank-relevant features include medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, 2 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity credit reflects a comparatively distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or dominant probe class in the population context.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_6386_darkonium_universal_bound_state_v1", "paper_id": "1311_6386", "source_line": 1992, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3642, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: indirect detection, small-scale structure; some diversity credit from family or production distinctiveness; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_04931_self_interacting_singlet_fermion_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1507_04931", "source_line": 2571, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 100, "global_rank": 3643, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory level; score-relevant card features include high BBN relevance.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_09784_exotic_fermion_neutrino_electron_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2102_09784", "source_line": 4581, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3644, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative neutrino_portal_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=high and BBN=high.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_11058_puffy_self_interacting_dm_yukawa_v1", "paper_id": "2303_11058", "source_line": 5579, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value after penalties for missing or sparse observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support."], "family_rank": 101, "global_rank": 3645, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: puffy self-interacting dark matter is phenomenologically distinct, but the card does not specify relic production or concrete observational routing.", "Global, percentile, and family ranks are intentionally left null for parent aggregation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0608344_thermal_gravitino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0608344", "source_line": 605, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 3646, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0609246_gravitino_lsp_sneutrino_nlsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0609246", "source_line": 646, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 3647, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0606234_holomorphic_thermal_inflation_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0606234", "source_line": 635, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3648, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, high diversity value within the population-count context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2287_broken_r_parity_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2287", "source_line": 758, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 3649, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 10.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance critical, phase-space type nonthermal; probe classes counted: ['BBN'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_06590_qcd_axion_hidden_photon_coupled_v1", "paper_id": "1711_06590", "source_line": 3286, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 247, "global_rank": 3650, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion like dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space structure.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching CMB.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 10.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_0491_neutralino_dark_matter_from_heavy_axino_decay_v1", "paper_id": "0801_0491", "source_line": 810, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3651, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/high, phase space is nonthermal. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_07705_z3_cp_violating_semi_annihilation_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_07705", "source_line": 4251, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority in this model-card-only pass because explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 102, "global_rank": 3652, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied card gives speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support, production via thermal semi-annihilation freeze-out; asymmetry generation by CP-violating 2-to-2 annihilation.", "Limited by the model-card-only extraction: explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and benchmark points are absent in this card; no reusable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "k_essence_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_04460_two_field_pure_k_essence_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_04460", "source_line": 59, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3653, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this k_essence_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_colored_partner_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_08100_z2_fermion_colored_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1602_08100", "source_line": 2784, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3654, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in coannihilating_colored_partner_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out with X-chi coannihilation; portals: other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_colored_partner_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_08100_z2_scalar_colored_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1602_08100", "source_line": 2785, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3655, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in coannihilating_colored_partner_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: thermal freeze-out with X-chi coannihilation; portals: other.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_06739_axion_like_dilaton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_06739", "source_line": 5409, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Observational extension would need external routing and constraints not present in the allowed card content."], "family_rank": 248, "global_rank": 3656, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: the axion-like dilaton model has field-like phase-space and CMB relevance, but no concrete observable, constraint, route, or code support is supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0703130_gravitino_dm_sneutrino_nlsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0703130", "source_line": 691, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 3657, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior, distinct observational-probe emphasis; limited computational support; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hadrophilic_pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_01939_hadrophilic_pseudoscalar_mediator_light_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_01939", "source_line": 4458, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3658, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for hadrophilic_pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 10.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_07917_hidden_sector_monopole_kibble_zurek_emd_v1", "paper_id": "2007_07917", "source_line": 4310, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3659, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Hidden-sector monopole topological dark matter with early matter domination as a speculative topological_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and production via Kibble-Zurek production of monopoles in a hidden-sector second-order phase transition.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=unknown and BBN=high; phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "rayleigh_coupled_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_03383_magnetomorphic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2010_03383", "source_line": 4479, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3660, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for rayleigh_coupled_scalar_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from field_like phase-space history, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 10.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_12906_uv_freeze_in_time_dependent_reheating_v1", "paper_id": "2202_12906", "source_line": 5073, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card."], "family_rank": 173, "global_rank": 3661, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 40.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 10 (defer) as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: limited but nonzero model-card support.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Motivation hooks from supplied fields: inflation/reheating, hidden/multicomponent/freeze-in.", "Production summary used: UV freeze-in during reheating; SM bath annihilation through higher-dimensional operators."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_2491_pqmssm_mixed_axion_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1110_2491", "source_line": 1443, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 142, "global_rank": 3662, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 10.0 because the card describes multi component dark matter at uv complete level, with neutralino thermal freeze-out; axion coherent oscillations and high BBN relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0612235_gravitino_lsp_slepton_nlsp_msugra_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0612235", "source_line": 692, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3663, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_self_interacting_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_04951_hidden_singlet_scalar_freeze_in_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_04951", "source_line": 2945, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3664, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_self_interacting_scalar_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it can supply the full dark-matter abundance in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance high, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type decay_produced, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_decay_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_13272_spinhalf_relativistic_decay_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2212_13272", "source_line": 5500, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3665, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Spin-1/2 relativistic-decay dark matter EFT has some theory and relic-density motivation, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, decay_produced phase space, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_04552_scalar_singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1604_04552", "source_line": 2800, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because observational-extension fields, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 3666, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer from the supplied card: speculative simplified_model in higgs_portal_dark_matter.", "Leverage comes from production: not specified in detail; WIMP-like Higgs-portal thermal production is implied but the paper focuses on invisible decays and direct detection; portals: higgs.", "Score is limited by empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5171_massive_neutrino_halo_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5171", "source_line": 1484, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 143, "global_rank": 3667, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable sterile_neutrino_dark_matter variant and records cosmological relic neutrino background gravitationally clusters into galactic halos.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_03690_pev_dm_nonlocal_gravity_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2206_03690", "source_line": 5196, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 174, "global_rank": 3668, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: nonlocal-gravity PeV freeze-in has BBN/pre-BBN cosmology relevance, but particle identity fields and structure behavior are too unknown for strong follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_03644_two_fraction_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1505_03644", "source_line": 78, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 3669, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this decaying_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_03553_light_scalar_dm_resonant_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2109_03553", "source_line": 4824, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 3670, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_1776_wimp_dark_gauge_boson_dark_fermion_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1303_1776", "source_line": 1802, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 277, "global_rank": 3671, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal; CMB relevance is high.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on CMB, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_03553_light_scalar_dm_forbidden_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2109_03553", "source_line": 4825, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 3672, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_02486_neutrinophilic_scalar_triplet_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_02486", "source_line": 3634, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 3673, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative decaying_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "frustrated_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_17607_frustrated_dm_diquark_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2312_17607", "source_line": 5930, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3674, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Frustrated dark matter with di-quark portal messenger sectors is a speculative frustrated_dark_matter card with unknown phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and collider, indirect detection from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 7, observational leverage 3, complementarity 5, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 4.0, penalties 18; raw score 10.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_11038_cold_su2_hidden_sector_gauge_boson_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_11038", "source_line": 3719, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 278, "global_rank": 3675, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Cold SU(2) hidden-sector gauge-boson dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, probe relevance for BBN, CMB; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kk_graviton_mediated_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_10583_lepto_philic_rs_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_10583", "source_line": 3838, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3676, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, annihilation through s-channel KK graviton exchange.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kk_graviton_mediated_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_10583_top_philic_rs_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_10583", "source_line": 3834, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3677, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, annihilation through s-channel KK graviton exchange.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_11173_axion_hybrid_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_11173", "source_line": 4590, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 249, "global_rank": 3678, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=medium and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_05275_residual_discrete_higgs_portal_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2202_05275", "source_line": 5075, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the supplied card lacks explicit observables and/or theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by sparse computational representation, benchmark, likelihood, or public-code support.", "Applicable constraints are not explicitly supplied in the card.", "High-severity warning(s) reduce confidence but do not meet the strict elimination gate."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 3679, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 10 (defer) as a speculative simplified_model member of higgs_portal_dark_matter.", "Positive factors: limited but nonzero model-card support.", "Limiting factors: no explicit observables block; no explicit applicable-constraints block; no theory-to-observable routes; sparse code or computational representation.", "Inferred probe classes from supplied fields: direct/lab, collider/accelerator.", "Production summary used: thermal WIMP production through Higgs portal interactions."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermion_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0612_fermion_portal_complex_scalar_down_quark_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0612", "source_line": 1922, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3680, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 10.0 because the model card is a speculative fermion_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermion_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0612_fermion_portal_complex_scalar_up_quark_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0612", "source_line": 1921, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3681, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 10.0 because the model card is a speculative fermion_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0608127_anomaly_mediated_wino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0608127", "source_line": 633, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 3682, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_pion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_4423_strong_hidden_sector_dark_pion_v1", "paper_id": "1310_4423", "source_line": 1904, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3683, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 10.0 because the model card is a speculative composite_dark_pion_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support; high diversity value in the registry population and touches direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9809489_inflaton_induced_superheavy_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9809489", "source_line": 6128, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3684, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 10 (defer) from supplied card content: superheavy_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_00834_relaxino_relaxion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1509_00834", "source_line": 2548, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 143, "global_rank": 3685, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Relaxino and relaxion dark matter in natural heavy supersymmetry: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 10.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_06632_minimal_wtc_multicomponent_dark_atom_v1", "paper_id": "2401_06632", "source_line": 5990, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 144, "global_rank": 3686, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from multi_component_dark_matter: Minimal walking technicolor multicomponent dark atom dark matter has moderate model/theory value through asymmetric production through nonperturbative electroweak sphaleron transitions transferring baryon/lepton asymmetry to techniparticle excess, formation of X-helium dark atoms by binding stable multiply charged cores with primordial helium; inferred probe classes are BBN.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_06520_paper_boat_relaxion_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_06520", "source_line": 3642, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 250, "global_rank": 3687, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative axion_like_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_scalar_higgs_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1202_5231_radiative_higgs_triplet_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_5231", "source_line": 1532, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current model-card-only score because explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields are absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3688, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: speculative status, simplified model theory level, and inert scalar higgs triplet dark matter identity.", "Observational follow-up value is driven by card-level probe hints (galaxy satellites) plus cosmology/phase-space/structure fields, while absent observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation blocks add penalties.", "Auditability is supported by provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning metadata; feasibility gets little code credit from the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_03902_resonant_vector_dark_matter_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "2211_03902", "source_line": 5448, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Inflationary production hooks are under-specified for observational extension without supplied observables, constraints, or routing."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3689, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but distinctive: resonant vector production during inflation has nonthermal approximate phase-space support and rare vector diversity, but no concrete observable route or code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_02518_powerlaw_interacting_dark_matter_dark_energy_v1", "paper_id": "1506_02518", "source_line": 260, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3690, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Power-law interacting dark matter and dark energy fluid model, a speculative interacting dark sector dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, scale dependent growth transfer behavior.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: 1506_fluid_not_particle_uv."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boosted_light_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_11837_atmospheric_boosted_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2006_11837", "source_line": 4318, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3691, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Atmospheric boosted dark matter with scalar and vector mediators as a speculative boosted_light_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via cosmic-ray proton collisions with atmospheric nitrogen producing mesons.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type decay_produced.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: present_day_flux_not_relic."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "tachyon_matter_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0208019_born_infeld_tachyon_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0208019", "source_line": 447, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3692, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value, partial computational support from associated code or calculations; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, a high-severity card warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_00436_asymmetric_bose_gas_wimp_like_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1709_00436", "source_line": 3221, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 103, "global_rank": 3693, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Asymmetric Bose gas Higgs-portal dark matter is a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with CMB/BBN relevance medium/medium, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_04388_modified_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1709_04388", "source_line": 3217, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3694, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Modified Dark Matter is a speculative modified_dark_matter card with CMB/BBN relevance high/unknown, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_03516_superheavy_scalar_inflaton_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "1812_03516", "source_line": 3752, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3695, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 10 because the card identifies production via inflaton-induced displacement during inflation, post-inflationary coherent oscillations, field_like phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higher_spin_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_15125_higher_spin_bosonic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2010_15125", "source_line": 4477, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3696, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for higher_spin_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from nonthermal phase-space history, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 10.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_03760_majorana_cp_even_higgs_portal_strong_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2405_03760", "source_line": 6086, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3697, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 10.0: speculative effective field theory model in higgs_portal_freeze_in_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_03760_vector_higgs_portal_strong_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2405_03760", "source_line": 6088, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3698, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 10.0: speculative effective field theory model in higgs_portal_freeze_in_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0109230_decay_produced_superheavy_x_from_y_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0109230", "source_line": 410, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3699, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0109230_direct_tachyonic_preheating_superheavy_x_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0109230", "source_line": 409, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3700, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0810_3285_generalized_g2_mssm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0810_3285", "source_line": 912, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3701, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, nonthermal phase-space character, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_10314_majorana_light_fermion_dark_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "1807_10314", "source_line": 3611, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 279, "global_rank": 3702, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_10314_secluded_dark_higgs_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1807_10314", "source_line": 3612, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 280, "global_rank": 3703, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0504036_kklt_moduli_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0504036", "source_line": 587, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 144, "global_rank": 3704, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["KKLT-type heavy-gravitino mixed neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production described as standard thermal freeze-out of neutralinos.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN, CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_1646_pq_nmssm_singlet_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1002_1646", "source_line": 1087, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 281, "global_rank": 3705, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model hidden_sector_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium, BBN medium).", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2304_12558_improved_e_model_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2304_12558", "source_line": 309, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 186, "global_rank": 3706, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is high.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, compact-object dynamics; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:fine_tuning, medium:mass_estimate_uncertainty.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/2/5/0/9/2/16."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2104_08654_no_scale_modified_superpotential_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_08654", "source_line": 4662, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 187, "global_rank": 3707, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; probe relevance for CMB, compact objects.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "viscous_dark_fluid", "model_id": "0710_0210_viscous_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "0710_0210", "source_line": 10, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3708, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "braneworld_dark_matter", "model_id": "0805_1792_braneworld_bulk_injected_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0805_1792", "source_line": 38, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3709, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance and medium BBN relevance, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_1992_trilinear_rpv_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_1992", "source_line": 1770, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 3710, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 10: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: BBN relevance high; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as BBN.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 16; computational/code fields add feasibility support; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_2067_r_parity_breaking_gravitino_v1", "paper_id": "0809_2067", "source_line": 841, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 3711, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked yes, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/high. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_5030_bilinear_r_parity_breaking_gravitino_v1", "paper_id": "0809_5030", "source_line": 842, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 3712, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked yes, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/high. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "co_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_03110_co_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1607_03110", "source_line": 2827, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3713, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from BBN relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph9810362_nonthermal_wimpzilla_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9810362", "source_line": 6139, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3714, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 10 (defer) from supplied card content: superheavy_nonthermal_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and yes all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_06050_hidden_sector_singlino_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_06050", "source_line": 4665, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3715, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; high BBN relevance; probe relevance for BBN.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermi_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0112315_charged_fermi_ball_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0112315", "source_line": 445, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3716, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive model class; probe signal: compact objects.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_4540_mssm8_neutralino_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1003_4540", "source_line": 1102, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 145, "global_rank": 3717, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization entry in supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_00552_radiative_seesaw_freeze_in_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_00552", "source_line": 4691, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 175, "global_rank": 3718, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level uv_complete, and relic production parameter_dependent; nonthermal phase space.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_08485_extended_t1_2_a_scotogenic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2301_08485", "source_line": 5485, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 3719, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Extended T1-2-A scotogenic dark matter has solid theory/motivation content, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_6472_local_baryon_number_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_6472", "source_line": 2005, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 104, "global_rank": 3720, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=nonthermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_01591_fermionic_quintuplet_mdm_rhn_v1", "paper_id": "1507_01591", "source_line": 2544, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3721, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Right-handed-neutrino nonthermal fermionic quintuplet minimal dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 10.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_01591_scalar_septuplet_mdm_rhn_v1", "paper_id": "1507_01591", "source_line": 2545, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3722, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 39.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Right-handed-neutrino nonthermal scalar septuplet minimal dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 10.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_07355_electroweak_skyrmion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1605_07355", "source_line": 2821, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3723, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_04293_vector_higgs_portal_wimpzilla_v1", "paper_id": "1708_04293", "source_line": 3209, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3724, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Vector Higgs-portal WIMPzilla is a speculative superheavy_higgs_portal_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_04105_clockwork_higgs_portal_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1709_04105", "source_line": 3239, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 176, "global_rank": 3725, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Clockwork Higgs-portal freeze-in dark matter is a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_2830_throat_kaluza_klein_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1002_2830", "source_line": 1071, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 282, "global_rank": 3726, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete hidden_sector_dark_matter; nonthermal phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dipolar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_5515_dipolar_dark_baryon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1007_5515", "source_line": 1133, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3727, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory entry in asymmetric_dipolar_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase space, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_4977_secluded_su2_hidden_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_4977", "source_line": 2082, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3728, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of secluded_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_11192_damp_pi_hilltop_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_11192", "source_line": 3721, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 251, "global_rank": 3729, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Dynamical Axion Misalignment Production to the hilltop is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, field like phase-space behavior; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0107053_uniton_superstring_relic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0107053", "source_line": 393, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3730, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative uv_complete model; production via nonthermal gravitational production; production during preheating or reheating after inflation; nonthermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_00889_new_type_charged_q_ball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_00889", "source_line": 3026, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 3731, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["New-type charged Q-ball dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; uses a nonthermal phase-space history; adds high diversity value for this batch; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_00778_ksvz_axion_quasi_degenerate_minima_v1", "paper_id": "1807_00778", "source_line": 3572, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 252, "global_rank": 3732, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has field-like phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_08174_automatic_pq_composite_axion_adjoint_v1", "paper_id": "1812_08174", "source_line": 3717, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 253, "global_rank": 3733, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Automatic PQ composite axion Model II with QCD adjoint exotic fermions is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, field like phase-space behavior; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_08174_automatic_pq_composite_axion_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1812_08174", "source_line": 3716, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 254, "global_rank": 3734, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Automatic PQ composite axion Model I with QCD triplet exotic fermions is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, field like phase-space behavior; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_0005_hidden_zprime_fermion_dm_dimension_six_v1", "paper_id": "1307_0005", "source_line": 1862, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3735, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative effective-field-theory model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_05554_natural_nmssm_singlino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1505_05554", "source_line": 2491, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 146, "global_rank": 3736, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=yes.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=309, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_1413_two_singlet_light_scalar_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1201_1413", "source_line": 1491, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 3737, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable scalar_singlet_dark_matter variant and records thermal cold-dark-matter relic-density solution through scalar singlet interactions.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_2197_no_scale_f_su5_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1101_2197", "source_line": 1264, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 147, "global_rank": 3738, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 10 for No-Scale F-SU(5) neutralino dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is medium; probe hints: CMB, collider.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_2145_hidden_singlet_cascade_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0902_2145", "source_line": 976, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 283, "global_rank": 3739, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_7874_fermionic_dark_photon_bound_state_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_7874", "source_line": 2288, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 284, "global_rank": 3740, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_09300_higgs_aligned_dark_lepton_atom_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_09300", "source_line": 3019, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 285, "global_rank": 3741, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Higgs-aligned dark lepton and dark atom dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "baryonic_macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_1103_hgd_primordial_gas_planet_pgc_v1", "paper_id": "1210_1103", "source_line": 217, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3742, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 9, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative baryonic_macroscopic_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: compact-object/dynamical, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: non_bsm_baryonic_model, nonstandard_cosmology."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_2527_mssm_right_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1401_2527", "source_line": 2021, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 3743, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=yes and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_09382_hidden_u1_majorana_dark_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "1605_09382", "source_line": 2814, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 286, "global_rank": 3744, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_04416_higgsino_dominated_nmssm_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1606_04416", "source_line": 2832, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 148, "global_rank": 3745, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked yes.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "little_higgs_dark_matter", "model_id": "0911_2389_little_higgs_z_parity_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0911_2389", "source_line": 1062, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3746, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model little_higgs_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium); above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimensions_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0303497_homogeneous_ued_lkp_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0303497", "source_line": 419, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3747, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value, partial computational support from associated code or calculations; probe signal: cmb.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, a high-severity card warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1605_04974_pbh_two_stage_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_04974", "source_line": 2830, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 188, "global_rank": 3748, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_03878_lr_su2r_quintuplet_minimal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_03878", "source_line": 2834, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3749, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter_compact_star_capture", "model_id": "2405_12277_heavy_asymmetric_dm_wd_collapse_v1", "paper_id": "2405_12277", "source_line": 6052, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3750, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 10.0: speculative phenomenological parameterization model in asymmetric_dark_matter_compact_star_capture, with relic-density capability recorded as unknown.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: compact objects/dynamics.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauge_higgs_unification_stable_higgs_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_6076_so5_u1_gauge_higgs_stable_higgs_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1103_6076", "source_line": 1327, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3751, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for gauge_higgs_unification_stable_higgs_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "z_prime_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_07526_zbl_portal_rh_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_07526", "source_line": 2709, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3752, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: collider.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_08418_neutralino_gluino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1811_08418", "source_line": 3650, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3753, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative coannihilating_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_3639_weak_eigenstate_so10_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1111_3639", "source_line": 1437, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 149, "global_rank": 3754, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 10.0 because the card describes supersymmetric neutralino dark matter at simplified model level, with thermal freeze-out with neutralino annihilation through the CP-odd Higgs funnel; stau coannihilation in near-degenerate scan points and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage with partial associated-code support.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_like_lepton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03351_s3_2hdm_vll_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03351", "source_line": 4674, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3755, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_04761_spin_flipped_lmu_ltau_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_04761", "source_line": 3743, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3756, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Spin-flipped L_mu-L_tau scalar WIMP is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_01107_b_l_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_no_rhn_v1", "paper_id": "1704_01107", "source_line": 3103, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 287, "global_rank": 3757, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of hidden_sector_dark_matter with raw score 10.0.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance.", "Feasibility receives limited support from partial associated-code information, but explicit routes and benchmarks are absent.", "Penalties are moderate for missing observable/routing fields but partly offset by provenance, validity-domain, and robustness entries."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_01099_type_ii_seesaw_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_01099", "source_line": 3238, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 3758, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Type-II seesaw inert-doublet dark matter is a speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_4633_gaugino_anomaly_mediated_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1002_4633", "source_line": 1105, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 3759, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_4546_new_type_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1402_4546", "source_line": 2056, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3760, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of q_ball_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_multi_higgs_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_12470_z3_i2plus1hdm_hermaphrodite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1907_12470", "source_line": 3917, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3761, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative inert_multi_higgs_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_0658_type_ii_two_higgs_darkon_v1", "paper_id": "0811_0658", "source_line": 884, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 3762, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, simplified model theory level, parameter-dependent relic abundance, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimensions_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_1598_nonminimal_ued_kk_higgs_lkp_v1", "paper_id": "0811_1598", "source_line": 873, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority from the supplied model-card fields; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3763, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the supplied model card gives speculative but non-eliminated model-card status, effective field theory theory level, potential probe classes suggested by card fields: BBN, CMB, collider / fixed-target / beam dump and more. Score is limited by limited explicit observational-leverage fields, little usable code, benchmark, likelihood, or routing support, large model-card completeness penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_5452_bminusl_scalar_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_5452", "source_line": 1451, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 105, "global_rank": 3764, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable asymmetric_dark_matter variant and records B-L asymmetric production transferred from the SM sector.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_11804_mixed_particle_pbh_density_spike_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_11804", "source_line": 4352, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 145, "global_rank": 3765, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Mixed particle dark matter and primordial black hole density-spike model: PBHs form in the radiation-dominated era before particle-DM kinetic decoupling; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes compact-object/dynamics, indirect/transient, laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_5795_singlet_extended_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_5795", "source_line": 2289, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 3766, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_6157_pq_uv_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_6157", "source_line": 2276, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 177, "global_rank": 3767, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and unknown phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_6930_higgsino_like_pmssm_neutralino_sommerfeld_v1", "paper_id": "1411_6930", "source_line": 2336, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 150, "global_rank": 3768, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 10 because the assigned model card simplified model supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "magnetic_inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_3454_magnetic_inelastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1112_3454", "source_line": 1485, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3769, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable magnetic_inelastic_dark_matter variant and records standard thermal freeze-out of dipole-mediated annihilations.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "magnetic_dipole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_2951_magnetic_dipole_wimp_charged_messengers_v1", "paper_id": "1305_2951", "source_line": 1867, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3770, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3 while penalties total 17."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_05687_pseudoscalar_mfv_eft_galactic_center_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_05687", "source_line": 3001, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3771, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Pseudo-scalar MFV EFT Galactic Center dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_05687_vector_mfv_eft_galactic_center_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_05687", "source_line": 3002, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3772, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Vector MFV EFT Galactic Center dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_07413_su2x_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1501_07413", "source_line": 2382, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 288, "global_rank": 3773, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal annihilation production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_2619_nonabelian_su2_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_2619", "source_line": 2370, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 289, "global_rank": 3774, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal freeze-out through annihilation channels, resonant annihilation through X^3 near 2 m_DM production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_05698_focus_point_high_scale_susy_electroweakino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1501_05698", "source_line": 2409, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 3775, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a supersymmetric_dark_matter entry (uv_complete); implicit probe coverage includes CMB, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2863_nmssm_singlet_resonant_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2863", "source_line": 1565, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 151, "global_rank": 3776, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card gives a concrete UV supersymmetric resonant neutralino region with multiple probe handles implied by the portal structure, but it is narrow and has no supplied routing, constraints, or code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_mediator_wimp", "model_id": "1305_6609_scalar_mediator_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1305_6609", "source_line": 1839, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3777, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative scalar_mediator_wimp model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on collider, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_mixed_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_03116_singlet_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1506_03116", "source_line": 2500, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3778, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=benchmark, theory_level=simplified_model, family=electroweak_mixed_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=1, diversity_value=3.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_11579_u1x_dirac_dm_electron_channel_v1", "paper_id": "1711_11579", "source_line": 3278, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3779, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative vector mediator dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 10.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_11579_u1x_dirac_dm_on_shell_x_pair_v1", "paper_id": "1711_11579", "source_line": 3280, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3780, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative vector mediator dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 10.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_11579_u1x_dirac_dm_universal_fermion_channel_v1", "paper_id": "1711_11579", "source_line": 3279, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3781, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative vector mediator dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching galaxy satellites, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 10.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_twin_baryon_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_03520_full_twin_sector_adm_atoms_v1", "paper_id": "1506_03520", "source_line": 2462, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3782, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=asymmetric_twin_baryon_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=2, diversity_value=6.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dipole_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_3289_dipole_interacting_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1103_3289", "source_line": 1298, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3783, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 38.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 10 for Dipole-interacting Dirac fermion dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from probe hints: collider, direct detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_4506_fermi_degenerate_compact_ultradense_object_v1", "paper_id": "1303_4506", "source_line": 1803, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3784, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative macroscopic_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is not_applicable.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on compact-object dynamics, indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimpy_leptogenesis_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_6878_bl_violating_bardama_vectorlike_lepton_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1307_6878", "source_line": 1884, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3785, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with asymmetric/baryogenesis production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 6 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_3545_u1r_neutralino_a_funnel_v1", "paper_id": "0901_3545", "source_line": 963, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 152, "global_rank": 3786, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_2696_inert_higgsino_singlino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0905_2696", "source_line": 979, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 3787, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative neutralino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_5055_anomalous_ux_chiral_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0909_5055", "source_line": 968, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 290, "global_rank": 3788, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_0206_light_sneutrino_sism_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_0206", "source_line": 2125, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 3789, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: partial associated-code support is noted, but explicit routing and benchmark support are absent, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_6856_triplet_singlet_mssm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1304_6856", "source_line": 1814, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3790, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_2143_sism_light_sneutrino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1306_2143", "source_line": 1833, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 3791, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_10379_nugm_higgsino_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1703_10379", "source_line": 3014, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3792, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Higgsino-like neutralino dark matter in a non-universal gaugino-mass MSSM scenario is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauge_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_02453_anomaly_free_leptophobic_axial_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_02453", "source_line": 3636, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3793, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative gauge_portal_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "331_heavy_neutral_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_7802_331lhn_heavy_neutral_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1307_7802", "source_line": 1827, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3794, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative 331_heavy_neutral_fermion_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_2510_cmssm_rhn_neutralino_sneutrino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "0902_2510", "source_line": 974, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 3795, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative neutralino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_2847_anomaly_induced_two_component_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0905_2847", "source_line": 959, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 146, "global_rank": 3796, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_b_minus_l_singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_07101_d4_alternative_bl_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_07101", "source_line": 3562, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3797, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative gauged_b_minus_l_singlet_fermion_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_triplet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_4577_so10_s4_fermionic_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1011_4577", "source_line": 1261, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3798, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 10 for SO(10) x S4 hyperchargeless fermionic triplet dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from probe hints: direct detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_13098_twin_stau_self_interacting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2210_13098", "source_line": 5375, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 102, "global_rank": 3799, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Twin stau self-interacting dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0707_2812_top_squark_mediated_compressed_susy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0707_2812", "source_line": 763, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes"], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 3800, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 10.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance low, CMB relevance low; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_3368_singlet_scalar_lepton_specific_2hdm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_3368", "source_line": 1324, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 3801, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_1228_so10_negative_mu_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_1228", "source_line": 1337, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 153, "global_rank": 3802, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_2110_no_scale_fsu5_neutralino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1109_2110", "source_line": 1341, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 154, "global_rank": 3803, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_10451_dark_su2d_z4_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_10451", "source_line": 4719, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 147, "global_rank": 3804, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via thermal relic abundance from pair annihilation; semi-annihilation and semi-coannihilation among Z4-charged components.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 10 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_6180_stable_exotic_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_6180", "source_line": 1422, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3805, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 10.0 because the card describes electroweak doublet dark matter at effective field theory level, with thermal freeze-out of a pure Higgsino-like electroweak doublet and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage with partial associated-code support.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_05329_5d_mssm_bino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1606_05329", "source_line": 2816, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 155, "global_rank": 3806, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked yes.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_01001_csi_su3x_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_01001", "source_line": 2817, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 291, "global_rank": 3807, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked yes.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_04884_blssm_sneutrino_bound_state_v1", "paper_id": "2009_04884", "source_line": 4346, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3808, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes BLSSM right-handed sneutrino bound-state dark matter as a speculative right_handed_sneutrino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via thermal freeze-out.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_3225_singlet_extended_radiative_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1002_3225", "source_line": 1101, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3809, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in radiative_seesaw_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status partial and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_0180_stable_fourth_generation_ohelium_dark_atoms_v1", "paper_id": "1402_0180", "source_line": 2074, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3810, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of composite_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; partial associated computational tool support; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "quark_philic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_00697_up_type_quark_philic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_00697", "source_line": 3248, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3811, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Up-type quark-philic real scalar dark matter is a speculative quark_philic_scalar_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_8183_scale_invariant_u1x_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1401_8183", "source_line": 2015, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3812, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_05403_higgsino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1504_05403", "source_line": 2508, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3813, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Stable Higgsino dark matter in Naturalness redux: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 10.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "discrete_symmetry_scalar_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_0871_discrete_scalar_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1007_0871", "source_line": 1142, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3814, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in discrete_symmetry_scalar_doublet_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dissipative_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_02528_two_component_dissipative_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1707_02528", "source_line": 3246, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3815, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Two-component dissipative dark matter is a speculative dissipative_hidden_sector_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_higgs_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_07373_dark_cp_violating_3hdm_inert_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_07373", "source_line": 4733, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 10, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3816, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_higgs_doublet_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; freeze-in.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 10 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Diversity credit is elevated because the card occupies a sparse or phenomenologically distinctive family or production regime in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 10, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2211_13364_gb_higgs_inflation_pbh_plateau_type_v1", "paper_id": "2211_13364", "source_line": 5397, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 189, "global_rank": 3817, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Gauss-Bonnet Higgs-inflation PBH dark matter (plateau-type effective potential) has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: compact objects, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_11308_dark_force_charged_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2009_11308", "source_line": 4447, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 178, "global_rank": 3818, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes freeze-in from Higgs decays, freeze-in from higher-dimensional SM scattering before electroweak symmetry breaking.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase-space structure, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_02279_axion_axion_kinetic_mixing_ultralight_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_02279", "source_line": 4408, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 3819, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes axion field misalignment or other axion population mechanism consistent with CDM-like redshifting.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space structure, suppression of small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer-function behavior.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_16945_self_interacting_fuzzy_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2402_16945", "source_line": 199, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 3820, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 9.5 for fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter: positive factors include field_like phase-space behavior, smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior, suppression in small-scale power, diversity credit from distinctive card fields, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_17371_warm_inflation_uv_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2401_17371", "source_line": 5960, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 179, "global_rank": 3821, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from freeze_in_dark_matter: Warm-inflation ultraviolet freeze-in dark matter has moderate model/theory value through ultraviolet freeze-in during warm inflation; inferred probe classes are CMB.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superwimp_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0404231_supergravity_gravitino_lsp_thermal_nlsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0404231", "source_line": 496, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3822, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_superwimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0409278_gravitino_slepton_superwimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0409278", "source_line": 488, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3823, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_03657_codecaying_complex_scalar_secluded_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_03657", "source_line": 5941, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 292, "global_rank": 3824, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Codecaying complex scalar secluded-sector dark matter is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and no explicit routed probe class from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 9, observational leverage 5, complementarity 0, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 2.5, penalties 16; raw score 9.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_08374_dark_color_unification_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_08374", "source_line": 4983, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 106, "global_rank": 3825, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and asymmetric production by darko-baryo-genesis from late sterile-neutrino decay.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "2201_05903_logotropic_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "2201_05903", "source_line": 93, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3826, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this unified_dark_fluid card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and suppression in small-scale power, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_1268_top_hypercharge_gauged_z2_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_1268", "source_line": 728, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 3827, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_00119_large_pq_scale_axion_no_domain_wall_v1", "paper_id": "1507_00119", "source_line": 2589, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 255, "global_rank": 3828, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include field_like phase space, high CMB relevance.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0612368_nonminimal_split_susy_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0612368", "source_line": 702, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 156, "global_rank": 3829, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0701107_stueckelberg_millicharged_hidden_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0701107", "source_line": 705, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 293, "global_rank": 3830, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative uv_complete model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_17099_type_x_2hdm_axion_like_v1", "paper_id": "2312_17099", "source_line": 5923, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 256, "global_rank": 3831, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Type-X extended 2HDM axion-like dark matter is a speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and no explicit routed probe class from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 12, observational leverage 4, complementarity 0, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 2.5, penalties 18; raw score 9.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_15581_imploding_fermion_yukawa_blob_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_15581", "source_line": 5950, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3832, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Imploding fermion+Yukawa anti-baryonic dark blobs is a speculative macroscopic_composite_dark_matter card with not_applicable phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and compact objects, indirect detection from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 6, observational leverage 3, complementarity 5, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 6.5, penalties 20; raw score 9.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "feebly_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_03349_light_feebly_interacting_entropy_dilution_v1", "paper_id": "2312_03349", "source_line": 5909, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3833, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Light feebly interacting dark matter with EMD entropy dilution is a speculative feebly_interacting_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and gravitational waves from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 6, observational leverage 3, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 6.5, penalties 17; raw score 9.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inflaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_01729_disappearing_inflaton_potential_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1509_01729", "source_line": 2578, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3834, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative inflaton_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include nonthermal phase space, medium CMB relevance.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_15174_z3_phase_transition_fermionic_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2012_15174", "source_line": 4548, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 180, "global_rank": 3835, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cosmic_string_loop_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0504049_cycloop_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0504049", "source_line": 567, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3836, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Cycloop dark matter from brane-inflation cosmic strings is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card in family cosmic_string_loop_dark_matter with production described as nonthermal production by long-string interactions after brane collision.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase space.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1912_10437_parametric_resonance_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_10437", "source_line": 62, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 190, "global_rank": 3837, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this primordial_black_holes card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2104_08881_thermal_planck_mass_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2104_08881", "source_line": 4628, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 191, "global_rank": 3838, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial black holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and relic support marked yes; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include CMB, compact objects / microlensing / dynamics. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_04119_light_higgs_portal_thermal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_04119", "source_line": 2704, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 294, "global_rank": 3839, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB, direct detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_08426_wgc_singlet_doublet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_08426", "source_line": 3816, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3840, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as standard thermal freeze-out, co-annihilation with nearly degenerate neutral fermion chi_2.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_02574_abelian_magnetic_monopole_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_02574", "source_line": 4649, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 257, "global_rank": 3841, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative axion like dark matter entry with unknown theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_02574_nonabelian_color_magnetic_monopole_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_02574", "source_line": 4650, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority-tier defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly due to missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 258, "global_rank": 3842, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative axion like dark matter entry with unknown theory level and relic support marked parameter_dependent; limited positive scoring signals; probe classes inferred from card fields include laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches. The score is limited by absent model_comparison, observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, and computational-representation fields in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "early_matter_domination_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_05007_early_matter_domination_dm_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1711_05007", "source_line": 3324, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3843, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with parameter dependent relic-density support, high BBN relevance, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_11833_higgs_quadruplet_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_11833", "source_line": 5904, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 3844, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 37.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Higgs-quadruplet connector Majorana fermion dark matter is a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter card with unknown phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and collider from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 11, observational leverage 2, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 2.5, penalties 17; raw score 9.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_04911_polonyi_inflation_thermal_wino_v1", "paper_id": "1604_04911", "source_line": 2739, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3845, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves a card-local full-dark-matter production route, medium BBN relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: BBN.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_10167_stabilized_spacetime_boundary_bubble_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2210_10167", "source_line": 5380, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3846, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Stabilized spacetime-boundary bubble dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space, large penalties for missing observables, constraints, and follow-up machinery."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2401_11651_starobinsky_supergravity_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2401_11651", "source_line": 195, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 192, "global_rank": 3847, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 9.5 for primordial_black_holes: positive factors include effective_field_theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic-density viability, high CMB relevance, some associated computational support, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; current-data compatibility is unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_1653_r2_gravity_scalar_mode_v1", "paper_id": "0809_1653", "source_line": 840, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3848, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/low, phase space is field_like. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_12253_fermionic_inelastic_dark_matter_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2201_12253", "source_line": 5042, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 3849, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Fermionic inelastic dark matter with a dark photon mediator has probe classes: CMB, laboratory/particle, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_12253_scalar_inelastic_dark_matter_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2201_12253", "source_line": 5043, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 3850, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Scalar inelastic dark matter with a dark photon mediator has probe classes: CMB, laboratory/particle, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_08699_millicharged_minimal_dark_matter_dirac_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1709_08699", "source_line": 3300, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3851, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative cold dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching CMB, direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 9.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_6467_model_d_real_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1305_6467", "source_line": 1888, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3852, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, collider / fixed-target.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_04201_mixed_singlet_doublet_blind_spot_v1", "paper_id": "1704_04201", "source_line": 3180, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3853, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 9.5: Mixed singlet-doublet blind-spot scalar dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with thermal freeze-out of a well-tempered mixed scalar through gauge/contact and t-channel annihilation.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: direct detection, gravitational waves.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_6118_radiative_flavor_mini_split_wino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_6118", "source_line": 2048, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3854, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_01082_composite_dark_kaon_thermal_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1709_01082", "source_line": 3261, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3855, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative composite dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 9.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_4319_spontaneous_cogenesis_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_4319", "source_line": 1355, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 107, "global_rank": 3856, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as asymmetric_dark_matter: production is represented by spontaneous genesis of X asymmetry from rolling scalar background; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_3516_quark_flavored_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1109_3516", "source_line": 1368, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 3857, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as flavored_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal freeze-out; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by simplified_model structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "conversion_driven_freeze_out_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_09292_conversion_driven_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1705_09292", "source_line": 3119, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3858, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a emerging simplified_model member of conversion_driven_freeze_out_dark_matter with raw score 9.5.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level cosmology or structure fields.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 3.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_5985_high_scale_susy_higgsino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_5985", "source_line": 1619, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 157, "global_rank": 3859, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for High-scale SUSY Higgsino-like neutralino dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_5985_high_scale_susy_wino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_5985", "source_line": 1618, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 158, "global_rank": 3860, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 10, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for High-scale SUSY Wino-like neutralino dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with Lyman-alpha forest, collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cascade_annihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_2926_leptonic_axion_portal_cascade_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0901_2926", "source_line": 1006, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3861, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 9.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family cascade_annihilation_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptocentric_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_0771_leptocentric_u1_b_minus_3le_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0910_0771", "source_line": 1039, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3862, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 9.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family leptocentric_vector_portal_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptocentric_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_0771_leptocentric_u1_b_minus_3lmu_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0910_0771", "source_line": 1040, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3863, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 9.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family leptocentric_vector_portal_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptocentric_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_0771_leptocentric_u1_b_minus_3ltau_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0910_0771", "source_line": 1041, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3864, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 9.5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family leptocentric_vector_portal_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimpy_baryogenesis_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_6878_bl_conserving_bardama_vectorlike_quark_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1307_6878", "source_line": 1883, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3865, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with asymmetric/baryogenesis production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 5.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_12631_2hdma_light_pseudoscalar_benchmark_i_v1", "paper_id": "2202_12631", "source_line": 5040, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3866, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: 2HDM+a light-pseudoscalar dark matter benchmark I has probe classes: laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_12631_2hdma_light_pseudoscalar_benchmark_ii_v1", "paper_id": "2202_12631", "source_line": 5041, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3867, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: 2HDM+a light-pseudoscalar dark matter benchmark II has probe classes: laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_02886_pq_scotogenic_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_02886", "source_line": 3254, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3868, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scotogenic inert doublet dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 9.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_09984_modular_a4_b_l_light_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_09984", "source_line": 4815, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3869, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_01440_dark_su2_yang_mills_glueball_v1", "paper_id": "1910_01440", "source_line": 4007, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 295, "global_rank": 3870, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.9, "feasibility": 5, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19.6, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative uv_complete; rank-relevant evidence includes limited explicit observational handles in the supplied card.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_09063_dark_matter_decay_to_dark_photons_v1", "paper_id": "2209_09063", "source_line": 5376, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 3871, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Dark matter decay to dark photons with resonant photon conversion has some cosmology or phase-space leverage, probe classes: CMB, phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value, large penalties for missing observables, constraints, and follow-up machinery."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_11288_pbh_evaporation_multicomponent_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_11288", "source_line": 5363, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3872, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because PBH-evaporation multicomponent relic dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: compact objects, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_00758_sterile_neutrino_nssi_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2112_00758", "source_line": 4969, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 144, "global_rank": 3873, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile neutrino dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and nonthermal production by active-sterile oscillations and collisions.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space, suppression small-scale power, smooth cutoff transfer-function shape; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_08948_bec_solitonic_core_isothermal_halo_v1", "paper_id": "1810_08948", "source_line": 33, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3874, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_00892_ultralight_scalar_neutrino_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_00892", "source_line": 3579, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 3875, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter entry with effective-field-theory theory support; it has field-like phase-space behavior, has suppression in small-scale power.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "branon_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0310272_thermal_branon_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0310272", "source_line": 471, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3876, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by mixed small-scale-power effect; mixed_cold_warm transfer behavior.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_06836_u1prime_extended_msm_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_06836", "source_line": 2698, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 145, "global_rank": 3877, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 170. Observational leverage comes from suppression small-scale-power effect, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_02287_nonthermal_wimp_elastic_scattering_v1", "paper_id": "1611_02287", "source_line": 2972, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3878, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative nonthermal_wimp_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on decay_produced phase-space behavior.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_06358_heavy_inflaton_sterile_neutrino_freezein_v1", "paper_id": "2010_06358", "source_line": 4441, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3879, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes freeze-in from inflaton decay during reheating.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, high CMB relevance, decay produced phase-space structure.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_12120_f_portal_scalar_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2301_12120", "source_line": 5496, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 181, "global_rank": 3880, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: F-portal real scalar freeze-in dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase space, suppression small-scale-power effect, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_00322_esgb_chameleon_scalaron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2304_00322", "source_line": 219, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 3881, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative scalar_field_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=scale_dependent_growth, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: phenomenological_density_not_relic."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_07829_scalar_electroweak_quintuplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_07829", "source_line": 3760, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3882, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 9 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out, co-annihilation, thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: direct detection; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_07829_scalar_electroweak_septuplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_07829", "source_line": 3759, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3883, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 9 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out, co-annihilation, thermal phase-space treatment, probe classes: direct detection; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_07188_dirac_sharing_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_07188", "source_line": 2861, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 108, "global_rank": 3884, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium CMB relevance; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_07188_scalar_sharing_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_07188", "source_line": 2860, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 109, "global_rank": 3885, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card says it can produce all dark matter; medium CMB relevance; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0011385_low_reheat_nmssm_neutralino_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0011385", "source_line": 413, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 148, "global_rank": 3886, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: bbn.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_00013_pure_higgsino_variable_splitting_v1", "paper_id": "1903_00013", "source_line": 3801, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3887, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a benchmark effective field theory model with production listed as thermal freeze-out.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_04210_dirac_neutrino_dfsz_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_04210", "source_line": 4114, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 259, "global_rank": 3888, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 9: speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: field_like phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: no explicit probe routing objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_04210_dirac_neutrino_ksvz_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_04210", "source_line": 4113, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 260, "global_rank": 3889, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 9: speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: field_like phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: no explicit probe routing objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_08063_hidden_vector_dark_freezeout_3to2_v1", "paper_id": "1510_08063", "source_line": 2639, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 103, "global_rank": 3890, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Hidden vector dark matter with dark freeze-out 3-to-2 production is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'yes'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, limited but present observational leverage in phase-space or structure fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, nonthermal phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'nonthermal' and small-scale-power effect 'suppression'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_08063_hidden_vector_freezein_light_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1510_08063", "source_line": 2640, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 104, "global_rank": 3891, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Hidden vector dark matter with freeze-in via a light mediator is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'yes'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, limited but present observational leverage in phase-space or structure fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, nonthermal phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'nonthermal' and small-scale-power effect 'suppression'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_07196_axion_oscillation_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_07196", "source_line": 3693, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3892, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative dark_photon_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes; medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior; high model-card diversity value from population-count rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_quark_cluster_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_06820_superconducting_quark_cluster_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_06820", "source_line": 192, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3893, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 9.0 for macroscopic_quark_cluster_dark_matter: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, medium CMB relevance, strong BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_7901_higgs_portal_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_7901", "source_line": 1914, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 149, "global_rank": 3894, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 6, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 9.0 because the model card is a speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; unknown BBN and medium CMB relevance and touches CMB, direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1407_4306_velocity_diffusion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1407_4306", "source_line": 11, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3895, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_15380_leptonic_scalar_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_15380", "source_line": 4571, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 105, "global_rank": 3896, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=medium and BBN=high.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "gr_qc0303058_tev_braneworld_pbh_sulco_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "gr-qc0303058", "source_line": 424, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 193, "global_rank": 3897, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: compact objects.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0005123_low_reheat_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0005123", "source_line": 402, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 261, "global_rank": 3898, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, some cosmological or phase-space leverage, moderate diversity value; probe signal: bbn.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_3196_hidden_u1_gaugino_v1", "paper_id": "0809_3196", "source_line": 848, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 296, "global_rank": 3899, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/critical, phase space is mixed_cold_warm. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_03828_gravitationally_produced_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2009_03828", "source_line": 4387, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 3900, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Completely dark photon from gravitational particle production: gravitational particle production during inflation; some cosmological or phase-space leverage; inferred probe coverage includes CMB.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_06803_cc_bl_qcd_axion_on_scalar_thermal_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "2105_06803", "source_line": 4738, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 262, "global_rank": 3901, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via misalignment production of QCD axion fluctuations; thermal-inflation dilution after the QCD transition.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB; the raw score is 9 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_01674_type_ii_2hdm_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1606_01674", "source_line": 2853, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3902, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support, emphasizing 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0712_4206_inert_doublet_h0_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0712_4206", "source_line": 709, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 3903, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_0271_gravitino_sneutrino_nlsp_nuhm_v1", "paper_id": "0811_0271", "source_line": 827, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 3904, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/high, phase space is decay_produced. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_06896_gravitational_fermionic_dm_rhn_leptogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2103_06896", "source_line": 4657, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3905, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 36.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and relic production parameter_dependent; high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space; probe relevance for BBN.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_06896_gravitational_scalar_dm_rhn_leptogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2103_06896", "source_line": 4656, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3906, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and relic production parameter_dependent; high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase space; probe relevance for BBN.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_13292_sm_fermion_heavy_exotic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1909_13292", "source_line": 3998, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 150, "global_rank": 3907, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Two-component scalar dark matter with light-fermion loop mediator: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are indirect detection.", "Score 9 (defer) uses production=thermal freeze-out; thermal freeze-in; phase=unknown; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_08965_sgoldstino_suppressed_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_08965", "source_line": 3242, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 3908, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Sgoldstino-suppressed gravitino dark matter is a speculative gravitino_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_04176_real_representation_simp_dark_pions_v1", "paper_id": "2402_04176", "source_line": 5956, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 106, "global_rank": 3909, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from self_interacting_dark_matter: Real-representation SIMP dark pion model has moderate model/theory value through thermal SIMP freeze-out through WZW 3-to-2 cannibalization; inferred probe classes are no explicit probe classes.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_05655_q_ball_axino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1511_05655", "source_line": 2660, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3910, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability yes, and family count 13. Observational leverage comes from critical BBN relevance, decay_produced phase-space behavior.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "accidental_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_06975_gluequark_accidental_composite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_06975", "source_line": 3658, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3911, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative accidental_composite_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; high model-card diversity value from population-count rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_03627_vector_k_mouflage_charged_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_03627", "source_line": 338, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 107, "global_rank": 3912, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=unknown; observational features include CMB relevance is medium, transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB, small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:assumed-abundance.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 5/3/5/0/9/3/16."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_01384_asymmetron_scalarization_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1508_01384", "source_line": 209, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 3913, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative scalar_field_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=low, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=none, and probe classes: precision/fifth-force, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_04328_gravitino_dm_no_scale_b_l_higgs_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "2104_04328", "source_line": 4682, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 3914, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; probe relevance for BBN, CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kk_graviton_mediated_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_10583_lepto_philic_rs_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_10583", "source_line": 3839, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3915, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, annihilation through s-channel KK graviton exchange.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kk_graviton_mediated_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_10583_lepto_philic_rs_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_10583", "source_line": 3837, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3916, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, annihilation through s-channel KK graviton exchange.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kk_graviton_mediated_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_10583_lepto_philic_rs_spin_3_2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_10583", "source_line": 3840, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3917, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, annihilation through s-channel KK graviton exchange.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kk_graviton_mediated_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_10583_top_philic_rs_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_10583", "source_line": 3835, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3918, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, annihilation through s-channel KK graviton exchange.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kk_graviton_mediated_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_10583_top_philic_rs_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_10583", "source_line": 3833, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3919, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, annihilation through s-channel KK graviton exchange.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kk_graviton_mediated_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_10583_top_philic_rs_spin_3_2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_10583", "source_line": 3836, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3920, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out, annihilation through s-channel KK graviton exchange.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_03647_bactrian_two_resonance_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_03647", "source_line": 4598, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 3921, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative vector_portal_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=critical and BBN=medium.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermion_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0612_fermion_portal_dirac_down_quark_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0612", "source_line": 1918, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3922, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 9.0 because the model card is a speculative fermion_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermion_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0612_fermion_portal_dirac_up_quark_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0612", "source_line": 1917, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3923, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 9.0 because the model card is a speculative fermion_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermion_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0612_fermion_portal_majorana_down_quark_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0612", "source_line": 1920, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3924, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 9.0 because the model card is a speculative fermion_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermion_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0612_fermion_portal_majorana_up_quark_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0612", "source_line": 1919, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3925, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 9.0 because the model card is a speculative fermion_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_08736_wimp_triggered_baryogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "1605_08736", "source_line": 2840, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 297, "global_rank": 3926, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from BBN relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_5662_leptonic_asymmetric_dm_decay_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1003_5662", "source_line": 1089, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 110, "global_rank": 3927, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative effective_field_theory asymmetric_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium); nonthermal phase-space/production behavior.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_4015_sequestered_throat_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0801_4015", "source_line": 792, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 298, "global_rank": 3928, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 9.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance medium, phase-space type nonthermal; probe classes counted: ['BBN'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unparticle_dark_matter", "model_id": "0803_3223_unmatter_only_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0803_3223", "source_line": 814, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3929, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked yes, CMB/BBN relevance is high/unknown. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_02364_fimp_leptogenesis_fast_expanding_universe_v1", "paper_id": "2104_02364", "source_line": 4681, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 182, "global_rank": 3930, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium BBN relevance; decay_produced phase space; probe relevance for BBN.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "brane_world_radion_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9909373_brane_world_radion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9909373", "source_line": 6135, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3931, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 9 (defer) from supplied card content: brane_world_radion_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and no all-DM production; field_like phase-space behavior; cosmological relevance: BBN medium.", "Penalties (17) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_3624_pq_higgs_stability_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_3624", "source_line": 1633, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 263, "global_rank": 3932, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory card for Peccei-Quinn Higgs-stability axion dark matter correlation; it offers field like phase-space behavior; CMB relevance with CMB.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fourth_generation_heavy_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0411093_asymmetric_decaying_heavy_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0411093", "source_line": 557, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3933, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Asymmetric decaying fourth-generation heavy-neutrino subcomponent is a speculative uv complete card in family fourth_generation_heavy_neutrino_dark_matter with production described as thermal relic abundance modified by a primordial N/anti-N asymmetry.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase space; probe classes: halo/subhalo structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0011082_higgsino_like_neutralino_nonthermal_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0011082", "source_line": 380, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 3934, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative uv_complete model; production via nonthermal production from gravitino decay; nonthermal production from moduli decay; CMB relevance unknown and BBN relevance medium; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: BBN, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0011082_wino_like_neutralino_nonthermal_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0011082", "source_line": 381, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 3935, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative uv_complete model; production via nonthermal production from gravitino decay; nonthermal production from moduli decay; CMB relevance unknown and BBN relevance medium; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: BBN, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "torsion_vector_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_03651_torsion_higgs_portal_tdm2_v1", "paper_id": "1611_03651", "source_line": 2974, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3936, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative torsion_vector_higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and yes all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include fermion_coupling_stability."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hadrophilic_scalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_01939_hadrophilic_scalar_mediator_light_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_01939", "source_line": 4457, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3937, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for hadrophilic_scalar_mediator_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 9.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_00211_gravitational_heavy_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_00211", "source_line": 3720, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3938, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Gravitationally produced heavy scalar spectator dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, nonthermal phase-space behavior, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "exciting_dark_matter", "model_id": "0911_2222_exciting_dark_matter_metastable_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "0911_2222", "source_line": 1056, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3939, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model exciting_dark_matter; nonthermal phase-space/production behavior; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_13573_dark_photon_cosmic_string_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_13573", "source_line": 5460, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3940, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Dark photon dark matter from cosmic strings has some theory and relic-density motivation, nonthermal phase space, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_10353_fermionic_dm_scalar_vector_mediator_ns_v1", "paper_id": "2106_10353", "source_line": 4739, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 108, "global_rank": 3941, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production via thermal freeze-out in the early universe; capture/accretion into neutron stars by scattering and thermalization.", "Card-local leverage comes from compact objects/dynamics, structure formation; the raw score is 9 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "spin0_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_11070_cp_violating_spin0_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_11070", "source_line": 3821, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3942, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model model with production listed as thermal freeze-out.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code or named implementation support in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "0911_4483_parity_violating_composite_inelastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0911_4483", "source_line": 1027, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 109, "global_rank": 3943, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 9 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family self_interacting_dark_matter, theory level effective_field_theory, and nonthermal phase-space history, probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_13810_light_vector_dm_scalar_mediator_muon_g2_v1", "paper_id": "2104_13810", "source_line": 4664, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 3944, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; probe relevance for BBN, CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2107_07310_running_curvaton_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2107_07310", "source_line": 4805, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 194, "global_rank": 3945, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_5160_hidden_photon_dirac_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1211_5160", "source_line": 1675, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 299, "global_rank": 3946, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model entry; production is summarized as thermal annihilation through hidden-photon exchange, with thermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 9 reflects card-implied probe classes include direct detection, indirect detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_6217_controlled_fcnc_invisible_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_6217", "source_line": 2291, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 264, "global_rank": 3947, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and field_like phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by distinctive phase-space history, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_04444_dark_photon_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_04444", "source_line": 4397, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 3948, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Dark-photon-mediated inelastic dark matter for stellar cooling and XENON: nonthermal production of relic chi_1 allowed by assumption; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes indirect/transient, laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0610379_mssm_neutralino_nonstandard_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0610379", "source_line": 616, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 3949, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some computational or code support recorded in the model card, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_06032_two_component_doublet_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_06032", "source_line": 4558, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 151, "global_rank": 3950, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=medium and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_10809_inhomogeneous_inflaton_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_10809", "source_line": 5186, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 300, "global_rank": 3951, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: speculative conformal/inflaton CDM candidate has some CMB and phase-space content, but low robustness and nonstandard scaling warnings dominate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "0911_2664_fast_transition_unified_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0911_2664", "source_line": 1029, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3952, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 9 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, registry diversity value.", "Card-local details considered: identity family unified_dark_matter, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and probe handles: CMB.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_04007_asymmetric_sidm_light_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1507_04007", "source_line": 2536, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 110, "global_rank": 3953, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Asymmetric SIDM with light vector mediator: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 9.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_02393_long_range_self_interacting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2405_02393", "source_line": 6098, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 111, "global_rank": 3954, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 9.0: speculative simplified model model in self_interacting_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as unknown.", "Observational leverage comes from probe hints: compact objects/dynamics.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dipolar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_3114_dipolar_dark_matter_dark_energy_v1", "paper_id": "0901_3114", "source_line": 304, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3955, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is high.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:not_particle_relic, medium:linear_cdm_limit.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/2/2/0/9/4/16."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_1655_susy_gauge_mediated_hidden_sector_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1005_1655", "source_line": 1084, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 111, "global_rank": 3956, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative effective_field_theory asymmetric_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (BBN high).", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7335_decaying_axion_like_particle_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7335", "source_line": 2118, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 265, "global_rank": 3957, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: phase-space type is field_like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimpless_dark_matter", "model_id": "0806_3746_wimpless_dama_connector_v1", "paper_id": "0806_3746", "source_line": 830, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3958, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is high/unknown. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_compact_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_5377_gravipulson_dark_matter_lump_v1", "paper_id": "1106_5377", "source_line": 1343, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3959, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_all_dm=unknown.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level phase-space type field_like.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for scalar_field_compact_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_6221_oscillating_abelian_vector_field_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1203_6221", "source_line": 1594, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3960, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but diverse because the card describes a rare coherent vector-field dark-matter class with field-like phase space, but no relic-density calculation, SM coupling, or observational routing is supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_06107_diffusive_dst_interacting_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2104_06107", "source_line": 54, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3961, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this interacting_unified_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and high CMB relevance.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "co_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_03110_dark_su2d_vector_co_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1607_03110", "source_line": 2828, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3962, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from BBN relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_00538_sm_singlet_dark_baryon_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1908_00538", "source_line": 3936, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3963, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative composite_asymmetric_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_15697_electron_specific_scalar_mediator_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_15697", "source_line": 5933, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3964, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Scalar DM with an electron-specific spin-0 mediator is a benchmark scalar_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and collider from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 11, observational leverage 2, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 3.0, penalties 18; raw score 9.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_08418_stable_gluino_colored_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1811_08418", "source_line": 3649, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3965, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative strongly_interacting_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and no abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_13031_scotogenic_a5_a4_dirac_freeze_in_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2202_13031", "source_line": 5044, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 183, "global_rank": 3966, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 35.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Scotogenic A5 to A4 Dirac-neutrino freeze-in dark matter has probe classes: laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07894_gauged_two_loop_z3_model_ii_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07894", "source_line": 2742, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 3967, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_absorption_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10861_charged_current_fermionic_absorption_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10861", "source_line": 3939, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3968, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative fermionic_absorption_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from card-level relevance to CMB.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_15694_stochastic_relaxion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_15694", "source_line": 5401, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation leave low current observational-extension value."], "family_rank": 266, "global_rank": 3969, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the card has a speculative EFT relaxion/axion-like field that can produce all dark matter, but CMB/structure observables, constraints, routing, and usable code are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_02243_lambda_zero_linear_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_02243", "source_line": 5901, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 301, "global_rank": 3970, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because lambda_phi zero linear-breaking scalar singlet dark matter variant is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, none small-scale-power information, and no explicit routed probe class from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 9, observational leverage 2, complementarity 0, feasibility 1, provenance 9, diversity 0.0, penalties 12; raw score 9.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_04788_light_lepton_portal_minimal_v1", "paper_id": "2011_04788", "source_line": 4463, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 3971, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for lepton_portal_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 9.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_04788_light_lepton_portal_singlet_extended_v1", "paper_id": "2011_04788", "source_line": 4464, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 3972, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for lepton_portal_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 9.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_14786_extended_three_loop_scalar_dm_ewbg_v1", "paper_id": "2212_14786", "source_line": 5476, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 3973, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 14.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Extended three-loop radiative neutrino-mass model with Z2-odd scalar dark matter and electroweak baryogenesis has solid theory/motivation content, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_4923_b_l_assisted_amsb_wino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0807_4923", "source_line": 793, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 3974, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 9.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: phase-space type nonthermal; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_3464_sm4_darkon_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1004_3464", "source_line": 1108, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 3975, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in scalar_singlet_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1007_0019_hidden_sector_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1007_0019", "source_line": 1145, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 267, "global_rank": 3976, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in axion_like_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by field-like phase space, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_5334_inert_doublet_ewpt_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1110_5334", "source_line": 1444, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 3977, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 9.0 because the card describes scalar higgs portal dark matter at simplified model level, with thermal WIMP freeze-out and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_04293_majorana_higgs_portal_wimpzilla_v1", "paper_id": "1708_04293", "source_line": 3208, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 3978, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Majorana Higgs-portal WIMPzilla is a speculative superheavy_higgs_portal_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_04293_scalar_higgs_portal_wimpzilla_v1", "paper_id": "1708_04293", "source_line": 3207, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3979, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Scalar Higgs-portal WIMPzilla is a speculative superheavy_higgs_portal_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_electroweak_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_08624_dirac_electroweak_multiplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1708_08624", "source_line": 3243, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3980, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Dirac electroweak multiplet dark matter with I3=Y=0 is a speculative minimal_electroweak_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_04535_331_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1709_04535", "source_line": 3205, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 268, "global_rank": 3981, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Axion dark matter in a gravity-stable 3-3-1 model is a speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with field_like phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_13066_hidden_u1_semiannihilating_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_13066", "source_line": 3788, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3982, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 9 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out with annihilation and semi-annihilation, semi-annihilation enabled by accidental Z_3 structure, thermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_05741_accidental_pq_pati_salam_flavourful_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1711_05741", "source_line": 3298, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 269, "global_rank": 3983, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion like dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from field like phase-space structure.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 9.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "magnetic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_5446_magnetic_majorana_fermion_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_5446", "source_line": 2083, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3984, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of magnetic_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1805_07757_axion_like_curvaton_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_07757", "source_line": 258, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 195, "global_rank": 3985, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Axion-like curvaton primordial-black-hole dark matter, a speculative primordial black holes entry with simplified model theory support and high CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: pbh_mass_exponent_warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_06122_su2d_rh_neutrino_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_06122", "source_line": 3737, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 112, "global_rank": 3986, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because SU(2)_D right-handed-neutrino portal asymmetric dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, nonthermal phase-space behavior; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_04449_radiative_nonthermal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_04449", "source_line": 3730, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3987, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Radiatively produced nonthermal fermion dark matter from inflaton decay is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, nonthermal phase-space behavior, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_05962_ultralight_b_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_05962", "source_line": 3723, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 3988, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Ultralight U(1)_B dark photon dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, field like phase-space behavior, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_05962_ultralight_bminusl_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_05962", "source_line": 3724, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 3989, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Ultralight U(1)_{B-L} dark photon dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, field like phase-space behavior, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_out_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_09269_electron_coscattering_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_09269", "source_line": 3909, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 3990, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative freeze_out_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_string_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0201129_fractional_u1z_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0201129", "source_line": 437, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3991, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides uv complete theory support, moderate diversity value; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_00952_vector_like_portal_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_00952", "source_line": 2707, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 113, "global_rank": 3992, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, nonthermal phase-space history.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_07892_sfopt_qball_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_07892", "source_line": 3639, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 114, "global_rank": 3993, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative asymmetric_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "stringy_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0507199_stringy_cold_dark_matter_dilaton_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0507199", "source_line": 584, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 3994, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Stringy cold dark matter with rolling dilaton and strongly coupled SCDM is a speculative uv complete card in family stringy_cold_dark_matter with production described as post-inflationary reheating production of momentum modes.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase space.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0536_bino_higgsino_focus_point_gaugino_mediation_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0536", "source_line": 1898, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 159, "global_rank": 3995, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with coannihilation production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching BBN, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 1 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_6815_chern_simons_hidden_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1305_6815", "source_line": 1861, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 3996, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative effective-field-theory model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_2918_green_schwarz_u1x_chiral_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0907_2918", "source_line": 1014, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 302, "global_rank": 3997, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 9 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family hidden_sector_dark_matter, theory level effective_field_theory, and probe handles: CMB, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_04382_dark_photon_inelastic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2001_04382", "source_line": 4193, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 303, "global_rank": 3998, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of hidden_sector_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include medium CMB relevance, 2 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_1833_bmssm_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1412_1833", "source_line": 2354, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 160, "global_rank": 3999, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory and thermal freeze-out, co-annihilation production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_08608_dark_kaon_resonant_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_08608", "source_line": 4356, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 112, "global_rank": 4000, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Dark-kaon resonant self-interacting dark matter: thermal freeze-out through K+ K- annihilation via a resonant dark photon to Standard Model states; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2006_07321_growing_sound_speed_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2006_07321", "source_line": 22, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 196, "global_rank": 4001, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, medium CMB relevance, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2211_03523_asymmetric_double_pole_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_03523", "source_line": 5414, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["No concrete observational routing or computational representation is supplied."], "family_rank": 197, "global_rank": 4002, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked PBH entry: it can produce all dark matter and has compact-object/CMB relevance, but the supplied card lacks detailed structure, observables, constraints, and code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_6621_flux_stabilized_type_iib_mirage_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1312_6621", "source_line": 2003, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 161, "global_rank": 4003, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=partial and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_06783_family_nonuniversal_umssm_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "2103_06783", "source_line": 4667, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 162, "global_rank": 4004, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level uv_complete, and relic production parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; probe relevance for CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0512192_low_split_susy_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0512192", "source_line": 606, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4005, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlino_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0609061_e6_extra_u1_singlino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0609061", "source_line": 619, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4006, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0512282_su2z_fermion_wimp_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0512282", "source_line": 644, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 304, "global_rank": 4007, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophobic_zprime_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_0885_dirac_fermion_leptophobic_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_0885", "source_line": 1278, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4008, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 9 for Dirac fermion leptophobic Z-prime dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from distribution function availability is approximate; probe hints: direct detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophobic_zprime_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_0885_scalar_leptophobic_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_0885", "source_line": 1277, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4009, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 9 for Scalar leptophobic Z-prime dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from distribution function availability is approximate; probe hints: direct detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_1759_susy_su5_rh_neutrino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_1759", "source_line": 757, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 163, "global_rank": 4010, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 9.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance medium; probe classes counted: ['CMB'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0804_2613_cpmssm_neutralino_cp_violating_v1", "paper_id": "0804_2613", "source_line": 789, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 164, "global_rank": 4011, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 9.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance medium; probe classes counted: ['CMB'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_fermionic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_5700_scotogenic_fermionic_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1303_5700", "source_line": 1751, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4012, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 9: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family scotogenic_fermionic_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance medium; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as CMB.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 1; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_09040_pev_shadow_baryon_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_09040", "source_line": 2502, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 305, "global_rank": 4013, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for PeV shadow baryon decaying dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 9.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_08723_extended_singlet_scalar_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1710_08723", "source_line": 3271, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 4014, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs portal scalar dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 9.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_matter_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9902085_mirror_matter_machos_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9902085", "source_line": 6114, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4015, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 9 (defer) from supplied card content: mirror_matter_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_1448_light_higgsino_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1205_1448", "source_line": 1555, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 4016, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable because the card links gravitino dark matter to a high-reheating SUSY spectrum and BBN relevance, while the relic treatment is qualitative and no observable routing or implementation support is supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavor_anomaly_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_01789_b_anomaly_majorana_scalar_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_01789", "source_line": 3711, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4017, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Complex-coupling B-anomaly Majorana dark matter with scalar mediators is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, probe relevance for CMB; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_03213_lmu_ltau_majorana_leptoquark_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_03213", "source_line": 3596, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 4018, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative wimp_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_2750_gravitino_dm_from_heavy_neutrino_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1104_2750", "source_line": 1290, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 4019, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 9 for Gravitino dark matter from heavy Majorana neutrino decay reheating: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from BBN relevance is medium; probe hints: BBN.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_15640_z3_complex_scalar_type_ii_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_15640", "source_line": 5419, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Observational detail would require missing constraints, observables, routing, and computational support."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 4020, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: the Z3 complex scalar/type-II seesaw model is UV-complete and neutrino-motivated, with only weak CMB relevance and no supplied route or constraint content."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_05891_fermionic_u1x_inelastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2012_05891", "source_line": 4495, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 4021, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for inelastic_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 9.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_05891_scalar_u1x_inelastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2012_05891", "source_line": 4494, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 4022, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for inelastic_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 9.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_01956_png_dm_early_kinetic_decoupling_v1", "paper_id": "2106_01956", "source_line": 4695, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4023, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production yes; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "resonant_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_2900_resonant_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0909_2900", "source_line": 1061, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4024, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model resonant_dark_matter; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp", "model_id": "1211_5129_pmssm_neutralino_xen1_v1", "paper_id": "1211_5129", "source_line": 1715, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4025, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp", "model_id": "1211_5129_pmssm_neutralino_xen2_v1", "paper_id": "1211_5129", "source_line": 1716, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4026, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp", "model_id": "1211_5129_pmssm_neutralino_xen3_v1", "paper_id": "1211_5129", "source_line": 1717, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4027, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 34.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp", "model_id": "1211_5129_pmssm_neutralino_xen4_v1", "paper_id": "1211_5129", "source_line": 1718, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4028, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "b_minus_l_right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0023_minimal_b_minus_l_rh_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0023", "source_line": 1850, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4029, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative b_minus_l_right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on no explicit probe class in observables, constraints, or routing fields and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "exciting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_4795_excited_radiative_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_4795", "source_line": 2052, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4030, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of exciting_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_axion_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_11448_product_group_axion_wino_mixed_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_11448", "source_line": 4454, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4031, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for multi_component_axion_wino_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 9.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_4872_pseudoscalar_higgs_portal_fermion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1109_4872", "source_line": 1455, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 4032, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable higgs_portal_dark_matter variant and records thermal freeze-out through Higgs-mediated annihilation.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_5536_multi_higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0912_5536", "source_line": 1044, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 4033, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 9 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from multi-probe complementarity, auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family higgs_portal_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_01386_light_vector_inelastic_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_01386", "source_line": 2401, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 4034, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a inelastic_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_4993_compact_susy_higgsino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1206_4993", "source_line": 1609, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 165, "global_rank": 4035, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete card for Compact supersymmetry Higgsino-like neutralino dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_3013_so10_susy_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_3013", "source_line": 2274, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 166, "global_rank": 4036, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and unknown phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_06501_dark_gauge_u1s_alternative_left_right_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1706_06501", "source_line": 3177, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 152, "global_rank": 4037, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 9.0: Dark gauge U(1)_S alternative left-right two-component dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out of chi_0 through chi_0 chi_0 -> scalar scalar*.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_5452_bminusl_fermionic_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_5452", "source_line": 1452, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 115, "global_rank": 4038, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable asymmetric_dark_matter variant and records B-L asymmetric production transferred through the fermionic operator.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mev_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_5373_mev_scalar_messenger_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0912_5373", "source_line": 1038, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4039, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 9 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family mev_scalar_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_01143_kk_graviton_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_01143", "source_line": 3335, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4040, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 2 inferred probe classes.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_03116_vector_mediator_s_channel_v1", "paper_id": "1506_03116", "source_line": 2498, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4041, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=benchmark, theory_level=simplified_model, family=simplified_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=3, diversity_value=2.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_simplified_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_10833_s4z5_scalar_mediator_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_10833", "source_line": 4399, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4042, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as S4 x Z5 flavored scalar-mediator scalar dark matter: thermal freeze-out through mediator exchange; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes indirect/transient, laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_06061_trapped_composite_blob_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2008_06061", "source_line": 4374, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4043, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Trapped composite blob dark matter for the neutron bottle anomaly: dark-sector confinement into composite blobs below the confinement scale; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes compact-object/dynamics, laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9807347_extended_higgs_majorana_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9807347", "source_line": 73, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4044, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this higgs_portal_wimp_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with simplified_model theory support and limited explicit observational content.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptoquark_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_07844_vector_leptoquark_portal_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_07844", "source_line": 3587, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4045, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative leptoquark_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_1853_multicomponent_radiative_seesaw_v1", "paper_id": "1408_1853", "source_line": 2265, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 153, "global_rank": 4046, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "solitonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_6430_non_skyrmionic_electroweak_soliton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_6430", "source_line": 1630, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4047, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory card for Non-Skyrmionic electroweak soliton dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_02200_radiative_type_ii_seesaw_lepton_parity_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1502_02200", "source_line": 2398, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4048, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scotogenic_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and thermal history not specified, stability from residual dark parity production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (1 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: thermal history not specified, and related mechanisms."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_7672_b_yukawa_422_neutralino_gluino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1412_7672", "source_line": 2323, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 167, "global_rank": 4049, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 9 because the assigned model card uv complete supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_7672_b_yukawa_422_neutralino_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1412_7672", "source_line": 2324, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 168, "global_rank": 4050, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 9 because the assigned model card uv complete supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card; can account for the full dark-matter abundance in the assigned card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_15090_minimal_fermion_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_15090", "source_line": 5006, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4051, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Minimal fermion doublet dark matter has probe classes: laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value; some implementation support from code or benchmarks, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_b_minus_l_singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_00885_gauged_bl_singlet_doublet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_00885", "source_line": 4396, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4052, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Gauged U(1) B-L singlet-doublet fermion dark matter: thermal freeze-out; partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_14394_hidden_u1x_fermion_eta4_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_14394", "source_line": 5194, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 306, "global_rank": 4053, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: hidden U(1)X fermion candidate is identified with annihilation channels, but full relic and observational detail are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_14394_hidden_u1x_scalar_sd_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_14394", "source_line": 5193, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 307, "global_rank": 4054, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: hidden U(1)X scalar candidate is identified, but the paper only sketches relic phenomenology and the card has no phase-space, routes, or constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "created_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_5203_ccdm_particle_creation_cosmology_v1", "paper_id": "1412_5203", "source_line": 2360, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4055, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative created_cold_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory and gravitational particle creation production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: large-scale structure.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (1 cards in population context); rare production mechanism: gravitational particle creation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_2022_sequestered_gauge_mediation_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0906_2022", "source_line": 951, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 169, "global_rank": 4056, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_13508_z4_2hdm_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_13508", "source_line": 5368, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4057, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Z4 two-Higgs-doublet model with singlet scalar dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: collider, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_5990_su3_so3_b1_axial_skyrmion_v1", "paper_id": "1103_5990", "source_line": 1312, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4058, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for topological_soliton_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "rayleigh_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2910_rayleigh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2910", "source_line": 1597, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4059, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but diverse because the card captures a rare Rayleigh-operator dark-matter family, while contact-limit validity and absent routing constrain observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_light_gaugino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph9710395_light_gaugino_photino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9710395", "source_line": 6104, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4060, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 9 (defer) from supplied card content: supersymmetric_light_gaugino_dark_matter with simplified_model theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_0720_split_ued_kk_photon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0901_0720", "source_line": 957, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4061, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative kaluza_klein_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauge_higgs_unification_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_3837_stable_ebh_gauge_higgs_unification_v1", "paper_id": "1205_3837", "source_line": 1558, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4062, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card gives a rare UV gauge-Higgs-unification scalar relic scenario, but the candidate is CDM-like and the supplied card has no observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, or code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_01628_u1_monopole_condensation_simp_v1", "paper_id": "1606_01628", "source_line": 2849, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 113, "global_rank": 4063, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from structure formation relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_10059_knt_leptogenesis_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_10059", "source_line": 5449, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Thermal CDM-like behavior plus absent observables, constraints, routing, and code keep follow-up low."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 4064, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but scientifically strong: the KNT right-handed-neutrino dark matter model connects relic density to leptogenesis and radiative neutrino mass, but supplied observational leverage is minimal."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1501_00206_scalar_split_wimps_v1", "paper_id": "1501_00206", "source_line": 2310, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 4065, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 9 because the assigned model card simplified model higgs_portal_dark_matter card.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_6964_so10_yukawa_unified_neutralino_stau_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1303_6964", "source_line": 1766, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 170, "global_rank": 4066, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 9: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 309; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0608135_type_i_string_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0608135", "source_line": 631, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 171, "global_rank": 4067, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some computational or code support recorded in the model card, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_4611_inert_doublet_extra_families_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1105_4611", "source_line": 1301, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 4068, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_3988_no_scale_fsu5_bino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1105_3988", "source_line": 1321, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 172, "global_rank": 4069, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_0887_d6_pati_salam_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1108_0887", "source_line": 1338, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 173, "global_rank": 4070, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_02921_minimal_leptophilic_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_02921", "source_line": 4715, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4071, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative leptophilic_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via thermal freeze-out of N_R; co-annihilation with H^+ for small mass splitting.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 9 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_04466_gsugra_bino_like_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2106_04466", "source_line": 4729, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 174, "global_rank": 4072, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; stau coannihilation.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 9 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_7178_susy_left_right_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_7178", "source_line": 1410, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 175, "global_rank": 4073, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 9.0 because the card describes supersymmetric neutralino dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal freeze-out with annihilation and coannihilation; stau coannihilation and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage with partial associated-code support.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_1708_pqsugra_pq1_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1212_1708", "source_line": 1726, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 176, "global_rank": 4074, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to strong-CP/PQ/axion, supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2108_08717_pbh_all_dm_frb_source_v1", "paper_id": "2108_08717", "source_line": 4877, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 198, "global_rank": 4075, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from phenomenological_parameterization theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_higgs_pnGB_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_04005_m10_uv_safe_composite_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_04005", "source_line": 3744, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4076, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because M10 UV-safe composite pNGB dark matter is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_higgs_pnGB_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_04005_m11_uv_safe_composite_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_04005", "source_line": 3745, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4077, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because M11 UV-safe composite pNGB dark matter is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_flavor_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_3213_radiative_flavor_dirac_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1311_3213", "source_line": 2039, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4078, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_technicolor_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_4284_hidden_sector_technicolor_model_ii_v1", "paper_id": "0801_4284", "source_line": 768, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4079, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 9.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_0617_gauged_bl_inert_doublet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1005_0617", "source_line": 1138, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4080, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in scalar_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_1024_leptonic_gauge_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1005_1024", "source_line": 1111, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 4081, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavor_symmetric_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_06904_lepton_quarticity_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1606_06904", "source_line": 2823, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4082, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_07155_resonant_wino_zreft_coulomb_v1", "paper_id": "1708_07155", "source_line": 3236, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4083, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Resonant wino zero-range effective field theory with Coulomb resummation is a benchmark wino_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_0493_kinetic_mixing_portal_qed_prime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_0493", "source_line": 1427, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4084, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 9.0 because the card describes hidden sector portal dark matter at uv complete level, with freeze-in from SM pair annihilation; reannihilation after hidden-sector thermalization and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_radiative_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1301_2087_inert_doublet_radiative_neutrino_inverted_hierarchy_v1", "paper_id": "1301_2087", "source_line": 1730, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4085, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to neutrino, baryogenesis/cogenesis.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "technicolor_interacting_massive_particle", "model_id": "0809_0713_ultra_minimal_technicolor_timp_v1", "paper_id": "0809_0713", "source_line": 826, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4086, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/low. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_00199_su2ell_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_00199", "source_line": 3107, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 116, "global_rank": 4087, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of asymmetric_dark_matter with raw score 9.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_02086_su10_noncos_domain_wall_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1705_02086", "source_line": 3125, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4088, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 33.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of asymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter with raw score 9.0.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 4.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_02086_su12_cos_domain_wall_unified_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1705_02086", "source_line": 3122, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4089, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of asymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter with raw score 9.0.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 4.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_02086_su12_noncos_domain_wall_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1705_02086", "source_line": 3124, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4090, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of asymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter with raw score 9.0.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 4.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_02086_su9_cos_domain_wall_su2_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1705_02086", "source_line": 3123, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 9.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4091, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of asymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter with raw score 9.0.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 4.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 9.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_02510_gravitational_pbh_uv_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_02510", "source_line": 4425, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4092, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes Hawking evaporation of primordial black holes, UV gravitational freeze-in from SM annihilation through s-channel graviton exchange.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space structure, suppression of small-scale power.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_08355_logotropic_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1504_08355", "source_line": 152, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4093, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 8.5 for cold_dark_matter: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, medium CMB relevance, suppression in small-scale power, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "1710_10588_diffusive_two_measure_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1710_10588", "source_line": 196, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4094, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 8.5 for unified_dark_sector: positive factors include parameter-dependent relic-density viability, medium CMB relevance, strong BBN relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_5255_scalar_field_dark_matter_mexican_hat_v1", "paper_id": "1204_5255", "source_line": 91, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 4095, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this scalar_field_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, explicit nonlinear structure comment, field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_07809_sub_mev_fermion_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2002_07809", "source_line": 4180, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4096, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of effective_field_theory_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, 2 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_07809_sub_mev_scalar_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2002_07809", "source_line": 4179, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4097, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of effective_field_theory_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, high BBN relevance, 2 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_05721_gut_monopole_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1711_05721", "source_line": 3325, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 270, "global_rank": 4098, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory model with parameter dependent relic-density support, high CMB relevance, field like phase-space behavior, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_5076_r_symmetric_gauge_mediated_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_5076", "source_line": 1409, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 4099, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 8.5 because the card describes gravitino dark matter at simplified model level, with non-equilibrium production from thermal-plasma scatterings; possible NLSP cascade decays and high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0410252_supersymmetric_ksvz_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0410252", "source_line": 551, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 271, "global_rank": 4100, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Supersymmetric KSVZ axion model with intermediate-scale supersymmetry breaking is a speculative uv complete card in family axion_like_dark_matter with production described as nonthermal coherent axion oscillations from PQ misalignment.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; field like phase space; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_01203_pseudo_dirac_dark_photon_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_01203", "source_line": 5812, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card.", "Relic-density follow-up value is reduced because the card does not support a full-DM regime or leaves it unknown."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 4101, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative simplified_model model; the main production handle is early-universe abundance assumed for pseudo-Dirac dark matter.", "Follow-up value comes from CMB, direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (unknown, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05353_millicharged_minimal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05353", "source_line": 2705, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4102, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, medium CMB relevance.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: CMB, direct detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0510147_mev_majorana_u_boson_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0510147", "source_line": 573, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4103, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Majorana MeV dark matter with light U-boson mediator is a speculative simplified model card in family light_vector_mediator_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out through U-mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_2759_tgm_bilinear_rpv_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_2759", "source_line": 1450, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 4104, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 8.5 because the card describes gravitino dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal gravitino production after reheating; suppressed nonthermal contribution from NLSP decay and high BBN relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cosmic_string_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "0805_1060_cosmic_string_nonthermal_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0805_1060", "source_line": 802, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4105, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked parameter_dependent, phase space is nonthermal. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_baryogenesis", "model_id": "1212_2973_rpv_susy_wimp_baryogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_2973", "source_line": 1710, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4106, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to baryogenesis/cogenesis, supersymmetric framework, phase-transition/nonstandard history.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_6467_model_c_singlet_triplet_mixed_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1305_6467", "source_line": 1887, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4107, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, collider / fixed-target.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_6467_model_e_real_triplet_complex_triplet_mixed_v1", "paper_id": "1305_6467", "source_line": 1889, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4108, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, collider / fixed-target.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_1400_higgs_portal_majoron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_1400", "source_line": 2049, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4109, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_4777_a4_leptophilic_decaying_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1008_4777", "source_line": 1177, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 4110, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 8.5 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_01386_inelastic_eft_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_01386", "source_line": 2402, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 4111, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a inelastic_dark_matter entry (effective_field_theory); implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_01395_secluded_inelastic_dark_z_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_01395", "source_line": 2404, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 4112, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a inelastic_dark_matter entry (effective_field_theory); implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_3949_scalar_septuplet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1208_3949", "source_line": 1620, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4113, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete card for Scalar septuplet dark matter with enhanced Higgs diphoton rate; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_05089_secluded_singlet_fermionic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1601_05089", "source_line": 2727, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4114, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavor_violating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_0623_flavor_violating_scalar_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1107_0623", "source_line": 1383, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4115, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as flavor_violating_dark_matter: production is represented by collider production through flavor-violating top-quark associated channels; phase-space is unknown; inferred probe coverage includes collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauge_extended_dark_matter", "model_id": "1712_08994_su2_cubed_dark_u1_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1712_08994", "source_line": 3337, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4116, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_07572_hidden_qcd_pion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_07572", "source_line": 3265, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 308, "global_rank": 4117, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching gravitational waves.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 8.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_2764_so10_yukawa_unified_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1107_2764", "source_line": 1385, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 177, "global_rank": 4118, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal neutralino freeze-out; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_2131_higgs_portal_vector_u1x_v1", "paper_id": "1212_2131", "source_line": 1735, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4119, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to hidden-sector structure.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_11011_ir_fixed_point_dark_qcd_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_11011", "source_line": 5361, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 117, "global_rank": 4120, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Infrared-fixed-point dark QCD asymmetric dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_06750_s4_inverse_seesaw_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_06750", "source_line": 3108, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 4121, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of scotogenic_dark_matter with raw score 8.5.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_02960_neutrino_option_inflaton_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_02960", "source_line": 4332, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 184, "global_rank": 4122, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Nonthermal inflaton-decay dark matter in the Neutrino Option as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and production via nonthermal production from inflaton decay.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type decay_produced; structure-formation entries transfer=smooth_cutoff and small-scale effect=suppression.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: not_uv_complete_dm_model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0702200_rsii_stable_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0702200", "source_line": 673, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 4123, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: some cosmology or phase-space leverage; rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_03492_pseudo_dirac_self_interacting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1611_03492", "source_line": 2953, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 114, "global_rank": 4124, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and unknown all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_6827_rh_neutrino_dm_philic_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "1407_6827", "source_line": 2189, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 146, "global_rank": 4125, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with nonthermal phase-space entry, suppression small-scale-power effect, and smooth_cutoff transfer-function shape.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_branon_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0310272_self_interacting_warm_branon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0310272", "source_line": 472, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4126, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by suppression small-scale-power effect; scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including high severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_00637_large_n_type_i_sterile_neutrino_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1812_00637", "source_line": 3668, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 185, "global_rank": 4127, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with simplified_model theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; decay_produced phase-space behavior; suppression small-scale-power effect; smooth_cutoff transfer-function behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_05646_sterile_neutrino_charged_scalar_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1510_05646", "source_line": 2648, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 147, "global_rank": 4128, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Sterile-neutrino dark matter from charged scalar decay is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, decay_produced phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'decay produced' and small-scale-power effect 'suppression'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_05646_sterile_neutrino_neutral_scalar_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1510_05646", "source_line": 2647, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 148, "global_rank": 4129, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Sterile-neutrino dark matter from neutral scalar decay is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, decay_produced phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'decay produced' and small-scale-power effect 'suppression'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1707_09578_ultra_slow_roll_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_09578", "source_line": 294, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 199, "global_rank": 4130, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Ultra-slow-roll polynomial-inflation PBH dark matter, a speculative primordial black holes entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, enhancement of small-scale power.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: threshold_sensitive_abundance."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_fermionic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_03390_scalar_vector_fermionic_dark_star_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_03390", "source_line": 3768, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4131, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 8 because the card identifies production via unknown, probe classes: compact-object or macroscopic probes; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0111535_stationary_coupled_dark_matter_dark_energy_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0111535", "source_line": 398, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4132, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via phenomenological stationary scaling between dark matter and dark energy; linear structure effect enhancement with transfer shape scale_dependent_growth; probe hooks: large-scale/small-scale structure, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0407532_scalar_bec_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0407532", "source_line": 553, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4133, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scalar Bose-Einstein condensate dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card in family scalar_bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter with production described as Bose-Einstein condensation of a relativistic charged scalar gas with conserved charge.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; field like phase space; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2006_03768_slow_climb_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_03768", "source_line": 137, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 200, "global_rank": 4134, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and high CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_08142_smashed_dirac_neutrino_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_08142", "source_line": 5223, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 272, "global_rank": 4135, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; field like phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_09981_boosted_goldstini_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2007_09981", "source_line": 4303, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4136, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Boosted goldstini dark matter from heavier goldstini decay as a speculative supersymmetric_boosted_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via late decay of a slightly heavier long-lived goldstini mother particle.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=medium; phase-space type decay_produced.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: requires_gravitino_dilution."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_background_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0505310_virtual_massive_graviton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0505310", "source_line": 290, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4137, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Virtual massive graviton dark matter in a low-temperature graviton background, a speculative graviton background dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space treatment, nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: nonstandard_cosmology, qualitative_relic."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_01764_inert_2hdm_inverse_seesaw_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2001_01764", "source_line": 4118, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 4138, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 8: speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked unknown.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: collider, neutrino.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_01764_inert_2hdm_type_i_rhn_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2001_01764", "source_line": 4117, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 4139, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 8: speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked unknown.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: collider, neutrino.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_5580_kev_bino_rpv_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1403_5580", "source_line": 2043, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 4140, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=unknown, and structure effect=suppression/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, structure formation, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0504102_superheavy_gravitino_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0504102", "source_line": 601, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 4141, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0608140_ued_lkp_graviton_tower_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0608140", "source_line": 639, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4142, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some observational leverage from cosmology or nonthermal phase-space fields, moderate diversity value within the population-count context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_13017_topological_loop_chernon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2307_13017", "source_line": 5756, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4143, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Topological loop/chernon dark matter scenario has high diversity value in an underrepresented or distinctive model class; card-internal probe cues include gravitational waves.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: qualitative_candidate_identity, no_relic_density."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_unparticle_dark_matter", "model_id": "0707_2959_supersymmetric_unparticle_mssm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0707_2959", "source_line": 712, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4144, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative effective_field_theory model card; relic abundance marked unknown; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0709_2634_gmsb_gravitino_dm_q_ball_entropy_v1", "paper_id": "0709_2634", "source_line": 760, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 4145, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 8.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance critical, phase-space type nonthermal; probe classes counted: ['BBN'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_05958_axion_isocurvature_collider_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_05958", "source_line": 4578, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 273, "global_rank": 4146, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=high and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_15061_near_inflection_model_i_fermionic_reheating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_15061", "source_line": 5425, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["The card lacks implementation and observational mapping despite its inflation/reheating hook."], "family_rank": 186, "global_rank": 4147, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: near-inflection reheating freeze-in is cosmologically motivated and nonthermal with high CMB relevance, but no observables, constraints, routes, or code are supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_09105_coannihilating_511kev_mev_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_09105", "source_line": 4314, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4148, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Coannihilating MeV dark matter model for the 511 keV line as a speculative coannihilating_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via thermal coannihilation chi1 chi2 -> e+ e- through dark photon exchange.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=high and BBN=high; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "p_wave_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_09105_p_wave_511kev_mev_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_09105", "source_line": 4313, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4149, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 32.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes P-wave MeV dark matter model for the 511 keV line as a speculative p_wave_annihilating_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via thermal freeze-out through p-wave chi chi -> e+ e- annihilation.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=high and BBN=high; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10619_affleck_dine_pq_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10619", "source_line": 5247, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 274, "global_rank": 4150, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; field like phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_7370_two_component_boosted_thermal_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_7370", "source_line": 2187, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 154, "global_rank": 4151, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with medium CMB relevance, mixed_cold_warm phase-space entry, and approximate distribution-function support.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_coupled_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_03278_planckian_interacting_massive_particle_v1", "paper_id": "1511_03278", "source_line": 2655, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4152, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 1. Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code. High-severity warning(s) in the card add caution but do not eliminate the model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2022_dirac_wimp_axialvector_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2022", "source_line": 1238, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4153, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model fermion pairs.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2022_dirac_wimp_axialvector_vector_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2022", "source_line": 1243, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4154, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model fermion pairs.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2022_dirac_wimp_dual_tensor_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2022", "source_line": 1244, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4155, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model fermion pairs.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2022_dirac_wimp_pseudoscalar_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2022", "source_line": 1236, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4156, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model fermion pairs.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2022_dirac_wimp_pseudoscalar_scalar_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2022", "source_line": 1241, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4157, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model fermion pairs.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2022_dirac_wimp_scalar_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2022", "source_line": 1235, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4158, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model fermion pairs.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2022_dirac_wimp_scalar_pseudoscalar_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2022", "source_line": 1240, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4159, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model fermion pairs.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2022_dirac_wimp_tensor_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2022", "source_line": 1239, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4160, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model fermion pairs.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2022_dirac_wimp_vector_axialvector_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2022", "source_line": 1242, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4161, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model fermion pairs.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1012_2022_dirac_wimp_vector_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1012_2022", "source_line": 1237, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4162, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative effective_field_theory card in family effective_fermionic_wimp_dark_matter with production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to Standard Model fermion pairs.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: compact objects / dynamics, indirect detection.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0001017_dynamic_rs_bulk_modes_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0001017", "source_line": 406, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 309, "global_rank": 4163, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting; probe signal: bbn, cmb.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_18120_landscape_namsb_mixed_axion_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_18120", "source_line": 5938, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 155, "global_rank": 4164, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Landscape nAMSB mixed axion-higgsino dark matter is a speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with unknown phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and collider from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 8, observational leverage 3, complementarity 2, feasibility 1, provenance 9, diversity 0.0, penalties 15; raw score 8.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0208072_low_reheating_sugra_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0208072", "source_line": 438, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 4165, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting; probe signal: bbn.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bosonic_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_0173_stagflation_bec_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "0905_0173", "source_line": 94, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4166, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this bosonic_condensate_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dipolar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_5963_gravitationally_polarized_dipolar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_5963", "source_line": 349, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4167, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=unknown; observational features include transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth, nonlinear halo or subhalo effect is stated.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: small-scale structure; associated_code=no; warnings=medium:not_particle_relic_model, medium:nonrelativistic_scope.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 5/3/2/0/9/6/17."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_13358_starobinsky_hidden_fermion_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2105_13358", "source_line": 4745, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 310, "global_rank": 4168, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via nonthermal pair production from scalaron decay.", "Card-local leverage comes from CMB; the raw score is 8 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0009202_so10_pq_axion_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0009202", "source_line": 407, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 275, "global_rank": 4169, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides uv complete theory support, moderate diversity value; probe signal: bbn.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_15602_bubble_expansion_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_15602", "source_line": 4808, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 118, "global_rank": 4170, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by nonthermal phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_03008_eev_gravitino_high_scale_susy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_03008", "source_line": 3034, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 4171, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["EeV gravitino dark matter in high-scale supersymmetry is ranked because it can produce the full dark-matter abundance in the card; uses a nonthermal phase-space history; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimension_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_06760_phenomenological_ued_kk_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1611_06760", "source_line": 2969, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4172, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative universal_extra_dimension_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensed_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_2897_vortical_bec_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0912_2897", "source_line": 1031, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4173, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 8 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, registry diversity value.", "Card-local details considered: identity family bose_einstein_condensed_dark_matter, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and field_like phase-space history.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_4594_scalar_decay_freeze_in_thermal_effects_v1", "paper_id": "1111_4594", "source_line": 1425, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 187, "global_rank": 4174, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 8.0 because the card describes freeze in dark matter at simplified model level, with freeze-in; nonthermal production from thermal-bath decays and decay produced phase-space behavior.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_6828_higgs_lepton_inflation_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_6828", "source_line": 1721, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 4175, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to neutrino, baryogenesis/cogenesis, inflation/curvaton, supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_quintessence_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_5263_higher_order_coupled_quintessence_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1009_5263", "source_line": 267, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4176, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Higher-order coupled quintessence dark matter, a speculative coupled quintessence dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, scale dependent growth transfer behavior.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: dark_energy_model_overlap."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_4776_alp_nonthermal_bose_einstein_condensate_v1", "paper_id": "1402_4776", "source_line": 2070, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 276, "global_rank": 4177, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative effective_field_theory member of axion_like_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_01233_constant_eos_non_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_01233", "source_line": 262, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4178, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Constant equation-of-state non-cold dark matter, a speculative non cold dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, scale dependent growth transfer behavior.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: 2308_constant_gp_parameterization."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_06795_temperature_dependent_gmsb_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_06795", "source_line": 2714, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 4179, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production, nonthermal phase-space history.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_10374_s4_u1_axion_flavon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2011_10374", "source_line": 4531, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 277, "global_rank": 4180, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium BBN relevance, field_like phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "forbidden_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_12199_forbidden_fermionic_dm_ekd_v1", "paper_id": "2301_12199", "source_line": 5462, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4181, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Forbidden fermionic dark matter with early kinetic decoupling has some theory and relic-density motivation, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase space, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2001_09160_false_vacuum_bubble_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2001_09160", "source_line": 4191, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 201, "global_rank": 4182, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of primordial_black_holes; rank-relevant features include medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, 3 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_04288_very_degenerate_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_04288", "source_line": 2818, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 178, "global_rank": 4183, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from BBN, CMB relevance in the supplied cosmology/structure fields.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_11006_wimp_kination_production_v1", "paper_id": "1710_11006", "source_line": 3272, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 4184, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative wimp dark matter candidate with phenomenological parameterization theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from critical BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 8.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptoquark_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_7052_fermionic_singlet_leptoquark_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1310_7052", "source_line": 1939, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4185, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 8.0 because the model card is a speculative leptoquark_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_10493_left_handed_quark_doublet_dmfv_v1", "paper_id": "1711_10493", "source_line": 3303, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4186, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with yes relic-density support, medium CMB relevance, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majoron_dark_matter", "model_id": "0805_2372_late_decaying_majoron_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0805_2372", "source_line": 783, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4187, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 8.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance high; probe classes counted: ['CMB'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_04530_m_theory_su5_hidden_chiral_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_04530", "source_line": 3259, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 311, "global_rank": 4188, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from high BBN relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching BBN.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 8.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_14605_sterile_neutrino_u1bl_light_x_v1", "paper_id": "2007_14605", "source_line": 4354, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 149, "global_rank": 4189, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Sterile neutrino dark matter in U(1)_B-L with a light X boson: freeze-in production from SM fermion annihilation f fbar -> nu_s nu_s through the extra U(1) interaction; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_light_boson_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0511262_kev_scalar_light_boson_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0511262", "source_line": 353, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4190, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative effective_field_theory model; production via early-Universe production followed by decoupling; possible production from heavier-particle decays or exotic cosmological evolution; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: laboratory/direct detection, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_4590_interacting_dark_matter_acceleration_v1", "paper_id": "0807_4590", "source_line": 804, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4191, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked yes, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/high. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_4151_scalar_dm_gut_suppressed_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1205_4151", "source_line": 1574, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4192, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but distinctive because the card describes nonthermal decaying scalar dark matter with a rare GUT-suppressed decay structure, while abundance and UV embedding are underspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dipolar_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0605637_dipolar_gravitational_polarization_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0605637", "source_line": 320, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4193, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include transfer function shape is scale_dependent_growth.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: small-scale structure; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:dipolar_dm_not_particle_relic.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/2/2/0/9/5/18."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_5228_ohelium_dark_atom_v1", "paper_id": "1401_5228", "source_line": 2023, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4194, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=unknown, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_15475_flrw_scalar_background_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "2210_15475", "source_line": 5384, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4195, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because FLRW scalar-background dark matter and dark energy model has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space, large penalties for missing observables, constraints, and follow-up machinery."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2110_05982_anisotropic_pbh_formation_v1", "paper_id": "2110_05982", "source_line": 4897, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 202, "global_rank": 4196, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from phenomenological_parameterization theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: nonthermal phase-space production.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_05283_dimension6_zee_babu_freeze_in_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_05283", "source_line": 2838, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 4197, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic production marked yes.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "braneworld_scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1102_0825_hidden_brane_scalar_field_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1102_0825", "source_line": 336, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4198, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=unknown; observational features include phase-space type is field_like.", "associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:phenomenological_relic_logic, medium:not_plain_fuzzy_dm.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 6/2/0/0/9/6/15."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_04543_two_component_nonthermal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_04543", "source_line": 2549, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 156, "global_rank": 4199, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Two-component nonthermal scalar dark matter model: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 8.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_05955_two_component_scalar_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1709_05955", "source_line": 3206, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 188, "global_rank": 4200, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Two-component singlet scalar FIMP dark matter is a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter card with nonthermal phase-space treatment, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_06572_freeze_in_gauge_mediation_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1710_06572", "source_line": 3292, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 189, "global_rank": 4201, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from nonthermal phase-space structure.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 8.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph9809453_reheating_produced_superheavy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9809453", "source_line": 6112, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4202, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 8 (defer) from supplied card content: superheavy_nonthermal_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_8138_iss_axion_pq_v1", "paper_id": "1403_8138", "source_line": 2130, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 278, "global_rank": 4203, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: phase-space type is field_like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_0013_pev_right_handed_neutrino_b_minus_l_v1", "paper_id": "1405_0013", "source_line": 2132, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 150, "global_rank": 4204, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_04449_no_scale_radiative_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_04449", "source_line": 3731, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 4205, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Radiative gravitino dark matter in high-scale no-scale supergravity is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, nonthermal phase-space behavior; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_majorana_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_00773_majorana_fermion_charged_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1612_00773", "source_line": 2967, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4206, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_majorana_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_10156_axiflavon_higgs_unification_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_10156", "source_line": 3565, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 279, "global_rank": 4207, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has field-like phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0107053_singleton_superstring_relic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0107053", "source_line": 394, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4208, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative uv_complete model; production via nonthermal gravitational production; production during preheating or reheating after inflation; nonthermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_string_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0201129_uniton_bound_state_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0201129", "source_line": 436, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4209, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides uv complete theory support, moderate diversity value; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1008_0398_dynamical_matter_parity_gravitino_v1", "paper_id": "1008_0398", "source_line": 1141, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 4210, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 31.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in gravitino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_01755_conformal_standard_model_pseudo_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_01755", "source_line": 2569, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4211, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include field_like phase space.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_10609_dark_boson_spin_one_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2008_10609", "source_line": 4351, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4212, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Dark boson EFT with heavy spin-one mediators: thermal WIMP-like freeze-out through effective spin-one mediator operators; partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes CMB, laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_08480_subgev_scalar_gravity_portal_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_08480", "source_line": 3260, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4213, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravity portal dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and unknown all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching CMB, indirect detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 8.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2202_00700_usr_pbh_affleck_dine_v1", "paper_id": "2202_00700", "source_line": 5038, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 203, "global_rank": 4214, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Ultra-slow-roll inflation primordial black hole dark matter with Affleck-Dine baryogenesis has probe classes: CMB, compact objects, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_mediator_dirac_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_7008_dirac_singlet_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1305_7008", "source_line": 1854, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4215, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_cosmology_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_4387_out_of_equilibrium_bounce_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_4387", "source_line": 2286, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4216, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative nonstandard_cosmology_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by CMB/BBN relevance, relic-density support in the card, registry-diversity value, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2006_07321_mess_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2006_07321", "source_line": 23, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 204, "global_rank": 4217, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "astro-ph0209324_pregalactic_pbh_induced_halo_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0209324", "source_line": 13, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 205, "global_rank": 4218, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_09021_fermionic_dm_admixed_sqs_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2209_09021", "source_line": 5355, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 312, "global_rank": 4219, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Fermionic DM-admixed strange quark star with vector dark boson mediator has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: CMB, compact objects, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0512197_mssm_bino_neutralino_stau_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0512197", "source_line": 617, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4220, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_01262_two_component_singlet_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_01262", "source_line": 4383, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 157, "global_rank": 4221, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Two-component singlet-triplet scalar dark matter: thermal freeze-out of two coupled scalar components; partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_1031_f_theory_scenario_ii_stau_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1002_1031", "source_line": 1086, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 179, "global_rank": 4222, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium).", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_07609_stable_light_scalar_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_07609", "source_line": 2538, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 115, "global_rank": 4223, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Stable light scalar self-interacting dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 8.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_05772_power_law_three_form_spinor_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "1704_05772", "source_line": 306, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4224, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; associated_code=no; warnings=medium:not_freezeout_model.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/1/2/0/9/4/16."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_07365_muon_specific_complex_scalar_wimp_z3_v1", "paper_id": "1711_07365", "source_line": 3307, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4225, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with yes relic-density support, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_07365_muon_specific_real_scalar_wimp_z2_v1", "paper_id": "1711_07365", "source_line": 3306, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4226, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with yes relic-density support, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mimetic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_01850_mimetic_horndeski_unified_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "1708_01850", "source_line": 321, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4227, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes; observational features include CMB relevance is medium.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:modified_gravity_not_particle_dm.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 9/1/2/0/9/4/17."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_10322_cp_in_the_dark_n2hdm_singlet_v1", "paper_id": "1807_10322", "source_line": 3624, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4228, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative scalar_portal_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hadrophilic_dark_sector", "model_id": "1812_05103_up_philic_scalar_mediator_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_05103", "source_line": 3726, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4229, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Up-philic scalar-mediated Dirac dark matter is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter, probe relevance for BBN; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_09033_dark_asteroid_macroscopic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_09033", "source_line": 4710, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4230, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative macroscopic_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production via macroscopic-object formation in dark sectors; asymmetric dark matter composites.", "Card-local leverage comes from compact objects/dynamics; the raw score is 8 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_4568_su5_1plus75_mixed_bino_higgsino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0902_4568", "source_line": 920, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 180, "global_rank": 4231, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, partial code or computational support, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Penalties mainly reflect missing observable mapping, constraints, and routing rather than global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0904_2173_inert_doublet_2hdm_cp_violating_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0904_2173", "source_line": 923, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 4232, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, partial code or computational support, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Penalties mainly reflect missing observable mapping, constraints, and routing rather than global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_12432_fermion_inelastic_dark_higgs_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2112_12432", "source_line": 4973, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 4233, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative inelastic dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and thermal freeze-out through annihilation and coannihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by partial associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_12432_scalar_inelastic_dark_higgs_decay_v1", "paper_id": "2112_12432", "source_line": 4974, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 4234, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative inelastic dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and thermal freeze-out dominated by coannihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by partial associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0704_3518_susy_su5_seesaw_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0704_3518", "source_line": 677, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 4235, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; limited computational support; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_3087_singlet_fermionic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1402_3087", "source_line": 2145, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4236, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: an approximate distribution treatment is available.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: partial associated-code support is noted, but explicit routing and benchmark support are absent, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_02905_susy_422_qyu_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_02905", "source_line": 5498, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 181, "global_rank": 4237, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Supersymmetric 422 quasi-Yukawa neutralino dark matter has solid theory/motivation content, medium CMB relevance, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_05868_neutrino_portal_complex_scalar_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2111_05868", "source_line": 4905, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4238, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Neutrino-portal complex scalar thermal freeze-out dark matter is benchmark with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: no explicit probe class in the model card.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_00961_right_handed_neutrino_u1x_ssm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_00961", "source_line": 6084, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 4239, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 8.0: speculative uv complete model in right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "u1_portal_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_00484_left_right_u1_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_00484", "source_line": 3622, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4240, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative u1_portal_fermion_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multistate_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_1779_hidden_su2_multistate_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1005_1779", "source_line": 1116, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4241, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in multistate_hidden_sector_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multistate_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_1779_hidden_su2_multistate_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1005_1779", "source_line": 1117, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4242, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in multistate_hidden_sector_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "grand_unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_03974_so10_u1chi_fermion_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_03974", "source_line": 3617, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4243, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative grand_unified_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_02011_su2n_vector_boson_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_02011", "source_line": 3905, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 313, "global_rank": 4244, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1907_11595_z3_dirac_fermion_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1907_11595", "source_line": 3928, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4245, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative semi_annihilating_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_01395_public_dark_z_light_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_01395", "source_line": 2405, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 314, "global_rank": 4246, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a hidden_sector_dark_matter entry (simplified_model); implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_6930_bino_like_pmssm_wino_nlsp_sommerfeld_v1", "paper_id": "1411_6930", "source_line": 2337, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 182, "global_rank": 4247, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 8 because the assigned model card simplified model supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_6930_mixed_wino_higgsino_trajectory_v1", "paper_id": "1411_6930", "source_line": 2338, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 183, "global_rank": 4248, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 8 because the assigned model card simplified model supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_6930_wino_like_pmssm_neutralino_sommerfeld_v1", "paper_id": "1411_6930", "source_line": 2335, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 184, "global_rank": 4249, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 3, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 8 because the assigned model card simplified model supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_3167_z2_real_scalar_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0910_3167", "source_line": 1047, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 4250, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 8 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family scalar_singlet_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_5699_so10_natural_susy_case_i_v1", "paper_id": "1306_5699", "source_line": 1894, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 185, "global_rank": 4251, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with coannihilation production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 1 while penalties total 18."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_16161_bec_scalar_condensate_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2307_16161", "source_line": 5724, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4252, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 3.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer from supplied model-card fields: Bose-Einstein-condensate scalar dark matter formation model is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization card with unknown relic-abundance support and limited explicit observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Probe complementarity was inferred from explicit card fields across galaxy satellites, indirect detection; main score limiters are absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation in the supplied card.", "Component balance: scientific 3.0, observational 0.0, complementarity 5.0, feasibility 0.0, provenance 9.0, diversity 5.0, penalties 14.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_higgs_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_5361_mssm_light_higgs_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0912_5361", "source_line": 1037, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4253, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 8 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family light_higgs_neutralino_dark_matter, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_09980_little_composite_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_09980", "source_line": 3252, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4254, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative composite dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 8.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9808343_sterile_neutrino_extended_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9808343", "source_line": 6113, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 151, "global_rank": 4255, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 8 (defer) from supplied card content: sterile_neutrino_dark_matter with simplified_model theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (17) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_6308_u1s_fermion_inverse_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1207_6308", "source_line": 1649, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4256, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for U(1)_S radiative inverse-seesaw neutral fermion dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_simplified_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_10833_s4z5_scalar_mediator_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_10833", "source_line": 4400, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4257, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as S4 x Z5 flavored scalar-mediator fermionic dark matter: thermal freeze-out through mediator exchange; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes indirect/transient, laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_4635_froggatt_nielsen_leptophilic_scalar_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1105_4635", "source_line": 1273, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4258, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 8 for Froggatt-Nielsen leptophilic scalar dark matter decay model: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from probe hints: direct detection, indirect detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_03990_constrained_nmssm_rh_sneutrino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1707_03990", "source_line": 3194, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 4259, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 8.0: Constrained NMSSM with right-handed sneutrino LSP is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal freeze-out of the right-handed sneutrino LSP followed by late-time entropy dilution if it is to match the observed abundance.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_01386_dark_higgsstrahlung_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_01386", "source_line": 2400, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 315, "global_rank": 4260, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and possible thermal relic through scalar Higgs portal, collider production via dark-Higgsstrahlung production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_11899_pseudoreal_electroweak_multiplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_11899", "source_line": 5442, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Potential probe complementarity is under-specified because observables, constraints, routing, and code are absent."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4261, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the pseudoreal electroweak multiplet has natural direct/indirect/collider complementarity in principle, but the supplied card omits those routes and constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_4549_lonely_higgsino_high_scale_susy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_4549", "source_line": 2302, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 4262, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 8 because the assigned model card effective field theory supersymmetric_dark_matter card; touches direct detection.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_5600_flavor_origin_z3_semiannihilating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_5600", "source_line": 2307, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4263, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 8 because the assigned model card uv complete semi_annihilating_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_6608_natural_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1305_6608", "source_line": 1830, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 4264, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and the filled card gives limited distinctive observational structure-formation content.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_00885_singlet_doublet_fermion_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_00885", "source_line": 4395, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4265, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Singlet-doublet fermion dark matter with right-handed neutrinos: thermal freeze-out; partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_5724_su5_orbifold_natural_susy_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1304_5724", "source_line": 1832, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4266, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=no, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on direct detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_6342_mass_degenerate_majorana_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1306_6342", "source_line": 1865, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4267, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with coannihilation production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4 while penalties total 17."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_0628_o_n_scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0902_0628", "source_line": 973, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 4268, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_singlet_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and can produce all dark matter.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bottom_philic_axial_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_2018_bottom_philic_axial_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1404_2018", "source_line": 2101, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4269, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bottom_philic_pseudoscalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_2018_bottom_philic_pseudoscalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1404_2018", "source_line": 2103, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4270, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bottom_philic_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_2018_bottom_philic_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1404_2018", "source_line": 2102, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4271, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 30.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_mediated_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_4675_axion_mediated_dirac_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1205_4675", "source_line": 1560, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4272, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the axion-mediated family is rare and phenomenologically distinctive, but the card supplies no model-local observable routing, constraints, or code and flags resonance sensitivity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "top_coupled_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2863_top_window_scalar_resonance_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2863", "source_line": 1564, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4273, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the top-window scalar resonance is a rare illustrative simplified model, but observational and computational routing are missing and the relic argument is resonance and loop sensitive."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_00685_z3_two_loop_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_00685", "source_line": 3038, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4274, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Z3 two-loop radiative neutrino model with singlet-like scalar dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "grand_unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_03974_so10_u1chi_scalar_triplet_s_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_03974", "source_line": 3618, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4275, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative grand_unified_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_06025_a4_hybrid_seesaw_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_06025", "source_line": 4385, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 4276, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as A4 hybrid seesaw scalar dark matter: thermal scalar dark-matter freeze-out; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_2772_little_higgs_topological_soliton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0905_2772", "source_line": 996, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4277, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative topological_soliton_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and full or subcomponent relic treatment.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Diversity score is boosted by a rare or distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or macroscopic/composite character in the population context.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_07427_2hdm_pseudoscalar_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_07427", "source_line": 3046, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4278, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Two-Higgs-doublet pseudoscalar mediator singlet-fermion dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_07385_rh_sneutrino_wino_coannihilation_sism_v1", "paper_id": "1807_07385", "source_line": 3553, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 4279, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "2204_12517_sigma81_scotogenic_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2204_12517", "source_line": 5167, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 4280, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: rare multi-component radiative-neutrino model, but the supplied card has no relic-density calculation, no phase-space content, and no observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_09751_softly_broken_sun_pseudo_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_09751", "source_line": 3735, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4281, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Softly broken SU(N) pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone Higgs-portal dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_5084_e6_dterm_amsb_wino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0807_5084", "source_line": 781, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes"], "family_rank": 186, "global_rank": 4282, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 8.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_2571_scale_invariant_hidden_pion_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1103_2571", "source_line": 1307, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 316, "global_rank": 4283, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 11, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1430_nonminimal_ued_z1_lkp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1430", "source_line": 1309, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4284, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for kaluza_klein_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_00547_alp_portal_majorana_rhn_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2106_00547", "source_line": 4721, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 317, "global_rank": 4285, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and production via thermal freeze-out through ALP-mediated annihilation.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 8 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_04466_gsugra_bino_wino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2106_04466", "source_line": 4731, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 187, "global_rank": 4286, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; neutralino annihilation to W+W-.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 8 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_13376_singlet_triplet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2010_13376", "source_line": 4462, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4287, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for scalar_singlet_triplet_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 8.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03301_multiflavor_real_scalar_lepton_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03301", "source_line": 4651, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4288, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inflaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_05860_thermal_inflaton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2105_05860", "source_line": 4711, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4289, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative inflaton_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via thermal freeze-out after Higgs-portal thermalization; post-inflation reheating through particle production during scalar oscillations.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 8 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_12569_b_minus_l_scalar_dm_radiative_dirac_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "2112_12569", "source_line": 4964, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4290, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar singlet doublet dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and thermal freeze-out.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by partial associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "isospin_violating_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_03878_so10_u1x_dirac_fermion_ivdm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_03878", "source_line": 4951, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4291, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative isospin violating vector portal dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and thermal WIMP freeze-out through Z-prime mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by partial associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_13551_scotogenic_georgi_machacek_inert_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2011_13551", "source_line": 4547, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4292, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0612245_su2z_false_vacuum_wimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0612245", "source_line": 632, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 318, "global_rank": 4293, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "conformal_quiver_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0606152_lightest_conformality_particle_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0606152", "source_line": 648, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4294, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has high diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimensions_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0610155_left_right_ued_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0610155", "source_line": 649, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4295, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "conformality_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0608039_lightest_conformality_particle_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0608039", "source_line": 618, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4296, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has high diversity value within the population-count context, comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_00720_pseudoscalar_diboson_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_00720", "source_line": 3231, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 4297, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Pseudoscalar diboson-portal Dirac fermion dark matter is a speculative wimp_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_00720_scalar_diboson_portal_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_00720", "source_line": 3229, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 4298, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Scalar diboson-portal real vector dark matter is a speculative wimp_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavoured_dark_matter", "model_id": "1502_03385_nonminimal_flavour_violating_quark_flavoured_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1502_03385", "source_line": 2385, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4299, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative flavoured_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal WIMP freeze-out production.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card is CDM-like or leaves cosmological and structure-formation effects unknown.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card. Diversity credit is added for underrepresented family (5 cards in population context); multi-component candidate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_0302_fourth_family_majorana_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1105_0302", "source_line": 1347, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4300, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=no.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for decaying_neutrino_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_0366_two_component_decaying_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1312_0366", "source_line": 2037, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4301, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=unknown, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "magnetic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_3326_s_e_y_magnetic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1312_3326", "source_line": 2010, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4302, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_05023_gev_mixed_sneutrino_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1505_05023", "source_line": 2509, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4303, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for GeV-mass mixed sneutrino WIMP: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 8.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "magnetic_moment_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_05872_sey_magnetic_moment_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_05872", "source_line": 2511, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4304, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for SEy magnetic-moment dark matter model: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 8.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fourth_generation_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_3490_b4l4_right_handed_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1105_3490", "source_line": 1332, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4305, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for fourth_generation_neutrino_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1107_2048_dirac_fermion_contact_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1107_2048", "source_line": 1349, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4306, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=benchmark, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for effective_operator_wimp_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_07962_750gev_scalar_portal_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_07962", "source_line": 2845, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4307, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_06083_inert_doublet_u1l_neutrino_mass_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_06083", "source_line": 3210, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4308, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Flavor-dependent U(1)_L radiative neutrino model with inert doublet dark matter is a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_inert_doublet_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_11430_indalo_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_11430", "source_line": 5386, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 119, "global_rank": 4309, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Indalo asymmetric dark matter in minimal SU(5) asymptotic grand unification has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_1669_shadow_baryon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0910_1669", "source_line": 1051, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 319, "global_rank": 4310, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_7817_nonabelian_vector_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1210_7817", "source_line": 1731, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4311, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 8.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_scalar_wimp", "model_id": "1212_4806_three_loop_radiative_scalar_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_4806", "source_line": 1740, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4312, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to neutrino.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlino_resonant_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_7371_singlino_resonant_dm_nmssm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_7371", "source_line": 2148, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4313, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: CMB relevance is low; BBN relevance is low.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_4192_grand_unified_hidden_sector_dark_baryons_v1", "paper_id": "1407_4192", "source_line": 2209, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 120, "global_rank": 4314, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked for a uv complete asymmetric_dark_matter card with explicit relic-production relevance.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "No distinct probe classes were explicit enough to score complementarity.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_scalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_07443_dirac_dm_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1701_07443", "source_line": 3105, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4315, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of simplified_scalar_mediator_dark_matter with raw score 8.0.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 1.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_09822_accidentally_asymmetric_dark_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "2103_09822", "source_line": 4668, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 8, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4316, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status emerging, theory level uv_complete, and relic production yes; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_11667_sterile_neutrino_dark_massive_halos_v1", "paper_id": "2210_11667", "source_line": 5370, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 116, "global_rank": 4317, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Sterile-neutrino dark massive halos has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2211_13364_gb_higgs_inflation_pbh_bump_type_v1", "paper_id": "2211_13364", "source_line": 5398, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 206, "global_rank": 4318, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Gauss-Bonnet Higgs-inflation PBH dark matter (bump-type effective potential) has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: compact objects, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value, large penalties for missing observables, constraints, and follow-up machinery."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2211_13364_gb_higgs_inflation_pbh_intermediate_type_v1", "paper_id": "2211_13364", "source_line": 5399, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 207, "global_rank": 4319, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Gauss-Bonnet Higgs-inflation PBH dark matter (intermediate-type effective potential) has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: compact objects, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value, large penalties for missing observables, constraints, and follow-up machinery."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_dirac_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_05307_dark_photon_u1x_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_05307", "source_line": 5366, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4320, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because U(1)_X dark-photon Dirac-fermion dark matter in the undemocratic Dirac seesaw has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_1105_pev_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1308_1105", "source_line": 1973, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 4321, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: moderate observational leverage from cosmology, phase space, laboratory reach, or structure formation.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: indirect detection; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "hep-ph0209322_cardassian_interacting_dark_matter_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0209322", "source_line": 451, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4322, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 8, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; suppression small-scale-power effect; scale_dependent_growth transfer behavior.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including high, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_03698_pbh_boosted_self_annihilating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_03698", "source_line": 4503, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 158, "global_rank": 4323, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 7.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from enhancement of small-scale power.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_1634_nonthermal_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "0807_1634", "source_line": 809, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4324, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/high, phase space is nonthermal. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_2089_planck_boundary_singlet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1312_2089", "source_line": 1993, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4325, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_3547_axion_bec_big_vortex_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1307_3547", "source_line": 1863, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 280, "global_rank": 4326, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative phenomenological-parameterization model with axion/field production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from nonlinear structure-formation effects, field-like phase-space behavior.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching galaxy satellites / small-scale structure.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 5.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_05327_tev_mirage_nmssm_higgsino_singlino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1509_05327", "source_line": 2566, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 188, "global_rank": 4327, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include mixed_cold_warm phase space, high BBN relevance.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "2109_08676_shan_chen_interacting_vacuum_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_08676", "source_line": 197, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4328, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 7.5 for interacting_dark_sector: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, high CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, some associated computational support, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; current-data compatibility is unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_09706_scale_invariant_z2_majorana_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2012_09706", "source_line": 4511, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 190, "global_rank": 4329, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from high CMB relevance, decay_produced phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_unparticle_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "0803_3223_cold_plus_unmatter_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0803_3223", "source_line": 815, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4330, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked no, CMB/BBN relevance is high/unknown. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_11210_susy_clockwork_axion_axino_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_11210", "source_line": 5943, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4331, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because SUSY clockwork axion-mediated axino inelastic dark matter is a speculative axion_mediated_dark_matter card with unknown phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and direct detection from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 10, observational leverage 3, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 3.5, penalties 20; raw score 7.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "clustered_primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_03704_extreme_cluster_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_03704", "source_line": 193, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4332, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 29.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 7.5 for clustered_primordial_black_hole_dark_matter: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, high CMB relevance, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2109_09769_near_extremal_charged_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2109_09769", "source_line": 4819, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 208, "global_rank": 4333, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1908_02662_domain_wall_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1908_02662", "source_line": 88, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 209, "global_rank": 4334, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this primordial_black_holes card is viable enough to score, with simplified_model theory support and explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0510147_mev_complex_scalar_u_boson_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0510147", "source_line": 574, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4335, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Complex scalar MeV dark matter with light U-boson mediator is a speculative simplified model card in family light_vector_mediator_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out through U-mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium BBN relevance; probe classes: BBN.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_0715_high_scale_susy_gaugino_coannihilation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_0715", "source_line": 2047, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4336, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=effective_field_theory, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_th0405081_light_q_balls_expanding_universe_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0405081", "source_line": 506, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 4337, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Light Q-balls in an expanding universe is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card with unknown relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (field like; small-scale effect unknown); it touches compact objects / microlensing / dynamics; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_03486_anomaly_free_zprime_dark_lepton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_03486", "source_line": 4112, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4338, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 7.5: speculative zprime_portal_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: collider.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_06856_scalar_fermion_two_component_simp_v1", "paper_id": "2201_06856", "source_line": 5047, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 159, "global_rank": 4339, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Scalar and fermion two-component SIMP dark matter with accidental Z4 has probe classes: small-scale structure, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_14199_qed_dm_thermal_dirac_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2402_14199", "source_line": 5949, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 117, "global_rank": 4340, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because QED_DM thermal Dirac dark matter is a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and no explicit routed probe class from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 11, observational leverage 2, complementarity 0, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 1.5, penalties 16; raw score 7.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_07652_no_scale_nonuniversal_gaugino_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_07652", "source_line": 2594, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4341, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include medium CMB relevance.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2508_right_chiral_sneutrino_lsp_msugra_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2508", "source_line": 761, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 4342, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 7.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance medium; probe classes counted: ['BBN'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_relic_entropy_dilution_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_11444_entropy_injected_generalized_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2111_11444", "source_line": 5013, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4343, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Entropy-injected generalized freeze-out dark matter has probe classes: BBN; high diversity value from rare or distinctive production/phase-space behavior, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_1847_singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_1847", "source_line": 1429, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 4344, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 7.5 because the card describes higgs portal dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal freeze-out through scalar-mediated annihilation and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage with partial associated-code support.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coannihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_6169_coannihilating_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_6169", "source_line": 2004, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4345, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=effective_field_theory, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=partial and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_7006_dark_technicolor_technibaryon_v1", "paper_id": "1304_7006", "source_line": 1864, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4346, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_0231_no_scale_f_su5_bino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1104_0231", "source_line": 1382, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 189, "global_rank": 4347, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter: production is represented by thermal neutralino freeze-out; phase-space is thermal; inferred probe coverage includes indirect detection.", "Score drivers: scientific score is supported by uv_complete structure and the supplied production history; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauge_higgs_unification_stable_higgs_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_3756_susy_gauge_higgs_stable_higgs_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_3756", "source_line": 1424, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4348, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 7.5 because the card describes gauge higgs unification stable higgs dark matter at uv complete level, with stable Higgs relic abundance tied to Higgs mass window and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_6632_axion_mediated_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_6632", "source_line": 1741, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4349, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to strong-CP/PQ/axion, hidden-sector structure.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_08432_sism_single_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1511_08432", "source_line": 2728, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4350, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves a card-local full-dark-matter production route.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_8384_ab_r_string_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1409_8384", "source_line": 2232, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 4351, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "Some cosmological or phase-space handles are present, but explicit observable fields are absent.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching BBN.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_b_minus_l_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_05307_gauged_b_minus_l_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_05307", "source_line": 5365, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4352, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because U(1) B-L Dirac-fermion dark matter in the undemocratic Dirac seesaw has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05344_ethos_interacting_dm_dr_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05344", "source_line": 2691, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 320, "global_rank": 4353, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 9, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status emerging, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, production ability unknown, and family count 506. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, oscillations small-scale-power effect, approximate distribution information.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_08369_stiff_scalar_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_08369", "source_line": 2631, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 4354, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Complex scalar-field dark matter with stiff early phase is marked speculative with phenomenological parameterization theory level and production support 'yes'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare production wording in population counts, field_like phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'field like' and small-scale-power effect 'suppression'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_05364_usr_inflation_supermassive_pbh_seed_v1", "paper_id": "2306_05364", "source_line": 144, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 210, "global_rank": 4355, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, enhancement small-scale-power effect, enhanced small scale power transfer behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_06268_axion_star_phase_transition_bec_v1", "paper_id": "1710_06268", "source_line": 41, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 281, "global_rank": 4356, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, suppression small-scale-power effect, field_like phase-space description, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "1901_01031_extended_logotropic_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1901_01031", "source_line": 125, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4357, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative unified_dark_fluid card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and high CMB relevance, scale dependent growth transfer behavior, field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "brane_world_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0307062_massive_branon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0307062", "source_line": 489, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4358, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; suppression small-scale-power effect.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "curvaton_decay_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0311562_curvaton_decay_cdm_three_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0311562", "source_line": 462, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4359, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including low, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0511098_type_iib_flux_dilaton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0511098", "source_line": 651, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 4360, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: some cosmology or phase-space leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "emergent_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_14649_pattern_field_effective_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1910_14649", "source_line": 242, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4361, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative emergent_effective_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=scale_dependent_growth, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: galaxy_scale_only."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2006_14597_usr_inflation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2006_14597", "source_line": 4301, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 211, "global_rank": 4362, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Ultra-slow-roll inflationary primordial black-hole dark matter as a speculative primordial_black_holes model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and production via collapse of enhanced primordial curvature perturbations after horizon re-entry.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=high and BBN=unknown; phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_14488_minimal_scalar_rrg_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "2010_14488", "source_line": 277, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 4363, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Minimally coupled scalar-field reduced-relativistic-gas warm dark matter, a speculative warm dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, thermal phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: warn_001."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_05738_su5_dfsz_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_05738", "source_line": 4115, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 4364, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 7: speculative qcd_axion_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked unknown.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: field_like phase-space behavior; inferred probe classes: no explicit probe routing objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_03573_superheavy_wimp_string_single_modulus_branching_v1", "paper_id": "2010_03573", "source_line": 4439, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4365, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes nonthermal branching production from inflaton decay, dilution by late modulus decay.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance, decay produced phase-space structure.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_1259_scotogenic_n1_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1405_1259", "source_line": 2154, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 191, "global_rank": 4366, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with nonthermal phase-space entry, and suppression small-scale-power effect.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_03056_type_a_varying_kinetic_mixing_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_03056", "source_line": 5481, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 192, "global_rank": 4367, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Type-A scalar-controlled varying-kinetic-mixing dark photon dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase space, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_03056_type_b_varying_kinetic_mixing_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_03056", "source_line": 5482, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 193, "global_rank": 4368, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Type-B scalar-controlled varying-kinetic-mixing dark photon dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase space, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_06546_neutron_decay_asymmetric_dm_light_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1811_06546", "source_line": 3686, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 121, "global_rank": 4369, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative asymmetric_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; high BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "qcd_axion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_04464_false_vacuum_higgs_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2001_04464", "source_line": 4174, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 4370, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of qcd_axion_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity credit reflects a comparatively distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or dominant probe class in the population context.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0005123_low_reheat_wimp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0005123", "source_line": 400, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 4371, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via production from thermal scatterings during reheating; annihilation and freeze-out before radiation domination can complete; CMB relevance unknown and BBN relevance critical; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: BBN, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_08598_small_instanton_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_08598", "source_line": 4652, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 282, "global_rank": 4372, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production yes; high CMB relevance; field_like phase space; probe relevance for CMB.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_15061_near_inflection_model_ii_fermionic_reheating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_15061", "source_line": 5426, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Near-duplicate inflationary freeze-in variant with missing observables, constraints, routing, and code."], "family_rank": 194, "global_rank": 4373, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: this sibling near-inflection reheating freeze-in variant has high CMB relevance and nonthermal production, but sparse observational details and a duplicate penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_08527_z2_simp_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_08527", "source_line": 2611, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 118, "global_rank": 4374, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Z2 SIMP singlet scalar dark matter with 4-to-2 freeze-out is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'yes'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, limited but present observational leverage in phase-space or structure fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, nonthermal phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'nonthermal' and small-scale-power effect 'unknown'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2301_13215_quasi_extremal_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_13215", "source_line": 111, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 212, "global_rank": 4375, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0704_2914_neutralino_lsp_stau_nlsp_v1", "paper_id": "0704_2914", "source_line": 684, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 4376, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_06746_hidden_u1d_z4_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_06746", "source_line": 2999, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 160, "global_rank": 4377, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_massive_particle", "model_id": "2006_15148_hidden_qcd_simp_unstable_pion_v1", "paper_id": "2006_15148", "source_line": 4339, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4378, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Hidden-QCD SIMP with an unstable pNGB meson as a speculative strongly_interacting_massive_particle model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via thermal SIMP freeze-out through WZW 3-to-2 dark meson reactions.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=high and BBN=medium; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: isospin_breaking_sensitivity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mirror_dark_sector", "model_id": "2211_03236_mirror_dark_sector_varying_alpha_v1", "paper_id": "2211_03236", "source_line": 116, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4379, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative mirror_dark_sector card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and critical CMB relevance, high BBN relevance.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_12493_scalar_tensor_cdm_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2312_12493", "source_line": 158, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4380, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 7.0 for interacting_dark_matter: positive factors include simplified_model theory level, high CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_gravitational_production", "model_id": "2401_16910_spectator_ultralight_scalar_inflationary_production_v1", "paper_id": "2401_16910", "source_line": 103, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4381, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative ultralight_scalar_gravitational_production card with simplified model theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "curvaton_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0611948_neutralino_curvaton_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0611948", "source_line": 686, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4382, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_11516_spectator_coupled_light_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_11516", "source_line": 5451, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 321, "global_rank": 4383, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Spectator-coupled light dark photon dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase space, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boosted_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_13035_fopt_pbh_boosted_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_13035", "source_line": 5471, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4384, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: FOPT primordial-black-hole boosted fermion dark matter has limited supplied theoretical scoring fields, medium CMB relevance, decay_produced phase space, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1011_0286_rastall_scalar_gcg_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1011_0286", "source_line": 86, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4385, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this unified_dark_matter_dark_energy card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_1776_wimp_dark_gauge_boson_radiation_v1", "paper_id": "1303_1776", "source_line": 1801, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 322, "global_rank": 4386, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal; CMB relevance is high.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on CMB and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phenomenological_unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "1404_5836_chiral_two_field_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1404_5836", "source_line": 240, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4387, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative phenomenological_unified_dark_sector entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_01947_moduli_portal_vector_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_01947", "source_line": 3647, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 195, "global_rank": 4388, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_00013_pure_wino_variable_splitting_v1", "paper_id": "1903_00013", "source_line": 3802, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority under the model-card-only rule because key observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4389, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a benchmark effective field theory model with production listed as thermal freeze-out.", "Lower observational leverage because the card is mostly CDM-like or lacks explicit observable and constraint entries.", "Feasibility is limited because computational representation, routing, benchmarks, and public code are sparse or absent in the card.", "The score is strongly penalized by missing observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing under the model-card-only rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mimetic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_13495_extended_mimetic_gravity_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2010_13495", "source_line": 82, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4390, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this mimetic_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "0912_0949_non_lagrangian_unified_dark_sector_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "0912_0949", "source_line": 21, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4391, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector_scalar_field", "model_id": "1002_4035_einstein_tensor_scalar_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1002_4035", "source_line": 50, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4392, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_08595_inelastic_dark_higgs_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_08595", "source_line": 4504, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 323, "global_rank": 4393, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 28.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_10286_pngb_freeze_in_inflaton_v1", "paper_id": "2012_10286", "source_line": 4492, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 196, "global_rank": 4394, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from nonthermal phase-space history.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2010_14426_pbh_cdm_asymmetric_hawking_baryogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2010_14426", "source_line": 4482, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 213, "global_rank": 4395, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for primordial_black_holes.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_12433_split_family_susy_bino_wino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1903_12433", "source_line": 3782, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 190, "global_rank": 4396, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 7 because the card identifies production via thermal_freeze_out, bino_wino_coannihilation, thermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dipole_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_03662_undulating_electric_dipole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_03662", "source_line": 4341, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4397, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Undulating electric-dipole dark matter as a speculative dipole_portal_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via fermion dark matter abundance left phenomenological.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=unknown and BBN=medium; phase-space type mixed_cold_warm.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_baryonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9907023_cold_hydrogen_halo_clouds_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9907023", "source_line": 252, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4398, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Cold molecular hydrogen halo cloud dark matter, a speculative macroscopic baryonic dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance, nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: macroscopic_baryonic_borderline, mass_exponent_parsing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_10934_dark_glueball_d6_higgs_portal_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1901_10934", "source_line": 3750, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 324, "global_rank": 4399, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Dark glueball d=6 Higgs-portal UV freeze-in model is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, nonthermal phase-space behavior; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_01233_linear_redshift_eos_non_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_01233", "source_line": 263, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4400, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Linear-redshift equation-of-state non-cold dark matter, a speculative non cold dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, scale dependent growth transfer behavior.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: 2308_linear_gp_parameterization."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majorana_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0612024_dim5_majorana_dark_neutrino_oscillation_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0612024", "source_line": 667, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4401, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phenomenological_dark_matter_fluid", "model_id": "1411_6789_polytropic_dark_matter_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1411_6789", "source_line": 264, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4402, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Polytropic dark matter fluid cosmological model, a speculative phenomenological dark matter fluid entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: phenomenological_not_particle_model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_02313_composite_dark_baryon_adm_nuggets_v1", "paper_id": "1707_02313", "source_line": 3138, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 122, "global_rank": 4403, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of asymmetric_dark_matter with raw score 7.0.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from distinct phase-space production.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 182.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_boson_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0611664_pgb_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0611664", "source_line": 658, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4404, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "1401_1270_viscous_unified_dark_fluid_cass_v1", "paper_id": "1401_1270", "source_line": 208, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4405, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative unified_dark_fluid entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2003_03821_dbi_sound_speed_resonance_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2003_03821", "source_line": 4152, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 214, "global_rank": 4406, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of primordial_black_holes; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, 2 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2207_11878_generalized_e_attractor_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2207_11878", "source_line": 202, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 215, "global_rank": 4407, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=low, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB, compact-object/dynamical.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_12291_su3_adjoint_wino_triplet_composite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_12291", "source_line": 4367, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 161, "global_rank": 4408, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as SU(3) adjoint anomaly-matched composite Wino-triplet dark matter: thermal freeze-out through electroweak annihilation; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes BBN, CMB.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2112_07614_two_field_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2112_07614", "source_line": 5008, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 216, "global_rank": 4409, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Two-field sharp-turn primordial black hole dark matter model has probe classes: CMB, compact objects, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "astro_ph9808142_qcd_transition_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9808142", "source_line": 6137, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 217, "global_rank": 4410, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 7 (defer) from supplied card content: primordial_black_holes with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production; cosmological relevance: CMB medium.", "Penalties (20) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_0868_cold_dark_matter_creation_v1", "paper_id": "1205_0868", "source_line": 1577, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4411, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card has CMB/BBN-relevant dark-matter-creation cosmology, but no microscopic particle identity, constraints, routes, or implementation are supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_3401_bilinear_rpv_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1003_3401", "source_line": 1075, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 4412, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model gravitino_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (BBN high).", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_4280_unbroken_u1x_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1303_4280", "source_line": 1763, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 325, "global_rank": 4413, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 7: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family hidden_sector_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance medium; BBN relevance low; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as CMB.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 506; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_7673_r_symmetric_gmsb_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_7673", "source_line": 1788, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 4414, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 7: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family gravitino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance low; BBN relevance high; complementarity probes counted as BBN.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 77; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_05022_millicharged_dark_photon_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_05022", "source_line": 3563, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 197, "global_rank": 4415, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it can supply all dark matter according to the production block, has nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_14605_sterile_neutrino_u1r_light_x_v1", "paper_id": "2007_14605", "source_line": 4355, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 152, "global_rank": 4416, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Sterile neutrino dark matter in U(1)_R with a light X boson: freeze-in production from SM fermion annihilation f fbar -> nu_s nu_s through the extra U(1) interaction; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_15697_electron_specific_scalar_mediator_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_15697", "source_line": 5936, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 4417, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Vector DM with an electron-specific spin-0 mediator is a benchmark vector_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and collider from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 11, observational leverage 2, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 1.0, penalties 18; raw score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_02241_scale_genesis_hidden_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1610_02241", "source_line": 2889, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 326, "global_rank": 4418, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production; 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_thermal_history_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_10522_modified_early_matter_domination_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_10522", "source_line": 3732, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4419, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Modified early matter domination dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, probe relevance for BBN, distinctive production, phase-space, or family coverage; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1910_07756_su2_yang_mills_glueball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1910_07756", "source_line": 3983, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observational routes, constraints, and observables.", "No usable computational-representation or public-code support is present in the model card."], "family_rank": 327, "global_rank": 4420, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for SU(2) Yang-Mills glueball dark matter: limited but nonzero model-card support; inferred probe classes are galaxy satellites.", "Score 7 (defer) uses production=nonperturbative glueball formation in a confining dark Yang-Mills sector; possible production associated with the dark deconfinement/confinement phase transition; phase=unknown; CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown; transfer=unknown, small_scale=unknown; it is limited by empty explicit observables/constraints/routes and sparse computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptonic_scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_04410_leptonic_scalar_portal_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_04410", "source_line": 5025, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4421, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Leptonic scalar portal complex-scalar dark matter has probe classes: CMB; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector_fluid", "model_id": "astro_ph0411221_new_generalized_chaplygin_gas_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0411221", "source_line": 552, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4422, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["New generalized Chaplygin gas unified dark-sector model is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card in family unified_dark_sector_fluid with production described as phenomenological FRW fluid evolution.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_08339_r2_kinetic_misalignment_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2209_08339", "source_line": 5369, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 283, "global_rank": 4423, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because R^2-modified kinetic misalignment axion has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: phase-space observables, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_12002_loop_neutrino_portal_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_12002", "source_line": 4459, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4424, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for neutrino_portal_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_12002_loop_neutrino_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_12002", "source_line": 4460, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4425, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for neutrino_portal_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1707_03595_matter_dominated_primordial_black_holes_v1", "paper_id": "1707_03595", "source_line": 3216, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 218, "global_rank": 4426, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Matter-dominated primordial black holes with angular-momentum spin distribution is a speculative primordial_black_holes card with CMB/BBN relevance medium/unknown, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_1452_vector_like_charged_lepton_portal_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_1452", "source_line": 1786, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 123, "global_rank": 4427, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 7: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family asymmetric_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance low; BBN relevance low; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type nonthermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 182; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_1452_vector_like_down_quark_portal_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_1452", "source_line": 1785, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 124, "global_rank": 4428, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 7: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family asymmetric_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance low; BBN relevance low; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type nonthermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 182; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_1452_vector_like_up_quark_portal_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_1452", "source_line": 1784, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 125, "global_rank": 4429, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 7: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family asymmetric_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance low; BBN relevance low; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type nonthermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 182; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_10025_pq_relaxion_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_10025", "source_line": 3277, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 284, "global_rank": 4430, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion like dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from field like phase-space structure.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 7.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "isospin_violating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_0324_complex_scalar_colored_mediator_ivdm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_0324", "source_line": 2060, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4431, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of isospin_violating_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "isospin_violating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_0324_real_scalar_colored_mediator_ivdm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_0324", "source_line": 2059, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4432, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of isospin_violating_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_1914_split_susy_neutralino_gravitino_decay_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1404_1914", "source_line": 2072, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 4433, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of supersymmetric_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_4737_singlet_scalar_higgs_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_4737", "source_line": 2069, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 4434, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2205_14813_higgs_r2_tachyonic_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2205_14813", "source_line": 5221, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 219, "global_rank": 4435, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, high CMB relevance, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "quark_nugget_macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "0704_3064_antimatter_quark_nugget_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0704_3064", "source_line": 688, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4436, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_03309_fermionic_scotogenic_tbm_perturbed_v1", "paper_id": "1607_03309", "source_line": 2857, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 4437, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_multicomponent_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_00365_hidden_su3_mixed_spin_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_00365", "source_line": 2976, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4438, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_multicomponent_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_16267_composite_vacuum_misalignment_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_16267", "source_line": 4309, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4439, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Composite vacuum-misalignment pNGB dark matter with a light ALP as a speculative composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via nonthermal vacuum-misalignment production.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: w_eta_not_dm."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_06189_lepton_number_fimp_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_06189", "source_line": 4742, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 198, "global_rank": 4440, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via freeze-in from scalar isosinglet decay; out-of-equilibrium production tied to lepton-number violation.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 7 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_06618_e7_pure_gravity_wino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_06618", "source_line": 2882, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4441, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support, emphasizing card gives parameter-dependent dark-matter production.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified; high-severity card warning requires care."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_06590_scotogenic_scalar_doublet_sommerfeld_v1", "paper_id": "1611_06590", "source_line": 2997, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4442, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_06590_scotogenic_scalar_quartet_sommerfeld_v1", "paper_id": "1611_06590", "source_line": 2998, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4443, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_03172_thermal_phase_transition_sterile_neutrino_portal_fimp_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1810_03172", "source_line": 3603, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 199, "global_rank": 4444, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_flavoured_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_08142_lepton_flavoured_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_08142", "source_line": 5474, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4445, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Lepton-flavoured complex scalar dark matter with left- and right-handed lepton couplings has some theory and relic-density motivation, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "uv_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_01675_uv_freeze_in_singlet_fermion_dim5_v1", "paper_id": "2103_01675", "source_line": 4569, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4446, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_freeze_in_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 2."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "uv_freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_01675_uv_freeze_in_singlet_fermion_dim6_v1", "paper_id": "2103_01675", "source_line": 4570, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4447, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_freeze_in_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 2."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_03063_earth_mass_axion_star_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_03063", "source_line": 4807, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 285, "global_rank": 4448, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_08767_flavorful_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1701_08767", "source_line": 3006, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 328, "global_rank": 4449, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Flavorful portal dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_1280_millicharged_decaying_dark_matter_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1403_1280", "source_line": 2111, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4450, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: CMB relevance is medium.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2212_03577_nonminimal_spectator_pbh_dm_model_g_v1", "paper_id": "2212_03577", "source_line": 5421, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables, constraints, routing, or code are supplied for this variant."], "family_rank": 220, "global_rank": 4451, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked PBH spectator variant: it can produce all dark matter and touches CMB/compact-object probes, but supplied observational and computational details are sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1302_4394_heavy_scalar_cmssm_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1302_4394", "source_line": 1767, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 191, "global_rank": 4452, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 7: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance medium; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as CMB.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 309; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_10791_dirac_fermion_pseudoscalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_10791", "source_line": 3746, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4453, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Dirac fermion pseudoscalar Higgs-portal dark matter is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, probe relevance for CMB; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "branon_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0507066_massive_branon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0507066", "source_line": 602, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4454, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 27.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_2380_hidden_sector_global_u1x_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_2380", "source_line": 2020, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 329, "global_rank": 4455, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=unknown/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to CMB, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0803_4196_wimpless_hidden_sector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0803_4196", "source_line": 782, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 330, "global_rank": 4456, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability yes, raw score 7.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance medium, CMB relevance low; probe classes counted: ['BBN'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_0517_dbrane_low_string_scale_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0912_0517", "source_line": 1068, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 192, "global_rank": 4457, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative effective_field_theory supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium).", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_1031_f_theory_scenario_i_bino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1002_1031", "source_line": 1085, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 193, "global_rank": 4458, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium).", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1134_light_mssm_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1134", "source_line": 1316, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 194, "global_rank": 4459, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_degenerate_wimp", "model_id": "0803_2251_pseudo_degenerate_wimp_type_a_v1", "paper_id": "0803_2251", "source_line": 807, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4460, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/medium. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_degenerate_wimp", "model_id": "0803_2251_pseudo_degenerate_wimp_type_b_v1", "paper_id": "0803_2251", "source_line": 808, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4461, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is unknown/medium. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fifth_force_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_4363_fifth_force_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0807_4363", "source_line": 803, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4462, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0204176_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0204176", "source_line": 431, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 195, "global_rank": 4463, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides uv complete theory support; probe signal: cmb.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_04566_r_symmetric_gravitino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1701_04566", "source_line": 3050, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 4464, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["R-symmetric Dirac-gaugino gravitino dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0904_1114_purely_kinetic_dbi_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "0904_1114", "source_line": 250, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4465, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative unified_dark_sector_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_09091_self_interacting_scalar_u1chi_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_09091", "source_line": 3706, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4466, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Self-interacting scalar dark matter in a scotogenic U(1)_chi Dirac-neutrino model is a speculative uv complete candidate with probe relevance for CMB; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9608420_wilsonian_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9608420", "source_line": 6132, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 331, "global_rank": 4467, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 7 (defer) from supplied card content: hidden_sector_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (18) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptonic_scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_04410_leptonic_scalar_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_04410", "source_line": 5026, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4468, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Leptonic scalar portal fermionic dark matter has probe classes: CMB; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_12243_meson_haloscopy_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_12243", "source_line": 4864, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 286, "global_rank": 4469, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from phenomenological_parameterization theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Observational/diversity drivers: medium CMB relevance.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_coannihilation", "model_id": "hep-ph0402208_gluino_coannihilation_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0402208", "source_line": 459, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4470, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_4568_su5_1plus200_mixed_bino_wino_higgsino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0902_4568", "source_line": 921, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 196, "global_rank": 4471, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, partial code or computational support, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Penalties mainly reflect missing observable mapping, constraints, and routing rather than global elimination.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_4601_leptophilic_sterile_neutrino_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1002_4601", "source_line": 1081, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 153, "global_rank": 4472, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model sterile_neutrino_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0701256_mssm_interval_higgsino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0701256", "source_line": 656, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 197, "global_rank": 4473, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; limited computational support; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_0937_exothermic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1004_0937", "source_line": 1104, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 4474, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in inelastic_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3867_minimal_dark_matter_fermion_5plet_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3867", "source_line": 839, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4475, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark simplified_model model, production is marked yes. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_03765_model_a_multicomponent_radiative_seesaw_v1", "paper_id": "1711_03765", "source_line": 3283, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 162, "global_rank": 4476, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi component dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 7.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_05868_neutrino_portal_dirac_fermion_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2111_05868", "source_line": 4904, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 4477, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Neutrino-portal Dirac fermion thermal freeze-out dark matter is benchmark with simplified_model theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: no explicit probe class in the model card.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: scientific value, provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 1-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "technicolor_dark_matter", "model_id": "0810_2022_minimal_walking_technicolor_n2_v1", "paper_id": "0810_2022", "source_line": 818, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4478, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_effective_wimp", "model_id": "1402_7358_complex_scalar_leptophilic_effective_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7358", "source_line": 2094, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4479, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_effective_wimp; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_effective_wimp", "model_id": "1402_7358_dirac_leptophilic_effective_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7358", "source_line": 2092, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4480, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_effective_wimp; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_effective_wimp", "model_id": "1402_7358_majorana_leptophilic_effective_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7358", "source_line": 2093, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4481, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_effective_wimp; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_effective_wimp", "model_id": "1402_7358_real_scalar_leptophilic_effective_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7358", "source_line": 2095, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4482, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_effective_wimp; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_07981_dynamical_space_time_unified_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1802_07981", "source_line": 257, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4483, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Dynamical-space-time unified dark matter and dark energy, a speculative unified dark sector dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: dst_effective_fluid_warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_07985_nonuniversal_gaugino_nmssm_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_07985", "source_line": 3576, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 4484, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph9608420_wilsonian_uniton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9608420", "source_line": 6131, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 332, "global_rank": 4485, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 7 (defer) from supplied card content: hidden_sector_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (18) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_2647_dark_matter_pions_v1", "paper_id": "1307_2647", "source_line": 1821, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4486, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on no explicit probe class in observables, constraints, or routing fields and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_01395_secluded_elastic_dark_z_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_01395", "source_line": 2403, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the supplied model-card-only evidence."], "family_rank": 333, "global_rank": 4487, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a hidden_sector_dark_matter entry (effective_field_theory); implicit probe coverage includes CMB, collider, galaxy satellites.", "Priority is limited because the card has no explicit observables, applicable constraints, benchmark points, or theory-to-observable routes for this worker pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_0951_two_singlet_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1207_0951", "source_line": 1627, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 4488, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Two-singlet inert scalar dark matter model; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_1099_su5_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1306_1099", "source_line": 1858, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4489, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative phenomenological-parameterization model with coannihilation production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 2 while penalties total 17."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_3214_ewsusy_nmssm_neutralino_full_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1305_3214", "source_line": 1879, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4490, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 1 while penalties total 19."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_5699_so10_natural_susy_case_ii_v1", "paper_id": "1306_5699", "source_line": 1895, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 198, "global_rank": 4491, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with coannihilation production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 1 while penalties total 19."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_0362_singlet_extended_mssm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0906_0362", "source_line": 1004, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 199, "global_rank": 4492, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 7 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_2619_nonabelian_su2_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_2619", "source_line": 2371, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 334, "global_rank": 4493, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory and thermal freeze-out through annihilation channels, resonant annihilation through X^3 near 2 m_DM production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0907_3146_su2d_spontaneous_z2_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0907_3146", "source_line": 1017, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 335, "global_rank": 4494, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 7 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family hidden_sector_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_03116_fermion_singlet_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1506_03116", "source_line": 2499, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 4495, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=benchmark, theory_level=simplified_model, family=higgs_portal_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=90.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_scalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_0007_scalar_mediator_gamma_box_v1", "paper_id": "1205_0007", "source_line": 1607, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4496, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Complex scalar dark matter with real scalar gamma-box mediator; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_06556_renormalizable_singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1506_06556", "source_line": 2451, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 4497, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=benchmark, theory_level=uv_complete, family=higgs_portal_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=90.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1101_3576_2hdm_d_real_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1101_3576", "source_line": 1262, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 4498, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 7 for 2HDM+D real scalar D-boson dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from probe hints: collider, direct detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_6608_natural_higgs_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1305_6608", "source_line": 1831, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 4499, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and the filled card gives limited distinctive observational structure-formation content.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_02917_general_no_scale_fsu5_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_02917", "source_line": 3032, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 200, "global_rank": 4500, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["General No-Scale F-SU(5) neutralino dark matter with bino, higgsino, and Higgs-funnel regions is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_06639_vector_like_fermion_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_06639", "source_line": 3632, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 4501, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "The card has an audit trail and assumptions, but still lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_12985_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_12985", "source_line": 4394, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4502, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone scalar dark matter from a complex singlet: standard thermal WIMP freeze-out; partial computational/code support; inferred probe coverage includes laboratory/direct.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_5053_greenschwarz_chiral_hidden_fermion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0909_5053", "source_line": 995, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 336, "global_rank": 4503, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter-dependent full-density production.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_14528_neutrinophilic_u1_lmu_ltau_hidden_u1_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_14528", "source_line": 5450, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Benchmark dependence and absent observables, constraints, and routing limit observational-extension value."], "family_rank": 337, "global_rank": 4504, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: the neutrinophilic hidden-U(1) Dirac model has light-DM benchmark interest and partial MicrOMEGAs context, but robustness is low and no route or constraints are supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_12367_secluded_dark_fermion_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2206_12367", "source_line": 5197, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from missing structured observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 338, "global_rank": 4505, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but viable: secluded dark fermion/dark photon model is useful as an illustrative hidden-sector benchmark, but observables, routes, and constraints are essentially absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_00877_inelastic_self_interacting_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_00877", "source_line": 4737, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 119, "global_rank": 4506, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via thermal freeze-out.", "Card-local leverage comes from direct detection; the raw score is 7 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2910_magnetic_inelastic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2910", "source_line": 1596, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 4507, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card is an inelastic EFT with distinctive dipole phenomenology, but explicit observables, constraints, routing, and UV support are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_09960_cxsm_two_component_a_s_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_09960", "source_line": 3251, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 163, "global_rank": 4508, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi component dark matter candidate with simplified model theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 7.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_06406_hidden_u1_neutrinophilic_2hdm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_06406", "source_line": 3257, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 339, "global_rank": 4509, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from card fields/text touching direct detection.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 7.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_5028_ce6ssm_bino_inert_higgsino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1206_5028", "source_line": 1585, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 4510, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card has a UV cE6SSM neutralino coannihilation mechanism, but the observational leverage is CDM-like and the inert-Higgsino condition is required for viability."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_2529_supersymmetric_dark_sector_scalar_x_v1", "paper_id": "1207_2529", "source_line": 1559, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4511, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card has an explicit simplified SUSY hidden-sector freeze-out candidate, but observational leverage and routing are absent and the light-X regime remains undeveloped."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_triplet_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_1546_technicolor_singlet_triplet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1307_1546", "source_line": 1841, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4512, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative singlet_triplet_wimp_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_01080_three_loop_leptoquark_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1701_01080", "source_line": 3005, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4513, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Three-loop leptoquark triplet model with inert scalar doublet dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "solid_dark_matter", "model_id": "0707_3944_nonrelativistic_string_network_solid_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0707_3944", "source_line": 207, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4514, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative solid_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: compact-object/dynamical.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_5990_su3_so3_b2_spherical_skyrmion_v1", "paper_id": "1103_5990", "source_line": 1313, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4515, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 26.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for topological_soliton_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_5990_sun_son_b1_spherical_skyrmion_v1", "paper_id": "1103_5990", "source_line": 1314, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4516, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for topological_soliton_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gamma_line_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2863_charged_loop_gamma_line_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2863", "source_line": 1563, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4517, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but distinctive because the card captures a rare charged-loop gamma-line EFT umbrella, while the model is not a single UV completion and lacks card-level routing or constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavoured_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_08457_top_flavoured_dmfv_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1702_08457", "source_line": 3020, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4518, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Top-flavoured dark matter in Dark Minimal Flavour Violation is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_06036_u1_lmutau_zprime_singlino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_06036", "source_line": 3570, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 340, "global_rank": 4519, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_02141_z_portal_cp_violating_3hdm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2003_02141", "source_line": 4151, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4520, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of inert_scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity credit reflects a comparatively distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or dominant probe class in the population context.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_4506_vacuum_pressure_compact_ultradense_object_v1", "paper_id": "1303_4506", "source_line": 1804, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4521, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative macroscopic_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is not_applicable.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on compact-object dynamics and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2639_nmssm_130gev_neutralino_photon_line_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2639", "source_line": 1579, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 201, "global_rank": 4522, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because it is a concrete UV neutralino resonance region, but the card supplies no routes, constraints, or code and the line rate is tied to a near-resonant CP-odd Higgs condition."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_03466_crossover_qcd_strangeon_nugget_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_03466", "source_line": 5402, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["No supplied observables, constraints, routing, or code for turning the macroscopic QCD-nugget idea into extension work."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4523, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: the macroscopic strangeon-nugget scenario is rare and can make all dark matter, but the supplied card gives no concrete observational route beyond generic compact-object relevance."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_06852_scotogenic_three_loop_fermionic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_06852", "source_line": 5418, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Thermal CDM-like behavior plus absent observables, constraints, routing, and code make the card low priority."], "family_rank": 341, "global_rank": 4524, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: the UV-complete scotogenic fermion candidate is scientifically motivated by neutrino-mass physics, but the supplied fields give no structure or observational route leverage."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_06852_scotogenic_three_loop_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_06852", "source_line": 5417, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["No supplied observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or code support observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 342, "global_rank": 4525, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: the UV-complete scotogenic scalar candidate has strong theory motivation through neutrino-mass physics, but the supplied card has thermal CDM-like phenomenology and no observational routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_02891_muon_specific_fermion_dm_radiative_muon_mass_v1", "paper_id": "2212_02891", "source_line": 5432, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["No supplied observables, constraints, routing, or code despite possible laboratory relevance."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4526, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but scientifically motivated by muon-specific radiative mass physics; observational and structure leverage are not supplied in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_5526_gluino_driven_sugra_bino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1304_5526", "source_line": 1796, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 202, "global_rank": 4527, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 7: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 309; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_15708_z2_singlet_one_step_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2010_15708", "source_line": 4468, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 4528, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for scalar_singlet_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_08195_type_ii_scotogenic_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2011_08195", "source_line": 4490, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 4529, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for scotogenic_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03839_gsugra_bino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03839", "source_line": 4680, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 203, "global_rank": 4530, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level uv_complete, and relic production parameter_dependent; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_6301_su2hv_fourth_generation_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_6301", "source_line": 2062, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4531, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of leptophilic_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; partial associated computational tool support; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_11574_real_quintuplet_ewdm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_11574", "source_line": 4727, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4532, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; coannihilation among electroweak multiplet components.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 7 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_11574_real_triplet_ewdm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_11574", "source_line": 4726, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4533, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; coannihilation among electroweak multiplet components.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 7 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_03964_scale_invariant_scalar_dm_vll_v1", "paper_id": "2203_03964", "source_line": 5046, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4534, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Scale-invariant scalar dark matter with a vector-like lepton has moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_00720_scalar_diboson_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_00720", "source_line": 3230, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 4535, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Scalar diboson-portal Dirac fermion dark matter is a speculative wimp_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_00720_scalar_diboson_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_00720", "source_line": 3228, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 4536, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 12, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Scalar diboson-portal real scalar dark matter is a speculative wimp_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_05872_pnc_weyl_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_05872", "source_line": 2510, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4537, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for PNC singlet-scalar plus Weyl-fermion dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "chromo_rayleigh_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_07110_chromo_rayleigh_o1_color_octet_v1", "paper_id": "1506_07110", "source_line": 2512, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4538, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Complex scalar chromo-Rayleigh dark matter with color-octet mediator: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "chromo_rayleigh_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_07110_chromo_rayleigh_o2_color_triplet_fermions_v1", "paper_id": "1506_07110", "source_line": 2513, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4539, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Complex scalar chromo-Rayleigh dark matter with color-triplet fermions: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_0630_unstable_branon_decaying_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0801_0630", "source_line": 788, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4540, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, relic viability yes, raw score 7.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "little_higgs_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_1662_t_parity_mini_little_higgs_bhat_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0801_1662", "source_line": 780, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4541, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, relic viability yes, raw score 7.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1001_3408_singlet_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1001_3408", "source_line": 1114, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4542, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "left_right_symmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1001_4057_dark_left_right_scotino_v1", "paper_id": "1001_4057", "source_line": 1079, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4543, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete left_right_symmetric_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "discrete_symmetry_stabilized_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_0899_z3_stabilized_wimp_decay_topology_v1", "paper_id": "1003_0899", "source_line": 1129, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4544, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization entry in discrete_symmetry_stabilized_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status no and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_0649_u1x_multicomponent_hidden_sector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1004_0649", "source_line": 1120, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 164, "global_rank": 4545, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in multi_component_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_0649_u1x_u1c_leptophilic_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1004_0649", "source_line": 1121, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 165, "global_rank": 4546, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in multi_component_dark_matter; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimpless_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_5068_majorana_fermion_wimpless_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1103_5068", "source_line": 1322, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4547, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for wimpless_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_1894_so10_asymmetric_symmetry_breaking_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_1894", "source_line": 2378, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 126, "global_rank": 4548, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory and asymmetric dark matter relic abundance from connected visible and dark baryon asymmetries production.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card is CDM-like or leaves cosmological and structure-formation effects unknown.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_08285_type_ii_seesaw_real_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_08285", "source_line": 2506, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 4549, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Type-II seesaw real singlet scalar dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_03613_gluino_bino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1509_03613", "source_line": 2532, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4550, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Mini-split gluino-bino co-annihilation dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_03613_wino_bino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1509_03613", "source_line": 2533, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4551, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Mini-split wino-bino co-annihilation dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; it adds some diversity through family, production, phase-space, or probe coverage; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_mass_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_09055_u1r_radiative_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1606_09055", "source_line": 2846, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4552, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_03931_z3_scotogenic_dirac_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1607_03931", "source_line": 2847, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4553, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_01437_composite_scotogenic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2010_01437", "source_line": 4480, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4554, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for composite_scotogenic_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 7.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_04466_su2n_vector_x_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2105_04466", "source_line": 4708, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 4555, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative vector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via thermal freeze-out through X X -> H H.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 7 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_12242_extended_scotogenic_3loop_z2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_12242", "source_line": 6062, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 4556, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 7.0: speculative uv complete model in scotogenic_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "baryon_number_violating_asymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_18472_two_component_bnv_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2405_18472", "source_line": 6106, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4557, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 7 (defer) from supplied card content: baryon_number_violating_asymmetric_wimp_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory content and unknown all-DM production.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_technicolor_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_3124_dg_technigluon_bound_state_v1", "paper_id": "0807_3124", "source_line": 837, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4558, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_1652_u1_seesaw_right_handed_sneutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1105_1652", "source_line": 1320, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4559, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for right_handed_sneutrino_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_4717_e6_s4z2_lsp_flavon_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_4717", "source_line": 1345, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 166, "global_rank": 4560, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=yes.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_2962_dirac_leptophilic_charged_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_2962", "source_line": 1773, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4561, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 7: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family leptophilic_fermion_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: BBN relevance low; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 2; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_2962_majorana_leptophilic_charged_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_2962", "source_line": 1772, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4562, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 7: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family leptophilic_fermion_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: BBN relevance low; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 2; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_4193_t_prime_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1304_4193", "source_line": 1758, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4563, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 7: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family scalar_wimp_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 6; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07536_scalar_dm_left_muon_vectorlike_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07536", "source_line": 2806, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4564, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_07536_scalar_dm_right_muon_vectorlike_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1604_07536", "source_line": 2807, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4565, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_01585_u1_bl3_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_01585", "source_line": 3270, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 4566, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative right handed neutrino dark matter candidate with uv complete theory level and yes all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 7.0, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_light_photino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9504081_light_photino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9504081", "source_line": 6134, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4567, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 7 (defer) from supplied card content: supersymmetric_light_photino_dark_matter with simplified_model theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_2786_peaked_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0801_2786", "source_line": 801, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4568, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked yes. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_4035_double_action_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0902_4035", "source_line": 902, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4569, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, full relic-abundance support in the card, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, distinctive or underrepresented population features, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "maverick_wimp_effective_field_theory", "model_id": "1009_0008_maverick_wimp_complex_scalar_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1009_0008", "source_line": 1136, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4570, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a benchmark effective field theory entry in maverick_wimp_effective_field_theory; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "maverick_wimp_effective_field_theory", "model_id": "1009_0008_maverick_wimp_dirac_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1009_0008", "source_line": 1134, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4571, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a benchmark effective field theory entry in maverick_wimp_effective_field_theory; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "maverick_wimp_effective_field_theory", "model_id": "1009_0008_maverick_wimp_majorana_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1009_0008", "source_line": 1135, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4572, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a benchmark effective field theory entry in maverick_wimp_effective_field_theory; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "maverick_wimp_effective_field_theory", "model_id": "1009_0008_maverick_wimp_real_scalar_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1009_0008", "source_line": 1137, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4573, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a benchmark effective field theory entry in maverick_wimp_effective_field_theory; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_4953_csi_su2_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_4953", "source_line": 2097, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 4574, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of vector_dark_matter; abundance capability marked no; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_4953_csi_su2_vector_singlet_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_4953", "source_line": 2098, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 167, "global_rank": 4575, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of multi_component_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_lepton_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_2368_radiative_lepton_mass_z2_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_2368", "source_line": 2150, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4576, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 25.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_11447_simplest_scoto_seesaw_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1807_11447", "source_line": 3621, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4577, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative scotogenic_wimp_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_07443_dirac_dm_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1701_07443", "source_line": 3104, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4578, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of simplified_vector_mediator_dark_matter with raw score 7.0.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 6.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_05476_quintet_majorana_minimal_dm_radiative_seesaw_v1", "paper_id": "1808_05476", "source_line": 3615, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 4579, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative minimal_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and yes abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_09117_su2_dark_baryon_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_09117", "source_line": 3598, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 4580, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative composite_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0412290_brane_coil_superheavy_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0412290", "source_line": 560, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4581, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Brane-coil superheavy stable relic dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family topological_relic_dark_matter with production described as nonthermal production after angled brane inflation.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_4360_z2_odd_neutral_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_4360", "source_line": 2027, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 7, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4582, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 7, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_01393_perturbative_unitarity_simp_dark_pion_v1", "paper_id": "2210_01393", "source_line": 5357, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 120, "global_rank": 4583, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Perturbative-unitarity improved SIMP dark pion model has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_15200_asymptotic_safety_m1_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2012_15200", "source_line": 4505, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.8, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 4584, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.8, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_05871_galactic_bec_ultralight_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1509_05871", "source_line": 2573, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 4585, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 8.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 3.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory level; score-relevant card features include field_like phase space, suppression small-scale power.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_02105_7p1kev_spin_3_2_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1509_02105", "source_line": 2565, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 4586, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative warm_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory level; score-relevant card features include suppression small-scale power.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_15581_dark_dwarf_collision_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2402_15581", "source_line": 5951, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4587, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from macroscopic_composite_dark_matter: Dark-dwarf collision dark matter has high diversity value through early-Universe formation of macroscopic composite dark objects, present-day collision-triggered fireball seeding; inferred probe classes are indirect_detection.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_03920_hadrophilic_hyper_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "2112_03920", "source_line": 4979, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 200, "global_rank": 4588, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and UV freeze-in through a gluon effective operator.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_15536_nonminimal_gravitational_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2403_15536", "source_line": 5999, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4589, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from dark_photon_dark_matter: Nonminimally coupled gravitationally produced dark photon has high diversity value through gravitational particle production during inflation, enhanced longitudinal-mode production from nonminimal curvature couplings; inferred probe classes are no explicit probe classes.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "0806_0602_decaying_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0806_0602", "source_line": 833, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 4590, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is low/unknown, phase space is nonthermal. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_12195_stochastic_axion_flat_direction_v1", "paper_id": "2002_12195", "source_line": 4155, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 287, "global_rank": 4591, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of axion_like_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_12195_stochastic_axion_plateau_nflation_v1", "paper_id": "2002_12195", "source_line": 4157, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 288, "global_rank": 4592, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of axion_like_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_12195_stochastic_axion_quartic_tiny_mass_v1", "paper_id": "2002_12195", "source_line": 4156, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 289, "global_rank": 4593, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of axion_like_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_09751_bplus_mesogenesis_dark_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "2109_09751", "source_line": 4833, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 127, "global_rank": 4594, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radion_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0310258_light_radion_oscillation_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0310258", "source_line": 499, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4595, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance; field_like phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_t_channel_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_01491_nonthermal_leptophilic_t_channel_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2112_01491", "source_line": 4992, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4596, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative nonthermal t channel mediator dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and freeze-in from mediator decays and scatterings.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_t_channel_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_01491_nonthermal_top_philic_t_channel_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2112_01491", "source_line": 4991, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4597, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative nonthermal t channel mediator dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and freeze-in from mediator decays and scatterings.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0609572_dual_axion_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0609572", "source_line": 162, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 290, "global_rank": 4598, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 6.5 for axion_like_dark_matter: positive factors include effective_field_theory theory level, carded ability to supply all dark matter, high CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0406114_tracker_pq_axion_quintessence_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0406114", "source_line": 80, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 291, "global_rank": 4599, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this axion_like_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_13265_forbidden_freeze_in_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2003_13265", "source_line": 4199, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 201, "global_rank": 4600, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of freeze_in_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_13211_two_component_s1_nuh_fimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_13211", "source_line": 4197, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 168, "global_rank": 4601, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of multi_component_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include nonthermal phase-space information.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_11476_scalar_millicharged_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "2112_11476", "source_line": 4971, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 4602, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative millicharged dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and axion-like field misalignment after spontaneous symmetry breaking.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by field like phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_13592_qcd_axion_witten_trapping_v1", "paper_id": "2012_13592", "source_line": 4538, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 292, "global_rank": 4603, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium BBN relevance, field_like phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_4981_hidden_u1_radiative_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1207_4981", "source_line": 1629, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 4604, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Hidden-U(1) radiatively decaying scalar dark matter; it offers nonthermal phase-space behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_quark_nugget_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_06747_neutrino_cooled_axionic_quark_nugget_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_06747", "source_line": 4437, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4605, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes QCD-scale axion domain-wall collapse, trapping and contraction of quark-gluon plasma inside axion-domain-wall bubbles.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_12787_qed_dark_dirac_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2402_12787", "source_line": 5964, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 343, "global_rank": 4606, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from hidden_sector_dark_matter: QED-like Dirac-fermion dark matter with dark photons and recoil-corrected freeze-out has moderate model/theory value through hidden-sector thermal freeze-out with Sommerfeld, bound-state formation, bound-state dissociation, and recoil-corrected effective cross section; inferred probe classes are no explicit probe classes.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_12787_su_n_dark_dirac_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2402_12787", "source_line": 5965, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 344, "global_rank": 4607, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from hidden_sector_dark_matter: Non-abelian SU(N) Dirac-fermion dark matter with recoil-corrected freeze-out has moderate model/theory value through non-abelian hidden-sector thermal freeze-out with annihilation, bound-state formation, bound-state dissociation, and recoil-corrected effective cross section; inferred probe classes are no explicit probe classes.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_11476_composite_millicharged_dark_pion_misalignment_v1", "paper_id": "2112_11476", "source_line": 4972, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 4608, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative millicharged dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and misalignment production of charged dark pions after dark confinement.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by field like phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0507236_late_phase_transition_exotic_axions_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0507236", "source_line": 571, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4609, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Late phase-transition exotic axion dark matter is a speculative simplified model card in family axion_like_multi_component_dark_matter with production described as nonthermal coherent misalignment oscillations.", "Observational leverage is driven by field like phase space.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_2556_gauge_singlet_lr_spontaneous_cp_v1", "paper_id": "0811_2556", "source_line": 844, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 4610, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is medium/unknown. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_12847_inert_doublet_light_scalar_small_splitting_v1", "paper_id": "2012_12847", "source_line": 4484, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 4611, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for inert_doublet_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 6.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2403_20278_e6_spinorial_parity_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2403_20278", "source_line": 5995, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 4612, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from inert_doublet_dark_matter: E6 spinorial-parity inert doublet dark matter has moderate model/theory value through inert-doublet relic abundance requirement; inferred probe classes are no explicit probe classes.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_17169_third_generation_philic_inert_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_17169", "source_line": 5841, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 4613, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative uv_complete model; the main production handle is annihilation-controlled inert-doublet relic abundance.", "Follow-up value comes from direct/collider, indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (unknown, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1207_6308_u1d_scalar_higgs_portal_inverse_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1207_6308", "source_line": 1648, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 4614, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for U(1)_D radiative inverse-seesaw scalar singlet dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_3867_zp_multi_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1208_3867", "source_line": 1624, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4615, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization card for Zp-protected multi-inert Higgs-doublet scalar dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_4107_gravity_mediated_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1306_4107", "source_line": 1869, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4616, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative effective-field-theory model with gravity-mediated production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_4107_gravity_mediated_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1306_4107", "source_line": 1870, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4617, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative effective-field-theory model with gravity-mediated production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_4107_gravity_mediated_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1306_4107", "source_line": 1871, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4618, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative effective-field-theory model with gravity-mediated production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_4733_predictive_discrete_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1204_4733", "source_line": 1605, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4619, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete card for Delta(54) predictive discrete dark matter model; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2311_14716_extended_scotogenic_3loop_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2311_14716", "source_line": 5840, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 4620, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative uv_complete model; the main production handle is not specified in detail; the paper states the model can accommodate the measured dark matter relic abundance.", "Follow-up value comes from neutrino/indirect, with phase-space/structure entries (unknown, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_singlet_2hdm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_15536_type_x_2hdm_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_15536", "source_line": 5007, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4621, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Type X 2HDM plus scalar singlet dark matter has probe classes: laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_5281_leptophobic_zprime_portal_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1312_5281", "source_line": 2012, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4622, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_lsp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_6695_intermediate_susy_tev_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1312_6695", "source_line": 2032, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4623, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_lsp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_6695_intermediate_susy_tev_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1312_6695", "source_line": 2031, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4624, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phase_transition_modified_thermal_relic", "model_id": "1104_5034_second_order_scalar_phase_transition_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1104_5034", "source_line": 1403, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4625, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 6.5 because the card describes phase transition modified thermal relic at phenomenological parameterization level, with thermal freeze-out with a nearby second-order scalar phase transition and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_5036_inverse_seesaw_scalar_s_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_5036", "source_line": 1408, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 4626, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 6.5 because the card describes scalar singlet dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal annihilation through scalar portal couplings and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_2696_scale_invariant_two_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_2696", "source_line": 1411, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 4627, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 6.5 because the card describes scalar singlet dark matter at simplified model level, with thermal freeze-out of phi_2; Higgs-portal annihilation to Standard Model particles and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_00713_gauge_stabilized_vector_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_00713", "source_line": 3320, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4628, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity value is boosted by rarity or distinctive production, phase-space, structure, or probe features in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pnGB_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_06264_soft_broken_pngb_composite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_06264", "source_line": 4478, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4629, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for composite_pnGB_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 6.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0810_5547_u1x_radiative_seesaw_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0810_5547", "source_line": 836, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4630, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimension_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_4356_5d_ued_b1_lkp_v1", "paper_id": "0811_4356", "source_line": 819, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4631, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimension_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_4356_5d_ued_z1_lkp_v1", "paper_id": "0811_4356", "source_line": 820, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4632, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_08780_oscillating_asymmetric_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_08780", "source_line": 2701, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 128, "global_rank": 4633, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_05038_three_loop_neutrino_mass_rh_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1601_05038", "source_line": 2718, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 4634, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves a card-local full-dark-matter production route.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_08309_alternative_u1bl_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1705_08309", "source_line": 3118, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 4635, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter with raw score 6.5.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "so10_decaying_fermionic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_01286_so10_decaying_fermion_dm_model_i_v1", "paper_id": "1707_01286", "source_line": 3126, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4636, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of so10_decaying_fermionic_dark_matter with raw score 6.5.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 2.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "so10_decaying_fermionic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_01286_so10_decaying_fermion_dm_model_ii_v1", "paper_id": "1707_01286", "source_line": 3127, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4637, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 24.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of so10_decaying_fermionic_dark_matter with raw score 6.5.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 2.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_02707_spinless_adjoint_scalar_assisted_baryon_violation_v1", "paper_id": "2210_02707", "source_line": 5379, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4638, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Spinless adjoint scalar dark matter with assisted baryon-number violation has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, useful diversity value from a rare or distinctive model space."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_06611_bec_scalar_field_dark_matter_galaxy_scale_v1", "paper_id": "1511_06611", "source_line": 2603, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 4639, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 10, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Bose-Einstein condensate scalar-field dark matter with galaxy-scale quantum Jeans length is marked speculative with phenomenological parameterization theory level and production support 'unknown'. Score is driven by explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for field_like phase space, distinct transfer or small-scale-power behavior.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'field like' and small-scale-power effect 'suppression'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_4729_unsterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "0905_4729", "source_line": 930, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 154, "global_rank": 4640, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 7, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has effective-theory structure, non-CDM linear-structure information, nonthermal phase-space character, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_06802_qcd_axion_thermal_inflation_cmb_v1", "paper_id": "2007_06802", "source_line": 4345, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 293, "global_rank": 4641, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes QCD-like axion CMB-anisotropy scenario with thermal-inflation dilution as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and production via axion misalignment/coherent field fluctuations generated during primordial inflation.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=critical and BBN=high; phase-space type field_like.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "0801_0885_clustered_primordial_black_holes_v1", "paper_id": "0801_0885", "source_line": 113, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 221, "global_rank": 4642, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and enhancement small-scale-power effect, enhanced small scale power transfer behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_15112_scalar_screened_millicharged_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2006_15112", "source_line": 4344, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 4643, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Scalar-screened millicharged-particle dark-matter subcomponent as a speculative millicharged_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via late thermal freeze-in through feeble electromagnetic interactions after the scalar-induced effective mass falls belo....", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=high and BBN=high; phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: do-not-promote-to-all-dm."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "astro-ph0412479_pbh_cluster_induced_dm_condensation_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0412479", "source_line": 134, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 222, "global_rank": 4644, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and enhancement small-scale-power effect, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_01950_audible_invisible_axion_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1811_01950", "source_line": 3652, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 294, "global_rank": 4645, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative axion_like_dark_matter with simplified_model theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; field_like phase-space behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_04648_sterile_pq_multicomponent_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2012_04648", "source_line": 4516, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 169, "global_rank": 4646, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 6.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, mixed_cold_warm phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "2112_13318_generalized_logotropic_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "2112_13318", "source_line": 4996, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4647, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative unified dark matter dark energy entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and phenomenological unified dark fluid evolution.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by oscillations small-scale power, oscillatory transfer-function shape; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_07713_stimulated_dark_photon_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_07713", "source_line": 5203, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 345, "global_rank": 4648, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative simplified model model content, high CMB relevance; decay produced phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2207_07576_pbh_cdm_spike_mixed_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_07576", "source_line": 5226, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 223, "global_rank": 4649, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 3.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, medium CMB relevance; enhancement of small-scale power, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2007_06481_clustered_qcd_epoch_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_06481", "source_line": 4335, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 224, "global_rank": 4650, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Clustered QCD-epoch primordial black-hole dark matter as a speculative primordial_black_holes model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and production via gravitational collapse of primordial density fluctuations.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=unknown; phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: not_monochromatic_pbh."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_14488_conformal_scalar_rrg_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "2010_14488", "source_line": 278, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 4651, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Conformally coupled scalar-field reduced-relativistic-gas warm dark matter, a speculative warm dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and medium CMB relevance, suppression of small-scale power, thermal phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: warn_001."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_14527_pseudo_dirac_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_14527", "source_line": 4968, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 155, "global_rank": 4652, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative sterile neutrino dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and Dodelson-Widrow production of N_1.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by decay produced phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_6967_u1r_sterile_neutrino_wdm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_6967", "source_line": 2178, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 156, "global_rank": 4653, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with nonthermal phase-space entry, and suppression small-scale-power effect.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_03573_superheavy_wimp_string_two_moduli_branching_v1", "paper_id": "2010_03573", "source_line": 4440, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4654, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes nonthermal branching production from inflaton decay, dilution by late modulus decay.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance, decay produced phase-space structure.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2111_14190_no_scale_sugra_w1_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2111_14190", "source_line": 101, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 225, "global_rank": 4655, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with effective field theory theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2111_14190_no_scale_sugra_w2_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2111_14190", "source_line": 102, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 226, "global_rank": 4656, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with effective field theory theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "0911_3163_complex_scalar_unifying_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "0911_3163", "source_line": 200, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4657, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 5.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 6.0 for unified_dark_fluid_dark_matter: positive factors include parameter-dependent relic-density viability, high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0705_3017_axion_condensate_vortex_halo_v1", "paper_id": "0705_3017", "source_line": 361, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 295, "global_rank": 4658, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via primordial axions from the Peccei-Quinn phase transition; Bose-Einstein condensation when the axion acquires mass near the QCD epoch; CMB relevance low and BBN relevance unknown; field_like phase-space treatment; probe hooks: galaxy satellites/halo structure, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_01723_neutrino_portal_fermion_fimp_emde_v1", "paper_id": "2003_01723", "source_line": 4166, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 202, "global_rank": 4659, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of freeze_in_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_01723_neutrino_portal_scalar_fimp_emde_v1", "paper_id": "2003_01723", "source_line": 4167, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 203, "global_rank": 4660, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of freeze_in_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_1668_singlet_higgs_coupled_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_1668", "source_line": 743, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 4661, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked unknown; probe coverage from portal/laboratory.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2306_14953_einstein_cartan_torsion_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2306_14953", "source_line": 5655, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from supplied fields; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are too sparse."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 4662, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Einstein-Cartan torsion-produced singlet fermion dark matter (gravitationally_produced_dark_matter) has gravitational portal coverage, but is held back by missing explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields, limited computational support, low robustness. Raw score 6.0, defer."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_15522_composite_asymmetric_dark_nucleon_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_15522", "source_line": 4405, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 129, "global_rank": 4663, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes asymmetric dark matter co-genesis, thermal depletion of the symmetric component.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_05186_minimal_parametric_mixing_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_05186", "source_line": 5218, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 157, "global_rank": 4664, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, medium CMB relevance; suppression of small-scale power. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_08404_majoron_freeze_in_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2212_08404", "source_line": 5475, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 204, "global_rank": 4665, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Majoron freeze-in dark matter from right-handed-neutrino annihilation has some theory and relic-density motivation, nonthermal phase space, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_cosmology_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0704_3285_kination_quintessence_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0704_3285", "source_line": 680, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4666, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_1827_axino_large_rpv_moduli_v1", "paper_id": "1407_1827", "source_line": 2196, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 296, "global_rank": 4667, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with high BBN relevance, and mixed_cold_warm phase-space entry.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, computational representation is sparse, and the supplied warnings include high-severity caveats."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0612211_right_handed_sneutrino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0612211", "source_line": 678, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 4668, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_7469_feebly_self_interacting_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1307_7469", "source_line": 239, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 121, "global_rank": 4669, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_6407_causal_patch_gravitino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1304_6407", "source_line": 1798, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 4670, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 6: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, family gravitino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: BBN relevance medium; phase-space type nonthermal; complementarity probes counted as BBN.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 77; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_00226_portal_matter_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_00226", "source_line": 5913, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 346, "global_rank": 4671, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Portal-matter UV completion of dark-photon thermal dark matter is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, unknown small-scale-power information, and CMB from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 9, observational leverage 3, complementarity 2, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 0.0, penalties 17; raw score 6.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_01947_moduli_portal_fermionic_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_01947", "source_line": 3646, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 205, "global_rank": 4672, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_01947_moduli_portal_scalar_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_01947", "source_line": 3645, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 206, "global_rank": 4673, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "active_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_16635_relativistic_electron_neutrino_halo_v1", "paper_id": "2006_16635", "source_line": 48, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4674, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, nonthermal phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "torsion_vector_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_03651_torsion_higgs_portal_tdm1_v1", "paper_id": "1611_03651", "source_line": 2973, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4675, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative torsion_vector_higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and no all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include fermion_coupling_stability."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dirac_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_11950_dirac_zn_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_11950", "source_line": 4058, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score 6 is below 30 because observational routing, formal observable/constraint fields, or implementation support are incomplete in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4676, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative scotogenic_dirac_neutrino_dark_matter with uv_complete structure and relic reach 'unknown'.", "Observational leverage is driven by phase-space 'unknown', transfer function 'unknown', small-scale effect 'unknown', and inferred probe classes: none explicit in the card.", "Score is limited by no formal theory-to-observable routing field; no formal observables field; no formal constraints.applicable field; no identified public implementation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_03886_minimal_flavored_freeze_in_dm_su2_v1", "paper_id": "2103_03886", "source_line": 4575, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 207, "global_rank": 4677, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=low and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_2846_late_time_reheating_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1402_2846", "source_line": 2091, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4678, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of nonthermal_wimp_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "massive_graviton_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_05606_massive_graviton_geon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_05606", "source_line": 369, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4679, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative simplified_model model; production via Jeans-instability-like formation of self-gravitating geons from massive-graviton fluctuations; field_like phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_00854_mev_secluded_scalar_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2201_00854", "source_line": 4990, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4680, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative secluded dark sector dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and freeze-in production of phi from SM neutrino inverse decay.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boson_star_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_15277_superradiant_micro_proca_star_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_15277", "source_line": 5249, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4681, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_11598_vish_variant_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_11598", "source_line": 5208, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 297, "global_rank": 4682, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, medium CMB relevance; field like phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decay_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_03484_palatini_superheavy_portal_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_03484", "source_line": 4323, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4683, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Palatini superheavy portal decay to lighter scalar dark matter as a speculative decay_produced_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via gravitational/tachyonic production of a superheavy parent during Palatini preheating.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=unknown; phase-space type decay_produced.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: not_always_cold."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_lsp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_1580_pure_gravity_mediation_chaotic_inflation_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_1580", "source_line": 2193, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4684, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with medium BBN relevance, and decay_produced phase-space entry.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_02313_elementary_adm_nuggets_v1", "paper_id": "1707_02313", "source_line": 3137, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 130, "global_rank": 4685, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of asymmetric_dark_matter with raw score 6.0.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from distinct phase-space production.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 182.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2302_03955_logarithmic_attractor_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_03955", "source_line": 5465, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 227, "global_rank": 4686, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Logarithmic-potential generalized attractor inflation with PBH dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, high CMB relevance, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_05385_self_interacting_fuzzy_axion_condensate_v1", "paper_id": "1705_05385", "source_line": 3154, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 4687, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 6.0: Self-interacting fuzzy axion condensate dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with formation of macroscopic condensates from ultralight axion-like particles.", "Rank-relevant positives are field like phase-space treatment, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: no explicit probe routing.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_00618_wed_freeze_in_self_interacting_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2101_00618", "source_line": 4540, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 208, "global_rank": 4688, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from nonthermal phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_11933_11d_supergravity_inflaton_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2404_11933", "source_line": 255, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4689, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as 11D-supergravity inflaton dark-sector scalar, a speculative ultralight scalar dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: dm_or_de_ambiguity, weak_field_only."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1009_4593_inert_doublet_thermal_history_v1", "paper_id": "1009_4593", "source_line": 1222, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card has sparse explicit observational routing, constraints, or computational support."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 4690, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from a speculative uv_complete card in family inert_doublet_dark_matter with production via thermal evolution into the inert vacuum; dark matter appears after the phase transition to I_1 in multi-step histories.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, compact objects / dynamics.", "Penalized because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, and theory-to-observable routing for the observational extension pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1301_0708_slim_susy_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1301_0708", "source_line": 1674, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model card because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 204, "global_rank": 4691, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization entry; production is summarized as neutralino relic abundance from MSSM mass and couplings; detailed cosmological production mechanism not calculated in the paper, with unknown phase-space behavior.", "Priority score 6 reflects card-implied probe classes include collider, direct detection; it is limited because observables are absent, applicable constraints are absent, routing is absent, compatibility is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_00075_puffy_composite_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_00075", "source_line": 3728, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 122, "global_rank": 4692, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Puffy finite-size composite dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization candidate with probe relevance for BBN, small-scale structure; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_04138_hidden_abelian_higgs_dark_portal_vortex_v1", "paper_id": "2202_04138", "source_line": 5030, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 347, "global_rank": 4693, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Hidden Abelian-Higgs dark-portal vortex model has probe classes: gravitational waves, laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0511299_singlino_lsp_extra_u1_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0511299", "source_line": 641, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 205, "global_rank": 4694, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has limited positive support beyond basic model identity, provenance, and relic-density context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_2617_susy_adm_x_lle_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1310_2617", "source_line": 1944, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 131, "global_rank": 4695, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 6.0 because the model card is a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_2617_susy_adm_x_qld_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1310_2617", "source_line": 1942, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 132, "global_rank": 4696, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 6.0 because the model card is a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_2617_susy_adm_x_udd_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1310_2617", "source_line": 1943, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 133, "global_rank": 4697, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 6.0 because the model card is a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_6649_qud_sextet_neuson_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1310_6649", "source_line": 1938, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 4698, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 23.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 6.0 because the model card is a speculative composite_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support; some underrepresented-family or production diversity and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; high-severity card warnings limit robustness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_08905_uv_ir_freeze_in_dirac_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1811_08905", "source_line": 3640, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 209, "global_rank": 4699, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_1570_millicharged_atomic_excited_state_v1", "paper_id": "1403_1570", "source_line": 2127, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 348, "global_rank": 4700, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hot_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0609125_gravity_hot_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0609125", "source_line": 227, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4701, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative hot_neutrino_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=high, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_04617_mpp_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_04617", "source_line": 4554, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 4702, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=high and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0607179_oscillating_axion_bubble_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0607179", "source_line": 26, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 298, "global_rank": 4703, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_05845_asymmetric_complex_scalar_dark_star_v1", "paper_id": "2211_05845", "source_line": 5429, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Follow-up would need missing observables, constraints, routes, and code."], "family_rank": 134, "global_rank": 4704, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: the asymmetric complex scalar dark-star scenario is distinct and nonthermal, but the supplied card has no concrete compact-object observable routing or computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0103189_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0103189", "source_line": 391, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 4705, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative effective_field_theory model; production via Affleck-Dine condensate collapse or fragmentation into Q-balls; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: compact objects/dynamics, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimensions_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0512304_6d_ued_spinless_hypercharge_adjoint_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0512304", "source_line": 613, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4706, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_1654_singlet_scalar_fimp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1105_1654", "source_line": 1274, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 210, "global_rank": 4707, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 6 for Singlet scalar FIMP dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=yes.", "Positive leverage comes from phase space is nonthermal.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_4639_elastic_hidden_sector_light_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1109_4639", "source_line": 1413, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 349, "global_rank": 4708, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 6.0 because the card describes hidden sector dark matter at simplified model level, with thermal freeze-out through dominant annihilation into invisible dark neutrinos and medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_4639_inelastic_quasi_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1109_4639", "source_line": 1414, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 350, "global_rank": 4709, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 6.0 because the card describes hidden sector dark matter at simplified model level, with thermal freeze-out through dominant annihilation into invisible dark neutrinos and medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0108138_nonthermal_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0108138", "source_line": 382, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 4710, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via non-thermal production from late decays of very heavy gravitinos or other non-standard sources; nonthermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0108138_nonthermal_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0108138", "source_line": 383, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 4711, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via non-thermal production from late decays of very heavy gravitinos or other non-standard sources; nonthermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_5533_bino_neutralino_slepton_coannihilation_mixing_v1", "paper_id": "1208_5533", "source_line": 1748, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 4712, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "excited_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_1037_su2_triplet_metastable_idm_xdm_v1", "paper_id": "0903_1037", "source_line": 933, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4713, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1010_2237_induced_gravity_dark_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1010_2237", "source_line": 296, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4714, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Induced-gravity dark fermion dark matter with a Higgs-type scalar, a speculative coupled dark energy dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and high CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: w1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_6260_rh_neutrino_inert_doublet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_6260", "source_line": 2099, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 4715, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of inert_doublet_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10538_so10_axion_singlet_doublet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10538", "source_line": 5217, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 170, "global_rank": 4716, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, mixed cold warm phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "excited_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_1037_su2_dirac_triplet_up_down_xdm_v1", "paper_id": "0903_1037", "source_line": 934, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4717, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_1375_black_hole_atom_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_1375", "source_line": 109, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4718, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_hole_composite_dark_matter card with simplified model theory-level support and nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "two_higgs_doublet_vector_like_lepton_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_06186_2hdm_vector_like_lepton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_06186", "source_line": 2986, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4719, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative two_higgs_doublet_vector_like_lepton_wimp_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_like_lepton_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_06186_sm_higgs_portal_vector_like_lepton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_06186", "source_line": 2985, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4720, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative vector_like_lepton_wimp_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_higgs_doublet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_03629_cpv_i21hdm_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_03629", "source_line": 2977, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4721, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative inert_higgs_doublet_scalar_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2211_14900_noncanonical_inflation_primordial_black_hole_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2211_14900", "source_line": 130, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 228, "global_rank": 4722, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with uv complete theory-level support and medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "tachyon_unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "astro-ph0505509_decaying_tachyon_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0505509", "source_line": 283, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4723, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Decaying tachyon unified dark matter-dark energy model, a speculative tachyon unified dark sector entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and field like phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: tachyon_effective_dm."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_singlino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_04322_singlino_vectorlike_fn_susy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_04322", "source_line": 2975, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4724, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_singlino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and yes all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include requires_r_parity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1410_0203_pbh_closed_wall_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1410_0203", "source_line": 233, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 229, "global_rank": 4725, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: compact-object/dynamical, structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2001_08220_pbh_polynomial_inflation_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2001_08220", "source_line": 4172, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 230, "global_rank": 4726, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of primordial_black_holes; rank-relevant features include medium CMB relevance, 2 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2110_11897_cyclic_relict_black_hole_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2110_11897", "source_line": 367, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 231, "global_rank": 4727, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via survival of black holes through cyclic-universe bounces; stellar black-hole birth in each cycle; probe hooks: compact objects/microlensing/dynamics, galaxy satellites/halo structure, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2212_03577_nonminimal_spectator_pbh_dm_model_o_v1", "paper_id": "2212_03577", "source_line": 5423, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Near-duplicate spectator variant with no explicit observables, constraints, routing, or code."], "family_rank": 232, "global_rank": 4728, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked PBH spectator variant: similar scientific and CMB/compact-object hooks to sibling spectator models, with a small duplicate penalty and sparse supplied follow-up details."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2212_03577_nonminimal_spectator_pbh_dm_model_r_v1", "paper_id": "2212_03577", "source_line": 5422, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Near-duplicate spectator variant with no explicit observables, constraints, routing, or code."], "family_rank": 233, "global_rank": 4729, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked PBH spectator variant: similar scientific and CMB/compact-object hooks to sibling spectator models, with a small duplicate penalty and sparse supplied follow-up details."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0306144_rsugra_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0306144", "source_line": 416, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 206, "global_rank": 4730, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, partial computational support from associated code or calculations; probe signal: cmb.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0512081_stringy_split_susy_heavy_higgsino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0512081", "source_line": 625, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 207, "global_rank": 4731, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0601016_ps_susy_gut_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0601016", "source_line": 591, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 208, "global_rank": 4732, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Pati-Salam SUSY GUT neutralino dark matter with Yukawa quasi-unification is a speculative uv complete card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production described as thermal neutralino freeze-out.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_6023_stable_higgs_gauge_higgs_unification_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1003_6023", "source_line": 1097, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 4733, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete higgs_portal_dark_matter; cosmology relevance (CMB medium).", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_3178_phantom_coupled_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1204_3178", "source_line": 1551, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4734, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority because the card describes a rare phantom-coupled halo construction, but it lacks relic production, observables, constraints, routing, code, and carries a high phantom-EFT instability warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "chaplygin_gas_unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "astro-ph0510357_extended_chaplygin_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0510357", "source_line": 372, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4735, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via phenomenological dark-fluid evolution that mimics matter at early times and vacuum-like behavior at late times; Taylor-expanded A(a) yields effective matter, radiation, and vacuum-energy components; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance unknown; probe hooks: CMB, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gluon_line_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2279_fermion_gluon_line_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2279", "source_line": 1572, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4736, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the fermion gluon-line EFT is rare and has thermal-relic logic, but the card lacks observables, constraints, routing, code, and has the same EFT-validity warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gluon_line_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_2279_scalar_gluon_line_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1206_2279", "source_line": 1571, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4737, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the scalar gluon-line EFT is rare and CMB-relevant as a thermal relic, but EFT validity, missing UV completion, and absent routing dominate the observational-extension score."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_4124_kk_radion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1104_4124", "source_line": 1294, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4738, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 6 for KK-radion dark matter in warped scenarios with KK parity: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from BBN relevance is medium; probe hints: BBN.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_u1prime_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0508027_umssm_singlino_zprimeino_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0508027", "source_line": 596, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4739, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["UMSSM singlino/Z-prime-ino neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family supersymmetric_u1prime_neutralino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out of the lightest neutralino through annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_04092_pseudoscalar_higgs_portal_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_04092", "source_line": 3695, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4740, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 2.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter with simplified_model theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "twist2_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_00192_fermionic_type1_twist2_eft_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_00192", "source_line": 3739, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4741, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Fermionic Type-1 twist-2 EFT dark matter is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "twist2_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_00192_fermionic_type2_twist2_eft_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_00192", "source_line": 3740, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4742, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Fermionic Type-2 twist-2 EFT dark matter is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "twist2_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_00192_real_scalar_twist2_eft_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_00192", "source_line": 3741, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4743, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Real scalar twist-2 EFT dark matter is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "twist2_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_00192_real_vector_twist2_eft_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_00192", "source_line": 3742, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4744, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Real vector twist-2 EFT dark matter is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_09139_inelastic_dark_matter_dark_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "2112_09139", "source_line": 4963, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 4745, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative inelastic dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and thermal forbidden annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by partial associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_6965_smssm_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1406_6965", "source_line": 2151, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 209, "global_rank": 4746, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with medium CMB relevance.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strange_quark_matter_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_03024_strange_quark_matter_conglomerate_halo_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_03024", "source_line": 181, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4747, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 6.0 for strange_quark_matter_dark_matter: positive factors include parameter-dependent relic-density viability, some associated computational support, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; current-data compatibility is unspecified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1001_2308_primordial_black_holes_all_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1001_2308", "source_line": 1126, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 234, "global_rank": 4748, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization entry in primordial_black_holes; the relic-production field is yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_0296_b_minus_l_hybrid_seesaw_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1004_0296", "source_line": 1076, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4749, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete radiative_seesaw_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_03165_lmu_ltau_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_03165", "source_line": 4471, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4750, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for vector_portal_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 6.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_10827_forbidden_secluded_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_10827", "source_line": 5381, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 351, "global_rank": 4751, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Freeze-out forbidden secluded vector dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_massive_particle", "model_id": "1109_6009_fermionic_simp_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1109_6009", "source_line": 1433, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4752, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 6.0 because the card describes strongly interacting massive particle at simplified model level, with collider pair production through quark couplings; cosmological abundance mechanism not calculated; asymmetric SIMP abundance is discussed as a way to avoid self-annihilation hea... and medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_04109_vector_simp_custodial_su2x_u1zp_v1", "paper_id": "1904_04109", "source_line": 3783, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 123, "global_rank": 4753, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 6 because the card identifies production via thermal_freeze_out, 3_to_2_simp_annihilation, thermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2010_03537_two_stage_resonant_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2010_03537", "source_line": 4467, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 235, "global_rank": 4754, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for primordial_black_holes.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 6.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_14211_scotogenic_hybrid_texture_t1_v1", "paper_id": "2109_14211", "source_line": 4845, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4755, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_0609_dirac_odd_neutrino_kk_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0901_0609", "source_line": 937, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4756, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, full relic-abundance support in the card, medium cosmological relevance, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_3246_kinetic_mixing_light_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "0902_3246", "source_line": 927, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 352, "global_rank": 4757, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_3463_b_l_right_handed_sneutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0902_3463", "source_line": 939, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 4758, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, full relic-abundance support in the card, medium cosmological relevance, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_03867_u1x_right_handed_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_03867", "source_line": 3901, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 353, "global_rank": 4759, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 22.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_01060_one_zero_texture_scotogenic_n1_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_01060", "source_line": 3574, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 4760, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_asymmetric_dark_qcd", "model_id": "1810_04360_dark_quark_nuggets_v1", "paper_id": "1810_04360", "source_line": 3670, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4761, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative macroscopic_asymmetric_dark_qcd with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; high model-card diversity value from population-count rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9703145_light_photino_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9703145", "source_line": 6110, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 4762, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 6 (defer) from supplied card content: supersymmetric_dark_matter with uv_complete theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (18) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_3675_ussm_a_axion_neutralino_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "0811_3675", "source_line": 936, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 299, "global_rank": 4763, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, medium cosmological relevance, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, distinctive or underrepresented population features, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "anapole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_08029_anapole_majorana_scalar_fermion_loop_v1", "paper_id": "1706_08029", "source_line": 3121, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4764, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of anapole_dark_matter with raw score 6.0.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 1.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gauged_baryon_number_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_13887_dibaryonic_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2011_13887", "source_line": 4522, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4765, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_wimp", "model_id": "2101_08667_minimal_singlet_doublet_higgs_portal_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2101_08667", "source_line": 4576, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4766, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_wimp entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 2."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_2939_sm_plus_hs_higgsino_singlino_high_scale_susy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_2939", "source_line": 2299, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 4767, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1409_2939_sm_plus_w_wino_high_scale_susy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1409_2939", "source_line": 2298, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 4768, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by multiple probe classes inferred from card values, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_7999_so10_yukawa_bino_stau_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1307_7999", "source_line": 1897, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 210, "global_rank": 4769, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with coannihilation production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 1 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_3749_strong_hidden_sector_composite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0905_3749", "source_line": 1003, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 354, "global_rank": 4770, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 6 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family hidden_sector_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_08112_bl_zee_babu_flavored_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_08112", "source_line": 2477, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 171, "global_rank": 4771, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=multi_component_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=220, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_04448_dark_chiral_partially_composite_pion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_04448", "source_line": 2474, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 355, "global_rank": 4772, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=506, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_07109_multicomponent_twin_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1505_07109", "source_line": 2495, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 172, "global_rank": 4773, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=multi_component_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=220, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_07109_twin_w_boson_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1505_07109", "source_line": 2494, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 356, "global_rank": 4774, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=506, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_07480_hidden_sun_vector_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_07480", "source_line": 2479, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 357, "global_rank": 4775, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=506, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_06929_hidden_su3_baryonic_composite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_06929", "source_line": 2480, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 4776, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=composite_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=35, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_6157_zprime_uv_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_6157", "source_line": 2277, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 211, "global_rank": 4777, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and unknown phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_00751_hidden_spin2_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_00751", "source_line": 5338, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 358, "global_rank": 4778, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 6.0: hidden_sector_dark_matter with unknown cosmological production; science=8.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=5.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection) and diversity=3.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_2529_z4_radiative_inverse_seesaw_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1204_2529", "source_line": 1601, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 173, "global_rank": 4779, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete card for Z4 radiative inverse-seesaw multi-component dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_4505_leptophilic_lmu_ltau_mssm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1306_4505", "source_line": 1859, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 4780, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 1 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter_eft", "model_id": "1409_5775_scalar_dm_axial_vector_quark_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1409_5775", "source_line": 2225, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4781, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative scalar_dark_matter_eft card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter_eft", "model_id": "1409_5775_scalar_dm_pseudo_gluon_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1409_5775", "source_line": 2226, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4782, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative scalar_dark_matter_eft card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter_eft", "model_id": "1409_5775_scalar_dm_pseudoscalar_quark_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1409_5775", "source_line": 2224, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4783, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative scalar_dark_matter_eft card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "Probe complementarity was inferred only from model-card fields touching collider, indirect detection.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_singlet_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_2435_minimal_supersymmetric_inverse_seesaw_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0910_2435", "source_line": 1033, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4784, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 6 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family supersymmetric_singlet_sneutrino_dark_matter, theory level simplified_model, and probe handles: indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_00713_pseudo_goldstone_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_00713", "source_line": 3319, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 4785, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0503117_wimp_parameterization_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0503117", "source_line": 537, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 4786, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Model-independent WIMP collider-production parameterization is a benchmark phenomenological parameterization card with either relic-density treatment; it touches indirect detection; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_3917_two_singlet_scalar_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_3917", "source_line": 1813, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 4787, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative scalar_singlet_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on direct detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_0295_scale_invariant_complex_singlet_cpodd_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1308_0295", "source_line": 1835, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 4788, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative scalar_singlet_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_0751_strongly_mixed_photino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1206_0751", "source_line": 1587, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4789, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card has a sparse hidden-sector photino LSP scenario, but relic support is qualitative and the dark-matter interpretation requires the photino to be the stable LSP."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_09153_fermionic_singlet_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_09153", "source_line": 3022, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 4790, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Fermionic singlet dark matter in a one-loop neutrino-mass model is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_00219_scale_invariant_dqcd_dark_pion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1704_00219", "source_line": 3023, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 4791, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Classically scale-invariant dQCD dark-pion WIMP is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_01039_majorana_pseudoscalar_mediator_thdm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_01039", "source_line": 3589, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4792, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_0200_nrmssm_neutralino_chargino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1303_0200", "source_line": 1765, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 211, "global_rank": 4793, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 6: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 309; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_5166_accidental_susy_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1208_5166", "source_line": 1783, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 212, "global_rank": 4794, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 6: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 309; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1302_3427_cp_violating_u1prime_mssm_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1302_3427", "source_line": 1764, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 213, "global_rank": 4795, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 6: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 309; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_05082_dark_loops_model5_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_05082", "source_line": 4312, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 4796, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Dark-loops model-5 scalar dark matter as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via ordinary thermal freeze-out of S.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_04466_gsugra_wino_like_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "2106_04466", "source_line": 4730, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 214, "global_rank": 4797, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; wino annihilation.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 6 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_06113_thermal_dark_axion_portal_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_06113", "source_line": 6056, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 359, "global_rank": 4798, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 6.0: speculative effective field theory model in hidden_sector_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is partial and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0812_2384_ussm_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0812_2384", "source_line": 914, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 215, "global_rank": 4799, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, partial code or computational support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Penalties mainly reflect missing observable mapping, constraints, and routing rather than global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_1750_inert_doublet_majorana_neutrino_extension_v1", "paper_id": "0901_1750", "source_line": 901, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 4800, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, partial code or computational support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Penalties mainly reflect missing observable mapping, constraints, and routing rather than global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimensions_dark_matter", "model_id": "0904_1442_chiral_square_spinless_photon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0904_1442", "source_line": 919, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4801, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has effective-theory structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, partial code or computational support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Penalties mainly reflect missing observable mapping, constraints, and routing rather than global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_08635_cp_symmetric_complex_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_08635", "source_line": 4465, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 4802, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for singlet_scalar_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is helped by partial associated-code support, but explicit routing and benchmarks are absent.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 6.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_11574_pseudoreal_doublet_ewdm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_11574", "source_line": 4724, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 4803, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; coannihilation among electroweak multiplet components.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 6 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_13105_lr_symmetric_two_component_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_13105", "source_line": 5216, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 174, "global_rank": 4804, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, partial associated-code support. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "co_scattering_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10536_singlet_triplet_coscattering_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10536", "source_line": 5244, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4805, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative effective field theory model content, partial associated-code support. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_04382_vectorlike_lepton_singlet_doublet_leptoquark_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_04382", "source_line": 4970, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 4806, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative wimp dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and thermal freeze-out.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by partial associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_electroweak_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0703056_scalar_electroweak_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0703056", "source_line": 662, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4807, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, sparse-class representative; limited computational support; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_0394_singlet_scalar_vector_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_0394", "source_line": 1723, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 4808, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to phase-transition/nonstandard history.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_singlino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_0038_pq_limit_singlino_subew_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_0038", "source_line": 2172, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4809, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp", "model_id": "2102_08645_leptophilic_majorana_wimp_left_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2102_08645", "source_line": 4566, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4810, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative leptophilic_wimp entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 7."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_3583_leptophobic_e6_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1106_3583", "source_line": 1344, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 360, "global_rank": 4811, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_technicolor_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_4284_hidden_sector_technicolor_model_i_v1", "paper_id": "0801_4284", "source_line": 767, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4812, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 6.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_2967_warped_pseudo_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1002_2967", "source_line": 1127, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 361, "global_rank": 4813, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model entry in hidden_sector_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_05193_dirac_singlet_doublet_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1605_05193", "source_line": 2841, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4814, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_05193_majorana_singlet_doublet_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1605_05193", "source_line": 2842, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4815, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_05896_two_loop_neutrino_mass_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_05896", "source_line": 3232, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 4816, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Two-loop neutrino-mass scalar dark matter model B is a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_14863_u1d_zz_mass_mixing_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_14863", "source_line": 5383, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 124, "global_rank": 4817, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because U(1)_D Z-Z-prime mass-mixing self-interacting dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2405_10367_qcd_like_theta_dark_pion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_10367", "source_line": 6061, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because current supplied fields lack enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 362, "global_rank": 4818, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 6.0: speculative uv complete model in hidden_sector_dark_matter, with relic-density capability recorded as parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from phase space is thermal.", "Provenance is usable through supplied provenance, validity, assumptions, robustness, and warnings; feasibility remains low because associated code is unknown and explicit observables, constraints, routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent or sparse.", "Penalty is substantial under the rule because the supplied card lacks explicit observational-detail machinery needed for reliable follow-up routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_rayleigh_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_7817_retrofitted_rayleigh_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1210_7817", "source_line": 1732, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4819, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to hidden-sector structure.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_0435_vectorlike_fourth_neutrino_cogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1211_0435", "source_line": 1707, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 135, "global_rank": 4820, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 21.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to neutrino, baryogenesis/cogenesis, phase-transition/nonstandard history.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "top_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_4717_axial_top_partner_u1_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_4717", "source_line": 1756, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4821, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 6: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family top_portal_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 3; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "top_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_4717_top_mediated_forbidden_channel_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_4717", "source_line": 1755, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4822, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 6: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family top_portal_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 3; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_00820_cp_violating_i21hdm_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_00820", "source_line": 3644, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 4823, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative scalar_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_higgs_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_04338_su6_so6_singlet_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_04338", "source_line": 4320, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4824, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes SU(6)/SO(6) singlet pNGB dark matter as a speculative composite_higgs_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via thermal freeze-out through annihilation to t tbar, W+W-, ZZ, and hh.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=low and BBN=low; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bilepton_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2104_scalar_bilepton_wimp_331rh_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2104", "source_line": 765, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4825, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 6.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: BBN relevance low, CMB relevance low; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_dark_matter_mimic", "model_id": "1111_3167_nonminimal_curvature_matter_cluster_dm_mimic_v1", "paper_id": "1111_3167", "source_line": 1449, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4826, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 6.0 because the card describes modified gravity dark matter mimic at effective field theory level, with effective_geometric_dark_component_from_curvature_matter_coupling and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_2055_radiative_rh_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_2055", "source_line": 1812, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 4827, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on no explicit probe class in observables, constraints, or routing fields and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_7004_soft_rpv_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_7004", "source_line": 1836, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 4828, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative gravitino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on no explicit probe class in observables, constraints, or routing fields and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_02673_hidden_u1x_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_02673", "source_line": 4360, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4829, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Hidden U(1)_X two-loop neutrino-mass model with scalar singlet dark matter: thermal freeze-out through p-wave annihilation; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes no explicit probe classes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "universal_extra_dimensions_dark_matter", "model_id": "0708_0239_minimal_ued_b1_lkp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0708_0239", "source_line": 670, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4830, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_07235_u1d_bl_wimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1706_07235", "source_line": 3116, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 363, "global_rank": 4831, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of hidden_sector_dark_matter with raw score 6.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_06563_effective_pq_scotogenic_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_06563", "source_line": 3588, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 4832, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative scotogenic_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter_to_axion_like_particles", "model_id": "1403_2370_scalar_decay_to_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_2370", "source_line": 2067, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4833, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of decaying_dark_matter_to_axion_like_particles; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support; large sparsity penalties from missing observational-extension fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "grand_unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_07468_su5_adjoint_fermion_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_07468", "source_line": 2715, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4834, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves auditable provenance and validity-domain text.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_model", "model_id": "2212_14788_2hda_pseudoscalar_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_14788", "source_line": 5490, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4835, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: 2HD+a pseudoscalar-mediated fermion dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1906_10849_pati_salam_cp_axion_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1906_10849", "source_line": 3916, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 6, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 175, "global_rank": 4836, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage is weak because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 6, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "quark_axial_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_07849_quark_axial_vector_current_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2108_07849", "source_line": 4843, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.8, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4837, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_14305_majorana_connector_pseudo_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_14305", "source_line": 5360, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 364, "global_rank": 4838, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Majorana-mass vector-like connector dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: direct detection, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2211_15674_strongly_coupled_crossover_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2211_15674", "source_line": 5400, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 236, "global_rank": 4839, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Strongly coupled smooth-crossover PBH dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: compact objects, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_14587_light_higgsino_subcomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_14587", "source_line": 5393, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 4840, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Light higgsino-like LSP subcomponent dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: direct detection, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_15200_asymptotic_safety_m2_fermion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2012_15200", "source_line": 4506, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.8, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 4841, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.8, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_15200_asymptotic_safety_m3_fermion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2012_15200", "source_line": 4507, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.8, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 4842, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.8, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "Feasibility gets limited credit from associated code or reusable tooling noted in the card.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_1999_meta_sequential_wprime_odd_higgs_lop_v1", "paper_id": "1312_1999", "source_line": 1998, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 4843, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: laboratory/collider/direct; explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superfluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_03003_two_field_superfluid_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2009_03003", "source_line": 4417, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4844, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes cosmological normal phase behaving like cold dark matter, galactic condensation into a superfluid core with a MOND-like phonon force.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space structure.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_09751_bc_charged_b_mesogenesis_dark_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "2109_09751", "source_line": 4832, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 136, "global_rank": 4845, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by CMB/BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_06221_majorana_sidm_heavier_zprime_v1", "paper_id": "1705_06221", "source_line": 3133, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 125, "global_rank": 4846, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of self_interacting_dark_matter with raw score 5.5.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_06221_scalar_sidm_heavier_zprime_v1", "paper_id": "1705_06221", "source_line": 3132, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 126, "global_rank": 4847, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of self_interacting_dark_matter with raw score 5.5.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9908152_scalar_field_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9908152", "source_line": 51, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 4848, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this scalar_field_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0601189_gravitational_scalar_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0601189", "source_line": 566, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 4849, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scalar-tensor gravitational scalar cold dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card in family scalar_field_dark_matter with production described as nonthermal coherent scalar-field evolution.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; field like phase space; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_10505_cosmological_bec_ultralight_boson_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "1808_10505", "source_line": 176, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4850, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 5.5 for bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter: positive factors include parameter-dependent relic-density viability, field_like phase-space behavior, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_11396_dirac_radiative_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2003_11396", "source_line": 4147, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 4851, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 5.5: speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: direct detection.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10334_lepto_philic_rs_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10334", "source_line": 3925, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4852, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative graviton_mediated_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10334_lepto_philic_rs_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10334", "source_line": 3923, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4853, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative graviton_mediated_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10334_lepto_philic_rs_spin_3_2_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10334", "source_line": 3926, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4854, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative graviton_mediated_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10334_lepto_philic_rs_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10334", "source_line": 3924, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4855, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative graviton_mediated_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10334_top_philic_rs_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10334", "source_line": 3921, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4856, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative graviton_mediated_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10334_top_philic_rs_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10334", "source_line": 3919, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4857, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative graviton_mediated_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10334_top_philic_rs_spin_3_2_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10334", "source_line": 3922, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 4858, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative graviton_mediated_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "graviton_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_10334_top_philic_rs_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1908_10334", "source_line": 3920, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4859, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative graviton_mediated_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_baryogenesis", "model_id": "1212_2973_wimp_baryogenesis_minimal_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_2973", "source_line": 1709, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4860, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to baryogenesis/cogenesis.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_00445_pgu_focus_point_gauge_mediation_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_00445", "source_line": 2551, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 4861, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative gravitino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include mixed_cold_warm phase space.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_02787_zn_ultralight_modulus_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_02787", "source_line": 4502, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 4862, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from field_like phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1803_07626_string_axion_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1803_07626", "source_line": 166, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 237, "global_rank": 4863, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 5.5 for primordial_black_holes: positive factors include uv_complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-density viability, high CMB relevance, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_04198_vector_dm_double_chern_simons_v1", "paper_id": "1706_04198", "source_line": 3188, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4864, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 5.5: Vector dark matter with double Chern-Simons Z prime portal is a speculative effective field theory entry with thermal WIMP freeze-out through Chern-Simons vector portal.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider, laboratory precision.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1909_08536_baryonium_string_junction_torus_v1", "paper_id": "1909_08536", "source_line": 4037, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-local scoring and missing-field penalties."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 4865, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 4, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from model-card fields as speculative phenomenological_parameterization; rank-relevant evidence includes limited explicit observational handles in the supplied card.", "Penalized because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, computational-representation, benchmark, or theory-to-observable-routing blocks.", "Low current observational-extension priority after penalties, but not rejected because the card does not state global exclusion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_singlino_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0508027_nmssm_singlino_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0508027", "source_line": 594, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4866, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["NMSSM singlino-admixed neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family supersymmetric_singlino_neutralino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out of the lightest neutralino through annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_singlino_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0508027_nmssm_smodel_decoupling_singlino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0508027", "source_line": 595, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4867, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["nMSSM/S-model decoupling singlino neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family supersymmetric_singlino_neutralino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out of the lightest neutralino through annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_4144_inelastic_dark_matter_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1109_4144", "source_line": 1387, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 4868, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as inelastic_dark_matter: production is represented by collider production of chi chi* through up-quark contact operators; phase-space is unknown; inferred probe coverage includes collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_04274_flavour_gut_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1706_04274", "source_line": 3183, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 216, "global_rank": 4869, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 5.5: SU(5) A4 flavour GUT neutralino dark matter with SUGRA SUSY breaking is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal neutralino freeze-out in a standard cosmology.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: direct detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_04561_umssm_bino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1706_04561", "source_line": 3191, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 217, "global_rank": 4870, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 5.5: Least-fine-tuned UMSSM neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal neutralino freeze-out.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_1168_hidden_photon_dirac_toy_v1", "paper_id": "1306_1168", "source_line": 1822, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 365, "global_rank": 4871, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_1168_susy_hidden_photon_fi_dirac_v1", "paper_id": "1306_1168", "source_line": 1823, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 366, "global_rank": 4872, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_1168_susy_hidden_photon_fi_majorana_v1", "paper_id": "1306_1168", "source_line": 1824, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 367, "global_rank": 4873, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_1168_susy_hidden_photon_radiative_majorana_v1", "paper_id": "1306_1168", "source_line": 1825, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 368, "global_rank": 4874, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_07607_pq_scotogenic_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_07607", "source_line": 3309, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 4875, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory model with parameter dependent relic-density support, 1 inferred probe class.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05353_decaying_minimal_dark_matter_quintuplet_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05353", "source_line": 2706, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 4876, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: indirect detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_5346_type_ii_thdm_scalar_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1308_5346", "source_line": 1874, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4877, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with decay production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 5.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phase_transition_modified_thermal_relic", "model_id": "1104_5034_supercooled_scalar_phase_transition_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1104_5034", "source_line": 1404, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4878, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 5.5 because the card describes phase transition modified thermal relic at phenomenological parameterization level, with thermal freeze-out with a nearby supercooled first-order scalar phase transition and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_10461_dark_flavon_radiative_flavor_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_10461", "source_line": 4144, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 369, "global_rank": 4879, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 5.5: speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: no explicit probe routing objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_0493_higgs_portal_scalar_u1_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_0493", "source_line": 1428, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 4880, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 5.5 because the card describes higgs portal dark matter at uv complete level, with Higgs-decay freeze-in for m_DM < m_h/2; scattering freeze-in for m_DM > m_h/2 and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_08432_sism_two_component_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1511_08432", "source_line": 2729, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 176, "global_rank": 4881, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 20.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 15}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves a card-local full-dark-matter production route.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_01833_solar_identical_dark_matter_axions_v1", "paper_id": "2109_01833", "source_line": 4834, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.2, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 177, "global_rank": 4882, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by mixed cold warm phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_05911_solar_semi_annihilating_boosted_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_05911", "source_line": 4829, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.2, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 4883, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_06732_cascade_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_06732", "source_line": 2708, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.2, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 370, "global_rank": 4884, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production.", "Explicit probe classes used for complementarity: collider, indirect detection.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_04832_bec_three_particle_interaction_two_phase_v1", "paper_id": "2007_04832", "source_line": 253, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 4885, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as BEC fuzzy dark matter with repulsive three-particle interaction, a speculative fuzzy ultralight dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and suppression of small-scale power, field like phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: core_model_not_relic_model, static_thermodynamics."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_0660_string_axion_thermal_inflation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_0660", "source_line": 2199, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 300, "global_rank": 4886, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, effective_field_theory theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, and field_like phase-space entry.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_05749_leptophilic_three_body_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_05749", "source_line": 2852, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card-local score is below 30, mainly from missing observable, constraint, and routing content."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 4887, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative decaying_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support, emphasizing 1 card-implied probe class.", "Score limited by large penalties from empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no usable associated code is identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1511_08470_particle_production_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1511_08470", "source_line": 2671, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 238, "global_rank": 4888, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 275. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior, approximate distribution information.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_00267_fr_scalaron_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2207_00267", "source_line": 5211, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 4889, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, high CMB relevance; field like phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_03279_two_step_sfoewpt_fimp_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_03279", "source_line": 3671, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 212, "global_rank": 4890, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; high BBN relevance; decay_produced phase-space behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_07407_u1r_scotogenic_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_07407", "source_line": 3794, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 4891, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 5 because the card identifies production via scotogenic dark matter production is not computed in this paper, candidate stability follows from the residual Z2 symmetry, probe classes: collider; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_0345_two_scalar_unified_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1105_0345", "source_line": 1348, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 4892, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level CMB relevance medium, phase-space type field_like.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_07578_vev_flip_flop_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_07578", "source_line": 2940, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 371, "global_rank": 4893, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance low, phase-space type nonthermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_03886_minimal_flavored_freeze_in_dm_su3_v1", "paper_id": "2103_03886", "source_line": 4574, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 213, "global_rank": 4894, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=low and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_13008_u1x_alp_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2007_13008", "source_line": 4348, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 214, "global_rank": 4895, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes U(1)_X axion-like FIMP dark matter with neutrino mass as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via freeze-in from vector-like lepton decays.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=unknown; phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_6934_asymmetric_dm_rsii_braneworld_v1", "paper_id": "1403_6934", "source_line": 2058, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 137, "global_rank": 4896, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of asymmetric_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "boson_star_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_15277_superradiant_micro_bose_star_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2205_15277", "source_line": 5248, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4897, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_05647_broken_clockwork_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1810_05647", "source_line": 3651, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 372, "global_rank": 4898, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_11423_superheavy_r2_stable_particle_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2011_11423", "source_line": 4532, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4899, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium BBN relevance, nonthermal phase space.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "2110_10085_gbi_v_unified_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "2110_10085", "source_line": 279, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4900, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as GBI+V generalized Chaplygin gas unified dark fluid, a speculative unified dark matter dark energy entry with effective field theory theory support and medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: warn_001."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electromagnetic_form_factor_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_04095_dirac_fermion_em_form_factor_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_04095", "source_line": 3664, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4901, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative electromagnetic_form_factor_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; high CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; high model-card diversity value from population-count rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_07780_type_ib_seesaw_neutrino_portal_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "2102_07780", "source_line": 4573, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 215, "global_rank": 4902, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_14809_tnh_composite_superheavy_pngb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_14809", "source_line": 5472, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 4903, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: TNH composite superheavy pNGB dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase space, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_0853_late_decaying_dark_matter_bulk_viscosity_v1", "paper_id": "0801_0853", "source_line": 359, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 4904, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via initial cold relic abundance followed by late decay into relativistic particles; bulk viscosity from delayed pressure equilibration; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance low; probe hooks: CMB, galaxy satellites/halo structure, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_3065_bino_slepton_stau_coannihilation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1309_3065", "source_line": 1941, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 218, "global_rank": 4905, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 5.0 because the model card is a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and touches collider.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0511262_kev_pseudoscalar_light_boson_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0511262", "source_line": 352, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 301, "global_rank": 4906, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative effective_field_theory model; production via early-Universe production followed by decoupling; possible production from heavier-particle decays or exotic cosmological evolution; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: laboratory/direct detection, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_05881_triplet_three_loop_radiative_neutrino_mass_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_05881", "source_line": 2559, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 4907, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_05930_ohe_atomic_dm_o_nuclearites_v1", "paper_id": "1901_05930", "source_line": 3710, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4908, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because OHe atomic dark matter with O-enriched nuclearites is a speculative phenomenological parameterization candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, probe relevance for BBN; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0510036_split_light_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0510036", "source_line": 590, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 219, "global_rank": 4909, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Split light Higgsino neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production described as thermal relic freeze-out via annihilation in the high-symmetric electroweak phase.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2310_17291_fermion_proca_star_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_17291", "source_line": 366, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 373, "global_rank": 4910, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via dark matter accumulation around neutron stars as cores or clouds; possible seeds, mergers with boson stars, accretion, or SM-particle decay inside neutron stars; field_like phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1211_2371_inflating_curvaton_primordial_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1211_2371", "source_line": 1703, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 239, "global_rank": 4911, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to inflation/curvaton, primordial-black-hole formation.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_01367_monodromy_pngb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1605_01367", "source_line": 2819, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 302, "global_rank": 4912, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kinetic_mixing_dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_08502_complex_scalar_dark_isr_kinetic_mixing_v1", "paper_id": "2006_08502", "source_line": 4307, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4913, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Complex scalar dark-photon portal model with dark initial-state radiation as a speculative kinetic_mixing_dark_photon_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via thermal freeze-out through p-wave scalar annihilation via an off-shell dark photon.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=high and BBN=unknown; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kinetic_mixing_dark_photon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_08502_pseudo_dirac_dark_isr_kinetic_mixing_v1", "paper_id": "2006_08502", "source_line": 4308, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4914, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Split pseudo-Dirac dark-photon portal model with dark initial-state radiation as a speculative kinetic_mixing_dark_photon_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via thermal co-annihilation of chi_1 and chi_2 through an off-shell dark photon.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=high and BBN=unknown; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_09894_radiative_seesaw_inelastic_boson_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_09894", "source_line": 4315, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 4915, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Radiative-seesaw inelastic inert-boson dark matter as a speculative inelastic_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via thermal annihilation of complex scalar dark matter through s-channel Z' resonance.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=medium; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_10754_inelastic_fermion_lmu_ltau_v1", "paper_id": "2007_10754", "source_line": 4347, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 4916, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Inelastic fermion dark matter in gauged L_mu-L_tau as a speculative inelastic_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via thermal freeze-out with annihilation and coannihilation of the two dark states.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=medium; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bosonic_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_2932_condensate_dark_matter_star_v1", "paper_id": "1205_2932", "source_line": 100, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4917, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this bosonic_condensate_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_1570_pseudo_dirac_magnetic_inelastic_v1", "paper_id": "1403_1570", "source_line": 2128, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 127, "global_rank": 4918, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_01202_composite_adm_dark_photon_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2112_01202", "source_line": 4954, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 138, "global_rank": 4919, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and asymmetric transfer between SM and dark sectors.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by limited explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_07873_mimetic_curvaton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2207_07873", "source_line": 5243, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4920, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, field like phase-space behavior, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10093_conformal_freeze_in_gluon_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10093", "source_line": 5230, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 216, "global_rank": 4921, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10093_conformal_freeze_in_hypercharge_gauge_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10093", "source_line": 5233, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 217, "global_rank": 4922, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10093_conformal_freeze_in_lepton_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10093", "source_line": 5231, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 218, "global_rank": 4923, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10093_conformal_freeze_in_quark_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10093", "source_line": 5229, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 219, "global_rank": 4924, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10093_conformal_freeze_in_weak_gauge_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10093", "source_line": 5232, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 220, "global_rank": 4925, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_branon_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0310272_nonthermal_branon_condensate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0310272", "source_line": 473, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4926, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by field_like phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0706_4309_kk_gravitino_decay_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0706_4309", "source_line": 654, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 4927, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_susy_so10_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_03509_so10_model_i_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1510_03509", "source_line": 2606, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4928, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: SO(10) Model I singlet fermion dark matter is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare family in population context, non-generic production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'nonthermal' and small-scale-power effect 'unknown'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_susy_so10_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_03509_so10_model_ii_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1510_03509", "source_line": 2607, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4929, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: SO(10) Model II singlet fermion dark matter is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare family in population context, non-generic production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'nonthermal' and small-scale-power effect 'unknown'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_03782_boosted_multicomponent_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_03782", "source_line": 2678, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 178, "global_rank": 4930, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, production ability yes, and family count 220. Observational leverage comes from mixed_cold_warm phase-space behavior.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_reheating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_08004_irreversible_reheating_dm_creation_v1", "paper_id": "1708_08004", "source_line": 368, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4931, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via irreversible nonthermal creation from inflationary scalar-field decay during reheating; nonthermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_00482_uv_o5_asymmetry_sharing_v1", "paper_id": "1806_00482", "source_line": 3556, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 139, "global_rank": 4932, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_00482_uv_o6_asymmetry_sharing_v1", "paper_id": "1806_00482", "source_line": 3557, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 140, "global_rank": 4933, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_02031_large_n_higgs_portal_scalar_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1808_02031", "source_line": 3599, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 221, "global_rank": 4934, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it can supply all dark matter according to the production block, has decay-produced phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_03484_palatini_superheavy_stable_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_03484", "source_line": 4322, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4935, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Stable superheavy scalar dark matter from Palatini gravitational preheating as a speculative gravitationally_produced_superheavy_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via nonthermal gravitational/tachyonic production during Palatini preheating.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=low and BBN=unknown; phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: mass_tuning_critical."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "brane_world_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0611024_branon_flexible_braneworld_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0611024", "source_line": 700, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4936, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0612152_ssc_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0612152", "source_line": 683, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 4937, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector_scalar", "model_id": "1204_2298_rastall_noncanonical_scalar_gcg_v1", "paper_id": "1204_2298", "source_line": 15, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4938, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_5880_high_scale_susy_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1403_5880", "source_line": 2089, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 4939, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of supersymmetric_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal or otherwise distinctive phase-space information; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support; large sparsity penalties from missing observational-extension fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nuclear_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_01840_fixed_k_nuclear_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1610_01840", "source_line": 2922, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4940, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative nuclear_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support; it can supply the full dark-matter abundance in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type nonthermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "atomic_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_11205_atomic_rearrangement_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2010_11205", "source_line": 4476, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4941, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for atomic_hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from nonthermal phase-space history, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_11156_modular_a4_radiative_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_11156", "source_line": 4529, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 4942, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 19.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_tensor_chameleon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_10364_efstg_chameleon_ghost_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_10364", "source_line": 273, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4943, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Einstein-frame scalar-tensor ghost chameleon dark matter, a speculative scalar tensor chameleon dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: toy_model_perturbations_missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_tensor_chameleon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_10364_efsts_chameleon_scalaron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2309_10364", "source_line": 272, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4944, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Einstein-frame scalar-tensor scalaron chameleon dark matter, a speculative scalar tensor chameleon dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: toy_model_perturbations_missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0504105_affleck_dine_q_ball_a_term_instability_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0504105", "source_line": 583, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 4945, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Affleck-Dine Q-ball dark matter with U(1)-breaking A-term instability is a speculative uv complete card in family q_ball_dark_matter with production described as Affleck-Dine condensate fragmentation into Q-balls in the early universe.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase space.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_6467_model_a_inert_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1305_6467", "source_line": 1885, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 4946, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, collider / fixed-target.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 0 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_6467_model_b_inert_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1305_6467", "source_line": 1886, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 4947, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, collider / fixed-target.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 0 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_7146_twin_peak_higgs_majorana_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1307_7146", "source_line": 1893, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 4948, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching CMB, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 0 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2101_10340_extreme_value_pbh_formation_v1", "paper_id": "2101_10340", "source_line": 4556, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 240, "global_rank": 4949, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=medium and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2102_05620_constant_rate_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_05620", "source_line": 4599, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 241, "global_rank": 4950, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=medium and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_1953_stuckelino_xwimp_v1", "paper_id": "0811_1953", "source_line": 843, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 374, "global_rank": 4951, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is medium/unknown. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_4505_self_interacting_asymmetric_dark_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "1003_4505", "source_line": 1093, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 141, "global_rank": 4952, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative phenomenological_parameterization asymmetric_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_5840_inert_doublet_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1404_5840", "source_line": 2117, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 4953, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: CMB relevance is medium.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_0145_phenomenological_unified_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1412_0145", "source_line": 63, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4954, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this unified_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium BBN relevance.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_06758_majorana_scalar_mediator_simplified_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_06758", "source_line": 2485, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4955, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=simplified_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=medium.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=5, diversity_value=2.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_12291_so_nf3_singlet_quintuplet_composite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_12291", "source_line": 4368, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 4956, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as SO(N) N_F=3 singlet-quintuplet anomaly-matched composite dark matter: thermal freeze-out; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes BBN.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "1901_11006_umami_chaplygin_unified_matter_dark_energy_v1", "paper_id": "1901_11006", "source_line": 334, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 4957, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:no_microphysical_candidate, medium:baryon_unification_is_effective.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/1/2/0/9/3/18."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_05075_semivisible_inelastic_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_05075", "source_line": 3722, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 375, "global_rank": 4958, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Semi-visible inelastic dark photon dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production, probe relevance for CMB; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_matter_creation_unification", "model_id": "0812_3865_matter_creation_dark_unification_v1", "paper_id": "0812_3865", "source_line": 342, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4959, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:phenomenological_fluid_only, medium:late_time_creation_model.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/1/2/0/9/5/19."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fourth_generation_heavy_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0411093_fourth_generation_heavy_neutrino_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0411093", "source_line": 555, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4960, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Charge-symmetric fourth-generation heavy neutrino subcomponent is a speculative uv complete card in family fourth_generation_heavy_neutrino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out of primordial fourth-generation neutrino and antineutrino gas.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: halo/subhalo structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fourth_generation_heavy_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0411093_y_charged_heavy_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0411093", "source_line": 556, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4961, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Y-charged fourth-generation heavy neutrino with Coulomb-like interaction is a speculative uv complete card in family fourth_generation_heavy_neutrino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out similar to baseline heavy neutrino.", "Observational leverage is driven by probe classes: halo/subhalo structure.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_02874_multicomponent_asymmetric_dm_conversions_v1", "paper_id": "2207_02874", "source_line": 5213, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 179, "global_rank": 4962, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 4.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, some analytic or public-code feasibility support. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0309029_msugra_neutralino_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0309029", "source_line": 486, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 220, "global_rank": 4963, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including low, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "geometric_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "2404_19498_shear_hypermomentum_effective_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2404_19498", "source_line": 265, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4964, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Shear-hypermomentum effective dark matter in quadratic metric-affine gravity, a speculative geometric effective dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: effective_not_particle, perturbations_missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0803_1444_intermediate_higgs_portal_singlet_v1", "paper_id": "0803_1444", "source_line": 785, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 4965, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 5.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_2771_asymmetric_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1103_2771", "source_line": 1308, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 142, "global_rank": 4966, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_6052_scalar_wimp_effective_operator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_6052", "source_line": 1430, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4967, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 5.0 because the card describes effective operator wimp dark matter at effective field theory level, with thermal freeze-out through WIMP anti-WIMP annihilation to SM fermion pairs and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_6052_spin_3_2_wimp_effective_operator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_6052", "source_line": 1432, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4968, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 5.0 because the card describes effective operator wimp dark matter at effective field theory level, with thermal freeze-out through WIMP anti-WIMP annihilation to SM fermion pairs and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_6052_vector_wimp_effective_operator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_6052", "source_line": 1431, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4969, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 5.0 because the card describes effective operator wimp dark matter at effective field theory level, with thermal freeze-out through WIMP anti-WIMP annihilation to SM fermion pairs and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_08581_type_x_2hdm_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1709_08581", "source_line": 3202, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 4970, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Singlet scalar dark matter in leptophilic Type-X 2HDM is a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter card with CMB/BBN relevance medium/unknown, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_04255_dirac_fermion_pseudoscalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_04255", "source_line": 4707, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 180, "global_rank": 4971, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; annihilation.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 5 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_5890_stueckelberg_portal_hidden_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1401_5890", "source_line": 2040, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 376, "global_rank": 4972, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_00640_wino_nlo_sommerfeld_relic_v1", "paper_id": "2009_00640", "source_line": 4418, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4973, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a benchmark simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out, Sommerfeld-enhanced annihilation.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_energy_wimp", "model_id": "2011_11548_interacting_de_wimp_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2011_11548", "source_line": 4493, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4974, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for interacting_dark_energy_wimp.", "Diversity credit comes from underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_0287_radiative_seesaw_singlet_fermion_coannihilation_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "0903_0287", "source_line": 922, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4975, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_particle_creation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_6505_gravitational_matter_creation_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1208_6505", "source_line": 287, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4976, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Gravitational matter-creation dark matter cosmology with curvature, a speculative gravitational particle creation dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: background_degeneracy, phenomenological_only."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_7419_so6_so5_composite_pngb_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_7419", "source_line": 2065, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 4977, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of composite_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_09106_bottom_loop_composite_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_09106", "source_line": 3604, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 4978, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative composite_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_seesaw_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_13686_u1r_radiative_seesaw_bosonic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_13686", "source_line": 4392, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4979, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Gauged U(1)_R radiative-seesaw bosonic dark matter: thermal freeze-out computed from annihilation cross sections; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes no explicit probe classes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_14052_vector_higgs_portal_eft_scale_v1", "paper_id": "2312_14052", "source_line": 5928, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card has low current observational-extension value, usually from missing observables, constraints, routing, benchmark, or computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 4980, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current follow-up value because Vector Higgs-portal dark matter EFT with explicit new-physics scale is a benchmark higgs_portal_dark_matter card with thermal phase-space information, none small-scale-power information, and no explicit routed probe class from the supplied fields.", "Component balance: science 11, observational leverage 1, complementarity 0, feasibility 0, provenance 9, diversity 1.0, penalties 17; raw score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_0609_majorana_odd_neutrino_kk_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0901_0609", "source_line": 938, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4981, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, full relic-abundance support in the card, medium cosmological relevance, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_02011_su2n_vector_scalar_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_02011", "source_line": 3907, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 181, "global_rank": 4982, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory level.", "Observational leverage is limited but nonzero from phase-space, cosmological, or associated-code fields in the card.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_4874_e6_shadow_baryon_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "0902_4874", "source_line": 907, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 377, "global_rank": 4983, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, medium cosmological relevance, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1102_4249_b_l_right_handed_sneutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1102_4249", "source_line": 1275, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 4984, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 5 for B-L right-handed sneutrino dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from distribution function availability is approximate.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_05565_nmssm_higgs_pseudoscalar_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1505_05565", "source_line": 2484, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 4985, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=27.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_07109_twin_tau_lepton_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1505_07109", "source_line": 2493, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 378, "global_rank": 4986, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=506.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_portal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_06767_u1_10_5_dirac_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_06767", "source_line": 2465, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4987, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=zprime_portal_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=4, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_portal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_06767_u1_b_l_dirac_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_06767", "source_line": 2463, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4988, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=zprime_portal_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=4, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_portal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_06767_u1_d_u_dirac_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_06767", "source_line": 2464, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 4989, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=zprime_portal_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=4, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_portal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_06767_u1_universal_dirac_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_06767", "source_line": 2466, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 4990, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=zprime_portal_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=4, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_00789_2hdm_pseudoscalar_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_00789", "source_line": 2469, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 4991, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=10, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_04143_hidden_sector_higgs_portal_pwave_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_04143", "source_line": 2470, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 4992, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=secluded_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=7, diversity_value=2.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_3516_internal_flavored_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1109_3516", "source_line": 1369, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, computational representation, or routing in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 4993, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as flavored_dark_matter: production is represented by portal-mediated production or freeze-out; phase-space is unknown; inferred probe coverage includes direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score drivers: provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warnings are populated.", "Score is strongly limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, computational representation, and theory-to-observable routing in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cascade_annihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_4100_cascade_photon_line_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1208_4100", "source_line": 1645, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 4994, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Cascade photonic thermal dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_simplified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_7120_scalar_leptophilic_charged_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1307_7120", "source_line": 1882, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 4995, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 4 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1412_5600_flavor_origin_z2_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1412_5600", "source_line": 2306, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 4996, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 5 because the assigned model card uv complete scotogenic_dark_matter card; touches collider / fixed-target / beam dump.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_5497_axino_lsp_bino_nlsp_hadronic_axion_susy_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_5497", "source_line": 1461, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 4997, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable axino_dark_matter variant and records late decays of Bino NLSP to axino LSP in supersymmetric cascades.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_2877_wimpless_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0909_2877", "source_line": 1025, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 379, "global_rank": 4998, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 5 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness, scientific-value baseline.", "Card-local details considered: identity family hidden_sector_dark_matter, theory level uv_complete, and probe handles: indirect detection.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "astro-ph9901292_radiation_era_pbh_formation_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9901292", "source_line": 6101, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 242, "global_rank": 4999, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 5 (defer) from supplied card content: primordial_black_holes with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (15) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_01272_singlet_scalar_sidm_neutrinophilic_2hdm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_01272", "source_line": 3607, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 128, "global_rank": 5000, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative self_interacting_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_02670_split_fermion_leptophilic_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_02670", "source_line": 4820, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5001, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "astro-ph9901293_first_order_phase_transition_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9901293", "source_line": 6102, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 243, "global_rank": 5002, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 5 (defer) from supplied card content: primordial_black_holes with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and parameter_dependent all-DM production.", "Penalties (16) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; local near-duplicate context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_1675_inverted_hierarchy_mssm_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1205_1675", "source_line": 1567, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 221, "global_rank": 5003, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 18.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because it is a viable neutralino LSP construction with standard CDM-like structure, but the observational extension inputs are sparse and stability depends on the R-parity assumption."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_2372_large_a_focus_point_susy_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1205_2372", "source_line": 1595, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 222, "global_rank": 5004, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card records a standard CDM-like neutralino focus-point scenario with qualitative relic viability and no model-local routes, constraints, or code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_10402_orbifold_scotogenic_dark_parity_v1", "paper_id": "2007_10402", "source_line": 4388, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 5005, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Orbifold scotogenic dark-parity model: not specified in assigned text; stable lightest dark-parity particle is proposed as the candidate; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes compact-object/dynamics.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_04987_bosonic_electroweak_baryon_topological_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_04987", "source_line": 3016, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 5006, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Bosonic electroweak baryon topological dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_09153_bosonic_inert_scalar_neutrino_model_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_09153", "source_line": 3021, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 5007, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Bosonic inert scalar dark matter in a one-loop neutrino-mass model is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_qcd_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph9802337_stable_cosmic_qgp_bag_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph9802337", "source_line": 6124, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5008, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 5 (defer) from supplied card content: macroscopic_qcd_relic_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory content and unknown all-DM production.", "Penalties (18) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_light_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_6377_bmssm_light_neutralino_light_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "1011_6377", "source_line": 1265, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5009, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 5 for BMSSM light-neutralino light-Higgs dark matter scenario: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from probe hints: direct detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_07830_higgsino_pgm_nonuniversal_higgs_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_07830", "source_line": 5028, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 5010, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Higgsino dark matter in non-universal-Higgs pure gravity mediation has probe classes: laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_4521_loop_suppressed_neutrinophilic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1305_4521", "source_line": 1860, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5011, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 3 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_remnant_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_2504_palatini_geon_remnant_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1306_2504", "source_line": 18, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5012, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_massive_particle_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_00219_dqcd_dark_pion_simp_v1", "paper_id": "1704_00219", "source_line": 3024, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5013, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["dQCD dark-pion SIMP with Wess-Zumino-Witten annihilation is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited; high-severity validity warnings reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_04698_pseudo_scalar_u1x_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_04698", "source_line": 5440, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Absent observables, constraints, routing, and code leave little current follow-up leverage."], "family_rank": 380, "global_rank": 5014, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: the UV-complete pseudo-scalar U(1)_X dark matter model is viable in parameter space, but supplied phenomenology is thermal/CDM-like with no route or constraint content."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "weakly_interacting_massive_particle", "model_id": "2212_07756_z2_scalar_multiplet_wimp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_07756", "source_line": 5441, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["No supplied observables, constraints, routes, code, or distinctive structure signal."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5015, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: the Z2 scalar multiplet WIMP covers a rare family label, but the supplied fields are thermal/CDM-like and no observational routing is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavoured_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_03809_lepton_flavoured_scalar_dm_dmfv_v1", "paper_id": "2211_03809", "source_line": 5431, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Missing observables, constraints, routing, and code dominate over the flavour diversity value."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5016, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: lepton-flavoured scalar DM is a sparse flavour class, but the supplied fields are thermal/CDM-like and give no concrete observational route."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0610367_deconstructed_ued_kkdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0610367", "source_line": 610, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5017, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has some computational or code support recorded in the model card, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_1014_z3_scalar_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1211_1014", "source_line": 1736, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 5018, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 13.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=partial, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_08084_fsu5_dbrane_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "2108_08084", "source_line": 4836, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5019, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by some associated-code support, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_04973_s2hdm_png_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2207_04973", "source_line": 5207, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5020, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative simplified model model content, partial associated-code support. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_3142_extra_matter_susy_bino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_3142", "source_line": 1412, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 223, "global_rank": 5021, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 5.0 because the card describes supersymmetric neutralino dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal freeze-out; neutralino-stau coannihilation and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage with partial associated-code support.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "familon_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_00869_a4_charged_lepton_familon_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_00869", "source_line": 2626, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5022, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: A4 charged-lepton familon portal fermion dark matter is marked speculative with effective field theory theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare family in population context, distinct production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "familon_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_00869_a4_neutrino_familon_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_00869", "source_line": 2627, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5023, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: A4 neutrino-familon portal fermion dark matter is marked speculative with effective field theory theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare family in population context, distinct production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "familon_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_00869_su3_gut_familon_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_00869", "source_line": 2628, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5024, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: SU3 GUT-inspired familon portal fermion dark matter is marked speculative with effective field theory theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare family in population context, distinct production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_04085_smssm_smuon_coannihilation_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_04085", "source_line": 3048, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 224, "global_rank": 5025, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["sMSSM smuon-coannihilation neutralino dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_01180_scale_invariant_scotogenic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_01180", "source_line": 3675, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 5026, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative scotogenic_dark_matter with simplified_model theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_09807_two_singlet_scalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_09807", "source_line": 3698, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 5027, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter with simplified_model theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_11574_pseudoreal_quadruplet_ewdm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_11574", "source_line": 4725, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5028, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support and production via thermal freeze-out; coannihilation among electroweak multiplet components.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 5 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing.", "Feasibility receives limited credit from partial associated-code or public-tool information in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_11325_pseudo_dirac_singlet_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2001_11325", "source_line": 4169, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5029, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of singlet_doublet_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include limited explicit observable structure in the card.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_10879_atomic_size_dark_matter_pearls_v1", "paper_id": "2111_10879", "source_line": 4896, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5030, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card status is speculative and no card-local global-elimination condition was triggered.", "Scientific/provenance support comes from phenomenological_parameterization theory content, relic-density treatment scored from the card, and populated provenance/validity/assumption/robustness fields.", "Score limited by no explicit observables, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block, high-severity warning present in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_04887_degenerate_scalar_pseudoscalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_04887", "source_line": 4596, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5031, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=low and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 10."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_11355_iss_nmssm_sneutrino_higgsino_coannihilation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_11355", "source_line": 4594, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 5032, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_13029_cxsm_mpp_cp_odd_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_13029", "source_line": 5464, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 5033, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: CxSM with Multi-critical Point Principle and CP-odd scalar dark matter has solid theory/motivation content, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp", "model_id": "2102_08645_leptophilic_majorana_wimp_combined_mediators_v1", "paper_id": "2102_08645", "source_line": 4568, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5034, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative leptophilic_wimp entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 7."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp", "model_id": "2102_08645_leptophilic_majorana_wimp_right_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2102_08645", "source_line": 4567, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5035, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative leptophilic_wimp entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 7."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_4918_so10_nonuniversal_gaugino_split_sfermion_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1402_4918", "source_line": 2133, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 225, "global_rank": 5036, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: partial associated-code support is noted, but explicit routing and benchmark support are absent, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_3442_scalar_dm_quark_contact_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1311_3442", "source_line": 2009, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5037, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=effective_field_theory, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_3442_scalar_dm_z_contact_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1311_3442", "source_line": 2008, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5038, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=effective_field_theory, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_coupled_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_5695_strongly_coupled_gauge_singlet_wimp_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1312_5695", "source_line": 2042, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5039, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=effective_field_theory, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_05403_inert_doublet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_05403", "source_line": 2507, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 5040, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Inert-doublet scalar dark matter in Naturalness redux: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_04620_gauged_lmu_ltau_leptophilic_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_04620", "source_line": 2514, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 5041, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Gauged L_mu-L_tau leptophilic Dirac dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_02412_three_loop_right_hand_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_02412", "source_line": 2520, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 5042, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Three-loop radiative neutrino model with lightest right-hand Majorana neutrino dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_06993_leptophilic_pseudoscalar_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_06993", "source_line": 2541, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5043, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Leptophilic pseudoscalar portal fermionic dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_06179_dark_minimal_flavour_violation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_06179", "source_line": 2543, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5044, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Dark Minimal Flavour Violation flavored dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2058_su5_24_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2058", "source_line": 754, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 226, "global_rank": 5045, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 5.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0909_2484_susy_type_i_seesaw_bino_higgsino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "0909_2484", "source_line": 1058, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 227, "global_rank": 5046, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_0061_stueckelberg_hidden_sector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0910_0061", "source_line": 1053, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 381, "global_rank": 5047, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_4519_spread_susy_higgsino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_4519", "source_line": 1417, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 182, "global_rank": 5048, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 5.0 because the card describes multi component dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal freeze-out of a weakly interacting LSP or LOSP; environmental selection imposing an upper bound on total axion plus LSP dark matter abundance and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_4519_spread_susy_wino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_4519", "source_line": 1418, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 183, "global_rank": 5049, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 5.0 because the card describes multi component dark matter at uv complete level, with thermal freeze-out of a weakly interacting LSP or LOSP; environmental selection imposing an upper bound on total axion plus LSP dark matter abundance and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_05955_extended_ma_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_05955", "source_line": 2505, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 5050, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Extended Ma radiative-seesaw inert-doublet dark matter with constrained inflaton: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_04763_higgs_triplet_vector_like_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1509_04763", "source_line": 2534, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5051, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Higgs Triplet Model with vector-like neutrino dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_00585_bino_gluino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1605_00585", "source_line": 2809, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 228, "global_rank": 5052, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_00585_bino_wino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1605_00585", "source_line": 2810, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 229, "global_rank": 5053, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_04543_lepton_quarticity_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1606_04543", "source_line": 2850, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 382, "global_rank": 5054, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_02253_softly_broken_higgs_portal_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1708_02253", "source_line": 3204, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 5055, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Softly broken U(1) Higgs-portal scalar WIMP is a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_08619_hmdm_1m2d_v1", "paper_id": "1711_08619", "source_line": 3315, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5056, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_08619_hmdm_3m2d_v1", "paper_id": "1711_08619", "source_line": 3316, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5057, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_08619_hmdm_3m4d_v1", "paper_id": "1711_08619", "source_line": 3317, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5058, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1711_08619_hmdm_5m4d_v1", "paper_id": "1711_08619", "source_line": 3318, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5059, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_07964_left_right_u1d_s1_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_07964", "source_line": 4489, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 383, "global_rank": 5060, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 5.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_wimp_portal", "model_id": "1005_4632_top_philic_u1_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1005_4632", "source_line": 1074, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5061, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model simplified_wimp_portal; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_0559_nonminimal_fermion_scalar_interacting_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "1109_0559", "source_line": 305, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5062, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include few explicit observational handles are present.", "associated_code=no; warnings=medium:fluid_not_particle_relic.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/0/0/0/9/4/16."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_5154_nmssm_well_tempered_neutralino_singlet_pseudoscalar_v1", "paper_id": "1211_5154", "source_line": 1739, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 230, "global_rank": 5063, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_5647_zprime_mediated_dirac_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1212_5647", "source_line": 1701, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5064, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 17.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1301_4892_singlet_fermion_scalar_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1301_4892", "source_line": 1724, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5065, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=no, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Diversity value is relatively high because the family or production/phase-space mechanism is underrepresented in the population context.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0011335_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0011335", "source_line": 405, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5066, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides uv complete theory support, moderate diversity value; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_2914_pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0902_2914", "source_line": 926, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5067, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "top_philic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0912_0004_top_philic_dirac_wimp_zprime_v1", "paper_id": "0912_0004", "source_line": 1060, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5068, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative effective_field_theory top_philic_wimp_dark_matter; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimpy_baryogenesis", "model_id": "1402_0930_wimpy_leptogenesis_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1402_0930", "source_line": 2126, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5069, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_6033_majorana_three_loop_neutrino_dm_variants_v1", "paper_id": "1404_6033", "source_line": 2063, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 5070, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides emerging uv_complete member of radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_03116_scalar_mediator_s_channel_v1", "paper_id": "1506_03116", "source_line": 2496, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5071, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=benchmark, theory_level=simplified_model, family=simplified_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "No distinct probe class was inferred from the supplied model-card fields.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=3, diversity_value=3.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_10128_susy_su5_mirage_bino_wino_gluino_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1812_10128", "source_line": 3708, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 231, "global_rank": 5072, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because b-tau unified SUSY SU(5) mirage-mediation bino-wino neutralino dark matter with gluino coannihilation is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_10128_susy_su5_mirage_higgsino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_10128", "source_line": 3707, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 232, "global_rank": 5073, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because b-tau unified SUSY SU(5) mirage-mediation Higgsino-like neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_4067_finite_temperature_casimir_effective_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1303_4067", "source_line": 340, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5074, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include few explicit observational handles are present.", "associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:effective_not_particle.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 9/0/0/0/9/5/18."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_06397_general_op4_electroweak_skyrmion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_06397", "source_line": 3029, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5075, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["General O(p^4) electroweak Skyrmion dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; adds useful diversity value; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_baryogenesis_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_08911_singlet_ewbg_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_08911", "source_line": 3140, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5076, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of electroweak_baryogenesis_dark_matter with raw score 5.0.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 1.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_09537_cpv_mssm_bino_higgs_funnel_v1", "paper_id": "1805_09537", "source_line": 3566, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 233, "global_rank": 5077, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it can supply all dark matter according to the production block.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_06036_u1_lmutau_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_06036", "source_line": 3569, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 234, "global_rank": 5078, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extended_higgs_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_02781_higgson_extended_higgs_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1901_02781", "source_line": 3703, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5079, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Higgson extended-Higgs-sector WIMP is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_09091_light_dirac_fermion_u1chi_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_09091", "source_line": 3705, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5080, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Light Dirac fermion dark matter in a scotogenic U(1)_chi Dirac-neutrino model is a speculative uv complete candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_u1d_inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_01148_u1d_dark_symmetry_inert_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1604_01148", "source_line": 2735, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5081, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves auditable provenance and validity-domain text.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_quarticity_flavor_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_00210_a4_lepton_quarticity_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1706_00210", "source_line": 3129, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5082, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of lepton_quarticity_flavor_dark_matter with raw score 5.0.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 1.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "technicolor_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_0486_ultra_minimal_walking_technicolor_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0902_0486", "source_line": 989, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30, mainly because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5083, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative technicolor_composite_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support and unknown full-density capability.", "Observational leverage is modest because the supplied card is CDM-like or lacks explicit cosmological, structure-formation, and route fields.", "Priority is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in this model-card-only pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_15019_70gev_higgson_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2210_15019", "source_line": 5352, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5084, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because 70 GeV second-order-gauge-coupled higgson WIMP has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, moderate diversity value."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_4146_complex_scalar_quark_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1308_4146", "source_line": 1956, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5085, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_4146_real_scalar_quark_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1308_4146", "source_line": 1957, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 because the model-only card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or public-code support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5086, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 6, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from supplied model-card fields: limited but nonzero observational leverage in the supplied card.", "explicit routing, benchmark, likelihood, and public-code support is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_13706_uv_freeze_in_kination_stiff_era_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_13706", "source_line": 4198, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 222, "global_rank": 5087, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of freeze_in_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include high BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_absorption_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_01940_dark_photon_fermionic_absorption_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_01940", "source_line": 4433, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5088, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes production through vector absorption operator after neutrino decoupling, unspecified nonthermal abundance mechanism outside the thermal relic paradigm.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, high CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_05117_post_inflationary_temperature_dependent_alp_v1", "paper_id": "2112_05117", "source_line": 4997, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 303, "global_rank": 5089, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion like dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and post-inflationary misalignment from an inhomogeneous axion field.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by field like phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by yes associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_10827_decaying_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2012_10827", "source_line": 4497, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 5090, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for decaying_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from decay_produced phase-space history, underrepresented or distinctive model family.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 4.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_2156_assisted_coupled_quintessence_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1407_2156", "source_line": 157, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5091, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 4.5 for coupled_dark_energy_dark_matter: positive factors include parameter-dependent relic-density viability, medium CMB relevance, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_13211_s1_singlet_fimp_warm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2004_13211", "source_line": 4196, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 223, "global_rank": 5092, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of freeze_in_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include nonthermal phase-space information.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_12798_b_minus_3l_e_freeze_in_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_12798", "source_line": 4965, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 224, "global_rank": 5093, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and freeze-in through a flavored vector mediator.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_12798_b_minus_3l_mu_freeze_in_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_12798", "source_line": 4966, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 225, "global_rank": 5094, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and freeze-in through a flavored vector mediator.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_12798_b_minus_3l_tau_freeze_in_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_12798", "source_line": 4967, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 226, "global_rank": 5095, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and freeze-in through a flavored vector mediator.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_09014_leptonic_model_4a_symmetry_restoring_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_09014", "source_line": 4486, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 143, "global_rank": 5096, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for asymmetric_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from nonthermal phase-space history.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 4.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "brane_world_growing_cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0507227_growing_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0507227", "source_line": 155, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5097, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 4.5 for brane_world_growing_cold_dark_matter: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, high CMB relevance, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_0956_type_ii_seesaw_amsb_bino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0711_0956", "source_line": 724, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension score driven mainly by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 235, "global_rank": 5098, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card has speculative simplified_model model card; relic abundance marked parameter_dependent.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, model-comparison fields, and mostly missing computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_06089_mirror_shadow_baryon_pev_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_06089", "source_line": 2572, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 5099, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative decaying_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include nonthermal phase space.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0411364_modular_soft_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0411364", "source_line": 510, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 236, "global_rank": 5100, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Modular-invariant soft-breaking neutralino dark matter is a speculative effective field theory card with full dark matter relic-density treatment; it touches cmb; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_03031_scale_invariant_su2x_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1508_03031", "source_line": 2568, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 384, "global_rank": 5101, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_05950_lmssm6_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1704_05950", "source_line": 3168, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 237, "global_rank": 5102, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 4.5: LMSSM-6 neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with neutralino cold dark matter relic density calculation over the LMSSM-6 parameter space.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: collider.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1302_4034_spin_3_2_singlet_dark_matter_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1302_4034", "source_line": 1805, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5103, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0.5, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative effective_operator_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on indirect detection and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "astro_ph0408369_rs2_primordial_black_holes_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0408369", "source_line": 536, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 244, "global_rank": 5104, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Randall-Sundrum type-2 primordial black-hole dark matter is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card with either relic-density treatment; it touches compact objects / microlensing / dynamics; explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pNGB_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_11499_softly_broken_son_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_11499", "source_line": 4826, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5105, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_pion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_5245_stringy_hidden_pion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_5245", "source_line": 1641, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5106, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory card for Stringy hidden-valley U(1)_X charged hidden pion dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_5346_type_ii_thdm_fermion_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1308_5346", "source_line": 1873, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5107, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative effective-field-theory model with decay production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 5.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_5346_type_ii_thdm_vector_singlet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1308_5346", "source_line": 1875, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5108, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative effective-field-theory model with decay production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 5.5 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_01796_nonminimal_sleptonic_susy_bino_slepton_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2203_01796", "source_line": 5037, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 5109, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Non-minimal Sleptonic SUSY bino-slepton coannihilation dark matter has probe classes: laboratory/particle, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_01796_sleptonic_susy_mssm_bino_slepton_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2203_01796", "source_line": 5036, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 5110, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: MSSM Sleptonic SUSY bino-slepton coannihilation dark matter has probe classes: laboratory/particle, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_03455_dimension7_lnv_z2_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_03455", "source_line": 2570, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 5111, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_03954_gauged_u1_bminusl_pngb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2001_03954", "source_line": 4190, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5112, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include limited explicit observable structure in the card.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_6549_mssm_rn_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_6549", "source_line": 2006, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 5113, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=uv_complete, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_1448_qcd_latent_energy_domain_wall_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_1448", "source_line": 1447, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5114, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 4.5 because the card describes topological defect dark matter at phenomenological parameterization level, with first_order_qcd_phase_transition_latent_energy; pasted_or_patched_domain_wall_evolution and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card. Diversity credit is relatively high because the family or phenomenology is sparse in the supplied population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_06881_pseudo_dirac_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1703_06881", "source_line": 3109, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 5115, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of inelastic_dark_matter with raw score 4.5.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_09758_dark_su2d_st_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_09758", "source_line": 4527, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 385, "global_rank": 5116, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_09998_vdsidm_gravothermal_collapse_v1", "paper_id": "1904_09998", "source_line": 3792, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 129, "global_rank": 5117, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 4 because the card identifies production via unknown, probe classes: small-scale structure; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_06401_u1x_kev_dark_fermion_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "2007_06401", "source_line": 4302, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 386, "global_rank": 5118, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes U(1)_X keV dark fermion with nearly massless dark photons as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via thermal freeze-out of nonrelativistic dark fermions.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=high; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_02954_light_scalar_heavy_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2010_02954", "source_line": 4442, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5119, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out benchmark through annihilation to charged leptons, possible annihilation into neutrinos in neutrino-dependent variants.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, high CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_02954_light_scalar_leptophilic_zprime_v1", "paper_id": "2010_02954", "source_line": 4443, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5120, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out benchmark through s-channel Z' annihilation to leptons, near-resonant annihilation when m_Zprime is close to 2 m_phi.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, high CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_00052_mt2hdm_mirror_neutron_adm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_00052", "source_line": 4340, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 144, "global_rank": 5121, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Mirror neutron asymmetric dark matter in the MT2HDM as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via mirror-sector asymmetric baryogenesis inherited by Mirror Twin Higgs structure.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=high and BBN=high; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: not_mirror_atom_dm."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_06115_fermionic_leptobaryon_mesogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2011_06115", "source_line": 4423, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 145, "global_rank": 5122, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes asymmetric production from low-temperature mesogenesis, dark-sector scattering transfer of lepton asymmetry to baryon asymmetry.", "Observational leverage comes from critical BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space structure.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_06115_scalar_baryon_lepton_mesogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "2011_06115", "source_line": 4422, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 146, "global_rank": 5123, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes asymmetric production from low-temperature mesogenesis, dark-sector scattering transfer of lepton asymmetry to baryon asymmetry.", "Observational leverage comes from critical BBN relevance, nonthermal phase-space structure.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0702112_mssm_inflation_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0702112", "source_line": 661, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 238, "global_rank": 5124, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "co_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_02499_u1x_co_decaying_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_02499", "source_line": 4436, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5125, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 16.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes co-decaying freeze-out, cannibal 3 to 2 scatterings in the dark sector.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_00896_qcd_axion_helical_hidden_photons_v1", "paper_id": "2012_00896", "source_line": 4514, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 304, "global_rank": 5126, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, field_like phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "emergent_pattern_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_08372_pattern_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2101_08372", "source_line": 190, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5127, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 4.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 4.0 for emergent_pattern_dark_matter: positive factors include field_like phase-space behavior, scale_dependent_growth transfer-function behavior, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0702183_neutralino_dm_5d_sugra_kk_gravitino_decay_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0702183", "source_line": 695, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 5128, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_4035_einstein_tensor_scalar_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1002_4035", "source_line": 49, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 5129, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space description, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_07476_axion_pbh_minihalo_axion_star_v1", "paper_id": "2001_07476", "source_line": 4168, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 305, "global_rank": 5130, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of axion_like_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include field_like phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_10990_axion_hidden_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2010_10990", "source_line": 4466, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 306, "global_rank": 5131, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for axion_like_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from field_like phase-space history.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 4.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_05020_dark_photon_bound_state_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1510_05020", "source_line": 2629, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 130, "global_rank": 5132, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Dark photon self-interacting dark matter with bound states is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, limited but present observational leverage in phase-space or structure fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, nonthermal phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'nonthermal' and small-scale-power effect 'unknown'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_07195_dark_higgs_parametric_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_07195", "source_line": 3696, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 387, "global_rank": 5133, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with simplified_model theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal phase-space behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_03089_high_quality_composite_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1811_03089", "source_line": 3653, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 307, "global_rank": 5134, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative axion_like_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; field_like phase-space behavior.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9802258_massless_complex_scalar_halo_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9802258", "source_line": 124, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 5135, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative scalar_field_dark_matter card with uv complete theory-level support and field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_3730_weinberg_annihilating_kev_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_3730", "source_line": 2156, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 388, "global_rank": 5136, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with suppression small-scale-power effect.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "1405_5688_clustering_generalized_chaplygin_gas_v1", "paper_id": "1405_5688", "source_line": 2184, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5137, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, phenomenological_parameterization theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with medium CMB relevance, and field_like phase-space entry.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_1171_big_bang_darkleosynthesis_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_1171", "source_line": 2166, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 147, "global_rank": 5138, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, phenomenological_parameterization theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with medium BBN relevance, and nonthermal phase-space entry.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_2276_dark_nuclei_composite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_2276", "source_line": 2180, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 5139, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, effective_field_theory theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with mixed_cold_warm phase-space entry, and approximate distribution-function support.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_4121_stable_bound_state_adm_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1407_4121", "source_line": 2169, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 148, "global_rank": 5140, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, effective_field_theory theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with medium BBN relevance, and nonthermal phase-space entry.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2308_16412_instantaneous_symmetry_breaking_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2308_16412", "source_line": 5785, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 after penalties for missing explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 389, "global_rank": 5141, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Instantaneous-symmetry-breaking non-observed dark matter has limited but scoreable model-card content; card-internal probe cues include collider/fixed-target, direct detection.", "Priority is limited because the supplied card has empty explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields. High-severity caveats further reduce confidence: do_not_map_to_standard_wimp."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_1203_conformal_dark_gauge_boson_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_1203", "source_line": 1931, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 390, "global_rank": 5142, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 4.0 because the model card is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and touches direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_1203_conformal_real_scalar_higgs_portal_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_1203", "source_line": 1930, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 5143, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 4.0 because the model card is a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and touches direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_3561_2hdm_ii_scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1309_3561", "source_line": 1946, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 5144, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 4.0 because the model card is a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and touches direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_3561_extra_light_scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1309_3561", "source_line": 1947, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 5145, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 4.0 because the model card is a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and touches direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1309_3561_triplet_singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1309_3561", "source_line": 1945, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 65, "global_rank": 5146, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 4.0 because the model card is a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and touches direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_10632_vector_boson_quark_current_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_10632", "source_line": 3786, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5147, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 4 because the card identifies production via not specified in paper, probe classes: decay or indirect probes; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "1311_5644_unified_dark_fluid_fast_transition_v1", "paper_id": "1311_5644", "source_line": 374, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5148, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via phenomenological background energy-density evolution from UDF equation of state; CMB relevance high and BBN relevance unknown; probe hooks: CMB, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_02994_gravity_portal_scalar_singlet_v1", "paper_id": "2008_02994", "source_line": 4389, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5149, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Gravity-portal scalar singlet dark matter: thermal freeze-out with gravity-portal annihilation; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes CMB.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_05881_quintuplet_three_loop_radiative_neutrino_mass_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_05881", "source_line": 2560, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 5150, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_05525_cp4_3hdm_asymmetric_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_05525", "source_line": 3665, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 149, "global_rank": 5151, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative asymmetric_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_scalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_08500_leptophilic_scalar_singlet_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2007_08500", "source_line": 4342, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5152, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Leptophilic scalar-singlet dark matter EFT as a speculative leptophilic_scalar_mediator_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via thermal freeze-out to e+e- and scalar-singlet final states in some parameter regions.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=unknown and BBN=high.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: dm_signal_not_preferred, bbn_avoidance_required."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2207_09968_valley_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_09968", "source_line": 5205, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 245, "global_rank": 5153, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, high CMB relevance, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_10093_conformal_freeze_in_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10093", "source_line": 5228, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 227, "global_rank": 5154, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0212305_stable_gravitino_sneutrino_leptogenesis_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0212305", "source_line": 454, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 5155, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "branon_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0402142_branon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0402142", "source_line": 456, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5156, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic-density support yes.", "Observational leverage is driven by mixed_cold_warm phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_3271_sequestered_susy_dark_force_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0902_3271", "source_line": 932, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 391, "global_rank": 5157, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has effective-theory structure, full relic-abundance support in the card, high cosmological relevance, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_05185_scalar_singlet_radiative_ewsb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1612_05185", "source_line": 2968, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 5158, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_singlet_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_00482_asymmetry_sharing_dim5_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1806_00482", "source_line": 3554, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 150, "global_rank": 5159, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with effective-field-theory theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_00482_asymmetry_sharing_dim6_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1806_00482", "source_line": 3555, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 151, "global_rank": 5160, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with effective-field-theory theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_06506_u1chi_seesaw_fimp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1810_06506", "source_line": 3674, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 228, "global_rank": 5161, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; nonthermal phase-space behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_00637_large_n_two_loop_sterile_neutrino_fimp_v1", "paper_id": "1812_00637", "source_line": 3669, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 229, "global_rank": 5162, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative freeze_in_dark_matter with simplified_model theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes; decay_produced phase-space behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophobic_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_7049_u1b_complex_scalar_leptophobic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_7049", "source_line": 2186, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5163, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with medium CMB relevance, and medium BBN relevance.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophobic_vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_7049_u1b_dirac_fermion_leptophobic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_7049", "source_line": 2185, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5164, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with medium CMB relevance, and medium BBN relevance.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_04354_top_specific_variant_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1507_04354", "source_line": 2583, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 308, "global_rank": 5165, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include field_like phase space.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_inert_scalar_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_02106_democratic_mixed_inert_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1611_02106", "source_line": 2957, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5166, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative mixed_inert_scalar_triplet_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_inert_scalar_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_02106_dominant_complex_mixed_inert_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1611_02106", "source_line": 2956, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5167, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative mixed_inert_scalar_triplet_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_inert_scalar_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_02106_dominant_real_mixed_inert_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1611_02106", "source_line": 2955, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5168, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative mixed_inert_scalar_triplet_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_14907_kick_alignment_pseudogoldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_14907", "source_line": 4513, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 309, "global_rank": 5169, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from field_like phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "annihilating_subkev_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_11100_nonthermal_subkev_annihilating_dcbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_11100", "source_line": 5453, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5170, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Nonthermal sub-keV annihilating dark matter for direct-collapse black-hole seeds has limited supplied theoretical scoring fields, nonthermal phase space, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inflaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0701624_inflaton_remnant_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0701624", "source_line": 42, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5171, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, field_like phase-space description, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_00631_scalar_minicharged_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1610_00631", "source_line": 2942, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5172, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative minicharged_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance high, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiation_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_07769_rdm_star_radiation_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2102_07769", "source_line": 4555, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5173, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative radiation_like_dark_matter entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization.", "Observational leverage comes from phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_4791_nearly_conformal_bubble_collision_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_4791", "source_line": 1336, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 5174, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from card-level phase-space type nonthermal.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for nonthermal_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0512081_generalised_fluxed_mssm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0512081", "source_line": 623, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 239, "global_rank": 5175, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0512081_stringy_split_susy_bino_higgsino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0512081", "source_line": 624, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 240, "global_rank": 5176, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_3334_light_neutralino_scenario_a_v1", "paper_id": "0801_3334", "source_line": 772, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 241, "global_rank": 5177, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 4.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance medium; probe classes counted: ['CMB'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_3334_light_neutralino_scenario_b_v1", "paper_id": "0801_3334", "source_line": 773, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 242, "global_rank": 5178, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 4.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: CMB relevance medium; probe classes counted: ['CMB'].", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_3464_higgsogenesis_x_sector_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_3464", "source_line": 1774, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 152, "global_rank": 5179, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 4: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, family asymmetric_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance medium; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as CMB.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 182; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "0801_2008_viscous_chaplygin_gas_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "0801_2008", "source_line": 354, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5180, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via phenomenological cosmological fluid energy-density evolution; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance unknown; probe hooks: CMB, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "0905_3632_all_dark_matter_black_holes_v1", "paper_id": "0905_3632", "source_line": 1012, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below tier3 threshold under the ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 246, "global_rank": 5181, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with raw priority score 4 (defer) using the supplied model card only; main support comes from auditable provenance and robustness.", "Card-local details considered: identity family primordial_black_holes, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and probe handles: compact objects / microlensing / dynamics.", "Score is held down by absent observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_05187_leptophilic_wimp_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1504_05187", "source_line": 2481, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5182, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, family=effective_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB relevance=medium.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: CMB.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=19, diversity_value=3.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_07609_unstable_light_scalar_kolar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_07609", "source_line": 2539, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 5183, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Unstable light scalar dark matter for Kolar events: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 4.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "1901_11006_umami_chaplygin_unified_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1901_11006", "source_line": 333, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5184, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include CMB relevance is medium.", "probe classes inferred from card fields: CMB; associated_code=unknown; warnings=high:no_microphysical_candidate.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 8/1/2/0/9/2/18."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_03259_anomaly_mediated_wino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2104_03259", "source_line": 4679, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5185, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production yes; medium BBN relevance; probe relevance for BBN.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_1781_mfv_su3q_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1105_1781", "source_line": 1300, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5186, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 15.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 4 for MFV SU(3)_Q triplet scalar dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is medium; probe hints: CMB.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_01807_torsion_effective_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2202_01807", "source_line": 71, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5187, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this modified_gravity_effective_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_sector", "model_id": "1012_4459_bulk_viscous_unified_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "1012_4459", "source_line": 31, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5188, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mimetic_modified_gravity_dark_matter", "model_id": "1803_02620_mimetic_dark_matter_dark_energy_v1", "paper_id": "1803_02620", "source_line": 205, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5189, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative mimetic_modified_gravity_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=medium, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: CMB.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: not_particle_dm, caustic_completion."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2305_10933_nec_violation_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2305_10933", "source_line": 45, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 247, "global_rank": 5190, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, medium CMB relevance, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_10609_dark_fermion_spin_one_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2008_10609", "source_line": 4350, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5191, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Dark fermion EFT with heavy spin-one mediators as a speculative effective_field_theory_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via thermal WIMP-like freeze-out through effective spin-one mediator operators.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=unknown; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: eft_validity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_particle_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_05195_complement_transition_dm_particle_production_v1", "paper_id": "2201_05195", "source_line": 148, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5192, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative gravitational_particle_production_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_particle_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_05195_constant_rate_dm_particle_production_v1", "paper_id": "2201_05195", "source_line": 146, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5193, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative gravitational_particle_production_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_particle_production_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_05195_late_transition_dm_particle_production_v1", "paper_id": "2201_05195", "source_line": 147, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5194, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative gravitational_particle_production_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_2256_nonstandard_susy_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1004_2256", "source_line": 1107, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 243, "global_rank": 5195, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization entry in supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_06810_scotogenic_orbifold_majorana_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2110_06810", "source_line": 4924, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 5196, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Scotogenic orbifold Majorana-fermion WIMP is speculative with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: no explicit probe class in the model card.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_08083_doubly_composite_high_quality_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2112_08083", "source_line": 4950, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 310, "global_rank": 5197, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Doubly composite high-quality QCD axion is speculative with uv_complete theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by unknown phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: no explicit probe class in the model card.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majorana_singlet_eft_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_5013_majorana_singlet_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1212_5013", "source_line": 1720, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5198, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_eft_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_5013_real_scalar_singlet_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1212_5013", "source_line": 1719, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5199, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_0498_classically_scale_invariant_pseudoscalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_0498", "source_line": 2122, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 5200, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: an approximate distribution treatment is available.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_17064_assisted_freezeout_two_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2103_17064", "source_line": 4673, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 184, "global_rank": 5201, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_1373_bottom_flavored_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1404_1373", "source_line": 2086, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5202, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of flavored_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "compact_object_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_09923_thermal_ball_false_vacuum_remnant_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_09923", "source_line": 5206, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5203, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, medium BBN relevance, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1203_2984_finite_temperature_bec_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1203_2984", "source_line": 286, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5204, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Finite-temperature Bose-Einstein condensate dark matter, a speculative bose einstein condensate dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and thermal phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: thermal_cloud_not_separate_species, mean_field_approximation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_07877_lepton_specific_2hdm_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_07877", "source_line": 3597, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5205, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_10152_coupling_independent_hidden_valley_dark_pions_v1", "paper_id": "1809_10152", "source_line": 3578, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 392, "global_rank": 5206, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it can supply all dark matter according to the production block.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_06297_pseudo_dirac_higgsino_singlino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_06297", "source_line": 3694, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5207, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2007_07212_clustered_pbh_dm_non_gaussian_v1", "paper_id": "2007_07212", "source_line": 276, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 248, "global_rank": 5208, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Clustered primordial black hole dark matter from non-Gaussian threshold modulation, a speculative primordial black holes entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and nonlinear halo or subhalo effects.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: warn_001."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_14211_scotogenic_hybrid_texture_t3_v1", "paper_id": "2109_14211", "source_line": 4846, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5209, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_14211_scotogenic_hybrid_texture_t4_v1", "paper_id": "2109_14211", "source_line": 4847, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5210, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_14211_scotogenic_hybrid_texture_t5_v1", "paper_id": "2109_14211", "source_line": 4848, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5211, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_singlet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_14211_scotogenic_hybrid_texture_t6_v1", "paper_id": "2109_14211", "source_line": 4849, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5212, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0609777_su2z_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0609777", "source_line": 689, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 393, "global_rank": 5213, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis, sparse-class representative; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "little_higgs_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0306161_theory_space_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0306161", "source_line": 441, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5214, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_04053_singlet_fermion_lrsm_u1b_u1l_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_04053", "source_line": 2717, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 394, "global_rank": 5215, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves a card-local full-dark-matter production route.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cannibal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_09759_spontaneously_broken_cannibal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_09759", "source_line": 5477, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5216, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Spontaneously broken cannibal real-scalar dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "two_component_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_0460_two_state_wimp_xray_line_v1", "paper_id": "1407_0460", "source_line": 2200, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5217, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with medium CMB relevance.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, computational representation is sparse, and the supplied warnings include high-severity caveats."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_5301_yukawa_unified_bino_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1206_5301", "source_line": 1610, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 244, "global_rank": 5218, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization card for Yukawa-unified bino-Higgsino LSP dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_0894_su5_1_200_bino_bulk_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1208_0894", "source_line": 1643, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 245, "global_rank": 5219, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization card for SU(5) 1+200 non-universal gaugino bulk neutralino dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_0894_su5_1_75_bino_bulk_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1208_0894", "source_line": 1642, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 246, "global_rank": 5220, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative phenomenological parameterization card for SU(5) 1+75 non-universal gaugino bulk neutralino dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_2973_z2_singlet_lepton_dark_u1d_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1208_2973", "source_line": 1623, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 395, "global_rank": 5221, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 8, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Z2-stabilized singlet vector-like lepton dark matter in a light U(1)d framework; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_3214_ewsusy_nmssm_neutralino_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "1305_3214", "source_line": 1880, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5222, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 1 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_08206_bino_wino_coannihilation_minisplit_v1", "paper_id": "1506_08206", "source_line": 2457, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5223, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, family=supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=27, diversity_value=1.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "photon_line_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_4100_resonant_photon_line_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1208_4100", "source_line": 1644, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5224, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Resonant photonic thermal dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "stringy_hidden_valley_messenger_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_5245_stringy_hidden_valley_messenger_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1210_5245", "source_line": 1640, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5225, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective field theory card for Stringy hidden-valley messenger dark matter; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with collider / fixed-target / beam dump, indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1202_0412_self_dual_black_hole_remnant_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1202_0412", "source_line": 1483, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 249, "global_rank": 5226, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable primordial_black_holes variant and records primordial production of self-dual black holes.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_11499_bl_x_vector_portal_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_11499", "source_line": 4828, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5227, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0104258_msugra_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0104258", "source_line": 395, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 247, "global_rank": 5228, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative simplified_model model; production via thermal freeze-out of the neutralino LSP; thermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: laboratory/direct detection, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_5186_higgs_lkp_ued_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1204_5186", "source_line": 1575, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5229, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because the card has a phenomenological Higgs-LKP freeze-out scenario with supported relic logic, but no card-level observables, constraints, routes, or public code are available."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_05431_light_higgsino_b_tau_qyu_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_05431", "source_line": 3017, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 248, "global_rank": 5230, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Light higgsino neutralino dark matter in b-lepton quasi-Yukawa unified 4-2-2 SUSY is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_02670_split_fermion_hadrophilic_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_02670", "source_line": 4821, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5231, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_07388_dsb_pq_mixed_wimp_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_07388", "source_line": 2467, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 185, "global_rank": 5232, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, family=multi_component_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=220, diversity_value=3.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_04143_hidden_sector_axion_portal_pwave_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_04143", "source_line": 2471, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5233, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, family=secluded_wimp_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: laboratory precision / clocks / fifth-force searches.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=7, diversity_value=4.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1604_01494_sommerfeld_invisible_annihilating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1604_01494", "source_line": 223, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5234, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative self_annihilating_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=none, and probe classes: indirect detection.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_07474_two_component_dm_heavy_scalar_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1809_07474", "source_line": 3629, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 186, "global_rank": 5235, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative multi_component_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_07474_two_component_scalar_vectorlike_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_07474", "source_line": 3628, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 187, "global_rank": 5236, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative multi_component_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermi_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_th0301216_multiflavor_fermi_ball_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0301216", "source_line": 417, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5237, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value; probe signal: compact objects.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1306_4321_electroweak_cogenesis_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1306_4321", "source_line": 1857, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 153, "global_rank": 5238, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative uv-complete model with asymmetric/baryogenesis production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 2 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_03990_constrained_nmssm_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1707_03990", "source_line": 3195, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 249, "global_rank": 5239, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 13.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 4.0: Constrained NMSSM with neutralino LSP and right-handed neutrino superfields is a speculative uv complete entry with thermal neutralino freeze-out with possible stau coannihilation, followed by late-time dilution if it is to match the observed abundance.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_05005_z2_chiral_lepton_n1_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2103_05005", "source_line": 4592, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 396, "global_rank": 5240, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes inferred from card fields: gravitational waves/topological defects.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "holographic_continuum_dark_matter", "model_id": "2208_12273_linear_dilaton_holographic_continuum_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2208_12273", "source_line": 5319, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routes, or computational support for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5241, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 7.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as defer with raw score 4.0: holographic_continuum_dark_matter with brane-to-bulk energy transfer heats the bulk; science=6.0, observational leverage=0.0, complementarity=2.0.", "Follow-up value comes from card-internal probes (indirect detection) and diversity=7.0, with provenance/robustness support=9.0.", "Lowered strongly because explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations are mostly absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higher_spin_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_07442_supersymmetric_higher_spin_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2212_07442", "source_line": 5447, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Rare model-class value is outweighed by unknown relic production, missing routes, no code, and high-severity warnings."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5242, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but distinct: the supersymmetric higher-spin sector gains diversity for rare multi-component higher-spin content, but relic and UV warnings remain severe."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_5830_general_nugm_bino_bulk_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1303_5830", "source_line": 1769, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 250, "global_rank": 5243, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 4: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 309; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_5830_one_plus_200_bino_bulk_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1303_5830", "source_line": 1768, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 251, "global_rank": 5244, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 4: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 309; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0211071_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0211071", "source_line": 442, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 252, "global_rank": 5245, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, partial computational support from associated code or calculations; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0304071_nonuniversal_sfermion_coannihilation_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0304071", "source_line": 443, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 253, "global_rank": 5246, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 13, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, partial computational support from associated code or calculations; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_08456_dirac_neutralino_mdgssm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_08456", "source_line": 4694, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 254, "global_rank": 5247, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 14.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production parameter_dependent; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_13126_type_x_2plus1hdm_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_13126", "source_line": 4957, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 5248, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative inert doublet dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and thermal annihilation and coannihilation through the extended scalar sector.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by partial associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_11718_scalar_leptoquark_vll_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_11718", "source_line": 5209, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 397, "global_rank": 5249, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 14.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative simplified model model content, partial associated-code support. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_6180_stable_exotic_wino_mdm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_6180", "source_line": 1421, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5250, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 4.0 because the card describes electroweak multiplet dark matter at effective field theory level, with thermal freeze-out of an electroweak Minimal Dark Matter triplet and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage with partial associated-code support.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_04099_compact_supersymmetry_higgsino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1511_04099", "source_line": 2612, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 5251, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Compact Supersymmetry Higgsino-like neutralino dark matter component is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for non-generic production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_04901_hidden_gauged_su3_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_04901", "source_line": 3614, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 188, "global_rank": 5252, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative multi_component_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "The card has an audit trail and assumptions, but still lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_07020_z4_scalar_fermion_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_07020", "source_line": 4998, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 189, "global_rank": 5253, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi component dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and thermal freeze-out of two coupled dark matter components.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by partial associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_04559_fermionic_pseudoscalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_04559", "source_line": 2916, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5254, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_4782_stochastic_superspace_neutralino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1003_4782", "source_line": 1094, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 5255, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model supersymmetric_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_09004_cp_in_the_dark_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_09004", "source_line": 5461, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5256, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: CP in the Dark scalar-sector dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_4918_so10_universal_gaugino_nuhm2_split_sfermion_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1402_4918", "source_line": 2134, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 255, "global_rank": 5257, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: partial associated-code support is noted, but explicit routing and benchmark support are absent, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "elko_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_1127_elko_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1401_1127", "source_line": 2014, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5258, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_05195_two_stage_inert_doublet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_05195", "source_line": 2522, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 5259, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Two-stage inert-doublet neutral-scalar dark matter subcomponent: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 4.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1505_02785_positive_deflected_amsb_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1505_02785", "source_line": 2518, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 256, "global_rank": 5260, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Positive-deflected AMSB neutralino dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 4.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_06993_bottom_philic_pseudoscalar_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_06993", "source_line": 2540, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5261, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Bottom-philic pseudoscalar portal fermionic dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 4.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2058_su5_75_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2058", "source_line": 755, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 257, "global_rank": 5262, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 4.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_3086_susy_extra_u1_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0910_3086", "source_line": 1054, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 398, "global_rank": 5263, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1503_01119_minimal_asymmetric_su2_multiplet_v1", "paper_id": "1503_01119", "source_line": 2399, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 154, "global_rank": 5264, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory and asymmetry transfer through effective operator, annihilation of symmetric component through gauge interactions production.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card is CDM-like or leaves cosmological and structure-formation effects unknown.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_05536_fermionic_5plet_minimal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1507_05536", "source_line": 2530, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5265, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Fermionic SU(2)_L 5-plet Minimal Dark Matter benchmark: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 4.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_05536_scalar_7plet_minimal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1507_05536", "source_line": 2531, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5266, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Scalar SU(2)_L 7-plet Minimal Dark Matter benchmark: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 4.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_09960_cxsm_pseudoscalar_a_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_09960", "source_line": 3250, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5267, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Complex scalar singlet pseudoscalar A dark matter is a speculative singlet_scalar_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_07956_hidden_spin_3_2_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1708_07956", "source_line": 3220, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 399, "global_rank": 5268, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension priority but not rejected: Hidden spin-3/2 dark matter is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with limited observational structure encoded in the model card, while the supplied model card has empty observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and public computational-representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_03128_left_right_scotogenic_n2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_03128", "source_line": 4487, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 400, "global_rank": 5269, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 4.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_09044_two_singlet_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_09044", "source_line": 4716, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 5270, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via thermal freeze-out of S2; Breit-Wigner enhanced annihilation near h/H scalar resonances.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 4 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_12142_split_higgsino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2105_12142", "source_line": 4705, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 5271, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support and production via thermal freeze-out WIMP production.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 4 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_0393_cxsm_two_component_scalar_singlet_v1", "paper_id": "0811_0393", "source_line": 828, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 5272, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is low/low. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1302_3936_two_loop_radiative_seesaw_multicomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1302_3936", "source_line": 1753, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 190, "global_rank": 5273, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 4: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family multi_component_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 220; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_6162_law_mcdonald_double_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_6162", "source_line": 1775, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 5274, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 4: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family higgs_portal_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: BBN relevance low; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 90; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_2337_opposite_sign_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_2337", "source_line": 2105, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 258, "global_rank": 5275, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_2337_same_sign_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_2337", "source_line": 2106, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 259, "global_rank": 5276, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_3676_nearly_degenerate_rh_neutrino_transition_moment_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_3676", "source_line": 2109, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 158, "global_rank": 5277, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_07515_composite_pngb_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1808_07515", "source_line": 3608, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 401, "global_rank": 5278, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_12920_rh_neutrino_bl_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_12920", "source_line": 3641, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 159, "global_rank": 5279, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter with uv_complete theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_03631_scoto_seesaw_wimp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1903_03631", "source_line": 3774, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5280, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 4 because the card identifies production via WIMP thermal freeze-out, inferred from the paper's WIMP terminology, thermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_07039_two_loop_dirac_neutrino_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_07039", "source_line": 3798, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 5281, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 4 because the card identifies production via thermal freeze-out of the lightest singlet Majorana fermion, p-wave annihilation through mostly s2+ charged-scalar mediation in ..., thermal phase-space treatment; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_mediated_extra_dimensional_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_02239_rs_gravity_mediated_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_02239", "source_line": 4331, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5282, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Vector gravity-mediated dark matter in warped Randall-Sundrum as a speculative gravity_mediated_extra_dimensional_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via thermal freeze-out through KK-graviton and radion mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_11207_flipped_u1_majorana_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_11207", "source_line": 4499, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5283, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 4.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0006313_right_tau_sneutrino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0006313", "source_line": 390, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 5284, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative simplified_model model; production via thermal relic abundance from early-universe annihilation with suppressed cross sections; thermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0803_4156_adjoint_su5_real_scalar_triplet_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "0803_4156", "source_line": 786, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 5285, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability yes, raw score 4.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_3958_tev_higgs_sector_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0905_3958", "source_line": 904, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5286, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, full relic-abundance support in the card, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "magnetic_dipole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1001_0579_dirac_wimp_magnetic_moment_v1", "paper_id": "1001_0579", "source_line": 1067, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5287, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model magnetic_dipole_dark_matter; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_4137_maverick_axial_vector_dirac_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1002_4137", "source_line": 1109, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5288, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory entry in effective_wimp_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_3722_rp2_universal_extra_dimensions_lkp_v1", "paper_id": "1004_3722", "source_line": 1112, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5289, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in extra_dimensional_dark_matter; the relic-production field is unknown.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_8428_scale_invariant_su2d_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1307_8428", "source_line": 1828, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 131, "global_rank": 5290, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked because the card describes a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level, can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, and phase-space type is thermal.", "Priority is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields; probe complementarity is based on no explicit probe class in observables, constraints, or routing fields and provenance/validity/assumption fields are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_4902_hosotani_scalar_left_right_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1403_4902", "source_line": 2088, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 402, "global_rank": 5291, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of hidden_sector_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_4953_csi_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_4953", "source_line": 2096, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 5292, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative uv_complete member of higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_8138_iss_tev_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1403_8138", "source_line": 2129, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5293, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "top_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_1918_top_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1404_1918", "source_line": 2100, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5294, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of top_portal_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_03116_pseudoscalar_mediator_s_channel_v1", "paper_id": "1506_03116", "source_line": 2497, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5295, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=benchmark, theory_level=simplified_model, family=simplified_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "No distinct probe class was inferred from the supplied model-card fields.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=3, diversity_value=2.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_00611_s_channel_internal_higgsstrahlung_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_00611", "source_line": 2813, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5296, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked unknown.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_07236_cp_violating_singlet_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1702_07236", "source_line": 3102, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 403, "global_rank": 5297, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of hidden_sector_dark_matter with raw score 4.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_05996_o2_pseudo_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_05996", "source_line": 3727, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5298, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because O(2) pseudo-Goldstone scalar dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card says it can produce all dark matter; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_interacting_massive_particle", "model_id": "0912_2262_gimp_kk_flavon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0912_2262", "source_line": 1057, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5299, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model gravitationally_interacting_massive_particle; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1703_09417_scotogenic_two_zero_texture_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1703_09417", "source_line": 3033, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 5300, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["One-loop radiative seesaw singlet-fermion dark matter with two-zero neutrino mass texture is ranked because it can produce the full dark-matter abundance in the card; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_03382_u1r_radiative_thdm_real_scalar_s_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_03382", "source_line": 3030, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5301, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["U(1)_R radiative two-Higgs-doublet model with real scalar S dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_05122_right_handed_neutrino_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1807_05122", "source_line": 3573, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 404, "global_rank": 5302, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 13}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_11061_light_vector_fermion_invisible_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_11061", "source_line": 3619, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5303, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative vector_mediator_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_11061_light_vector_scalar_invisible_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_11061", "source_line": 3620, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5304, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative vector_mediator_dark_matter with simplified_model theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_goldstone_scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_03333_softly_broken_u1_pseudo_goldstone_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_03333", "source_line": 3704, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5305, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Softly broken U(1) pseudo-Goldstone scalar singlet dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1908_00538_composite_su2_triplet_dark_baryon_v1", "paper_id": "1908_00538", "source_line": 3935, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "The model card does not provide explicit observables or applicable constraints.", "The model card lacks theory-to-observable routing entries."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5306, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from supplied model-card fields as a speculative composite_asymmetric_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level.", "Observational leverage is weak because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields.", "Large penalties reflect missing observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational representation.", "Priority tier is defer because the local score remains below 30 after sparsity penalties."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_07039_massive_dark_photon_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2105_07039", "source_line": 4685, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 405, "global_rank": 5307, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status emerging, theory level simplified_model, and relic production yes; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_excited_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0703128_higgs_portal_metastable_singlet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0703128", "source_line": 687, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5308, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 13.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, sparse-class representative; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_2172_hidden_gauge_glueball_heavy_pion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1411_2172", "source_line": 2285, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 406, "global_rank": 5309, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_2172_hidden_gauge_pion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1411_2172", "source_line": 2284, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 407, "global_rank": 5310, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_08984_scalar_portal_dark_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_08984", "source_line": 2703, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 408, "global_rank": 5311, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 14}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves a card-local full-dark-matter production route.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bottom_flavored_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_13619_complex_scalar_bottom_spin0_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2011_13619", "source_line": 4517, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5312, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptoquark_portal_scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_05743_scalar_singlet_leptoquark_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_05743", "source_line": 4549, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5313, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fully_flipped_3311_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_10979_fully_flipped_3311_singlet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2012_10979", "source_line": 4519, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5314, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_14732_agut_indalo_singlet_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_14732", "source_line": 4512, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 155, "global_rank": 5315, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_11303_visible_sector_llp_baryogenesis_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_11303", "source_line": 5489, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 409, "global_rank": 5316, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Visible-sector long-lived-particle baryogenesis dark matter has solid theory/motivation content, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_07733_stable_singlet_hyperpion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_07733", "source_line": 2724, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5317, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves high diversity value in the population context.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "su5_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_01605_su5_two_triplet_fermion_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_01605", "source_line": 4593, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5318, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative su5_wimp_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_10795_decaying_neutralino_hidden_sector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_10795", "source_line": 4545, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 4, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5319, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_12302_intermediate_scale_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "2011_12302", "source_line": 4533, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.8, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 5320, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.8, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium BBN relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_12302_intermediate_scale_sneutrino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "2011_12302", "source_line": 4534, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.8, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 5321, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.8, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium BBN relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_12505_scalar_fimp_sommerfeld_contact_v1", "paper_id": "2210_12505", "source_line": 5351, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 230, "global_rank": 5322, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Sommerfeld-corrected scalar FIMP contact model has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_02050_smash_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2009_02050", "source_line": 4419, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 311, "global_rank": 5323, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes post-inflationary PQ symmetry breaking, axion production from global strings and string-wall systems.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance, field like phase-space structure.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "chameleon_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_01882_chameleon_mass_varying_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_01882", "source_line": 156, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5324, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 3.5 for chameleon_dark_matter: positive factors include diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strange_quark_matter_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_05607_strange_quark_nugget_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1601_05607", "source_line": 180, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5325, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 3.5 for strange_quark_matter_dark_matter: positive factors include nonthermal phase-space behavior, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mimetic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_11666_multifield_mimetic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2108_11666", "source_line": 84, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5326, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this mimetic_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "d_matter_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0311228_intermediate_scale_ldp_wimpzilla_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0311228", "source_line": 483, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5327, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1803_07626_dbi_warp_step_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1803_07626", "source_line": 167, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 250, "global_rank": 5328, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 3.5 for primordial_black_holes: positive factors include uv_complete theory level, high CMB relevance, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_08992_bino_smuon_coannihilation_gminus2_v1", "paper_id": "2112_08992", "source_line": 5009, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 5329, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Bino-smuon coannihilation model for muon g-2 has limited supplied observational leverage, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1710_03412_tev_scale_mirage_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1710_03412", "source_line": 3321, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observational routing/constraints and has limited implementation support for extension."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5330, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with parameter dependent relic-density support.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warped_extra_dimension_dark_matter", "model_id": "0712_2455_warped_kk_parity_kk_z_lkp_v1", "paper_id": "0712_2455", "source_line": 805, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5331, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warped_extra_dimension_dark_matter", "model_id": "0712_2455_warped_kk_parity_so4_vector_kk_z_v1", "paper_id": "0712_2455", "source_line": 806, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5332, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0804_3084_neutralino_natural_light_higgs_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "0804_3084", "source_line": 825, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 5333, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is low/unknown. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1709_08699_decaying_minimal_dark_matter_quintuplet_v1", "paper_id": "1709_08699", "source_line": 3299, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the ranking rule because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5334, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative cold dark matter candidate with effective field theory theory level and parameter dependent all-DM production status.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives CDM-like or unknown structure and no explicit observables.", "The score is limited by empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card; provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, and warning fields are present.", "Priority tier is defer because the shard-local score is 3.5, below the rule threshold for tier3."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_0393_cxsm_pseudo_goldstone_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "0811_0393", "source_line": 829, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 5335, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is low/low. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_02253_resonant_wino_zreft_v1", "paper_id": "1706_02253", "source_line": 3120, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5336, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a emerging effective_field_theory member of wino_dark_matter with raw score 3.5.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_09758_dark_su2d_tt_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_09758", "source_line": 4528, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 410, "global_rank": 5337, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.2, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_10648_linear_inflection_inflaton_decay_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_10648", "source_line": 5245, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 231, "global_rank": 5338, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_10648_sextic_inflection_inflaton_decay_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_10648", "source_line": 5246, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 232, "global_rank": 5339, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_07677_qcd_axion_early_matter_domination_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_07677", "source_line": 5202, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 312, "global_rank": 5340, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, medium BBN relevance; field like phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phenomenological_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_00017_modified_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1701_00017", "source_line": 112, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5341, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative phenomenological_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and limited extracted observational structure.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_00896_alp_helical_gauge_fields_v1", "paper_id": "2012_00896", "source_line": 4515, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 313, "global_rank": 5342, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 4.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, field_like phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "astro-ph0605682_dilaton_unified_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0605682", "source_line": 120, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5343, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative scalar_field_unified_dark_matter_dark_energy card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0610056_teves_effective_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0610056", "source_line": 117, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5344, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative modified_gravity_effective_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance, field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1201_3009_gradient_axion_photon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1201_3009", "source_line": 370, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 314, "global_rank": 5345, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative effective_field_theory model; production via magneto-electric production or growth of the pseudoscalar field in an early magnetized Bianchi-I universe; CMB relevance medium and BBN relevance unknown; field_like phase-space treatment; probe hooks: CMB, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_06873_k_essence_scalar_dm_solitons_v1", "paper_id": "2001_06873", "source_line": 4175, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 5346, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of scalar_field_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include field_like phase-space information, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0105232_annihilating_superheavy_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0105232", "source_line": 376, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5347, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via nonthermal production during bubble collisions after first-order inflation; preheating after inflation; CMB relevance low and BBN relevance unknown; nonthermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: galaxy satellites/halo structure, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bose_einstein_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "2205_00297_bec_disordered_halo_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2205_00297", "source_line": 358, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5348, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via Bose-Einstein condensation of cold bosons below critical temperature; galactic halo condensation governed by Gross-Pitaevskii-Poisson dynamics; field_like phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_02092_quark_nugget_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_02092", "source_line": 2641, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 5349, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Quark nugget dark matter is marked speculative with phenomenological parameterization theory level and production support 'yes'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, limited but present observational leverage in phase-space or structure fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, nonthermal phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'nonthermal' and small-scale-power effect 'unknown'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_01018_model_i_fimp_decay_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1511_01018", "source_line": 2617, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5350, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Model I FIMP-decay nonthermal Majorana dark matter is marked speculative with effective field theory theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, limited but present observational leverage in phase-space or structure fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, decay_produced phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'decay produced' and small-scale-power effect 'unknown'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_01018_model_ii_thermal_parent_decay_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1511_01018", "source_line": 2618, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5351, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Model II thermally produced parent-decay Majorana dark matter is marked speculative with effective field theory theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, limited but present observational leverage in phase-space or structure fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, decay_produced phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'decay produced' and small-scale-power effect 'unknown'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_02867_qcd_axion_misalignment_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1511_02867", "source_line": 2644, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 315, "global_rank": 5352, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: QCD axion misalignment dark matter is marked speculative with effective field theory theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, limited but present observational leverage in phase-space or structure fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, field_like phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'field like' and small-scale-power effect 'none'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_02442_starobinsky_uv_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_02442", "source_line": 4317, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 233, "global_rank": 5353, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Starobinsky UV freeze-in dark matter as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via UV freeze-in from Standard Model scatterings.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=low; phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: eft_validity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_13451_squeezed_axion_like_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2105_13451", "source_line": 4706, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 316, "global_rank": 5354, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and production via misalignment-produced coherent field initial condition; gravitational self-squeezing after production.", "Card-local leverage comes from no explicit probe classes; the raw score is 3 after penalties for sparse observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2310_09898_vacuum_bubble_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2310_09898", "source_line": 132, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 251, "global_rank": 5355, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_06675_qcd_axion_alp_level_crossing_v1", "paper_id": "1510_06675", "source_line": 2654, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 317, "global_rank": 5356, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 338. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, decay_produced phase-space behavior.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code. High-severity warning(s) in the card add caution but do not eliminate the model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_06920_axion_gauge_complex_scalar_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "1609_06920", "source_line": 2938, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 191, "global_rank": 5357, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type field_like, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_bounce_hot_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_00632_fermi_bounce_hot_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_00632", "source_line": 131, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5358, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative fermionic_bounce_hot_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory-level support and high CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_09637_flavored_astrophobic_qcd_axion_v1", "paper_id": "1811_09637", "source_line": 3673, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 318, "global_rank": 5359, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative axion_like_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1308_1203_conformal_dark_fermion_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "1308_1203", "source_line": 1932, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Feasibility is limited by missing identified associated code or public computational support."], "family_rank": 411, "global_rank": 5360, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 3.0 because the model card is a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and touches direct detection.", "Penalty drivers: explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routing is absent; usable associated code is not identified; near-duplicate variants reduce priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "1412_4185_constant_pressure_dissipative_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1412_4185", "source_line": 221, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5361, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative unified_dark_fluid entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=scale_dependent_growth, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: structure formation.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0404286_cp_violating_cmssm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0404286", "source_line": 469, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 260, "global_rank": 5362, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_1508_nonthermal_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "0807_1508", "source_line": 847, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 5363, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked parameter_dependent, phase space is nonthermal. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1211_4676_gaugino_mediation_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1211_4676", "source_line": 1711, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 5364, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with limited observational leverage because the card has some cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation relevance but no explicit observable block.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_08503_dyonic_ksvz_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2109_08503", "source_line": 4838, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 319, "global_rank": 5365, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by field like phase-space history, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0309064_gauge_mediated_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0309064", "source_line": 470, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 5366, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0309143_pq_symmetric_nmssm_axion_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0309143", "source_line": 464, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 320, "global_rank": 5367, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by field_like phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0310142_thermal_leptogenesis_gravitino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0310142", "source_line": 495, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 5368, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including low, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_00627_dark_matter_superfluid_dbi_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1511_00627", "source_line": 2614, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 132, "global_rank": 5369, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 12.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Dark matter superfluid with conformally coupled DBI scalar is marked speculative with effective field theory theory level and production support 'yes'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, field_like phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'field like' and small-scale-power effect 'unknown'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "magnetic_dipole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_02805_composite_magnetic_dipole_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1511_02805", "source_line": 2651, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5370, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 4. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0702041_mixed_bino_wino_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0702041", "source_line": 660, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 261, "global_rank": 5371, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare production mechanism, distinct observational-probe emphasis; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1701_02544_inflationary_primordial_black_holes_all_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1701_02544", "source_line": 2949, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 252, "global_rank": 5372, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support; it can supply the full dark-matter abundance in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance high, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type not_applicable, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1706_04947_modified_schechter_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1706_04947", "source_line": 293, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 253, "global_rank": 5373, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Modified Schechter primordial black-hole dark matter mass function, a speculative primordial black holes entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: phenomenological_pbh_distribution."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2011_07283_lepton_flavour_asymmetry_pbh_v1", "paper_id": "2011_07283", "source_line": 4526, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 254, "global_rank": 5374, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance, medium BBN relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_susy_q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0404278_d_term_q_ball_decay_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0404278", "source_line": 465, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5375, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including high severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_triplet_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_06212_zero_range_wino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1611_06212", "source_line": 2951, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5376, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative electroweak_triplet_wimp_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include zreft_scope."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_09675_abelian_higgs_portal_secluded_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_09675", "source_line": 2958, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5377, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_vector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include secluded_regime_required."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_09675_su3_higgs_portal_secluded_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_09675", "source_line": 2959, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5378, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_vector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include spectrum_assumptions."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_02031_large_n_neutrino_portal_fermion_freeze_in_v1", "paper_id": "1808_02031", "source_line": 3600, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 234, "global_rank": 5379, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it can supply all dark matter according to the production block, has decay-produced phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_06214_gravitational_reheating_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_06214", "source_line": 4565, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5380, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravitationally_produced_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_06214_gravitational_reheating_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_06214", "source_line": 4564, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5381, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative gravitationally_produced_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from phase-space type is nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonlocal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_02200_p_adic_scalaron_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2201_02200", "source_line": 282, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5382, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as p-adic scalaron matter, a speculative nonlocal scalar dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and field like phase-space treatment.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: padic_abundance_missing, padic_conjectural_dm_role."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter_k_essence", "model_id": "astro-ph0703259_k_essence_unified_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0703259", "source_line": 699, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5383, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_1439_dmm_higgs_lsp_benchmark_v1", "paper_id": "1011_1439", "source_line": 1253, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 262, "global_rank": 5384, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 3 for Deflected mirage mediation Higgs LSP benchmark point: status=speculative, theory_level=benchmark_mapping, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is medium; probe hints: CMB.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1011_1439_dmm_stau_nlsp_benchmark_v1", "paper_id": "1011_1439", "source_line": 1254, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 263, "global_rank": 5385, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 3 for Deflected mirage mediation stau NLSP benchmark point: status=speculative, theory_level=benchmark_mapping, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from CMB relevance is medium; probe hints: CMB.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fourth_generation_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1206_6110_fourth_generation_parity_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1206_6110", "source_line": 1573, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5386, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Very low priority because the card marks the heavy fourth-generation neutrino as a subcomponent rather than all dark matter and supplies little routing beyond generic portal handles."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_3765_stable_fourth_generation_majorana_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1103_3765", "source_line": 1292, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 160, "global_rank": 5387, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 3 for Stable fourth-generation Majorana neutrino dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=no.", "Positive leverage comes from distribution function availability is approximate; probe hints: direct detection.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1105_4626_global_bl_singlet_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1105_4626", "source_line": 1295, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 412, "global_rank": 5388, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 3 for Global U(1)_B-L singlet-fermion dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from BBN relevance is medium; probe hints: BBN.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_11031_miracle_less_scalar_triplet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2101_11031", "source_line": 4557, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 5389, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative wimp_dark_matter entry with theory level effective_field_theory.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=low and BBN=medium.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0503072_power_law_vamp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0503072", "source_line": 25, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5390, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0510311_split_susy_higgsino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0510311", "source_line": 577, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5391, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Split-SUSY decoupled-gaugino higgsino dark matter is a speculative simplified model card in family supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0604063_su2z_shadow_fermion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0604063", "source_line": 569, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 413, "global_rank": 5392, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["SU(2)_Z shadow-fermion WIMP dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family hidden_sector_dark_matter with production described as WIMP-like hidden-sector thermal history.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_6621_axino_trilinear_rpv_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1403_6621", "source_line": 2045, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 321, "global_rank": 5393, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=yes, phase_space=unknown, and structure effect=unknown/unknown.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to BBN, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1512_03515_mild_waterfall_hybrid_inflation_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_03515", "source_line": 2636, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 255, "global_rank": 5394, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Mild-waterfall hybrid-inflation primordial-black-hole dark matter is marked speculative with phenomenological parameterization theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_1937_hidden_dipole_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1405_1937", "source_line": 2194, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 414, "global_rank": 5395, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, effective_field_theory theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with medium CMB relevance.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_1937_hidden_scalar_charge_radius_rayleigh_v1", "paper_id": "1405_1937", "source_line": 2195, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 415, "global_rank": 5396, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, effective_field_theory theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with medium CMB relevance.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_04194_lmu_ltau_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_04194", "source_line": 2925, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 5397, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low, BBN relevance low, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_03274_scalar_singlet_quadruplet_neutrino_mass_v1", "paper_id": "1609_03274", "source_line": 2907, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 67, "global_rank": 5398, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0404266_yukawa_quasi_unified_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0404266", "source_line": 493, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 5399, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including high, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_06714_hidden_scalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_06714", "source_line": 2685, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 68, "global_rank": 5400, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability yes, and family count 90. Observational leverage comes from approximate distribution information.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1004_1567_pseudo_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1004_1567", "source_line": 1072, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 5401, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative effective_field_theory inelastic_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_5193_singlet_pt_wimp_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "1108_5193", "source_line": 1346, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5402, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is increased by sparse family coverage for cold_dark_matter in the population context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "anomaly_cancelled_baryon_number_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_09116_local_baryon_number_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_09116", "source_line": 4413, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5403, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out through Z_B resonance and h_B Z_B annihilation.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_thermal_freeze_out", "model_id": "2009_14591_final_state_sommerfeld_wimp_freezeout_v1", "paper_id": "2009_14591", "source_line": 4438, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5404, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out with final-state Sommerfeld-corrected annihilation.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_03554_no_scale_su5_m5_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_03554", "source_line": 4452, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 264, "global_rank": 5405, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 3.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2110_06810_scotogenic_orbifold_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2110_06810", "source_line": 4923, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-only record remains too sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or feasibility support for near-term observational extension."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 5406, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card: Scotogenic orbifold neutral-scalar WIMP is speculative with effective_field_theory theory support.", "Observational-extension value is driven by thermal phase-space information, unknown structure-formation content, and inferred probe coverage: no explicit probe class in the model card.", "Relative strengths in this model-card-only pass: provenance.", "Main penalties: sparse model-card fields; empty observable routing; empty observables; empty applicable constraints.", "Applied a 1-point near-duplicate penalty because this paper/family has another stronger representative in the same assigned shard."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "0706_4086_bulk_viscous_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "0706_4086", "source_line": 280, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5407, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Single bulk viscous dark-sector fluid, a speculative unified dark fluid entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: phenomenological_fluid_not_particle."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_2918_higgsphobic_fermiophobic_dark_zprime_v1", "paper_id": "1403_2918", "source_line": 2077, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 416, "global_rank": 5408, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative effective_field_theory member of hidden_sector_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_model_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_3716_renormalizable_pseudoscalar_2hdm_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_3716", "source_line": 2051, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5409, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of simplified_model_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_07798_flavor_dependent_scotogenic_a1_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_07798", "source_line": 3749, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 5410, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Flavor-dependent scotogenic A1 fermion dark matter is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_00487_hybrid_ksvz_wimp_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2207_00487", "source_line": 5225, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 192, "global_rank": 5411, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support, medium CMB relevance. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "resonant_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_1450_breit_wigner_physical_pole_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0901_1450", "source_line": 940, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5412, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, distinctive or underrepresented population features, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_sector_modified_gravity", "model_id": "1002_4721_abnormally_weighting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1002_4721", "source_line": 266, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5413, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Abnormally weighting dark matter in tensor-scalar anomalous gravity, a speculative coupled dark sector modified gravity entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: not_particle_complete."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "thermal_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_6407_causal_patch_thermal_freezeout_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1304_6407", "source_line": 1797, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5414, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 3: status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, family thermal_relic_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 5; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_06554_mixed_singlet_triplet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1601_06554", "source_line": 2669, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 5415, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability yes, and family count 32. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1704_08581_loop_induced_b_l_gev_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1704_08581", "source_line": 3139, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 417, "global_rank": 5416, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of hidden_sector_dark_matter with raw score 3.0.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_01153_scotogenic_complex_yukawa_single_zero_texture_v1", "paper_id": "1812_01153", "source_line": 3659, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 5417, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0609731_degenerate_fermionic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0609731", "source_line": 150, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5418, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative fermionic_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and limited extracted observational structure.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_thermal_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_00474_dark_u1_near_threshold_thermal_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1609_00474", "source_line": 2926, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5419, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative vector_portal_thermal_relic_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1307_7999_so10_yukawa_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1307_7999", "source_line": 1896, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 265, "global_rank": 5420, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative simplified-model model with thermal freeze-out production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Probe complementarity is inferred from card-level channels touching collider / fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 0 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_0857_mirror_dark_matter_neutron_star_core_v1", "paper_id": "1005_0857", "source_line": 1156, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below 30 because observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 418, "global_rank": 5421, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 3 because the supplied card has limited observational-detail content in the supplied card, little implementation or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_05185_pseudo_dirac_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1806_05185", "source_line": 3567, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 5422, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative inelastic_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_01598_complex_singlet_pseudo_goldstone_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_01598", "source_line": 3592, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 69, "global_rank": 5423, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2210_08696_su2d_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2210_08696", "source_line": 5382, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 322, "global_rank": 5424, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because SU(2)_D pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone boson dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: direct detection, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, large penalties for missing observables, constraints, and follow-up machinery."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_neutrinophilic_dark_fermion", "model_id": "2405_20890_neutrinophilic_gluonic_dark_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2405_20890", "source_line": 6121, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after penalties for sparse supplied observational-detail fields.", "No explicit observables or theory-to-observable routing are supplied in the model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5425, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored 3 (defer) from supplied card content: effective_neutrinophilic_dark_fermion with effective_field_theory theory content and unknown all-DM production.", "Penalties (18) reflect missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation; model-limiting warnings."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_02276_scotogenic_fermion_dm_sfopt_v1", "paper_id": "2003_02276", "source_line": 4159, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 5426, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of scotogenic_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_02276_scotogenic_scalar_dm_sfopt_v1", "paper_id": "2003_02276", "source_line": 4158, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 5427, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of scotogenic_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_decaying_dark_matter_eft", "model_id": "1405_3785_millicharged_dm_gamma_line_decay_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1405_3785", "source_line": 2147, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5428, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter_eft", "model_id": "1405_3785_neutral_dm_gamma_line_decay_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1405_3785", "source_line": 2146, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5429, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitational_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_6436_scalar_gravitational_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1410_6436", "source_line": 2283, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5430, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 11.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative gravitational_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_00212_inert_complex_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_00212", "source_line": 4582, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5431, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_multiplet_dark_matter entry with theory level simplified_model.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes inferred from card fields: gravitational waves/topological defects.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 10."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_2680_t13_two_component_decaying_leptophilic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1304_2680", "source_line": 1779, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 193, "global_rank": 5432, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 3: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, family multi_component_dark_matter, and relic-production flag unknown.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: no explicit observational fields beyond sparse card metadata; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 220; computational/code fields add feasibility support; penalties are moderated by some associated-code or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0210034_nonuniversal_susy_gut_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0210034", "source_line": 460, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 266, "global_rank": 5433, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_04081_compact_susy_scherk_schwarz_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1511_04081", "source_line": 2616, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 5434, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Compact Supersymmetry Scherk-Schwarz Higgsino LSP model is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_06375_type_ii_radiative_seesaw_scalar_s_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1511_06375", "source_line": 2635, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 5435, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Type II radiative seesaw model with scalar-singlet dark matter is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0703035_bino_lsp_large_tan_beta_mssm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0703035", "source_line": 690, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 5436, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism; limited computational support; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0610402_aligned_bottom_tau_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0610402", "source_line": 611, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 5437, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0610402_reduced_bottom_tau_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0610402", "source_line": 612, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 5438, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0606134_small_mu_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0606134", "source_line": 638, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 267, "global_rank": 5439, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has comparatively strong scientific-value score from status, theory level, motivation, and relic-density relevance, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_0242_rpv_gravitino_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0903_0242", "source_line": 916, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5440, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has partial code or computational support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, distinctive or underrepresented population features, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0611185_higgs_exempt_no_scale_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0611185", "source_line": 681, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 5441, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism; limited computational support; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_3288_resonant_vector_mediator_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_3288", "source_line": 2171, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5442, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, computational representation is sparse, and the supplied warnings include high-severity caveats."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_12699_gaugino_higgs_mediation_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1811_12699", "source_line": 3663, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 268, "global_rank": 5443, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_12699_gaugino_mediation_universal_scalar_mass_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1811_12699", "source_line": 3662, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 269, "global_rank": 5444, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked yes.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "brane_world_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0512302_branon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0512302", "source_line": 604, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5445, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_6458_coy_dirac_pseudoscalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1401_6458", "source_line": 2041, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 5446, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1754_light_neutralino_nmssm_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1754", "source_line": 1318, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 270, "global_rank": 5447, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_08093_high_scale_susy_higgsino_singlino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_08093", "source_line": 2504, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 5448, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for High-scale SUSY higgsino/singlino dark matter for Higgs inflation: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 3.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_08093_high_scale_susy_wino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1504_08093", "source_line": 2503, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 5449, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for High-scale SUSY wino dark matter for Higgs inflation: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 3.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_05665_hidden_su2h_fermionic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_05665", "source_line": 2521, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 419, "global_rank": 5450, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Hidden-sector SU(2)_H fermionic dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has moderate theory or production motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 3.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2211_05794_dark_glueball_shower_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2211_05794", "source_line": 5390, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 420, "global_rank": 5451, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Dark matter annihilating to dark glueball showers has limited explicit observational leverage, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_0692_dark_left_right_model_ii_dirac_scotino_v1", "paper_id": "1002_0692", "source_line": 1070, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 421, "global_rank": 5452, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative uv_complete hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_1902_zprime_higgs_interfering_asymmetric_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1111_1902", "source_line": 1415, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 156, "global_rank": 5453, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 3.0 because the card describes asymmetric dark matter at simplified model level, with asymmetric dark matter abundance from an initial particle-antiparticle asymmetry; possible mixed particle-antiparticle component if annihilation is not strong enough and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1955_axion_mediated_doublet_singlet_pq_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1955", "source_line": 1704, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 422, "global_rank": 5454, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to strong-CP/PQ/axion.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1955_axion_mediated_doublet_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1955", "source_line": 1706, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 423, "global_rank": 5455, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to strong-CP/PQ/axion.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1209_1955_axion_mediated_pq_neutral_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1209_1955", "source_line": 1705, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 424, "global_rank": 5456, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to strong-CP/PQ/axion.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_4520_hidden_photon_dirac_fermion_toy_model_v1", "paper_id": "1212_4520", "source_line": 1712, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 425, "global_rank": 5457, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to hidden-sector structure.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_4520_susy_hidden_photon_fi_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_4520", "source_line": 1713, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 426, "global_rank": 5458, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to hidden-sector structure, supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1212_4520_susy_hidden_photon_radiative_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1212_4520", "source_line": 1714, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 427, "global_rank": 5459, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to hidden-sector structure, supersymmetric framework.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1302_4781_nmssm_bino_pseudoscalar_gamma_line_v1", "paper_id": "1302_4781", "source_line": 1795, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 271, "global_rank": 5460, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 3: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 309; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_0332_top_flavored_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1303_0332", "source_line": 1793, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5461, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 3: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family flavored_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 18; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1303_1087_mfv_scalar_flavoured_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1303_1087", "source_line": 1754, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5462, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 3: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, family flavored_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 18; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_0966_vector_higgs_portal_u1x_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1304_0966", "source_line": 1778, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 428, "global_rank": 5463, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 3: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, family hidden_sector_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: CMB relevance low; BBN relevance low; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 506; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_6058_type_iii_two_higgs_doublet_darkon_v1", "paper_id": "1304_6058", "source_line": 1794, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 5464, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 3: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, family higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter, and relic-production flag yes.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: BBN relevance low; transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type thermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 51; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_6141_higgs_portal_z2_scalar_flat_potential_v1", "paper_id": "1404_6141", "source_line": 2104, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 5465, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_mediated_extra_dimensional_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_02239_rs_gravity_mediated_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_02239", "source_line": 4330, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5466, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Fermion gravity-mediated dark matter in warped Randall-Sundrum as a speculative gravity_mediated_extra_dimensional_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via thermal freeze-out through KK-graviton and radion mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_mediated_extra_dimensional_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_02239_rs_gravity_mediated_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_02239", "source_line": 4329, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5467, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Scalar gravity-mediated dark matter in warped Randall-Sundrum as a speculative gravity_mediated_extra_dimensional_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via thermal freeze-out through KK-graviton and radion mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_04052_hidden_u1h_axion_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_04052", "source_line": 4319, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 194, "global_rank": 5468, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Hidden U(1)_H axion and inert-scalar dark matter model as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via thermal freeze-out of X_D through d-wave dominated annihilation to charged leptons.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0304074_minimal_so10_susy_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0304074", "source_line": 421, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 272, "global_rank": 5469, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides uv complete theory support; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_1398_minimal_direct_gauge_mediation_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_1398", "source_line": 2066, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5470, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of supersymmetric_gravitino_dark_matter; abundance capability marked parameter_dependent; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_0406_charged_scalar_extended_singlet_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1404_0406", "source_line": 2090, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 70, "global_rank": 5471, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of higgs_portal_dark_matter; abundance capability marked yes; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_6033_dirac_mediator_inert_scalar_three_loop_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_6033", "source_line": 2064, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 5472, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides emerging uv_complete member of radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter; abundance capability marked unknown; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudo_nambu_goldstone_dark_matter", "model_id": "1901_09751_u1_sn_pseudo_goldstone_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1901_09751", "source_line": 3736, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5473, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Softly broken U(1) x S_N pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone Higgs-portal dark matter is a speculative simplified model candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_04063_nrvf_darkon_unified_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2006_04063", "source_line": 89, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5474, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this unified_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and limited explicit observational content.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_06184_pq_nelson_barr_scotogenic_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2010_06184", "source_line": 4455, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5475, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 3.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_0849_z2_real_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0901_0849", "source_line": 931, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 71, "global_rank": 5476, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, full relic-abundance support in the card, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_3125_inert_higgs_wwstar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1003_3125", "source_line": 1100, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 5477, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: benchmark uv_complete inert_doublet_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_5350_scalar_neutrino_asymmetric_dm_triplets_v1", "paper_id": "1111_5350", "source_line": 1420, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 157, "global_rank": 5478, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 3.0 because the card describes asymmetric dark matter at uv complete level, with asymmetric production from scalar triplet decays tied to leptogenesis; annihilation through neutralino exchange reduces the symmetric sneutrino abundance and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "grand_unified_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_02184_so10_remnant_z2_dirac_triplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_02184", "source_line": 2663, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5479, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability yes, and family count 4. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1808_01598_abelian_vector_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1808_01598", "source_line": 3593, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 5480, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative vector_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_06039_z2_inverse_seesaw_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_06039", "source_line": 3582, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 429, "global_rank": 5481, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_3934_residual_z2_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1104_3934", "source_line": 1293, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 5482, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 3 for Residual Z2 scalar dark matter from a TeV U(1) gauge model: status=speculative, theory_level=uv_complete, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1410_6157_uv_freeze_in_contact_operator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1410_6157", "source_line": 2275, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 235, "global_rank": 5483, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a emerging freeze_in_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and unknown phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_04467_pgm_bl_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1507_04467", "source_line": 2584, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5484, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative cold_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cp_violating_bino_stau_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0505160_cp_violating_bino_stau_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0505160", "source_line": 581, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5485, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["CP-violating bino-stau coannihilation dark matter is a speculative simplified model card in family cp_violating_bino_stau_coannihilation_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out with bino-sfermion coannihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cp_violating_bino_stop_coannihilation_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0505160_cp_violating_bino_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0505160", "source_line": 582, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5486, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["CP-violating bino-stop coannihilation dark matter is a speculative simplified model card in family cp_violating_bino_stop_coannihilation_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out with bino-sfermion coannihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_07521_extended_two_inert_higgs_neutrino_portal_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_07521", "source_line": 2599, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 158, "global_rank": 5487, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 12.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bottom_flavored_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_13619_real_scalar_bottom_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2011_13619", "source_line": 4518, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5488, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fully_flipped_3311_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_10979_fully_flipped_3311_triplet_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2012_10979", "source_line": 4520, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5489, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_01999_z2_scalar_331_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_01999", "source_line": 4600, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5490, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_portal_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Diversity value is boosted by a sparse registry family count of 10."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_sextet_baryon_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0510034_qcd_s_sextet_neutron_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0510034", "source_line": 572, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 3.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5491, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 10.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["QCD_S sextet-neutron cold dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family composite_sextet_baryon_dark_matter with production described as early-universe sextet neutron-antineutron production.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_15522_gauged_lmu_ltau_maximal_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_15522", "source_line": 4404, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 133, "global_rank": 5492, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out, N1/N2 co-annihilation.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_06640_two_component_peak_spectrum_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_06640", "source_line": 2576, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 195, "global_rank": 5493, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory level; score-relevant card features include nonthermal phase space.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_04336_axion_bec_dimer_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_04336", "source_line": 191, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 323, "global_rank": 5494, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 2.5 for axion_like_dark_matter: positive factors include parameter-dependent relic-density viability, field_like phase-space behavior, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_baryonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0301578_p_matter_baryonic_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0301578", "source_line": 452, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5495, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_07366_higgs_portal_pidm_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "2003_07366", "source_line": 4177, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 236, "global_rank": 5496, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of freeze_in_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include nonthermal phase-space information.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_01000_pev_leptophilic_three_body_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1507_01000", "source_line": 2556, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 5497, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative decaying_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory level; score-relevant card features include nonthermal phase space.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_09014_baryonic_model_2a_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_09014", "source_line": 4485, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 159, "global_rank": 5498, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for asymmetric_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from nonthermal phase-space history.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 2.5."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ghost_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0409241_ghost_condensate_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0409241", "source_line": 476, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5499, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by field_like phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including high severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1907_05042_nonminimal_derivative_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1907_05042", "source_line": 168, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 256, "global_rank": 5500, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 2.5 for primordial_black_holes: positive factors include effective_field_theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic-density viability, high CMB relevance, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2008_00327_hst_primordial_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_00327", "source_line": 163, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 257, "global_rank": 5501, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 2.5 for primordial_black_holes: positive factors include parameter-dependent relic-density viability, high CMB relevance, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_01931_r2_majorana_x_particle_v1", "paper_id": "2002_01931", "source_line": 4153, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5502, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18.5, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of superheavy_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include medium CMB relevance, 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_05989_scalar_cascade_annihilation_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_05989", "source_line": 2591, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 430, "global_rank": 5503, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory level; score-relevant card features include medium CMB relevance.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_01587_vector_like_wimp_effective_interactions_v1", "paper_id": "1509_01587", "source_line": 2593, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5504, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative effective_field_theory_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory level; score-relevant card features include medium CMB relevance.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_12283_bound_state_assisted_even_simp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_12283", "source_line": 5979, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 134, "global_rank": 5505, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from self_interacting_dark_matter: Bound-state-assisted even-numbered SIMP dark matter has moderate model/theory value through thermal freeze-out through bound-state-assisted self-depletion, even-numbered SIMP interactions involving bound states, optional bound-state catalysis of odd-numbered 3 to 2 SIMP processes; inferred probe classes are no explicit probe classes.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "phenomenological_dark_fluid_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0410503_van_der_waals_dark_matter_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0410503", "source_line": 184, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5506, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 2.5 for phenomenological_dark_fluid_dark_matter: positive factors include carded ability to supply all dark matter, medium CMB relevance, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2203_05509_2hdms_complex_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2203_05509", "source_line": 5049, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 72, "global_rank": 5507, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Type-II 2HDM plus complex scalar singlet dark matter has probe classes: laboratory/particle, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1208_3162_two_scalar_radiative_neutrino_z2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1208_3162", "source_line": 1638, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5508, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative uv complete card for Two-scalar radiative neutrino model with a Z2-odd thermal relic candidate; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_02336_scalar_fermion_multicomponent_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1706_02336", "source_line": 3162, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 196, "global_rank": 5509, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 2.5: Scalar-fermion multicomponent semi-annihilating dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with chi S -> chi h.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_02336_z3_singlet_doublet_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1706_02336", "source_line": 3160, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5510, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 2.5: Z_3 singlet-doublet scalar semi-annihilating dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with DM DM -> h DM*.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_02336_z3_singlet_scalar_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1706_02336", "source_line": 3159, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5511, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 2.5: Z_3 complex singlet scalar semi-annihilating dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with S S -> S* h.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_02336_z4_two_component_scalar_v1", "paper_id": "1706_02336", "source_line": 3161, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 197, "global_rank": 5512, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 2.5: Z_4 singlet-doublet two-component semi-annihilating scalar dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with semi-annihilation among Z_4-charged scalar components.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: indirect detection.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_09349_type_ii_seesaw_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2001_09349", "source_line": 4186, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 5513, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of scalar_singlet_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include limited explicit observable structure in the card.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_05554_scnmssm_light_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2002_05554", "source_line": 4189, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 273, "global_rank": 5514, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include limited explicit observable structure in the card.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_3881_multipartite_dm_scenario_a_v1", "paper_id": "0711_3881", "source_line": 794, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 198, "global_rank": 5515, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 2.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_3881_multipartite_dm_scenario_b_v1", "paper_id": "0711_3881", "source_line": 795, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 199, "global_rank": 5516, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 2.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_3881_multipartite_dm_scenario_c_v1", "paper_id": "0711_3881", "source_line": 796, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 200, "global_rank": 5517, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 2.5.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_4868_multicomponent_axial_vector_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1406_4868", "source_line": 2204, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 201, "global_rank": 5518, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "No distinct probe classes were explicit enough to score complementarity.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_4868_multicomponent_scalar_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1406_4868", "source_line": 2203, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 202, "global_rank": 5519, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with limited model-card-only scientific scoring.", "The card lacks explicit observables and has little structure-formation leverage in the supplied fields.", "No distinct probe classes were explicit enough to score complementarity.", "Feasibility is low because computational representation, benchmarks, and observable routes are not supplied.", "Model-only omissions of observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the penalties; no global elimination statement is present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_05515_multicomponent_zn_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1911_05515", "source_line": 4130, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 203, "global_rank": 5520, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 2.5: speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: no explicit probe routing objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_05149_spin32_scalar_tchannel_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1705_05149", "source_line": 3114, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 5521, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of wimp_dark_matter with raw score 2.5.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_06782_inflaton_modified_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_06782", "source_line": 2595, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 5522, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "1701_00780_interacting_dm_de_two_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1701_00780", "source_line": 160, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5523, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 2.5 for interacting_dark_sector: positive factors include emerging status, carded ability to supply all dark matter, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_11178_higgs_portal_spectator_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1705_11178", "source_line": 3155, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.5, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5524, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 2.5: Higgs-portal spectator scalar dark matter for stochastic Higgs stabilization is a speculative simplified model entry with Higgs-portal cold dark matter production not computed in detail in the paper.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: no explicit probe routing.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2108_00652_quark_nugget_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2108_00652", "source_line": 4801, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.2, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5525, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_04618_field_fluid_interacting_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2006_04618", "source_line": 4333, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5526, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 5, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Field-fluid interacting dark energy-dark matter model as a speculative interacting_dark_sector_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and production via phenomenological late-time interacting dark-sector evolution.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=unknown; phase-space type field_like; structure-formation entries transfer=scale_dependent_growth and small-scale effect=unknown.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: not_particle_dm_card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_13577_interacting_two_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2008_13577", "source_line": 128, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 204, "global_rank": 5527, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative multi_component_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_03831_instant_preheating_heavy_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_03831", "source_line": 5220, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 237, "global_rank": 5528, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_0753_bose_einstein_condensate_boson_dm_de_v1", "paper_id": "1411_0753", "source_line": 133, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 66, "global_rank": 5529, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2306_17577_multiverse_supermassive_pbh_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "2306_17577", "source_line": 143, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 258, "global_rank": 5530, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_04092_flat_bottomed_axion_landscape_v1", "paper_id": "1608_04092", "source_line": 2924, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 324, "global_rank": 5531, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type field_like, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_10453_clockwork_linear_dilaton_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_10453", "source_line": 4500, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 238, "global_rank": 5532, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Diversity credit comes from nonthermal phase-space history.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 2.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "tachyonic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_06772_tachyonic_black_hole_flow_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1601_06772", "source_line": 247, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5533, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative tachyonic_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: none explicitly identified.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code.", "Additional penalty applied for high-severity card warnings: tachyon_source_assumption."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_12923_scalar_graviton_dark_substance_v1", "paper_id": "1811_12923", "source_line": 3676, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5534, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 4.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative modified_gravity_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory-level support.", "Useful signals: field_like phase-space behavior; high model-card diversity value from population-count rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_01334_stable_sexaquark_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2201_01334", "source_line": 4978, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 5535, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative composite dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and statistical equilibrium in the quark-gluon plasma.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by limited explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inflationary_dark_matter_production", "model_id": "2303_02464_warm_inflation_dark_matter_creation_v1", "paper_id": "2303_02464", "source_line": 145, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5536, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 7, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative inflationary_dark_matter_production card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warm_dark_matter", "model_id": "1401_7132_semidegenerate_fermion_halo_core_v1", "paper_id": "1401_7132", "source_line": 17, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 5537, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_4468_dark_neutrino_quantum_environment_v1", "paper_id": "1411_4468", "source_line": 2322, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because observational-detail fields are sparse in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 161, "global_rank": 5538, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as defer with score 2 because the assigned model card phenomenological parameterization sterile_neutrino_dark_matter card; has limited cosmological, phase-space, or structure-formation leverage; uses nonthermal phase-space information.", "Main penalties come from no explicit observables field, no explicit constraints field, no theory-to-observable routes, no computational-representation block in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "electroweak_scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_05054_dileptonic_scalar_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "2010_05054", "source_line": 4420, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5539, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out through electroweak triplet annihilation.", "Observational leverage comes from high CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_02050_pq_u1x_ksvz_axion_v1", "paper_id": "2006_02050", "source_line": 4343, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 325, "global_rank": 5540, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes PQ U(1)_X KSVZ-type axion model with vector-like fermions as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via PQ symmetry breaking followed by standard axion cold-dark-matter production, with the paper not specifying a detailed....", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type field_like.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_05762_axion_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_05762", "source_line": 5201, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 326, "global_rank": 5541, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative effective field theory model content, mixed cold warm phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0404568_kev_singlet_fermion_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0404568", "source_line": 468, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 162, "global_rank": 5542, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0311240_kev_singlet_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0311240", "source_line": 455, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 163, "global_rank": 5543, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including low, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "0902_4710_nonadiabatic_viscous_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "0902_4710", "source_line": 271, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 5544, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Non-adiabatic viscous dark fluid, a speculative unified dark fluid entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and scale dependent growth transfer behavior.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: vdf_not_particle_dm."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_16876_local_z2_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_16876", "source_line": 4306, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 5545, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Light local-Z_2 fermion inelastic dark matter as a speculative inelastic_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via standard thermal freeze-out.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=medium; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: s_wave_channels_must_be_closed."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_16876_local_z2_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_16876", "source_line": 4305, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 5546, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Light local-Z_2 scalar inelastic dark matter as a speculative inelastic_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via standard thermal freeze-out.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=medium and BBN=medium; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: requires_open_dark_higgs_channel."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_06534_energy_momentum_portal_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_06534", "source_line": 4326, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 239, "global_rank": 5547, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Energy-momentum portal vector dark matter as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via UV freeze-in from Standard Model thermal-bath scattering.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: uv_freeze_in_sensitivity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0611278_warped_gauge_axion_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0611278", "source_line": 665, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 327, "global_rank": 5548, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; distinct phase-space or transfer behavior, sparse-class representative; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_1259_scotogenic_h0_wimp_fimp_decay_v1", "paper_id": "1405_1259", "source_line": 2155, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 205, "global_rank": 5549, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with mixed_cold_warm phase-space entry.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_01362_ohe_composite_dark_atom_v1", "paper_id": "2011_01362", "source_line": 4473, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 5550, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for composite_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 2.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2012_02817_double_field_bubble_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2012_02817", "source_line": 4510, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 259, "global_rank": 5551, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from high CMB relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "ultralight_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0105564_complex_scalar_halo_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0105564", "source_line": 387, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5552, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 9.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative effective_field_theory model; production via classical self-gravitating Bose-condensate halo configuration; field_like phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0208023_superstring_metastable_relic_uhecr_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0208023", "source_line": 449, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5553, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0210062_screened_charged_fermi_ball_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0210062", "source_line": 490, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5554, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including high, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0212332_stable_neutral_fermi_ball_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0212332", "source_line": 478, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5555, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 3 model-card warning(s), including high, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "string_gas_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0401037_massive_string_mode_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0401037", "source_line": 485, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5556, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_dark_matter", "model_id": "1310_7064_decaying_domain_wall_fragment_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1310_7064", "source_line": 140, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5557, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative topological_defect_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by phenomenological diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_3785_typicality_spread_susy_wino_lsp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_3785", "source_line": 2164, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 5558, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with mixed_cold_warm phase-space entry.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, computational representation is sparse, and the supplied warnings include high-severity caveats."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_00631_fermion_minicharged_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1610_00631", "source_line": 2943, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5559, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative minicharged_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance high, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_00482_light_phi2_asymmetry_sharing_v1", "paper_id": "1806_00482", "source_line": 3558, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 160, "global_rank": 5560, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability, has decay-produced phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_08610_dirac_neutrino_portal_boosted_dark_sector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_08610", "source_line": 3594, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5561, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative neutrino_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it is presented as a subcomponent rather than all dark matter, has nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_baryon_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_02603_dark_neutron_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2201_02603", "source_line": 4962, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5562, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative dark baryon dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and primordial dark baryon abundance from early-universe chemical equilibrium with Standard Model states.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "black_hole_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0210016_nonsingular_black_hole_relic_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0210016", "source_line": 458, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5563, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including high severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_2426_stochastic_superspace_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0809_2426", "source_line": 823, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 274, "global_rank": 5564, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, production is marked parameter_dependent, CMB/BBN relevance is medium/unknown. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0304080_light_neutralino_effmssm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0304080", "source_line": 415, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 275, "global_rank": 5565, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting; probe signal: cmb.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0508285_cp_violating_mssm_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0508285", "source_line": 568, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 276, "global_rank": 5566, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["CP-violating MSSM neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out of neutralino dark matter through pair annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0510311_partly_susy_light_higgsino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0510311", "source_line": 578, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5567, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Partly-SUSY light higgsino dark matter is a speculative effective field theory card in family supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0410352_strongly_coupled_higgsino_wino_bino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0410352", "source_line": 563, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 277, "global_rank": 5568, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Strongly coupled Higgsino-Wino-Bino neutralino dark matter is a speculative simplified model card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out of the lightest neutralino.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance; probe classes: CMB.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2212_00156_high_temperature_qcd_transition_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_00156", "source_line": 5444, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["High-severity abundance-assumption warning plus missing observables, constraints, routing, and code make extension premature."], "family_rank": 260, "global_rank": 5569, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: high-temperature QCD-transition PBH dark matter is distinctive, but strong assumption warnings and sparse observable/computational details dominate."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kaluza_klein_dark_matter", "model_id": "0706_3409_spinless_photon_6dsm_v1", "paper_id": "0706_3409", "source_line": 696, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5570, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family; limited computational support; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_14904_singlet_scalar_vll_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2007_14904", "source_line": 4403, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 5571, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out, coannihilation with vector-like fermions.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_14904_singlet_scalar_vlq_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2007_14904", "source_line": 4402, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 5572, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out, coannihilation with vector-like fermions.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05759_hidden_qcd_composite_baryon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05759", "source_line": 2680, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 431, "global_rank": 5573, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability unknown, and family count 506. Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code. High-severity warning(s) in the card add caution but do not eliminate the model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_03554_no_scale_su5_m4_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_03554", "source_line": 4451, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 278, "global_rank": 5574, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 2.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_03554_no_scale_su5_m6_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_03554", "source_line": 4453, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 279, "global_rank": 5575, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Some observational leverage is present through cosmological relevance, phase-space behavior, or structure-formation fields for supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 2.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_14009_complex_scalar_singlet_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2103_14009", "source_line": 4676, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 161, "global_rank": 5576, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level simplified_model, and relic production yes; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0210389_z2_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0210389", "source_line": 477, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 5577, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0402215_fat_higgs_anomaly_mediation_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0402215", "source_line": 467, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 280, "global_rank": 5578, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium BBN relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_0551_dark_compact_ultra_dense_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1110_0551", "source_line": 1435, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5579, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 2.0 because the card describes macroscopic dark matter at phenomenological parameterization level, with primordial formation of gravitationally self-bound compact objects from TeV-scale dark matter and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_07243_momentum_dependent_adm_scalar_pseudoscalar_v1", "paper_id": "1512_07243", "source_line": 2679, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 162, "global_rank": 5580, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability yes, and family count 182. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_08895_hidden_baryonic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_08895", "source_line": 2668, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 432, "global_rank": 5581, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 506. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "atomic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_05766_atomic_dark_matter_mirror_stars_v1", "paper_id": "2112_05766", "source_line": 4977, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5582, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative atomic dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and atomic dark matter subcomponent assumed.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by limited explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "resonant_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "0901_1450_breit_wigner_unphysical_pole_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "0901_1450", "source_line": 941, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5583, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, distinctive or underrepresented population features, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_zprime_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_7691_kinetically_mixed_zprime_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_7691", "source_line": 2190, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5584, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with approximate distribution-function support.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_zprime_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_7691_kinetically_mixed_zprime_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_7691", "source_line": 2191, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5585, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability with approximate distribution-function support.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_3574_so5_u1_gauge_higgs_dark_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1407_3574", "source_line": 2197, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 433, "global_rank": 5586, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with medium CMB relevance.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter_fluid", "model_id": "1104_0442_collisional_relativistic_dm_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1104_0442", "source_line": 275, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5587, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Collisional relativistic dark matter fluid cosmology, a speculative self interacting dark matter fluid entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: warn_001."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_10777_resonant_abelian_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1705_10777", "source_line": 3182, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 135, "global_rank": 5588, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 2.0: Resonant Abelian vector dark matter is a speculative simplified model entry with thermal resonant freeze-out through an s-channel scalar mediator.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: no explicit probe routing.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_08053_subgev_hidden_sector_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_08053", "source_line": 4541, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 434, "global_rank": 5589, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium BBN relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_00612_heavy_scalar_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_00612", "source_line": 2468, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 73, "global_rank": 5590, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, family=higgs_portal_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: collider / fixed-target / beam dump, direct detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=90.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1411_6344_inert_doublet_septet_mixing_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1411_6344", "source_line": 2358, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5591, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_multiplet_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes: collider, direct detection.", "Priority is held down by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and full computational-representation support in the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_6817_intermediate_scale_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1205_6817", "source_line": 1562, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 281, "global_rank": 5592, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because it is a broad neutralino phenomenological parameterization with standard thermal mechanisms but no explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or implementation support in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_5027_effective_hooperon_c2_scalar_quark_v1", "paper_id": "1403_5027", "source_line": 2112, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5593, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule.", "High-severity model-card warning(s) reduce robustness for observational-extension prioritization."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_5027_effective_hooperon_c6_scalar_gluon_v1", "paper_id": "1403_5027", "source_line": 2113, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5594, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule.", "High-severity model-card warning(s) reduce robustness for observational-extension prioritization."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_5027_effective_hooperon_d2_dirac_scalar_quark_v1", "paper_id": "1403_5027", "source_line": 2114, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5595, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule.", "High-severity model-card warning(s) reduce robustness for observational-extension prioritization."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_5027_effective_hooperon_d4_dirac_scalar_quark_v1", "paper_id": "1403_5027", "source_line": 2115, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5596, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule.", "High-severity model-card warning(s) reduce robustness for observational-extension prioritization."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_operator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1403_5027_effective_hooperon_d7_dirac_vector_quark_v1", "paper_id": "1403_5027", "source_line": 2116, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5597, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule.", "High-severity model-card warning(s) reduce robustness for observational-extension prioritization."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_08195_7kev_sterile_neutrino_dw_fraction_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_08195", "source_line": 2473, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 164, "global_rank": 5598, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, family=sterile_neutrino_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: indirect detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=170, diversity_value=3.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_08195_pev_scalar_x_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_08195", "source_line": 2472, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the raw score is below 30 after model-card-local missing-detail penalties."], "family_rank": 240, "global_rank": 5599, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, family=freeze_in_dark_matter.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card has no explicit observables and mostly CDM-like or unknown structure fields.", "Probe-class complementarity was inferred from model-card portal/cosmology/structure fields: indirect detection.", "Diversity credit uses population context only: family_count=249, diversity_value=3.", "Penalized for absent observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation blocks in this model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_04000_gauge_singlet_vector_like_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1702_04000", "source_line": 3015, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 435, "global_rank": 5600, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Gauge-singlet vector-like fermion hidden-sector dark matter is ranked because it has parameter-dependent relic-abundance viability; has auditable provenance, assumptions, validity notes, and warnings.", "Priority is limited because observables are absent; constraint lists are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; implementation support is limited."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dipole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_05185_pseudo_dirac_dipole_v1", "paper_id": "1806_05185", "source_line": 3568, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5601, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative dipole_dark_matter entry with effective-field-theory theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_4183_dynamical_dark_matter_collider_ensemble_v1", "paper_id": "1204_4183", "source_line": 1576, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension priority after model-card-local scoring; not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 206, "global_rank": 5602, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Very low priority because the card is an unusual multi-component ensemble scenario, but it is broad, not a unique Lagrangian model, and lacks usable observational routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_00382_bi_trinification_wimp_dark_sector_v1", "paper_id": "2212_00382", "source_line": 5405, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Unknown relic viability, no supplied observables or routing, and severe missing-calculation warnings make extension premature."], "family_rank": 436, "global_rank": 5603, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked: the UV-complete bi-trinification dark sector is distinctive, but relic production is unknown and the card warns that WIMP-like production was not computed in detail."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higher_spin_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_07442_bosonic_higher_spin_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_07442", "source_line": 5445, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Unknown relic calculation, no supplied observables/routes/constraints, no code, and high-severity warnings make follow-up low priority."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5604, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked despite rare higher-spin diversity: the card focuses on direct-detection spin phenomenology, but relic production is unknown and UV consistency warnings are severe."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higher_spin_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_07442_fermionic_higher_spin_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_07442", "source_line": 5446, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Unknown relic calculation, no supplied observables/routes/constraints, no code, and high-severity warnings make follow-up low priority."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5605, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked despite rare higher-spin diversity: the fermionic higher-spin card has direct-detection motivation but no relic calculation or route details in the supplied fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0304108_su5_200plet_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0304108", "source_line": 448, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 282, "global_rank": 5606, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, partial computational support from associated code or calculations; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, a high-severity card warning."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_09303_stop_higgsino_bino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1609_09303", "source_line": 2904, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 283, "global_rank": 5607, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0610006_u1_residual_z2_right_handed_neutrino_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0610006", "source_line": 609, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 5608, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has limited positive support beyond basic model identity, provenance, and relic-density context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0605024_scherk_schwarz_higgsino_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0605024", "source_line": 637, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 284, "global_rank": 5609, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has limited positive support beyond basic model identity, provenance, and relic-density context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0501265_high_mu_wino_split_susy_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0501265", "source_line": 650, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5610, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has limited positive support beyond basic model identity, provenance, and relic-density context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_0242_rpv_bino_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0903_0242", "source_line": 917, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5611, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has partial code or computational support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, distinctive or underrepresented population features, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_06267_neutrino_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_06267", "source_line": 2910, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5612, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative neutrino_portal_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_model_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_08958_spin_3_2_s_channel_vector_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_08958", "source_line": 2901, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5613, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 8.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_08314_2hdms_complex_singlet_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2301_08314", "source_line": 5495, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 437, "global_rank": 5614, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: 2HDM plus complex scalar singlet WIMP has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_0242_rpv_sneutrino_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0903_0242", "source_line": 918, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5615, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has partial code or computational support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, distinctive or underrepresented population features, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_3326_singlet_weyl_higgs_portal_relic_v1", "paper_id": "1312_3326", "source_line": 2011, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 74, "global_rank": 5616, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=simplified_model, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_2636_hidden_photon_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_2636", "source_line": 1406, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 438, "global_rank": 5617, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 15.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 2.0 because the card describes hidden sector dark matter at simplified model level, with thermal annihilation mediated by the hidden photon and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_3440_heavy_higgs_portal_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0801_3440", "source_line": 769, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 439, "global_rank": 5618, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability yes, raw score 2.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0802_0506_lup_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0802_0506", "source_line": 784, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 440, "global_rank": 5619, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability parameter_dependent, raw score 2.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1005_1655_gev_hidden_sector_adm_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1005_1655", "source_line": 1083, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 163, "global_rank": 5620, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative effective_field_theory asymmetric_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_2636_supersymmetric_hidden_sector_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_2636", "source_line": 1407, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 441, "global_rank": 5621, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 2.0 because the card describes hidden sector dark matter at simplified model level, with hidden-sector annihilation and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1302_2614_subdominant_inert_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1302_2614", "source_line": 1749, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 5622, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to baryogenesis/cogenesis, phase-transition/nonstandard history.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonabelian_hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_08153_dark_su2_nonabelian_kinetic_mixing_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_08153", "source_line": 4311, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5623, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Dark SU(2)_D fermion dark matter with non-Abelian kinetic mixing as a speculative nonabelian_hidden_sector_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via thermal freeze-out through dark-sector gauge annihilation.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0104258_so10_dterm_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0104258", "source_line": 397, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 285, "global_rank": 5624, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative uv_complete model; production via thermal freeze-out of the neutralino LSP; thermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_3957_real_triplet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0811_3957", "source_line": 913, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5625, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0902_4050_conformal_bl_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0902_4050", "source_line": 915, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 5626, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_4823_inert_scalar_doublet_high_mass_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0905_4823", "source_line": 908, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5627, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dipolar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_1979_majorana_transition_dipolar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0906_1979", "source_line": 911, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5628, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has effective-theory structure, full relic-abundance support in the card, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1003_1276_5d_cmssm_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1003_1276", "source_line": 1118, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 286, "global_rank": 5629, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory entry in supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter; the relic-production field is parameter dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1006_5916_type_i_msism_h2_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1006_5916", "source_line": 1131, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 5630, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter; the relic-production field is unknown.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "1210_3617_irreversible_dark_energy_dark_matter_creation_v1", "paper_id": "1210_3617", "source_line": 339, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied ranking rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing fields are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5631, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production_can_produce_all_dark_matter=parameter_dependent; observational features include few explicit observational handles are present.", "associated_code=unknown; warnings=medium:fluid_not_freezeout.", "Score limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; components sci/obs/comp/feas/prov/div/pen = 7/0/0/0/9/3/17."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_2996_inert_doublet_type_ii_seesaw_v1", "paper_id": "1404_2996", "source_line": 2131, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 442, "global_rank": 5632, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_04435_baryonic_leptophobic_zprime_anomalon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_04435", "source_line": 2516, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 443, "global_rank": 5633, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Baryonic leptophobic Z prime anomalon dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; it has solid theory/relic motivation in the supplied fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 2.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_06101_cxsm_type_b_c_single_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_06101", "source_line": 2826, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5634, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_10914_unitarised_fermionic_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1812_10914", "source_line": 3734, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5635, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Unitarised fermionic Higgs-portal dark matter EFT is a speculative effective field theory candidate with the card gives parameter-dependent relic production; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_02103_local_baryon_number_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_02103", "source_line": 4982, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 444, "global_rank": 5636, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and thermal freeze-out through Z_B and scalar-mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2206_04066_charged_kerr_newman_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2206_04066", "source_line": 5214, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 261, "global_rank": 5637, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_06324_eft_dimension6_v1", "paper_id": "2206_06324", "source_line": 5239, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5638, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative effective field theory model content. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "brane_world_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0301009_low_tension_branon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0301009", "source_line": 444, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5639, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting, moderate diversity value; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_00100_lepton_flavored_majorana_dm_dual_scalar_mediators_v1", "paper_id": "1510_00100", "source_line": 2661, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5640, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 4. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_07872_su2r_quintuplet_bminusl_0_v1", "paper_id": "1510_07872", "source_line": 2657, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5641, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability yes, and family count 23. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_bremsstrahlung_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_01105_fermionic_dm_pseudoscalar_dark_isr_v1", "paper_id": "1705_01105", "source_line": 3130, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5642, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of dark_bremsstrahlung_dark_matter with raw score 2.0.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 2.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dark_bremsstrahlung_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_01105_fermionic_dm_vector_dark_isr_v1", "paper_id": "1705_01105", "source_line": 3131, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5643, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of dark_bremsstrahlung_dark_matter with raw score 2.0.", "Diversity value is boosted by sparse or distinctive family/production/phase-space context; population family count is 2.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00753_model1_real_scalar_fermion_singlet_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00753", "source_line": 3141, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5644, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with raw score 2.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00753_model2_real_scalar_fermion_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00753", "source_line": 3142, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5645, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with raw score 2.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00753_model3_real_scalar_mixed_singlet_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00753", "source_line": 3143, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5646, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with raw score 2.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_01686_extended_scalar_singlet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_01686", "source_line": 3577, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 75, "global_rank": 5647, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_00490_scotogenic_majorana_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1811_00490", "source_line": 3678, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 5648, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative scotogenic_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_02689_cwld_gravitational_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1912_02689", "source_line": 4134, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 445, "global_rank": 5649, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 2.0: speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: no explicit probe routing objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2002_07517_susy_422_yu_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2002_07517", "source_line": 4154, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 5650, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of neutralino_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include limited explicit observable structure in the card.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_14759_composite_higgs_self_interacting_pngb_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_14759", "source_line": 4999, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 136, "global_rank": 5651, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self interacting dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and thermal freeze-out through pNGB dark matter annihilation into light pNGB singlets.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0603545_elko_mass_dimension_one_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0603545", "source_line": 292, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 446, "global_rank": 5652, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Elko mass-dimension-one fermion dark matter, a speculative hidden sector dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and limited explicit observational leverage in the card.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: astro-ph0603545_warn_1."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0612228_slim_scalar_mev_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0612228", "source_line": 676, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5653, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare family, rare production mechanism, sparse-class representative; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_2562_type_ii_seesaw_rpv_gravitino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0903_2562", "source_line": 924, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5654, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has UV-complete theory level, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1001_3149_composite_electroweak_neutral_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1001_3149", "source_line": 1078, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5655, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative phenomenological_parameterization composite_asymmetric_dark_matter; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1006_5916_type_ii_msism_maximal_scpv_h2_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1006_5916", "source_line": 1132, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 5656, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete entry in higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter; the relic-production field is unknown.", "Observational leverage is driven by no explicit observational-leverage fields beyond the base model-card metadata, while the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields are present; feasibility credit is limited by associated-code status unknown and no benchmark or computational-representation block."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1102_0013_gauge_yukawa_unified_422_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1102_0013", "source_line": 1269, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 5657, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 2 for Gauge-Yukawa unified 4-2-2 neutralino dark matter: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=yes.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "discrete_symmetry_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_3592_a4_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_3592", "source_line": 2159, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5658, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_01699_deflected_amsb_mixed_bino_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1602_01699", "source_line": 2749, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 287, "global_rank": 5659, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_08520_dark_pion_massive_mediator_secluded_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_08520", "source_line": 2909, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 5660, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative composite_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_01673_cp_violating_inert_three_higgs_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_01673", "source_line": 2933, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5661, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative inert_scalar_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low, BBN relevance none, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_complex_scalar_wimp", "model_id": "1609_06555_mixed_complex_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1609_06555", "source_line": 2913, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5662, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative mixed_complex_scalar_wimp entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2212_14037_delayed_fopt_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2212_14037", "source_line": 5493, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 262, "global_rank": 5663, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Delayed-vacuum-transition primordial black hole dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_00041_u1d_vector_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_00041", "source_line": 5491, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 5664, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Classically scale-invariant U(1)_D vector Higgs-portal dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_04513_dark_photon_resonant_simp_dark_pions_v1", "paper_id": "2301_04513", "source_line": 5455, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5665, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Dark-photon-assisted resonant SIMP dark pion dark matter has limited supplied theoretical scoring fields, high diversity value in the batch/population context, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_1218_natural_susy_dfsz_axino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1407_1218", "source_line": 2149, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5666, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative uv_complete model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule.", "High-severity model-card warning(s) reduce robustness for observational-extension prioritization."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_02336_dark_su3_vector_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1706_02336", "source_line": 3163, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 447, "global_rank": 5667, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 2.0: Dark SU(3) vector semi-annihilating dark matter is a speculative uv complete entry with coupled Boltzmann evolution of A^1=A^2 and A^3.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: no explicit probe routing.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strangeon_macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1708_03908_strangeon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1708_03908", "source_line": 12, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5668, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, high diversity value in a sparse or distinctive registry class; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_07587_dbrane_dirac_dm_kk_lepton_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2112_07587", "source_line": 4994, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5669, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative extra dimensional leptophilic dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and thermal annihilation freeze-out through KK lepton-number vectors.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "kk_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0601161_ued_kk_neutrino_dipole_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0601161", "source_line": 586, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5670, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["UED KK-neutrino dark matter with induced magnetic dipole moment is a speculative effective field theory card in family kk_neutrino_dark_matter with production described as thermal relic production of the first KK-neutrino LKP.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0604154_two_component_kk_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0604154", "source_line": 565, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 207, "global_rank": 5671, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 12}, "ranking_rationale": ["Two-component KK hypercharge boson and KK right-handed-neutrino dark matter in 6D UED is a speculative uv complete card in family multi_component_dark_matter with production described as thermal relic freeze-out through early-universe annihilation of KK modes.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgson_dark_matter", "model_id": "2104_11715_higgson_h0_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2104_11715", "source_line": 4675, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 2, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5672, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level phenomenological_parameterization, and relic production parameter_dependent; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2209_14305_minimal_vector_like_connector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2209_14305", "source_line": 5359, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.8, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, and usable code/computational support."], "family_rank": 448, "global_rank": 5673, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked because Minimal vector-like connector fermion dark matter has limited explicit observational leverage, probe classes: direct detection, no populated routing, benchmark, code, or computational-representation support, large penalties for missing observables, constraints, and follow-up machinery."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fermionic_absorption_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_01940_scalar_mediator_fermionic_absorption_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_01940", "source_line": 4432, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5674, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 7.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes production through the fermionic absorption operator after SM neutrino decoupling, unspecified nonthermal abundance mechanism outside the thermal relic paradigm.", "Observational leverage comes from high BBN relevance, high CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_15214_gravitational_portal_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_15214", "source_line": 4985, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 241, "global_rank": 5675, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and gravitational freeze-in from SM thermal bath.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_15214_gravitational_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_15214", "source_line": 4984, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 242, "global_rank": 5676, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and gravitational freeze-in from SM thermal bath.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2009_01728_accreting_lognormal_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_01728", "source_line": 4414, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 263, "global_rank": 5677, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes collapse of sizeable overdensities in radiation domination, lognormal PBH mass function from a curvature-power-spectrum peak.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_12774_hidden_scalar_decaying_dm_curvature_v1", "paper_id": "2112_12774", "source_line": 4953, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 449, "global_rank": 5678, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and gravitational production in the early universe.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by no associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_14261_vector_dilaton_portal_uv_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_14261", "source_line": 4959, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 243, "global_rank": 5679, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and ultraviolet freeze-in from SM annihilation through the dilaton portal.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_16460_aetherically_active_axionic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2401_16460", "source_line": 188, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 328, "global_rank": 5680, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 1.5 for axion_like_dark_matter: positive factors include uv_complete theory level, field_like phase-space behavior, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_05668_vector_biportal_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2112_05668", "source_line": 5023, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5681, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Vector biportal Dirac dark matter with light and heavy mediators has probe classes: laboratory/particle, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_0551_dark_compact_ultra_dense_bag_v1", "paper_id": "1110_0551", "source_line": 1436, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 5682, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 1.5 because the card describes composite dark matter at phenomenological parameterization level, with dark-quark matter formation during a dark-confining phase transition; density fluctuations becoming progenitors of gravitationally self-bound compact objects and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "0809_3196_decaying_neutralino_hidden_u1_v1", "paper_id": "0809_3196", "source_line": 849, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 5683, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_04537_general_u1x_dirac_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2011_04537", "source_line": 4421, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5684, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out of a vector-portal WIMP.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1312_2597_disformal_dark_d_brane_dimps_v1", "paper_id": "1312_2597", "source_line": 164, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 450, "global_rank": 5685, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 1.5 for hidden_sector_dark_matter: positive factors include simplified_model theory level, parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mimetic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_08575_mimetic_horndeski_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1506_08575", "source_line": 187, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5686, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 1.5 for mimetic_dark_matter: positive factors include effective_field_theory theory level, parameter-dependent relic-density viability, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1705_05149_spin32_vector_tchannel_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1705_05149", "source_line": 3115, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 5687, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of wimp_dark_matter with raw score 1.5.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_04371_ihd_two_sector_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_04371", "source_line": 4426, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5688, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes asymmetric production from CP-violating N_1 decays into the dark sector, two-sector leptogenesis with sphaleron conversion of visible lepton asymmetry.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "heavy_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0505059_fourth_family_heavy_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0505059", "source_line": 592, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5689, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Fourth-family heavy neutrino in walking technicolor is a speculative uv complete card in family heavy_neutrino_dark_matter with production described as not specified; the paper identifies a stable weakly interacting cold dark matter candidate but does not compute its production.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_10365_alternative_bl_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_10365", "source_line": 4542, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 165, "global_rank": 5690, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 10.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_02658_massive_graviton_bec_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1509_02658", "source_line": 149, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 451, "global_rank": 5691, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1702_04759_z2_two_loop_dm_messenger_models_v1", "paper_id": "1702_04759", "source_line": 3082, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Low model-card-only priority score, primarily from missing observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 5692, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 5, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry with theory level unknown and production ability unknown.", "Observational leverage comes from mostly CDM-like or unspecified observational structure; inferred probe classes: collider/fixed-target, indirect detection.", "Penalized for absent model-comparison, explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational-representation fields in the model-only card; provenance, validity domain, assumptions, and warnings are present."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_00399_majorana_sidm_zprime_v1", "paper_id": "1609_00399", "source_line": 2905, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 137, "global_rank": 5693, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance medium, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_00399_scalar_sidm_zprime_v1", "paper_id": "1609_00399", "source_line": 2906, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 138, "global_rank": 5694, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance medium, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_04559_mimetic_fr_gravity_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1511_04559", "source_line": 178, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5695, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 1.0 for modified_gravity_dark_matter: positive factors include effective_field_theory theory level, medium CMB relevance, field_like phase-space behavior, diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_09226_condensed_qcd_axion_infall_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_09226", "source_line": 3685, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 329, "global_rank": 5696, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative axion_like_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; field_like phase-space behavior; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_04138_hidden_scalar_condensate_dark_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2202_04138", "source_line": 5031, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 452, "global_rank": 5697, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Hidden scalar condensate dark-portal model has probe classes: laboratory/particle, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_6524_baryon_tied_self_interacting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1311_6524", "source_line": 2018, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 139, "global_rank": 5698, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=phenomenological_parameterization, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=unknown, phase_space=unknown, and structure effect=unknown/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_3685_metaspin_scalarino_dirishonic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1304_3685", "source_line": 1781, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 5699, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored defer with raw score 1: status speculative, theory level unknown, family composite_dark_matter, and relic-production flag parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage comes from model-card fields: transfer function cdm_like; phase-space type nonthermal; complementarity probes counted as no distinct probe classes from supplied observable/routing fields.", "Diversity uses population-count context for family count 35; no usable routes, benchmarks, or code support are listed; large penalties reflect empty observables, constraints, routing, and/or computational support in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_4462_mlsom_ultralight_axi_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "0905_4462", "source_line": 905, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 330, "global_rank": 5700, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has effective-theory structure, field-like phase-space character, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonthermal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_08477_flooded_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1509_08477", "source_line": 2619, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5701, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Flooded Dark Matter is marked speculative with phenomenological parameterization theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism, nonthermal phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'nonthermal' and small-scale-power effect 'unknown'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_06534_energy_momentum_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_06534", "source_line": 4325, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 244, "global_rank": 5702, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Energy-momentum portal Dirac fermion dark matter as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via UV freeze-in from Standard Model thermal-bath scattering.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: uv_freeze_in_sensitivity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_06534_energy_momentum_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_06534", "source_line": 4324, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 245, "global_rank": 5703, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Energy-momentum portal scalar dark matter as a speculative freeze_in_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via UV freeze-in from Standard Model thermal-bath scattering.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type nonthermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: uv_freeze_in_sensitivity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0611278_warped_scalar_axion_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0611278", "source_line": 664, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 331, "global_rank": 5704, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; distinct phase-space or transfer behavior; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_11377_hidden_su2x_quintet_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_11377", "source_line": 4530, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 453, "global_rank": 5705, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0411548_axion_bubble_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0411548", "source_line": 509, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, and computational-representation metadata are sparse in the supplied model card.", "High-severity model-card warning reduces confidence for observational-extension prioritization."], "family_rank": 332, "global_rank": 5706, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current priority but not rejected because Axion dark-matter bubble model for intrinsically faint quasars is a speculative effective field theory card with unknown relic-density treatment; it has phase-space or structure-formation leverage (field like; small-scale effect unknown); explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational representation are sparse in the card; high-severity card warnings limit confidence."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "q_ball_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0404278_new_type_q_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0404278", "source_line": 466, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5707, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by nonthermal phase-space/production character.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including high severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_03527_partially_n2_susy_sbino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_03527", "source_line": 2932, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 5708, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type mixed_cold_warm, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_11647_disformal_scalar_fimp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2011_11647", "source_line": 4521, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 246, "global_rank": 5709, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from nonthermal phase space.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_04836_pbh_u1_superheavy_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2112_04836", "source_line": 4980, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 454, "global_rank": 5710, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden sector dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and Hawking evaporation of ultralight primordial black holes.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by decay produced phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "tachyon_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0409064_tachyonic_clot_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0409064", "source_line": 105, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5711, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative tachyon_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory-level support and field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cannibal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_11046_real_scalar_cannibal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2206_11046", "source_line": 5234, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable.", "Validity-domain information is empty, adding local penalty under the ranking rule."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5712, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 7.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative simplified model model content, nonthermal phase-space behavior, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0711_3528_mev_millicharged_hidden_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "0711_3528", "source_line": 811, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 455, "global_rank": 5713, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model, production is marked no, CMB/BBN relevance is medium/unknown. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1606_01271_active_dark_matter_disk_v1", "paper_id": "1606_01271", "source_line": 57, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 208, "global_rank": 5714, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this multi_component_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and explicit nonlinear structure comment.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "0912_1143_dark_energy_decay_dm_creation_v1", "paper_id": "0912_1143", "source_line": 14, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 5715, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, medium CMB relevance, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_13057_singlet_extended_scotogenic_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_13057", "source_line": 4430, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5716, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out, coannihilation of inert-doublet components.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_08621_inelastic_u1x_dark_photon_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_08621", "source_line": 5227, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 456, "global_rank": 5717, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative simplified model model content, medium CMB relevance. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_06471_plasma_hidden_sector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_06471", "source_line": 2683, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 457, "global_rank": 5718, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 506. Observational leverage comes from approximate distribution information.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_04709_fermionic_pseudoscalar_rsidm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_04709", "source_line": 3654, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 140, "global_rank": 5719, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative self_interacting_dark_matter with simplified_model theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; medium CMB relevance.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_scalar_portal_wimp", "model_id": "2006_01149_conformal_light_scalar_portal_dirac_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2006_01149", "source_line": 4336, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5720, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Conformal light-scalar portal Dirac WIMP as a speculative light_scalar_portal_wimp model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via thermal freeze-out through conformal light-scalar mediated interactions.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=low and BBN=low; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: eft_scale_misuse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_scalar_portal_wimp", "model_id": "2006_01149_disformal_light_scalar_portal_dirac_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2006_01149", "source_line": 4337, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5721, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Disformal light-scalar portal Dirac WIMP as a speculative light_scalar_portal_wimp model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via thermal freeze-out through disformal light-scalar interactions.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=low and BBN=low; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: disformal_eft_cutoff."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_scalar_portal_wimp", "model_id": "2006_01149_disformal_light_scalar_portal_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2006_01149", "source_line": 4338, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5722, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Disformal light-scalar portal scalar WIMP as a speculative light_scalar_portal_wimp model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via thermal freeze-out via s-wave disformal scalar-DM annihilation.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=low and BBN=low; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: eft_cutoff."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_6481_two_component_transition_edm_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_6481", "source_line": 2181, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 209, "global_rank": 5723, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with approximate distribution-function support.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_08277_self_interacting_scalar_dm_light_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1608_08277", "source_line": 2941, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 141, "global_rank": 5724, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it can supply the full dark-matter abundance in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low, BBN relevance medium, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_04748_gauged_z3_self_interacting_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1610_04748", "source_line": 2927, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 142, "global_rank": 5725, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_11847_dark_su2_z3_z2_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_11847", "source_line": 5478, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 210, "global_rank": 5726, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Dark SU(2) -> Z3 x Z2 two-component dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fourth_generation_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0310006_su4_fourth_generation_neutrino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0310006", "source_line": 498, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5727, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including high, low severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "lepton_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_12524_minimal_lepton_portal_majorana_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2301_12524", "source_line": 5473, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5728, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Minimal lepton-portal Majorana fermion dark matter has limited supplied theoretical scoring fields, medium CMB relevance, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_09867_nonholomorphic_mssm_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_09867", "source_line": 5001, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value from this model-only card: structured observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent or incomplete."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5729, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: Non-holomorphic MSSM higgsino dark matter has probe classes: laboratory/particle; moderate diversity value, but the model-only card lacks structured observables, constraints, and observable-routing entries. This keeps current observational-extension priority in the defer band rather than triggering elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1205_0007_complex_scalar_higgs_portal_box_v1", "paper_id": "1205_0007", "source_line": 1606, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observational, constraint, routing, or computational support for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5730, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified model card for Complex scalar Higgs-portal dark matter box example; it offers mostly CDM-like or underspecified observational behavior with indirect detection.", "Score is limited because the supplied card has empty observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routing and computational representation fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1102_1522_thdm_ii_darkon_v1", "paper_id": "1102_1522", "source_line": 1272, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 5731, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score 1 for Two-Higgs-doublet model with a darkon: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "Positive leverage comes from probe hints: collider.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2101_07812_excursion_set_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_07812", "source_line": 4589, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 264, "global_rank": 5732, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization.", "Observational leverage comes from probe classes inferred from card fields: compact-object/PBH probes.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2102_03610_usr_non_gaussian_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_03610", "source_line": 4591, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 265, "global_rank": 5733, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with theory level phenomenological_parameterization.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=low and BBN=unknown.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0010112_s0_light_gluino_baryon_self_interacting_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0010112", "source_line": 379, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 143, "global_rank": 5734, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative uv_complete model; production via thermal freeze-out after early-universe equilibrium with nucleons; thermal phase-space treatment; probe hooks: galaxy dynamics/self-interaction, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0404025_cp_phase_higgs_pole_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0404025", "source_line": 475, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 288, "global_rank": 5735, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 6.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_7759_three_component_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_7759", "source_line": 2162, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5736, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, phenomenological_parameterization theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, computational representation is sparse, and the supplied warnings include high-severity caveats."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_7759_two_component_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_7759", "source_line": 2161, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5737, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, phenomenological_parameterization theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, computational representation is sparse, and the supplied warnings include high-severity caveats."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_00073_invisible_dark_photon_light_dm_running_v1", "paper_id": "1509_00073", "source_line": 2529, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 458, "global_rank": 5738, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Invisible dark photon light dark matter with running U(1)_d coupling: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; its scientific score is limited by missing or weak model-comparison/relic fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 1.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1605_04043_extended_gravity_dilaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1605_04043", "source_line": 2808, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5739, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_11082_mssm_bino_like_neutralino_resonance_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_11082", "source_line": 3635, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 289, "global_rank": 5740, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with benchmark_mapping theory support and parameter_dependent abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_16221_blmssm_lightest_sneutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2010_16221", "source_line": 4435, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 5741, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out, self-annihilation of the lightest scalar neutrino.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0104258_nonuniversal_higgs_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0104258", "source_line": 396, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 290, "global_rank": 5742, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative simplified_model model; production via thermal freeze-out of the neutralino LSP; thermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_0122_leptophilic_u1_model_a_v1", "paper_id": "0903_0122", "source_line": 944, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5743, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2006_01319_extended_higgs_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2006_01319", "source_line": 4316, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 166, "global_rank": 5744, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Extended Higgs sterile-neutrino dark matter model as a speculative sterile_neutrino_dark_matter model with uv_complete theory level and production via sterile-neutrino production through the extended scalar/sterile sector.", "The card gives little explicit observational leverage beyond the general model description.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_05811_z3_fermionic_rhn_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2206_05811", "source_line": 5250, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5745, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative effective field theory model content. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_06324_sterile_pseudodirac_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2206_06324", "source_line": 5240, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5746, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative simplified model model content. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_01656_leptophilic_majorana_inert_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "2207_01656", "source_line": 5242, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5747, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative simplified model model content. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0801_3686_natural_susy_mev_hidden_sector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0801_3686", "source_line": 770, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 459, "global_rank": 5748, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, relic viability yes, raw score 1.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_4010_real_scalar_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "0903_4010", "source_line": 948, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5749, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_4823_higher_su2_scalar_multiplet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0905_4823", "source_line": 909, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5750, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_1902_two_higgs_interfering_asymmetric_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1111_1902", "source_line": 1416, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 164, "global_rank": 5751, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 1.0 because the card describes asymmetric dark matter at effective field theory level, with asymmetric dark matter abundance from an initial particle-antiparticle asymmetry; possible mixed particle-antiparticle component if annihilation is not strong enough and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_06851_m_theory_inspired_nmssm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_06851", "source_line": 2630, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 5752, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: M-theory inspired super-natural NMSSM dark matter is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_07872_su2r_quintuplet_bminusl_4_v1", "paper_id": "1510_07872", "source_line": 2659, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5753, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 23. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_09247_z3_scalar_singlet_semi_annihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1511_09247", "source_line": 2601, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 5754, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Z3 scalar singlet semi-annihilating dark matter is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'yes'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majorana_fermion_wimp", "model_id": "1512_01991_extended_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_01991", "source_line": 2623, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5755, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Extended Majorana fermionic dark matter case is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare family in population context, non-generic production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majorana_fermion_wimp", "model_id": "1512_01991_neutralino_like_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_01991", "source_line": 2621, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5756, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Neutralino-like Majorana fermionic dark matter case is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare family in population context, non-generic production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "majorana_fermion_wimp", "model_id": "1512_01991_reduced_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_01991", "source_line": 2622, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5757, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Reduced Majorana fermionic dark matter case is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare family in population context, non-generic production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05779_dark_qcd_5plus5_g_odd_pion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05779", "source_line": 2693, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 29, "global_rank": 5758, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 35. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05779_dark_qcd_8plus1plus1_g_odd_pion_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05779", "source_line": 2694, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 30, "global_rank": 5759, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 35. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_06687_inert_triplet_singlet_like_bosonic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_06687", "source_line": 2675, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5760, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 3. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_00602_pseudoscalar_mediated_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_00602", "source_line": 2688, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5761, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 2. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_06374_complex_scalar_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_06374", "source_line": 2676, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5762, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 2. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1806_08080_scalar_assisted_singlet_doublet_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1806_08080", "source_line": 3564, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5763, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter entry with uv-complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic viability.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_08254_self_interacting_fermionic_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1809_08254", "source_line": 3580, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 165, "global_rank": 5764, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it has limited observable detail in the supplied model card.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_04709_dark_pion_p_wave_rsidm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_04709", "source_line": 3656, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 144, "global_rank": 5765, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative self_interacting_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_04709_dark_pion_s_wave_rsidm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_04709", "source_line": 3655, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 145, "global_rank": 5766, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative self_interacting_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_12291_so_nf5_neutralino_like_composite_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_12291", "source_line": 4369, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 5767, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as SO(N) N_F=5 neutralino-like anomaly-matched composite dark matter: WIMP-like thermal freeze-out of neutralino-like mixed states; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes no explicit probe classes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2103_15430_su5_missing_partner_bino_lsp_stop_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "2103_15430", "source_line": 4661, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 291, "global_rank": 5768, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level uv_complete, and relic production yes; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_08393_lmu_ltau_simp_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_08393", "source_line": 4976, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 146, "global_rank": 5769, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self interacting dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and thermal SIMP freeze-out through 3-to-2 scatterings.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0701156_sm_darkon_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0701156", "source_line": 697, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5770, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0701156_thdm_iii_darkon_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0701156", "source_line": 698, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5771, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "light_hidden_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_3177_light_hidden_fermion_ovr_eft_v1", "paper_id": "0910_3177", "source_line": 1055, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5772, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative effective_field_theory light_hidden_fermion_dark_matter; above-average diversity value in this population context.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_higgs_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_6374_partially_composite_majorana_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1406_6374", "source_line": 2163, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5773, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, effective_field_theory theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05786_z2_singlet_scalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05786", "source_line": 2713, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 460, "global_rank": 5774, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves parameter-dependent relic production.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_06101_cxsm_type_a_two_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_06101", "source_line": 2825, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5775, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic production marked parameter_dependent.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_04698_njl_composite_pseudoscalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_04698", "source_line": 2919, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5776, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative composite_higgs_portal_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support; it can supply the full dark-matter abundance in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "mixed_complex_scalar_wimp_with_majorana_mediator", "model_id": "1609_06555_majorana_mediator_mixed_complex_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1609_06555", "source_line": 2914, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5777, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative mixed_complex_scalar_wimp_with_majorana_mediator entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_majorana_wimp_simplified_model", "model_id": "1611_07494_majorana_leptophilic_scalar_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_07494", "source_line": 2946, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5778, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative leptophilic_majorana_wimp_simplified_model entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00753_model1a_complex_scalar_fermion_singlet_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00753", "source_line": 3144, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5779, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with raw score 1.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00753_model2a_complex_scalar_fermion_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00753", "source_line": 3145, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 5780, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with raw score 1.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00753_model3a_complex_scalar_mixed_singlet_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00753", "source_line": 3146, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5781, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with raw score 1.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_10577_quartic_superfluid_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_10577", "source_line": 5487, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 147, "global_rank": 5782, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Quartic self-interacting superfluid scalar dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_13268_bulk_black_hole_linear_dilaton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_13268", "source_line": 5459, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5783, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Linear-dilaton brane-world bulk black hole dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_07070_inert_charged_higgs_scotogenic_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_07070", "source_line": 5479, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 5784, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Inert charged-Higgs scotogenic scalar dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0408296_rpv_split_susy_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0408296", "source_line": 559, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 292, "global_rank": 5785, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["R-parity-violating split-supersymmetry neutralino dark matter is a speculative uv complete card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production described as neutralino LSP relic abundance in split supersymmetry, with the paper noting contributions from gravitino decay/scattering and neutralino annihilation when region I is interpreted as dark matter.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_bino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_00283_qdee_heavy_bino_mssm4g_v1", "paper_id": "1608_00283", "source_line": 2912, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5786, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_bino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_bino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_00283_que_heavy_bino_mssm4g_v1", "paper_id": "1608_00283", "source_line": 2911, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5787, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_bino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2102_05317_extended_nmssm_singlino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2102_05317", "source_line": 4579, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 293, "global_rank": 5788, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from cosmology fields list CMB=low and BBN=low.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "geometric_quasiparticle_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_14158_weakly_interacting_geometric_particles_v1", "paper_id": "2206_14158", "source_line": 274, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5789, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Weakly interacting geometric particles, a speculative geometric quasiparticle dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and limited explicit observational leverage in the card.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: cutoff_sensitivity, quasiparticle_interpretation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_00041_su2d_vector_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2301_00041", "source_line": 5492, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 5790, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 11.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Classically scale-invariant SU(2)_D vector Higgs-portal dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "technicolor_composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0703266_minimal_walking_technicolor_majorana_dg_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0703266", "source_line": 674, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5791, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare family, rare production mechanism, sparse-class representative; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "non_topological_soliton_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0412070_vacuum_gauge_ball_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0412070", "source_line": 558, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5792, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Vacuum gauge ball soliton dark matter candidate is a speculative uv complete card in family non_topological_soliton_dark_matter with production described as formation of a false-vacuum/domain-wall soliton in a finite-density fermion system.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavor_symmetry_stabilized_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_10619_a4_residual_z2_a1_dm_stability_v1", "paper_id": "1811_10619", "source_line": 3687, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5793, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative flavor_symmetry_stabilized_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: high model-card diversity value from population-count rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavor_symmetry_stabilized_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_10619_a4_residual_z2_a2_dm_stability_v1", "paper_id": "1811_10619", "source_line": 3688, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5794, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative flavor_symmetry_stabilized_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: high model-card diversity value from population-count rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_00445_large_macroscopic_dark_matter_pearls_v1", "paper_id": "2012_00445", "source_line": 4523, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.8, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5795, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.8, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_00445_small_macroscopic_dark_matter_pearls_v1", "paper_id": "2012_00445", "source_line": 4524, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.8, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5796, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 5.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.8, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is boosted by a rare or phenomenologically distinctive family/production/phase-space combination in the population counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.8, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_14261_fermion_dilaton_portal_uv_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_14261", "source_line": 4960, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 247, "global_rank": 5797, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and ultraviolet freeze-in from SM annihilation through the dilaton portal.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_14261_scalar_dilaton_portal_uv_freeze_in_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_14261", "source_line": 4958, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 248, "global_rank": 5798, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative freeze in dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and ultraviolet freeze-in from SM annihilation through the dilaton portal.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "nonstandard_cosmology_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0302159_quintessential_neutralino_relic_enhancement_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0302159", "source_line": 453, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5799, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high BBN relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including high, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_0158_mpcp_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1406_0158", "source_line": 2179, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 5800, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with approximate distribution-function support.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00709_modified_axial_anomalous_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00709", "source_line": 3134, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5801, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of zprime_mediated_dark_matter with raw score 0.5.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_6709_minimal_dark_minimal_flavor_violation_v1", "paper_id": "1405_6709", "source_line": 2177, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5802, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with approximate distribution-function support.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, computational representation is sparse, and the supplied warnings include high-severity caveats."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1311_6823_composite_higgsino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1311_6823", "source_line": 2013, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after model-card-only scoring, mainly because supplied observables, constraints, and observable-routing fields are empty."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5803, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 14, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as speculative with theory_level=effective_field_theory, production can_produce_all_dark_matter=unknown, phase_space=thermal, and structure effect=none/cdm_like.", "Current observational-extension priority is defer because probe evidence is limited to no explicit probe class in the supplied observables/routing fields, while supplied observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty; associated_code=unknown and provenance/validity fields provide the main audit support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_00173_minimal_composite_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2008_00173", "source_line": 4416, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5804, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal and derivative-interaction annihilation channels.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1109_3747_exciting_dark_matter_light_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1109_3747", "source_line": 1419, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 5805, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of 0.5 because the card describes inelastic dark matter at simplified model level, with thermal freeze-out through annihilation into light dark mediators and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_02689_cwld_gravitational_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1912_02689", "source_line": 4133, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 461, "global_rank": 5806, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 0.5: speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: no explicit probe routing objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1912_02689_cwld_gravitational_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1912_02689", "source_line": 4132, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card lacks explicit observable, constraint, and routing objects for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 462, "global_rank": 5807, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 0.5: speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory support and relic-density support marked parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by card-local features: limited explicit observational structure in the card; inferred probe classes: no explicit probe routing objects.", "Score is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing objects are absent in this model-card-only assignment.", "Provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are populated enough for auditable first-pass ranking."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_08471_nmssm_singlino_lsp_squark_z_excess_v1", "paper_id": "1507_08471", "source_line": 2579, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 5808, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "d_matter_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0311228_tev_ldp_thermal_d_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0311228", "source_line": 484, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5809, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including low severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_scalar_gravity_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_03696_gravity_portal_singlet_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1603_03696", "source_line": 2734, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5810, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked low but not rejected because the supplied card preserves auditable provenance and validity-domain text.", "Score limited because observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; observable routing is absent; card sparsity/severe caveats dominate the penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "geometric_vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_06577_geometric_vector_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2001_06577", "source_line": 4170, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5811, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of geometric_vector_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include limited explicit observable structure in the card.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Diversity credit reflects a comparatively distinctive family, production history, phase-space behavior, or dominant probe class in the population context.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "brane_world_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0510399_massive_branon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0510399", "source_line": 585, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5812, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Massive branon dark matter with one-loop branon radiative corrections is a speculative effective field theory card in family brane_world_dark_matter with production described as thermal WIMP-like relic abundance of stable massive branons.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0309434_decaying_particle_reionization_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0309434", "source_line": 491, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 5813, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 4, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by high CMB relevance; high BBN relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_04924_higgs_r2_z2_scalar_preheating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_04924", "source_line": 5222, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 5814, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 3.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, medium CMB relevance; nonthermal phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_07773_mev_fermion_millicharged_particle_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_07773", "source_line": 2921, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5815, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative millicharged_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance medium, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_07773_mev_scalar_millicharged_particle_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_07773", "source_line": 2920, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5816, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative millicharged_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance medium, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "unified_dark_fluid", "model_id": "2103_07252_generalized_logotropic_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "2103_07252", "source_line": 127, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5817, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative unified_dark_fluid card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance, scale dependent growth transfer behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitationally_produced_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_12299_geometric_quasiparticle_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_12299", "source_line": 119, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5818, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative gravitationally_produced_scalar_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory-level support and nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2009_09867_muonic_puzzle_mev_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2009_09867", "source_line": 4427, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 463, "global_rank": 5819, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out, additional tree-level annihilation channel involving neutrinos.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_04735_non_degenerate_scalar_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_04735", "source_line": 4428, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 464, "global_rank": 5820, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out in the minimal EFT is discussed but often overabundant, annihilation into additional dark-sector states in richer completions.", "Observational leverage comes from medium BBN relevance, medium CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_05922_mixed_wino_pbh_shining_black_holes_v1", "paper_id": "2011_05922", "source_line": 4429, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 211, "global_rank": 5821, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out of wino dark matter, primordial black-hole formation from radiation-era density perturbations.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_03852_leptophobic_zprime_light_dm_beam_v1", "paper_id": "1512_03852", "source_line": 2633, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 465, "global_rank": 5822, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Leptophobic U(1)_B Z' light dark matter beam model is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'unknown'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for rare production wording in population counts, nonthermal phase space.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass. The card records phase-space type 'nonthermal' and small-scale-power effect 'unknown'."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_10632_dirac_fermion_quark_vector_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1903_10632", "source_line": 3787, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5823, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 0 because the card identifies production via not specified in paper; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2108_03422_noncanonical_spectator_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2108_03422", "source_line": 122, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 266, "global_rank": 5824, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_black_holes card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "2307_14861_tdiff_scalar_dust_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2307_14861", "source_line": 204, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 5825, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative scalar_field_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=cdm_like, small_scale_power_effect=none, and probe classes: none explicitly identified.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_03290_axion_bec_dimer_two_phase_v1", "paper_id": "2309_03290", "source_line": 203, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score falls below tier3 because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and benchmark support for observational extension."], "family_rank": 333, "global_rank": 5826, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the model card as a speculative axion_like_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization; scientific score reflects status, theory level, and card-local abundance relevance.", "Observational leverage comes from CMB=unknown, BBN=unknown, transfer_function=unknown, small_scale_power_effect=unknown, and probe classes: none explicitly identified.", "Penalized because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_01605_protophobic_vector_singlet_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_01605", "source_line": 2931, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 148, "global_rank": 5827, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_04235_oscillating_q_field_cold_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1612_04235", "source_line": 20, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5828, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative effective_field_theory model, field_like phase-space description, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_04230_nonlinear_eym_aether_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_04230", "source_line": 5210, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 334, "global_rank": 5829, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, field like phase-space behavior. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0002126_quintessence_scalar_halo_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0002126", "source_line": 4, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 5830, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, field_like phase-space description, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_tachyonic_dark_sector", "model_id": "1312_1175_higgs_like_tachyonic_field_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1312_1175", "source_line": 288, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the card lacks explicit observational/constraint/routing content needed for a higher-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5831, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as Higgs-like interacting tachyonic scalar dark matter, a speculative interacting tachyonic dark sector entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and high CMB relevance.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmark points, and mostly absent reusable computational support in the card. Warnings considered: phenomenological_microphysics."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_07132_q_ball_self_interacting_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_07132", "source_line": 2610, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 149, "global_rank": 5832, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Q-ball self-interacting dark matter and supermassive compact object scenario is marked speculative with phenomenological parameterization theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for distinct production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_09797_z2_odd_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_09797", "source_line": 2996, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the model card is sparse in explicit observables, constraints, routing, or usable computational support."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 5833, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar_singlet_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory level and parameter_dependent all-DM capability.", "Observational leverage is based on limited explicit observational leverage in the model card.", "Priority is held down because the model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation fields for observational follow-up.", "High-severity model-card warnings include stability_mass_ordering."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_09719_leptophilic_singlet_fermion_dm_le_all_v1", "paper_id": "1811_09719", "source_line": 3690, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5834, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative leptophilic_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_09719_leptophilic_singlet_fermion_dm_lmu_ltau_v1", "paper_id": "1811_09719", "source_line": 3691, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5835, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative leptophilic_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: medium CMB relevance; medium BBN relevance; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2112_01505_spectator_fvb_primordial_black_holes_v1", "paper_id": "2112_01505", "source_line": 4975, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 267, "global_rank": 5836, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial black holes entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and stochastic inflationary spectator-field fragmentation into false-vacuum domains.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by limited explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_05730_unified_baryogenesis_dm_quasiparticle_v1", "paper_id": "2112_05730", "source_line": 4987, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 166, "global_rank": 5837, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and nonthermal reheating-era particle production.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by nonthermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_dark_matter_baryon_interaction", "model_id": "hep-ph0304228_yukawa_suppressed_dm_baryon_gravity_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0304228", "source_line": 422, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5838, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides moderate diversity value; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_03554_no_scale_su5_m1_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_03554", "source_line": 4448, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 294, "global_rank": 5839, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal neutralino freeze-out on a focus-point relic-density strip.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_03746_nl_mssm_higgs_portal_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_03746", "source_line": 4393, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-extension priority.", "Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 5840, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as Higgs-portal scalar dark matter in the nonlinear MSSM: thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal annihilation to Standard Model particles; limited explicit observational leverage; inferred probe coverage includes no explicit probe classes.", "Priority is deferred because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, leaving a high penalty despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_03554_no_scale_su5_m2_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_03554", "source_line": 4449, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 295, "global_rank": 5841, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal neutralino freeze-out on a focus-point relic-density strip.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_03554_no_scale_su5_m3_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_03554", "source_line": 4450, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 296, "global_rank": 5842, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal neutralino freeze-out on a focus-point relic-density strip.", "Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0409203_large_cutoff_msugra_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0409203", "source_line": 497, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 297, "global_rank": 5843, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium BBN relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_2283_fermionic_higgs_portal_eft_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_2283", "source_line": 2120, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 77, "global_rank": 5844, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: an approximate distribution treatment is available.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule.", "High-severity model-card warning(s) reduce robustness for observational-extension prioritization."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_05378_higgs_z_resonant_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1510_05378", "source_line": 2664, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 298, "global_rank": 5845, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability yes, and family count 309. Observational leverage comes from approximate distribution information.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_06089_mssm4g_qdee_bino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_06089", "source_line": 2643, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 5846, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: MSSM4G QDEE Bino dark matter is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_06089_mssm4g_que_bino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_06089", "source_line": 2642, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 5847, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: MSSM4G QUE Bino dark matter is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_08117_axion_like_pseudoscalar_portal_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_08117", "source_line": 2682, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5848, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 11. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_02314_nonlocal_scalar_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_02314", "source_line": 3700, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 5849, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative scalar_higgs_portal_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_4877_b_minus_l_rh_neutrino_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1405_4877", "source_line": 2176, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 78, "global_rank": 5850, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with approximate distribution-function support.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_4877_singlet_fermionic_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1405_4877", "source_line": 2175, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 79, "global_rank": 5851, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card combines speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card with approximate distribution-function support.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_02607_scale_invariant_three_loop_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_02607", "source_line": 2575, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 5852, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1609_00907_weak_scale_primordial_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_00907", "source_line": 2935, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 268, "global_rank": 5853, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial_black_holes entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance low, phase-space type not_applicable, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_01605_protophobic_vector_singlet_real_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_01605", "source_line": 2930, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 466, "global_rank": 5854, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance medium, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_04145_soft_collision_decoherence_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1609_04145", "source_line": 2903, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 467, "global_rank": 5855, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has unknown relic-density completion in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_02672_zprime_portal_rhn_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_02672", "source_line": 2950, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 5856, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative right_handed_neutrino_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_06584_hydrogen_mixing_portal_dm_cooling_v1", "paper_id": "2012_06584", "source_line": 4508, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 468, "global_rank": 5857, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 4.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from medium CMB relevance.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_14870_two_component_inert_doublet_2hdm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_14870", "source_line": 4539, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 212, "global_rank": 5858, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_2642_two_fluid_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1106_2642", "source_line": 46, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observable, constraint, routing, or computational-support fields are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 213, "global_rank": 5859, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-scoring but not rejected because it is a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model, moderate diversity value; explicit observables, constraints, and routing are sparse or absent in the card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "effective_field_theory_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_08195_rsii_membrane_eft_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_08195", "source_line": 2625, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5860, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: RSII membrane effective field theory dark matter is marked speculative with effective field theory theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for underrepresented family in population context, non-duplicate representative of sparse family.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "fluorescent_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_01684_fluorescent_two_state_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1608_01684", "source_line": 2915, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5861, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative fluorescent_dark_matter entry with effective_field_theory theory support; it has unknown relic-density completion in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type unknown, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_11189_superweak_vector_boson_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_11189", "source_line": 3765, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 5862, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 0 because the card identifies production via WIMP-like vector dark matter candidate; cosmological production is ...; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2112_11486_emd_scalar_force_pbh_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2112_11486", "source_line": 4989, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 269, "global_rank": 5863, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial black holes entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and rapid growth of dark-fermion overdensities during a pre-BBN early matter dominated era.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by limited explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hot_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0108050_relic_neutrino_hot_dark_halo_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0108050", "source_line": 388, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5864, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 7, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the supplied card gives speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; production via standard cosmological relic neutrino production; gravitational clustering into Galactic or Local Group halos; thermal phase-space treatment, while observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation are absent from the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "vector_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2109_11499_u1x_vector_portal_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2109_11499", "source_line": 4827, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Current card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational representation for high-priority observational extension."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5865, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score driven by limited card-local observational leverage, while the supplied card has empty observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_5142_annihilating_asymmetric_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1408_5142", "source_line": 2279, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Raw score is below 30 because current model-card fields lack explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 167, "global_rank": 5866, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as a speculative asymmetric_dark_matter model with phenomenological_parameterization theory level and thermal phase-space classification.", "Priority is driven by relic-density support in the card, auditable provenance, validity, and warning fields; score is limited by missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational-representation fields in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "2309_12166_dark_sector_effective_field_theory_v1", "paper_id": "2309_12166", "source_line": 5816, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the supplied global ranking rule.", "Top-level observables and theory-to-observable routing are absent in the supplied card.", "Relic-density follow-up value is reduced because the card does not support a full-DM regime or leaves it unknown."], "family_rank": 214, "global_rank": 5867, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; the main production handle is not specified in the assigned text.", "Follow-up value comes from indirect detection, with phase-space/structure entries (unknown, unknown) and audited provenance/validity fields.", "Deferred tier because the supplied card lacks enough populated observable, constraint, routing, and computational fields to justify higher-priority observational extension."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_4798_quintessence_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1112_4798", "source_line": 1499, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low observational-extension score under the model-card-only rubric; explicit observable, constraint, and routing fields are absent in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 167, "global_rank": 5868, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 2, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-priority but not rejected because the card marks a viable sterile_neutrino_dark_matter variant and records cosmological evolution of a quintessence-coupled Majorana neutrino sector.", "The score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable-constraint entries, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and public computational support in the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_02735_2hdm_pseudoscalar_benchmark_i_llp_v1", "paper_id": "2302_02735", "source_line": 5469, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 469, "global_rank": 5869, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: 2HDM+a long-lived pseudoscalar benchmark I has limited supplied theoretical scoring fields, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0508125_sextet_neutron_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0508125", "source_line": 603, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because observational detail fields needed for extension are sparse or empty in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 32, "global_rank": 5870, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 1, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer because the model card has moderate diversity value within the population-count context, while observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1504_05419_large_composite_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1504_05419", "source_line": 2517, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 33, "global_rank": 5871, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Large composite dark matter states: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; its scientific score is limited by missing or weak model-comparison/relic fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score 0.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_04026_pnmssm_bino_higgsino_singlino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_04026", "source_line": 4488, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 299, "global_rank": 5872, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 15, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score 0.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "0910_5713_inelastic_sommerfeld_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0910_5713", "source_line": 1063, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 under the ranking rule because explicit observational routes, constraints, observables, or computational support are missing from the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 150, "global_rank": 5873, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Positive factors: speculative simplified_model self_interacting_dark_matter.", "Limiting factors: the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, public computational support, so observational-extension feasibility is low."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_5962_planck_scale_scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_5962", "source_line": 2121, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 44, "global_rank": 5874, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative phenomenological_parameterization model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_01501_noncommutative_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_01501", "source_line": 4321, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 5875, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Non-commutative singlet scalar Higgs-portal dark matter as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via thermal WIMP freeze-out through Higgs-portal annihilation.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0710_2058_su5_200_neutralino_subcomponent_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0710_2058", "source_line": 756, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["no explicit observable list", "no applicable-constraint list", "no theory-to-observable routes", "no usable public computational representation"], "family_rank": 300, "global_rank": 5876, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, relic viability no, raw score 0.0.", "Observational leverage uses card-local signals: no explicit observational leverage beyond model identity fields; probe classes counted: none.", "Penalties reflect sparse observational-extension inputs: no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint list, no theory-to-observable routes, no usable public computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "dipolar_dark_matter", "model_id": "0906_1979_dirac_direct_dipolar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "0906_1979", "source_line": 910, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5877, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has effective-theory structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7074_mono_higgs_zprime_2hdm_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7074", "source_line": 2076, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 470, "global_rank": 5878, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative simplified_model member of hidden_sector_dark_matter; abundance capability marked unknown; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7369_complex_scalar_charged_fermion_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7369", "source_line": 2137, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5879, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7369_complex_scalar_neutral_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7369", "source_line": 2138, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5880, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7369_complex_scalar_neutral_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7369", "source_line": 2139, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5881, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7369_dirac_fermion_charged_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7369", "source_line": 2144, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5882, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7369_majorana_fermion_charged_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7369", "source_line": 2140, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 5883, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7369_majorana_fermion_charged_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7369", "source_line": 2141, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 5884, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7369_majorana_fermion_neutral_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7369", "source_line": 2142, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 22, "global_rank": 5885, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7369_majorana_fermion_neutral_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7369", "source_line": 2143, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 23, "global_rank": 5886, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7369_real_scalar_charged_fermion_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7369", "source_line": 2135, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 24, "global_rank": 5887, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_7369_real_scalar_neutral_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1402_7369", "source_line": 2136, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 25, "global_rank": 5888, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_11902_type_ii_2hdm_pseudoscalar_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_11902", "source_line": 4955, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5889, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative pseudoscalar portal dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and thermal freeze-out through pseudoscalar-mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_11902_type_x_2hdm_pseudoscalar_portal_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_11902", "source_line": 4956, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5890, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative pseudoscalar portal dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and thermal freeze-out through pseudoscalar-mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutrino_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2206_06324_u1_lmu_ltau_gauge_v1", "paper_id": "2206_06324", "source_line": 5241, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5891, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 17.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative simplified model model content. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "brane_world_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0212269_massive_branon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0212269", "source_line": 482, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5892, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level effective_field_theory and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "0808_3600_lightest_u_parity_particle_v1", "paper_id": "0808_3600", "source_line": 817, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card has limited observable, constraint, routing, or computational support for an observational-detail extension."], "family_rank": 471, "global_rank": 5893, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete model, production is marked parameter_dependent. The card is penalized for sparse observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_00494_u1_inert_two_higgs_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_00494", "source_line": 2638, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 5894, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: U(1)-symmetric inert two-Higgs-doublet dark matter variant is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_00494_z2_inert_two_higgs_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_00494", "source_line": 2637, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 5895, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Z2 inert two-Higgs-doublet dark matter is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_02168_u1_lmu_ltau_extended_ma_n1_v1", "paper_id": "1510_02168", "source_line": 2620, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 168, "global_rank": 5896, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Right-handed neutrino dark matter in local U(1) L_mu-L_tau extended Ma model is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_02297_dirac_wimp_zprime_simplified_model_v1", "paper_id": "1510_02297", "source_line": 2613, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 472, "global_rank": 5897, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Dirac WIMP Z-prime simplified model is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_02495_bmssm_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_02495", "source_line": 2634, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 301, "global_rank": 5898, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: BMSSM neutralino dark matter with dimension-five Higgs-sector operators is marked speculative with effective field theory theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for non-generic production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_03413_vector_dark_matter_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1510_03413", "source_line": 2602, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 473, "global_rank": 5899, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Vector dark matter with complex scalar Higgs portal is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "warped_extra_dimension_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_04116_warped_higgs_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_04116", "source_line": 2604, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5900, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Warped Higgs dark matter scalar is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'no'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for underrepresented family in population context, rare production wording in population counts.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_04321_unbroken_complex_singlet_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1510_04321", "source_line": 2624, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 5901, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Unbroken conformal complex-singlet Higgs-portal dark matter is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_06151_singlet_doublet_dirac_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_06151", "source_line": 2650, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 14, "global_rank": 5902, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Singlet-Doublet Dirac Dark Matter is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for non-generic production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_07053_2hdms_h125_alt_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1510_07053", "source_line": 2609, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 80, "global_rank": 5903, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Type-II 2HDMS singlet scalar dark matter (H125 scenario) is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'yes'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_07053_2hdms_h125_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1510_07053", "source_line": 2608, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 81, "global_rank": 5904, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Type-II 2HDMS singlet scalar dark matter (h125 scenario) is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'yes'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "flavored_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_06293_skew_flavored_right_handed_lepton_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1511_06293", "source_line": 2649, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 5905, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Skew-flavored dark matter with right-handed leptons is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for non-generic production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_07458_a4_scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1511_07458", "source_line": 2670, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 37, "global_rank": 5906, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 43. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_00229_gauged_two_higgs_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_00229", "source_line": 2632, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 5907, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Gauged two Higgs doublet model dark matter is marked speculative with uv complete theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by solid scientific value from status/theory/production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for non-generic production mechanism.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_00476_s_channel_axial_zprime_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_00476", "source_line": 2646, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5908, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Gauge-invariant s-channel axial Z-prime mediator dark matter is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for underrepresented family in population context.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_00476_t_channel_colored_scalar_mediator_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_00476", "source_line": 2645, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5909, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Gauge-invariant t-channel colored-scalar mediator dark matter is marked speculative with simplified model theory level and production support 'unknown'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata, diversity credit for underrepresented family in population context.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_02384_a4_inverse_type_ii_seesaw_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_02384", "source_line": 2652, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 5910, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 17. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_03317_fermionic_inelastic_u1x_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_03317", "source_line": 2615, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly due to absent explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or reusable computational support."], "family_rank": 474, "global_rank": 5911, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: Fermionic inelastic U(1)_X dark matter is marked speculative with phenomenological parameterization theory level and production support 'parameter_dependent'. Score is driven by some scientific value from the supplied theory and relic-production fields, auditable provenance, assumptions, validity domain, and robustness metadata.", "Priority is limited because the supplied model-only card does not provide explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, or benchmark points for this ranking pass."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_07961_u1x_radiative_inert_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_07961", "source_line": 2681, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 5912, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 54. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_00138_a4_u1d_z2_two_component_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_00138", "source_line": 2672, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 215, "global_rank": 5913, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 220. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_01569_dark_sector_assisted_scalar_decay_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_01569", "source_line": 2689, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 15, "global_rank": 5914, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 17. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_00004_750gev_pseudoscalar_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1602_00004", "source_line": 2677, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5915, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 10. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_mimetic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1602_06890_bi_scalar_mimetic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1602_06890", "source_line": 107, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5916, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative modified_gravity_mimetic_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory-level support and limited extracted observational structure.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_05403_hidden_baryon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1607_05403", "source_line": 2824, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational routing, constraint content, or computational support for immediate high-priority extension."], "family_rank": 475, "global_rank": 5917, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic production marked unknown.", "The supplied card does not provide explicit observable routes, constraints, or non-CDM structure signatures, limiting observational leverage.", "Diversity value reflects family rarity or distinctive particle/production features relative to the supplied population counts.", "Penalized for missing observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and/or limited computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1903_01477_residual_z6_dirac_scotogenic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1903_01477", "source_line": 3790, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 5918, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 3.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 0 because the card identifies production via unknown; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1904_07558_s3_z2_scotogenic_inert_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1904_07558", "source_line": 3791, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 5919, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score 0 because the card identifies production via unknown; priority is limited by missing observables, applicable constraints, routing in the model-only card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_08700_minimal_dimensional_transmutation_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_08700", "source_line": 4406, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 82, "global_rank": 5920, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out, Higgs-portal annihilation.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2009_08268_pbh_dark_matter_nanograv_flat_spectrum_v1", "paper_id": "2009_08268", "source_line": 4444, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 270, "global_rank": 5921, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes collapse of large primordial curvature perturbations into PBHs at horizon re-entry during radiation domination.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2009_11853_solar_mass_primordial_black_holes_v1", "paper_id": "2009_11853", "source_line": 4434, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 271, "global_rank": 5922, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative phenomenological parameterization model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes collapse of enhanced primordial curvature perturbations into PBHs in the early Universe, curvature-induced second-order gravitational waves from the same enhanced perturbations.", "Diversity credit reflects sparse or phenomenologically distinctive registry space for this card.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "grand_unified_long_lived_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_01398_su6_long_lived_n2_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_01398", "source_line": 4431, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5923, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv complete model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out through N_2 annihilation to scalar bosons.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_09716_bended_valley_bosonic_dm_ns_collapse_v1", "paper_id": "2112_09716", "source_line": 4981, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 168, "global_rank": 5924, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative asymmetric dark matter entry with simplified model theory support and asymmetric dark matter relic with antiparticles depleted.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by limited explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0611001_e6_su2z_wimp_cdm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0611001", "source_line": 682, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 476, "global_rank": 5925, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare production mechanism, sparse-class representative; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_4010_inert_scalar_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "0903_4010", "source_line": 947, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 8, "global_rank": 5926, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_4010_real_scalar_quintuplet_v1", "paper_id": "0903_4010", "source_line": 949, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5927, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_multiplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_4010_real_scalar_septuplet_v1", "paper_id": "0903_4010", "source_line": 950, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5928, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1402_0682_asymmetric_long_range_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1402_0682", "source_line": 2123, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 169, "global_rank": 5929, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative simplified_model model; observational leverage comes from: the supplied observables, constraints, routing, and structure-specific leverage fields are mostly empty or CDM-like.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_2392_scalar_t_baryon_su2_confinement_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_2392", "source_line": 2188, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 5930, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_2543_radiative_neutrino_two_component_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_2543", "source_line": 2158, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 216, "global_rank": 5931, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_6588_local_z2_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_6588", "source_line": 2170, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 477, "global_rank": 5932, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "millicharged_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_00571_spin_1_millicharged_vector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_00571", "source_line": 2574, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5933, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative millicharged_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_02179_fermionic_semi_annihilating_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1510_02179", "source_line": 2600, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5934, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative semi_annihilating_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_08461_interacting_two_component_scalar_singlet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_08461", "source_line": 2939, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 217, "global_rank": 5935, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1608_02694_colored_knt_majorana_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1608_02694", "source_line": 2934, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 54, "global_rank": 5936, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low, BBN relevance none, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_01504_two_loop_radiative_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_01504", "source_line": 2936, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 55, "global_rank": 5937, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low, BBN relevance none, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_02188_anomaly_free_axial_vector_zprime_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_02188", "source_line": 2918, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5938, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative zprime_portal_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_04986_colored_triplet_knt_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1610_04986", "source_line": 2923, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 56, "global_rank": 5939, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it can supply the full dark-matter abundance in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1611_03297_conformal_complex_singlet_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1611_03297", "source_line": 2944, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 5940, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type unknown, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_01973_radiatively_corrected_inert_doublet_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1612_01973", "source_line": 2948, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 5941, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter entry with uv_complete theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance low, BBN relevance none, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect none and transfer shape cdm_like.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_03908_nonuniversal_u1prime_scotogenic_solution1_v1", "paper_id": "1812_03908", "source_line": 3701, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 5942, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Non-universal U(1)' scotogenic charge solution 1 is a speculative uv complete candidate with a defined model identity and provenance but sparse observational content; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_03908_nonuniversal_u1prime_scotogenic_solution2_v1", "paper_id": "1812_03908", "source_line": 3702, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below the tier3 threshold because the model card lacks explicit observational-extension support such as observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 5943, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because Non-universal U(1)' scotogenic charge solution 2 is a speculative uv complete candidate with a defined model identity and provenance but sparse observational content; it lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higher_spin_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_02224_general_spin_higgs_portal_dm_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2010_02224", "source_line": 4424, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5944, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective field theory model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes thermal freeze-out through Higgs-portal annihilation, freeze-in through feeble Higgs-portal production.", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_10121_composite_higgs_asymmetric_rh_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2010_10121", "source_line": 4445, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied model-card-only fields; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 170, "global_rank": 5945, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified model model with relic production marked unknown.", "Production content in the card includes asymmetric production from out-of-equilibrium decays of TeV-scale composite scalar bound states to right-handed heavy neutrinos, visible-sector asymmetry transfer through N_R,1 interactions with Standard Model leptons....", "The score is conservative because the supplied card has no observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, or computational-representation section."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_09101_2hdm_fermionic_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2011_09101", "source_line": 4546, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 83, "global_rank": 5946, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2301_12120_f_portal_fermion_freeze_out_v1", "paper_id": "2301_12120", "source_line": 5497, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 478, "global_rank": 5947, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: F-portal vector-like singlet fermion freeze-out dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_05410_mixed_idm_three_hnf_semivisible_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_05410", "source_line": 5457, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 39, "global_rank": 5948, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Mixed-iDM three-HNF semi-visible dark photon dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0504046_metastable_scalar_decay_to_dark_energy_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0504046", "source_line": 564, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 47, "global_rank": 5949, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Metastable scalar dark matter decaying to a dark-energy scalar is a speculative phenomenological parameterization card in family decaying_dark_matter with production described as unspecified relic component of metastable scalar dark matter.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0508098_heavy_higgsino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0508098", "source_line": 575, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 5950, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Heavy higgsino-like LSP dark matter is a speculative simplified model card in family supersymmetric_higgsino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out with higgsino pair annihilation and co-annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter_to_axion_like_particles", "model_id": "1403_2370_fermionic_decay_to_alp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1403_2370", "source_line": 2068, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5951, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of decaying_dark_matter_to_axion_like_particles; abundance capability marked unknown; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support; large sparsity penalties from missing observational-extension fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_fermion_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_0688_singlet_fermion_scalar_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_0688", "source_line": 2174, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5952, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and can produce all dark matter in the supplied card, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, computational representation is sparse, and the supplied warnings include high-severity caveats."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "secluded_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_08520_massive_mediator_secluded_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_08520", "source_line": 2908, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5953, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative secluded_dark_matter entry with simplified_model theory support; it has parameter-dependent relic-density viability in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type thermal, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is moderate because the family or production/phase-space pattern is underrepresented relative to the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_dark_matter", "model_id": "1610_01016_f_r_scalaron_chameleon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1610_01016", "source_line": 2917, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 threshold because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, routing, benchmarks, or computational representation needed for high-value observational extension."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 5954, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative modified_gravity_dark_matter entry with phenomenological_parameterization theory support; it has unknown relic-density completion in the supplied card.", "Card-level observational leverage comes from CMB relevance unknown, BBN relevance unknown, phase-space type unknown, and structure fields with small-scale effect unknown and transfer shape unknown.", "Diversity value is comparatively high because the card occupies a rare or distinctive production, phase-space, or model-family region in the population context.", "Priority is limited by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "semi_annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_02336_semi_hooperon_phenomenological_v1", "paper_id": "1706_02336", "source_line": 3158, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Assigned model card has no explicit observables block.", "Assigned model card has no applicable-constraints block.", "No theory-to-observable routing is present in the assigned card.", "Feasibility support is low or limited to partial/non-public associated-code information."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5955, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model-card-only score 0.0: Semi-Hooperon semi-annihilating WIMP setup is a speculative phenomenological parameterization entry with DM DM -> DM h.", "Rank-relevant positives are little explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage, provenance/validity support, and probe touchpoints: no explicit probe routing.", "Priority is limited because the assigned card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing; no paper text was used."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00753_model4_scalar_doublet_fermion_singlet_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00753", "source_line": 3147, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 9, "global_rank": 5956, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with raw score 0.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00753_model5_scalar_doublet_fermion_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00753", "source_line": 3148, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 10, "global_rank": 5957, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with raw score 0.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00753_model7_scalar_doublet_fermion_triplet_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00753", "source_line": 3149, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 5958, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with raw score 0.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00753_model9_scalar_doublet_adjoint_doublet_mixing_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00753", "source_line": 3150, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5959, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter with raw score 0.0.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_02066_superheavy_neutralino_colored_coannihilation_v1", "paper_id": "1812_02066", "source_line": 3683, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 34, "global_rank": 5960, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative neutralino_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_05565_u1_munu_ssm_singlet_wimp_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2101_05565", "source_line": 4588, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 5961, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 10}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative supersymmetric_wimp_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_12138_solution_b_dark_dirac_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2101_12138", "source_line": 4552, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 479, "global_rank": 5962, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2101_12138_solution_c_dark_majorana_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2101_12138", "source_line": 4553, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing for this ranking pass."], "family_rank": 480, "global_rank": 5963, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 11}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter entry with theory level uv_complete.", "Observational leverage comes from no explicit observable, constraint, or routing fields are supplied.", "Priority is limited because observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2112_02534_accretion_assisted_pbh_matter_era_v1", "paper_id": "2112_02534", "source_line": 4993, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 272, "global_rank": 5964, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative primordial black holes entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and collapse of overdensities in a matter-dominated era.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by limited explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_03755_mass_radius_self_interacting_sub_ev_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_03755", "source_line": 5000, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 151, "global_rank": 5965, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative self interacting dark matter entry with phenomenological parameterization theory support and no early-Universe production mechanism specified; late-time halo phenomenology is modeled.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by limited explicit phase-space or structure-formation leverage; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_09103_muonic_wimp_zprime_eft_v1", "paper_id": "2112_09103", "source_line": 4995, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5966, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative leptophilic wimp dark matter entry with effective field theory theory support and thermal WIMP freeze-out through Z' mediated annihilation.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2201_00560_supercooled_two_scalar_filtered_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2201_00560", "source_line": 4961, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below the tier3 threshold for observational-detail extension.", "No explicit routed probe classes are present in observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Supplied model card has empty observable and applicable-constraint sections."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 5967, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative scalar singlet dark matter entry with uv complete theory support and thermal freeze-out modified by filtering at expanding true-vacuum bubble walls during a strong first-order phase transition.", "Observational leverage is driven mainly by thermal phase space; the card has no explicit observables, constraints, or theory-to-observable routes.", "Auditability is comparatively strong because the card includes provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness notes, and warnings; feasibility remains limited by unknown associated-code support and no benchmarks."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_10577_sextic_three_body_superfluid_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_10577", "source_line": 5488, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 152, "global_rank": 5968, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Sextic three-body superfluid dark matter variant has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_naked_singularity_dark_matter", "model_id": "2401_14431_primordial_naked_singularity_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2401_14431", "source_line": 123, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 5969, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 8, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative primordial_naked_singularity_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and limited extracted observational structure.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0604235_dterm_mixed_modulus_anomaly_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0604235", "source_line": 579, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 302, "global_rank": 5970, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["D-term mixed modulus-anomaly neutralino dark matter is a speculative simplified model card in family supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter with production described as thermal freeze-out.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, model-comparison fields; provenance, validity-domain, assumptions, robustness, and warning fields are used only as supplied in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_4127_effective_zprime_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "1104_4127", "source_line": 1319, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low field-only priority score; explicit observational routing, observables, and applicable constraints are absent or sparse in the supplied card."], "family_rank": 481, "global_rank": 5971, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, production_all_dm=parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is limited because the supplied card has CDM-like or unknown structure fields and no explicit observable block.", "Score is penalized because explicit observable routing, observables, or applicable constraints are absent in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_04679_singlet_doublet_blind_spot_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_04679", "source_line": 3684, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 16, "global_rank": 5972, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter with simplified_model theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent; some diversity value from family or phenomenology rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_06539_type_3_2_spin_3_2_hidden_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2105_06539", "source_line": 4692, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the score is below 30 after model-card-local penalties for missing observables, constraints, and routing."], "family_rank": 482, "global_rank": 5973, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 8, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not eliminated: the supplied card lists status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, and relic production unknown; little explicit observational leverage encoded in the supplied card.", "Low current priority because the card has empty observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields, with limited computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_07822_scalar_higgs_portal_eft_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2012_07822", "source_line": 4544, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Score below tier3 because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing are absent or sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 84, "global_rank": 5974, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory model; no global elimination statement is present.", "Diversity value is modest and comes from the family, production, or phase-space counts.", "The score is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "superheavy_relic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2207_06467_r2_scalaron_superheavy_relic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2207_06467", "source_line": 5235, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable.", "Validity-domain information is empty, adding local penalty under the ranking rule."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5975, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 7.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include uv complete construction with parameter-dependent abundance support. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2207_10394_pbh_dm_warm_natural_inflation_v1", "paper_id": "2207_10394", "source_line": 5236, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": 0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value because observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are empty in the supplied card.", "Computational representation and reusable code support are mostly unknown or unavailable.", "Validity-domain information is empty, adding local penalty under the ranking rule."], "family_rank": 273, "global_rank": 5976, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 7.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Deferred but scored because the card is not globally eliminated; positive signals include speculative status with limited theory-level scoring, distinctive or sparse population coverage. Missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes dominate the low follow-up priority."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": 0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_02958_yukawa_light_mediator_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2007_02958", "source_line": 185, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 153, "global_rank": 5977, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score -0.5 for self_interacting_dark_matter: positive factors include simplified_model theory level, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00709_b_plus_l_anomalous_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00709", "source_line": 3135, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -0.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 5978, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of zprime_mediated_dark_matter with raw score -0.5.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "zprime_mediated_dark_matter", "model_id": "1707_00709_leptophilic_l_anomalous_zprime_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1707_00709", "source_line": 3136, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -0.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 5979, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 2.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of zprime_mediated_dark_matter with raw score -0.5.", "Observational leverage comes mainly from cosmological relevance.", "Feasibility is limited because the supplied card lacks explicit computational representation, benchmark, and route fields.", "Penalties are high because observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and model-comparison compatibility are missing or unknown in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0510088_x4_baryon_sequestration_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0510088", "source_line": 68, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 171, "global_rank": 5980, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this asymmetric_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and limited explicit observational content.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_05857_331_remnant_z2_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2003_05857", "source_line": 4173, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -0.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 57, "global_rank": 5981, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative uv_complete member of radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include limited explicit observable structure in the card.", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_03943_residual_z3_bminusl_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_03943", "source_line": 2552, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 483, "global_rank": 5982, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 9.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_06660_leptophilic_scalar_muon_anomaly_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1507_06660", "source_line": 2553, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 26, "global_rank": 5983, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative leptophilic_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_05323_singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1509_05323", "source_line": 2582, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -0.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 5984, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative singlet_doublet_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -0.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_15191_two_component_plasma_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2007_15191", "source_line": 4349, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 484, "global_rank": 5985, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 3, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Two-component plasma dark matter with dark electron and dark proton as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter model with simplified_model theory level and production via not specified; the paper assumes a present-day hidden-sector dark plasma halo.", "Observational leverage in the card comes from cosmological relevance CMB=unknown and BBN=medium; phase-space type thermal.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: borderline_relic_logic, shielding_assumption."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2111_11593_two_fluid_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2111_11593", "source_line": 172, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 48, "global_rank": 5986, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 3.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 4.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score -1.0 for decaying_dark_matter: positive factors include medium CMB relevance, decay_produced phase-space behavior, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_02879_dimension8_higgs_portal_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2302_02879", "source_line": 5486, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 85, "global_rank": 5987, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 2.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Dimension-8 Higgs-portal real scalar WIMP has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0611006_self_interacting_pseudoscalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0611006", "source_line": 672, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 154, "global_rank": 5988, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare production mechanism, distinct phase-space or transfer behavior, sparse-class representative; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_07992_dirac_fermion_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_07992", "source_line": 2667, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 485, "global_rank": 5989, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 506. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_07992_scalar_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_07992", "source_line": 2666, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 486, "global_rank": 5990, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 506. Observational leverage comes from medium CMB relevance.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2402_03959_su2_scalar_dark_glueball_v1", "paper_id": "2402_03959", "source_line": 5967, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Supplied card lacks explicit observables and applicable constraints for observational-extension routing.", "No theory-to-observable routes are provided in the supplied card.", "Computational representation, benchmarks, likelihoods, and usable public-code support are absent or minimal.", "Missing-field and warning penalties dominate the current follow-up value."], "family_rank": 487, "global_rank": 5991, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score from hidden_sector_dark_matter: SU(2) scalar dark glueball dark matter has moderate model/theory value through unknown; inferred probe classes are no explicit probe classes.", "The score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representations in the supplied card.", "High-severity card warnings were treated as penalties but not as strict elimination because they do not rule out the whole model class."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0307356_non_universal_higgs_masses_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0307356", "source_line": 457, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 303, "global_rank": 5992, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by medium CMB relevance.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "1009_4942_density_product_interacting_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "1009_4942", "source_line": 69, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 12, "global_rank": 5993, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this interacting_dark_sector card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and limited explicit observational content.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector", "model_id": "2203_16083_four_kernel_rheological_dark_fluid_v1", "paper_id": "2203_16083", "source_line": 70, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 13, "global_rank": 5994, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this interacting_dark_sector card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and limited explicit observational content.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "strongly_interacting_massive_particle_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0212063_stable_color_triplet_higgs_subcomponent_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0212063", "source_line": 479, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 5995, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support no.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_00246_nmssm_light_singlino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "1510_00246", "source_line": 2656, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 304, "global_rank": 5996, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 309. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_07872_su2r_quintuplet_bminusl_2_v1", "paper_id": "1510_07872", "source_line": 2658, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 20, "global_rank": 5997, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability no, and family count 23. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1511_07380_su4_top_flavored_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1511_07380", "source_line": 2692, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 488, "global_rank": 5998, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 506. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_04003_u1_bl_u1_d_cdm_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "1512_04003", "source_line": 2686, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 489, "global_rank": 5999, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 506. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_05491_u1x_radiative_lepton_mass_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1512_05491", "source_line": 2697, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 490, "global_rank": 6000, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 506. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_08255_loop_philic_pseudoscalar_inert_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_08255", "source_line": 2687, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 6001, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 54. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_09048_radiative_seesaw_majorana_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_09048", "source_line": 2684, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 58, "global_rank": 6002, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 65. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_04516_four_loop_radiative_seesaw_boson_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_04516", "source_line": 2674, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 59, "global_rank": 6003, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 65. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_04516_four_loop_radiative_seesaw_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_04516", "source_line": 2673, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 60, "global_rank": 6004, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 65. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_04990_doublet_triplet_fermion_multicomponent_v1", "paper_id": "1809_04990", "source_line": 3584, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks populated observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated code."], "family_rank": 218, "global_rank": 6005, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored from the supplied model card as a speculative multi_component_dark_matter entry with simplified-model theory support; it is presented as a subcomponent rather than all dark matter.", "Observational-extension value is limited by absent observables, applicable constraints, routing, computational representation, benchmarks, and usable associated-code fields in this card.", "The final score falls below the tier3 threshold, so this is a low-current-value observational-extension candidate rather than an eliminated model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_0122_leptophilic_u1_model_b_v1", "paper_id": "0903_0122", "source_line": 945, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 27, "global_rank": 6006, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1406_4903_leptophilic_mssm_new_bulk_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1406_4903", "source_line": 2153, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 305, "global_rank": 6007, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_01010_cmdgssm_pseudo_dirac_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "1507_01010", "source_line": 2564, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 306, "global_rank": 6008, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_04996_classically_scale_invariant_inert_doublet_v1", "paper_id": "1507_04996", "source_line": 2557, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 53, "global_rank": 6009, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative inert_doublet_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_01046_three_loop_nr_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_01046", "source_line": 2554, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 61, "global_rank": 6010, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_02534_fssm_i_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1508_02534", "source_line": 2586, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 18, "global_rank": 6011, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative cold_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_05616_r_parity_susy_zee_wino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_05616", "source_line": 2581, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 45, "global_rank": 6012, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_09127_split_lr_scotogenic_n_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2010_09127", "source_line": 4461, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 6013, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for scotogenic_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score -1.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1429_adm_complex_scalar_pseudoscalar_quark_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1429", "source_line": 1283, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 172, "global_rank": 6014, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score -1 for Asymmetric complex scalar dark matter with pseudoscalar quark operator: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1429_adm_complex_scalar_scalar_quark_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1429", "source_line": 1282, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 173, "global_rank": 6015, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score -1 for Asymmetric complex scalar dark matter with scalar quark operator: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1429_adm_complex_scalar_vector_quark_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1429", "source_line": 1284, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 174, "global_rank": 6016, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score -1 for Asymmetric complex scalar dark matter with vector quark operator: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1429_adm_dirac_fermion_axial_quark_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1429", "source_line": 1288, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 175, "global_rank": 6017, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score -1 for Asymmetric Dirac fermion dark matter with axial-vector quark operator: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1429_adm_dirac_fermion_pseudoscalar_quark_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1429", "source_line": 1286, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 176, "global_rank": 6018, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score -1 for Asymmetric Dirac fermion dark matter with pseudoscalar quark operator: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1429_adm_dirac_fermion_scalar_quark_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1429", "source_line": 1285, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 177, "global_rank": 6019, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score -1 for Asymmetric Dirac fermion dark matter with scalar quark operator: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1429_adm_dirac_fermion_tensor_quark_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1429", "source_line": 1289, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 178, "global_rank": 6020, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score -1 for Asymmetric Dirac fermion dark matter with tensor quark operator: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1104_1429_adm_dirac_fermion_vector_quark_operator_v1", "paper_id": "1104_1429", "source_line": 1287, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 179, "global_rank": 6021, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score -1 for Asymmetric Dirac fermion dark matter with vector quark operator: status=speculative, theory_level=effective_field_theory, all-DM production=parameter_dependent.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness.", "A near-duplicate local benchmark/operator-family penalty was applied within this assigned model-card subset."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_3730_weinberg_decaying_excited_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_3730", "source_line": 2157, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 491, "global_rank": 6022, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, uv_complete theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "extra_dimensional_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_05722_warped_kk_parity_dark_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "1510_05722", "source_line": 2665, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 6023, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability no, and family count 1. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code. High-severity warning(s) in the card add caution but do not eliminate the model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_model_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_06842_750gev_cp_even_majorana_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1512_06842", "source_line": 2695, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 6024, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 7. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code. High-severity warning(s) in the card add caution but do not eliminate the model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_model_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_06842_750gev_cp_odd_majorana_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1512_06842", "source_line": 2696, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 6025, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 7. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code. High-severity warning(s) in the card add caution but do not eliminate the model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "matter_antimatter_bound_state_dark_matter", "model_id": "1807_06428_matter_antimatter_bound_state_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1807_06428", "source_line": 173, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 6026, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 4.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score -1.0 for matter_antimatter_bound_state_dark_matter: positive factors include diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_05410_inelastic_dirac_semivisible_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2302_05410", "source_line": 5458, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 40, "global_rank": 6027, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Inelastic Dirac semi-visible dark photon dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_05410_two_hnf_semivisible_inelastic_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2302_05410", "source_line": 5456, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 41, "global_rank": 6028, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Two-HNF semi-visible inelastic dark matter has some theory and relic-density motivation, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "composite_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0611262_qud_sextet_neutron_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0611262", "source_line": 668, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 6029, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; underrepresented family, rare production mechanism, sparse-class representative; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_exotic_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0612280_just_so_higgs_exotic_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0612280", "source_line": 679, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 6030, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; very rare family, rare production mechanism, sparse-class representative; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_field_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph9905024_dilatonic_scalar_halo_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph9905024", "source_line": 74, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 38, "global_rank": 6031, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this scalar_field_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with effective_field_theory theory support and field_like phase-space behavior.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_09290_spin2_fermion_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2003_09290", "source_line": 4164, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 155, "global_rank": 6032, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of self_interacting_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_09290_spin2_scalar_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2003_09290", "source_line": 4163, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 156, "global_rank": 6033, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of self_interacting_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_09290_spin2_vector_sidm_v1", "paper_id": "2003_09290", "source_line": 4165, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.5, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 157, "global_rank": 6034, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 2.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative effective_field_theory member of self_interacting_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_00874_effective_self_interacting_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1509_00874", "source_line": 2592, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 158, "global_rank": 6035, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 1.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 5.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative self_interacting_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1110_3640_a5_decaying_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1110_3640", "source_line": 1426, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 49, "global_rank": 6036, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of -1.5 because the card describes decaying dark matter at effective field theory level, with not specified in assigned text; relic abundance is assumed for the decaying dark matter candidate and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "singlet_doublet_fermion_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_5886_z2_dark_fermion_seesaw_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_5886", "source_line": 2160, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.5, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 6037, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_02534_fake_split_extended_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_02534", "source_line": 2588, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -1.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 50, "global_rank": 6038, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative decaying_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -1.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_00021_spin_half_sidm_axial_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2003_00021", "source_line": 4184, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 159, "global_rank": 6039, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of self_interacting_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_00021_spin_half_sidm_pseudoscalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2003_00021", "source_line": 4182, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 160, "global_rank": 6040, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 1.0, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of self_interacting_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_00021_spin_half_sidm_scalar_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2003_00021", "source_line": 4181, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 161, "global_rank": 6041, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.983607, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of self_interacting_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_00021_spin_half_sidm_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "2003_00021", "source_line": 4183, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 162, "global_rank": 6042, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.967213, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 2, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as a speculative simplified_model member of self_interacting_dark_matter; rank-relevant features include 1 inferred probe class(es).", "Score is limited by absent explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes in the model card.", "Priority tier is defer because the model is not eliminated but currently has low model-card-local observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_0432_antisymmetric_tensor_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_0432", "source_line": 2124, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the supplied model-card-only fields, mainly because observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational support are sparse or absent."], "family_rank": 86, "global_rank": 6043, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.95082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model-card fields as a speculative effective_field_theory model; observational leverage comes from: an approximate distribution treatment is available.", "Score is limited by model-card sparsity: explicit computational representations, routing, benchmarks, and public-code support are absent in the supplied card, with empty supplied observables/constraints/routing penalized under the rule.", "High-severity model-card warning(s) reduce robustness for observational-extension prioritization."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "bosonic_condensate_dark_matter", "model_id": "1805_02504_bose_gas_halo_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1805_02504", "source_line": 139, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 4, "global_rank": 6044, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.934426, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 1, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative bosonic_condensate_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and limited extracted observational structure.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2302_02735_2hdm_pseudoscalar_benchmark_ii_llp_v1", "paper_id": "2302_02735", "source_line": 5470, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 492, "global_rank": 6045, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.918033, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 1.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: 2HDM+a long-lived pseudoscalar benchmark II has limited supplied theoretical scoring fields, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0201001_yukawa_unified_nonuniversal_gaugino_neutralino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0201001", "source_line": 450, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 307, "global_rank": 6046, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.901639, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 16, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0212350_finite_su5_lsp_neutralino_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0212350", "source_line": 463, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 308, "global_rank": 6047, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.885246, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support unknown.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "0708_0247_late_decaying_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0708_0247", "source_line": 685, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 6048, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.868852, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare production mechanism; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; medium-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1510_02110_gauge_invariant_spin1_mediator_dark_higgs_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1510_02110", "source_line": 2662, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 493, "global_rank": 6049, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.852459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level simplified_model, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 506. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2011_07182_bdw_gauge_kinetic_mixing_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2011_07182", "source_line": 4472, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 494, "global_rank": 6050, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.836066, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for hidden_sector_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score -2.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "0905_4462_chiral_decoupling_gev_axi_higgs_v1", "paper_id": "0905_4462", "source_line": 906, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 335, "global_rank": 6051, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.819672, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has effective-theory structure, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "inelastic_dark_matter", "model_id": "1404_6043_exothermic_isospin_violating_dark_photon_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1404_6043", "source_line": 2053, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the assigned model card lacks populated observables, constraints, routing, and mostly lacks computational-representation support."], "family_rank": 42, "global_rank": 6052, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.803279, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked defer because the card provides speculative phenomenological_parameterization member of inelastic_dark_matter; abundance capability marked unknown; auditable provenance, validity, assumptions, and warning fields, but no populated observable/constraint/routing probe complementarity; no populated computational-representation, benchmark, or routing support; large sparsity penalties from missing observational-extension fields."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_geometric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_07057_unimodular_mimetic_geometric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_07057", "source_line": 72, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the supplied card."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 6053, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.786885, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 5.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because this modified_gravity_geometric_dark_matter card is viable enough to score, with phenomenological_parameterization theory support and limited explicit observational content.", "The current model card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing, so observational-extension value is deferred despite provenance and validity-domain support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_01599_residual_z6_dirac_neutrino_loop_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_01599", "source_line": 3682, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 62, "global_rank": 6054, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.770492, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_12377_top_philic_scalar_t_channel_portal_v1", "paper_id": "2212_12377", "source_line": 5467, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 495, "global_rank": 6055, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.754098, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Top-philic real-scalar t-channel portal dark matter has limited supplied theoretical scoring fields, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0202089_theory_space_scalar_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0202089", "source_line": 414, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 after sparse-observability and feasibility penalties."], "family_rank": 31, "global_rank": 6056, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.737705, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Defer priority because the card provides speculative status with a defined production setting; probe signal: no explicit probe class beyond the sparse card fields.", "The score remains low because it has no explicit observable list, no applicable-constraint entries, no theory-to-observable routing, little reusable computational representation. Penalties are near the rule cap for sparse or uncertain observational-extension inputs."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0404184_nmssm_neutralino_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0404184", "source_line": 492, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 35, "global_rank": 6057, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.721311, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level uv_complete and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including high, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "leptophilic_dark_matter", "model_id": "0903_0122_leptophilic_u1_model_c_v1", "paper_id": "0903_0122", "source_line": 946, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the rule; the supplied card lacks observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 28, "global_rank": 6058, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.704918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low current observational-extension score because the supplied model card has simplified-model structure, parameter-dependent relic-abundance support, strong provenance, validity, and robustness metadata, but leaves observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes empty.", "Additional penalties come from unknown compatibility/testability fields and mostly absent computational representation in the model card.", "A near-duplicate or local-variant penalty was applied within the supplied batch context."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "1106_0308_gravitino_dm_partial_split_susy_brpv_v1", "paper_id": "1106_0308", "source_line": 1280, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier is defer because the model-card-local score is below 30 after observational-readiness penalties."], "family_rank": 76, "global_rank": 6059, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.688525, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 9}, "ranking_rationale": ["Assigned defer tier with score -2 for Gravitino dark matter in partial split supersymmetry with bilinear R-parity violation: status=speculative, theory_level=simplified_model, all-DM production=unknown.", "The card supplies little explicit observational leverage beyond relic-density or model-definition information.", "Provenance, assumptions, validity-domain, robustness, and warnings are present, but empty observables/constraints/routing/benchmark fields heavily limit observational-extension readiness."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_4127_17ev_thermal_axion_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1304_4127", "source_line": 1750, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the supplied rule, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, and routing are absent from the assigned model card."], "family_rank": 336, "global_rank": 6060, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.672131, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked conservatively because the card lacks explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routing fields.", "Scientific value is supported by model-card links to strong-CP/PQ/axion.", "Feasibility is constrained by associated_code=unknown, 0 benchmark point(s), and absent explicit routing.", "Main penalties: current-data compatibility is not populated; model_comparison block is missing; observable routing is absent; observables are absent."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_axial_vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_8257_msdm_axial_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1407_8257", "source_line": 2183, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 6061, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.655738, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, and simplified_model theory level, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_01046_three_loop_s0_higgs_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_01046", "source_line": 2555, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 63, "global_rank": 6062, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.639344, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 8.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "cold_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_02534_fssm_ii_lsp_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1508_02534", "source_line": 2587, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 19, "global_rank": 6063, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.622951, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative cold_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "modified_gravity_effective_dark_matter", "model_id": "1802_04916_non_neutral_plasma_dark_matter_like_v1", "paper_id": "1802_04916", "source_line": 115, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 3, "global_rank": 6064, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.606557, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 6, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative modified_gravity_effective_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and limited extracted observational structure.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "The diversity component is helped by rare-family diversity and distinctive production or phase-space structure relative to the population-count context.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "macroscopic_qcd_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_02691_string_junction_torus_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_02691", "source_line": 3692, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 6065, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.590164, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 6.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 3.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative macroscopic_qcd_dark_matter with phenomenological_parameterization theory-level support.", "Useful signals: high model-card diversity value from population-count rarity.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "annihilating_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro_ph0404205_tev_annihilating_galactic_center_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0404205", "source_line": 487, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 6066, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.57377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including high severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_3043_dirac_fermion_higgs_descendant_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1112_3043", "source_line": 1441, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 87, "global_rank": 6067, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.557377, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 4.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of -2.5 because the card describes higgs portal dark matter at phenomenological parameterization level, with unspecified dark matter production; non-thermal methods allowed; thermal freeze-out not imposed and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1112_3043_scalar_higgs_descendant_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1112_3043", "source_line": 1440, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority tier defer because the score is below 30 under the ranking rule; the model is not globally eliminated."], "family_rank": 88, "global_rank": 6068, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.540984, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 16.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 4.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with a score of -2.5 because the card describes higgs portal dark matter at phenomenological parameterization level, with unspecified dark matter production; non-thermal methods allowed; thermal freeze-out not imposed and limited explicit cosmological or structure-formation leverage.", "Score is limited by missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, benchmarks, and computational-representation fields in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_01200_custodial_septet_fermion_quintet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_01200", "source_line": 2597, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 21, "global_rank": 6069, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.52459, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative minimal_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_01110_2hdm_pseudoscalar_portal_dirac_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1509_01110", "source_line": 2577, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 11, "global_rank": 6070, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.508197, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative pseudoscalar_portal_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_0659_z2_real_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1407_0659", "source_line": 2152, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.5, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 17, "global_rank": 6071, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.491803, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "interacting_dark_sector_fluid", "model_id": "1506_05823_nonlinear_interacting_dm_vve_v1", "paper_id": "1506_05823", "source_line": 189, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -2.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because the supplied card lacks enough explicit observables, constraints, routing, or computational support for immediate observational extension."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 6072, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.47541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 4.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["defer score -2.5 for interacting_dark_sector_fluid: positive factors include diversity credit for an underrepresented family, but explicit observables are absent; applicable constraints are absent; theory-to-observable routes are absent; computational and public-code support is missing."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -2.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1002_1327_tev_dm_cion_v1", "paper_id": "1002_1327", "source_line": 138, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 46, "global_rank": 6073, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.459016, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 3}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative supersymmetric_dark_matter card with phenomenological parameterization theory-level support and nonthermal phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0409064_axionic_quasar_bubble_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0409064", "source_line": 104, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 for observational-extension ranking.", "The supplied card lacks extracted observables and theory-to-observable routing needed for immediate extension."], "family_rank": 337, "global_rank": 6074, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.442623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 2, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Scored as a non-eliminated speculative axion_like_dark_matter card with effective field theory theory-level support and field like phase-space behavior.", "Priority is limited by absent extracted observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, and usable public computational support in the supplied model card.", "Agent warnings in the model card reduce priority but do not state global elimination."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep_ph0212379_light_relic_neutralino_effmssm_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0212379", "source_line": 494, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 36, "global_rank": 6075, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.42623, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level phenomenological_parameterization and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 2 model-card warning(s), including low, medium severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_08176_fr_gravity_scalaron_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_08176", "source_line": 2699, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 163, "global_rank": 6076, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.409836, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 166. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1512_08176_nonminimal_dilaton_gravity_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1512_08176", "source_line": 2700, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 164, "global_rank": 6077, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.393443, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 18, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level effective_field_theory, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 166. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1508_01200_custodial_septet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1508_01200", "source_line": 2596, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 64, "global_rank": 6078, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.377049, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter card with effective_field_theory theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0404483_pulsar_kick_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0404483", "source_line": 474, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Raw priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension ranking rule.", "The card is sparse in observational observables, constraints, routing, or computational support."], "family_rank": 169, "global_rank": 6079, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.360656, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 19, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied model card as speculative with theory level simplified_model and relic-density support parameter_dependent.", "Observational leverage is driven by limited explicit observational handles in the card.", "Priority is reduced because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, observable routing, computational support.", "Model-card caveats include 1 model-card warning(s), including high severity."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_0688_z2_singlet_scalar_portal_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1407_0688", "source_line": 2173, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 51, "global_rank": 6080, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.344262, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, simplified_model theory level, and has parameter-dependent relic-density viability, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_vector_mediator_dark_matter", "model_id": "1407_8257_msdm_vector_mediator_v1", "paper_id": "1407_8257", "source_line": 2182, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 6081, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.327869, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, and simplified_model theory level, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_model_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_05771_higgs_portal_tchannel_lsms_v1", "paper_id": "1509_05771", "source_line": 2562, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 5, "global_rank": 6082, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.311475, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified_model_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_model_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_05771_vector_higgs_portal_lsms_v1", "paper_id": "1509_05771", "source_line": 2561, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 6, "global_rank": 6083, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.295082, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified_model_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "simplified_model_dark_matter", "model_id": "1509_05771_vector_tchannel_lsms_v1", "paper_id": "1509_05771", "source_line": 2563, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 7, "global_rank": 6084, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.278689, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative simplified_model_dark_matter card with simplified_model theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1601_02490_u1x_dark_higgs_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1601_02490", "source_line": 2690, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": 496, "global_rank": 6085, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.262295, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 8}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from supplied model-card fields: status speculative, theory level uv_complete, production ability parameter_dependent, and family count 506. Low observational leverage because the supplied card has no explicit observables, constraints, or non-CDM structure/phase-space signal.", "Penalized because the supplied card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, benchmarks, public likelihoods, and usable associated code. High-severity warning(s) in the card add caution but do not eliminate the model."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_07898_fermionic_higgs_portal_dark_matter_eft_v1", "paper_id": "1811_07898", "source_line": 3661, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 89, "global_rank": 6086, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.245902, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative higgs_portal_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1811_09645_u1chi_leptonic_self_interacting_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1811_09645", "source_line": 3681, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 165, "global_rank": 6087, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.229508, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative self_interacting_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1812_05373_framed_standard_model_hidden_sector_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1812_05373", "source_line": 3677, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 497, "global_rank": 6088, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.213115, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 6.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with uv_complete theory-level support.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "scotogenic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2012_05189_z8_scoto_seesaw_scpv_v1", "paper_id": "2012_05189", "source_line": 4491, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.0, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 43, "global_rank": 6089, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.196721, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 7}, "ranking_rationale": ["Limited observational leverage is encoded in the supplied model card for scotogenic_dark_matter.", "Feasibility is limited because explicit routing, benchmarks, computational representation, and usable code are absent from the supplied card.", "Score remains in the defer band because the card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes; raw local score -3.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "supersymmetric_neutralino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-th0701034_g2_m_theory_wino_lsp_v1", "paper_id": "hep-th0701034", "source_line": 657, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 309, "global_rank": 6090, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.180328, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 2, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; rare production mechanism; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_00886_su2x_z3_vector_higgs_portal_v1", "paper_id": "1507_00886", "source_line": 2590, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -3.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 498, "global_rank": 6091, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.163934, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 19.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 8.0, "scientific_value": 7.5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with uv_complete theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -3.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_01161_curved_gauge_slice_gluon_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1507_01161", "source_line": 2528, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -4, "defer_reason": ["No explicit observables are supplied in the model card.", "No applicable constraints are supplied in the model card.", "No theory-to-observable routing is supplied in the model card.", "No usable computational representation, benchmark, public code, or route support is supplied."], "family_rank": 499, "global_rank": 6092, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.147541, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 17, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from model-card-only evidence for Curved gauge slice low-energy gluon dark matter: the model card provides limited explicit observational leverage; its scientific score is limited by missing or weak model-comparison/relic fields; diversity value is modest relative to the population context; empty observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routing, and computational/code fields impose the main model-card-local penalties. Raw score -4.0."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1305_2715_kolar_decaying_light_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1305_2715", "source_line": 1866, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 under the observational-extension rubric, mainly because explicit observables, constraints, routing, and computational support are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 52, "global_rank": 6093, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.131148, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 2.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 5.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected because the card presents a speculative phenomenological-parameterization model with decay production/phenomenology.", "Observational leverage is limited because the assigned card has no explicit observable list, constraints, or routing entries.", "Score is held down by sparse explicit observables/constraints/routing and mostly missing computational support; diversity contributes 2 while penalties total 20."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "self_interacting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1810_04709_scalar_tensor_rsidm_v1", "paper_id": "1810_04709", "source_line": 3657, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -4.0, "defer_reason": ["Priority score below 30 because the supplied model card lacks enough observational-extension content for a higher tier."], "family_rank": 166, "global_rank": 6094, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.114754, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 0.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 7.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the supplied card as speculative self_interacting_dark_matter with simplified_model theory-level support.", "Useful signals: relic-density relevance marked parameter_dependent.", "Score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, current-data compatibility is unknown, computational follow-through is not supplied."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "gravity_portal_decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "2007_09681_affine_gravitational_scalar_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2007_09681", "source_line": 4328, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -4, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because explicit observational-detail fields are sparse in the supplied model card, especially observables, applicable constraints, routing, and computational representation."], "family_rank": 1, "global_rank": 6095, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.098361, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 3, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 4}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked, not rejected: the supplied card describes Affine gravitational scalar dark matter as a speculative gravity_portal_decaying_dark_matter model with effective_field_theory theory level and production via cosmological production not specified.", "The card gives little explicit observational leverage beyond the general model description.", "Priority is limited because explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the supplied model card.", "Additional penalty from high-severity model-card warnings: missing_relic_density."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -4, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "annihilating_subkev_dark_matter", "model_id": "2212_11100_thermal_subcomponent_subkev_annihilating_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2212_11100", "source_line": 5454, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -4.0, "defer_reason": ["Low current observational-extension value under the rule because supplied observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation are absent or sparse."], "family_rank": 2, "global_rank": 6096, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.081967, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0.0, "diversity_value": 4.0, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20.0, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 3.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Low-ranked but not rejected: Thermal subcomponent sub-keV annihilating dark matter for UV-assisted direct collapse has limited supplied theoretical scoring fields, moderate diversity value, but the supplied card lacks observables, applicable constraints, observable routes, computational representation and receives a high missing-information penalty."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -4.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1405_4282_millicharged_higgs_stueckelberg_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1405_4282", "source_line": 2165, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -5.0, "defer_reason": ["Low score under the observational-extension ranking rule due to sparse observables, constraints, routing, or computational support in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 500, "global_rank": 6097, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.065574, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked with low current priority because the card has speculative status, and simplified_model theory level, but little model-card-local observational leverage.", "The score is limited because observables are empty, applicable constraints are empty, theory-to-observable routes are empty, and computational representation is sparse."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -5.0, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1809_07768_planck_scale_dm_u1d_baryon_messenger_v1", "paper_id": "1809_07768", "source_line": 3630, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -5, "defer_reason": ["Score below 30 because this model-only card lacks explicit observables, applicable constraints, and theory-to-observable routes."], "family_rank": 501, "global_rank": 6098, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.04918, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 5}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked from the assigned model card as speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter with effective_field_theory theory support and unknown abundance coverage.", "Observational leverage is limited because the card gives no explicit observable, constraint, or route entries.", "Score is held down by missing explicit observables, applicable constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and mostly absent computational support."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0701254_shadow_higgs_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0701254", "source_line": 655, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -5, "defer_reason": ["Low preliminary score for observational extension under the global ranking rule.", "Assigned card lacks explicit observables and theory-to-observable routing."], "family_rank": 502, "global_rank": 6099, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.032787, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9, "scientific_value": 6}, "ranking_rationale": ["Preliminary sharded score based only on the supplied model card: limited explicit observational leverage; no explicit computational representation or usable routing; no explicit multi-probe routing; high-severity warnings.", "Score is heavily penalized because explicit observables, constraints, and theory-to-observable routes are absent from the assigned card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1507_06454_dilaton_dark_photon_v1", "paper_id": "1507_06454", "source_line": 2585, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": -5.5, "defer_reason": ["Priority score is below 30 because observational-extension inputs are sparse in the supplied model card."], "family_rank": 503, "global_rank": 6100, "observational_followup_allowed": true, "priority_tier": "defer", "rank_percentile": 0.016393, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 1.5, "feasibility": 0.0, "observational_leverage": 0.0, "penalties": 20, "provenance_and_robustness": 9.0, "scientific_value": 4.0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Ranked as a speculative hidden_sector_dark_matter card with phenomenological_parameterization theory level; score-relevant card features include limited observational leverage in the supplied card.", "Auditability is helped by provenance, validity-domain, assumption, robustness, and warning fields in the card.", "The score is heavily penalized for missing explicit observables, constraints, theory-to-observable routes, and computational representation in the supplied card."], "ranking_state": "ranked", "raw_priority_score": -5.5, "rejection_reason": []}}
{"family": "topological_defect_dark_matter", "model_id": "0807_4373_cosmic_defect_galactic_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "0807_4373", "source_line": 791, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring: identity.status is excluded.", "Rejected models are not scored or ranked in the sharded worker pass."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "sneutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "0811_0485_sterile_sneutrino_inverse_decay_v1", "paper_id": "0811_0485", "source_line": 832, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model status as excluded. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "radiative_neutrino_mass_dark_matter", "model_id": "1103_0857_tev_right_handed_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1103_0857", "source_line": 1279, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the model card marks identity.status as excluded.", "Observational-detail extension is not allowed under the strict elimination gate."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "inert_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "1108_2753_y2_inert_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1108_2753", "source_line": 1340, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied card marks the model status as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "composite_topological_dark_matter", "model_id": "1111_2047_little_higgs_skyrmion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1111_2047", "source_line": 1478, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model status as excluded, triggering the strict elimination gate."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "radiative_minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_6597_fermionic_radiative_mdm_quintuplet_v1", "paper_id": "1204_6597", "source_line": 1552, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because identity.status is excluded in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "radiative_minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_6597_scalar_radiative_mdm_quintuplet_v1", "paper_id": "1204_6597", "source_line": 1553, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because identity.status is excluded in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "radiative_minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1204_6597_scalar_radiative_mdm_septuplet_v1", "paper_id": "1204_6597", "source_line": 1554, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because identity.status is excluded in the assigned model card."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "coupled_dark_energy_dark_matter", "model_id": "1210_8016_disformally_coupled_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1210_8016", "source_line": 318, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card triggers the strict elimination gate; observational follow-up is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring.", "The assigned model card marks the model status or compatibility as excluded."]}}
{"family": "radiative_inverse_seesaw_dark_matter", "model_id": "1304_6162_ma_radiative_iss_s2l_cold_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1304_6162", "source_line": 1776, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded; observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring.", "identity.status is excluded in the supplied model card."]}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_modified_gravity", "model_id": "1407_1207_modified_baryonic_dynamics_sterile_neutrino_v1", "paper_id": "1407_1207", "source_line": 32, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the card marks the model as excluded or nonviable at model level. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "nonabelian_exciting_dark_matter", "model_id": "1408_0233_nonabelian_triplet_collisional_xdm_v1", "paper_id": "1408_0233", "source_line": 2273, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card sets identity.status to excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1506_07521_minimal_inert_higgs_neutrino_portal_adm_v1", "paper_id": "1506_07521", "source_line": 2598, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the card marks the model as excluded at the model level. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_04723_radiative_minimal_fermion_quintet_v1", "paper_id": "1603_04723", "source_line": 2804, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "minimal_dark_matter", "model_id": "1603_04723_radiative_scalar_septet_v1", "paper_id": "1603_04723", "source_line": 2805, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1607_05283_dimension4_lh_freeze_in_decaying_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1607_05283", "source_line": 2837, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_01605_protophobic_vector_charged_complex_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_01605", "source_line": 2928, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model status as excluded. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1609_01605_protophobic_vector_charged_dirac_fermion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1609_01605", "source_line": 2929, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model status as excluded. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_05279_double_inflation_red_tilt_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_05279", "source_line": 2988, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model status as excluded. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "primordial_black_hole_dark_matter", "model_id": "1612_05279_running_mass_inflation_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1612_05279", "source_line": 2989, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model status as excluded. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "hidden_sector_dark_matter", "model_id": "1701_07043_quartified_stickball_warm_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1701_07043", "source_line": 3045, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the model card marks the candidate as excluded, so observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "decaying_dark_matter", "model_id": "1706_04921_decaying_hidden_photon_cib_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "1706_04921", "source_line": 3184, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the assigned model card marks the model status as excluded. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "1902_09552_spin_dependent_asymmetric_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1902_09552", "source_line": 319, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card triggers the strict elimination gate; observational follow-up is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring.", "The assigned model card marks the model status or compatibility as excluded."]}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1905_02011_su2n_degenerate_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1905_02011", "source_line": 3906, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded at the strict elimination gate."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "multi_component_dark_matter", "model_id": "1911_05579_cxsm_z2_symmetric_two_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1911_05579", "source_line": 4100, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card has identity.status set to excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "1912_02682_higgs_criticality_pbh_dm_v1", "paper_id": "1912_02682", "source_line": 4129, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the model card marks identity.status as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "scalar_triplet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2001_05335_real_triplet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2001_05335", "source_line": 4188, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the card marks the model as excluded before observational-detail extension."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "inert_doublet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2003_11434_d4_inert_scalar_doublet_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2003_11434", "source_line": 4217, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model status as excluded. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring because identity.status is excluded."]}}
{"family": "wimp_dark_matter", "model_id": "2004_06727_early_qcd_vector_wimp_v1", "paper_id": "2004_06727", "source_line": 4240, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model status as excluded. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring because identity.status is excluded."]}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_02279_discrete_symmetry_ultralight_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_02279", "source_line": 4412, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded; observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "fuzzy_ultralight_dark_matter", "model_id": "2008_02279_stueckelberg_axion_vector_mixing_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2008_02279", "source_line": 4410, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded; observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "scalar_singlet_dark_matter", "model_id": "2010_15708_z2_singlet_two_step_first_order_v1", "paper_id": "2010_15708", "source_line": 4469, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks identity.status as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "inflaton_dark_matter", "model_id": "2105_05860_nonthermal_inflaton_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2105_05860", "source_line": 4712, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card sets identity.status to excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "macroscopic_dark_matter", "model_id": "2106_12589_electroweak_symmetric_ball_dark_matter_v1", "paper_id": "2106_12589", "source_line": 4802, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "gravitino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2107_01263_type_iii_gmsb_messenger_inflation_gravitino_v1", "paper_id": "2107_01263", "source_line": 4804, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "sterile_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "2112_10337_matter_triality_ssm_sterile_neutrino_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2112_10337", "source_line": 4988, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model status as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "radiative_lepton_mass_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2202_07784_dark_sector_scalar_eta_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2202_07784", "source_line": 5063, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied card marks the model status as excluded.", "No science, observational, complementarity, feasibility, provenance, diversity, or penalty score was used for ranking; component fields are zero-valued schema placeholders."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "scotogenic_scalar_dark_matter", "model_id": "2303_04655_dirac_scotogenic_singlet_scalar_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2303_04655", "source_line": 5576, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the card status is excluded; the singlet-dominated scalar variant is eliminated by the strict gate."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "freeze_in_dark_matter", "model_id": "2304_02904_lepton_portal_freeze_in_scalar_universal_v1", "paper_id": "2304_02904", "source_line": 5570, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the card status is excluded; the universal lepton-coupling freeze-in variant is eliminated by the strict gate."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "higgs_portal_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_00982_singlet_higgs_portal_dark_fermion_v1", "paper_id": "2312_00982", "source_line": 5914, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the card marks the model as excluded by current data with no remaining viable parameter domain. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "axion_like_dark_matter", "model_id": "2312_08425_high_tension_string_qcd_axion_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2312_08425", "source_line": 5894, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the card marks this high-tension unwarped QCD axion-string variant as excluded/overproducing dark matter, with no viable parameter domain for observational follow-up."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "primordial_black_holes", "model_id": "2405_13072_expanding_microscopic_black_hole_dm_v1", "paper_id": "2405_13072", "source_line": 6057, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded; observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring because identity.status is excluded."]}}
{"family": "asymmetric_dark_matter", "model_id": "astro-ph0510088_h_dibaryon_baryon_sequestration_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0510088", "source_line": 67, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks the model as excluded by current data. Observational-detail extension is not allowed."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}
{"family": "unified_dark_matter_dark_energy", "model_id": "astro_ph0307214_chaplygin_gas_condensate_dm_v1", "paper_id": "astro-ph0307214", "source_line": 435, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the model card marks the model identity status as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring: identity.status is excluded."]}}
{"family": "majorana_neutrino_dark_matter", "model_id": "hep-ph0612024_minimal_majorana_dark_neutrino_oscillation_v1", "paper_id": "hep-ph0612024", "source_line": 666, "triage": {"adjusted_priority_score": null, "defer_reason": [], "family_rank": null, "global_rank": null, "observational_followup_allowed": false, "priority_tier": "rejected", "rank_percentile": null, "ranking_components": {"complementarity": 0, "diversity_value": 0, "feasibility": 0, "observational_leverage": 0, "penalties": 0, "provenance_and_robustness": 0, "scientific_value": 0}, "ranking_rationale": ["Rejected before scoring because the supplied model card marks identity.status as excluded."], "ranking_state": "rejected_eliminated", "raw_priority_score": null, "rejection_reason": ["Model eliminated before observational-extension scoring."]}}